Papers · Lutheranism and …

Lutheranism and Methodism

A Heart Strangely Warmed

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“Therefore, my beloved, as you have always obeyed, so now, not only as in my presence but much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling, for it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure.” — Philippians 2:12–13


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921), with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions, and cited in the notes by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, SC, LC, FC Ep, FC SD). The Methodist Articles of Religion, the General Rules, and the Confession of Faith of the Evangelical United Brethren are quoted from The Book of Discipline of The United Methodist Church as published on the church’s website. John Wesley’s sermons are quoted from the 1872 edition of his Sermons on Several Occasions, and his Journal from Percy Livingstone Parker’s abridgment, except where a note names the fuller text. Older spellings are left as they stand.


Aldersgate Street

On the evening of Wednesday, May 24, 1738, a discouraged clergyman of the Church of England went to a small religious society that met in Aldersgate Street in London. He was thirty-four years old, a fellow of an Oxford college, home that winter from a mission to the colony of Georgia that had gone badly. He wrote that night in his Journal:

“In the evening I went very unwillingly to a society in Aldersgate Street, where one was reading Luther’s preface to the Epistle to the Romans. About a quarter before nine, while he was describing the change which God works in the heart through faith in Christ, I felt my heart strangely warmed. I felt I did trust in Christ, Christ alone, for salvation; and an assurance was given me that He had taken away my sins, even mine, and saved me from the law of sin and death.”1

The man was John Wesley and the book being read aloud was Luther’s. We do not know which page the reader had reached. However, words from that same preface are printed in our Book of Concord, where the Formula of Concord quotes them to show how faith and good works belong together: “Thus faith is a divine work in us, that changes us and regenerates us of God, and puts to death the old Adam, makes us entirely different men in heart, spirit, mind, and all powers, and brings with it [confers] the Holy Ghost. Oh, it is a living, busy, active, powerful thing that we have in faith, so that it is impossible for it not to do good without ceasing.”2 In other words, the movement that Methodists date from that evening was born while Lutheran words about faith were being read to a man who needed them.

Although that is where the story begins, it is not where it ends. Three years later Wesley read Luther’s commentary on Galatians and wrote that he was ashamed he had ever praised it. The Methodism that grew from his preaching parted from Lutheran teaching on the freedom of the will, on the holiness possible in this life, on how a Christian knows he is forgiven, and on what the sacraments give. Today one large Lutheran church body is in full communion with the largest Methodist one while other Lutheran bodies are not, and many Lutherans have Methodist husbands, wives, and grandchildren. I want to describe the Methodists as they describe themselves, from Wesley’s sermons and their own Articles, and then to say where our Confessions stand and why.

The questions are these:

  1. Who are the Methodists, and how have Lutherans and Methodists met?
  2. What do we confess together?
  3. Does God’s grace restore to every person the ability to accept or refuse Him?
  4. Can a Christian be made perfect in love in this life?
  5. How does a Christian know that his sins are forgiven?
  6. What do Baptism and the Lord’s Supper give?
  7. Can a believer fall from grace?

I. The People Called Methodists

From Epworth to Aldersgate

John Wesley was born in 1703 at Epworth in Lincolnshire, the son of the rector there. He and his younger brother Charles were both ordained priests of the Church of England. At Oxford the brothers gathered a few friends to read the Greek New Testament, to receive the Lord’s Supper weekly, to fast, and to visit prisoners, and their fellow students called them the Holy Club and the Methodists, because they ordered their lives by method.

In 1735 the brothers sailed for Georgia as missionaries. On the ship were twenty-six German Moravians and in January 1736 a storm broke over the ship during their evening service. Wesley wrote, “In the midst of the psalm wherewith their service began, the sea broke over, split the mainsail in pieces, covered the ship, and poured in between the decks, as if the great deep had already swallowed us up. A terrible screaming began among the English. The Germans calmly sang on.”3 Wesley knew that he was afraid to die. On the voyage home two years later he wrote, “I went to America, to convert the Indians; but oh! who shall convert me?”4

The Moravians were the renewed Unity of the Brethren, the old Hussite church of Bohemia, whose refugees had settled in 1722 at Herrnhut in Saxony on the estate of Count Nicholas von Zinzendorf, a Lutheran nobleman raised in the Pietism of Halle. Back in London in 1738, Wesley met a young Moravian minister named Peter Böhler, who convinced him (as Wesley put it) “of unbelief, of the want of that faith whereby alone we are saved.” When Wesley asked whether he should stop preaching, Böhler answered, “By no means,” and when he asked what he should preach, Böhler said, “Preach faith till you have it; and then, because you have it, you will preach faith.”5 Charles came to faith first. On May 17, 1738, he wrote, “To-day I first saw Luther on the Galatians, which Mr. Holland had accidentally lit upon. We began, and found him nobly full of faith.” That evening he “spent some hours this evening in private with Martin Luther, who was greatly blessed to me, especially his conclusion of the 2d chapter.”6 The end of Galatians 2 is Paul’s confession, “the life I now live in the flesh I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me” (Galatians 2:20). Charles found peace with God on Pentecost Sunday, May 21, three days before his brother’s evening in Aldersgate Street.

That summer John spent three months with the Moravians in Germany. Within two years, however, he had parted from the Moravians in London, some of whom taught that a seeker should be “still” and stay away from the means of grace, the Lord’s Supper included, until faith came. Wesley believed that the ordinances were the very places where God gives faith, and in 1740 he withdrew from their society to form his own.

Wesley and Luther’s Galatians

On June 15, 1741, Wesley read Luther’s commentary on Galatians for himself. “I was utterly ashamed,” he wrote. “How have I esteemed this book, only because I heard it so commended by others.”7 Then he came to his chief complaint:

“Again, how blasphemously does he speak of good works and of the Law of God; constantly coupling the Law with sin, death, hell, or the devil; and teaching, that Christ delivers us from them all alike. Whereas, it can no more be proved by Scripture that Christ delivers us from the Law of God, than that he delivers us from holiness or from heaven. Here (I apprehend) is the real spring of the grand error of the Moravians. They follow Luther, for better for worse. Hence their ‘No works; no Law; no commandments.’”8

The last sentence shows what he was fighting. Wesley was not attacking justification by faith, which he preached for fifty more years, but instead the antinomianism (the teaching that the Christian has nothing to do with God’s Law) that he believed he had met among the London Moravians. Lutherans reject that error too. Forty-six years later his judgment was more measured and also sharper. “Who has wrote more ably than Martin Luther on justification by faith alone?” he asked in 1787. “And who was more ignorant of the doctrine of sanctification, or more confused in his conceptions of it?”9 That sentence names the fault line that runs through everything that follows. Wesley heard Luther’s sharp distinction of Law and Gospel as a threat to holiness, where Lutherans hear it as the protection of the Gospel.

