Papers · Lutheranism and …

Lutheranism and Anglicanism

Two Reformations, One Inheritance, and the Questions Still Between Us

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread.” — 1 Corinthians 10:16–17


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are cited in the notes by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, FC Ep, FC SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions, and quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Words in square brackets inside a Triglotta quotation are the Triglotta’s own, translating the German text. The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion are given in Arabic numerals (Article 28) so that they are not confused with the articles of the Augsburg Confession, and they are quoted from the text of 1571 printed with the Book of Common Prayer as the Church of England publishes it. The 1662 Prayer Book is quoted in its standard text. Richard Hooker is cited by book, chapter and section of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity as in Keble’s edition, though quoted from the older editions named in the notes, with the long s modernized and nothing else changed.


An Old Acquaintance

A Lutheran who walks into an English parish church that still uses the old Book of Common Prayer will feel at home before he has found his seat. He will hear the Kyrie, the Gloria, the Creed, the Sanctus and the Agnus Dei. He will hear the Epistle and Gospel for the Sunday after Trinity, often the very lessons his own grandparents heard, and collects that Lutherans have prayed in English for more than a century. He will kneel for the confession, hear the absolution, and before the Communion hear the priest say, “Hear what comfortable words our Saviour Christ saith unto all that truly turn to him,” followed by “Come unto me all that travail and are heavy laden, and I will refresh you.”1 He may well ask himself why these two churches are not one.

The answer begins in the words spoken over the bread and in Article 28 of the Thirty-Nine Articles, and I will come to both. Before that, it is worth noticing how much these churches learned from one teacher. The Augsburg Confession, in its article on the Church, says that “to the true unity of the Church it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments,” and that human rites need not “be everywhere alike.” For proof it cites Paul: “There is one body and one Spirit—just as you were called to the one hope that belongs to your call—one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is over all and through all and in all” (Ephesians 4:4–6).2 A generation later the bishops of the Church of England wrote in their own Article 34, “It is not necessary that Traditions and Ceremonies be in all places one, and utterly like.” In addition, some Lutherans (the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America in this country and many of the Lutheran churches of Scandinavia and the Baltic) now share the altar and the pulpit with Anglicans, while the Missouri Synod and the Wisconsin Synod do not. Why the difference? What does each side see that the other does not?

I want to answer those questions as a confessional Lutheran pastor and to describe the Anglican faith as a well-taught Anglican would describe it, with his own texts and his own reasons. In this paper I will take up five matters: 1) who the Anglicans are and how our two churches have met; 2) what we hold in common, which is much; 3) where we part, chiefly on the Lord’s Supper, on bishops, and on how tightly a church should hold its confession; 4) what each church might learn from the other; and lastly 5) a word for the Lutheran whose family worships at an Anglican altar.


I. The Church of England and Its Daughters

Two Roots

The English Reformation had two roots. One was an evangelical movement that read Luther and Tyndale in the 1520s. The other was a king’s quarrel with the pope over his marriage. The second gave the first its opening. When Rome would not annul Henry VIII’s marriage to Catherine of Aragon, Parliament cut the English Church off from the papacy between 1532 and 1534 and named the king its Supreme Head. Henry himself remained in most things a Catholic of the old kind. He had written against Luther in 1521 and in his later years he put to death evangelicals and papists alike. Under Edward VI (1547–1553) the Church of England became Protestant in doctrine and worship, under Mary I (1553–1558) it was returned to Rome and Archbishop Thomas Cranmer was burned, and under Elizabeth I (1558–1603) the Protestant settlement was restored in the shape it has kept, more or less, ever since.

That settlement rests on three “historic formularies”: the Book of Common Prayer (Cranmer’s work, first issued in 1549, revised in 1552 and 1559, and for the last time in 1662), the Ordinal for making deacons, priests and bishops, and the Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion, adopted in 1563 and in English in 1571. The Church of England’s canon law says, “The doctrine of the Church of England is grounded in the Holy Scriptures, and in such teachings of the ancient Fathers and Councils of the Church as are agreeable to the said Scriptures. In particular such doctrine is to be found in the Thirty-nine Articles of Religion, The Book of Common Prayer, and the Ordinal.”3 Beside these stands the Church’s greatest early apologist, Richard Hooker (1554–1600). His Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity defended the Elizabethan Church against the Puritans, who wanted it ordered on the Genevan pattern. Hooker argued that Scripture is supreme in everything necessary to salvation, while in what Scripture leaves open the Church may order its life by reason and by the wisdom of the ancient Church. Anglicans of every party still read him.

Wittenberg and Lambeth

In the 1520s a circle of young scholars is said to have met at the White Horse inn in Cambridge to read Luther’s books. One of them, Robert Barnes, went to Wittenberg, became Luther’s friend, and was burned at Smithfield in 1540. William Tyndale took many of the prefaces and notes of his New Testament from Luther. Cranmer himself spent 1532 in Germany as Henry’s ambassador. In Nuremberg he came to know the Lutheran reformer Andreas Osiander and secretly married Margarete, the niece of Osiander’s wife, a remarkable thing for a priest who would be Archbishop of Canterbury within months.4

In the later 1530s Henry, wanting allies against the emperor, opened talks with the Lutheran princes. A Lutheran delegation came to London in 1538 and the two sides drew up thirteen articles in Latin that closely followed the Augsburg Confession. Henry never approved them. However, Philip Schaff showed that “some passages were transferred verbatim from the Lutheran document to the Thirteen Articles, and from these to the Forty-two (1553), and were retained in the Elizabethan revision (1563 and 1571).” When Archbishop Matthew Parker revised the articles in 1563 he drew on another Lutheran confession as well, the Württemberg Confession of 1552. The 1549 Prayer Book borrowed in turn from the Consultation of Archbishop Hermann of Cologne, which Bucer and Melanchthon had drafted, and Lutheran divines sometimes called the English Church an Ecclesia Lutheranizans (“a Lutheranizing church”).5 The debt shows on the page. The Augsburg Confession teaches that God is “eternal, without body, without parts, of infinite power, wisdom, and goodness, the Maker and Preserver of all things, visible and invisible.” Article 1 says that God is “everlasting, without body, parts, or passions; of infinite power, wisdom, and goodness; the Maker, and Preserver of all things both visible and invisible.”6

