Wine, Cards and Christian Liberty
Alcohol, Gambling and the Weaker Brother
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“So, whether you eat or drink, or whatever you do, do all to the glory of God.” — 1 Corinthians 10:31, ESV
A Note on Citations
Bible passages are quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). Quotations from the Lutheran Confessions, the documents gathered in the Book of Concord, are from the Concordia Triglotta of 1921 and are cited by part and paragraph; the first note gives the details.1
I. Wine at a Wedding
The first sign Jesus did was a gift of wine at a wedding. The wine had run out before the feast was over, so Jesus had the servants fill six stone jars with water and carry some to the master of the feast.
“When the master of the feast tasted the water now become wine, and did not know where it came from (though the servants who had drawn the water knew), the master of the feast called the bridegroom and said to him, ‘Everyone serves the good wine first, and when people have drunk freely, then the poor wine. But you have kept the good wine until now.’ This, the first of his signs, Jesus did at Cana in Galilee, and manifested his glory. And his disciples believed in him.” (John 2:9–11)
Christians have argued over that wine for two hundred years. They come to the question from homes where no bottle was ever kept, from homes where a beer after work was as ordinary as supper, and from homes that drink has broken. The deck of cards raises a smaller form of the question, while the lottery ticket at the gas station, the office pool and the betting app on a phone raise a larger one. Where is the line? Who draws it?
A Christian may drink wine, beer and spirits with thanksgiving and a good conscience, because they are gifts of God. Drunkenness is a sin, as Scripture says without qualification. A Christian may also choose not to drink, for his own sake or for his neighbor’s; that choice deserves honor rather than mockery. However, no church may make total abstinence a law for every Christian conscience, since God has not made it one. Games of chance are not forbidden as such, for Scripture nowhere names them. Although the outward act is free, covetousness can enter any wager, and the Seventh and Tenth Commandments have much to say about gambling as it is now sold. If drink or gambling has hurt you or your family, the last section of this paper is written to you.
II. Neither Commanded nor Forbidden
The Lutheran Confessions have a name for things God has neither commanded nor forbidden. They call them adiaphora (Greek, “things indifferent”). The Formula of Concord, the last of the Lutheran confessions, written in 1577 to settle disputes among Lutherans after Luther’s death, speaks of “ceremonies or church rites which are neither commanded nor forbidden in God’s Word.”2 Its tenth article was written about the rites of the Church, and we apply it to food and drink by analogy. The analogy is an old one. Paul worked out the principle over meat sold in the market at Corinth and over clean and unclean foods at Rome, and the Augsburg Confession gives a whole article to the distinction of meats. The Apology, Melanchthon’s defense of the Augsburg Confession, applies it to our question directly: “We must also retain this doctrine, namely, that human traditions are useless services, and therefore neither sin nor righteousness should be placed in meat, drink, clothing, and like things, the use of which Christ wished to be left free.”3 In other words, a Christian is not more righteous before God because he drinks or because he does not, and no one may tell him that he is.
It is important to be careful with the word indifferent. In everyday English it can mean “unimportant” or “I do not care.” The Confessions do not mean that. A free thing is indifferent in the sense that it does not make anyone righteous before God and that God has not bound the conscience to it. It may still matter very much to the neighbor, since the way a Christian uses it may be either love or sin. A glass of wine is an adiaphoron; drunkenness is not, nor is a drink pressed on a man who is trying to stay sober.
The Confessions teach three things about such free things: 1) no one may turn them into law, 2) love governs how they are used, and 3) when someone insists that a free thing is necessary for salvation, a Christian must not give way, even in a small matter. On the first, the Formula writes that as soon as Christian liberty is weakened “and the ordinances of men [human traditions] are forced upon the Church with coercion, as though it were wrong and a sin to omit them, the way is already prepared for idolatry.”4 Paul writes, “For freedom Christ has set us free; stand firm therefore, and do not submit again to a yoke of slavery” (Galatians 5:1). On the second, he continues, “Only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another” (Galatians 5:13). The Epitome, the Formula’s short summary, asks that in free things “all frivolity and offense should be avoided, and especial care should be taken to exercise forbearance towards the weak in faith.”5 On the third, the Formula draws the line from Paul’s own conduct: “Thus Paul yields and gives way to the weak as to food and [the observance of] times or days, Rom. 14, 6. But to the false apostles, who wished to impose these upon the conscience as necessary things, he will yield not even in such things as in themselves are adiaphora.”6 Paul gave way gladly to the weak. He would not give way for a moment to those who made a free thing necessary.
III. What Scripture Says About Wine
Scripture both praises wine and warns against it. An honest reader has to hear both. The psalmist thanks the God who makes the earth fruitful.