Societies, and then churches

Wesley never meant to found a church, but to awaken the Church of England. From 1739 he preached in the open air to miners and laborers who never entered a parish church, and he gathered those who were awakened into societies, divided into classes of about twelve. The General Rules of 1743, still printed in the Book of Discipline, describe a society as “a company of men having the form and seeking the power of godliness, united in order to pray together, to receive the word of exhortation, and to watch over one another in love, that they may help each other to work out their salvation.”10

The American Revolution left the Methodists in the new United States without clergy to baptize them or give them the Supper. In 1784 Wesley ordained men for America and sent them with a service book revised from the Book of Common Prayer and an abridgment of the Thirty-Nine Articles. In the letter that went with them he wrote, “I also advise the elders to administer the Supper of the Lord on every Lord’s Day.”11 The Methodist Episcopal Church was organized at Baltimore that Christmas. Wesley had cut the Thirty-Nine Articles to twenty-four, leaving out among others the article on predestination, and the Americans added one on the civil rulers of the new nation.12 Wesley himself died in 1791 a priest of the Church of England.

The Wesleyan family today

American Methodism divided over slavery long before it divided over anything else. The Wesleyan Methodists left the Methodist Episcopal Church in 1843 chiefly over slavery, and in 1844–45 the church itself split into a northern and a southern body, which reunited only in 1939.13 The Free Methodists organized in 1860, joining opposition to slavery with the call for free pews for the poor and for Wesley’s teaching on holiness. Later in the century others left because they believed the church had let go of Christian perfection, and from that conviction came the Church of the Nazarene (1908), which today counts nearly 2.8 million members worldwide.14 The Wesleyan Church was formed in 1968 by a union of the Wesleyan Methodists and the Pilgrim Holiness Church. These holiness churches confess their own Articles of Faith, drawn from the Methodist ones. The Pentecostal movement grew from this soil as well.

The African Methodist Episcopal Church grew from the Free African Society founded in Philadelphia in 1787 by Richard Allen and Absalom Jones. At St. George’s Methodist Episcopal Church, Black worshipers were pulled from their knees while they prayed, and they walked out and built their own church. The AME Church was organized in 1816 with Allen as its first bishop and now reports congregations in thirty-nine countries on five continents.15 The AME Zion and Christian Methodist Episcopal churches belong to this family too.

The United Methodist Church was formed in 1968 from the Methodist Church and the Evangelical United Brethren. Its doctrinal standards are the Twenty-Five Articles of Religion, the Confession of Faith of the Evangelical United Brethren, Wesley’s Standard Sermons and Explanatory Notes upon the New Testament, and the General Rules. For fifty years it argued over sexuality, and beneath that over how Scripture is to be read. Between 2019 and 2023 nearly 7,700 American congregations, about a quarter of the whole, left the denomination, and in 2024 its General Conference removed its restrictions on gay clergy and same-sex weddings.16 The Articles and the Confession of Faith, which the church’s constitution protects, were not changed. Many of the departing congregations joined the Global Methodist Church, founded in 2022, which presents itself as recovering Wesleyan doctrine and discipline and which reported more than 7,000 congregations early in 2026, in annual conferences that lie mostly outside the United States.17 Methodism is also far larger than its American branches. The United Methodist Church is strong in Africa and the Philippines, and the British, Korean, and many other Methodist churches belong to the World Methodist Council.

By “Methodist teaching” in this paper I mean what this family holds in common: the teaching of Wesley’s sermons, the Articles of Religion (or, in the holiness churches, the Articles of Faith drawn from them), and the General Rules.

Lutherans and Methodists in conversation

The Lutheran World Federation and the World Methodist Council met in international dialogue from 1979 to 1984 and issued a report called The Church: Community of Grace.18 In 2006 at Seoul the World Methodist Council associated itself with the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification, declaring that the common understanding of justification set out there “corresponds to Methodist doctrine.”19 In the United States the United Methodist General Conference of 2008 and the Churchwide Assembly of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America in 2009 adopted full communion between the two churches, the ELCA by a wide margin.20 Full communion means that each recognizes the other’s sacraments and ministry, that they share pulpit and altar, and that their clergy may serve in either church.

The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod and the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod are not party to that agreement. The reason is the one our Confessions give for the unity of the Church: “And to the true unity of the Church it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments.”21 The Formula of Concord explains that this agreement must be “in the doctrine and all its articles, also in the right use of the holy Sacraments.”22 Our churches do not yet agree in that way, as this paper will show. That is a confessional judgment, and it is no judgment on the faith of Methodist Christians, many of whom love the Lord Jesus more warmly than I do.


II. What We Confess Together

Most of the Methodist Articles come from the Church of England’s Thirty-Nine, whose authors had read the Augsburg Confession closely, so much of the shared language is more than coincidence. We confess one Triune God, “three persons, of one substance, power, and eternity,” and one Christ, “very God and very Man, who truly suffered, was crucified, dead, and buried.”23 Methodists confess the Apostles’ and Nicene Creeds in their worship as Lutherans do. Article V says, “The Holy Scripture containeth all things necessary to salvation.” Article VII teaches that original sin “is the corruption of the nature of every man, that naturally is engendered of the offspring of Adam, whereby man is very far gone from original righteousness, and of his own nature inclined to evil, and that continually.”

Most important of all, we confess justification by faith. Article IX reads:

“We are accounted righteous before God only for the merit of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, by faith, and not for our own works or deservings. Wherefore, that we are justified by faith, only, is a most wholesome doctrine, and very full of comfort.”

