Pastoral Care · Interim Ministry

Session 4 — The Marks of the Church

AH AH: AI-generated; human-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“It is also taught among us that one holy Christian Church will be and remain forever. This is the assembly of all believers among whom the Gospel is preached in its purity and the holy sacraments are administered according to the Gospel.” — Augsburg Confession, Article VII

Opening Prayer

Almighty God, you have built your Church on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, with Christ Jesus himself as the cornerstone. You have not entrusted her to our cleverness, our programs, or our personalities. You sustain her by your Word and Sacraments, given by your hand. Open our eyes today to see clearly what your Church is, that we may stop trying to build what only you can build, and instead receive what you have given. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

Scripture Readings

Read aloud, taking turns:

  • Matthew 16:13–19 — “On this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.”
  • Ephesians 2:19–22 — “Built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Christ Jesus himself being the cornerstone.”
  • 1 Corinthians 3:5–11 — “I planted, Apollos watered, but God gave the growth.”
  • Acts 2:42 — “And they devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers.”

Teaching: What Makes a Church a Church

A congregation in vacancy is tempted to ask the wrong question. The wrong question is: what makes us a successful congregation? The right question is: what makes us a Church at all?

The Augsburg Confession answers in one sentence (Article VII): “the assembly of all believers among whom the Gospel is preached in its purity and the holy sacraments are administered according to the Gospel.” That is it. Two marks. Word and Sacrament. Where these are, there is the Church. Where these are not, there is not.

This is the most theologically liberating sentence the Council can hear in the vacancy.

Notice what it does not require:

  • It does not require a building.
  • It does not require a pastor with twenty years of experience.
  • It does not require a youth program, a contemporary service, a thriving choir, a balanced budget, or 200 in worship.
  • It does not require unanimous agreement on every issue.
  • It does not require young families.
  • It does not require a strategic plan.

It requires the Gospel preached purely and the Sacraments administered rightly. These are the marks — the notae ecclesiae, in Latin — by which the Church is recognized.

A congregation that loses sight of this is a congregation that will measure itself by the wrong metrics, call the next pastor for the wrong reasons, and exhaust itself trying to be something other than what it has been given to be. A congregation that grasps it can be small, embattled, weary, and still be the Church.

What Are the Marks, More Fully?

Luther, expanding on Augsburg VII in his treatise On the Councils and the Church (1539), names seven marks by which the Church can be recognized in any place:

  1. The holy Word of God preached, believed, confessed, and lived.
  2. Holy Baptism, rightly administered.
  3. The Sacrament of the Altar (the Lord’s Supper), rightly administered.
  4. The Office of the Keys — confession and absolution — exercised publicly.
  5. The ministry of the Office — that is, called and ordained servants of the Word.
  6. Public prayer, praise, and thanksgiving — corporate worship.
  7. The holy cross — suffering borne for the sake of Christ.

Notice how this list reframes the vacancy. Five of the seven marks (Word, Baptism, Supper, Keys, public worship) continue without interruption during a vacancy — supplied by neighboring pastors, vacancy pastors, lay readers under proper authority. The sixth (the ministry of the Office) is temporarily interrupted but is being restored through the call process itself, which is the Church doing its work. And the seventh (the cross) is, if anything, more present in a vacancy than in ordinary times.

If your congregation is gathering for the Word, baptizing infants and adults who come to faith, communing the faithful, hearing absolution, praying together, and bearing the cross of this season patiently — you are the Church. You are not a defective version of the Church. You are not a Church-in-waiting. You are the Church.

The Identity of This Congregation

This is the deeper question that sits underneath every Council discussion in a vacancy: who are we?

Many congregations in vacancy do not know how to answer this without referring to a pastor. “We are the church where Pastor So-and-so was.” “We are the church that did such-and-such program.” “We are the church that used to be big.” Those are not identities. Those are nostalgia.

The Christian answer is given, not chosen:

  • We are baptized. Our identity is given in the font. We are children of God by adoption, members of the body of Christ, temples of the Holy Spirit.
  • We are gathered. The Holy Spirit calls, gathers, enlightens, sanctifies, and keeps us. We did not gather ourselves. We will not keep ourselves.
  • We are sent. We are placed in a particular town, on a particular street, among particular neighbors, to be the Church here, not somewhere else.
  • We are weak. We are simul justus et peccator — saint and sinner — as a congregation, the way each baptized Christian is as an individual. We are not the heroic remnant. We are sinners under grace.