“You cause the grass to grow for the livestock and plants for man to cultivate, that he may bring forth food from the earth and wine to gladden the heart of man, oil to make his face shine and bread to strengthen man’s heart.” (Psalm 104:14–15)
In that psalm wine stands beside bread and oil as one of God’s good gifts, given for gladness. The law of Moses told Israel to keep the feast of the tithe with “oxen or sheep or wine or strong drink” and to “rejoice, you and your household” (Deuteronomy 14:26). His enemies said of our Lord, “Look at him! A glutton and a drunkard” (Matthew 11:19), which no one would have said of a man who drank nothing. Paul told Timothy, “No longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your stomach and your frequent ailments” (1 Timothy 5:23). On the night He was betrayed Jesus gave His disciples the cup of the Passover as His blood, and He spoke of it as “this fruit of the vine” (Matthew 26:29). Paul writes, “For everything created by God is good, and nothing is to be rejected if it is received with thanksgiving, for it is made holy by the word of God and prayer” (1 Timothy 4:4–5). Luther’s explanation of the First Article in the Small Catechism counts “meat and drink” among the gifts God gives “richly and daily,” along with clothing and shoes, house and home.7
The warnings are just as clear. “Wine is a mocker, strong drink a brawler, and whoever is led astray by it is not wise” (Proverbs 20:1). Proverbs paints the drunkard better than any modern pamphlet.
“Who has woe? Who has sorrow? Who has strife? Who has complaining? Who has wounds without cause? Who has redness of eyes? Those who tarry long over wine; those who go to try mixed wine. Do not look at wine when it is red, when it sparkles in the cup and goes down smoothly. In the end it bites like a serpent and stings like an adder.” (Proverbs 23:29–32)
The New Testament is sharper still. Paul writes, “And do not get drunk with wine, for that is debauchery, but be filled with the Spirit” (Ephesians 5:18). Drunkenness stands in his list of the works of the flesh, with the warning “that those who do such things will not inherit the kingdom of God” (Galatians 5:21). It appears again among the sins of those who “will not inherit the kingdom of God,” and then comes the Gospel: “And such were some of you. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God” (1 Corinthians 6:10–11).
What, then, is drunkenness? This is drinking until judgment, speech or self-control is given over to the drink. Scripture sets no number of glasses; a Christian should not look for one. However, the sin begins well before a man falls down, as Proverbs shows of those who “tarry long” over wine. A Christian whose conscience troubles him after a wedding toast or a third glass need not settle the question alone, since he may bring it to confession and hear the absolution. The Augsburg Confession teaches that every Christian “ought to train and subdue himself with bodily restraints, or bodily exercises and labors, that neither satiety nor slothfulness tempt him to sin, but not that we may merit grace or make satisfaction for sins by such exercises.” For this it cites our Lord’s word in Luke 21:34, “Take heed lest your hearts be overcharged with surfeiting,” that is, with excess of food and drink.8 Luther did not soften the matter for his own Saxons. In the Large Catechism he counts among those who desecrate the Lord’s day those who “lie in taverns and are dead drunk like swine.”9
Although Scripture never commands total abstinence, it does know of people who did not drink. The Nazirite vowed that “he shall separate himself from wine and strong drink” (Numbers 6:3) for the time of his vow. The Rechabites kept their father Jonadab’s command, “You shall not drink wine, neither you nor your sons forever” (Jeremiah 35:6). God held up their faithfulness as a rebuke to Judah, although He did not lay their rule on Israel. Kings were warned, “it is not for kings to drink wine, or for rulers to take strong drink, lest they drink and forget what has been decreed and pervert the rights of all the afflicted” (Proverbs 31:4–5). An overseer of the Church must be “sober-minded, self-controlled… not a drunkard” (1 Timothy 3:2–3). In every one of these cases the abstinence was not a law for all of God’s people, but a vow, a family’s rule, or the demand of a particular office.
IV. The Case for Total Abstinence
Many Christians whom Lutherans love and respect do not drink at all and believe that no Christian should. Their position has a history and reasons drawn from Scripture.
