Papers · Lutheranism and …

Lutheranism and the Baptists

The Font, the Table, and the Conscience

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life.” — Romans 6:4


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921) and cited in the notes by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, FC Ep, FC SD) with paragraph numbers as in the Kolb–Wengert and Tappert editions. Baptist documents are quoted from these texts: the Second London Confession of 1677/1689 (cited in the notes as 2LCF, by chapter and paragraph) from the lightly modernized text at the1689confession.com; the New Hampshire Confession of 1833 and the Declaration of 1611 from Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom; and The Baptist Faith and Message of 2000 (BF&M) from the text published by the Southern Baptist Convention, which, as a copyrighted document, is quoted only in short phrases. Thomas Helwys is quoted from the 1612 printing of A Short Declaration of the Mystery of Iniquity with the spelling modernized.


At the Font

Lutherans and Baptists read the same Bible and worship the same crucified and risen Lord, yet they cannot stand together at the font. A Lutheran pastor carries an infant to the water on a Sunday morning and says that God has made this child His own. A Baptist pastor waits until a boy or girl can tell the congregation that he has repented and believed in Christ, and then he lowers the child beneath the water of the baptistery and raises him up again. Each is convinced that he is doing what Christ commanded.

The Southern Baptist Convention is the largest Protestant body in the United States and Baptist churches stand in nearly every American town. Some of the people in our pews were raised Baptist and some of our children and grandchildren now belong to Baptist congregations. Therefore it is worth knowing what Baptists believe and why, and worth being able to explain our own confession in words a Baptist friend can hear. I have tried to describe Baptist teaching as a well-taught Baptist would describe it himself. I take up four questions:

  1. Who are the Baptists, and how are they related to the Anabaptists our Confessions condemn?
  2. What do we confess together?
  3. Where do we part, and for what reasons on each side?
  4. What might we learn from one another, and what might we say to the Lutheran whose family now worships in a Baptist church?

Infant Faith and the Lord’s Table and Baptism and Falling Away carry part of this load and I will not repeat them.


I. Who the Baptists Are

Baptists and Anabaptists: not the same people

The Baptists began in English Puritanism and not in the radical movements of Zurich or Münster. In 1609 John Smyth, a Separatist clergyman in exile in Amsterdam, became convinced that infant baptism was no true baptism. He baptized himself (by pouring) and then his congregation. A layman of that congregation, Thomas Helwys, led a small company back to England in 1612 and gathered the first Baptist church on English soil, outside London. Helwys sent King James a book pleading for liberty of conscience and died in prison about 1616. A larger, Calvinist branch of Baptists grew up in London in the 1630s and 1640s, and by 1644 they had come to insist on baptism by immersion. When seven of their congregations published a confession that year, they called themselves churches “which are commonly (but unjustly) called Anabaptists.”1 Philip Schaff, the great nineteenth-century historian of the creeds and no Baptist himself, judged that the English and American Baptists “inherited some of the principles without the eccentricities and excesses of the Continental Anabaptists and Mennonites.”2

Lutherans should hear that protest. The Augsburg Confession condemns the Anabaptists by name five times, and the Formula of Concord gives a long list of their errors, many of which no Baptist has ever held. Helwys and the Baptists after him taught that a Christian may be a magistrate, swear a lawful oath, own property, and bear arms. Baptists confess that Christ took His flesh from the Virgin Mary. In other words, a Lutheran should never call a Baptist an Anabaptist, as if he were answerable for Münster.

However, some of the condemnations do apply, because they condemn a teaching wherever it is held. The Augsburg Confession condemns “the Anabaptists, who reject the baptism of children, and say that children are saved without Baptism.”3 The Formula explains what lay behind that second clause. It rejects the teaching that unbaptized children “are not sinners before God, but righteous and innocent, and thus are saved in their innocency without Baptism, which they do not need,” because that teaching denies original sin.4 Baptists reject the baptism of children. Many of them also teach an “age of accountability,” and The Baptist Faith and Message says that people become transgressors “as soon as they are capable of moral action.”5 Particular Baptists speak differently; the 1689 Confession says that “elect infants dying in infancy are regenerated and saved by Christ through the Spirit.”6 Lutherans, for their part, do not teach that God’s mercy is shut against a child who dies before Baptism could be had. Luther wrote a letter of comfort in 1542 for mothers whose infants died unbaptized, commending such children to God, who hears the prayers of their parents.7 The condemnation does not concern God’s freedom to be merciful, but instead the claim that children have no need of Baptism because they have no sin.

The Augsburg Confession also condemns “the Anabaptists, who deny that those once justified can lose the Holy Ghost.”8 Most Baptists teach that a true believer cannot finally fall, and so this condemnation touches them too, although the perfectionism that went with it in 1530 is foreign to them. Interestingly, the first Baptist confession agreed with us here. Helwys’s Declaration of 1611 says, “Men may fall away from the grace of God, and from the truths which they have received and acknowledged.”9 The General Baptists and their American heirs, the Free Will Baptists, still teach it.

How can we keep these condemnations and still call Baptists our brothers in Christ? The Preface to the Book of Concord answers that question. Its authors write, “it is in no way our design and purpose to condemn those men who err from a certain simplicity of mind, but are not blasphemers against the truth of the heavenly doctrine, much less, indeed, entire churches,” and that they intend “to censure and condemn only the fanatical opinions and their obstinate and blasphemous teachers.”10 We condemn the rejection of infant Baptism. We do not condemn our Baptist neighbor’s heart, which only God can see.

The confessions

The Calvinist or “Particular” Baptists (so called because they taught that Christ died for the particular number of the elect) published their great confession in 1677, and in 1689 the messengers of more than a hundred churches commended it. It follows the Westminster Confession of the English Presbyterians almost word for word, except on the Church and the ordinances. Its preface says that the authors kept Westminster’s words on purpose, to show their “hearty agreement” with other Protestants “in that wholesome Protestant doctrine.”11 American Baptists adopted it in 1742, and Reformed Baptists hold it today. The General Baptists, who were Arminian (that is, they taught that Christ died for all and that grace can be resisted and lost), wrote their own.

