Papers · Lutheranism and …

Lutheranism and Presbyterianism

Covenant, Conscience, and the Lord's Day in the Westminster Standards and the Book of Concord

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“So I exhort the elders among you, as a fellow elder and a witness of the sufferings of Christ, as well as a partaker in the glory that is going to be revealed: shepherd the flock of God that is among you…” — 1 Peter 5:1–2


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921) and cited in the notes by the standard abbreviations, with paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions. The Westminster Confession of Faith (WCF) and the Larger and Shorter Catechisms (WLC, WSC) are quoted from the text published by the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, which is substantially the text also used by the Presbyterian Church in America. The PCA’s Book of Church Order (BCO) is quoted from its 2026 edition.


The Name and the Question

What does the word Presbyterian mean? It comes from the Greek presbyteros (“an older man, an elder”), the word the New Testament uses for the men who led the first congregations. Paul and Barnabas “appointed elders for them in every church” (Acts 14:23) and Paul left Titus in Crete to “appoint elders in every town” (Titus 1:5). A Presbyterian church is a church governed by elders. Like Episcopalians and Congregationalists, Presbyterians are named for their form of government, while their doctrinal name is Reformed. However, the name tells us something true about them. Historic Presbyterianism has always held that Christ the King gave His Church an order as well as a doctrine and sacraments, and that the order matters because the King gave it.

Lutherans and Presbyterians are near neighbors. In many American towns the two churches stand a few blocks apart and their members marry each other. Some assume the two churches are nearly alike, since both baptize infants and both come from the Reformation. Others know only that they once quarreled over the Lord’s Supper. Neither is quite right, and so I want to set out where the two churches stand together and where they part, and why each believes what it believes. Luther teaches us in the Eighth Commandment to defend our neighbor and speak well of him. I have tried to keep that commandment by letting the Westminster Standards speak for themselves before I answer them. I take up six questions:

  1. Who are the Presbyterians, and how have they and the Lutherans met?
  2. What do we confess together?
  3. How does Westminster’s covenant theology compare with the Lutheran distinction of Law and Gospel?
  4. What does it mean to call the sacraments signs and seals, and where does a doubting Christian find assurance?
  5. Who decides how God is to be worshiped, and is Sunday the Christian Sabbath?
  6. Is government by elders and presbyteries a matter of divine command or of Christian freedom?

The Lord’s Supper, the person of Christ, and election are treated at length in the companion essay, Lutheranism and the Reformed Churches, and I touch them here only in passing.


The Church of the Westminster Standards

The Presbyterian churches belong to the Reformed family that grew from the work of Zwingli in Zurich and Calvin in Geneva, and they took their particular shape in Scotland. John Knox (c. 1514–1572), a priest turned preacher who had spent years in exile in Calvin’s Geneva, came home in 1559. In 1560 the Scottish Parliament accepted the Scots Confession, which Knox and five colleagues had written. The next generation, led by Andrew Melville, taught in the Second Book of Discipline (1578) that Christ alone is King and Head of the Church and that the Church is governed by its own officers, without bishops over them.1 For more than a century the Scottish Church contended with the Stuart kings over that question, which is the question that gives Presbyterians their name: who rules the Church of Christ, and by what right?

The documents that define Presbyterian doctrine were written in England. In 1643, during the civil war, Parliament called an assembly of divines to Westminster Abbey to reform the Church of England, and the Scots sent commissioners. The Assembly produced the Confession of Faith (1646) and the Larger and Shorter Catechisms (1647).2 England returned to bishops in 1660. Therefore the Westminster Standards lived on chiefly in Scotland and in the churches Scottish and Scots-Irish settlers carried around the world. Generations of Presbyterian children have learned the Shorter Catechism, and its first answer is known far beyond Presbyterian walls: “Man’s chief end is to glorify God, and to enjoy him forever.”3

The first American presbytery met in Philadelphia in 1706. In 1729 the Synod of Philadelphia required its ministers to receive the Westminster Confession and Catechisms, and in 1788 the American church revised the sections on the civil magistrate so that the state would have no power over the Church.4 After two centuries of division and reunion, four families of American Presbyterians matter most:

  1. the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), formed in 1983 from the northern and southern mainline churches, with just over a million members. Its Book of Confessions sets the Westminster Standards beside the ancient creeds and later statements such as the Barmen Declaration and the Confession of 1967. It ordains women, and since 2014–2015 it has permitted its ministers to officiate at same-sex marriages and has defined marriage in its constitution as between two people;
  2. the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, formed in 1936 after J. Gresham Machen was suspended from the ministry of the northern church in the controversy over modernism, with about 34,000 members;
  3. the Presbyterian Church in America, formed in 1973 from the southern church and joined in 1982 by the Reformed Presbyterian Church, Evangelical Synod, now about 400,000 members and the largest conservative Presbyterian body in the country;
  4. the Evangelical Presbyterian Church (1981) and ECO: A Covenant Order of Evangelical Presbyterians (2012), formed largely by congregations that left the mainline.5

When I speak of Presbyterian teaching in this essay, I mean the Westminster Standards as the PCA and the OPC receive them. Their ministers vow that they “sincerely receive and adopt the Confession of Faith and the Catechisms of this Church, as containing the system of doctrine taught in the Holy Scriptures.”6

