Lutheranism and the Reformed Churches
Marburg, Geneva, and Dort: A Lutheran Reading of Our Nearest Relatives
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread.” — 1 Corinthians 10:16–17
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921) and cited in the notes by the standard abbreviations, with paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions. The Reformed confessions are quoted from the English texts in Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, volume 3; readers who know the newer English of the Christian Reformed Church and the Reformed Church in America will find the same passages there in different wording. Calvin’s Institutes are quoted in the translation of Henry Beveridge.
Marburg, October 1529
In the first days of October 1529 the two halves of the Reformation sat down at one table. Landgrave Philip of Hesse, who wanted the evangelical princes of Germany and the evangelical cities of Switzerland to stand together, had brought them to his castle at Marburg. From Wittenberg came Martin Luther and Philip Melanchthon. From Zurich came Ulrich Zwingli, with the theologians of Basel and Strasbourg. The Landgrave sat and listened. The question before them was the Lord’s Supper.1
Everyone who has heard of Marburg has heard of the chalk. As the story is usually told, Luther wrote four Latin words on the table before the debate began, Hoc est corpus meum (“This is my body”), and through three days of argument he would not rub them out. The story is old and it is substantially true. However, it is worth saying how it reaches us. Andreas Osiander of Nuremberg was in the room and he reported to his city council that Luther had written “This is my body” on the table in chalk for himself. Later, when the words were challenged, Luther lifted the velvet tablecloth and showed what he had written under it. The large letters for all to see belong to the later retellings.2 I begin with that small correction because this paper asks us to be careful with what others have said, and we may as well start with ourselves.
What is less often remembered is how much the two sides agreed. Before they parted Luther drew up fifteen articles and the Swiss and Strasbourg men signed them. Together they confessed the Trinity, the person of Christ, His death and resurrection, original sin, justification by faith, the work of the Holy Spirit, and the sacraments. Even the fifteenth article, on the Supper, lists what they held in common before it names the one point that divided them. “And although at present we can not agree whether the true body and the true blood of Christ be corporeally present in the bread and wine, yet each party is to show to the other Christian love, as far as conscience permits, and both parties should fervently pray to Almighty God that by his Spirit he may strengthen us in the true understanding. Amen.”3 By the common account Zwingli then came to Luther with tears in his eyes and held out his hand. Luther would not take it. He told the Swiss that theirs was a different spirit, and that evening he wrote to his wife, “we want no brothership and membership, only peace and good-will.”4
I do not want to tell that story so that either man is the villain. Luther believed the words of Christ were at stake, while Zwingli believed the honor of Christ’s true humanity was at stake. Almost five hundred years later the churches that came from Zurich and Geneva and the churches that came from Wittenberg are still not at one altar, except where they have decided that the old difference need not divide.
This paper is about those churches, the Reformed. They are our nearest relatives in the Reformation family, which makes them in some ways the hardest to write about fairly. I have tried to set down their teaching so that a Reformed minister would find his own reasons in it, and the Lutheran judgment beside it. I will take up five questions:
- Who are the Reformed churches, and how have they and the Lutherans met?
- What do we hold in common?
- Where do we differ, on the Lord’s Supper, the person of Christ, election, and Baptism?
- What should we make of the Leuenberg Agreement of 1973 and A Formula of Agreement of 1997?
- What might we learn from one another?
This paper treats the continental Reformed tradition of Switzerland, the Rhineland, the Netherlands, and Hungary. The Westminster Confession and the Presbyterian churches belong to the companion paper, Lutheranism and Presbyterianism.
The Reformed Family
The Reformed tradition begins with Ulrich Zwingli (1484–1531), people’s priest at the Great Minster in Zurich from 1519. Where Luther came to the Reformation through a terrified conscience, Zwingli came as a humanist scholar who set out to reform the Church by the Greek New Testament. Both roads led to justification by faith alone. Zwingli’s road also led to a strict reading of the Second Commandment, so that whatever God had not commanded in worship, whether images, relics, organs, or the Mass, was to be removed. Zwingli was killed in 1531, two years after Marburg, when the Catholic cantons defeated Zurich at Kappel.5 His successor, Heinrich Bullinger (1504–1575), led the Zurich church for more than forty years. A confession he wrote for his own use was published in 1566 as the Second Helvetic Confession, and it was received from Switzerland to Hungary.6
The second founder is John Calvin (1509–1564), the reformer of Geneva. Although Calvin read Luther with gratitude, he was convinced that Zwingli had been right about where Christ’s body is and that Luther had been right that the Supper is no empty sign. Schaff calls his view a middle course, “retaining, on the basis of Zwingli’s exegesis, the religious substance of Luther’s faith.”7 In Germany some of Melanchthon’s students came to hold Calvin’s view of the Supper while still calling themselves Lutherans. Their opponents called them Crypto-Calvinists (“hidden Calvinists”) and the struggle over their teaching lies behind the Formula of Concord of 1577.8
The Reformed faith spread north and east. The Heidelberg Catechism was written in the Palatinate in 1563, and the Belgic Confession in the Netherlands in 1561 by Guido de Brès, who died a martyr six years later. In 1618 and 1619 a synod at Dordrecht (Dort) answered the followers of Jacobus Arminius, who taught that God elects those He foresees will believe and that His grace can be resisted, and adopted the Canons of Dort. These three, the “Three Forms of Unity,” still bind the Dutch and German Reformed churches and their daughters in North America, South Africa, and elsewhere.9 The World Communion of Reformed Churches counts about 100 million Christians in more than 230 churches, a number that includes the Presbyterians.10 As with the Lutherans, there is a mainline branch, which in North America includes the Reformed Church in America and the United Church of Christ, and a confessional one, which includes the Christian Reformed Church and the United Reformed Churches. When I describe what the Reformed teach, I mean what their confessions say and what the confessional churches still hold.
Lutherans and Reformed have been meeting and missing each other ever since Marburg. Martin Bucer of Strasbourg helped bring about the Wittenberg Concord of 1536 with Luther, though the Swiss never joined it.11 In 1817 King Frederick William III of Prussia united the Lutheran and Reformed churches of his kingdom by royal decree. Many confessional Lutherans refused the union and some emigrated to America and Australia rather than accept it, and the memory has made their heirs wary of agreements made over the top of doctrine. In Europe the twentieth-century conversation led to the Leuenberg Agreement of 1973, which now joins nearly a hundred Lutheran, Reformed, United, and Methodist churches.12 In North America official dialogue began in 1962, and its first report was called, fittingly, Marburg Revisited. That road led in 1997 to A Formula of Agreement, by which the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America entered full communion with the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), the Reformed Church in America, and the United Church of Christ.13 The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod and the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod are not party to it, and neither are the confessional Reformed churches.