In America the Baptists trace their beginnings to Roger Williams, the founder of Rhode Island, who gathered the first Baptist church on the continent in 1638 or 1639.12 Small and often persecuted until the Great Awakening, they grew with astonishing speed on the frontier after the Revolution. Most American Baptists came to use the shorter New Hampshire Confession (about 1833), which Schaff called “in harmony with the doctrines of older confessions, but expressed in milder form.”13 In 1845 Baptists of the slave-holding states organized the Southern Baptist Convention. Its confession, The Baptist Faith and Message, was adopted in 1925 on the pattern of the New Hampshire Confession and revised in 1963 and 2000. In 1995 the Convention repudiated slavery and racism and asked forgiveness of African Americans.14

The family today

There is no single Baptist church and Baptists would not want one. The Southern Baptist Convention has about twelve million members and baptizes about a quarter of a million people a year.15 The historically African American conventions, chief among them the National Baptist Convention, USA, and the Progressive National Baptist Convention (the convention of Martin Luther King Jr.), gave the civil rights movement much of its leadership. American Baptist Churches USA, the old Northern Baptists, is the most mainline of the Baptist bodies and ordains women; the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship gathered the moderates who left the Southern Convention in the 1990s. Thousands of independent Baptist churches belong to no convention at all. Among them the Landmark Baptists teach that only Baptist churches are true churches and keep the Table closed to all others. The Reformed Baptists hold the 1689 and the Free Will Baptists hold that a believer can fall away. Around the world the Baptist World Alliance counts about fifty-three million baptized believers.16 When I speak of “Baptist teaching” below, I mean what the 1689, the New Hampshire Confession, and The Baptist Faith and Message share, and I will say where the branches differ.

Lutherans and Baptists have met seldom in formal dialogue. The Lutheran World Federation and the Baptist World Alliance held conversations from 1986 to 1989 and published a joint report in 1990.17 In 2010 the Lutheran World Federation asked the Mennonites’ forgiveness for the persecution of the sixteenth-century Anabaptists.18 No Lutheran church in America shares the altar with a Baptist body.


II. Common Ground

We share, first of all, the authority of Holy Scripture. The 1689 begins, “The Holy Scripture is the only sufficient, certain, and infallible rule of all saving knowledge, faith, and obedience.”19 The New Hampshire Confession calls the Bible “the supreme standard by which all human conduct, creeds, and opinions should be tried.”20 The Formula of Concord confesses the Scriptures to be “the sole rule and standard according to which all dogmas together with [all] teachers should be estimated and judged.”21 When a Lutheran and a Baptist argue about Baptism, they argue about what the text says.

We share the faith of the ancient creeds. Although many Baptists do not recite the creeds in worship, their confessions teach the Holy Trinity and the true deity and humanity of Christ, His virgin birth, atoning death, bodily resurrection, and return in glory. The New Hampshire Confession confesses “three persons, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost; equal in every divine perfection.”22

In addition, we share the substitutionary atonement and justification by faith alone. The New Hampshire Confession says that Christ “by his death made a full atonement for our sins,” and that justification “is bestowed, not in consideration of any works of righteousness which we have done, but solely through faith in the Redeemer’s blood; by virtue of which faith his perfect righteousness is freely imputed to us of God.”23 The 1689 says that God justifies sinners “not for anything wrought in them, or done by them, but for Christ’s sake alone.”24 The Augsburg Confession says that men “are freely justified for Christ’s sake, through faith, when they believe that they are received into favor, and that their sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake, who, by His death, has made satisfaction for our sins.”25 On the article on which the Church stands or falls, a Lutheran and a confessional Baptist speak almost with one voice. I say “almost” because Lutherans cannot follow the 1689 in limiting the atonement to the elect; the Formula of Concord teaches that Christ died for all and that God earnestly wills all to be saved.26 Many Southern Baptists, who call themselves Traditionalists, agree with us on that point and not with the 1689.

We share a zeal for missions. The modern Protestant missionary movement is usually dated from 1792, when William Carey, an English Baptist shoemaker and pastor, persuaded his fellow ministers to form a missionary society and then sailed for India himself.

We share as well the distinction between the two kingdoms, that is, between God’s rule in the Church by the Gospel and His rule in the world by the law and the sword. However, the Baptists drew a conclusion from it that the sixteenth-century Lutherans did not. Helwys wrote to King James that the King “is but an earthly King, and he hath no authority as a King but in earthly causes.” Then he wrote words that were dangerous to write in 1612: “For men’s religion to God is betwixt God and themselves; the King shall not answer for it, neither may the King be judge between God and man. Let them be heretics, Turks, Jews, or whatsoever, it appertains not to the earthly power to punish them in the least measure.”27 In other words, the government has no right to punish anyone for his religion. The Augsburg Confession teaches that civil rulers “defend not minds, but bodies and bodily things,” and Luther taught that faith cannot be compelled by the sword.28 Although Luther taught this, the Treatise of 1537 still charged kings and princes “to see to it that errors be removed,” and some Lutheran princes did persecute Anabaptists.29 The Baptists applied the distinction more consistently than we did. “God alone is Lord of the conscience” is a phrase they took from the Westminster Confession, but they pressed it against the magistrate further than the Presbyterians did.30 The religious liberty every Lutheran congregation in this country enjoys owes more to Roger Williams, Isaac Backus, and John Leland than to Lutherans.