American Lutherans and Presbyterians began formal conversations in 1962. Those conversations led in 1997 to A Formula of Agreement, by which the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America entered full communion with the PCUSA and two other Reformed churches. The companion essay treats that agreement, and the Missouri and Wisconsin Synods, like the PCA and the OPC, are not party to it. The reason a confessional Lutheran cannot join it is the Supper. Lutherans confess that Christ gives His body and blood into the mouth of every communicant for the forgiveness of sins, because He said so, and the Formula of Concord rejects the Reformed teaching for that reason.7 The Augsburg Confession says that “to the true unity of the Church it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments,” and the Formula of Concord explains what that agreement means; churches are one when they are “agreed with one another in the doctrine and all its articles, also in the right use of the holy Sacraments.”8 Although I hold to every condemnation in the Book of Concord, I can call Presbyterians brothers in Christ without contradicting myself. The Preface to the Book of Concord says that “it is in no way our design and purpose to condemn those men who err from a certain simplicity of mind, but are not blasphemers against the truth of the heavenly doctrine, much less, indeed, entire churches,” but “only the fanatical opinions and their obstinate and blasphemous teachers.”9 In other words, a condemnation is aimed at a doctrine. A vote of the churches cannot withdraw it; it falls only when the doctrine is no longer taught. A PCA elder would agree from the other side, since he does not regard the Lutheran doctrine of the Supper as a matter of emphasis either.


Common Ground

A Lutheran reading the Westminster Confession will find much he can confess with gladness. It confesses the Holy Trinity in the words of the ancient Church: “In the unity of the Godhead there be three persons, of one substance, power, and eternity: God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Ghost.”10 It confesses Christ true God and true man in the faith of Chalcedon (the council of 451 that confessed Christ as one person in two natures). Where we differ about His person, we differ within that faith and not outside it. However, the difference, over how truly the two natures share their properties in the one person, lies at the root of our difference over the Supper, and the companion essay treats it at length. In addition, Westminster holds that Scripture is the only rule of faith. “The supreme judge by which all controversies of religion are to be determined,” it says, “can be no other but the Holy Spirit speaking in the Scripture.”11

Westminster also teaches the bondage of the will as firmly as Luther did. Fallen man “hath wholly lost all ability of will to any spiritual good accompanying salvation,” and in his conversion he is “altogether passive therein, until, being quickened and renewed by the Holy Spirit, he is thereby enabled to answer this call.”12 The Augsburg Confession and the Formula of Concord say the same.13 The two churches also agree in baptizing infants, though on different grounds, which we will come to.

The agreement on justification is closest of all. The Westminster Confession says:

“Those whom God effectually calleth, he also freely justifieth: not by infusing righteousness into them, but by pardoning their sins, and by accounting and accepting their persons as righteous; not for anything wrought in them, or done by them, but for Christ’s sake alone; nor by imputing faith itself, the act of believing, or any other evangelical obedience to them, as their righteousness; but by imputing the obedience and satisfaction of Christ unto them, they receiving and resting on him and his righteousness, by faith.”14

In other words, God declares the sinner righteous because Christ’s obedience and death are counted to him, and faith receives that gift without being itself the righteousness. The Shorter Catechism gives the whole article in one sentence: “Justification is an act of God’s free grace, wherein he pardoneth all our sins, and accepteth us as righteous in his sight, only for the righteousness of Christ imputed to us, and received by faith alone.”15 Westminster calls faith “the alone instrument of justification,” and the Formula of Concord calls faith “the means and instrument whereby we lay hold of Christ.”16 The Augsburg Confession teaches this article in its fourth article, and on it Lutherans and Presbyterians stood together against Rome and still do.17 Paul’s sentence is ours together: “For we hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law” (Romans 3:28).

The two churches are also teaching and preaching churches. The Shorter Catechism says that “the Spirit of God maketh the reading, but especially the preaching, of the word, an effectual means of convincing and converting sinners, and of building them up in holiness and comfort, through faith, unto salvation.”18 A Lutheran who hears a careful Presbyterian sermon working through a book of the Bible is hearing something our fathers would have recognized.


Westminster’s Covenant, and Law and Gospel

No idea shapes Presbyterian theology more than the covenant. The Confession introduces it this way:

“The distance between God and the creature is so great, that although reasonable creatures do owe obedience unto him as their Creator, yet they could never have any fruition of him as their blessedness and reward, but by some voluntary condescension on God’s part, which he hath been pleased to express by way of covenant.”19

In other words, God is so far above us that we could never enjoy Him at all unless He stooped to bind Himself to us by a promise. That covenant has two forms. “The first covenant made with man was a covenant of works, wherein life was promised to Adam; and in him to his posterity, upon condition of perfect and personal obedience.” After the fall God made “a second, commonly called the covenant of grace; wherein he freely offereth unto sinners life and salvation by Jesus Christ.”20 The covenant of grace is one covenant from Eden to the end of the world, administered before Christ “by promises, prophecies, sacrifices, circumcision, the paschal lamb, and other types,” and since Christ by preaching and the sacraments.21

For a Presbyterian this framework does three things. It shows the unity of the Bible, so that Abraham was justified exactly as we are. It guards the Gospel, because Christ the second Adam kept the law that Adam broke, and His obedience as well as His death is counted to us. It also grounds infant Baptism, since God’s covenant has always embraced believers with their children, who receive its sign now as Israel’s sons received circumcision.22 The texts are drawn from the whole of Scripture. God gave Adam a command with a promise and a threat: “of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall surely die” (Genesis 2:17). Hosea calls Adam’s sin covenant-breaking: “But like Adam they transgressed the covenant” (Hosea 6:7). Paul sets Adam and Christ side by side: “For as by the one man’s disobedience the many were made sinners, so by the one man’s obedience the many will be made righteous” (Romans 5:19). The promise of grace begins in Eden, where God tells the serpent that the woman’s offspring “shall bruise your head” (Genesis 3:15), and runs through His word to Abraham, “to be God to you and to your offspring after you” (Genesis 17:7).