Under Edward VI the influence of other teachers grew. The Strasbourg reformer Martin Bucer, a mediating figure between Wittenberg and Zurich, taught at Cambridge, Peter Martyr Vermigli at Oxford, and John à Lasco led the foreign congregations in London. Cranmer’s mind on the Supper moved away from a bodily presence of Christ in the bread toward a presence of Christ to the faith of the receiver, and the Prayer Book of 1552 and the Articles were written on that side of the line. In other words, the Church of England took its doctrine of justification largely from Wittenberg and its doctrine of the Supper largely from the Reformed. Even so, the Elizabethan church hesitated at the very point where Lutherans differ. Article 29, which denies that the wicked receive the body of Christ, was left out of the printed Articles in 1563 and restored only in 1571.7

The Anglican Communion Today

As England’s people spread across the world, its church went with them. The Episcopal Church in the United States organized itself with its own bishops in 1789, and in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries the mission churches of Africa, Asia and the Pacific became self-governing provinces. In 1867 the Archbishop of Canterbury called their bishops to the first Lambeth Conference, and the family that grew from it came to be called the Anglican Communion. It has no pope and no single binding confession. In 1888 the Lambeth Conference named four marks of the unity it sought with other churches: the Holy Scriptures, the Apostles’ and Nicene Creeds, the two sacraments of Baptism and the Supper, and the historic episcopate, which it allowed to be adapted locally to the needs of each nation. By “the historic episcopate” Anglicans mean bishops consecrated by other bishops in an unbroken line of the laying on of hands that reaches back, they believe, to the apostles. The Anglican Communion is usually said to number some eighty-five million people, most of whom now live in Africa.8

Anglicans have long spoken of three tendencies in their church. The evangelical or “low church” tradition reads the Articles as a Reformed confession and stresses preaching, conversion and justification by faith. The Anglo-Catholic tradition, heir to the older high churchmanship and renewed by the Oxford Movement of the 1830s, stresses the sacraments, the priesthood and continuity with the ancient and medieval Church. The liberal or “broad church” tradition stresses reason, scholarship and openness to new thought. Each has a claim on the formularies and a Lutheran should never assume that one Anglican speaks for all the rest.

In our own day the Communion has divided over marriage and sexuality, much as the Lutheran world has. In 2008 conservative bishops meeting in Jerusalem formed GAFCON (the Global Anglican Future Conference), and in mid-October 2025 its primates declared that the Communion’s councils had “failed to uphold the doctrine and discipline of the Anglican Communion” and that they no longer recognized the authority of the Archbishop of Canterbury. In March 2026 they met in Abuja and formed a Global Anglican Council.9 Those on the other side argue that faithfulness to the Gospel’s welcome and a developing reading of Scripture permit the changes they have made. I will not try to settle an argument among Anglicans that Lutherans are having among themselves, and as I write it is too early to say what shape the Communion will take.

How Our Churches Have Met

After going their own ways for three centuries, the two churches met again in the twentieth. The Church of England entered a limited intercommunion with the Church of Sweden after 1920, since the Swedish bishops had kept the succession at the Reformation. International dialogues followed from 1972. In 1992 the British and Irish Anglican churches and the Nordic and Baltic Lutheran churches agreed on the Porvoo Common Statement, which established communion among the churches that adopted it. In this country the Lutheran-Episcopal Agreement of 1982 led to Called to Common Mission, adopted by the ELCA in 1999 and by the Episcopal Church in 2000.10 The Missouri Synod and Lutheran Church–Canada are not in fellowship with any Anglican body. However, since 2010 they have held theological conversations with the Anglican Church in North America, which was formed in 2009 by Anglicans who left the Episcopal Church and the Anglican Church of Canada, and in 2016 they issued an interim report, On Closer Acquaintance.11


II. What We Hold in Common

We share with Anglicans 1) the creeds and the faith they confess, 2) the authority and sufficiency of Holy Scripture, 3) justification by faith alone, 4) the sacraments as means of grace and the baptism of infants, 5) the liturgy and the church year, 6) the freedom of the Church in ceremonies, and lastly 7) a doctrine of election that is closer to ours than most Lutherans suppose. I will take them in order.

Article 8 says that the Nicene, Athanasian and Apostles’ Creeds “ought thoroughly to be received and believed: for they may be proved by most certain warrants of holy Scripture.” Our Book of Concord opens with the same three creeds, and we too confess them because they are drawn from Scripture and not because a council imposed them. The 1662 Prayer Book appoints the Athanasian Creed for Morning Prayer on certain feasts, and many Lutheran congregations still say it on Holy Trinity.

On Scripture, Article 6 reads, “Holy Scripture containeth all things necessary to salvation: so that whatsoever is not read therein, nor may be proved thereby, is not to be required of any man, that it should be believed as an article of the Faith, or be thought requisite or necessary to salvation.” Article 21 adds that general councils “may err, and sometimes have erred, even in things pertaining unto God.” The Formula of Concord also says this, in its own idiom: “the sole rule and standard according to which all dogmas together with [all] teachers should be estimated and judged are the prophetic and apostolic Scriptures of the Old and of the New Testament alone.”12 We hear Paul alike: “All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness” (2 Timothy 3:16). Article 6 and Luther’s Bible even agree on the Apocrypha, which both commend for reading but not for establishing doctrine.

The most important agreement is justification. Article 11 is short enough to quote whole: “We are accounted righteous before God, only for the merit of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ by Faith, and not for our own works or deservings: Wherefore, that we are justified by Faith only is a most wholesome Doctrine, and very full of comfort, as more largely is expressed in the Homily of Justification.” Set that beside our own article, which says that men “are freely justified for Christ’s sake, through faith, when they believe that they are received into favor, and that their sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake, who, by His death, has made satisfaction for our sins.”13 The homily Article 11 names is Cranmer’s Sermon of the Salvation of Mankind (1547). There Cranmer writes that “this saying, that we be justified by faith only, freely, and without works, is spoken for to take away clearly all merit of our works, as being unable to deserve our justification at God’s hands.” He even cites the same sentence of Ambrose that the Augsburg Confession cites, that he who believes in Christ “should be saved without works, by faith only, freely receiving remission of his sins.”14 Paul’s sentence is the common ground: “For we hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law” (Romans 3:28). Article 12 then says that good works “do spring out necessarily of a true and lively Faith,” as our Confession says that “this faith is bound to bring forth good fruits.” Although John Henry Newman, while still an Anglican, argued in his Lectures on Justification (1838) for a position between Rome and Wittenberg, and many Anglo-Catholics followed him, the Article and the Homily remain the Church of England’s own, and an Anglican evangelical and a confessional Lutheran reading Romans together will usually find they speak one language.

