Papers · Essays

Must Christians Tithe?

Money, Debt and the Generous Heart

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“For you know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though he was rich, yet for your sake he became poor, so that you by his poverty might become rich.” — 2 Corinthians 8:9, ESV


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the Concordia Triglotta of 1921 and cited by part and paragraph.1


I. A Tenth of Everything

The first tithe in the Bible was given on a road. Abram was coming home from rescuing his nephew Lot, with the plundered goods of Sodom recovered and behind him, when a priest-king came out to meet him:

“And Melchizedek king of Salem brought out bread and wine. (He was priest of God Most High.) And he blessed him and said, ‘Blessed be Abram by God Most High, Possessor of heaven and earth; and blessed be God Most High, who has delivered your enemies into your hand!’ And Abram gave him a tenth of everything.” (Genesis 14:18–20)

Thousands of years later the tenth is still with us and Christians still ask about it. Is a Christian bound by God to give ten percent of his income? Is the member who cannot give ten percent, because the credit card bill comes first, displeasing God every Sunday the plate goes by? There is also a question that is seldom asked aloud. Is the pastor who preaches on giving simply asking for his own salary? I am aware that a pastor who writes about giving to the church is writing, in part, about his own living, and I will come to that directly rather than hide it.

I will give my answer first. A Christian is not bound by God’s Law to give a tenth. The tithe was part of the law God gave Israel for its life in the land, for the support of the Levites, the sanctuary, and the poor, and it belonged to the Levitical order that was fulfilled in Christ. What has not ended is the duty beneath it. Christians are bound to support the ministry of the Word among them, to help the neighbor in need, and to pay what they owe. How much each one gives is left to faith and love. The New Testament asks for giving that is generous, proportionate, regular, and cheerful, and many Christians have found the tithe a good guide for doing that. However, a guide is not a law and no one may make it one. If you are behind on your bills and ashamed of what you put in the plate, the last section before the conclusion is written to you, and it is a kind word.


II. The Tithe in Israel

Before Moses we meet the tithe twice. Abram gives a tenth of the spoils to Melchizedek, and Jacob, fleeing from Esau and sleeping on a stone at Bethel, makes a vow, “And of all that you give me I will give a full tenth to you” (Genesis 28:22). At Sinai the tenth became law for the whole nation. “Every tithe of the land, whether of the seed of the land or of the fruit of the trees, is the LORD’s; it is holy to the LORD” (Leviticus 27:30). The law of Moses used the tithe for three purposes. The first was to support the tribe of Levi, which received no land of its own when Canaan was divided. “To the Levites I have given every tithe in Israel for an inheritance, in return for their service that they do, their service in the tent of meeting” (Numbers 18:21). The second was a festival tithe. Deuteronomy tells the Israelite to bring the tithe of grain, wine, and oil to the place God would choose and to eat it there with his household, “that you may learn to fear the LORD your God always” (Deuteronomy 14:23). The third was a tithe for the poor, gathered every third year:

“At the end of every three years you shall bring out all the tithe of your produce in the same year and lay it up within your towns. And the Levite, because he has no portion or inheritance with you, and the sojourner, the fatherless, and the widow, who are within your towns, shall come and eat and be filled, that the LORD your God may bless you in all the work of your hands that you do.” (Deuteronomy 14:28–29)

Scholars disagree about how these laws fit together, whether there were two or three separate tithes and how often each was given.2 What is not in dispute is the setting. The tithe was paid in grain, wine, oil, and livestock, from land that God had given to the tribes as their inheritance. It supported a priesthood descended from Aaron and a sanctuary in the place God chose. It could even be bought back for money at a price of one-fifth more (Leviticus 27:31). The tithe belonged to the life of Israel in its land under the covenant of Sinai.