What We Hold in Common
A Lutheran who reads the Reformed confessions for the first time is usually surprised by how much of them he could sign. We are children of one Reformation and our fathers fought the same battles.
Both traditions confess Holy Scripture as the only rule of the Church’s teaching and both hold the preached Word in honor. The Second Helvetic Confession confesses that “when this Word of God is now preached in the church by preachers lawfully called, we believe that the very Word of God is preached, and received of the faithful.”14 Both receive the ancient creeds; the Belgic Confession says, “we do willingly receive the three creeds, namely, that of the Apostles, of Nice, and of Athanasius.”15 Where we differ on the person of Christ, then, we differ within the faith of the councils and not outside it.
In addition, on sin and grace both traditions are Augustinian to the bone. The Canons of Dort confess that “all men are conceived in sin, and are by nature children of wrath, incapable of any saving good, prone to evil, dead in sin, and in bondage thereto.”16 The Augsburg Confession and the Formula of Concord teach the same bondage of the will. Neither tradition gives the sinner any part in his own conversion: “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast” (Ephesians 2:8–9).
On justification the Heidelberg Catechism is as clear as our own Book of Concord. To the question “How art thou righteous before God?” it answers, “Only by true faith in Jesus Christ,” and confesses that God, “without any merit of mine, of mere grace, grants and imputes to me the perfect satisfaction, righteousness, and holiness of Christ, as if I had never committed nor had any sin.”17 That is the Fourth Article of the Augsburg Confession in the voice of a catechism.18 Lastly, we share the habit of teaching the faith to children by question and answer. The Heidelberg’s first answer, “That I, with body and soul, both in life and in death, am not my own, but belong to my faithful Saviour Jesus Christ,” is one of the most beautiful sentences ever given a child to learn.19
That makes the differences more painful, since these are brothers and not strangers.
The Table
The question that broke up the meeting at Marburg is still the first question between us. Lutherans confess, in the words of the Small Catechism, that the Sacrament of the Altar “is the true body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, under the bread and wine, for us Christians to eat and to drink, instituted by Christ Himself.”20 The reason is the words of institution. “Now as they were eating, Jesus took bread, and after blessing it broke it and gave it to the disciples, and said, ‘Take, eat; this is my body’” (Matthew 26:26). These were the words of a man making His last will on the night before His death, and a testament is the one place where everyone expects the words to mean what they say. Therefore the Formula of Concord confesses that “the words of the testament of Christ are not to be understood otherwise than as they read, according to the letter, so that the bread does not signify the absent body and the wine the absent blood of Christ, but that, on account of the sacramental union, they [the bread and wine] are truly the body and blood of Christ.”21
Paul calls the bread “a participation in the body of Christ” (1 Corinthians 10:16). He also warns that “whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord” (1 Corinthians 11:27). How can a man be guilty of a body that was never there for him to receive? For that reason our Confessions teach that the body and blood are received with the mouth by “not only the true believers [in Christ] and the worthy, but also the unworthy and unbelievers,” the believer to life and the unbeliever to judgment.22
Lutherans do not teach several things the Reformed have feared we teach. We do not teach that Christ’s flesh is chewed and digested like ordinary food, which the Formula calls the “Capernaitic” eating (after the crowd at Capernaum in John 6 who took Jesus in that crude sense). It confesses an oral eating “not in a Capernaitic, but in a supernatural, heavenly mode, because of the sacramental union.”23 Nor do we teach that Christ’s body is enclosed in the bread as in a place. The Wittenberg Concord, which the Formula quotes, denies that it is “included in the bread localiter, that is, locally.”24 Nor does faith or the minister make Christ present; the Formula says that “Christ Himself, through the spoken words, is still efficacious by virtue of the first institution.”25
Zurich, Geneva, and the Reformed confessions
There are two Reformed doctrines of the Supper, Zwingli’s and Calvin’s, and Bullinger’s stands close to Calvin’s. Zwingli taught that the Supper is above all a memorial and a public pledge. In his account of the faith sent to the emperor in 1530 he wrote that the Holy Spirit needs no guide or vehicle to bring grace, and that the body of Christ is present to “the eye, contemplacion and beholdyng of fayth.”26 In other words, Christ is present to the believer who looks to Him by faith. Zwingli’s chief text was our Lord’s word in John 6: “It is the Spirit who gives life; the flesh is no help at all. The words that I have spoken to you are spirit and life” (John 6:63). For Zwingli, to feed on Christ simply is to believe in Him.
Calvin did not agree and the difference matters. He wrote against Zwingli’s followers, “According to them, to eat is merely to believe; while I maintain that the flesh of Christ is eaten by believing, because it is made ours by faith, and that that eating is the effect and fruit of faith.” He added, “The difference is little in words, but not little in reality.”27 With Cyril of Alexandria, Calvin taught that Christ’s flesh “is properly said to be life-giving, as it is pervaded with the fulness of life for the purpose of transmitting it to us.”28 In the Supper we truly feed on that flesh. “That sacred communion of flesh and blood by which Christ transfuses his life into us, just as if it penetrated our bones and marrow, he testifies and seals in the Supper, and that not by presenting a vain or empty sign, but by there exerting an efficacy of the Spirit by which he fulfils what he promises.”29
What Calvin denied is that the flesh is present in the bread. “They are greatly mistaken in imagining that there is no presence of the flesh of Christ in the Supper, unless it be placed in the bread. They thus leave nothing for the secret operation of the Spirit, which unites Christ himself to us.” Then comes the sentence that sums up the quarrel: “The only question, therefore, is as to the mode, they placing Christ in the bread, while we deem it unlawful to draw him down from heaven.”30 In addition, Calvin held that the gift does not depend on the communicant. “The integrity of the sacrament, an integrity which the whole world cannot violate, lies here, that the flesh and blood of Christ are not less truly given to the unworthy than to the elect believers of God; and yet it is true, that just as the rain falling on the hard rock runs away because it cannot penetrate, so the wicked by their hardness repel the grace of God, and prevent it from reaching them.”31
The Reformed confessions teach children this doctrine. The Heidelberg Catechism teaches that Christ feeds my soul with His body and blood “as certainly as I receive from the hand of the minister, and taste with my mouth, the bread and cup of the Lord,” and that by the Holy Spirit “who dwells both in Christ and in us” we are united to His body, so that “although he is in heaven, and we on the earth, we are nevertheless flesh of his flesh and bone of his bones.”32 The Belgic Confession puts it strongly: “we err not when we say that what is eaten and drunk by us is the proper and natural body and the proper blood of Christ. But the manner of our partaking of the same is not by the mouth, but by the Spirit through faith.”33
The Reformed give their reasons from Scripture and from the ancient Church. Peter preached Jesus as the one “whom heaven must receive until the time for restoring all the things about which God spoke by the mouth of his holy prophets long ago” (Acts 3:21), and Calvin read that verse to mean that the heavens contain Christ’s body until He returns.34 A true human body, they hold, is in one place at a time, and our Lord remains the high priest who “in every respect has been tempted as we are, yet without sin” (Hebrews 4:15). Scripture’s sacramental language gives the sign the name of the thing it seals; the Second Helvetic Confession says that “the signs bear the names of things, because they are mystical tokens of holy things, and because the signs and the things signified are sacramentally joined together,” just as Paul says “the Rock was Christ” (1 Corinthians 10:4).35 Lastly, Calvin points to the ancient liturgy, where it was the custom “previous to consecration, to call aloud upon the people to raise their hearts, sursum corda” (“Lift up your hearts”). The office of the Sacrament, he says, is “to aid the infirmity of the human mind, assisting it in rising upwards.”36 Behind these reasons lies the Second Commandment, which forbids worshiping God by any image He has not given, and so the Second Helvetic Confession teaches that “our hearts are to be lifted up on high, and not to be fixed on the bread, neither is the Lord to be worshiped in the bread.”37
Where the line runs
A Lutheran who says that the Reformed believe the Supper is only a symbol has broken the Eighth Commandment. The Belgic Confession confesses “the proper and natural body,” and Calvin writes that the sign is not “vain or empty.” Our own Formula of Concord knew this and distinguished two kinds of opponents. Some say openly that only bread and wine are present. Others “speak very speciously in our own words, and pretend that they also believe a true presence of the true, essential, living body and blood of Christ in the Holy Supper, however, that this occurs spiritually through faith.”38 The word “pretend” is hard. I would not use it of Calvin’s heart, because I believe he meant what he wrote. Even so, the Formula saw where the line runs.