John Wesley’s General Rules of 1743, still printed in the United Methodist Book of Discipline, forbid “buying or selling spirituous liquors, or drinking them, unless in cases of extreme necessity.”10 Spirituous liquors were distilled spirits, and the rule did not forbid wine or beer. Total abstinence came later. In the 1780s the Philadelphia physician Benjamin Rush still commended cider, beer and wine “taken only at meals and in moderate quantities.” By 1900, as the historian Jennifer Woodruff Tait writes, the average American Protestant understood temperance to mean “total abstinence from all alcohol.”11 The temperance preachers were answering a crisis. Americans of the eighteenth century drank on average about seven gallons of pure alcohol a year; after decades of temperance preaching the figure had fallen to about one by 1848. Grape juice kept in the ordinary way would ferment within weeks. In 1869 a Methodist dentist named Thomas Welch found a way to keep it from fermenting, so that his church could give the Lord’s Supper without alcohol. When the Methodists required grape juice at the Supper in 1916, many other Protestant churches soon followed.12
The abstaining churches build their case on the same texts of love that this paper uses. The Church of the Nazarene writes in its Manual: “In light of the Holy Scriptures and human experience concerning the ruinous consequences of the use of alcohol as a beverage, and in light of the findings of medical science regarding the detrimental effect of both alcohol and tobacco to the body and mind, as a community of faith committed to the pursuit of a holy life, our position and practice is abstinence rather than moderation.” It continues, “Holy Scripture teaches that our body is the temple of the Holy Spirit,” and it adds, “The widespread incidence of alcohol abuse in our world demands that we embody a position that stands as a witness to others.” Among its texts are Romans 14:15–21 and 15:1–2, 1 Corinthians 10:31–33, and Galatians 5:13–14.13 The Southern Baptist Convention in 2006 cited the harm alcohol does to health, to families and on the highways, and the road from drinking to addiction. It declared its “total opposition to the manufacturing, advertising, distributing, and consuming of alcoholic beverages.”14 The United Methodist Church now urges those who drink “to do so wisely and in moderation,” but it still acknowledges “the historic United Methodist stance on abstinence as a safeguard against mental, physical, and spiritual harms caused by excessive drinking.”15
Put in their own terms, the strongest argument runs like this. Paul wrote, “It is good not to eat meat or drink wine or do anything that causes your brother to stumble” (Romans 14:21). About one American in ten has an alcohol use disorder. No one can tell which guest at the table is fighting it or which child will become an alcoholic. Where the weaker brother is everywhere and often hidden, love’s counsel has to become a standing practice, and a church may covenant together to keep it. The body is the temple of the Holy Spirit. In addition, a Christian’s example teaches his children and his neighbors. Many add that the wine of the ancient world was commonly mixed with water and that distilled liquor was unknown. Some, like William Patton in Bible Wines (1871), went further. Patton found that some texts praise wine and others condemn it. He asked, “Must there not have been two kinds of wine?” He answered that the wine Scripture blesses was unfermented juice and the wine it condemns was intoxicating.16 Not every abstaining Christian holds that view.
Lutherans should agree with much of this. Drunkenness is a sin and its harms are very great. A Christian who never drinks has chosen a good thing. Paul’s words in Romans 14:21 are true. In addition, Lutherans have too often answered the temperance movement with a joke about beer and let the alcoholic in our own pews hide behind that joke while his family paid for it.
However, the two-wine reading does not fit the texts. Paul rebukes the Corinthians because at the Lord’s Supper some went hungry while others got drunk: “One goes hungry, another gets drunk” (1 Corinthians 11:21). The cup on that table could make a man drunk. At Pentecost the mockers said of the apostles, “They are filled with new wine” (Acts 2:13); even new wine was known to intoxicate. Our Lord was called a drunkard. Before Welch there was no practical way to keep the juice of the late-summer harvest from fermenting until Passover in the spring. Mixing with water made wine weaker, but it was still wine that could make a man drunk, as Ephesians 5:18 assumes.
The argument from love is the stronger one. Paul himself answers it.
“Eat whatever is sold in the meat market without raising any question on the ground of conscience. For ‘the earth is the Lord’s, and the fullness thereof.’ If one of the unbelievers invites you to dinner and you are disposed to go, eat whatever is set before you without raising any question on the ground of conscience. But if someone says to you, ‘This has been offered in sacrifice,’ then do not eat it, for the sake of the one who informed you, and for the sake of conscience—I do not mean your conscience, but his. For why should my liberty be determined by someone else’s conscience?” (1 Corinthians 10:25–29)
In other words, Paul tells the strong to eat what is set before them without asking questions, and to abstain when someone speaks up for the sake of that person’s conscience. Love yields to the brother who is present or known, not to every brother who might possibly be at the table. Paul also forbids the one who abstains to judge the one who eats: “Let not the one who eats despise the one who abstains, and let not the one who abstains pass judgment on the one who eats, for God has welcomed him” (Romans 14:3). A rule for every Christian table would take away the freedom Paul guards in the very chapter in which he asks the strong to yield. A congregation that knows recovering alcoholics are among its members should take that seriously, and the next section says how.