The prophet Malachi preached to that nation after the exile, when the temple had been rebuilt and the people had grown careless. His words are the ones most often heard in sermons on the tithe:

“Will man rob God? Yet you are robbing me. But you say, ‘How have we robbed you?’ In your tithes and contributions. You are cursed with a curse, for you are robbing me, the whole nation of you. Bring the full tithe into the storehouse, that there may be food in my house. And thereby put me to the test, says the LORD of hosts, if I will not open the windows of heaven for you and pour down for you a blessing until there is no more need.” (Malachi 3:8–10)

Israel was withholding what God’s Law required and there was no food in God’s house because of it. God calls that robbery, because the tenth was His before it was ever brought; it was “holy to the LORD.” Although the passage begins with a rebuke, it begins with mercy before that, “For I the LORD do not change; therefore you, O children of Jacob, are not consumed” (Malachi 3:6). The promise of the open windows of heaven is the promise of a God who wants His people to trust Him with their harvest and who will not let them starve for doing it.


III. Why Many Christians Teach the Tithe Today

The teaching that the tithe still binds believers is held in many Baptist and other evangelical churches and by the Seventh-day Adventists. They hold it because of what they read in Scripture. The Southern Baptist Convention adopted a resolution in 2013 that begins, “Biblical stewardship is a generous response of loving obedience that constitutes an essential part of our worship of God (2 Corinthians 9:6–7).” It goes on to say that “Tithing predates the Law of Moses,” that “The Scripture equates failure to tithe with robbing God (Malachi 3:8),” that “Christ affirmed the tithe (Matthew 23:23),” and that “Proportional giving of at least a tithe is expected by God throughout Scripture.” It then exhorts Southern Baptists “to tithe cheerfully and give sacrificially” and commends “those who tithe faithfully in loving obedience to God.”3 The Convention’s confession of faith, the Baptist Faith and Message, speaks of “a binding stewardship” in all of a Christian’s possessions and gives its standard in words very close to Paul’s own: “According to the Scriptures, Christians should contribute of their means cheerfully, regularly, systematically, proportionately, and liberally for the advancement of the Redeemer’s cause on earth.” Its proof texts run from Genesis 14 and Malachi 3 to 1 Corinthians 16 and 2 Corinthians 8–9.4

The Seventh-day Adventists confess, “We acknowledge God’s ownership by faithful service to Him and our fellow human beings, and by returning tithe and giving offerings for the proclamation of His gospel and the support and growth of His church.” They add that “Stewardship is a privilege given to us by God for nurture in love and the victory over selfishness and covetousness.” Their church’s explanation draws a line that matters to the whole argument: “Tithe is not the same as offering. Tithes are the first ten percent of our income,” while an offering is “anything you choose to give beyond your tithe.” It also applies the tithe to the ministry directly: “Tithe was designed to support the priesthood. Today, that means pastors.”5

The heart of their case is the word the Adventists use, returning. Leviticus says the tithe “is the LORD’s; it is holy to the LORD.” On this reading the tenth is not a gift at all, because it never belonged to us; we give offerings from what is ours, but we return the tithe to its Owner. This is why Malachi can call withholding it robbery and why the resolution can speak of “the biblical command to tithe” while also calling for cheerful giving.

In addition, the tithe is older than Moses. Abram gave it centuries before Sinai and Jacob vowed it at Bethel, so if it began before the ceremonial law it cannot have ended with the ceremonial law. Also, Jesus affirmed it. When He rebuked the Pharisees for tithing their garden herbs while neglecting justice, mercy, and faithfulness, He did not tell them to stop tithing. “These you ought to have done, without neglecting the others” (Matthew 23:23). Hebrews contrasts the Levites, who were mortal, with Melchizedek, to whom Abraham gave his tenth, “In the one case tithes are received by mortal men, but in the other case, by one of whom it is testified that he lives” (Hebrews 7:8), and since Christ is a priest “after the order of Melchizedek” (Hebrews 7:17) some read this to mean that the living Christ still receives His people’s tithes. Paul grounds the support of ministers on the temple pattern. “Do you not know that those who are employed in the temple service get their food from the temple, and those who serve at the altar share in the sacrificial offerings? In the same way, the Lord commanded that those who proclaim the gospel should get their living by the gospel” (1 Corinthians 9:13–14). The temple workers lived from the tithe and Paul says “in the same way.” Lastly, the New Testament never lowers God’s standard. Jesus told His disciples that their righteousness must exceed that of the scribes and Pharisees (Matthew 5:20), and the Pharisee in the temple could say, “I give tithes of all that I get” (Luke 18:12). How could a Christian, who has received far more than any Pharisee, give less? On this reading the tenth is not a ceiling but a floor from which the Christian begins. The argument is an old one. Thomas Aquinas made it in the thirteenth century from the same verse and Augustine made it eight centuries before him.6