The difference is not whether Christ gives Himself to His people in the Supper, since both churches confess that He does, but whether His body and blood are present in the Supper itself, with the bread and wine, so that the mouth receives them. The Reformed would put the question as one about the bond, the Holy Spirit, who joins us to Christ’s flesh in heaven. Lutherans put it as a question about the mouth because Christ put it that way: “Take, eat; this is my body.” The Formula rejects in so many words the teaching “that the bread and wine are no more than a memorial, seal, and pledge, through which we are assured that when faith elevates itself to heaven, it there becomes partaker of the body and blood of Christ as truly as we eat bread and drink wine in the Supper.”39 Then there is the unworthy communicant. Calvin writes that the body is given to him and runs off him like rain off a rock; the Second Helvetic says he “is made partaker of the outward sacrament only.”40 Our Confessions say he receives the body of Christ to his judgment, as Paul says he is “guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord.”
What of the Reformed reasons? On Acts 3:21 the Formula answers that the verse says heaven must receive Christ, not that heaven encloses Him so that He can in no way be with us on earth.41 On sacramental speech, “the Rock was Christ” explains a type after the fact, while “this is my body” institutes something new, spoken over bread in the hands of the One whose body it was. On John 6, Lutherans and Calvin stand together against Zwingli. Christ’s flesh is life-giving, and His saying that “the flesh is no help at all” does not mean that His own flesh, given “for the life of the world” (John 6:51), profits nothing. The Formula agrees that John 6 speaks of the spiritual eating of faith, which every Christian needs “in the preaching and meditation of the Gospel, as well as in the Lord’s Supper,” and holds that the Supper adds to it the oral eating Christ commands.42 As for the sursum corda, the same ancient liturgy that lifts our hearts goes straight on to the words of institution spoken over the gifts. We lift our hearts because the Lord is about to come near, not because He is far away.
Why does it matter? Both churches say that the gift rests on Christ’s promise and not on the communicant’s worthiness. The Lutheran confession adds that the gift is received with the mouth by everyone who eats, so that the body and blood are there for the weak believer whether his faith is strong or weak, and he does not have to ask whether he was lifted high enough to receive them. The Heidelberg gives him a sure sign of the body; the Small Catechism gives him the body itself, with the promise that “he that believes these words has what they say and express.”43 I believe the Lutheran confession gives the weak believer more to hold, because it puts the gift into his hand and mouth. I should add that Lutherans do not always live by our own confession here. Many of our people come to the altar rarely and some of our preachers send them searching their hearts as surely as any Puritan. This is a difference in doctrine and not in practice, which is why confessional Lutherans and confessional Reformed do not share the altar. The fuller argument is in my paper One Body at Many Altars.
The Person of Christ
Underneath the Supper lies a simpler-sounding question: can the human body of Jesus be in more than one place? The Reformed say that a true human body is in one place, that Jesus’ body ascended to heaven and is there, and that His divine nature is everywhere. Lutherans say that because God and man are one person in Christ, His human nature shares in the divine majesty, so that He can be present with His body wherever He has promised to be. The Formula of Concord records that this disagreement grew out of the controversy over the Supper.44
The Heidelberg Catechism asks whether Christ is not with us to the end of the world, as He promised. It answers, “Christ is true Man and true God: according to his human nature, he is now not upon earth; but according to his Godhead, majesty, grace, and Spirit, he is at no time absent from us.” Does this not separate the natures? “By no means; for since the Godhead is incomprehensible and every where present, it must follow that it is indeed beyond the bounds of the Manhood which it has assumed, but is yet none the less in the same also, and remains personally united to it.”45 In other words, the eternal Son is wholly in the flesh He took, and He is also beyond it. Lutheran theologians nicknamed this the extra Calvinisticum, “the Calvinist beyond,” for the Son’s being beyond His flesh.
The Reformed do not think it is Calvin’s invention. They find it in Athanasius, who wrote that “the Word was not hedged in by His body, nor did His presence in the body prevent His being present elsewhere as well.”46 They find it in Augustine, whom Calvin quotes on the very promise Lutherans cite, Matthew 28:20. Christ is with us always “in regard to his majesty, in regard to his providence, in regard to his ineffable and invisible grace,” but not “in regard to the flesh which the Word assumed.”47 They appeal to the Council of Chalcedon (451), which confessed that the distinction of the natures is not taken away by the union and that the property of each nature is preserved. Lastly, they appeal to the Gospels’ picture of a true man, who “increased in wisdom and in stature and in favor with God and man” (Luke 2:52). Calvin, with Augustine, writes that Christ gave His risen flesh “incorruption and glory, but without destroying its nature and reality.”48 The Reformed want a Savior who is like us in every respect, and they believe the fathers wanted no less.