III. Where We Part

The font

Baptists teach that Baptism belongs only to those who profess faith and that it must be by immersion. The 1689 says that “those who do actually profess repentance towards God, faith in, and obedience to, our Lord Jesus Christ, are the only proper subjects of this ordinance,” and that “immersion, or dipping of the person in water, is necessary to the due administration of this ordinance.”31

The Baptist’s first and deepest argument is the New Covenant. Jeremiah promised a covenant unlike the old one: “I will put my law within them, and I will write it on their hearts. And I will be their God, and they shall be my people. And no longer shall each one teach his neighbor and each his brother, saying, ‘Know the LORD,’ for they shall all know me, from the least of them to the greatest” (Jeremiah 31:33–34; quoted in Hebrews 8:10–11). Under the Old Covenant the people of God were a nation by birth and the sign of circumcision went to infants. Under the New, every member knows the Lord. Therefore its sign belongs to those who confess Him. The Church should be a fellowship of those who have repented and believed. This is why the 1689 changed the Westminster Confession’s article on Baptism. Westminster calls Baptism “a sign and seal of the covenant of grace”;32 the 1689 calls it a sign of the believer’s “fellowship with him, in his death and resurrection” and drops the word “seal.”33

He adds the order of the Great Commission, “make disciples of all nations, baptizing them” (Matthew 28:19), and the pattern of Acts, where baptism follows hearing and believing every time it is described. “Those who received his word were baptized” (Acts 2:41). The Ethiopian heard “the good news about Jesus” and asked, “See, here is water! What prevents me from being baptized?” Then “they both went down into the water, Philip and the eunuch, and he baptized him” (Acts 8:35–38). For immersion he points to the Greek baptizō, which Thayer’s lexicon defines as “properly, to dip repeatedly, to immerge, submerge,”34 and above all to Paul: “Do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death? We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death” (Romans 6:3–4). Baptism is a burial and a rising and immersion shows it.

The Baptist does not deny that God can work in an infant, but instead denies that the Church may baptize on a faith it cannot hear confessed. The 1689 confesses that elect infants who die are regenerated by the Spirit, “who works when, and where, and how He pleases.”35

Lutherans baptize infants because Christ commands all nations to be baptized, because infants need what Baptism gives, and because God gives faith to them through His Word. The Apology puts the argument in a sentence: “it is very certain that the promise of salvation pertains also to little children… Therefore it is necessary to baptize little children, that the promise of salvation may be applied to them, according to Christ’s command, Matt. 28, 19: Baptize all nations.”36 Jesus did not say to make disciples by teaching them and then baptize them, but to make disciples by baptizing and teaching them. Since at least the end of the second century the Church has made disciples of adults by teaching first and of children by baptizing first. Peter attached the promise to the children: “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is for you and for your children and for all who are far off, everyone whom the Lord our God calls to himself” (Acts 2:38–39). Lydia was baptized with her household, and the jailer “was baptized at once, he and all his family” (Acts 16:33). Paul joins Baptism to circumcision: “In him also you were circumcised with a circumcision made without hands, by putting off the body of the flesh, by the circumcision of Christ, having been buried with him in baptism” (Colossians 2:11–12).

The Baptist has answers to these texts and they should be heard. The promise of Acts 2:39 is bounded by “everyone whom the Lord our God calls to himself,” and the promise in view is the gift of the Spirit, which in Acts follows repentance. In Colossians 2 he takes the circumcision “made without hands” to be the new birth, which Baptism signifies, and he notes that Paul goes on, “in which you were also raised with him through faith” (Colossians 2:12). Where Luke describes a household, he says it heard and believed: the jailer “rejoiced along with his entire household that he had believed in God” (Acts 16:34), and Crispus “believed in the Lord, together with his entire household” (Acts 18:8).

These are serious readings, but I do not think they overcome the plain sense of “you and your children,” or the need that Jesus names: “unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God. That which is born of the flesh is flesh” (John 3:5–6). As for the New Covenant, Lutherans agree that every true member of it knows the Lord. However, “they shall all know me” describes what God gives in the covenant and not a roll of members the Church can audit. The Church on earth remains mixed, as our Lord’s parables of the wheat and the weeds and of the net teach, and as the Augsburg Confession confesses.37 Infants can know the Lord, because faith is not a skill that comes with age, but trust the Holy Spirit creates through the Word. Jesus says of the children brought to Him, “to such belongs the kingdom of God. Truly, I say to you, whoever does not receive the kingdom of God like a child shall not enter it” (Mark 10:14–15), and He speaks of “these little ones who believe in me” (Matthew 18:6). The Smalcald Articles say that “even those who believe before Baptism, or become believing in Baptism, believe through the preceding outward Word, as the adults, who have come to reason, must first have heard: He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved.”38 Adults hear and then are baptized; infants are given faith in Baptism by the same Word.

On the mode, Lutherans have no quarrel with immersion. Luther wrote in The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520) that he would prefer the baptized to be fully immersed, since that fits both the word and its meaning. The Large Catechism describes Baptism as an act in which “we are sunk under the water, which passes over us, and afterwards are drawn out again,” which signifies “putting to death the old Adam, and after that the resurrection of the new man.”39 The Baptist reading of Romans 6 as a burial and rising is our reading too! What Lutherans deny is that immersion belongs to the essence of Baptism. Thayer gives a second sense of baptizō, “to wash oneself, bathe,” and cites Luke 11:38, where a Pharisee “was astonished to see that he did not first wash before dinner.”40 No one supposes the Pharisee expected Jesus to immerse Himself before eating. A Lutheran congregation could immerse every infant and adult it baptizes without changing its confession at all.

A Lutheran who joins a Baptist church is ordinarily baptized. The chief reason is not the mode, but instead that he was baptized before he could profess faith. The Baptist does not think of this as a second baptism, since in his view the first was not baptism at all; that is exactly why the 1644 churches refused the name Anabaptist, “rebaptizer.” For us it is painful, because it treats a Baptism done in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit as no Baptism.

What the water gives

Baptists call Baptism an ordinance, something Christ has commanded and the believer obeys Him by doing. The Baptist Faith and Message calls it “an act of obedience symbolizing the believer’s faith in a crucified, buried, and risen Saviour.”41 The 1689 calls it “a sign of his fellowship with him, in his death and resurrection” and “of remission of sins.”42 The Baptist’s reason is justification itself. If we are justified by faith apart from works, then the outward rite cannot be what saves. Abraham “received the sign of circumcision as a seal of the righteousness that he had by faith while he was still uncircumcised” (Romans 4:11); the sign followed the righteousness and did not give it. Paul could even say, “Christ did not send me to baptize but to preach the gospel” (1 Corinthians 1:17). Peter himself qualifies his statement that Baptism saves: it saves “not as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a good conscience” (1 Peter 3:21). The Greek word there, eperōtēma (“appeal, pledge, answer”), names something the baptized person says to God.