On the sacraments, Article 25 says that they are “not only badges or tokens of Christian men’s profession, but rather they be certain sure witnesses, and effectual signs of grace, and God’s good will towards us, by the which he doth work invisibly in us.” The Augsburg Confession says in nearly the same words that the sacraments were ordained “not only to be marks of profession among men, but rather to be signs and testimonies of the will of God toward us.”15 Article 27 calls Baptism “a sign of Regeneration or new Birth, whereby, as by an instrument, they that receive Baptism rightly are grafted into the Church,” and it ends, “The Baptism of young Children is in any wise to be retained in the Church, as most agreeable with the institution of Christ.” The 1662 rite for infants is bolder still. After the baptism the priest says, “Seeing now, dearly beloved brethren, that this Child is regenerate, and grafted into the body of Christ’s Church, let us give thanks unto Almighty God for these benefits.”16 We baptize infants on the strength of Christ’s command and promise, as Anglicans do, and we hear that promise in Peter’s sermon at Pentecost: “the promise is for you and for your children and for all who are far off, everyone whom the Lord our God calls to himself” (Acts 2:39). Some Anglican evangelicals have read the Prayer Book’s “is regenerate” more loosely than we would, and in the Gorham case of 1850 the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, overruling the church’s own court, allowed that looser reading. Even so, the words stand in the book, and a Lutheran can pray them as written.

The Niagara Report, which the ELCA and the Episcopal Church adopted into Called to Common Mission, says that “Anglicans and Lutherans use very similar orders of service for the Eucharist, for the Prayer Offices, for the administration of Baptism, for the rites of Marriage, Burial, and Confession and Absolution.”17 Like us, the Church of England kept the historic Western Mass, purged of the sacrifice of the Mass and put into the people’s language, the church year with its collects and its Epistles and Gospels, and private confession and absolution for the troubled, although neither church compels it. The 1662 order for the Visitation of the Sick gives the priest these words for a penitent: “by his authority committed to me, I absolve thee from all thy sins, In the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost.”

On ceremonies I have already set Article 34 beside our article on the Church. Our Formula of Concord adds that “no Church should condemn another because one has less or more external ceremonies not commanded by God than the other, if otherwise there is agreement among them in doctrine and all its articles, as also in the right use of the holy Sacraments.”18 In addition, the Articles reject “the Romish Doctrine concerning Purgatory” and the invocation of saints (Article 22), “the sacrifices of Masses” (Article 31) and the withholding of the cup (Article 30), as we do.

Lastly, election. Lutherans often assume that Article 17 is Calvinist. It speaks of “the everlasting purpose of God, whereby (before the foundations of the world were laid) he hath constantly decreed by his counsel secret to us, to deliver from curse and damnation those whom he hath chosen in Christ out of mankind.” It warns that for “curious and carnal persons” to dwell on God’s predestination “is a most dangerous downfal” (that is, downfall), and it ends, “we must receive God’s promises in such wise, as they be generally set forth to us in holy Scripture.” The Formula of Concord also teaches that election “does not extend at once over the godly and the wicked, but only over the children of God,” and it sends the troubled to Christ, “the Book of Life,” and not into “the secret counsel of God.”19 Although many Elizabethan divines were Calvinists and Archbishop Whitgift approved the Lambeth Articles of 1595, which taught a double predestination, the Queen would not authorize them, and they never became the Church’s doctrine. On the Article as written I see no contradiction of the Formula. However, the Article does not confess, as the Formula does, that the promise of the Gospel is meant earnestly for all, since God “desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth” (1 Timothy 2:4). Since some Anglicans read it in a Reformed sense and others do not, a Lutheran will want to know which reading his neighbor holds.


III. Where We Part

With so much in common, why are we not one? I believe the honest answer is that we differ in fewer places than many Lutherans suppose, but that the places are not small. The first is the Lord’s Supper. The second is bishops. The third, which lies beneath both, is how tightly a church should hold its confession.

1. The Lord’s Supper

What we confess, and why

Our confession of the Supper is short: “Of the Supper of the Lord they teach that the Body and Blood of Christ are truly present, and are distributed to those who eat the Supper of the Lord; and they reject those that teach otherwise.”20 The reason is the words of Christ Himself:

Now as they were eating, Jesus took bread, and after blessing it broke it and gave it to the disciples, and said, “Take, eat; this is my body.” And he took a cup, and when he had given thanks he gave it to them, saying, “Drink of it, all of you, for this is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins. (Matthew 26:26–28)

We take the word “is” as it stands. Christ, who is God and man in one person, gives what He says He gives. Paul confirms it in the verses at the head of this essay, where the bread is a koinōnia (“participation, sharing, communion”) in the body of Christ (1 Corinthians 10:16).

From this follows the point on which everything turns. Because the body and blood are present by Christ’s word, and not by the faith of the one who receives them, all who eat the bread receive them, the believer for forgiveness and life and the unbeliever to his judgment. Paul writes, “Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord. Let a person examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment on himself” (1 Corinthians 11:27–29). How can anyone be guilty of a body that he did not receive? The Formula of Concord draws the conclusion that even “unworthy, godless hypocrites, as Judas and his ilk,” receive “orally in the Sacrament the true body and [true] blood of Christ.” It is careful to add that this eating happens “not in a gross, carnal, Capernaitic, but in a supernatural, incomprehensible way.”21 In other words, we do not imagine the crude fleshly eating that shocked the crowd at Capernaum in John 6.

We do not teach that the Supper benefits a man without faith. The Small Catechism says that “he that believes these words has what they say and express, namely, the forgiveness of sins,” and that “he is truly worthy and well prepared who has faith in these words: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins.”22 However, faith receives the gift and does not make it present. A man who doubts whether his faith is strong enough does not have to look into his own heart to know whether Christ is there for him. He can look at the bread in the pastor’s hand and hear the words “given for you.”

What Anglicans confess, and why

Article 28 says more than many Lutherans expect. It denies that the Supper is only “a sign of the love that Christians ought to have among themselves one to another,” and calls it “a Sacrament of our Redemption by Christ’s death: insomuch that to such as rightly, worthily, and with faith, receive the same, the Bread which we break is a partaking of the Body of Christ; and likewise the Cup of Blessing is a partaking of the Blood of Christ.” It rejects transubstantiation as “repugnant to the plain words of Scripture.” Then it gives its own answer: “The Body of Christ is given, taken, and eaten, in the Supper, only after an heavenly and spiritual manner. And the mean whereby the Body of Christ is received and eaten in the Supper is Faith.” Article 29 adds that the wicked, “although they do carnally and visibly press with their teeth (as Saint Augustine saith) the Sacrament of the Body and Blood of Christ, yet in no wise are they partakers of Christ: but rather, to their condemnation, do eat and drink the sign or Sacrament of so great a thing.”