Sharing the properties
The technical name for the point at issue is the “communication of properties,” which means the sharing of each nature’s qualities with the one person of Christ. Lutheran teachers distinguish three ways Scripture speaks of it. In one, what belongs to either nature is said of the one person, as when Paul says that the rulers of this age “crucified the Lord of glory” (1 Corinthians 2:8). In another, each nature does its own work in the one work of our salvation. In the third, the human nature is given divine majesty, so that the man Jesus can do and be what God does and is. Calvin and the Reformed accept the first two and Calvin called the first a figure of speech that the ancients taught.49 The quarrel is over the third.
The Formula of Concord confesses it. Because of the union, the Son of Man was exalted “according to His human nature to the right hand of the almighty majesty and power of God,” so that “now not only as God, but also as man He knows all things, can do all things, is present with all creatures.”50 It appeals to the risen Christ’s words, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me” (Matthew 28:18). The eternal Son always had that authority. If it was given, it was given to Him in His humanity. The Reformed answer that it was given to the Mediator, the God-man, in His office, and that this does not require His flesh to share God’s presence everywhere. However, Paul writes that “in him the whole fullness of deity dwells bodily” (Colossians 2:9), and that He “ascended far above all the heavens, that he might fill all things” (Ephesians 4:10). On that ground the Formula reads Matthew 28:20 as the promise of the whole Christ. He “can be, and also is, present where He will, and especially that in His Church and congregation on earth He is present as Mediator, Head, King, and High Priest, not in part, or one-half of Him only, but the entire person of Christ is present, to which both natures belong, the divine and the human; not only according to His divinity, but also according to, and with, His assumed human nature, according to which He is our Brother, and we are flesh of His flesh and bone of His bone.”51
The Formula is careful about what it does not teach. It condemns the teaching “that the human nature of Christ is locally extended to all places of heaven and earth, which should not be ascribed even to the divine nature.”52 Christ’s body is not spread through space like air, and Lutherans also deny that the Word is enclosed in His flesh. Our question is whether the Word is ever present where His flesh is not. Following Luther, the Formula teaches that God has more than one way for a body to be present, so that Christ is in the Supper “not according to the mode or property of the human nature, but according to the mode and property of the right hand of God.”53
In addition, the Formula is sharper than Lutherans sometimes remember. It says that to join the natures “as two boards are glued together,” so that they have no real communion, “was the error and heresy of Nestorius and Samosatenus,” and it holds that its own doctrine keeps the person of Christ from being “divided, as it was by Nestorius.”54 Nestorius was the fifth-century bishop who so separated Christ’s natures that he seemed to make two persons of Him. The Reformed answer that they confess one person as firmly as anyone, and that the Lutheran view risks the opposite error of Eutyches, who mingled the natures into one. I take the Formula’s comparison as a warning about where the Reformed view tends, not as a verdict that Reformed Christians are Nestorians. Luther’s sharpest words were aimed at Zwingli, who taught that when Scripture says the Son of God died, one nature is named for the other by a figure of speech, so that only the human nature truly suffered. Luther answered, “if I believe this [permit myself to be persuaded] that only the human nature has suffered for me, then Christ is to me a poor Savior, then He Himself indeed needs a Savior.”55 The Reformed confessions after Zwingli do not teach that, and Calvin meant a true saying about the one person. Even so, Lutherans believe that confining the sharing of properties to the person, and denying it to the human nature, does not do justice to texts like Colossians 2:9.
I believe the Lutheran confession is the more faithful one. The Heidelberg Catechism also confesses that we are “flesh of his flesh,” joined from heaven by the Spirit who dwells in Christ and in us, and a Reformed pastor at a deathbed means the whole Christ. The Lutheran adds that Christ’s human nature itself is with us where He has promised. When a Lutheran pastor stands at a deathbed and says, “The Lord be with you,” he means the Lord who has hands and a face, and he means that those hands are near. In my Heidelberg Catechism: A Lutheran Appraisal I called the Supper and the Christology “the same disagreement, made twice,” and I still think so.
Election
The Reformed doctrine of predestination is the part of their teaching most Lutherans have heard of and least understand. The Canons of Dort define election as “the unchangeable purpose of God, whereby, before the foundation of the world, he hath, out of mere grace, according to the sovereign good pleasure of his own will, chosen, from the whole human race, which had fallen through their own fault, from their primitive state of rectitude, into sin and destruction, a certain number of persons to redemption in Christ.”56 Notice that Dort chooses out of a fallen race. It did not adopt the stricter view that God decreed the fall itself as a means to election. Election is not grounded in foreseen faith; rather “men are chosen to faith and to the obedience of faith.”57 Dort also teaches that “not all, but some only, are elected, while others are passed by in the eternal decree,” and that God “hath decreed to leave” these “in the common misery into which they have willfully plunged themselves,” and to condemn them “not only on account of their unbelief, but also for all their other sins.”58
The Reformed reasons are Scripture’s own words. God “chose us in him before the foundation of the world” (Ephesians 1:4). Paul writes in Romans 9, “For he says to Moses, ‘I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.’ So then it depends not on human will or exertion, but on God, who has mercy” (Romans 9:15–16). Then comes the verse no one can read quickly: “So then he has mercy on whomever he wills, and he hardens whomever he wills” (Romans 9:18). Our Lord says, “I lay down my life for the sheep” (John 10:15), and prays, “I am not praying for the world but for those whom you have given me” (John 17:9). Luke writes that “as many as were appointed to eternal life believed” (Acts 13:48). Calvin read Paul’s “all people” in 1 Timothy 2:4 as all kinds and ranks of people, kings among them, as the verses before it suggest.59 If salvation is all of grace, the Reformed reason, then the cause of one believing and another not must lie in God’s mercy and not in man.
