Pastoral Care · Interim Ministry

Session 3 — Grief, Endings, and Honest Goodbyes

AH AH: AI-generated; human-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“For everything there is a season, and a time for every matter under heaven: a time to be born, and a time to die… a time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance.” — Ecclesiastes 3:1–4

Opening Prayer

Heavenly Father, you are the God who weeps with those who weep and rejoices with those who rejoice. You sent your Son into a world of partings and graves, that he might be acquainted with our sorrows. Today, as we name what we have lost, do not let us be sentimental, and do not let us be hard. Give us tears where we have been holding them back. Give us peace where we have been gripping too tightly. Help us to say what needs to be said. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, who is the resurrection and the life. Amen.

Scripture Readings

Read aloud, taking turns:

  • Ecclesiastes 3:1–8 — A time for every matter under heaven.
  • John 16:5–7, 16–22 — “I tell you the truth: it is to your advantage that I go away.”
  • Acts 20:36–38 — Paul’s parting from the Ephesian elders: “And there was much weeping on the part of all.”
  • 2 Samuel 1:17–27 — David’s lament for Saul and Jonathan: a model of honest grief, even where the relationship was complicated.

Teaching: You Cannot Begin Until You Have Ended

A vacancy is, among other things, a loss. The previous pastor — whether he was beloved, whether he was endured, whether he was driven out, whether he died, whether he retired in dignity, whether he was scandalous — was your pastor, and now is not. Something has ended. Until you can say that out loud and feel it, you cannot begin what comes next.

Most congregations in vacancy try to skip this session.

The reasons are various. Sometimes the congregation is sick of grief and wants to move on. Sometimes the departure was so painful that no one wants to revisit it. Sometimes the departure was so quiet that no one realizes there is grief to attend to. Sometimes there is a particular faction that does not want to grieve — perhaps because they were the ones who pushed the pastor out, and grieving would feel like an admission. Sometimes everyone is afraid that if they start weeping, they will not stop.

The result, in all of these cases, is the same: a congregation that calls a new pastor with the unprocessed grief of the previous one still in the room. The new pastor will inherit that grief whether or not he knows about it. He will be compared to a man he never met. He will be punished for sins that were not his. He will preach his first funeral, baptize his first baby, lead his first holy week, and find that the congregation is reacting to him with an intensity that has nothing to do with him.

That is not fair to him. It is not fair to you. The only remedy is honest grief, in this session, under the Word.

Three Kinds of Endings

The pastoral departure that brought you here will fall, broadly, into one of three categories. Each carries its own grief.

1. A faithful ending.

The pastor retired in good standing. The pastor accepted a call elsewhere. The pastor died in office. The pastorate was, on balance, a faithful one. The departure was orderly. The good-byes were said.

Even here there is grief. A retiring pastor is still the loss of a pastor. A call elsewhere is still a leaving. A death is the deepest leaving of all. Do not dismiss the grief simply because the ending was clean.

2. A complicated ending.

The pastor’s ministry had mixed reviews. The departure was prompted by friction, fatigue, or accumulated disagreements. There was no scandal, but there was strain. He may have accepted a call elsewhere “for everyone’s sake.” He may have retired earlier than planned. Some are sad to see him go; some are quietly relieved.

This is the most common kind of ending and the easiest to fail. The congregation tries to remember him as if his pastorate were entirely happy, and the unspoken complaints leak out months later. Or the congregation tries to forget him, and the unspoken thanksgivings sour into resentment. The work here is honesty — naming both the gift and the strain.

3. A broken ending.

The pastor was removed. The pastor resigned under cloud. The pastor was credibly accused of serious sin. The pastor split the congregation and walked out, taking members with him. There was scandal. There was litigation. There was reporting to the district. There was newspaper coverage. There were members who left and have not returned.

A broken ending requires more than this course can provide. If your congregation is in this category, this session is a beginning, not an end, of the grief work. Plan to involve your district office, and likely a counselor or interim specialist trained in congregational crisis recovery, before this course is over.

The Lutheran Word for This: Lament

Scripture has a category for honest grief, and it is not “moving on.” It is lament. Lament is the speech of God’s people in the presence of God when something is wrong. The Psalter is full of it. Forty psalms are laments. The Old Testament includes an entire book called Lamentations.

Lament is not the opposite of faith. Lament is faith doing its work in a fallen world. To lament is to bring the loss, the wound, the disappointment, the bewilderment, into the presence of God, rather than pretending it is not there. Lament says: this is what happened, this is what hurts, this is what we do not understand, and we are still here, before you, waiting on you.

Lutheran piety has not always done lament well. We can be tempted toward a sturdy stoicism that mistakes itself for faith. Today is the day to set that aside. The Lord is not honored by your refusal to grieve. He is honored by your honesty.