The Nazarene Manual calls its standards “guides and helps to holy living” and speaks of “the collective Christian conscience.” It does not teach that abstinence earns salvation. I take it at its word.17 The difference between us is narrower. May a church make a member’s private table, in a matter God has left free, a condition of membership? The Confessions allow a congregation to order free things according to its circumstances, for good order and Christian discipline, and they say that usages “which may be observed without sin” ought to be kept.18 A congregation may decide not to serve alcohol at its youth events, or expect sobriety of those who serve at the altar. However, the Formula does not allow a church to impose a free thing on the conscience as necessary, and the Apology will not place sin or righteousness in meat and drink. I believe that a rule which binds the private table of every member as a condition of belonging crosses that line, whatever the intention of those who made it.
One more difference touches the altar. The Nazarene Manual directs, “Only unfermented wine should be used in the sacrament of the Lord’s Supper.” For Lutherans the wine is not ours to change, because it is what our Lord took and blessed when He instituted His Supper, “this fruit of the vine.” What Christ instituted is not an adiaphoron.19 Section VI says what this means for the Christian in recovery.
V. Who Is the Weaker Brother?
The phrase “weaker brother” has become a weapon in church arguments. Someone says, “You are causing me to stumble,” and means, “I do not approve of what you are doing.” Paul did not mean that. It is important to see what he did mean.
In Romans 14 the weak brother is a Christian whose conscience is not yet persuaded that a free thing is free. “One person believes he may eat anything, while the weak person eats only vegetables” (Romans 14:2). Paul does not call him a hypocrite or a legalist. He calls him a brother “for whom Christ died” (Romans 14:15) and tells the church to “welcome him, but not to quarrel over opinions” (Romans 14:1). The danger Paul sees is not that the weak man will be annoyed, but that he will be led by the example of a stronger Christian to do what his own conscience still condemns. To the Corinthians Paul writes,
“But take care that this right of yours does not somehow become a stumbling block to the weak. For if anyone sees you who have knowledge eating in an idol’s temple, will he not be encouraged, if his conscience is weak, to eat food offered to idols? And so by your knowledge this weak person is destroyed, the brother for whom Christ died.” (1 Corinthians 8:9–11)
The reason this destroys him is that “whatever does not proceed from faith is sin” (Romans 14:23). To stumble in Paul’s sense is to be drawn into sin against one’s own conscience, and perhaps away from Christ. For that brother Paul will give up anything: “Therefore, if food makes my brother stumble, I will never eat meat, lest I make my brother stumble” (1 Corinthians 8:13). “We who are strong have an obligation to bear with the failings of the weak, and not to please ourselves. Let each of us please his neighbor for his good, to build him up” (Romans 15:1–2). The Formula writes that Paul teaches in Romans 14 “how we can yield and give way with a good conscience to the weak in faith in such external adiaphora.”20
The weaker brother is not the Christian who is merely displeased. He may need patient teaching, although he is in no danger of sinning because someone else had a glass of wine. Neither is he the Christian who insists that everyone keep his rule. To him Paul would not yield “even for a moment” (Galatians 2:5), because yielding would teach that the rule is necessary. A Lutheran who is the guest of Christians who do not drink will gladly drink what they serve; the Apology writes that “for love’s sake we do not refuse to observe adiaphora with others.”21 However, if he were told that drinking is itself a sin, or that a faithful Christian must sign a pledge, he would have to say kindly that his Lord has not asked it of him.
Luther, arguing in 1522 that images should not be destroyed merely because some abused them, put the principle bluntly: “Again, wine and women bring many a man to misery and make a fool of him. Shall we, therefore, kill all the women and pour out all the wine?”22 The cure for drunkenness is not to pour out all the wine, but to preach repentance to the drunkard and to love the brother who might be harmed.
Who, then, is the weaker brother today? He may be a young Christian from an abstaining home who would feel he had betrayed Christ if he drank, or a new believer just out of a life of heavy drinking who is not yet sure where the line is. The man or woman in recovery from alcoholism is not Paul’s weak brother in the strict sense. His conscience about drink may be the clearest in the room. The word “weak” says nothing against his faith or his courage. What he faces is harder, a body and mind that drink can take captive again. By analogy, however, the love Paul commands reaches him with greater force (Romans 14:21; 15:1–2). The Fifth Commandment points the same way, since Luther writes that we are to “neither use nor assent to any kind of means or methods whereby any one may be injured.”23 A Christian host who knows that a guest is fighting to stay sober will put the wine away without being asked and without making a show of it. Those who lead young people should not drink in front of them. A pastor, who must be “not a drunkard,” will remember that his example is watched.