The Augsburg Confession teaches that we are “freely justified for Christ’s sake, through faith,” and the Methodist article even uses our word comfort.24 It is the comfort Paul gives: “For we hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law” (Romans 3:28). Wesley preached it all his life. “The plain scriptural notion of justification,” he wrote, “is pardon, the forgiveness of sins,” and justifying faith is “a sure trust and confidence that Christ died for ‘my’ sins, that he loved ‘me,’ and gave himself for ‘me.’”25

In addition, both churches teach that good works “are the fruits of faith, and follow after justification,” and that they “cannot put away our sins” (Article X), as the Augsburg Confession teaches that faith “is bound to bring forth good fruits” but that we “should not rely on those works to merit justification before God.”26 Both confess Baptism and the Lord’s Supper as Christ’s own institutions and reject the sacrifice of the Mass, although the Apology goes further than the Methodist Articles and also calls Absolution “truly” a sacrament.27

We also share a love for singing the faith. Luther gave the Church the congregation’s hymn, and Charles Wesley wrote more than six thousand hymns and sacred poems, among them “Hark! the Herald Angels Sing” and “Christ the Lord Is Risen Today,” which Lutherans have sung for generations. Here is the last stanza of his “And Can It Be,” written in the year of his conversion:

No condemnation now I dread; Jesus, and all in Him is mine! Alive in Him, my living Head, And clothed in righteousness divine, Bold I approach th’eternal throne, And claim the crown, through Christ my own.28

That is Romans 8:1 set to music. Lastly, our founders shared a high regard for the Lord’s Supper. Wesley’s sermon The Duty of Constant Communion, written at Oxford and reissued near the end of his life, argues “that it is the duty of every Christian to receive the Lord’s Supper as often as he can,” and refuses even the phrase “frequent communion,” because “if it means anything less than constant, it means more than can be proved to be the duty of any man.”29 Lutherans who have worked to restore the Sacrament to every Sunday will recognize a friend.


III. Where We Part

The grace that goes before

Methodists teach that before any person turns to God, God has already turned toward him. They call this prevenient grace, from the Latin praevenire (“to come before”). Wesley’s own term was “preventing grace,” in the old sense of prevent, “to go before.” Article VIII, taken from the Church of England, reads:

“The condition of man after the fall of Adam is such that he cannot turn and prepare himself, by his own natural strength and works, to faith, and calling upon God; wherefore we have no power to do good works, pleasant and acceptable to God, without the grace of God by Christ preventing us, that we may have a good will, and working with us, when we have that good will.”

In other words, fallen man cannot turn to God by his own strength, and every good desire in him is the work of Christ’s grace, which goes ahead of him and then works with him. Wesley did not teach that the will is naturally free, but instead that the grace of Christ has already gone out to every human being. In his sermon on our epigraph he wrote:

“For allowing that all the souls of men are dead in sin by nature, this excuses none, seeing there is no man that is in a state of mere nature; there is no man, unless he has quenched the Spirit, that is wholly void of the grace of God. No man living is entirely destitute of what is vulgarly called natural conscience. But this is not natural: It is more properly termed preventing grace.”30

Salvation, he wrote in the same sermon, “begins with what is usually termed (and very properly) preventing grace; including the first wish to please God, the first dawn of light concerning his will, and the first slight transient conviction of having sinned against him.”31 That grace awakens and enables without compelling, and a person may yield to it or quench it.

Wesley’s texts were these. John says of Christ, “The true light, which gives light to everyone, was coming into the world” (John 1:9). Paul writes, “Therefore, as one trespass led to condemnation for all men, so one act of righteousness leads to justification and life for all men” (Romans 5:18), and that “the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation for all people” (Titus 2:11). God “desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth” (1 Timothy 2:4). Jesus lamented over Jerusalem, “How often would I have gathered your children together as a hen gathers her brood under her wings, and you were not willing!” (Matthew 23:37). Wesley could not reconcile these texts with the Reformed teaching that God decreed to pass some by. “The grace or love of God, whence cometh our salvation,” he preached in 1739, “is FREE IN ALL, and FREE FOR ALL.” It is free in all because “it does not depend on any power or merit in man; no, not in any degree, neither in whole, nor in part.”32 Wesley and his preachers agreed in 1745 that the truth of the Gospel lies “within a hair’s breadth” of Calvinism, and when they asked where they might “come to the very edge of Calvinism,” they answered, “In ascribing all good to the free grace of God,” and “In denying all natural free-will, and all power antecedent to grace.”33 This is close to what the Dutch theologian Jacobus Arminius had taught more than a century before, that God elects those He foresees will believe and that grace may be resisted, and Methodists are often called Arminians for it.

A Lutheran owes Wesley two corrections of the way he is often described. He was no Pelagian. Pelagius, a monk of the early 400s, taught that people can obey God without inner help from grace, and Wesley denied it. Nor was he a semi-Pelagian, one who holds that the first step toward God, the beginning of faith, comes from our side and grace then meets it, since for Wesley even “the first wish to please God” is grace. The Formula of Concord rejects the Synergists (from the Greek for “working together”) of its own day, who taught that once the Holy Ghost had made a beginning, “the free will, from its own natural powers, can meet God.”34 Wesley would point to the words “from its own natural powers” and say, rightly, that he never taught them. The Formula answers the Synergists that the power to apply oneself to grace “does not proceed from our own natural powers, but alone from the operation of the Holy Ghost,” and Wesley would agree with that sentence as well.35

Where, then, do we part? Lutherans teach that the unconverted man is dead in sin until God raises him. Paul writes that we “were dead in the trespasses and sins” (Ephesians 2:1), and Jesus says, “No one can come to me unless the Father who sent me draws him” (John 6:44). The Formula draws the consequence. Because man before his conversion is dead in sins, “it cannot be correctly said that man before his conversion has a modus agendi, or a way, namely, of working something good and salutary in divine things.”36 It refuses to count the human will as a third cause of conversion beside the Word and the Spirit; the will of the unconverted man is only “that which is to be converted,” and conversion “is a work of God the Holy Ghost alone.”37 Once a man is converted, his renewed will does cooperate with the Spirit in all that follows.38

Lutherans also teach that grace can be resisted. Those who are lost are lost because they “resist the Holy Spirit” (Acts 7:51), and the Formula says that God, “who does not wish that any man be damned,” is in no way the cause of anyone’s condemnation.39 A Methodist may fairly ask, “Then why is my not resisting a work, and yours is not?” The Lutheran answer is that resisting is our own doing, while believing is God’s doing alone, and that we may not explain why one is converted and another, “who is indeed in the same guilt,” is not.40 The Formula looks at that question and stops. Wesley answers it. In his account grace restores to every person, before conversion, a power to yield or to resist, and among those whom grace has equally awakened, the one who is saved is the one who yielded. That is the point at which our Confessions part from him. Wesley would say that no one is left merely dead, since preventing grace is already quickening every soul. Lutherans reply that Scripture still speaks of the unconverted as dead until the Word raises them.