On almost all of this Lutherans agree. God claims all we have, the Lord has commanded that those who preach the Gospel be supported, and Christians who have been given everything in Christ should not be stingy. Regular, planned, proportionate giving is better than giving whatever happens to be left at the end of the month. The question between us is narrower, whether the number ten is a command of God that binds the Christian conscience.


IV. Does the Tenth Bind the Christian?

How a Christian reads any command of Moses begins with Christ, for “Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to everyone who believes” (Romans 10:4). In The Law in Three Parts I set out the Church’s old distinction within the Law of Moses. The ceremonial law (the sacrifices, the priesthood, the sanctuary, the feasts, and the rules of clean and unclean) was a shadow fulfilled in Christ. The civil law was the constitution of Israel as a nation in its land and does not bind other nations. The moral law, God’s eternal will written on every heart and summarized in the Ten Commandments, remains. The Augsburg Confession teaches that “since the Gospel has been revealed, all the ceremonies of Moses can be omitted.”7

Where does the tithe belong? Our Confessions answer that question themselves. When the Apology (Melanchthon’s defense of the Augsburg Confession) sorts the sacrifices of the Old Testament, it names among the Levitical thank-offerings “the oblation, the drink-offering, thank-offerings, first-fruits, tithes.”8 The tithe stood with the firstfruits and the drink offering in Israel’s worship. It supported the Levitical priesthood and the sanctuary, and it was paid from the produce of the inheritance God gave the tribes, which belongs to Israel’s civil order. Thomas Aquinas, who defended the tithe as strongly as anyone, agreed on the decisive point. He held that the people’s duty to support those who minister to them is moral law, but that the proportion of a tenth “does not belong to the natural law” and was fixed for Israel because the tribe of Levi had no land of its own. In his day the Church required the tithe by its own law. He added that the Church could set “some other proportion” if times required.9 Here Aquinas differs from those today who hold the tenth binding by God’s own command. In other words, the duty to support the ministry is moral law and the tenth was Israel’s particular way of keeping it.

What, then, of the argument that the tenth is the Lord’s and is returned to Him? The answer is not that God owns less than the tithing churches say, but that He owns more. “The earth is the LORD’s and the fullness thereof” (Psalm 24:1). When Israel brought its great offering for the temple, David prayed, “For all things come from you, and of your own have we given you” (1 Chronicles 29:14). The Small Catechism has every Christian confess that God has given him “house and homestead… and all my goods.”10 It is important to see what the New Testament does with this. It never divides a holy tenth from a common nine-tenths, as though the first belonged to God and the rest to us. Paul asks the Christian to present his whole body “as a living sacrifice” (Romans 12:1), and the Macedonians, he writes, “gave themselves first to the Lord” (2 Corinthians 8:5). The Christian returns everything, his paycheck and his time and his body, and gives from it as faith and love direct. Therefore the Law does accuse a Christian about money, and sharply. Of a people who will not provide for the ministers of the Word, Luther writes, “In this we also deserve that God deprive us of His Word and blessing.”11 However, the Law accuses him for withholding love from God and neighbor, not for missing a percentage that the New Testament never sets.