VI. Drunkenness, Addiction and the Gospel
Alcohol does great harm. According to the 2024 National Survey on Drug Use and Health, nearly 28 million Americans aged twelve and older, about one in ten, had an alcohol use disorder in the past year. Excessive drinking caused about 178,000 deaths a year in 2020 and 2021.24
The Church has sometimes spoken about drunkenness as though it were only a choice, while the medical world sometimes speaks about addiction as though it were only a disease. Scripture holds both together. Drunkenness is a sin for which the drunkard is responsible before God. In addition, Scripture knows that sin enslaves. Peter writes, “For whatever overcomes a person, to that he is enslaved” (2 Peter 2:19). Paul cries out under the weight of his own flesh, “Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death? Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord!” (Romans 7:24–25). Luther writes in the Large Catechism that “in the flesh we dwell and carry the old Adam about our neck, who exerts himself and incites us daily to inchastity, laziness, gluttony and drunkenness, avarice and deception.”25 The pull toward the bottle is one of the ways the old Adam works in all of us, and no Christian is so strong that he could not fall.
Therefore, a Christian caught in addiction needs the Law and the Gospel, in that order. The Law tells him the truth about what his drinking is doing to him, to his family, and to his faith; many alcoholics already know that truth better than the pastor does. Above all he needs the Gospel. Christ died for drunkards along with the rest of us sinners, and Paul could write to a church that included former drunkards, “And such were some of you. But you were washed.” The absolution is spoken to the alcoholic who confesses his sin as truly as to anyone else. It does not wait for him to have been sober for a year. I believe the help of doctors, counselors, and recovery groups is also God’s gift, as surely as medicine for any other illness, and a Christian should not be ashamed to use it. God has promised, “No temptation has overtaken you that is not common to man. God is faithful, and he will not let you be tempted beyond your ability, but with the temptation he will also provide the way of escape, that you may be able to endure it” (1 Corinthians 10:13).
Christ also feeds the one who is fighting. Luther writes that the Lord’s Supper “is given for a daily pasture and sustenance, that faith may refresh and strengthen itself so as not to fall back in such a battle.” He goes on, “If, therefore, you are heavy-laden and feel your weakness, then go joyfully to this Sacrament and obtain refreshment, consolation, and strength. For if you would wait until you are rid of such burdens, that you might come to the Sacrament pure and worthy, you must forever stay away.”26 In other words, the Supper is food for the man in the fight and not a test of his sobriety. A Christian in recovery who is worried about the wine should speak with his pastor before he comes to the altar. Together they can find a way for him to receive the Sacrament without endangering his sobriety.
The hardest moment may come after the first absolution, when he drinks again months later. A man who falls will be tempted to read 1 Corinthians 10:13 as an accusation, as though God had given him a way out and he had refused it. Luther teaches every Christian to answer that temptation from his Baptism: “Therefore our Baptism abides forever; and even though some one should fall from it and sin, nevertheless we always have access thereto, that we may again subdue the old man.” He adds, “Repentance, therefore, is nothing else than a return and approach to Baptism.”27 A relapse does not undo a man’s Baptism. It sends him back to it, and back to the absolution, as often as he falls, and the congregation should not keep score.
VII. Cards, Dice and the Lottery
Gambling is staking money or something of value on an outcome decided mostly by chance, in the hope of winning what others lose. It is very old; the soldiers at the foot of the cross cast lots for Jesus’ clothing (John 19:24). Although Scripture never names gambling as a sin, the casting of lots it describes was usually something different. “The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD” (Proverbs 16:33). Israel divided the land by lot. The apostles chose Judas’s replacement by lot: “And they cast lots for them, and the lot fell on Matthias” (Acts 1:26). In these cases the lot was a way of leaving a decision to God, not a wager.
Many Christians who do not object to wine do object to gambling. The United Methodist Church writes, “Gambling, as a means of acquiring material gain by chance and at the neighbor’s expense, is a menace to personal character and social morality,” and it adds that gambling “serves as a ‘regressive tax’ on those with lower income.”28 The Church of the Nazarene asks its members to avoid “Lotteries and other forms of gambling, whether legal or illegal,” because “the final result of these practices is detrimental both to the individual and society.”29 The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod’s Commission on Theology and Church Relations studied the question in 1996. According to a 2011 summary in The Lutheran Witness, the report found that Scripture does not address gambling directly but named six dangers: gambling encourages greed and covetousness, mismanages what God has entrusted to us, undermines reliance on God for His provision, works against a commitment to productive work, is potentially addictive, and threatens the welfare of the neighbor and the common good.30 Scripture stands behind each of these. “Wealth gained hastily will dwindle, but whoever gathers little by little will increase it” (Proverbs 13:11). Paul warns,
“But those who desire to be rich fall into temptation, into a snare, into many senseless and harmful desires that plunge people into ruin and destruction. For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evils.” (1 Timothy 6:9–10)
A Lutheran weighs gambling by the Commandments. The Seventh Commandment says, “You shall not steal” (Exodus 20:15). Luther writes that “to steal is nothing else than to get possession of another’s property wrongfully, which briefly comprehends all kinds of advantage in all sorts of trade to the disadvantage of our neighbor.”31 Although a friendly game in which everyone agrees to the stakes and can afford to lose them is not theft, the commercial gambling business is built on the certainty that the players as a whole will lose. The National Council on Problem Gambling estimates that about one percent of American adults have a severe gambling problem in a given year and another two or three percent a milder one.32 A business that profits from the neighbor’s compulsion takes “advantage … to the disadvantage of our neighbor,” and this is a Seventh Commandment matter for those who build and run it. In addition, the man who gambles away the rent has stolen from his own wife and children.