Presbyterians do not think of the covenant as a rival to the distinction of Law and Gospel, but instead as that distinction set out as the history of God’s dealings with mankind. The covenant of works is the Law and the covenant of grace is the Gospel. The Larger Catechism says that believers “be delivered from the moral law as a covenant of works, so as thereby they are neither justified nor condemned.”23 The law still convicts everyone, driving sinners “to Christ,” and the Confession says that the law’s uses for believers “do sweetly comply” with the grace of the gospel.24 A Presbyterian preacher, too, preaches Law and Gospel every Sunday.

The Lutheran Confessions begin from the two words themselves. Melanchthon writes in the Apology, “All Scripture ought to be distributed into these two principal topics, the Law and the promises.” The Formula of Concord calls the distinction “a special brilliant light, which serves to the end that God’s Word may be rightly divided,” and warns that it must be guarded “in order that these two doctrines may not be mingled with one another, or a law be made out of the Gospel, whereby the merit of Christ is obscured and troubled consciences are robbed of their comfort.”25 Paul writes, “For all who rely on works of the law are under a curse” (Galatians 3:10), and he calls himself a minister “of a new covenant, not of the letter but of the Spirit. For the letter kills, but the Spirit gives life” (2 Corinthians 3:6). The Law commands and accuses, for “the Law always accuses and terrifies consciences,” and the Gospel gives freely, for Christ’s sake, what the Law demands.26 The Lutheran preacher therefore asks of every text which word is speaking and what it is doing to the sinner in the pew. The Presbyterian preacher more often begins from the text’s place in the history of redemption. Both preach Christ, but each habit shapes the sermon differently.

Although much is shared, I see two points where the difference goes deeper than habit. The first is the grammar of conditions. The Larger Catechism says that in the covenant of grace God “freely provideth and offereth to sinners a mediator, and life and salvation by him; and requiring faith as the condition to interest them in him, promiseth and giveth his Holy Spirit to all his elect, to work in them that faith, with all other saving graces.”27 The divines made the condition God’s own gift, and they took care to say that faith justifies “only as it is an instrument by which he receiveth and applieth Christ and his righteousness.”28 Even with those safeguards a Lutheran is uneasy, because a troubled conscience hears the word condition as Law and begins to ask whether its faith is good enough. The second is the place of the Law in the Christian life. Lutherans speak of three uses of the Law (to restrain the wicked, to show us our sin, and to guide the Christian), and the Formula of Concord teaches that the Law is to be urged on believers too.29 However, Calvin called the third use the law’s “principal use,” and Westminster sets the law before believers as “the rule of their obedience.”30 The Lutheran insists that whenever the Law speaks to the old Adam it accuses, and so the preacher may never leave a Christian under the Law without bringing him back to the Gospel.

These are not the chief differences between our churches and they do not touch the article of justification as Westminster states it. However, the Formula of Concord treats the distinction of Law and Gospel as doctrine rather than a habit of preaching, and it is one of the articles on which churches must agree before they can be one.31 It is also the reason a Lutheran sermon and a Presbyterian sermon on one text often sound different.


Signs, Seals, and the Promise

The Westminster Standards do not regard the sacraments as bare symbols, but instead as means of grace. The Shorter Catechism says, “The outward and ordinary means whereby Christ communicateth to us the benefits of redemption, are his ordinances, especially the word, sacraments, and prayer,” and “the sacraments become effectual means of salvation, not from any virtue in them, or in him that doth administer them; but only by the blessing of Christ, and the working of his Spirit in them that by faith receive them.”32 The Confession calls sacraments “holy signs and seals of the covenant of grace,” and it teaches a “sacramental union, between the sign and the thing signified: whence it comes to pass, that the names and effects of the one are attributed to the other.”33 For that reason a Presbyterian can read “Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you” (1 Peter 3:21) without embarrassment. The words sign and seal come from Paul’s account of Abraham: “He received the sign of circumcision as a seal of the righteousness that he had by faith while he was still uncircumcised” (Romans 4:11).

Westminster’s reserve lies elsewhere. “The efficacy of baptism is not tied to that moment of time wherein it is administered; yet, notwithstanding, by the right use of this ordinance, the grace promised is not only offered, but really exhibited, and conferred, by the Holy Ghost, to such (whether of age or infants) as that grace belongeth unto, according to the counsel of God’s own will, in his appointed time.”34 In other words, Baptism truly gives what it promises, but the Spirit gives it to the elect, and at the time He chooses.

Lutherans can use the language of signs and seals; the Apology calls the Sacraments “the signs [and seals] of the promises.”35 The difference is about the person to whom the promise is spoken. The Small Catechism says that Baptism “works forgiveness of sins, delivers from death and the devil, and gives eternal salvation to all who believe this, as the words and promises of God declare.”36 The Lutheran holds that the promise spoken over the water belongs to the one baptized, because God spoke it to him by name. The Presbyterian holds that the grace is conferred on those to whom it belongs by God’s counsel, and received by faith. That question leads straight to election and to the Supper, where we disagree whether the unworthy also receive Christ’s body and blood with the mouth, as the Formula of Concord confesses, or believers only, by faith.37 The companion essay treats both. What concerns us here is what this difference means for a Christian who doubts.