The Prayer Book teaches the same faith in the voice of prayer, and an Anglican learns his doctrine of the Supper at least as much from the rite as from the Articles. Before Communion the priest prays in the people’s name, “Grant us therefore, gracious Lord, so to eat the flesh of thy dear Son Jesus Christ, and to drink his blood, that our sinful bodies may be made clean by his body, and our souls washed through his most precious blood.” In the prayer of consecration he asks that “we receiving these thy creatures of bread and wine… may be partakers of his most blessed Body and Blood.” The 1662 Catechism says that the inward part of the Sacrament is “The Body and Blood of Christ, which are verily and indeed taken and received by the faithful in the Lord’s Supper.”23 In 1549 the bread was given with the words, “The body of our Lorde Jesus Christe whiche was geven for thee, preserve thy bodye and soule unto everlasting lyfe.” In 1552 those words gave way to, “Take and eat this in remembrance that Christ died for thee, and feed on him in thy heart by faith with thanksgiving.” The 1662 book joins the two, so that the communicant hears first that the Body of our Lord was given for him and then that he is to feed on Christ in his heart by faith.24

Anglicans who hold this teaching have serious reasons. The first is Christological. Article 4 confesses that Christ “took again his body, with flesh, bones, and all things appertaining to the perfection of Man’s nature; wherewith he ascended into Heaven, and there sitteth, until he return to judge all Men at the last day.” Peter says of Jesus that “heaven must receive” Him “until the time for restoring all the things” (Acts 3:21). The English Reformers argued that a body which is truly human, and which will come again visibly, cannot be everywhere without ceasing to be a human body. For them this was a matter of confessing Christ’s true humanity, as the Council of Chalcedon does when it says the two natures are united without confusion. The declaration on kneeling at the end of the 1662 rite puts it this way: “the natural Body and Blood of our Saviour Christ are in Heaven, and not here; it being against the truth of Christ’s natural Body to be at one time in more places than one.” The second reason is the movement of the rite itself. The 1662 service lifts the communicant’s heart to Christ in heaven (“Lift up your hearts.” “We lift them up unto the Lord.”), and the Anglican sees the Supper as the Spirit’s joining us to Christ where He is. The third is Christ’s word in John 6, “It is the Spirit who gives life; the flesh is no help at all” (John 6:63), and the fourth is Augustine, whom Article 29 quotes. The fifth is pastoral. The English Reformers had seen ordinary people gaze at the elevated host in the Latin Mass, worship it and go home without receiving it, and they wanted nothing to draw the people’s eyes from Christ or to keep them from His table. Therefore Article 28 ends, “The Sacrament of the Lord’s Supper was not by Christ’s ordinance reserved, carried about, lifted up, or worshipped.”25

Hooker gave this teaching its classic form. “The real Presence of Christ’s most Blessed Body and Blood is not therefore to be sought for in the Sacrament, but in the worthy Receiver of the Sacrament.” He also begged Christians to stop quarreling over the manner. “What these Elements are in themselves it skilleth not; it is enough, that to me which take them they are the Body and Blood of Christ; his promise in witness hereof sufficeth; his word he knoweth which way to accomplish.”26 In other words, it does not matter what the elements are in themselves, since Christ’s promise is enough. Later Anglicans called Hooker’s view “receptionism,” the teaching that Christ’s body is received by the believer’s faith rather than present in the bread itself, though the name does not always do him justice. Others went further. The Caroline divines of the seventeenth century and the Tractarians of the nineteenth taught an objective presence of Christ in the consecrated elements, and Newman argued in Tract 90 (1841) that Article 28 rejects only a carnal presence and not a real one. Today a few Anglicans hold a memorial view, most evangelicals hold the spiritual presence of Cranmer and Hooker, and Anglo-Catholics teach an objective presence in the elements without requiring transubstantiation. In the Porvoo Statement and in Called to Common Mission, Anglican churches signed this sentence: “We believe that the Body and Blood of Christ are truly present, distributed, and received under the forms of bread and wine in the Lord’s Supper.”27

Where the difference lies

An Anglican will rightly say that his Sacrament rests on Christ’s promise as firmly as ours does. Article 28 makes faith “the mean whereby” the body is received just as Article 11 makes faith the means of justification, as the hand that receives and not the cause, and Hooker says outright that Christ’s “promise in witness hereof sufficeth.” I grant it. Nor is the difference transubstantiation or the sacrifice of the Mass, which we both reject, or the word “spiritual,” since the Formula also denies a carnal eating.

The difference is not therefore a small one. It lies in two questions. Is Christ’s body given in the bread on the altar, or in heaven to the believing soul? Do the unworthy receive the body of Christ, or only the sign? On both questions our Confessions answer by name. Among the errors the Formula of Concord rejects are these:

  1. That in the Holy Supper the body of Christ is not received orally with the bread; but that with the mouth only bread and wine are received, the body of Christ, however, only spiritually by faith. …
  2. That believers must not seek the body [and blood] of Christ in the bread and wine of the Holy Supper, but raise their eyes from the bread to heaven and there seek the body of Christ.
  3. That unbelieving, impenitent Christians do not receive the true body and blood of Christ in the Holy Supper, but only bread and wine.28

The reader can set these beside Article 28’s “the mean… is Faith,” Hooker’s “not… in the Sacrament, but in the worthy Receiver,” and Article 29. Therefore the question is not whether faith is needed, but what faith does. In the Articles faith is the means by which the body itself is received. In the Small Catechism faith is the means by which the forgiveness promised in the body and blood is received, while the body is given with the bread to every mouth. The 1662 rubric I would read more cautiously. It places Christ’s “natural Body” in heaven, and an Anglican may read that, as a Lutheran could, as a denial only of a local, circumscribed presence, which the Formula also denies. Article 29 is plainer.