The two churches also name differently what God gives to every conscience. What Wesley calls preventing grace, Lutherans have called the natural knowledge of the Law, which Paul describes when he writes that the Gentiles “show that the work of the law is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness” (Romans 2:15). It accuses and it excuses but it does not convert. The Smalcald Articles teach that “God does not wish to deal with us otherwise than through the spoken Word and the Sacraments.”41 Wesley agreed more than he is often given credit for. He called the means of grace “the ordinary channels whereby he might convey to men, preventing, justifying, or sanctifying grace,” and he broke with the Moravians to defend them.42

Wesley’s answer holds together more of what Scripture says about God’s will for all. I believe the Lutheran answer is more faithful to what Scripture says about the dead heart, and more comforting to a troubled conscience. If my conversion depends on my yielding at the right moment, sooner or later I will ask whether I yielded enough. If it is God’s work alone, my eyes go to Christ.

Perfect love

Wesley believed that God had raised up the Methodists especially to proclaim the doctrine he called Christian perfection, perfect love, or entire sanctification. In The Scripture Way of Salvation (1765) he described it this way:

“It is thus that we wait for entire sanctification; for a full salvation from all our sins,—from pride, self-will, anger, unbelief; or, as the Apostle expresses it, ‘go unto perfection.’ But what is perfection? The word has various senses: here it means perfect love. It is love excluding sin; love filling the heart, taking up the whole capacity of the soul.”43

Wesley and his brother held “that this is received merely by faith.”44 In other words, perfect love is a gift, received as justification is received, and not an achievement. Wesley taught that it usually comes in a moment after a time of growth, that those who receive it go on growing in grace, and that they can fall from it. He also granted that most believers he had known “were not so sanctified till near death.”45 Behind the doctrine lay his reading of God’s commands. “Every command in holy writ is only a covered promise,” he preached, because God “hath engaged to give whatsoever he commands.”46 When Jesus says, “You therefore must be perfect, as your heavenly Father is perfect” (Matthew 5:48), and Paul prays, “Now may the God of peace himself sanctify you completely” (1 Thessalonians 5:23), Wesley heard promises.

He also defined his terms with care. “Christian perfection, therefore, does not imply (as some men seem to have imagined) an exemption either from ignorance or mistake, or infirmities or temptations.”47 In A Plain Account of Christian Perfection he distinguished “sin, properly so called, (that is, a voluntary transgression of a known law,)” from “sin, improperly so called, (that is, an involuntary transgression of a divine law, known or unknown,)” and he said that both need “the atoning blood.” He wrote, “Therefore sinless perfection is a phrase I never use, lest I should seem to contradict myself,” and he warned that no one should think himself able to “stand before infinite justice without a Mediator.”48 Against Zinzendorf, who taught that a believer is wholly sanctified the moment he is justified, Wesley held, “I do suppose sin remains (at least for a time) in all that are justified.”49 The holiness churches made this doctrine their center, and the United Methodist standards still confess it; the Evangelical United Brethren Confession speaks of the born again as “cleansed from sin in their thoughts, words and acts.”50

Lutherans also teach that the Spirit sanctifies the believer, and that the work is begun and grows. Luther writes in the Large Catechism that “sanctification has begun and is growing daily,” and then goes straight on: “For now we are only half pure and holy, so that the Holy Ghost has ever [some reason why] to continue His work in us through the Word, and daily to dispense forgiveness, until we attain to that life where there will be no more forgiveness.”51 That is the teaching that the believer is simul iustus et peccator, “at the same time righteous and a sinner.” He is righteous because Christ’s righteousness is counted to him whole, and he is a sinner because the old nature clings to him until death.

The Lutheran and Augustinian reading of Romans 7 hears Paul the apostle speaking of his present life: “For I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I keep on doing” (Romans 7:19). Wesley, with many of the early fathers, read the passage as the cry of an awakened man still under the Law, “the person whom I am personating,” as he put it, before his deliverance.52 Paul’s later words are harder to read that way: “Not that I have already obtained this or am already perfect, but I press on to make it my own, because Christ Jesus has made me his own” (Philippians 3:12). John writes, “If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us” (1 John 1:8). His other sentence, which Wesley’s Bible gave as “Whosoever is born of God doth not commit sin,” uses a Greek present tense that the ESV renders “No one born of God makes a practice of sinning” (1 John 3:9). The Smalcald Articles quote both of John’s sentences side by side, as two truths about every believer.53

Wesley disowned sinless perfection and the Augsburg Confession’s condemnation of “those who contend that some may attain to such perfection in this life that they cannot sin” does not touch him.54 Nor did Wesley join his teaching to merit, as the opponents did whom the Formula rejects for saying that the regenerate “can completely fulfil the Law of God in this life.”55 The difference lies in the definition of sin. Wesley could speak of a heart from which sin is excluded because sin “properly so called” meant for him a voluntary transgression of a known law. The Augsburg Confession teaches that the inborn “disease, or vice of origin, is truly sin,” including the desire that rises in us before we choose it.56 If that is so, no Christian in this life loves God with all his heart, and every Christian prays “forgive us our trespasses” until he dies. The Apology asks how a conscience could ever be certain that it pleased God, “since we never satisfy the Law?”57 Wesley saw the pastoral danger himself, that a sincere believer may claim a perfection he does not have or despair because he cannot find it in himself. The Lutheran answer does not lower the goal, but instead places the believer’s confidence entirely in Christ’s righteousness while the Spirit goes on with His unfinished work in us. Our perfection is fixed on the last day: “we know that when he appears we shall be like him, because we shall see him as he is” (1 John 3:2).

Repentance and its fruits

A smaller difference, though not a trivial one, lies close to this. In the same sermon Wesley asked how faith can be the only condition of justification if God also commands repentance and its fruits. He answered that “both repentance, and fruits meet for repentance, are, in some sense, necessary to justification. But they are not necessary in the same sense with faith, nor in the same degree,” since they are needed only “if there be time and opportunity for them,” and the thief on the cross was justified without them.58 Wesley guarded faith carefully here. However, the Formula of Concord would not allow even that much. It teaches that good works are necessary as fruits and as obedience, and in the same article it rejects the propositions “that good works are necessary to salvation” and “that it is impossible to be saved without good works,” because they mingle works into the article of justification.59 Lutherans speak of repentance as contrition and faith, and of works as following after.