The Doubting Christian

Chapter 18 of the Westminster Confession is one of the most pastoral chapters in any Reformation confession. It teaches that true believers “may, in this life, be certainly assured that they are in the state of grace,” and it describes that assurance:

“This certainty is not a bare conjectural and probable persuasion grounded upon a fallible hope; but an infallible assurance of faith founded upon the divine truth of the promises of salvation, the inward evidence of those graces unto which these promises are made, the testimony of the Spirit of adoption witnessing with our spirits that we are the children of God.”38

Westminster grounds assurance first and chiefly on the promises of God, and confirms it by the evidence of grace in the believer’s life and by the Spirit’s witness. It adds that assurance does not belong to the essence of faith, so that a true believer “may wait long, and conflict with many difficulties before he be partaker of it.” Yet he is not left to himself, because “being enabled by the Spirit to know the things which are freely given him of God, he may, without extraordinary revelation, in the right use of ordinary means, attain thereunto.”39 Those ordinary means are the Word, the sacraments, and prayer. The Scriptures behind the chapter are Peter’s “be all the more diligent to confirm your calling and election” (2 Peter 1:10), Paul’s “The Spirit himself bears witness with our spirit that we are children of God” (Romans 8:16), and John’s marks of a living faith: “And by this we know that we have come to know him, if we keep his commandments” (1 John 2:3), and “We know that we have passed out of death into life, because we love the brothers” (1 John 3:14). The divines knew that “hypocrites and other unregenerate men may vainly deceive themselves with false hopes,”40 and they meant to warn the careless without crushing the weak.

The Larger Catechism goes further in the same direction. It urges Christians to “improve” their Baptism (in the old sense of the word, to put it to good use) all their lives, “especially in the time of temptation,” by “growing up to assurance of pardon of sin, and of all other blessings sealed to us in that sacrament.”41 It tells the one who doubts whether he is in Christ that he “may and ought to come to the Lord’s supper, that he may be further strengthened,” because “this sacrament is appointed, for the relief even of weak and doubting Christians.”42 That is very near the Lutheran answer.

The Lutheran answer locates assurance outside the believer, in the promise God speaks and gives in Word and Sacrament. Paul writes that righteousness “depends on faith, in order that the promise may rest on grace and be guaranteed to all his offspring” (Romans 4:16). Jesus says, “whoever comes to me I will never cast out” (John 6:37). Luther taught the troubled Christian to answer his conscience with the words “I am baptized,” and the Formula of Concord tells the one who is anxious about election that he “should not trouble or harass himself with thoughts concerning the secret counsel of God,” but should “hear Christ,” who “is the Book of Life and of God’s eternal election.”43

A Lutheran fears that a believer who is told to look for the evidence of grace in himself may, in a dark hour, look there first and find little. Westminster’s own answer is to send him to the promise and to the Supper, and the Lutheran wants that answer to be the only one. Self-examination has its place (1 Corinthians 11:28), but its work is not to supply the evidence that entitles us to come, but instead to drive us to Christ. Lutherans fail here too. Many of our people have never once said “I am baptized” in a dark hour and some of our preachers send them searching their hearts as surely as any Puritan did.

Lutherans do not teach, as Westminster does, that a true believer can never finally fall away.44 However, we are not left without a doctrine of preservation. The Formula of Concord confesses that God “will also strengthen, increase, and support to the end the good work which He has begun in them,” and it says that God, knowing that our salvation “through the weakness and wickedness of our flesh … could easily be lost from our hands,” “placed it for preservation in the almighty hand of our Savior Jesus Christ, from which no one can pluck us.”45 Jesus says of His sheep, “no one will snatch them out of my hand” (John 10:28). We do not rest on our perseverance, nor are we left to keep ourselves; we rest on the hand that holds us, and that hand meets us in the Word and the Sacraments.


Worship by Command

The Westminster Confession states what is called the regulative principle of worship:

“But the acceptable way of worshiping the true God is instituted by himself, and so limited by his own revealed will, that he may not be worshiped according to the imaginations and devices of men, or the suggestions of Satan, under any visible representation, or any other way not prescribed in the Holy Scripture.”46

In other words, God alone decides how He is to be worshiped, and what He has not commanded is not to be brought into His worship. Presbyterians find the principle in the Second Commandment, which the Shorter Catechism says “forbiddeth the worshiping of God by images, or any other way not appointed in his word.”47 God says, “You shall not make for yourself a carved image … You shall not bow down to them or serve them, for I the LORD your God am a jealous God” (Exodus 20:4–5). Moses told Israel, “Everything that I command you, you shall be careful to do. You shall not add to it or take from it” (Deuteronomy 12:32), and Nadab and Abihu died because they “offered unauthorized fire before the LORD, which he had not commanded them” (Leviticus 10:1). Paul warns against rules that “have indeed an appearance of wisdom in promoting self-made religion” (Colossians 2:23), the Greek ethelothrēskia (“worship of one’s own devising”). Calvin had taught the principle before the Puritans, in his plea to the Emperor on the necessity of reforming the Church (1544), and the English vestments controversy only sharpened it.48 It is also a principle of liberty. “God alone is Lord of the conscience,” the Confession says, “and hath left it free from the doctrines and commandments of men, which are, in anything, contrary to his Word; or beside it, if matters of faith, or worship.”49

Presbyterians distinguish the elements of worship, which must be commanded (reading and preaching the Word, prayer, singing praise, the sacraments), from “some circumstances concerning the worship of God, and government of the church, common to human actions and societies, which are to be ordered by the light of nature, and Christian prudence.”50 Most PCA and OPC congregations therefore sing hymns as well as psalms, reading Paul’s “psalms and hymns and spiritual songs” (Colossians 3:16) as a command to sing praise. A minority sing only the Psalms.

