Pastoral Care · Interim Ministry

Session 5 — The Priesthood of All Believers and Lay Vocation

AH AH: AI-generated; human-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“But you are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people for his own possession, that you may proclaim the excellencies of him who called you out of darkness into his marvelous light.” — 1 Peter 2:9

Opening Prayer

Heavenly Father, by holy Baptism you have called every one of us into your priestly people. You have given each of us a vocation — in our families, in our work, in our neighborhoods, and in your Church — through which you serve our neighbors. In this season of vacancy, awaken us to the callings you have already laid upon us. Teach us not to wait for the next pastor to do what you have given us to do. Through Jesus Christ, our great High Priest. Amen.

Scripture Readings

Read aloud, taking turns:

  • 1 Peter 2:4–10 — A spiritual house, a holy priesthood, a royal priesthood.
  • Exodus 19:5–6 — “You shall be to me a kingdom of priests and a holy nation.”
  • Romans 12:1–8 — One body, many members, each with different gifts.
  • Acts 6:1–7 — The seven deacons: lay vocation alongside the apostolic office, neither replacing the other.

Teaching: Priesthood and Office

Two truths must be held together in this session, and they are often confused.

The first truth: every baptized Christian is a priest. This is what Scripture means when it says, “You are a chosen race, a royal priesthood” (1 Peter 2:9). Every Christian has direct access to God through Christ. Every Christian is called to pray, to bear witness, to serve the neighbor. There is no special class of Christians who are “really” Christians. There is no priestly caste. The priesthood is universal.

The second truth: Christ has also instituted the Office of the Holy Ministry. The Augsburg Confession, Article V, states: “To obtain such faith God instituted the office of the ministry, that is, provided the Gospel and the sacraments. Through these, as through means, he gives the Holy Spirit, who works faith, when and where he pleases, in those who hear the Gospel.” A man called and ordained into this office preaches, baptizes, administers the Lord’s Supper, and forgives sins in Christ’s stead and by his command.

These two truths are not in tension. The Reformed tradition has sometimes collapsed the Office into the priesthood — making the pastor merely “the most representative of the universal priesthood,” or worse, no different in kind from a layman. The Roman tradition has sometimes elevated the Office into a separate sacramental priesthood that overshadows the priesthood of all believers. The Lutheran Confession holds both: every Christian is a priest, and Christ has instituted the Office of the Ministry to preach the Word and administer the Sacraments publicly on behalf of his Church.

Why does this matter in a vacancy?

Because the vacancy tempts the congregation in two opposite directions, and both are errors.

Error one: Pastor-worship.

“We can’t do anything until the new pastor arrives.” “The church is at a standstill.” “Without a pastor, we’re just… here.”

This sentiment misunderstands the universal priesthood. You are not at a standstill. The work of the Christian life — prayer, mercy, witness, service, catechesis at home, hospitality, mutual encouragement, attending the Sunday Service, receiving the Word and Sacrament — is the work of every baptized Christian, every day, with or without a settled pastorate. The pastor’s job is to preach and administer the Sacraments; it is not to do the Christian life on your behalf. A congregation that goes dormant in the vacancy is a congregation that had been outsourcing the Christian life to its pastor — and that is not a Lutheran way to live.

Error two: Pastor-displacement.

“We don’t really need a pastor. We can handle this ourselves.” “Why don’t we just take turns preaching?” “If the priesthood of all believers is true, what’s the pastor for?”

This sentiment misunderstands the Office. Christ instituted the Office for the public preaching of the Word and the administration of the Sacraments. He did not leave this to the spiritual instincts of the congregation. The Office is not a bureaucratic convenience. It is a gift of Christ to his Church. To dismiss it is to dismiss Christ’s own provision for his people.

Augsburg XIV is clear: “Nobody should publicly teach or preach or administer the sacraments in the church without a regular call.” This is a confessional commitment. The vacancy makes it temporarily harder to honor — and the right response is to work with the district to arrange faithful supply of Word and Sacrament, not to invent improvisations that bypass the Office.

The Council’s Vocation

Members of the Church Council have a particular calling within the universal priesthood. You have been chosen by your fellow members to exercise a specific stewardship: of the temporalities, of the unity, of the order, of the discipline of this congregation. This is not a small thing.

Three things to understand about Council vocation in the vacancy:

1. You are not the de facto pastor.

The Council does not preach. The Council does not administer the Sacraments. The Council does not, on its own authority, decide doctrine. The Council does not, in the vacancy, become the office of pastoral leadership for the congregation. Your stewardship is real, and it is bounded.

2. You are not merely “filling in until the pastor arrives.”

The Council has its own God-given vocation, distinct from the pastoral office. Even with a settled pastor in place, the Council has work to do. Your work does not exist because there is no pastor; your work exists because there is a congregation. Do your work, in your vocation, faithfully.

3. You are responsible for what is yours and not for what is not yours.

Many Councils in vacancy overreach in some areas (deciding doctrinal questions, “calling” their own preaching arrangements) and underreach in others (failing to ensure faithful supply, failing to maintain pastoral care to shut-ins, failing to communicate clearly with the congregation). The discipline is to know what is yours.