How a Christian knows he is forgiven

Methodism has always taught that a Christian may know that he is forgiven. Its key text is Romans 8:16: “The Spirit himself bears witness with our spirit that we are children of God.” In 1767 Wesley restated his definition of that witness:

“By the testimony of the Spirit, I mean, an inward impression on the soul whereby the Spirit of God immediately and directly witnesses to my spirit, that I am a child of God; that Jesus Christ hath loved me, and given himself for me; that all my sins are blotted out, and I, even I, am reconciled to God.”60

Wesley taught that this direct witness must always be tested by its fruit, the love, joy, and obedience the Spirit produces. In his old age he also corrected the early Methodist preachers. In 1788 he wrote that “nearly fifty years ago” they “were not sufficiently apprized of the difference between a servant and a child of God,” and so “were apt to make sad the hearts of those whom God had not made sad.”61 He came to hold that a person who fears God and does what is right is accepted, even if he does not yet have the full assurance of a son. In other words, assurance is a privilege of faith but not the whole of it.

Lutherans also teach that a Christian may be certain of God’s favor and the Reformation was fought for that certainty. The difference is where the Christian is told to look. Lutherans look outside themselves: to the promise of the Gospel, to the absolution spoken by the pastor in Christ’s stead, which the Apology counts among the sacraments, to the body and blood given “for you,” and to Baptism.62 The Spirit does bear witness with our spirit but He bears it by the Word and the sacraments to which He has bound Himself.

Wesley’s own Journal shows why this matters. On the night of May 24, after he came home, “it was not long before the enemy suggested, ‘This cannot be faith; for where is thy joy?’” He was taught, he wrote, that “as to the transports of joy that usually attend the beginning of it, especially in those who have mourned deeply, God sometimes giveth, sometimes withholdeth, them according to the counsels of His own will.”63 That is a wise answer, and one a Lutheran could give. Therefore Lutherans teach the Christian in a dry season to rest on the promise God has spoken and sealed in water and in the Supper, whatever he feels. I should add that Lutherans do not always live by this. The searching of the heart that troubled Wesley’s early hearers was taught by Lutheran Pietism a generation before him, and many Lutherans have gone years without once taking comfort in their Baptism.

The font and the table

The Methodist Articles on the sacraments come from the Church of England. Article XVI calls the sacraments “certain signs of grace, and God’s good will toward us, by which he doth work invisibly in us,” which is a high statement. Article XVII calls Baptism “a sign of regeneration or the new birth” and retains the baptism of infants. Wesley’s abridgment dropped the Anglican clause that by Baptism, “as by an instrument, they that receive Baptism rightly are grafted into the Church.”64 Article XVIII teaches that “the body of Christ is given, taken, and eaten in the Supper, only after a heavenly and spiritual manner. And the mean whereby the body of Christ is received and eaten in the Supper is faith.” In other words, Christ is truly received in the Supper, but by faith and not by the mouth.

Wesley’s own teaching on Baptism was fuller than the abridged Article. In The New Birth he distinguished the outward sign from the inward grace, “baptism is not the new birth: They are not one and the same thing.” Yet he held with the Prayer Book that infants are born again in Baptism and defended it: “It is certain our Church supposes that all who are baptized in their infancy are at the same time born again… Nor is it an objection of any weight against this, that we cannot comprehend how this work can be wrought in infants.”65 What he denied was that an adult who had sinned away that grace could rest on his baptism without being born again now. Lutherans warn against trusting a Baptism one has abandoned in much the same way, although we would call the remedy a return to that Baptism. Lutherans confess that Baptism is “the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5) and that through it “is offered the grace of God,” for infants as for adults.66 We would gladly stand beside Methodists who hold Wesley’s view of infant Baptism.

On the Supper, Wesley’s piety ran higher than his Articles. He called it a means of grace in which God gives “the forgiveness of our past sins and the present strengthening and refreshing of our souls.”67 He also defended it as “a converting ordinance,” against the Moravians who would admit only those already converted: “many now present know, the very beginning of your conversion to God (perhaps, in some, the first deep conviction) was wrought at the Lord’s Supper.”68 That is the root of the Methodist open table, which invites all who seek Christ in repentance. American Methodism did not keep Wesley’s practice. On the frontier the elders were few and the circuits large, so most congregations received the Supper four times a year, and the revival meeting came to stand where the font and the table had stood for Wesley. Since 2004 the United Methodist statement This Holy Mystery has urged congregations toward a weekly celebration, as Wesley asked in 1784.69

Methodists confess that Christ is truly present in the Supper and that faith receives Him. The question between us is whether His body and blood are given with the bread to every mouth, believing or not. Lutherans say they are, on the strength of the Lord’s words, “Take, eat; this is my body” (Matthew 26:26), and of Paul’s warning that whoever eats “in an unworthy manner will be guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord” (1 Corinthians 11:27). The Formula therefore teaches that the unworthy also “receive orally in the Sacrament the true body and [true] blood of Christ,” although to their harm.70 This is the difference that divides Lutherans from the Reformed churches and the Church of England, from whom Article XVIII comes, and the sister essay on the Reformed churches and my One Body at Many Altars treat it at length. In his zeal for constant communion Wesley stood closer to Luther than many Lutherans of his century did. Methodists and Lutherans in America both let the Sacrament slip from the center of Sunday worship, and both have spent the last fifty years trying to put it back.

Falling from grace

Here Lutherans and Methodists stand side by side. The Methodist Article XII teaches, “After we have received the Holy Ghost, we may depart from grace given, and fall into sin, and, by the grace of God, rise again and amend our lives.” The Augsburg Confession condemns the Anabaptists (the radical reformers who rejected infant Baptism) for denying “that those once justified can lose the Holy Ghost.”71 Both churches read Paul’s warnings as warnings: “Therefore let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall” (1 Corinthians 10:12). Both also hold out the way back. The Formula says of the baptized who have “grieved and lost the Holy Ghost” that “they need not be rebaptized, but must be converted again.”72

Both churches therefore reject the Reformed teaching that a true believer can never fall from grace. However, Lutherans, unlike Wesley, also confess with the Formula that God will preserve His elect: that He “will also strengthen, increase, and support to the end the good work which He has begun in them,” and “preserve them.”73 Wesley rejected unconditional election and taught instead an election in Christ of those who believe, which he set out in Predestination Calmly Considered (1752). He taught that the grace which brought the believer to faith keeps him in it, as he continues in that grace and the means God gives. The Formula bids the anxious to look for their election in Christ and the Gospel, where He “testifies to all men without distinction that it is God’s will that all men should come to Him.”74 A Lutheran can rest there and leave the hidden counsel to God.