The Ninth and Tenth Commandments reach the heart. Luther writes that they “are especially directed against envy and miserable avarice,” and that they command “that we do not desire our neighbor’s damage, nor even assist, nor give occasion for it, but gladly wish and leave him what he has.”33 Covetousness can enter any wager. In a friendly game the stake is the agreed price of an evening’s play; no one is stripped, and the loser is not the target. When a man wants his neighbor’s loss, or plays to get what he has not worked for, the same game has become sin. The outward act is free; the heart is where it turns. The First Commandment goes deeper still. Luther writes, “That now, I say, upon which you set your heart and put your trust is properly your god.” He goes on, “Many a one thinks that he has God and everything in abundance when he has money and possessions; he trusts in them and boasts of them,” and he calls Mammon “the most common idol on earth.”34 The lottery sells exactly this hope, that one ticket might lift a person out of every trouble. “Keep your life free from love of money, and be content with what you have, for he has said, ‘I will never leave you nor forsake you’” (Hebrews 13:5). When Luther listed the disorders flooding the Germany of his day in the preface to the Smalcald Articles, he named “gluttony, gambling, idle display” together.35
Where, then, is the line? The Law speaks to the business built on the neighbor’s compulsion and to the heart that covets. The player’s occasional, affordable stake, a game of cards for small stakes or a lottery ticket bought now and then for fun, is free. My counsel concerns the habit and the industry, not the single ticket. Since the Supreme Court allowed the states to legalize sports betting in 2018, the betting app has put a casino in every pocket.36 For that reason I counsel most Christians to leave the casino, the betting app and the lottery alone, and I ask anyone who gambles to ask himself honestly why he does it, how much he loses, and whether he could stop. This is counsel, not a commandment. Whether the state should raise money by selling lottery tickets is a question for Christians as citizens (see Render to Caesar).
VIII. Help and Comfort
Whether you drink a glass of wine with thanksgiving or have chosen not to drink at all, you stand before God on one ground, the righteousness of Christ. The one who drinks should watch his own heart, since drunkenness rarely announces itself, and be quick to put the bottle away for a brother. The one who abstains should not judge the one who drinks, “for God has welcomed him,” and no one should mock his choice or press a drink on him.
The Christian who is already in recovery owes no one an explanation for the glass of water in his hand. His sobriety is not a sign of weaker faith; it is a gift of God and a fight he keeps fighting, and the congregation should guard it with him. Whether he tells others of his recovery is his to decide, because his story is his own.
The one who cannot stop is neither alone nor beyond the reach of Christ. Tell your pastor. He will not be shocked. What you confess to him he will keep to himself, and he will speak the forgiveness of sins to you. Get help from those who know how to give it. Come to the Lord’s Supper as one of the heavy-laden for whom it was given.
Husbands and wives, parents, brothers and sisters, and children of those who drink or gamble too much carry a burden of their own. What you have suffered is neither imaginary nor your fault. “The LORD is near to the brokenhearted and saves the crushed in spirit” (Psalm 34:18). The absolution is for you as well, for the resentment you carry and the words said in anger. Paul’s call to “Bear one another’s burdens” (Galatians 6:2) does not mean hiding the trouble, paying every debt, or pretending all is well. Protecting yourself and your children is not a failure of love.
Debt from gambling is serious. The mercy of God is greater. Confess it, tell your family the truth, and get help to stop. Our Lord says, “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28).
Conclusion
Wine is a gift of God and drunkenness is a sin against Him. A Christian may drink with thanksgiving or abstain with a good conscience. No church may bind every member’s table where God has left it free, although a congregation may order its own common life for good order and love. The weaker brother is the one our example might lead into sin. By analogy, the brother in recovery is the one it might lead into danger. For their sake we gladly give up what we are free to enjoy. Although the stake itself is free, covetousness can turn any wager into sin, while a business built on the neighbor’s compulsion stands under the Seventh Commandment. I share the grief of our Methodist, Nazarene and Baptist brothers and sisters over what drink has done to families, and I honor their zeal for a holy life. However, Christ has set the Christian conscience free, and only His Gospel can make the heart new. He gives that Gospel to drinkers and abstainers alike in His body and blood, given and shed for the forgiveness of sins.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture and Confessions
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
- Kolb, Robert, and Timothy J. Wengert, eds. The Book of Concord. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000.