The Baptist does not regard the ordinances as empty. The 1689 teaches that faith is “ordinarily wrought by the ministry of the Word,” and that by the administration of baptism and the Lord’s supper it is “increased and strengthened.”43 Reformed Baptists speak of the ordinances as means of grace for believers. What no Baptist confession says is that Baptism gives the new birth or the forgiveness of sins.

Lutherans agree completely that we are justified by grace through faith and not by works. We deny that Baptism is our work, for it is God’s. The Apology defines Sacraments as “rites which have the command of God, and to which the promise of grace has been added.”44 Baptists keep Baptism faithfully because Christ commands it. The question between us is whether God has also attached His promise to it.

Scripture speaks of Baptism not only as our pledge, but also as God’s washing. Paul writes that God “saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5). There the washing is set against our works as the way God’s mercy saves. Peter writes that Baptism “now saves you” (1 Peter 3:21), and Ananias told Paul to “be baptized and wash away your sins, calling on his name” (Acts 22:16). The baptized person’s appeal and calling are there and Lutherans gladly confess them. They are not the substance of the rite, but instead the response of faith to what God gives in the water. Even Romans 6 says that we “were buried therefore with him by baptism,” so that Baptism is the means of the burial and not only its picture. The Augsburg Confession grants that the Sacraments are marks of profession. It says they were ordained “not only to be marks of profession among men, but rather to be signs and testimonies of the will of God toward us, instituted to awaken and confirm faith in those who use them.”45 The Baptist Faith and Message makes Baptism “an act of obedience symbolizing the believer’s faith”; our Confession makes it, first of all, God’s testimony to us. That reversal of direction is the difference. The Formula of Concord rejects by name the teaching “that the water of Baptism is not a means by which God the Lord seals adoption and works regeneration,” and the matching teaching about the Supper.46

Here I think the two sides misunderstand each other more than anywhere else. The Baptist hears “Baptism saves” and thinks we have made a work of it. The Lutheran hears “Baptism is an act of obedience” and thinks the Baptist has made a work of it. Both of us fear a salvation that depends on something we do. The Large Catechism answers the Baptist’s worry almost word for word: “Yes, our works, indeed, avail nothing for salvation; Baptism, however, is not our work, but God’s… God’s works, however, are saving and necessary for salvation, and do not exclude, but demand, faith.”47 As for the thief on the cross, God has bound us to Baptism, and the Holy Spirit works through it, but He has not shut His mercy where Baptism cannot be had. It is the despising of Baptism that condemns and not the lack of it.

Although the difference can sound academic, it matters most when faith is weak. A good Baptist pastor will not send a doubting member back to the day of his decision, but instead to Christ and His promises, and in that we are agreed. The Lutheran adds that God has fastened His promise to something done to us that we can point to. Therefore the Lutheran in trouble is taught to say, “Nevertheless I am baptized; but if I am baptized, it is promised me that I shall be saved and have eternal life, both in soul and body.”48 He looks away from his faith to the promise God attached to the water, for “my faith does not make Baptism, but receives it.”49 I would gently ask a Baptist brother whether that is not the comfort he wants his own people to have.

The table

Baptists call the Lord’s Supper not a sacrament, but the second ordinance. The Baptist Faith and Message calls it “a symbolic act of obedience whereby members of the church, through partaking of the bread and the fruit of the vine, memorialize the death of the Redeemer and anticipate His second coming.”50 The governing word is the Lord’s command, “Do this in remembrance of me” (Luke 22:19). The chief reason Baptists, with the Reformed, do not believe the body of Christ is present in the bread is the ascension: Christ’s human body is in heaven, “whom heaven must receive until the time for restoring all the things” (Acts 3:21). They read “This is my body” as a figure and cite John 6:63, “the flesh is no help at all.” The 1689 teaches more than a memorial. It says that worthy receivers “spiritually receive, and feed upon Christ crucified, and all the benefits of his death; the body and blood of Christ being then not corporally or carnally, but spiritually present to the faith of believers in that ordinance.”51 Reformed Baptists hold this today. In addition, a growing number of Southern Baptist scholars argue for it. Most American Baptists hold a simpler memorial view that stands close to Zwingli’s.

Lutherans confess “that the Body and Blood of Christ are truly present, and are distributed to those who eat the Supper of the Lord.”52 We take Jesus at His word: “Take, eat; this is my body… Drink of it, all of you, for this is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins” (Matthew 26:26–28). Paul asks, “The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ?” (1 Corinthians 10:16), and he warns that whoever eats unworthily “will be guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord” (1 Corinthians 11:27). Lutherans welcome the 1689’s confession that the Supper is more than a memorial. However, the Formula of Concord rejects the teaching that “the body of Christ, however, [is received] only spiritually by faith,” and confesses that it is received “not only spiritually by faith, but also orally.”53 The memorial view keeps the Supper’s proclamation of Christ’s death, which Paul names (1 Corinthians 11:26), but it denies the gift Christ says He gives there, His body and blood for the forgiveness of sins. The essay in this series on the Reformed churches takes up the Supper at length.

There is an unexpected point of agreement. The Baptist Faith and Message makes Baptism, meaning the immersion of a believer, “prerequisite to the privileges of church membership and to the Lord’s Supper,”54 and many Baptist churches still restrict the Table to members of their own or like-minded congregations. On that principle a Lutheran baptized as an infant may not, strictly speaking, commune in a Baptist church. A Baptist pastor who has fenced his own Table understands, better than many Christians, why a Lutheran pastor asks guests to speak with him before they commune.