IV. Learning from One Another

Lutherans can learn first what Wesley wanted Luther’s readers to learn, that faith shows itself in a changed life. I believe Wesley’s charge against Luther’s Galatians was unfair, although it was not made out of nothing. Lutherans have sometimes spoken of grace as though it made holiness unnecessary, although our Confessions never do. The Formula calls the idea that a Christian may persist in sin against his conscience and keep his faith a “delusion,” and it teaches the third use of the Law, by which the Law guides the Christian (its other uses being to restrain the wicked and to show us our sin).75 Wesley’s sermons are a standing reminder that the Gospel has a goal, the renewal of the image of God in us, so that the forgiven “walk in newness of life” (Romans 6:4).

In addition, Lutherans can learn from the way the early Methodists cared for one another. In the class meeting a leader saw each of about twelve members weekly “to inquire how their souls prosper,” and members agreed “to watch over one another in love.”76 Most Lutheran congregations have never had such a form of mutual care, although Luther imagined something like it in his preface to the German Mass. Wesley took the Gospel to people the parish church had lost, preaching in fields and at the mouths of mines, and he urged his people to do good “of every possible sort, and, as far as possible, to all men.”77 Many Methodist hospitals, schools, and relief agencies grew from that rule. Charles Wesley’s hymns also set doctrine deep in the people who sing them, as Luther wanted the hymns of the Reformation to do.

What Lutherans have to give the Methodists begins with the Supper as Wesley loved it, and as more than his Articles allowed him to confess, the true body and blood of Christ given with the bread for the forgiveness of sins. We can offer the external Word and the sacraments as the place where assurance is found, and the teaching that the Christian is saint and sinner at once, which frees the discouraged believer from searching his heart for a perfection that is not there. We can offer the bound will, which sounds harsh until a person sees that it takes the whole weight of his salvation off his own shoulders. We can also offer Luther himself, read again. I believe Wesley misread what Luther meant when he joined the Law with sin, death, and the devil. Luther was speaking of the Law as it accuses the conscience before God, as Paul does in Galatians 3, and not of the Law as God’s holy will for our lives.

A word to the Lutheran whose son, daughter, or spouse is a Methodist. Be glad of the faith you share: the Creed, the forgiveness of sins for Christ’s sake, the hymns, and a love of holiness that may put you to shame. Hold to what your Confession teaches about the Lord’s Supper, and when your church does not commune your Methodist family at its altar, explain that it is a confession of one faith about the altar itself and not a judgment of their hearts. Your Methodist family’s Baptism is a true Baptism and no Lutheran pastor will repeat it. When they speak of a warmed heart, you can tell them gladly where Wesley’s heart was warmed.


V. Conclusion

Wesley’s warmed heart has sometimes been taken as the center of the Aldersgate story. It was God’s gift that night and Wesley treasured it. However, the faith rested on what was read: that God changes the heart through faith in Christ, and that Christ had taken away “my sins, even mine.” I believe Wesley held that faith to the end of his life, and I am glad to call the Methodists who hold it brothers and sisters in Christ.

That is also why I do not pretend that our differences are slight. We differ about the will before conversion, about how much of sin remains in the Christian, about where the Christian looks for assurance, and about what the mouth receives at the Lord’s table. The Supper is a confession of one faith: “Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread” (1 Corinthians 10:17). While we do not confess one faith about that bread, I believe the confessional Lutheran churches are right not to share the altar with Methodist churches. The Book of Concord itself explains how this firmness and this brotherhood belong together. Its condemnations are aimed at false doctrine, and its authors wrote that “it is in no way our design and purpose to condemn those men who err from a certain simplicity of mind, but are not blasphemers against the truth of the heavenly doctrine, much less, indeed, entire churches,” but “only the fanatical opinions and their obstinate and blasphemous teachers.”78

Charles Wesley spent the evening of May 17, 1738, with Luther’s Galatians, praying to feel the words of Paul, “who loved me and gave himself for me.” Four days later he found peace, and in that year he wrote the hymn whose last stanza Lutherans can sing with him without changing a word:

No condemnation now I dread; Jesus, and all in Him is mine!


Notes


Select Bibliography

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)

The Lutheran Confessions

  • Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (Text at bookofconcord.org.)
  • The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
  • The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Preface; Augsburg Confession II, IV, VI, VII, IX, XII; Apology IV, XIII; Smalcald Articles III.iii, III.viii; Large Catechism, Creed; Formula of Concord, Epitome IV and X, Solid Declaration II, IV, VI, VII, X, XI.)

Luther

  • Luther, Martin. Preface to the Epistle of St. Paul to the Romans (1522). Luther’s Works, vol. 35. Philadelphia: Muhlenberg, 1960.
  • Luther, Martin. Lectures on Galatians (1535). Luther’s Works, vols. 26–27. St. Louis: Concordia, 1963–1964.

John and Charles Wesley

  • Wesley, John. Sermons on Several Occasions. 1872 edition. Christian Classics Ethereal Library. (Especially Justification by Faith, The Witness of the Spirit I–II, On Sin in Believers, The Means of Grace, Upon Our Lord’s Sermon on the Mount V, Christian Perfection, The Scripture Way of Salvation, The New Birth, On Working Out Our Own Salvation, The Duty of Constant Communion, On Faith, On God’s Vineyard, Free Grace.)
  • Wesley, John. A Plain Account of Christian Perfection. 1766. Christian Classics Ethereal Library.
  • Wesley, John. Predestination Calmly Considered. 1752.
  • Wesley, John. Explanatory Notes upon the New Testament. 1755.
  • Wesley, John. The Journal of John Wesley. Edited by Percy Livingstone Parker. 1903. Christian Classics Ethereal Library.
  • Wesley, John. The Works of the Rev. John Wesley. Vol. 1, Journal. (For the unabridged entries of June 1740 and June 1741.)
  • Wesley, John. The Letters of John Wesley. Edited by John Telford. 8 vols. London: Epworth, 1931.
  • Outler, Albert C., ed. John Wesley. New York: Oxford University Press, 1964. (For the Minutes of 1745.)
  • Wesley, Charles. The Journal of Charles Wesley. Wesley Center Online.

Methodist Standards and Statements

  • The Book of Discipline of The United Methodist Church — 2020/2024. Nashville: United Methodist Publishing House, 2024. (Articles of Religion; Confession of Faith of the Evangelical United Brethren Church; General Rules.)
  • This Holy Mystery: A United Methodist Understanding of Holy Communion. 2004.
  • Manual of the Church of the Nazarene. Articles of Faith.
  • World Methodist Council. Statement of Association with the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. Seoul, 2006.