I believe our Confessions are right, because Christ did not say, “This is a pledge of my body in heaven,” but, “Take, eat; this is my body,” and Paul writes that the unworthy are “guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord.” To the Christological argument our Confessions give a Christological answer, not a bare appeal to God’s power. Luther’s reasons, which the Formula adopts, are that Christ is “true, essential, natural, perfect God and man in one person, undivided and inseparable,” that “God’s right hand is everywhere,” that “God’s Word is not false, and does not deceive,” and that “God has and knows of various modes of being in any place, and not only the one… which philosophers call localis (local).”29 The Formula then sets out the different ways Christ’s one body can be present, and it answers the very texts on the ascension that the Reformed cite.30 It holds as firmly as any Anglican that Christ’s body remains a true body and does not become infinite. It denies only that this body is bound to the one way of being present that we know. I have set out that argument more fully in One Body at Many Altars.

The Gospel is at stake here. A troubled believer who hears that the body is given only to faith may ask whether his faith was the kind that receives it. Cranmer meant faith to look away from itself to Christ and the best Anglican preaching does so. Even so, our answer gives that believer something outside himself to hold, the bread in the pastor’s hand and the words “given for you.” I must add that Lutherans fail here in our own way. Many a Lutheran who confesses the real presence comes to the altar seldom and without thought, and many have forgotten their Baptism as completely as any Christian has forgotten the promise. A right confession does not keep us from that sin.

The judgment of our Confessions falls on a doctrine and not on Anglicans as persons. The Preface to the Book of Concord, speaking of this very controversy, says that “it is in no way our design and purpose to condemn those men who err from a certain simplicity of mind, but are not blasphemers against the truth of the heavenly doctrine, much less, indeed, entire churches.”31 For this reason confessional Lutherans have not been able to share the altar on the strength of the Porvoo and Common Mission sentence alone. The sentence is true, but the Articles stand beside it, Article 29 among them, and an agreement that each side reads in its own sense is not yet the agreement “in the doctrine and all its articles, also in the right use of the holy Sacraments” that our Confessions ask before churches commune together.32

2. Bishops

The Anglican case

The Preface to the 1662 Ordinal begins, “It is evident unto all men diligently reading holy Scripture and ancient Authors, that from the Apostles’ time there have been these Orders of Ministers in Christ’s Church; Bishops, Priests, and Deacons.” It goes on to require that every minister of the Church of England be ordained by its rite “or hath had Episcopal Consecration, or Ordination.”33

The Anglican case rests on Scripture and on the ancient Church. The apostles laid hands on those they sent. Paul reminds Timothy “to fan into flame the gift of God, which is in you through the laying on of my hands” (2 Timothy 1:6), and he left Titus in Crete to “appoint elders in every town” (Titus 1:5). Most Anglican scholars since J. B. Lightfoot’s essay The Christian Ministry (1868) have granted that in the New Testament the words “elder” and “overseer” are used of the same men. Their answer is that the office Timothy and Titus themselves held, ordaining and overseeing the elders of many towns, is the office the Church later called bishop. By the second century the churches everywhere were led by a single bishop with presbyters and deacons, and Irenaeus answered the Gnostics by pointing to the lists of bishops in the apostolic churches. Anglicans reason that a pattern so early and so universal is the way God has kept His Church in the apostolic faith and the way the churches have known one another. They differ on how necessary it is. Some Anglo-Catholics have held that the episcopate belongs to the esse (the being) of the Church, so that a church without it is not fully a church. Most Anglicans say it belongs to the Church’s bene esse (its well-being) or plene esse (its fullness).

Hooker defended the episcopate as apostolic. Even so, he wrote that “there may be sometimes very just and sufficient reason to allow Ordination made without a Bishop.” When “the exigence of necessity doth constrain to leave the usual ways of the Church,” then “we are not, simply without exception, to urge a lineal descent of Power from the Apostles by continued succession of Bishops in every effectual Ordination.” He went on at once: “These cases of inevitable necessity excepted, none may ordain but only Bishops.”34 Nor did the classical Anglican divines deny that the Lutheran and Reformed churches were true churches. Lancelot Andrewes, who held episcopacy to be of divine right, wrote to the French Reformed theologian Pierre du Moulin in 1618 that it did not follow that churches without bishops were no churches or that there was no salvation in them.35

Our confession

Our Confessions begin from the office of preaching and the Sacraments, which God instituted “that we may obtain this faith,” and they say that “no one should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments unless he be regularly called.” Article 23 agrees (“lawfully called, and sent”). The difference appears when we ask what belongs to a bishop by divine command. The Augsburg Confession answers that “according to the Gospel or, as they say, by divine right, there belongs to the bishops as bishops, that is, to those to whom has been committed the ministry of the Word and the Sacraments, no jurisdiction except to forgive sins, to judge doctrine, to reject doctrines contrary to the Gospel, and to exclude from the communion of the Church wicked men.”36 In other words, the bishop’s office by divine right is the pastor’s office. The Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope draws the conclusion. This power “by divine right is common to all who preside over churches, whether they are called pastors, or elders, or bishops,” and therefore “it is by human authority that the grades of bishop and elder or pastor are distinct,” so that “ordination administered by a pastor in his own church is valid by divine law.”37 The Treatise rests on Paul’s own words. In Titus 1 the men Titus appoints are first called “elders,” and two verses later Paul writes, “For an overseer, as God’s steward, must be above reproach” (Titus 1:7). He calls the elders of Ephesus to Miletus and tells them, “Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers” (Acts 20:28). The word is episkopos, from which “bishop” comes.

Our reformers did not despise bishops. The Apology says that “it is our greatest wish to maintain church-polity and the grades in the Church, even though they have been made by human authority,” and that “we will gladly maintain ecclesiastical and canonical government, provided the bishops only cease to rage against our Churches.”38 When the German bishops would not ordain evangelical pastors, the Lutherans ordained their own. In Sweden and Finland the bishops became evangelical and the succession was kept, while in Denmark and Norway it was not, and Bugenhagen, a Wittenberg pastor, ordained new superintendents in 1537.

Therefore we may have bishops, many Lutheran churches do, and some stand in the historic succession. What we cannot do is make the succession a condition of a true ministry or of church unity, because it would add to the marks of the Church something Scripture does not command. The reason is evangelical. If a true ministry depended on an unbroken line of hands, the certainty of the absolution and the Sacrament would rest on a pedigree no layman can trace, when Christ has rested it on His own word and institution. That is also the reason the Treatise gives against the papacy’s claims.