Coming to faith

The Baptist confessions teach that the new birth is the Holy Spirit’s work. The New Hampshire Confession says that regeneration “is effected in a manner above our comprehension by the power of the Holy Spirit, in connection with divine truth,” and that repentance and faith are “sacred duties, and also inseparable graces, wrought in our souls by the regenerating Spirit of God.”55 The Baptist Faith and Message calls regeneration “a change of heart wrought by the Holy Spirit through conviction of sin, to which the sinner responds in repentance toward God and faith in the Lord Jesus Christ.”56 The 1689 teaches that God calls His elect “by His Word and Spirit,” so that “they come most freely, being made willing by His grace.”57

Baptists are also known for the public invitation at the close of the sermon, when those who wish to receive Christ are asked to come forward (to “walk the aisle”), and for the “sinner’s prayer,” in which a person asks Jesus to forgive him and come into his heart. Neither appears in the Baptist confessions. The invitation entered Baptist life with the revivals of the nineteenth century and Baptists still argue about it. In 2012 the Southern Baptist Convention affirmed the sinner’s prayer as a biblical expression of repentance and faith, while warning that it is no incantation that saves by being recited and should never be used apart from a clear presentation of the Gospel.58 Many Calvinist Baptists criticize what they call “decisionism.” The texts most often cited for the invitation are Romans 10, “if you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved” (Romans 10:9), and John 1:12, “to all who did receive him, who believed in his name, he gave the right to become children of God.” At its best the Baptist view is that the sinner hears the Gospel, the Spirit convicts and regenerates him, and he calls on Christ. The prayer is meant to give that response words, not to cause the new birth.

Lutherans also call sinners to repent and believe. The difference lies in where we tell them to look for the Spirit’s work. The Small Catechism confesses, “I believe that I cannot by my own reason or strength believe in Jesus Christ, my Lord, or come to Him; but the Holy Ghost has called me by the Gospel.”59 The Augsburg Confession says that “through the Word and Sacraments, as through instruments, the Holy Ghost is given, who works faith, where and when it pleases God, in them that hear the Gospel.”60 By the means of grace Lutherans mean the Gospel preached and the Sacraments given, through which the Spirit creates and keeps faith. Paul writes in the chapter Baptists cite, “So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ” (Romans 10:17). Every faithful invitation carries the Word of Christ. Even so, God has bound us to find His promises where He has placed them, in preaching, in Baptism, in Absolution, and in the Supper, and the Smalcald Articles insist that “God does not wish to deal with us otherwise than through the spoken Word and the Sacraments.”61

The best Baptist theology agrees that the Spirit converts sinners “in connection with divine truth,” which is to say through the Word, and the 1689 adds that the ordinances strengthen faith. The difference shows itself in two places. The first is the Sacraments, which no Baptist confession calls means by which the Spirit gives the new birth. The second is assurance. When the decision becomes the moment of salvation, the believer is tempted to look back to it for certainty, and if he is unsure whether he meant it, he may come forward again, or ask to be baptized again, and still not be sure. The Lutheran answer is not to stop calling people to faith, but to teach that faith rests on what God has done and said and not on the sincerity of our response. Reformed Baptists and confessional Lutherans could have a fruitful conversation here, because both are uneasy with a salvation that hangs on a human decision.

Kept to the end

Most Baptists teach the perseverance of the saints. The Baptist Faith and Message says, “All true believers endure to the end. Those whom God has accepted in Christ, and sanctified by His Spirit, will never fall away from the state of grace, but shall persevere to the end.”62 It adds at once that believers “may fall into sin through neglect and temptation,” grieving the Spirit and bringing judgments on themselves, “yet they shall be kept by the power of God through faith unto salvation.” The Baptist rests this on the promises of Christ: “I give them eternal life, and they will never perish, and no one will snatch them out of my hand. My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than all, and no one is able to snatch them out of the Father’s hand” (John 10:28–29). For the one who seems to fall away, he cites John: “They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would have continued with us” (1 John 2:19). The New Hampshire Confession says that “such only are real believers as endure unto the end.”63 He reads the warning of Hebrews 6:4–6, about those who “have shared in the Holy Spirit” and “then have fallen away,” either as a warning God uses to keep His own or as a description of those who were never born again.

Two different teachings go by the name “once saved, always saved,” and they should be kept apart. The confessional doctrine says that true believers endure in faith and holiness, and that one who finally abandons the faith shows he never had it. A popular teaching heard in some pulpits says that a person who once believed remains saved even if he later stops believing altogether. Calvinist Baptists reject the second as firmly as Lutherans do.

In addition, Lutherans share much of the first. We confess that perseverance is God’s gift and not our achievement, and the Formula of Concord says that God placed our salvation “in the almighty hand of our Savior Jesus Christ, from which no one can pluck us, John 10:28.”64 Even so, the difference is not small. The Augsburg Confession condemns those “who deny that those once justified can lose the Holy Ghost,” and the Smalcald Articles say that when holy men “happen to fall into manifest sins, as David into adultery, murder, and blasphemy,” then “faith and the Holy Ghost has departed from them.”65 The Smalcald Articles also reject in so many words the claim that “if any one sins after he has received faith and the Spirit, he never truly had the Spirit and faith.”66 Luther wrote against sectarians who drew a careless conclusion from it (“Do whatever you please”), and responsible Baptists do not draw it. Nevertheless, the doctrine he rejected is the one the confessional Baptist holds. Scripture warns believers that they can fall: some “believe for a while, and in time of testing fall away” (Luke 8:13), and “let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall” (1 Corinthians 10:12). When someone falls away, the Formula says, “the cause is not as though God were unwilling to grant grace for perseverance… but the cause is that they wilfully turn away again.”67

The difference reaches assurance. The 1689 grounds assurance first on “the blood and righteousness of Christ revealed in the Gospel,” and then on the inward evidence of the Spirit’s graces and the Spirit’s testimony.68 Because the inward evidences belong to that structure, a troubled Baptist is tempted to look inward and ask whether his faith was ever the real kind. A Lutheran who knows he can fall away must also ask whether he still believes. Lutherans fail here in our own way, for many a Lutheran has treated a Baptism he never remembers as a ticket that needs no faith, which is a carnal security worse than any Baptist doctrine. The Lutheran answer to both troubles is the same promise, spoken from outside, in the Word and the water, and the warning not to let go of it.