Ecumenical Documents

  • Lutheran–Methodist Joint Commission. The Church: Community of Grace. Geneva, 1984.
  • ELCA–UMC Bilateral Dialogue. Confessing Our Faith Together: A Statement Toward Full Communion. 2005.
  • Lutheran World Federation and the Roman Catholic Church. Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. 1999.

History and Reference

  • Schaff, Philip. The Creeds of Christendom. 3 vols. New York: Harper, 1877.
  • Synan, Vinson. The Holiness-Pentecostal Tradition: Charismatic Movements in the Twentieth Century. 2nd ed. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1997.

Footnotes

  1. John Wesley, Journal, May 24, 1738, in The Journal of John Wesley, ed. Percy Livingstone Parker (1903), as reproduced by the Christian Classics Ethereal Library (ccel.org/ccel/wesley/journal). ↩

  2. FC SD IV.10, quoting Luther’s Preface to the Epistle to the Romans (1522). ↩

  3. Wesley, Journal, January 25, 1736 (Parker ed.). He had begun to learn German “in order to converse with the Germans” (October 17, 1735). ↩

  4. Wesley, Journal, January 24, 1738 (Parker ed.). ↩

  5. Wesley, Journal, February 7 and March 4–5, 1738 (Parker ed.). ↩

  6. Charles Wesley, Journal, May 17, 1738, in The Journal of Charles Wesley (1707–1788), Wesley Center Online (wesley.nnu.edu), “May 1–August 31, 1738.” Pentecost, May 21, is in the same text. ↩

  7. Wesley, Journal, June 15, 1741 (Parker ed.). ↩

  8. Wesley, Journal, June 15, 1741, unabridged text: The Works of the Rev. John Wesley, vol. 1, Journal, pp. 315–16 (scanned page images published by wesleyscholar.com). The Parker abridgment omits this paragraph. The next evening Wesley preached on Galatians 6:15 and warned his hearers against “that dangerous treatise” (June 16, 1741, p. 316). ↩

  9. John Wesley, On God’s Vineyard (Sermon 107, 1787), I.5. ↩

  10. The Nature, Design, and General Rules of Our United Societies (1743), in The Book of Discipline of The United Methodist Church, as published at umc.org. ↩

  11. John Wesley, letter “To Our Brethren in America,” Bristol, September 10, 1784, in The Letters of John Wesley, ed. John Telford (London: Epworth, 1931), as reproduced by the Wesley Corpus (corpus.historyofmethodism.com), “Letters 1784B.” ↩

  12. Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 1 (New York: Harper, 1877), on Article XVII of the Thirty-Nine Articles: “John Wesley, unable to reconcile Art. XVII. with his Arminianism, omitted it altogether from his revision of the Articles.” ↩

  13. The Wesleyan Methodist Connection was organized at Utica, New York, May 31–June 8, 1843, under Orange Scott; on the cause, see the Wesleyan Church’s own account, “Antislavery Roots” (wesleyan.org). The Methodist Episcopal Church divided at its General Conference of 1844, the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, being organized in 1845. The reunion of 1939 joined these two churches and the Methodist Protestant Church, as the Discipline’s note on the “Uniting Conference (1939)” records. ↩

  14. Church of the Nazarene, “General Secretary releases 2024 statistics” (nazarene.org, January 2025): 2,783,731 members at the end of 2024. On the Free Methodist and Wesleyan churches, see Vinson Synan, The Holiness-Pentecostal Tradition, 2nd ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1997), and the denominations’ own histories. ↩

  15. African Methodist Episcopal Church, “Our History” (ame-church.com): “membership in twenty Episcopal Districts in thirty-nine countries on five continents” (accessed November 18, 2026). The date 1816 is from standard histories; the church’s page gives 1787 and 1794. Historians differ on whether the St. George’s incident came before or after 1787. ↩

  16. “United Methodists Down 7,659 Churches As Exit Window Ends,” Christianity Today, December 18, 2023 (7,659 congregations over four years, against 30,541 U.S. congregations in 2019). The finance agency reported 22,096 U.S. congregations at the end of 2023 and about 5.7 million U.S. members at the end of 2022 (Heather Hahn, “Tracking the official disaffiliation data,” UM News). On the General Conference at Charlotte, April 23–May 3, 2024, see umc.org, “Faith and inclusion: United Methodist General Conference opens doors,” which reports the removal of the 1972 statement that the practice of homosexuality is “incompatible with Christian teaching.” The same conference approved worldwide regionalization, which the annual conferences ratified by 34,148 votes to 3,124; the Council of Bishops announced the ratification on November 5, 2025 (UM News, “New United Methodist Church structure ratified”). ↩

  17. Global Methodist Church, “The Global Methodist Church Surpasses 7,000 Churches Worldwide,” Lubbock, Texas, February 18, 2026 (globalmethodist.org): 48 annual conferences, “the majority of which are located outside the United States.” ↩

  18. Lutheran–Methodist Joint Commission, The Church: Community of Grace (Geneva, 1984), listed with its sessions of 1979–1984 in the Centro Pro Unione archive of dialogues (prounione.it). ↩

  19. World Methodist Council, “Statement of Association with the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification,” Seoul, July 23, 2006, §2, as published by the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity (christianunity.va). ↩

  20. ELCA News Service, “ELCA Adopts Full Communion Agreement with the United Methodist Church,” Minneapolis, August 20, 2009: the vote was 958 to 51, and “in 2008 the UMC General Conference adopted the same agreement.” The theological basis is Confessing Our Faith Together: A Statement Toward Full Communion by the ELCA–UMC Bilateral Dialogue (2005). ↩

  21. AC VII.2. ↩

  22. FC SD X.31; compare FC Ep X.7, “in doctrine and all its articles.” ↩

  23. Articles of Religion I and II. All quotations of the Articles of Religion are from The Book of Discipline of The United Methodist Church — 2020/2024, as published at umc.org. Compare AC I and III. ↩

  24. AC IV.1–2. ↩

  25. John Wesley, Justification by Faith (Sermon 5), II.5 and IV.2. ↩

  26. Articles of Religion X; AC VI.1. ↩

  27. Ap XIII.4: “Therefore Baptism, the Lord’s Supper, and Absolution, which is the Sacrament of Repentance, are truly Sacraments.” Article XVI of the Articles of Religion denies the name to penance and four other rites. ↩