Called to Common Mission names the difference with real honesty. The Episcopal Church “is free to maintain that sharing in the historic catholic episcopate, while not necessary for salvation or for recognition of another church as a church, is nonetheless necessary when Anglicans enter the relationship of full communion in order to link the local churches for mutual responsibility in the communion of the larger church.” The ELCA “is free to maintain that this same episcopate, although pastorally desirable when exercised in personal, collegial, and communal ways, is nonetheless not necessary for the relationship of full communion,” and in receiving it the ELCA says that it “does not thereby affirm that it is necessary for the unity of the church.”39 Porvoo likewise says that the sign of succession “does not by itself guarantee the fidelity of a church to every aspect of the apostolic faith.”40 I understand the Anglican reason. For Anglicans, bishops in succession are the visible bond that knits local churches into one communion, and the Episcopal Church in these words does not unchurch Lutherans who lack them, as Andrewes did not. Even so, a confessional Lutheran asks the question the ELCA’s own debate raised in 1999. If a thing is not necessary for unity, why must one church receive it before the two may share the altar? Our Formula warns that a free thing does not stay free when it is “required and received in this sense, as though by and through them both contrary religions were reconciled and became one body,” and that Paul yielded to the weak but not to those “who wished to impose these upon the conscience as necessary things.”41 I do not apply those words to the Episcopal Church as if it were imposing on anyone, since the ELCA chose freely. I mean only that order is a matter of Christian freedom, and that freedom is not well kept when a free thing is made the condition of fellowship and agreement in doctrine is not.

3. How Tightly Should a Church Hold Its Confession?

Under the Supper and the episcopate lies a question about what a confession is for. Confessional Lutheran pastors subscribe the Book of Concord because it agrees with Scripture and not merely insofar as it does, as the Formula’s Rule and Norm requires. The Formula receives all other writings only “as witnesses” under the Scripture, which alone is “the sole rule and standard,” and it binds those who teach in the Church to the Confessions as the true exposition of that Scripture in every article.42 The reason is the comfort of consciences and the unity of the Church. A pastor bound to a confession can tell a troubled conscience what the Church teaches about the Supper and the absolution, and the conscience can rely on it, because it does not depend on that pastor’s private opinion.

Anglicans have held their Articles in more than one way. For most of their history the clergy of the Church of England subscribed them. An act of 1571 required it and from 1604 the canons required every ordinand to acknowledge all the Articles to be agreeable to the Word of God. Only in 1865 was this softened to a general assent, and in 1975 the present Declaration of Assent was adopted, in which the clergy affirm the faith “to which the historic formularies of the Church of England bear witness.”43 The Episcopal Church never required subscription, while several large provinces in Africa and elsewhere still bind their clergy to the Articles, and the Anglican Church in North America receives them “taken in their literal and grammatical sense, as expressing the Anglican response to certain doctrinal issues controverted at that time, and as expressing fundamental principles of authentic Anglican belief.”44 A well-taught Anglican will add that the Articles were never meant to be a complete system. Article 6 itself forbids requiring as an article of faith anything not proved by Scripture, and so the Articles deliberately define little. In addition, Anglicans have long spoken of their church as “comprehensive,” meaning a church that holds together Christians of different convictions under the same creeds, Prayer Book and bishops, and by the old maxim lex orandi, lex credendi (“the law of praying is the law of believing”) an Anglican learns his faith from the Prayer Book he prays.

There is real wisdom in this. It recognizes that the Church is made of sinners who will not all see alike, and that a church which defines too much will divide over too little. Hooker’s whole book argues against making every matter of order a matter of faith. We agree with that much. We too distinguish doctrine from adiaphora (matters God has neither commanded nor forbidden) and we too have been tempted to treat a hymnal or a custom as if it were an article of faith. I must also say that a confession on paper does not keep a church faithful. Lutheran churches that still print the Book of Concord in their constitutions have divided over the questions that trouble the Anglicans, and a confession helps only when a church means it. My claim is narrower. A church that binds its teachers to a confession has a standard to return to, and it can say to its people what it teaches about the Supper. Where a church holds together, as one fellowship at one altar, teachings on the Supper that our Confessions judge cannot both be true, we cannot join it, not because we doubt the faith of its members, but because we do not believe the Lord left the content of His Supper open. Anglicans who are returning to the Articles in our day will find in us a partner who has lived with subscription for four centuries.


IV. What Each Might Learn From the Other

What we might learn

I believe Lutherans have much to learn from Anglicans. First, we might learn again to pray the daily office. Cranmer took the eight medieval hours of prayer and made two of them, Morning and Evening Prayer, for every parish and every household, and he arranged the Psalter to be read through every month and the Bible every year. Luther also wanted this and the early Lutheran church orders kept Matins and Vespers. However, in most Lutheran parishes these services faded, together with the private confession our own Confessions kept, while the Anglicans kept the offices alive. A Lutheran who prays Evening Prayer from the Prayer Book will find nothing in it contrary to his Confessions and much to feed his soul.

Second, we might learn the dignity of English from Cranmer, who wrote prayers to be said aloud by ordinary people, in a language that has outlived the English of his age. Lutherans who worship in English owe him more than they know.

Third, we might learn from the best Anglican bishops what episkopē (“oversight”) can mean. The Anglican practice of a bishop who visits, confirms, encourages and corrects is the kind of oversight our own Apology wished to keep, and Lutherans who have bishops in name and administrators in practice could profit from it.

Lastly, we might learn from the Anglican churches of Africa, which have grown in a century from mission stations into some of the largest churches in Christendom. They also have martyrs to teach us, from the young Christians of Uganda killed in 1885–1887 to Archbishop Janani Luwum, murdered in 1977, and an evangelistic zeal that many of our older churches have lost.

What we might offer

In return, we have something to give. The most precious is the Sacrament itself as our Confessions teach it, because it ties the gift to the bread Christ named and not to the receiver, and so gives every anxious communicant something outside himself to trust. We can also offer the distinction between Law and Gospel as a named and taught tool for every sermon. Cranmer knew it, for in the 1662 rite the Comfortable Words follow the confession of sins as Gospel follows Law, and the first Book of Homilies sets the misery of man before his salvation. However, the Articles do not set out the distinction as an article, and we can help Anglican preachers renew what is already in their own inheritance. It was, after all, while hearing Luther’s preface to Romans read aloud that John Wesley, an Anglican priest, came to trust in Christ alone for his salvation. We can offer the Small Catechism, which has taught children in a hundred languages what the Commandments, the Creed, the Lord’s Prayer and the Sacraments mean for them. Lastly, we can offer the chorales, which came into English largely through Anglican hands, chiefly those of Catherine Winkworth, a member of the Church of England who gave us “Now Thank We All Our God.”