Dort does not make God the author of sin. It calls that thought “blasphemy” and places the cause of unbelief “nowise in God, but in man himself.”60 It requires the Gospel to be preached to all: “As many as are called by the gospel are unfeignedly called; for God hath most earnestly and truly declared in his Word what will be acceptable to him, namely, that all who are called should comply with the invitation. He, moreover, seriously promises eternal life and rest to as many as shall come to him, and believe on him.”61 It tells the anxious believer who does not yet feel a lively faith, but still uses the means of grace, that he “ought not to be alarmed at the mention of reprobation.”62 Its Conclusion lists the charges laid against the Reformed churches and rejects them, among them the charge that God, “by a mere arbitrary act of his will, without the least respect or view to any sin, has predestinated the greatest part of the world to eternal damnation.” Such things, it says, the Reformed churches “not only do not acknowledge, but even detest with their whole soul,” and it asks to be judged “not from the calumnies which on every side are heaped upon it… but from the public confessions of the Churches themselves.”63 That is the Eighth Commandment asked of us by Dort itself. The Second Helvetic Confession is gentler still: “Let Christ, therefore, be our looking-glass, in whom we may behold our predestination.”64
The Formula of Concord agrees with much of this. It teaches that election is wholly of grace and is “a cause which procures, works, helps, and promotes our salvation and what pertains thereto.”65 It denies as firmly as Dort that “in us there is a cause of God’s election.”66 It teaches, as Bullinger does, that election “is to be considered in Christ, and not outside of or without Christ.”67 It rejects the teaching that God ordains some to condemnation “without regard to their sins,” and Dort’s Conclusion rejects that teaching too.68
The Formula parts company with Dort at two points. The first is the decree to pass some by. The Formula teaches that election “does not extend at once over the godly and the wicked, but only over the children of God.”69 There is an eternal election to life and no eternal decree by which God, of His good pleasure, withholds faith from the rest. The second is the reach of Christ’s saving work and of God’s will to save. Dort confesses that Christ’s death is “abundantly sufficient to expiate the sins of the whole world,” yet teaches that God willed Christ “should effectually redeem… all those, and those only, who were from eternity chosen to salvation.”70 The Formula teaches that the promise of the Gospel “is universalis (universal), that is, it pertains to all men,” that Christ’s blood “is the propitiation for the sins of the whole world,” and that God’s call is not to be regarded “as jugglery.”71 Paul writes that God “desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth” (1 Timothy 2:4), and the Formula takes “all” to mean all.
The Formula’s position has its own hard places and a Reformed reader is entitled to name them. It admits that of two sinners “one is hardened, blinded, given over to a reprobate mind, while another, who is indeed in the same guilt, is converted again,” and it does not say why.72 It even says that God “determined in His counsel that He will harden, reprobate, and condemn those who are called through the Word, if they reject the Word and resist the Holy Ghost.”73 That is a decree, though a conditional one. Later Lutheran theologians tried to close the question by saying that God elected “in view of faith” (intuitu fidei), and in the 1880s Lutherans in America quarrelled bitterly over that teaching. In other words, our refusal to answer the question “Why one and not another?” is costly. I still think it is right. Dort answers the question by the decree, while the Formula declines to say more than Romans 11 says: “Oh, the depth of the riches and wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are his judgments and how inscrutable his ways!” (Romans 11:33). It warns that a doctrine of election that drives consciences to despair is taught “according to [the blind judgment of human] reason.”74 I believe the Formula’s silence is the more faithful course, because Scripture that speaks of election also says that God desires all people to be saved.
What is at stake is the comfort of a troubled conscience. The Reformed preacher may say to every hearer that God earnestly calls him and will receive him if he comes. The Lutheran preacher may say also that Christ’s blood was shed for him, as the propitiation for the whole world, and that God wills his salvation. I believe the second gives the troubled more to hold. I have taken up this mystery at length in Grace Alone and the Lost.
The Font
The Reformed baptize infants and defend the practice against the Anabaptists (the radical reformers who rejected infant Baptism) as firmly as we do. The Heidelberg Catechism teaches that since children “as well as their parents, belong to the covenant and people of God,” they “are also by Baptism, as a sign of the covenant, to be ingrafted into the Christian Church.”75 The argument runs through God’s covenant with Abraham, whose sign was circumcision. Paul connects the two: “In him also you were circumcised with a circumcision made without hands, by putting off the body of the flesh, by the circumcision of Christ, having been buried with him in baptism” (Colossians 2:11–12).
What does the sign do? The Reformed draw here the line they drew in the Supper, between the sign and the thing signified, and they join the two closely. The Belgic Confession calls the sacraments “visible signs and seals of an inward and invisible thing, by means whereof God worketh in us by the power of the Holy Ghost.”76 It says that as water washes the body, “so doth the blood of Christ, by the power of the Holy Ghost, internally sprinkle the soul, cleanse it from its sins, and regenerate us from children of wrath unto children of God. Not that this is effected by the external water,” but by the blood of Christ, and that while the minister gives what is visible, “our Lord giveth that which is signified by the Sacrament, namely, the gifts and invisible grace.”77 The Heidelberg Catechism explains that God calls Baptism the washing of regeneration so that “by this divine pledge and token he may assure us that we are as really washed from our sins spiritually as our bodies are washed with water.”78 In other words, the Reformed teach that God works through the sign as His pledge, and that He gives what it signifies in His own time to those to whom He has promised it.
The Lutheran Confessions teach that Baptism gives what it promises, because God has bound His promise to it. The Small Catechism teaches that Baptism works forgiveness of sins, rescues from death and the devil, and gives eternal salvation to all who believe, not because of the water but because of the Word of God in and with the water.79 The reason is the words of the apostles. Peter said, “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit” (Acts 2:38). Paul writes that God “saved us… by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5). Peter writes, “Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you” (1 Peter 3:21). Lutherans take these as statements of what God does through Baptism and not only of what He pledges by it. To the fear that people will trust the rite instead of Christ, the Large Catechism answers that Baptism is God’s work and not ours: “to be baptized in the name of God is to be baptized not by men, but by God Himself.”80 Neither does it compete with faith, for God’s works “do not exclude, but demand, faith; for without faith they could not be apprehended.”81
Both traditions baptize infants, refuse to rebaptize, and teach that Baptism is no work of man. The Belgic Confession even says something very near Luther’s teaching on the daily use of Baptism: “Neither doth this Baptism only avail us at the time when the water is poured upon us and received by us, but also through the whole course of our life.”82 The difference lies where it lay in the Supper. For the Reformed the sign and the gift are joined by God’s promise but may be separated in time and person, as the Spirit wills. For Lutherans the gift is given through the sign.
That shapes what a parent is told. The Canons of Dort comfort godly parents whose children die in infancy, and they ground the comfort in the Word and the covenant: “Since we are to judge of the will of God from his Word, which testifies that the children of believers are holy, not by nature, but in virtue of the covenant of grace, in which they together with the parents are comprehended, godly parents have no reason to doubt of the election and salvation of their children whom it pleaseth God to call out of this life in their infancy.”83 That is a real comfort. Both parents are pointed to the font. The Reformed parent is told that God there sealed His covenant promise, whose inward fulfilment is the Spirit’s to give in His time. The Lutheran parent is told that God there gave her child new birth, forgiveness, and the Holy Spirit, because He promised to do it there, and she need not first ask whether He meant it for this child. I believe the second is what Peter means when he says that Baptism “now saves you.”