  28. Charles Wesley, “And Can It Be That I Should Gain” (1738), stanza 5, text as given at hymnary.org. On the number of his hymns, Schaff, Creeds of Christendom, vol. 1, writes that he “composed over six thousand religious poems.” ↩

  29. John Wesley, The Duty of Constant Communion (Sermon 101), I and II.1. Wesley’s prefatory note of 1788 says the discourse “was written above five-and-fifty years ago, for the use of my pupils at Oxford.” ↩

  30. John Wesley, On Working Out Our Own Salvation (Sermon 85), III.4. ↩

  31. Wesley, On Working Out Our Own Salvation, II.1. ↩

  32. John Wesley, Free Grace (Sermon 128), 2–3. ↩

  33. Minutes of Some Late Conversations, Conference of August 1745, Q. 23, as reproduced (from Albert C. Outler, ed., John Wesley, New York: Oxford, 1964) in Kevin Stevick’s article in Participatio, supplementary vol. 4 (2018). The question before it (Q. 22) speaks of coming “within a hair’s breadth” of Calvinism. ↩

  34. FC SD II.77. ↩

  35. FC SD II.78. ↩

  36. FC SD II.61. ↩

  37. FC SD II.90. ↩

  38. FC SD II.88. ↩

  39. FC SD XI.81; compare XI.41 and XI.78, which cite Acts 7:51 and Matthew 23:37, and SD II.83, on those who “obstinately and persistently resist.” ↩

  40. FC SD XI.57–60. ↩

  41. SA III.viii.10. ↩

  42. John Wesley, The Means of Grace (Sermon 16), II.1. ↩

  43. John Wesley, The Scripture Way of Salvation (Sermon 43), I.9. ↩

  44. John Wesley, A Plain Account of Christian Perfection (1766), §18, summarizing what “both my brother and I maintained,” as reproduced by the Christian Classics Ethereal Library (ccel.org/ccel/wesley/perfection). ↩

  45. Wesley, Plain Account, quoting the conference of August 1745; on growth and falling, the questions and answers of 1759 (Q. 29–30). On the moment, The Scripture Way of Salvation, III.18. ↩

  46. John Wesley, Upon Our Lord’s Sermon on the Mount, Discourse V (Sermon 25), II.2–3. ↩

  47. John Wesley, Christian Perfection (Sermon 40), I.9. ↩

  48. Wesley, Plain Account, quoting his statement of 1762 and the conference of 1759. ↩

  49. John Wesley, On Sin in Believers (Sermon 13), IV.11–12; on Zinzendorf and “the Germans,” I.6. ↩

  50. Confession of Faith of the Evangelical United Brethren Church, Article XI, “Sanctification and Christian Perfection,” in the Book of Discipline (umc.org). The Methodist Protestant article “Of Sanctification,” printed after the Articles of Religion since 1939, speaks of believers “enabled, through grace, to love God with all our hearts and to walk in his holy commandments blameless.” The Church of the Nazarene confesses entire sanctification in Article X of its Articles of Faith. ↩

  51. LC II.57–58. ↩

  52. John Wesley, Explanatory Notes upon the New Testament, on Romans 7:14 (the passage shows “the whole process of a man reasoning, groaning, striving, and escaping from the legal to the evangelical state”) and 7:25, text as given by the Wesley Corpus (notes.historyofmethodism.com). ↩

  53. SA III.iii.45. ↩

  54. AC XII.8; compare Articles of Religion XII, which condemns those who say “they can no more sin as long as they live here.” ↩

  55. FC SD II.79. The Formula rejects that teaching together with the claim that by such fulfilment a man “merits eternal life,” which Wesley never taught. ↩

  56. AC II.2. ↩

  57. Ap IV.164 (Triglotta III.43). ↩

  58. Wesley, The Scripture Way of Salvation, III.2. ↩

  59. FC Ep IV.16; FC SD IV.22. On good works as necessary fruits, FC SD IV.14–15. ↩

  60. John Wesley, The Witness of the Spirit, Discourse II (Sermon 11), II.2, quoting Discourse I (Sermon 10), I.7. ↩

  61. John Wesley, On Faith (Sermon 106), I.11. ↩

  62. Ap XIII.4; compare LC IV.44. ↩

  63. Wesley, Journal, May 24, 1738 (Parker ed.). ↩

  64. Thirty-Nine Articles, XXVII, compared with Articles of Religion XVII. ↩

  65. John Wesley, The New Birth (Sermon 45), IV.1–2. ↩

  66. AC IX.2. ↩

  67. Wesley, The Duty of Constant Communion, I.2. ↩

  68. Wesley, Journal, June 27, 1740, unabridged text (Works, vol. 1, scanned pages published by wesleyscholar.com, “JW Journal June 22–July 23, 1740”). ↩

  69. This Holy Mystery: A United Methodist Understanding of Holy Communion, adopted by the General Conference of 2004, in The Book of Resolutions of The United Methodist Church. Paraphrased. ↩

  70. FC SD VII.60. ↩

  71. AC XII.7. ↩

  72. FC SD II.69. ↩

  73. FC SD XI.20–21. ↩

  74. FC SD XI.70. ↩

  75. FC SD IV.15 (“Epicurean delusion”); FC SD VI. ↩

  76. General Rules (1743), in The Book of Discipline. ↩

  77. General Rules (1743), “Secondly: By doing good.” ↩

  78. Preface to the Book of Concord (1580), in the Concordia Triglotta. ↩

Topics
Other Churches and Traditions
Scripture
Philippians 2:12–13Galatians 2:20Romans 3:28Romans 8:1John 1:9Romans 5:18Titus 2:111 Timothy 2:4Matthew 23:37Ephesians 2:1John 6:44Acts 7:51Romans 2:15Matthew 5:481 Thessalonians 5:23Romans 7:19Philippians 3:121 John 1:81 John 3:91 John 3:2Romans 8:16Titus 3:5Matthew 26:261 Corinthians 11:271 Corinthians 10:12Romans 6:4Galatians 31 Corinthians 10:17Galatians 6:15Romans 7:14
Confessions
SD IVAC VIISD XEp XAC IAC IVAC VIAp XIIISD IISD XISA IIILC IIAC XIIAC IIAp IVEp IVLC IVAC IXSD VIISD VILC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “Lutheranism and Methodism: A Heart Strangely Warmed.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/lutheranism-and/methodism/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.