The congregation and the conscience

Baptists are congregationalists. The Baptist Faith and Message defines a church as “an autonomous local congregation of baptized believers” that “operates under the Lordship of Christ through democratic processes.”69 The 1689 says that associations of churches may advise, but their messengers “are not intrusted with any church-power properly so called.”70 The Southern Baptist Convention cannot tell a local church what to believe, although it may decline to cooperate with churches that depart from its confession.

Behind this polity stands what Baptists call soul liberty or soul competency: every person is directly accountable to God, no priest or magistrate can believe for him, and faith must be personal and free. It explains why many Baptists, though not all, have been wary of binding confessions. Francis Wayland, a nineteenth-century Baptist leader, wrote that churches share a confession “because all of them, from the study of the Scriptures, understand them in the same manner, and not because any tribunal has imposed such interpretations upon them.”71 Other Baptists have bound their teachers firmly; the Particular Baptists subscribed the 1689, and the Southern Baptist seminaries require their professors to affirm a confession. Southern Baptists fought over this very question in the struggle of 1979–2000 that conservatives call the Conservative Resurgence. Moderates appealed to soul competency for freedom from confessional accountability. In 1988 the Convention adopted a resolution on the priesthood of the believer that set limits on how the doctrine may be used.72

Lutherans have much freedom in polity, not because polity is unimportant, but because the Gospel does not prescribe one form of it. The Augsburg Confession requires for the unity of the Church agreement “concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments,” and the Formula of Concord explains that this means agreement “in the doctrine and all its articles, also in the right use of the holy Sacraments.”73 It does not require one form of church government. The Treatise teaches that “wherever the Church is, there is the authority [command] to administer the Gospel,” and so the congregation may call and ordain its ministers.74 What Lutherans add is the office of the ministry as God’s gift through which the Spirit works, and the rule “that no one should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments unless he be regularly called.”75 Baptists call and ordain their pastors and we can say so warmly. However, some Baptist churches let any member baptize or preside at the Table, and many regard ordination as the recognition of a gift and not the conferring of an office.

Soul competency is used in more than one way. If it means that no human authority can coerce faith and that every Christian may come to God through Christ alone, then Lutherans agree, and our teaching on the priesthood of all believers says as much. If it means that the individual’s reading of Scripture answers to no confession of the Church, or that the soul comes to God without His appointed means, then we must disagree. The Lutheran conscience is free from the commandments of men, not because it is bound to nothing, but because it is bound to the Word of God, which comes to us through the preaching of the Church and the Sacraments Christ gave it. Southern Baptists drew that line themselves in 1988 and I suspect most Baptists who use the phrase mean the first sense.


IV. What We Owe One Another

Although we part at the font and the Table, Lutherans have much to learn from the Baptists: 1) their zeal for the lost, 2) their love for the Bible in the hands of ordinary people, 3) their seriousness about membership, and 4) their witness to religious liberty.

Their zeal is the first lesson. Baptists believe that every person they meet needs Christ and they tell him so. Behind the quarter of a million baptisms the Southern Baptists report each year are people who were told of Christ by someone who cared whether they knew Him. Lutherans confess that the Gospel is “the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes” (Romans 1:16). We should speak it to our neighbors not grudgingly, but with the urgency of people who believe it.

In addition, their seriousness about membership is the hardest lesson for us. Lutherans baptize infants and we are right to do it. However, we have sometimes treated Baptism as a family custom and confirmation as a graduation, and we have let our rolls fill with baptized people we never see. The Baptist critique of infant Baptism is mistaken, in my judgment, but the neglect it points to is ours. The cure is not to stop baptizing children, but to teach them all their lives what their Baptism means and to call them back to it.

A word belongs here to the Lutheran whose son or daughter, husband or wife, now worships in a Baptist church. You have much to be thankful for. Christ crucified is preached there, the Bible is opened and loved, and the Holy Spirit works through that Word. If your child has been baptized again, do not despair. The first Baptism was God’s work and not ours, and God does not take back what He has given; your child’s Baptism still stands, and you may pray for him and speak with him in that confidence. If your Baptist relative cannot commune at your altar at a wedding or at Christmas, tell him it is no verdict on his faith. His own church fences its Table for reasons of its own. Ours is fenced because the Supper is a confession of what Christ gives there. Speak about these things kindly and start with what you share.


One Lord, One Baptism

Our differences on Baptism, the Supper, conversion, and perseverance cannot be cleared away by goodwill, and I believe the Lutheran Confessions have read Scripture rightly on each of them. Therefore we cannot share the altar with Baptist churches. Even so, when a Baptist preacher proclaims that Christ died for sinners and that the sinner is justified by grace through faith, he preaches the Gospel, and God’s Word does not return to Him empty.

What we can offer our Baptist brothers is what we most need ourselves. We can offer the Supper, where Christ gives His body and blood for the forgiveness of sins to the weak as well as the strong. We can offer the distinction of Law and Gospel, which keeps the call to holy living from becoming a new burden on the conscience. We can offer the historic liturgy and the Christian year, which carry the whole story of Christ to a congregation every week, whoever is preaching. Above all we can offer the promise spoken over the water, which does not depend on how well we remember the day we received it.

The Baptist and the Lutheran both love Romans 6. Both have stood at the water and seen a sinner buried with Christ and raised to walk in newness of life. Paul, who wrote that chapter, also wrote that there is “one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is over all and through all and in all” (Ephesians 4:5–6). For now we disagree about what that one Baptism is and to whom it belongs. The Lord who gave it is one. He has buried us with Himself, and He will raise us on the last day.


Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Cited as ESV.)