The Lutheran Confessions answer the regulative principle with the doctrine of Christian liberty and of things neither commanded nor forbidden. The Augsburg Confession says that church usages “ought to be observed which may be observed without sin, and which are profitable unto tranquillity and good order in the Church, as particular holy days, festivals, and the like,” but that “consciences are not to be burdened, as though such observance was necessary to salvation.”51 The Formula of Concord confesses that rites “which are neither commanded nor forbidden in God’s Word, but have been instituted alone for the sake of propriety and good order, are in and of themselves no divine worship, nor even a part of it,” and that every congregation may change them as is “most useful and edifying.”52 These are called adiaphora (“things indifferent”), which does not mean that anything goes. When a ceremony is pressed on the Church as a confession of error, “it is no longer a question concerning adiaphora, but concerning the truth of the Gospel.”53

The question between us is what to do with everything Scripture neither commands nor forbids. The regulative principle requires each practice to find a warrant or be put away, and the Westminster Assembly followed it to its end. The Directory for Public Worship says, “There is no day commanded in scripture to be kept holy under the gospel but the Lord’s day, which is the Christian Sabbath. Festival days, vulgarly called Holy-days, having no warrant in the word of God, are not to be continued.”54 For generations Scottish Presbyterians kept neither Christmas nor Easter, and the sign of the cross, kneeling at the Supper, and a sung liturgy went with them. A Lutheran asks whether the principle has not here created the bondage it was meant to prevent. To make the absence of a command into a prohibition binds the conscience where Scripture has not. The Augsburg Confession says that “it is necessary that the doctrine of Christian liberty be preserved in the churches,” and that “the chief article of the Gospel be preserved, to wit, that we obtain grace freely by faith in Christ, and not for certain observances or acts of worship devised by men.”55 Paul writes, “Therefore let no one pass judgment on you in questions of food and drink, or with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath. These are a shadow of the things to come, but the substance belongs to Christ” (Colossians 2:16–17). Both churches appeal to Colossians 2. The Presbyterian hears its warning against self-made worship and the Lutheran hears its warning against judging consciences over days. Many Presbyterians today observe the Christian year as a circumstance or form that the principle allows, while others in their own churches say it contradicts Westminster, and that debate is theirs to settle. The difference of principle remains, and it concerns the doctrine of Christian liberty, not a matter of taste.


The Lord’s Day

The Sabbath commandment is the Fourth in Reformed numbering and the Third in ours. The Westminster Confession calls it “a positive, moral, and perpetual commandment binding all men in all ages,” by which God “hath particularly appointed one day in seven,” which since the resurrection is “the first day of the week, which, in Scripture, is called the Lord’s day, and is to be continued to the end of the world, as the Christian Sabbath.” The day is kept holy when Christians rest “all the day, from their own works, words, and thoughts about their worldly employments and recreations,” and spend it in worship “and in the duties of necessity and mercy.”56

The reasons begin before Moses. “So God blessed the seventh day and made it holy, because on it God rested from all his work that he had done in creation” (Genesis 2:3). The commandment appeals to creation, not to Israel’s history alone: “For in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, the sea, and all that is in them, and rested on the seventh day” (Exodus 20:11). Since the other nine commandments are moral and abiding, the Presbyterian reasons, the Sabbath commandment cannot be the one ceremonial law in the Decalogue. The rest from recreation rests on Isaiah: “If you turn back your foot from the Sabbath, from doing your pleasure on my holy day, and call the Sabbath a delight and the holy day of the LORD honorable; if you honor it, not going your own ways, or seeking your own pleasure, or talking idly” (Isaiah 58:13). Hebrews says that “there remains a Sabbath rest for the people of God” (Hebrews 4:9) and the apostolic Church gathered “on the first day of the week” (Acts 20:7). Presbyterians read Colossians 2:16 and Romans 14:5 as speaking of the ceremonial days of the Mosaic law, which Christ fulfilled, and not of the weekly rest God appointed at creation.

The Augsburg Confession answers directly. “For those who judge that by the authority of the Church the observance of the Lord’s Day instead of the Sabbath-day was ordained as a thing necessary, do greatly err. Scripture has abrogated the Sabbath-day; for it teaches that, since the Gospel has been revealed, all the ceremonies of Moses can be omitted.” It adds that the Church chose the Lord’s Day so that “men might have an example of Christian liberty, and might know that the keeping neither of the Sabbath nor of any other day is necessary.”57 Luther writes in the Large Catechism that the commandment “according to its gross sense, does not concern us Christians,” but he does not empty it. The day is kept so that “we come together to hear and treat of God’s Word, and then to praise God, to sing and pray,” and since Sunday has been appointed for this from of old, “we also should continue the same.”58 The Small Catechism turns the whole commandment toward the Word, that we “may not despise preaching and His Word, but hold it sacred, and gladly hear and learn it.”59 The Lutheran answer to the Presbyterian reading is that Paul names “a Sabbath” without distinction among the shadows whose substance is Christ, and that he leaves the esteeming of days to each conscience: “One person esteems one day as better than another, while another esteems all days alike. Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind” (Romans 14:5).