Luther
- Luther, Martin. Eight Sermons Preached at Wittenberg in Lent, 1522. Translated by A. Steimle. In Works of Martin Luther (Philadelphia Edition), vol. 2. Philadelphia: A. J. Holman.
Other Churches
- Church of the Nazarene. Manual of the Church of the Nazarene. Covenant of Christian Conduct, ¶¶28–29. Text posted by Northwest Nazarene University, November 2023.
- Commission on Theology and Church Relations. Gambling. St. Louis: The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, 1996.
- Joersz, Jerald C. “Gambling.” The Lutheran Witness, December 2011.
- Southern Baptist Convention. “On Alcohol Use in America.” Resolution, June 2006.
- The United Methodist Church. The Book of Discipline of The United Methodist Church. Nashville: United Methodist Publishing House. (The General Rules.)
- The United Methodist Church. The Book of Resolutions of The United Methodist Church 2020/2024. “Gambling.”
- The United Methodist Church. The Social Principles of The United Methodist Church. As adopted 2024.
History
- Patton, William. Bible Wines; or, The Laws of Fermentation and Wines of the Ancients. New York: National Temperance Society, 1871.
- Tait, Jennifer Woodruff. “Raise a Juice Box to the Temperance Movement.” Christian History 125 (2018).
Statistics and Law
- National Council on Problem Gambling. “FAQ.” ncpgambling.org.
- National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. “Alcohol Facts and Statistics.” niaaa.nih.gov.
- Murphy v. National Collegiate Athletic Association, 584 U.S. 453 (2018).
Footnotes
-
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version. The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the English text of the Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church (St. Louis: Concordia, 1921), and cited by the standard abbreviations: AC (Augsburg Confession), Ap (Apology of the Augsburg Confession), SA (Smalcald Articles), SC and LC (Small and Large Catechisms), and FC Ep and FC SD (Formula of Concord, Epitome and Solid Declaration). Paragraph numbers follow the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; the Apology is numbered as in the Triglotta and Tappert. Luther’s Wittenberg sermons of 1522 are quoted from the translation by A. Steimle in Works of Martin Luther (Philadelphia Edition), vol. 2. The statements of other churches are quoted from their own published texts, named in the notes. ↩
-
FC Ep X.1. FC SD X.1 adds that such rites are introduced “with a good intention, for the sake of good order and propriety, or otherwise to maintain Christian discipline.” ↩
-
Ap XXVIII.7. The Apology continues by citing Matthew 15:11 and Romans 14:17, “The kingdom of God is not meat and drink.” AC XXVI is the article “Of the Distinction of Meats.” ↩
-
FC SD X.15. ↩
-
FC Ep X.5, citing 1 Corinthians 8:9 and Romans 14:13. The printed Triglotta reads “especial”; the online transcription of the Triglotta at bookofconcord.org reads “special.” ↩
-
FC SD X.13. The Formula’s “time of confession” (FC Ep X.6; FC SD X.10–11) concerns enemies who would suppress the pure doctrine; in matters of private conduct it applies by analogy. ↩
-
SC II, First Article. The explanation of the Fourth Petition likewise defines daily bread as “Everything that belongs to the support and wants of the body, such as meat, drink, clothing, shoes” (SC III, Fourth Petition). ↩
-
AC XXVI.33–35. The Triglotta’s English quotes only the first half of Luke 21:34 (“surfeiting”); the ESV renders the verse, “But watch yourselves lest your hearts be weighed down with dissipation and drunkenness and cares of this life.” ↩
-
LC I.96. In the First Petition Luther counts among those who profane God’s name “those who are called Christians and the people of God” who are “adulterers, drunkards, misers, envious, and slanderers” (LC III.41). ↩
-
The Nature, Design, and General Rules of Our United Societies (1743), “First: By doing no harm,” in The Book of Discipline of The United Methodist Church, as published at umc.org (“The General Rules of the Methodist Church”). ↩
-
Jennifer Woodruff Tait, “Raise a Juice Box to the Temperance Movement,” Christian History 125 (2018). Rush’s phrase is quoted from his “temperance thermometer” as Tait gives it. Tait gives 7.1 gallons of absolute alcohol per person a year for eighteenth-century Americans, about five by 1835, three by 1840, and one by 1848. ↩
-