A Goodbye Ritual

Whether or not the previous pastor received a proper goodbye when he left, the congregation needs to say one now — not to him, but in his absence, before God.

In this session, we will conduct a goodbye exercise. The facilitator will lead the Council in the following:

  1. Each member will name aloud, in a single sentence, one thing they will miss about the previous pastorate.
  2. Each member will name aloud, in a single sentence, one thing they will not miss.
  3. Each member will say, aloud, one of the following two sentences (choose whichever is honest):
    • “Pastor [N], thank you for your ministry among us. I release you from being our pastor. May the Lord be with you.”
    • “Pastor [N], your ministry among us was painful. I release you from being our pastor. May the Lord have mercy on you and on me.”
  4. The facilitator will close the exercise with the absolution and a benediction.

This is not theater. It is not a substitute for whatever conversations may yet need to happen with the previous pastor himself, or with the district, or in confession. It is the Council, in its own seat of vocation, formally letting go.

Discussion Questions (for the session)

  1. When the previous pastor left, was there a goodbye? What did it look like? Was it adequate to what had happened?
  2. Where are you holding grief about the previous pastorate that you have not let yourself feel?
  3. Where are you holding resentment about the previous pastorate that you have not brought into the open?
  4. What would you say to the previous pastor today, if he walked into this room and sat down — in honesty, before God?
  5. What is the difference between releasing the previous pastor and forgetting him? Why are they not the same?

Homework for Session 3

Part A: A Letter You Will Not Send (Individual)

Write a letter to the previous pastor that you will not send. Be honest. Say what you would not normally allow yourself to say — the gratitude, the grief, the grievance, the bewilderment. Be specific. Use names, dates, events.

When you have written it, read it back to yourself slowly. Pray over it. Then put it in an envelope, seal it, and bring the sealed envelope to the next session. You will not be asked to read it aloud. The act of writing is the work.

(If you would like, the facilitator will collect the sealed envelopes at the end of the session and dispose of them privately — for example, by burning them — as a symbol of release. Or you may take yours home and dispose of it yourself.)

Part B: An Honest Reckoning (Individual)

Answer in writing, prayerfully:

  1. What did I contribute, directly or indirectly, to the conditions in which the previous pastor left? Be specific. Did I complain in the parking lot rather than speak to him? Did I withdraw from worship? Did I support him in word but not in deed? Did I expect things from him I never named?

  2. What did the previous pastor do or fail to do that I have not forgiven? Name it specifically. (You are not yet absolving him. You are naming what is still in your heart.)

  3. What does it mean to release someone from a role they no longer hold? What might be making this hard for me?

  4. Have I taken anything from the previous pastorate — a grievance, a wound, a resentment, a sense of betrayal — that I am unwilling to lay down before the next pastor arrives? Name it.

Part C: A Conversation (Two or Three Members Together)

Pair or group yourselves (the facilitator will help arrange this) and meet for at least an hour between sessions. Bring coffee. Read John 16:5–22 together aloud. Then take turns, each person speaking for ten minutes uninterrupted, on this question:

“Where do I still hurt from the last pastorate, and what do I need from this congregation and from the Lord in order to let it go?”

The other person(s) listen. Do not argue. Do not advise. Do not relativize (“yes, but…”). Listen. At the end of each person’s ten minutes, the listener(s) may say one sentence: “I have heard you. I will pray for you.” That is all.

Part D: Read and Reflect

Read each of the following:

  • Lamentations 3:1–33 (the long lament, ending in hope)
  • John 16:16–22 (sorrow turned to joy)
  • Luther’s Small Catechism, the Fifth Petition of the Lord’s Prayer: “Forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us.”

Write one paragraph in response: “What does it mean to pray ‘as we forgive those who trespass against us’ in this congregation, in this vacancy, right now?”

Part E: A Daily Practice

Each evening this week, before bed, pray:

Lord Jesus Christ, you wept at the grave of Lazarus. You wept over Jerusalem. You wept in Gethsemane. Teach me to weep where I should weep, and to give thanks where I should give thanks. Forgive me where I have not done either. Receive into your hands what I have been gripping too tightly. Amen.

Closing Prayer

O God, you are the God of all comfort, who comforts us in all our affliction. We have not always known what to do with our grief. We have buried it; we have ignored it; we have nursed it; we have weaponized it. Forgive us. Receive what we lay down today. Receive the previous pastor into your care, wherever he is. Bring this congregation through this valley into the wide place where you have prepared a future for us. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, who tasted death for every one of us. Amen.

Topics
Death and GriefChurch and Ministry
Scripture
Ecclesiastes 3:1–4Ecclesiastes 3:1–8John 16:5–7Acts 20:36–382 Samuel 1:17–27John 16:5–22Lamentations 3:1–33John 16:16–22
Confessions
SC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.