The Lutheran Confessions

  • Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
  • The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Preface; Augsburg Confession IV, V, VII–X, XII–XIV, XXVIII; Apology IX, XIII; Smalcald Articles III.iii, III.viii; Treatise 54, 67; Small and Large Catechisms on Baptism; Formula of Concord VII, X, XI, XII.)

Luther

  • Luther, Martin. The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520). Luther’s Works, vol. 36. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1959.
  • Luther, Martin. Temporal Authority: To What Extent It Should Be Obeyed (1523). Luther’s Works, vol. 45. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1962.
  • Luther, Martin. Comfort for Women Who Have Had a Miscarriage (1542). Luther’s Works, vol. 43. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1968.

Baptist Confessions and Documents

  • A Declaration of Faith of English People Remaining at Amsterdam in Holland. 1611.
  • Helwys, Thomas. A Short Declaration of the Mystery of Iniquity. 1612. Early English Books Online, Text Creation Partnership, A02915.
  • A Confession of Faith of Seven Congregations or Churches of Christ in London, Which Are Commonly (but Unjustly) Called Anabaptists. 1644.
  • A Confession of Faith Put Forth by the Elders and Brethren of Many Congregations of Christians (Baptized upon Profession of Their Faith). 1677; adopted 1689. (The Second London Confession.) Text at the1689confession.com.
  • The New Hampshire Confession of Faith. 1833. In Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 3.
  • The Baptist Faith and Message. Nashville: Southern Baptist Convention, 2000.
  • Southern Baptist Convention. Resolutions on racial reconciliation (Atlanta, 1995), on the priesthood of the believer (San Antonio, 1988), and on the sinner’s prayer (New Orleans, 2012).
  • Wayland, Francis. Notes on the Principles and Practices of Baptist Churches. New York, 1857.

Other Confessions

  • The Westminster Confession of Faith. 1646.

History and Ecumenical Documents

  • Schaff, Philip. The Creeds of Christendom, with a History and Critical Notes. 3 vols. New York: Harper, 1877.
  • Underhill, Edward Bean, ed. Confessions of Faith and Other Public Documents Illustrative of the History of the Baptist Churches of England in the 17th Century. London: Hanserd Knollys Society, 1854.
  • Baptist World Alliance and Lutheran World Federation. Baptists and Lutherans in Conversation: A Message to Our Churches. Geneva, 1990.
  • Lutheran World Federation. “Action on the Legacy of Lutheran Persecution of ‘Anabaptists.’” Stuttgart, 2010.

Statistics

  • Earls, Aaron. “Southern Baptists See Attendance and Baptism Gains amid Membership Declines.” Lifeway Research, May 5, 2026.
  • Baptist World Alliance. “BWA Welcomes 17 New Members.” July 10, 2025.

Reference

  • Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.

Footnotes

  1. The title of the London Confession of 1644 in its 1646 edition, as given in Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, 3 vols. (New York: Harper & Brothers, 1877; vol. 1 cited in the fourth edition, revised), 1:854. On Smyth, Helwys and the first Baptists see Schaff, 1:845–858, and Edward Bean Underhill, ed., Confessions of Faith and Other Public Documents Illustrative of the History of the Baptist Churches of England in the 17th Century (London: Hanserd Knollys Society, 1854). ↩

  2. Schaff, Creeds, 1:845. Schaff adds that claims of an unbroken Baptist succession from the Waldenses “are disputed, and no historical connection can be traced” (1:845, n. 1). ↩

  3. AC IX.3. The Augsburg Confession names the Anabaptists in Articles V, IX, XII, XVI and XVII. The Formula’s list of their errors is FC SD XII.9–27; the errors about magistracy, oaths, property and Christ’s flesh are XII.17–25. Schaff summarizes Article XXIV of the 1611 Declaration: “The duty of obedience to the magistrate is very earnestly enjoined” (1:858). ↩

  4. FC SD XII.11; compare FC Ep XII.6. ↩

  5. BF&M III. ↩

  6. 2LCF 10.3. ↩

  7. Martin Luther, Comfort for Women Who Have Had a Miscarriage (1542), in Luther’s Works, vol. 43 (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1968), paraphrased. ↩

  8. AC XII.7. The paragraph goes on to condemn “those who contend that some may attain to such perfection in this life that they cannot sin.” ↩

  9. A Declaration of Faith of English People Remaining at Amsterdam in Holland (1611), Art. VII, as quoted in Schaff, Creeds, 1:858, n. 3. ↩

  10. Preface to the Book of Concord (Triglotta). The Preface is speaking chiefly of the controversy over the Supper, and it adds the hope that such Christians, rightly taught, would agree with the Lutheran confession. ↩

  11. Preface to the Second London Confession, as quoted in Schaff, Creeds, 1:855–856. Schaff calls the confession “simply the Baptist recension of the Westminster Confession” (1:855). The Philadelphia Baptist Association adopted it in 1742. ↩

  12. Schaff, Creeds, 1:849–851, dates Williams’s rebaptism to 1638; many modern histories give 1639. ↩

  13. Schaff, Creeds, 3:742. The confession was drawn up by John Newton Brown. ↩

  14. On the founding of the Southern Baptist Convention at Augusta, Georgia, see “Southern Baptist Convention,” Encyclopaedia Britannica. The “Resolution on Racial Reconciliation on the 150th Anniversary of the Southern Baptist Convention” was adopted at Atlanta in June 1995. ↩

  15. For 2025 the Convention’s churches reported 12,331,954 members, 4,460,910 in average weekly worship, and 263,075 baptisms, in 46,608 affiliated congregations. Aaron Earls, “Southern Baptists See Attendance and Baptism Gains amid Membership Declines,” Lifeway Research, May 5, 2026. The figures are reported by the congregations themselves. ↩

  16. Baptist World Alliance, “BWA Welcomes 17 New Members,” July 10, 2025: “a fellowship of 283 conventions and unions in 138 countries and territories comprising 53 million baptized believers in 180,000 churches.” Because Baptists baptize only those who profess faith, the figure cannot be compared directly with the baptized membership of churches that baptize infants. ↩