Tait, “Raise a Juice Box.” She dates the first successful batch to 1869 and notes that American Methodists had urged “the pure juice of the grape” at the Supper since 1864 and required grape juice in 1916. On Moses Stuart’s Scriptural View of the Wine Question (1849) and the “two-wine theory,” see the same article. ↩
-
Manual of the Church of the Nazarene, Covenant of Christian Conduct, ¶29.5, from the text of the Covenant posted by Northwest Nazarene University (November 2023). The wording is the same as in the Manual 2017–2021. ↩
-
Southern Baptist Convention, “On Alcohol Use in America” (Greensboro, North Carolina, June 2006), at sbc.net. The resolution also gives as a reason that “some religious leaders … are now advocating the consumption of alcoholic beverages based on a misinterpretation of the doctrine of ‘our freedom in Christ.’” Resolutions of the Convention express the messengers’ judgment and do not bind Baptist congregations. ↩
-
The Social Principles of The United Methodist Church (as adopted by the General Conference of 2024), “The Social Community,” Other Social Issues, A. “Substance Abuse, Alcohol and Tobacco,” at umc.org. ↩
-
William Patton, Bible Wines; or, The Laws of Fermentation and Wines of the Ancients (New York: National Temperance Society, 1871; repr. Fort Worth: Star Bible Publications), 11. ↩
-
Manual of the Church of the Nazarene, Covenant of Christian Conduct, ¶28.2, from the same text. ↩
-
FC SD X.9 (the congregation’s “good right, power, and authority” to order such things “according to its circumstances”); AC XV.1. On what may not be done, FC SD X.15 and Ap XXVIII.7. ↩
-
Manual of the Church of the Nazarene, ¶29.5. FC Ep X.1 and FC SD X.1 define adiaphora as things “neither commanded nor forbidden in God’s Word”; the Supper is commanded. See also Freedom and Form in Worship, on the Supper given according to Christ’s institution as not ours to change. ↩
-
FC SD X.9, citing Romans 14, Acts 16:3, 21:26, and 1 Corinthians 9:19. ↩
-
Ap XV.52. ↩
-
Martin Luther, Eight Sermons Preached at Wittenberg in Lent, 1522, Fourth Sermon, in Works of Martin Luther (Philadelphia Edition), vol. 2. ↩
-
LC I.188, on the Fifth Commandment. ↩
-
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, “Alcohol Use Disorder (AUD) in the United States: Age Groups and Demographic Characteristics” (updated August 2025), reporting the 2024 NSDUH: 27.9 million people aged 12 and older (9.7 percent). NIAAA, “Alcohol-Related Emergencies and Deaths in the United States” (updated March 2026): about 178,000 deaths a year from excessive alcohol use in 2020 and 2021. ↩
-
LC III.102, on the Sixth Petition. ↩
-
LC V.24, 72–73. ↩
-
LC IV.77, 79. ↩
-
The Book of Resolutions of The United Methodist Church 2020/2024, “Gambling,” at umc.org. The 2024 Social Principles add that the church rejects gambling “because it focuses society’s attention on the acquisition of monetary goods at the exclusion of all else and enriches a small minority at the expense of the larger majority” (“The Social Community,” Other Social Issues, E. “Gambling”). ↩
-
Manual of the Church of the Nazarene, Covenant of Christian Conduct, ¶29.2, from the same text. ↩
-
Commission on Theology and Church Relations, Gambling (St. Louis: The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, February 1996), as summarized by Jerald C. Joersz, “Gambling,” The Lutheran Witness (December 2011). Joersz adds that the Synod’s 1998 convention encouraged pastors and lay leaders to study the report (Resolution 326, “To Address the Issue of Gambling”). ↩
-
LC I.224. Luther goes on to say that the commandment requires us “not only to do no injury to his neighbor, nor to deprive him of gain… but faithfully to preserve his property for him, to secure and promote his advantage” (LC I.233). ↩
-
National Council on Problem Gambling, “FAQ,” at ncpgambling.org: about 2.5 million adults (1 percent) meet the criteria for a severe gambling problem in a given year, and another 5–8 million (2–3 percent) have mild or moderate problems. ↩
-
LC I.310, 309. ↩
-
LC I.3, 5–6. ↩
-
SA Preface.12. ↩
-
Murphy v. National Collegiate Athletic Association, 584 U.S. 453 (2018), decided May 14, 2018. The National Council on Problem Gambling (“FAQ”) notes that some form of legal gambling is now available in forty-eight states and the District of Columbia, Hawaii and Utah being the exceptions. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Wine, Cards and Christian Liberty: Alcohol, Gambling and the Weaker Brother.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/wine-cards-and-christian-liberty/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.