Leuenberg and A Formula of Agreement
These agreements were made by serious people who wanted to obey our Lord’s prayer that His disciples “may all be one” (John 17:21), and many Reformed Christians have moved a long way toward us. The Leuenberg Agreement takes up the three old disputes. On the Supper it says that “the risen Jesus Christ imparts himself in his body and blood, given up for all, through his word of promise with bread and wine,” and it warns that “to be concerned about the manner of Christ’s presence in the Lord’s Supper in abstraction from this act is to run the risk of obscuring the meaning of the Lord’s Supper.”84 On predestination it says that Scripture “forbids us from supposing that God has uttered an eternal decree, condemning for all time specific individuals or a whole people.”85 It concludes that the Reformation condemnations “are inapplicable to the doctrinal position” of the churches that accept it.86 A Formula of Agreement builds on Leuenberg. Its working principle is “mutual affirmation and admonition,” and it grants that “remaining differences must be acknowledged, even to the extent of their irreconcilability,” yet concludes, “it is the inherent unity in Christ that is determinative. Thus, the remaining differences are not church-dividing.”87 The ELCA adopted it in August 1997 by about four votes to one.88
Leuenberg’s statement on predestination comes near the Formula of Concord in refusing a decree of reprobation, although it does not say, as the Formula does, that God’s judgment on those who despise His Word is real and final.89 Even so, confessional Lutherans have not been able to accept these agreements, and the reason is not stubbornness. The Augsburg Confession confesses, in its article on the Church, that “to the true unity of the Church it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments.”90 Leuenberg appeals to this article. However, the Formula of Concord explains that article as agreement “in the doctrine and all its articles, also in the right use of the holy Sacraments.”91 At Marburg the question was never whether Christ gives Himself in the Supper, but what the mouth receives. Leuenberg’s sentence lets a Lutheran read “with bread and wine” as the sacramental union and a Calvinist read it as the occasion at which Christ gives Himself to faith, and then it tells us not to be concerned about the manner of His presence. The Formula of Concord was written because that manner, with the mouth or by faith alone, is a matter of Christ’s own words. A Formula of Agreement admits that the differences may be irreconcilable and then declares them not church-dividing. In the Augsburg Confession agreement is the ground of unity, while here unity is declared over the top of disagreement.
How, then, can a Lutheran call Reformed Christians brothers and still keep the Confessions’ condemnations? The Book of Concord answers that itself. Its Preface says that “it is in no way our design and purpose to condemn those men who err from a certain simplicity of mind, but are not blasphemers against the truth of the heavenly doctrine, much less, indeed, entire churches,” and that it condemns “only the fanatical opinions and their obstinate and blasphemous teachers.”92 In other words, the condemnations are aimed at false teaching and at those who teach it obstinately, and not at the Reformed Christian in the pew. Condemnations of doctrine are not withdrawn by a vote. They fall when the doctrine is no longer taught. Mark Mattes put the question every such agreement must answer: “Since it is clear that Lutherans and the Reformed are not in doctrinal agreement, on what basis can fellowship as we see it in Leuenberg or A Formula of Agreement be established?”93 He also noted that confessional Reformed bodies, like the Missouri and Wisconsin Synods, “still frame the discussion in terms of the classical disagreements.”94 The Reformed Christians who most love their own confessions agree with confessional Lutherans that the differences are real, and that is a better place to begin than a declaration that they need not divide.
Learning from One Another
What can Lutherans learn from the Reformed? The first thing is gratitude as the shape of the Christian life. The Heidelberg Catechism is built in three parts, our misery, our deliverance, and our thankfulness, and it teaches the Ten Commandments and the Lord’s Prayer under the third. The law comes to the Christian there as the shape of a thankful life after the Gospel, and not as a ladder before it. Lutheran preaching on the Christian life could learn from that order. The second is the singing of the Psalms. The Reformed churches gave the whole Psalter to their people to sing and generations of them learned the Psalms by heart that way. Although Lutherans have a hymnody second to none, our people know fewer Psalms than they should. The third is the way their best teachers point troubled souls to Christ in the doctrine of election. Bullinger’s “Let Christ, therefore, be our looking-glass” stands beside the Formula of Concord, which presents Christ to us “as the Book of Life.”95 Reformed pastors who stand at a bedside know that need, and many of them meet it with Bullinger’s looking-glass.
Lutherans have something to give in return and the first gift is the Christ who comes near. The Reformed lift our hearts to Christ in heaven and they are right that He reigns there. The Lutheran Confessions add that the whole Christ, God and man, comes down to us in His Supper and in His Word, and that His body is given into the mouth of the weakest believer. With that goes the comfort of the external Word and Sacraments, which God has put outside of us so that the anxious conscience has something to hold that does not depend on its own condition. We can also offer the restraint of the Formula on election, which holds to grace alone without a decree of reprobation, by stopping where Paul stops.
Many readers of this paper have a Reformed son-in-law, a Christian Reformed neighbor, or a daughter who married into a Dutch Reformed family. Be glad of what they confess. They know they belong body and soul to their faithful Savior and know they are saved by grace alone. When they ask why they cannot commune at your altar, or you at theirs, tell them it is not a judgment on their faith, but a confession of what Christ gives at His table, and that you pray for the day when you can receive it together. Their children’s Baptism is a true Baptism and is never to be repeated.
The Hand at Marburg
Luther did not take Zwingli’s hand. He told the Swiss they were of a different spirit, and he wrote that he wanted no brotherhood with them, “only peace and good-will.” I have tried not to soften that. Yet he had signed an article that bound both sides “to show to the other Christian love, as far as conscience permits,” and to pray for one another.
That article still asks two things of us. We are to show love as far as conscience allows, but conscience does not allow us to say that a difference over Christ’s body and blood does not matter. However, it allows a great many things short of the altar. We may read the Scriptures together, pray for each other, defend each other against misrepresentation, and teach our children the catechisms that both our churches love. We are also to pray, as Marburg prayed, that God “by his Spirit” would “strengthen us in the true understanding.” That prayer is better than any agreement drafted since.
Our Lord prayed for this on the night He instituted His Supper: “I do not ask for these only, but also for those who will believe in me through their word, that they may all be one, just as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be in us, so that the world may believe that you have sent me” (John 17:20–21). Lord Jesus Christ, You gave Your body and blood for us and for them. Keep us faithful to Your words, give us love toward all who call on Your name, and by Your Spirit strengthen us all in the true understanding. Amen.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.
The Lutheran Confessions
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (Text at bookofconcord.org.)
- The Book of Concord. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1959.
- The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000. (Especially: Preface; Augsburg Confession IV, VII, X; Small Catechism IV, VI; Large Catechism IV; Formula of Concord, Epitome and Solid Declaration VII, VIII, X, XI.)