The next pastor will not invent your identity. He will preach the Word and administer the Sacraments and through those means the identity already given you will be confirmed and renewed. The Council’s job, in this vacancy, is to come to grips with the identity you already have, and to stop looking for someone to give you a different one.

Discussion Questions (for the session)

  1. Read Augsburg Confession, Article VII aloud, slowly, twice. What does it say is necessary for the Church? What does it say is not necessary?
  2. By this measure, is your congregation a Church? Where do you see the marks? Where, if anywhere, are they obscured?
  3. If five of the seven marks of the Church continue during the vacancy, what does that change about the urgency of calling a pastor “as soon as possible”?
  4. Complete this sentence and discuss: “If a visitor walked into our church on Sunday and asked, ‘What kind of church is this?’, the honest answer would be __________.”
  5. Where has the congregation been seeking its identity in something other than baptism, Word, and Sacrament? Be specific.

Homework for Session 4

Part A: A Survey of the Marks (Individual)

For each of the seven marks of the Church (Luther’s list, above), answer in writing:

  1. The Word of God. Is the Word preached purely in this congregation? Where do you see this clearly? Is there anything that has eroded — sermons that drift toward inspiration rather than Christ-and-him-crucified, Bible studies that have become discussion groups?

  2. Holy Baptism. Has this congregation been baptizing? Whom? When was the last? Is the meaning of baptism taught — at the font, in catechesis, in preaching?

  3. The Lord’s Supper. How often is it offered? Who comes? Who has stopped coming, and do you know why? Is the Supper taught — as the true body and blood of Christ, given and shed for the forgiveness of sins?

  4. The Office of the Keys. Is confession and absolution offered publicly in the liturgy? Privately, to anyone who asks? Do members know it is available to them?

  5. The ministry of the Office. Right now: who is preaching? Who is presiding at the Sacraments? Is this orderly? Is the district aware?

  6. Public worship. Is the Sunday Service the center of this congregation’s life, or has it become an obligation? What would change if it became, again, the center?

  7. The holy cross. Where is this congregation bearing the cross faithfully? Where, if anywhere, has the congregation been running from the cross — refusing to bear what God has given to bear?

Part B: Identity Examination (Individual)

Answer in writing:

  1. Without using the previous pastor’s name, without using attendance numbers, without using a tagline from any past initiative — describe this congregation in three sentences.

  2. What temptations to false identity does this congregation face? Examples might include: nostalgia (“we are the church that used to be…”), comparison (“we are the church that is more/less ____ than that other church”), program (“we are the church that does ____”), personality (“we are the church of Pastor So-and-so”), survival (“we are the church that is trying not to close”). Which of these have you, personally, been most prone to?

  3. Read Romans 6:1–11. What does Baptism say about who this congregation is? How would this congregation act differently if it remembered its baptism daily?

Part C: Read and Reflect

Read each of the following:

  • Augsburg Confession, Articles VII and VIII (the Church and what it is, even amid hypocrites and sinners)
  • Romans 6:1–11 (baptismal identity)
  • 1 Peter 2:9–10 (a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation)
  • Luther’s Small Catechism, the Third Article of the Creed and its explanation

Write one paragraph in response: “If the Church is constituted by Word and Sacrament — not by my preferences, not by our history, not by any pastor — what does this mean for how I should think about the call process?”

Part D: A Visit (Optional but Strongly Encouraged)

If at all possible, attend the Sunday Service of a neighboring Lutheran congregation between now and the next session. Sit quietly. Notice: where do you see the marks of the Church there? What is the same as your congregation? What is different?

The point is not comparison. The point is to see the marks in a place where you do not have decades of personal history clouding your view. Come back able to recognize them in your own congregation more clearly.

Part E: A Daily Practice

Each morning this week, after the sign of the cross, say:

In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. I am baptized.

That is all. Add nothing. The point is to remember, daily, that the identity that matters is the one given to you in the font, not the one you construct.

Closing Prayer

Lord Jesus Christ, head of your Church, you have promised that where two or three are gathered in your name, there you are in the midst. You have given us your Word. You have given us your Sacraments. You have given us one another. We confess that we have often looked for identity in lesser things. Teach us to see your Church where you have placed her: in this room, in this congregation, in this town. Make us content to be what you have made us to be, and free us from the anxious need to be something else. Through your holy name. Amen.

Topics
Church and MinistryBaptism
Scripture
Matthew 16:13–19Ephesians 2:19–221 Corinthians 3:5–11Acts 2:42Romans 6:1–111 Peter 2:9–10
Confessions
AC VIISC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.