Both churches give the Lord’s Day to the Word and the Sacraments, and both would say that a Christian who despises public worship sins against God’s commandment. The question is whether the first day of the week, and rest from recreation on it, bind the conscience by divine command. Westminster says yes. The Augsburg Confession says no. The Augsburg Confession was answering the medieval canonists a century before Westminster, and Presbyterians differ among themselves on how strictly to apply the clause on recreations; the PCA allows a presbytery to grant a minister an exception there.60 Even so, the Lutheran judgment stands. Sunday is the Church’s free and good arrangement for hearing God’s Word. Therefore to make it a perpetual moral command puts a law where the Gospel has given freedom.


Elders and Presbyteries

On one point of church order the two traditions stand together against much of Christendom. The Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope says that the power to preach, to forgive sins, and to administer the Sacraments “by divine right is common to all who preside over churches, whether they are called pastors, or elders, or bishops,” and that “it is by human authority that the grades of bishop and elder or pastor are distinct.”61 The PCA’s Book of Church Order says of the titles bishop, pastor, presbyter, and elder that “these titles do not indicate different grades of office, but all describe one and the same office.”62 Paul “called the elders of the church” at Ephesus and told them, “the Holy Spirit has made you overseers” (Acts 20:17, 28). In the New Testament the elder and the overseer (episkopos, “overseer, bishop”) are the same man.

Presbyterians go further and believe that Christ has given His Church a particular form of government. The Book of Church Order opens with Christ the King, who “has given to His Church officers, oracles and ordinances; and especially has He ordained therein His system of doctrine, government, discipline and worship, all of which are either expressly set down in Scripture, or by good and necessary inference may be deduced therefrom.”63 The Westminster divines held this government to be jure divino (“by divine right”). Each congregation is governed by its session of elders, congregations are joined in a presbytery, and presbyteries in a general assembly, as the Confession’s chapter on synods and councils provides.64 The texts are the plural elders of every church (Acts 14:23; Titus 1:5), the council at Jerusalem, where “the apostles and the elders were gathered together to consider this matter” (Acts 15:6), and Paul’s word, “Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in preaching and teaching” (1 Timothy 5:17). The ruling elder is an ordained officer who shares with the minister the government and spiritual care of the flock. Presbyterians differ among themselves on how to describe the offices. The PCA speaks of two orders within the one office of elder, teaching elders and ruling elders, while the OPC treats the minister of the Word as holding an office distinct from the ruling elder.65 The meaning of 1 Timothy 5:17 has been debated among Presbyterians since the Assembly.

The Lutheran Confessions teach that the ministry of Word and Sacraments is God’s institution and that “no one should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments unless he be regularly called.”66 By divine right the pastor’s jurisdiction is to forgive sins, to judge doctrine, and to exclude the openly wicked from communion, “and this without human force, simply by the Word.”67 Beyond that the Confessions treat church government as a matter of human right and Christian freedom. Whatever further powers bishops held, they held “by human right.”68 The Church of Sweden kept bishops, the German churches had consistories and superintendents, and American Lutherans organized synods.

A Lutheran agrees that the Church needs order and that ministers should be examined and rightly called. He would ask whether 1 Timothy 5:17 establishes an order of ordained elders who govern without preaching, or describes elders of one office who differ in their labors, and whether the council of Acts 15, at which the apostles themselves sat, sets the pattern for a permanent system of graded courts. The New Testament gives us the office and its qualifications and the Lutheran does not find a constitution there. If we were agreed in doctrine and all its articles, as the Formula requires, Lutherans would not make the form of church government a barrier to fellowship, because our Confessions hold it to be a matter of human right. Many Presbyterians would answer that church government belongs to the well-being of the Church rather than to its being. The Confession speaks of particular churches as “more or less pure,”69 and Presbyterians have not denied that Lutheran churches are churches of Christ, though they still hold that their order is the one Scripture teaches. I understand why and I would only ask them to weigh whether the New Testament gives an office or a constitution.


What Each Might Learn

Lutherans can learn from Presbyterians the seriousness of the catechism. Luther wrote the Small Catechism to be learned by heart and taught at home by the head of the household. A Presbyterian family that works through the Shorter Catechism at the supper table is doing what Luther asked our fathers to do with his, and in too many of our homes the catechism is closed after confirmation.

We can also learn from the ruling elder. Whatever we conclude about the order of the office, Presbyterians have taken seriously that the oversight of souls is too large for one pastor and that mature men can be trained and charged to visit, to pray with, and to admonish the flock. We could learn from churches where the elders know every family by name and go after the straying.

In addition, there is the keeping of the Lord’s Day. I do not believe the commandment binds us to the first day of the week. However, Luther said the day is sanctified when “we occupy ourselves with God’s Word, and exercise ourselves therein.”70 A Presbyterian household that gives the whole of Sunday to worship, rest, and works of mercy often keeps the Third Commandment as Luther explains it better than a Lutheran household that gives the Lord one hour.