  17. Baptists and Lutherans in Conversation: A Message to Our Churches (Geneva, 1990), the report of the joint commission of the Baptist World Alliance and the Lutheran World Federation. ↩

  18. Lutheran World Federation, Eleventh Assembly (Stuttgart, July 2010), “Action on the Legacy of Lutheran Persecution of ‘Anabaptists.’” ↩

  19. 2LCF 1.1. ↩

  20. New Hampshire Confession, Art. I, in Schaff, Creeds, 3:742. ↩

  21. FC Ep Rule and Norm 1. ↩

  22. New Hampshire Confession, Art. II. ↩

  23. New Hampshire Confession, Arts. IV and V. ↩

  24. 2LCF 11.1. ↩

  25. AC IV.1–2. ↩

  26. FC SD XI.28 ff.; FC Ep XI. ↩

  27. Thomas Helwys, A Short Declaration of the Mystery of Iniquity ([Amsterdam?], 1612), 69 (EEBO-TCP A02915), spelling modernized. The original reads: “for mens religion to God, is betwixt God and themselves; the King shall not answere for it, neither may the King be iugd betwene God and man. Let them be heretikes, Turcks, Iewes, or what soever it apperteynes not to the earthly power to punish them in the least measure.” He cites Gallio, who refused to judge “questions about words and names and your own law” (Acts 18:15). ↩

  28. AC XXVIII.11; Luther, Temporal Authority: To What Extent It Should Be Obeyed (1523), LW 45, paraphrased. ↩

  29. Tr 54: “especially the chief members of the Church, kings and princes, ought to guard the interests of the Church, and to see to it that errors be removed and consciences be healed.” ↩

  30. BF&M XVII. The sentence comes from the Westminster Confession 20.2 by way of 2LCF 21.2. ↩

  31. 2LCF 29.2, 29.4. BF&M VII defines Christian baptism as “the immersion of a believer in water in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.” ↩

  32. Westminster Confession of Faith 28.1. ↩

  33. 2LCF 29.1. ↩

  34. Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. βαπτίζω, I.1. ↩

  35. 2LCF 10.3: “Elect infants dying in infancy are regenerated and saved by Christ through the Spirit; who works when, and where, and how He pleases.” ↩

  36. Ap IX.2. ↩

  37. AC VIII; Matthew 13:24–30, 47–50. ↩

  38. SA III.viii.7. ↩

  39. LC IV.65. Compare SC IV.12–14. ↩

  40. Thayer, s.v. βαπτίζω, I.2, citing Mark 7:4 and Luke 11:38. ↩

  41. BF&M VII. ↩

  42. 2LCF 29.1. ↩

  43. 2LCF 14.1. Compare 2LCF 30.1 on the Supper as given for “confirmation of the faith of believers.” ↩

  44. Ap XIII.3. ↩

  45. AC XIII.1. ↩

  46. FC SD XII.31–32 (among the errors of the Schwenckfeldians). XII.30 rejects the teaching that the preached Word is not a means by which the Holy Ghost works. ↩

  47. LC IV.35. ↩

  48. LC IV.44. ↩

  49. LC IV.53. ↩

  50. BF&M VII. ↩

  51. 2LCF 30.7. ↩

  52. AC X.1. ↩

  53. FC Ep VII.26, VII.15. ↩

  54. BF&M VII. ↩

  55. New Hampshire Confession, Arts. VII and VIII. ↩

  56. BF&M IV. ↩

  57. 2LCF 10.1. ↩

  58. Southern Baptist Convention, “An Affirmation of a ‘Sinner’s Prayer’ as a Biblical Expression of Repentance and Faith,” resolution adopted at New Orleans, June 2012 (paraphrased). ↩

  59. SC II.6. ↩

  60. AC V.2. ↩

  61. SA III.viii.10. ↩

  62. BF&M V, quoted with the following sentence. ↩

  63. New Hampshire Confession, Art. XI. ↩

  64. FC SD XI.45. ↩

  65. AC XII.7; SA III.iii.43. ↩

  66. SA III.iii.42. ↩

  67. FC SD XI.42. ↩

  68. 2LCF 18.2. ↩

  69. BF&M VI. ↩

  70. 2LCF 26.15. ↩

  71. Francis Wayland, Notes on the Principles and Practices of Baptist Churches (New York, 1857), 13–14, as quoted in Schaff, Creeds, 1:853–854. ↩

  72. Southern Baptist Convention, resolution on the priesthood of the believer, adopted at San Antonio in June 1988 (paraphrased). ↩

  73. AC VII.2; FC SD X.31. Compare FC Ep X.7. ↩

  74. Tr 67. ↩

  75. AC XIV. ↩

Topics
Other Churches and TraditionsBaptismThe Holy Spirit
Scripture
Romans 6:4Jeremiah 31:33–34Hebrews 8:10–11Matthew 28:19Acts 2:41Acts 8:35–38Romans 6:3–4Acts 2:38–39Acts 16:33Colossians 2:11–12Acts 2:39Colossians 2:12Acts 16:34Acts 18:8John 3:5–6Mark 10:14–15Matthew 18:6Luke 11:38Romans 4:111 Corinthians 1:171 Peter 3:21Titus 3:5Acts 22:16Luke 22:19Acts 3:21John 6:63Matthew 26:26–281 Corinthians 10:161 Corinthians 11:271 Corinthians 11:26Romans 10:9John 1:12Romans 10:17John 10:28–291 John 2:19Hebrews 6:4–6John 10:28Luke 8:131 Corinthians 10:12Romans 1:16Ephesians 4:5–6Acts 18:15Matthew 13:24–30Mark 7:4
Confessions
AC IXSD XIIEp XIIAC XIIAC IVSD XIEp XIAC XXVIIIAp IXAC VIIISA IIILC IVAp XIIIAC XIIIAC XEp VIIAC VAC VIISD XEp XAC XIVSCLC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “Lutheranism and the Baptists: The Font, the Table, and the Conscience.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/lutheranism-and/baptists/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.