The Reformed Confessions and Theologians
- Schaff, Philip, ed. The Creeds of Christendom, with a History and Critical Notes. 3 vols. New York: Harper & Brothers. Vol. 1, The History of Creeds, 4th ed., 1919. Vol. 3, The Evangelical Protestant Creeds. (The Heidelberg Catechism, the Belgic Confession, the Canons of Dort, and the Second Helvetic Confession.)
- Calvin, John. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Translated by Henry Beveridge. Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society, 1845.
- Zwingli, Huldrych. Fidei Ratio. 1530. English translation by Thomas Cotsforde, 1555.
The Fathers
- Athanasius. On the Incarnation. Christian Classics Ethereal Library.
- Augustine. Tractates on the Gospel of John. As quoted in Calvin, Institutes IV.17.26.
History
- Osiander, Andreas. Report on the Marburg Colloquy, 1529. In D. Martin Luthers Werke: Kritische Gesamtausgabe, vol. 30, part 3. Weimar, 1910. English translation by Ellen Yutzy Glebe, German History in Documents and Images.
- Schaff, Philip. History of the Christian Church. Vol. 7, Modern Christianity: The German Reformation. New York: Scribner, 1892.
Ecumenical Documents and Responses
- Agreement between Reformation Churches in Europe (The Leuenberg Agreement). 1973. English translation of the Community of Protestant Churches in Europe.
- A Formula of Agreement between the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, the Presbyterian Church (USA), the Reformed Church in America, and the United Church of Christ. 1997.
- Commission on Theology and Church Relations, Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod. The Formula of Agreement in Confessional Lutheran Perspective. St. Louis, 1999.
- Mattes, Mark. “A Confessional Response to North American Lutheran–Reformed Ecumenism.” Concordia Theological Quarterly 75 (2011): 3–26.
Related Papers
- The Heidelberg Catechism: A Lutheran Appraisal.
- One Body at Many Altars.
- Grace Alone and the Lost.
- God Wills All to Be Saved.
Footnotes
-
On the setting, participants, and dates see Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church, vol. 7, Modern Christianity: The German Reformation (New York: Scribner, 1892), §§107–108, “The Marburg Conference.” Schaff dates the opening of the work to Friday, October 1, and the general discussion to October 2 and 3. With Zwingli came John Oecolampadius of Basel and Martin Bucer and Caspar Hedio of Strasbourg. ↩
-
Andreas Osiander, report to the council of Nuremberg on the Marburg Colloquy (1529), in D. Martin Luthers Werke: Kritische Gesamtausgabe (Weimar, 1910), 30/3:144–51; English translation by Ellen Yutzy Glebe in German History in Documents and Images (German Historical Institute, Washington). Osiander writes that Luther “wrote the text, ‘This is my body,’ etc. on the table with chalk,” and that later he “lifted the velvet tablecloth and showed him the quote.” Schaff’s narrative (History, vol. 7, §108) has Luther write the words “in large characters,” the form the story usually takes. ↩
-
Marburg Articles (1529), Article 15, in the translation given by Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, 4th ed., vol. 1, The History of Creeds (New York: Harper & Brothers, 1919), §39, p. 212 n. 1, omitting the two German phrases Schaff gives in parentheses. Schaff summarizes the result as agreement “in fourteen and a half articles” (1:212). The articles were signed by Luther, Jonas, Melanchthon, Osiander, Agricola, and Brenz for the Lutherans and by Oecolampadius, Zwingli, Bucer, and Hedio for the Reformed (1:228 n.). The summary of the other articles follows Schaff, History, vol. 7, §108. ↩
-
Schaff, Creeds, 1:212–13, and History, vol. 7, §108, report that Zwingli, “with tears in his eyes,” held out his hand and that Luther declined it. Schaff’s History gives Luther’s words as “Yours is a different spirit from ours”; Osiander’s report has Luther say to the Strasbourg men, “Our spirit does not harmonize with your spirit.” The letter to Katharina Luther is quoted from Schaff, History, vol. 7, §108. Schaff also reports that the Wittenbergers offered to include the Swiss “in that universal charity which we owe to our enemies.” ↩
-
Schaff, Creeds, 1:360 (Zwingli’s dates) and 1:260 (the defeat of Zurich at Kappel, 1531). On the Reformed reading of the Second Commandment see the Second Helvetic Confession, ch. 4, on idols and images. ↩
-
Schaff, Creeds, 1:390 (Bullinger’s dates and his election as Zwingli’s successor, December 9, 1531), 392 (the confession composed “in Latin, for his own use” in 1562), and 393 (its reception in Switzerland, Hungary, and elsewhere). ↩
-
Schaff, Creeds, 1:280. ↩
-
In 1549 Calvin and Bullinger agreed on the sacraments in the Zurich Consensus (Consensus Tigurinus), and in 1552 Joachim Westphal, a Lutheran pastor in Hamburg, attacked it, which began the controversy that hardened the line between the two confessions (Schaff, Creeds, 1:280). ↩
-
Schaff, Creeds, 3:383 (the Belgic Confession, “composed in French by Guy de Brès (died a martyr, 1567)”); 3:307 (the Heidelberg Catechism, 1563); 3:550 (the Canons of Dort, 1618–1619). Schaff’s English text of the Canons is the abridged one then in force in the Reformed Church in America, which gives the positive articles only; Schaff also prints the Synod’s Conclusion. The background of the Heidelberg Catechism is treated in The Heidelberg Catechism: A Lutheran Appraisal, Part I. ↩
-
World Communion of Reformed Churches, “About,” wcrc.eu (accessed November 18, 2026): “230+ member churches in 109 countries” and “100 million Christians.” ↩
-
The Wittenberg Concord of 1536 is quoted in FC SD VII.12–16. ↩
-
Community of Protestant Churches in Europe, leuenberg.eu (accessed November 18, 2026): “96 Lutheran, Reformed, United, and Methodist churches in Europe and overseas,” which it calls “the Protestant voice of Europe for 40 million believers.” ↩
-
A Formula of Agreement (1997), Preface, refers to “a process begun in 1962.” On Marburg Revisited as the report of the first round of dialogue see Mark Mattes, “A Confessional Response to North American Lutheran–Reformed Ecumenism,” Concordia Theological Quarterly 75 (2011): 3–26, at 23. ↩
-
Second Helvetic Confession, ch. 1, in the English version printed as an appendix to Schaff, Creeds, vol. 3. Compare FC Ep, Rule and Norm, 1. ↩
-