Lastly, the PCA requires every candidate for the ministry to state each of his differences with the Standards and its presbyteries to judge each one. Lutherans who subscribe quia (because the Confessions agree with Scripture) should be glad to see another church hold its confession that seriously.

What can a Lutheran bring in return? Lutherans know the struggle over assurance as well as anyone. Luther called it Anfechtung (“assault, trial”). What we can offer is the habit of answering it first and always with Baptism, as the Larger Catechism itself urges: God spoke His promise to you by name in the water, and you may rest on it before you have examined anything in yourself. We can also encourage our Presbyterian brothers in a distinction their own divines prized, by asking of every text which word it speaks and never leaving the hearer under the Law’s accusation without the Gospel’s absolution. Presbyterians are debating among themselves whether the Christian year fits their principle; Lutherans can show what it looks like when the church year is received freely and used to teach the Gospel.

Some who read this have a son, a daughter, or a friend in a Presbyterian church. Be glad of what they hear there: Scripture honored, justification by grace through faith preached, infants baptized, and the catechism taught. A Presbyterian church will not rebaptize a Lutheran, and a Lutheran church does not rebaptize a Presbyterian, because both receive Baptism in the name of the Triune God. Hold to what Christ gives in His Supper, and when a family wedding or a Christmas visit brings you to a Presbyterian service, you may explain gently that Lutherans commune where they share one confession of what is given at the altar. That is a confession of faith and is not meant as a judgment on anyone’s love for Christ.


Conclusion

When I read the Westminster Confession I find myself among men who loved the Scriptures, feared God, and wanted nothing in His Church that He had not given it. I find the justification by grace alone through faith alone that our fathers confessed at Augsburg, stated in some of the finest sentences in English. I also find teaching on the sacraments, on worship, and on the Lord’s Day that I cannot share, and a doctrine of the Supper that my Confession rejects. However, I am certain that the Presbyterian elder down the street and I confess the same Christ, crucified for sinners and raised for our justification, and that we will both stand before Him clothed in His righteousness.

Each Sunday he and I will go to church a few blocks apart. He will call it the Sabbath and I will call it the Lord’s Day, and we will both hear the Word of God read and preached. The Psalm appointed “for the Sabbath” begins, “It is good to give thanks to the LORD, to sing praises to your name, O Most High” (Psalm 92:1). His catechism says that our chief end is “to glorify God, and to enjoy him forever.” A Lutheran would add that we glorify Him first by receiving His gifts. Lord Jesus Christ, Shepherd and Overseer of our souls, gather Your people around Your Word, forgive us our sins against one another, and lead us into all truth, until we glorify and enjoy You together forever. Amen.


Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture and the Lutheran Confessions

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton: Crossway, 2001; text edition 2025.
  • Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
  • Kolb, Robert, and Timothy J. Wengert, eds. The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000.

Presbyterian standards and documents

  • The Westminster Confession of Faith (1646), with the Larger and Shorter Catechisms (1647), American text. Orthodox Presbyterian Church, opc.org.
  • The Directory for the Publick Worship of God (1645).
  • The Book of Church Order of the Presbyterian Church in America. 2026 edition. Office of the Stated Clerk of the General Assembly, pcaac.org.
  • Calvin, John. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Translated by Henry Beveridge. Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society, 1845.
  • Calvin, John. The Necessity of Reforming the Church. 1544.
  • Schaff, Philip. The Creeds of Christendom. 3 vols. New York: Harper, 1877.

Church statistics

  • Evangelical Presbyterian Church. “2025 Committee Report – Stated Clerk.” epconnect.org.
  • Jones, Andy. “New Statistics Reveal PCA’s Growth in 2024.” byFaith, April 29, 2025.
  • Orthodox Presbyterian Church. “92nd General Assembly Report (2026).” opc.org.
  • Presbyterian News Service. “PC(USA) Still Home to More Than 1 Million Members.” June 29, 2026. pcusa.org.

Footnotes

  1. The Scots Confession (Confessio Scoticana, 1560), text in Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 3; The Second Book of Discipline (1578), chapters 1–2. ↩

  2. The Assembly also produced a Directory for Public Worship and a Form of Presbyterial Church Government. The Confession was presented to Parliament in December 1646 and the Catechisms in 1647. See Schaff, Creeds of Christendom, vol. 1. ↩

  3. WSC 1. ↩

  4. The Adopting Act of the Synod of Philadelphia (1729) allowed a minister to declare scruples about articles the presbytery judged not essential. The American revision of 1788 concerns WCF 20.4, 23.3, and 31.2, and WLC 109, from which it removed “tolerating a false religion.” The text quoted in this essay is that American text. ↩

  5. PCUSA: 1,019,003 members and 8,304 congregations in 2025 (Presbyterian News Service, “PC(USA) still home to more than 1 million members,” June 29, 2026, pcusa.org). The 2014 General Assembly’s authoritative interpretation permitted ministers to officiate at same-sex marriages where civil law allowed; Amendment 14-F, ratified in 2015, changed the constitution’s definition of marriage. OPC: “At the end of 2025, total OPC membership stood at 33,941” (OPC, “92nd General Assembly Report (2026),” opc.org). PCA: 400,751 members in 2024, with 992 of 1,667 congregations reporting (Andy Jones, “New Statistics Reveal PCA’s Growth in 2024,” byFaith, April 29, 2025). EPC: 125,754 members in 626 congregations in 2024 (EPC, “2025 Committee Report – Stated Clerk,” June 2025, epconnect.org). ECO describes itself as more than 380 congregations; I found no dated membership total. ↩