A Word for the Family

Many who read this will have a husband or wife, a son-in-law or a dear friend who worships at an Anglican altar. To them I want to say a plain word. Your Anglican’s Baptism is a true Baptism and no Lutheran church will baptize him again. You can pray the Creed, the Lord’s Prayer and the Psalms together at home, and if you want a book for it, the Prayer Book’s Morning and Evening Prayer will serve you both. The hard place is the altar. The Episcopal Church will normally welcome you to its Communion as a baptized Christian, and a confessional Lutheran congregation will ask your Anglican spouse to wait. That difference can hurt at a wedding or at Christmas. It should be explained gently and with reasons. We hold back not because we doubt his faith or think ourselves better Christians, but because to commune together is to confess one faith about what is given at that altar, and we do not yet confess it together. Talk with your pastor and let the waiting be a reason to read Article 28 and the Small Catechism side by side.


Conclusion

The verses at the head of this essay end with a promise and a condition: “Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread” (1 Corinthians 10:17). Paul does not say that we become one body by agreeing to share a table, but that the one bread, which is the body of Christ, makes us one. That is why Lutherans and Anglicans have argued so long about the bread and why the argument still matters.

We have argued as kinsmen. The English and the German Reformations grew up in the same decade from the same books, and they wrote some of the same sentences into their confessions. On the creeds, on Scripture, on justification by faith alone, on Baptism and on the worship of the Church, Lutherans and Anglicans confess far more together than apart. Where we part, I have tried to give the Anglican his own reasons in his own words, and I believe the Lutheran Confessions are right that Christ’s body and blood are given in the bread and wine to all who eat, believer and unbeliever, because Christ said so, and that episcopal order is a good human order and not a mark of the Church. I count the Anglican a brother in Christ whose Baptism I honor and whose Prayer Book has taught many Lutherans to pray.

Therefore I pray as Hooker did, who asked Christians to quarrel less and to receive more, and who wrote that Christ’s “promise in witness hereof sufficeth.” May the Lord whose promise does suffice bring us at last to confess that promise together, so that we who are many may be one body because we all partake of the one bread.


Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)

The Lutheran Confessions

  • Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (Text at bookofconcord.org.)
  • The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
  • The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Preface; Augsburg Confession I, IV–VII, IX–X, XIII–XIV, XXVIII; Apology XIV; Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope 60–72; Small Catechism, Sacrament of the Altar; Formula of Concord, Rule and Norm, VII, X, XI.)

Anglican Formularies and Divines

  • Articles of Religion (1571), with “His Majesty’s Declaration” (1628). As printed with The Book of Common Prayer by the Church of England.
  • The Book of Common Prayer. 1549, 1552 and 1662 editions. (1549 and 1552 from the Society of Archbishop Justus; 1662 in the standard text.)
  • The Book of Common Prayer. Anglican Church in North America. Huntington Beach, CA: Anglican Liturgy Press, 2019.
  • Certain Sermons or Homilies Appointed to be Read in Churches. First Book, 1547.
  • Church of England. Canons of the Church of England, Canons A 5 and C 15.
  • Andrewes, Lancelot. Of Episcopacy: Three Epistles of Peter Moulin… Answered by… Lancelot Andrews. London, 1647.
  • Hooker, Richard. Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity. In The Works of that Learned and Judicious Divine Mr. Richard Hooker, vol. 2. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1793; and The Works of Mr. Richard Hooker, vol. 2. London: Cowie, 1825.
  • Lightfoot, J. B. “The Christian Ministry.” In Saint Paul’s Epistle to the Philippians. London: Macmillan, 1868.

Ecumenical Documents

  • The Porvoo Common Statement. London: Council for Christian Unity of the General Synod of the Church of England, 1993.
  • Evangelical Lutheran Church in America and The Episcopal Church. Called to Common Mission. 1999.
  • Anglican-Lutheran International Continuation Committee. The Niagara Report. 1989.
  • Anglican Church in North America, Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod and Lutheran Church–Canada. On Closer Acquaintance: Interim Report. 2016.
  • GAFCON. The Jerusalem Declaration. 2008; “A Council to Lead the Communion.” Abuja, March 5, 2026.

History

  • Bray, Gerald, ed. Documents of the English Reformation. Cambridge: James Clarke, 1994.
  • MacCulloch, Diarmaid. Thomas Cranmer: A Life. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1996.
  • Schaff, Philip. The Creeds of Christendom. 3 vols. New York: Harper, 1877. Vol. 1, §§78–80.

Footnotes

  1. The Book of Common Prayer (1662), The Order for the Administration of the Lord’s Supper, the Comfortable Words (Matthew 11:28 in the Prayer Book’s wording). ↩

  2. AC VII.2–4. ↩

  3. Canons of the Church of England, Canon A 5, “Of the doctrine of the Church of England.” ↩

  4. Diarmaid MacCulloch, Thomas Cranmer: A Life (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1996), on Cranmer’s embassy and marriage (MacCulloch makes Margarete the niece of Osiander’s wife). Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 1 (New York: Harper, 1877), §78, dates the marriage to 1532 and calls her “a niece of the Lutheran divine Osiander.” The White Horse circle rests chiefly on John Foxe. ↩

  5. Schaff, Creeds of Christendom, 1:§§78–80, where the Augsburg Confession, the Thirteen Articles, the Forty-Two and the Thirty-Nine are printed in parallel columns. On Parker’s use of the Württemberg Confession, see also Gerald Bray, ed., Documents of the English Reformation (Cambridge: James Clarke, 1994). ↩

  6. AC I.2; Article 1. In the same way, Articles 2, 9, 16 and 23 follow the Augsburg Confession’s order and wording closely, and Article 14 ends with Luke 17:10, as AC VI does. ↩

  7. Schaff, Creeds of Christendom, 1:§80, following Hardwick’s History of the Articles. Bishop Guest of Rochester is usually named as its opponent in 1563. ↩

  8. The figure of about 85 million is the one most often given; scholars have questioned how the largest provinces count. For recent figures: the Church of England reported an all-age average weekly attendance of about 701,000 in October 2024 (Statistics for Mission 2024, 2025); the Episcopal Church an in-person average Sunday attendance of 413,034 in 2024 (2024 Parochial Report, released October 24, 2025) and 1,547,779 baptized members in 2023; the Anglican Church in North America 130,111 members in 1,027 congregations in 2024 (Provincial Council, June 2025). ↩