The Vocation of Every Member

The same logic extends to every baptized member of the congregation:

  • Parents continue to catechize their children. The vacancy does not pause that. Family devotions, bedtime prayers, the Lord’s Prayer, the Creed, the Ten Commandments, the Small Catechism in the home — these are yours to keep up.
  • Members continue to attend the Sunday Service, to receive the Sacrament from whoever is rightly supplying it, to give of their means, to pray for one another, to bear with one another.
  • The catechized continue to read Scripture, to live their vocations in family, work, and citizenship, to bear witness in their neighborhoods.
  • Those with particular gifts — teachers, musicians, visitors of the sick, those skilled in hospitality, those with means to give — continue to use those gifts for the building up of the body.

This is what Luther meant when he said that every Christian’s daily work is a “mask of God” (larva Dei) through which God serves the neighbor. The plumber, the school teacher, the grandmother, the farmer — each is, in their work, an instrument of God’s providence. The vacancy does not change this. If anything, the vacancy makes it more visible.

Discussion Questions (for the session)

  1. Read 1 Peter 2:4–10 aloud. In what specific ways is this congregation living as “a royal priesthood” right now? In what ways have we been outsourcing the Christian life to the pastor?
  2. What does it look like, practically, for Council members to exercise their vocation faithfully without drifting into doing the pastor’s work?
  3. Which members of this congregation are quietly doing the work of the priesthood with little notice and less thanks? (Name them. Then plan to thank them this week.)
  4. In what ways has this congregation, during the vacancy, gone dormant where it should have been active? In what ways has the congregation overreached where it should have waited?
  5. What is the difference between “every Christian is a priest” and “every Christian is a pastor”? Why does the difference matter?

Homework for Session 5

Part A: A Vocation Inventory (Individual)

Make a list. In one column, list the callings God has placed on your life right now. (Examples: husband, wife, father, mother, son, daughter, grandparent, neighbor, employee, employer, citizen, Council member, choir member, Sunday school teacher.) In a second column, write what each calling requires of you. In a third column, write how you have been doing in each calling over the last six months.

Look at the list. Pray over it. Are there callings you have been neglecting? Are there callings you have been confusing with others (treating Council work like family work, or vice versa)? Are there callings that the vacancy has surfaced as needing renewed attention?

Part B: The Council’s Vocation Examined (Individual, to be discussed at next session)

Answer in writing:

  1. Why did I agree to serve on the Council? Be honest. Was it duty? Reluctance? A sense of calling? Pressure from someone else? Pride? A specific concern I wanted to influence?

  2. What do I believe the Council’s vocation is in this vacancy? In one paragraph.

  3. Where have I, personally, been overreaching — trying to do what is the pastor’s work, or the district’s work, or another member’s work?

  4. Where have I, personally, been underreaching — neglecting what is my work, in my vocation, in this congregation?

  5. What would it look like for me to serve the rest of the Council, the rest of the congregation, and the next (as-yet-unknown) pastor faithfully in my own vocation for the remainder of this vacancy?

Part C: An Act of Service (Individual)

Before the next session, do one specific act of service to a member of this congregation that you would not have done apart from this exercise. Examples:

  • Visit a shut-in member with a Bible reading and a prayer. (Coordinate with the vacancy pastor for the Sacrament if the member wishes it.)
  • Make a meal for a family in difficulty.
  • Write a handwritten note of encouragement to a member you have not spoken to in months.
  • Pick up the catechism with your children or grandchildren and teach them one petition of the Lord’s Prayer.
  • Invite a struggling member of the congregation for coffee, without an agenda except to listen.

Write a paragraph after: what did you do? What did you observe? What was the Lord doing?

Part D: Read and Reflect

Read each of the following:

  • 1 Peter 2:1–10 (the royal priesthood)
  • Romans 12:1–13 (the body, the gifts, the practical love)
  • Augsburg Confession, Articles V and XIV (the Office and good order)
  • Luther’s Small Catechism, the Table of Duties — read the entire Table, not only the section that applies to you

Write one paragraph in response: “If every Christian has a vocation through which God serves the neighbor, what vocations has the Lord laid upon me that I have been ignoring or undervaluing — and what would it look like to take them up again?”

Part E: A Daily Practice

Each day this week, when you wake up, ask:

Lord, who has been placed in my path today? In what vocation can I serve them in your name?

At the end of the day, ask:

Lord, where did I see you at work today through ordinary people in ordinary callings? Thank you.

Closing Prayer

O Lord Jesus Christ, our great High Priest, you have made us a kingdom of priests to serve our God and Father. You have given us callings in family, in work, in neighborhood, in the Church. Forgive us where we have despised the callings you gave us, or coveted callings you did not give us. Make us faithful in what is ours. Teach us to honor the Office you have instituted, even as we live the priesthood you have bestowed. Send the pastor you are preparing, and prepare us to receive him gladly. Through your holy name. Amen.

Topics
Vocation and Daily LifeChurch and Ministry
Scripture
1 Peter 2:91 Peter 2:4–10Exodus 19:5–6Romans 12:1–8Acts 6:1–71 Peter 2:1–10Romans 12:1–13
Confessions
AC VSC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.