  6. BCO 21-5, question 2; ruling elders and deacons take the same vow (BCO 24-6). The PCUSA also includes the Standards in its constitution, but its ministers vow to receive the essential tenets of the Reformed faith as all its confessions express them. ↩

  7. FC Ep VII; FC SD VII. On the dialogues, Marburg Revisited (1966), and A Formula of Agreement (1997), see Lutheranism and the Reformed Churches. ↩

  8. AC VII.2; FC SD X.31; compare FC Ep X.7, “in doctrine and all its articles.” ↩

  9. Preface to the Book of Concord (Triglotta wording; the paragraph number varies by edition). ↩

  10. WCF 2.3. ↩

  11. WCF 1.10. Compare FC Ep, Rule and Norm 1. ↩

  12. WCF 9.3; 10.2. ↩

  13. AC XVIII; FC Ep II. ↩

  14. WCF 11.1. ↩

  15. WSC 33. ↩

  16. WCF 11.2; FC Ep III.5. ↩

  17. AC IV.1–3. ↩

  18. WSC 89. Compare AC V.2. ↩

  19. WCF 7.1. ↩

  20. WCF 7.2–3. ↩

  21. WCF 7.5–6. ↩

  22. WCF 11.6; 11.1; 28.4. ↩

  23. WLC 97. ↩

  24. WLC 96; WCF 19.6–7. ↩

  25. Ap IV.5; FC SD V.1. ↩

  26. Ap IV.38. ↩

  27. WLC 32. ↩

  28. WLC 73. ↩

  29. FC Ep VI.3. ↩

  30. John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion II.7.12, trans. Henry Beveridge; WLC 97; WCF 19.6. ↩

  31. FC SD V.1; FC SD X.31. ↩

  32. WSC 88; 91. ↩

  33. WCF 27.1–2. ↩

  34. WCF 28.6. ↩

  35. Ap XIII.20. Compare AC XIII.1. ↩

  36. SC IV, Second Part. ↩

  37. FC Ep VII.16; FC SD VII.60; WCF 29.7–8. ↩

  38. WCF 18.1–2. ↩

  39. WCF 18.3; WSC 88. ↩

  40. WCF 18.1. ↩

  41. WLC 167. ↩

  42. WLC 172. ↩

  43. LC IV.44; FC SD XI.70. ↩

  44. WCF 17.1. See also Baptism and Falling Away. ↩

  45. FC SD XI.21; XI.45. ↩

  46. WCF 21.1. ↩

  47. WSC 51. ↩

  48. John Calvin, The Necessity of Reforming the Church (1544). ↩

  49. WCF 20.2. ↩

  50. WCF 1.6. ↩

  51. AC XV.1–2. ↩

  52. FC Ep X.3–4. ↩

  53. FC Ep X.6. On the Lutheran side see also Freedom and Form in Worship. ↩

  54. The Directory for the Publick Worship of God (1645), “An Appendix, Touching Days and Places for Publick Worship.” ↩

  55. AC XXVIII.51–52. ↩

  56. WCF 21.7–8; compare WSC 58–61. ↩

  57. AC XXVIII.58–60. ↩

  58. LC I.82, 84–85. ↩

  59. SC I, Third Commandment. ↩

  60. BCO 21-4.f permits an exception where a stated difference is “neither hostile to the system nor strikes at the vitals of religion.” The PCA publishes no count of the differences most often stated; that the recreations clause of WCF 21.8 is among them is the common report of its presbyteries. ↩

  61. Tr 61, 63. ↩

  62. BCO 8-1. ↩

  63. BCO, Preface I. ↩

  64. WCF 30.1; 31.1–2. ↩

  65. BCO 7-2. On the OPC’s view, see its Form of Government. ↩

  66. AC V; AC XIV. ↩

  67. AC XXVIII.21–22. ↩

  68. AC XXVIII.29; Tr 65, 67. ↩

  69. WCF 25.4. ↩

  70. LC I.88. ↩

Scripture
1 Peter 5:1–2Acts 14:23Titus 1:5Romans 3:28Genesis 2:17Hosea 6:7Romans 5:19Genesis 3:15Genesis 17:7Galatians 3:102 Corinthians 3:61 Peter 3:21Romans 4:112 Peter 1:10Romans 8:161 John 2:31 John 3:14Romans 4:16John 6:371 Corinthians 11:28John 10:28Exodus 20:4–5Deuteronomy 12:32Leviticus 10:1Colossians 2:23Colossians 3:16Colossians 2:16–17Genesis 2:3Exodus 20:11Isaiah 58:13Hebrews 4:9Acts 20:7Colossians 2:16Romans 14:5Acts 20:17Acts 15:61 Timothy 5:17Psalm 92:1
Confessions
Ep VIISD VIIAC VIISD XEp XAC XVIIIEp IIEp IIIAC IVAC VAp IVSD VEp VIAp XIIIAC XIIILC IVSD XIAC XVAC XXVIIILC IAC XIVSCLC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “Lutheranism and Presbyterianism: Covenant, Conscience, and the Lord's Day in the Westminster Standards and the Book of Concord.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/lutheranism-and/presbyterianism/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.