  9. GAFCON, “The Future Has Arrived,” statement of the GAFCON chairman, Archbishop Laurent Mbanda (mid-October 2025; reported by Christianity Today, October 22, 2025, and Evangelical Focus); “A Council to Lead the Communion,” communiqué from Abuja, March 5, 2026. Archbishop Sarah Mullally, the first woman to hold the see of Canterbury, was installed on March 25, 2026. ↩

  10. The Porvoo Common Statement, agreed at Järvenpää, Finland, October 13, 1992 (London: Council for Christian Unity, 1993), §58, whose Declaration names the Anglican churches of England, Ireland, Scotland and Wales and the Lutheran churches of Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Iceland, Latvia, Lithuania, Norway and Sweden (not every church named has adopted it); Called to Common Mission: Official Text (ELCA, August 19, 1999), §1. ↩

  11. Anglican Church in North America, Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod and Lutheran Church–Canada, On Closer Acquaintance: Interim Report (2016). ↩

  12. FC Ep, Rule and Norm, 1. ↩

  13. AC IV.1–2. The next sentences in the text quote Article 12 and AC VI.1. ↩

  14. “A Sermon of the Salvation of Mankind, by only Christ our Saviour, from Sin and Death Everlasting,” in Certain Sermons or Homilies Appointed to be Read in Churches (1547), Homily 3, quoted in modern spelling. Compare AC VI.3, which gives the Ambrose sentence as “without works, by faith alone.” ↩

  15. AC XIII.1. ↩

  16. The Book of Common Prayer (1662), The Ministration of Publick Baptism of Infants. Compare AC IX. ↩

  17. Called to Common Mission, §5, quoting the Niagara Report (1989). ↩

  18. FC Ep X.7. ↩

  19. FC SD XI.5, 66, 70. ↩

  20. AC X. ↩

  21. FC SD VII.60, 64. ↩

  22. SC VI.8, 10. ↩

  23. The Book of Common Prayer (1662), the Prayer of Humble Access, the Prayer of Consecration, and A Catechism. ↩

  24. The Book of Common Prayer (1549), The Supper of the Lorde and the Holy Communion (original spelling); The Book of Common Prayer (1552), whose original spelling reads “Take and eate this, in remembraunce that Christ dyed for thee, and feede on him in thy hearte by faythe, with thankesgeving,” here given in the 1662 wording; The Book of Common Prayer (1662), the words of distribution. The 1549 and 1552 texts are quoted from the transcriptions of the Society of Archbishop Justus. ↩

  25. The Book of Common Prayer (1662), the declaration at the end of the Order for the Administration of the Lord’s Supper and the Sursum corda. The 1552 form of the declaration denied that adoration was due to “anye reall and essencial presence there beeyng of Christ’s naturall fleshe and bloude”; the 1662 form changed this to “any Corporal Presence of Christ’s natural Flesh and Blood,” a change made to leave room for those who confessed a true but not a fleshly presence. ↩

  26. Richard Hooker, Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity, V.67.6 and V.67.12, quoted from The Works of that Learned and Judicious Divine Mr. Richard Hooker, vol. 2 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1793). ↩

  27. Called to Common Mission, §5, quoting the Niagara Report; compare Porvoo Common Statement, §32(h). ↩

  28. FC Ep VII.26, 36, 37. Compare also Ep VII.32 (“That the body of Christ is so enclosed in heaven that it can in no way be at once and at one time in many or all places upon earth where His Holy Supper is celebrated”) and VII.35 (“That not the omnipotent words of Christ’s testament, but faith, produces and makes [is the cause of] the presence of the body and blood of Christ in the Holy Supper”). ↩

  29. FC Ep VII.11–14. ↩

  30. FC SD VII.93–103. ↩

  31. Preface to the Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta, p. 19. The Preface adds that it has “no doubt whatever that even in those churches which have hitherto not agreed with us in all things many godly and by no means wicked men are found.” ↩

  32. FC SD X.31; compare AC VII.2. ↩

  33. The Book of Common Prayer (1662), The Ordinal, The Preface. ↩

  34. Hooker, Laws, VII.14.11, quoted from The Works of Mr. Richard Hooker, vol. 2 (London: Cowie, 1825). ↩

  35. Lancelot Andrewes, letters to Pierre du Moulin (1618), published in English as Of Episcopacy: Three Epistles of Peter Moulin… Answered by… Lancelot Andrews (London, 1647). Paraphrased; I have not quoted the letter. ↩

  36. AC V.1; AC XIV; AC XXVIII.21. ↩

  37. Tr 61, 63, 65. ↩

  38. Ap XIV.1, 5 (Triglotta paragraphs 24 and 28). The Triglotta’s bracketed words are omitted. ↩

  39. Called to Common Mission, §§13 and 18. The ELCA cites AC VII.3 for its last sentence. ↩

  40. Porvoo Common Statement, §51. The phrase “a sign, though not a guarantee” is from Called to Common Mission, §12. ↩

  41. FC SD X.5, 13. ↩

  42. FC Ep, Rule and Norm, 1–2, 6–8. ↩

  43. The Subscription Act of 1571 (13 Eliz. c. 12); Canon 36 of the Canons of 1604; the Clerical Subscription Act of 1865; and Canon C 15 (1975), “The Declaration of Assent,” in Common Worship: Ordination Services. ↩

  44. Anglican Church in North America, Fundamental Declarations of the Province, 7, printed in The Book of Common Prayer (2019) (Huntington Beach, CA: Anglican Liturgy Press, 2019). The same book prints the Jerusalem Declaration (2008), whose fourth article upholds the Articles “as containing the true doctrine of the Church agreeing with God’s Word and as authoritative for Anglicans today.” ↩

Topics
Other Churches and TraditionsThe Lord's Supper
Scripture
1 Corinthians 10:16–17Ephesians 4:4–62 Timothy 3:16Romans 3:28Acts 2:391 Timothy 2:4Matthew 26:26–281 Corinthians 10:161 Corinthians 11:27–29Acts 3:21John 6:632 Timothy 1:6Titus 1:5Titus 1:7Acts 20:281 Corinthians 10:17Matthew 11:28Luke 17:10
Confessions
AC VIIAC IAC VIAC IVAC XIIIAC IXEp XSD XIAC XSD VIIEp VIISD XAC VAC XIVAC XXVIIIAp XIVSC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “Lutheranism and Anglicanism: Two Reformations, One Inheritance, and the Questions Still Between Us.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/lutheranism-and/anglicanism/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.