Belgic Confession, Art. 9. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, Third and Fourth Heads, Art. 3. ↩
-
Heidelberg Catechism, Q. 60. ↩
-
AC IV.1–3. ↩
-
Heidelberg Catechism, Q. 1. ↩
-
SC VI.1–2. Compare AC X.1–2. ↩
-
FC Ep VII.7. ↩
-
FC Ep VII.16. ↩
-
FC Ep VII.15; compare VII.42. ↩
-
FC SD VII.14. ↩
-
FC SD VII.75; compare FC Ep VII.8. The Formula goes on to quote Chrysostom: “no man makes the bread and wine set before us the body and blood of Christ, but Christ Himself who was crucified for us” (SD VII.76). ↩
-
Huldrych Zwingli, Fidei Ratio (Account of the Faith), addressed to Charles V at Augsburg, dated Zurich, July 3, 1530, arts. 7–8, in the English translation of Thomas Cotsforde (1555). On the Spirit, Cotsforde’s English reads “a guyde or chariote is not nedful to ye spirite”; a modern rendering is “a leader or vehicle is not necessary for the Spirit.” ↩
-
John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, trans. Henry Beveridge (Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society, 1845), IV.17.5. ↩
-
Calvin, Institutes IV.17.9; compare IV.17.8, “the very flesh in which he resides he makes vivifying to us.” ↩
-
Calvin, Institutes IV.17.10. ↩
-
Calvin, Institutes IV.17.31. In IV.17.30 Calvin says that Christ “in the Supper exhibits his presence in a special manner.” ↩
-
Calvin, Institutes IV.17.33. ↩
-
Heidelberg Catechism, QQ. 75–76. ↩
-
Belgic Confession, Art. 35. ↩
-
Calvin, Institutes IV.17.29: “Peter says that the heavens must receive, or contain Christ, till he come again (Acts 3:21).” ↩
-
Second Helvetic Confession, ch. 19. ↩
-
Calvin, Institutes IV.17.36. ↩
-
Second Helvetic Confession, ch. 21. ↩
-
FC Ep VII.3–5. ↩
-
FC Ep VII.29. ↩
-
Calvin, Institutes IV.17.33; Second Helvetic Confession, ch. 21. ↩
-
FC SD VII.119. ↩
-
FC SD VII.61–62, 64–65. ↩
-
SC VI.8. ↩
-
FC Ep VIII.1. ↩
-
Heidelberg Catechism, QQ. 47–48. The newer English of the Christian Reformed Church and the Reformed Church in America reads “beyond the bounds of the humanity which it has assumed.” ↩
-
Athanasius, On the Incarnation 17, in the English translation published by the Christian Classics Ethereal Library (ccel.org). ↩
-
Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John, as quoted by Calvin, Institutes IV.17.26. ↩
-
Calvin, Institutes IV.17.24, citing Augustine’s letter to Dardanus. The Council of Chalcedon is paraphrased in the text. ↩
-
Calvin, Institutes II.14.1–2, where Calvin calls the communication of properties “a figure of speech” and insists that the Scripture passages on which it rests are not “of man’s devising.” The three ways are traditionally called the genus idiomaticum, the genus apotelesmaticum, and the genus maiestaticum; the Formula sets them out in that order in FC SD VIII.36–87. ↩
-
FC Ep VIII.15–16. ↩
-
FC SD VIII.78–79; compare VIII.77. ↩
-
FC Ep VIII.29. ↩
-
FC Ep VIII.17; compare FC SD VII.97–103, quoting Luther’s Confession Concerning Christ’s Supper (1528). ↩
-
FC SD VIII.14–15; FC Ep VIII.18. ↩
-
FC SD VIII.40, quoting Luther’s Confession Concerning Christ’s Supper. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, First Head, Art. 7. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, First Head, Art. 9. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, First Head, Art. 15. ↩
-
John Calvin, Commentary on 1 Timothy, on 2:4, paraphrased; compare 1 Timothy 2:1–2. On this reading and the Lutheran answer see God Wills All to Be Saved. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, First Head, Arts. 15 and 5. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, Third and Fourth Heads, Art. 8; compare Second Head, Art. 5. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, First Head, Art. 16. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, Conclusion, in Schaff, Creeds, vol. 3. ↩
-
Second Helvetic Confession, ch. 10. ↩
-
FC SD XI.8. ↩
-
FC SD XI.88; FC Ep XI.20. ↩
-
FC SD XI.65. ↩
-
FC Ep XI.19 rejects the teaching “that God is unwilling that every one should be saved, but that some, without regard to their sins, from the mere counsel, purpose, and will of God, are ordained to condemnation so that they cannot be saved.” ↩
-
FC SD XI.5. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, Second Head, Arts. 3 and 8. ↩
-
FC SD XI.28–29. ↩
-
FC SD XI.57. ↩
-
FC SD XI.40. ↩
-
FC SD XI.91; compare XI.55. ↩
-
Heidelberg Catechism, Q. 74. ↩
-
Belgic Confession, Art. 33. ↩
-
Belgic Confession, Art. 34. ↩
-
Heidelberg Catechism, Q. 73. ↩
-
SC IV.5–10, paraphrased. ↩
-
LC IV.10. ↩
-
LC IV.35. ↩
-
Belgic Confession, Art. 34. Compare LC IV.64–86 on the daily use of Baptism. ↩
-
Canons of Dort, First Head, Art. 17. ↩
-
Agreement between Reformation Churches in Europe (The Leuenberg Agreement) (1973), §§18–19, English translation of the Community of Protestant Churches in Europe. ↩
-
Leuenberg Agreement, §25. ↩
-
Leuenberg Agreement, §27. ↩
-
A Formula of Agreement between the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, the Presbyterian Church (USA), the Reformed Church in America, and the United Church of Christ on Entering into Full Communion on the Basis of A Common Calling (1997), “Mutual Affirmation and Admonition.” The Preface also declares that the four churches “withdraw any historic condemnation by one side or the other as inappropriate for the life and faith of our churches today.” ↩
-
The vote was 839 to 193 on August 28, 1997 (Mattes, “A Confessional Response,” 10, quoting Edgar R. Trexler). ↩
-
FC SD XI.57–60; FC Ep XI.12. ↩
-
AC VII.2. ↩
-
FC SD X.31; compare FC Ep X.7, “agreement among them in doctrine and all its articles.” ↩
-
Preface to the Book of Concord (1580), Triglotta. ↩
-
Mattes, “A Confessional Response,” 23. The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod’s Commission on Theology and Church Relations evaluated the agreement in The Formula of Agreement in Confessional Lutheran Perspective (1999). ↩
-
Ibid., 3. Mattes names the Christian Reformed Church and the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. ↩
-
FC Ep XI.13; compare FC SD XI.66. Bullinger is quoted from the Second Helvetic Confession, ch. 10. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Lutheranism and the Reformed Churches: Marburg, Geneva, and Dort: A Lutheran Reading of Our Nearest Relatives.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/lutheranism-and/reformed/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.