The other arguments can be met more briefly. It is true that the tithe is older than Moses. However, so are circumcision (Genesis 17) and animal sacrifice (Genesis 4 and 8), and both were taken up into the covenant at Sinai and fulfilled in Christ.12 A practice is not made moral law by being old. Neither tithe before Moses was commanded. Abram’s tenth was given once, from the spoils of a war. He kept none of the rest for himself and told the king of Sodom, “I would not take a thread or a sandal strap or anything that is yours” (Genesis 14:23). Jacob’s tenth was a vow he chose to make, with conditions attached (Genesis 28:20–22). Aquinas himself observes that before the Law no portion was fixed and “each man of his own accord gave him what he deemed right.”13 These are beautiful examples of faith thanking God and a Christian may follow them freely. Although Jesus did tell the Pharisees not to neglect the tithe, He was speaking to men who lived under the Law of Moses while the temple still stood. He also told the leper He had healed, “go, show yourself to the priest and offer the gift that Moses commanded” (Matthew 8:4), and no Christian thinks that verse obliges us to bring a sacrifice to a priest. Christ was “born under the law, to redeem those who were under the law” (Galatians 4:4–5) and kept it and taught others under it to keep it. What He presses in Matthew 23:23 is not the tenth, but the weightier matters of justice, mercy, and faithfulness, which the Pharisees had left undone while they counted their herbs.14

Hebrews 7 mentions Abraham’s tithe to show that Melchizedek was greater than Abraham, and so greater than Levi, who was “still in the loins of his ancestor” when the tithe was paid (Hebrews 7:10). The writer uses the tithe as proof of rank and nowhere tells his readers to give a tenth to Christ. A few verses later he draws a conclusion about the whole Levitical system. “For when there is a change in the priesthood, there is necessarily a change in the law as well” (Hebrews 7:12). The law that gave tithes to Levi is the law that has been changed, and Hebrews 7:8, which looks back on the meeting of Abraham and Melchizedek, cannot carry by itself a command that no apostle states. Paul’s “in the same way” in 1 Corinthians 9 is about support, not about a percentage. In that chapter he argues from a soldier’s pay, a farmer’s vineyard, and the ox treading grain, and in none of them does he name a proportion. What is common to all of them is that a worker lives from his work.

The argument from Matthew 5:20 has a pastoral truth in it and Augustine put it memorably. A Christian should not use his freedom as a reason to give less. However, the righteousness that exceeds that of the Pharisees is not a larger tithe, but the righteousness of faith which Christ gives and the love that comes from it. The Pharisee in the temple, who tithed everything, went home unjustified, while the tax collector who brought nothing but his sin went home justified (Luke 18:14). That parable should make every tither and every non-tither slow to measure faithfulness by a percentage.

What weighs most with me is the silence of the apostles. When the council at Jerusalem decided what to require of Gentile believers, it laid on them “no greater burden than these requirements: that you abstain from what has been sacrificed to idols, and from blood, and from what has been strangled, and from sexual immorality” (Acts 15:28–29). The tithe is not among them and Paul writes two whole chapters on giving in 2 Corinthians without naming the tenth. The earliest Christian writers did not treat the tenth as binding either. The Didache, a church manual from about the end of the first century, tells Christians to give their firstfruits to the prophets “for they are your high priests,” but names no proportion.15 Irenaeus, writing around A.D. 180, says that Christ asked for more than the tithe, not less, “instead of the law enjoining the giving of tithes, [He told us] to share all our possessions with the poor.”16 Later Fathers did urge the tenth on Christians. Cyprian lamented that “we do not even give the tenths from our patrimony,” and Augustine told his hearers to set aside “a tenth if you choose, though that is but little.”17 From the sixth century councils began to require it, and by Aquinas’s day it was the Church’s law throughout the West.18 Even then, as Aquinas shows, it was required as the Church’s ordinance and not as an apostolic command.

Therefore, the tenth is not a command of God for the Church. The Augsburg Confession settles what may be required of Christians in such things. “Since, therefore, ordinances instituted as things necessary, or with an opinion of meriting grace, are contrary to the Gospel, it follows that it is not lawful for any bishop to institute or exact such services,” for “it is necessary that the doctrine of Christian liberty be preserved in the churches.”19 The same article leaves a congregation free to make arrangements for good order, provided no one teaches “that consciences be bound to judge them necessary services, and to think that it is a sin to break them without offense to others.”20 The principle was stated about church ordinances, but it applies here by the same reasoning. A congregation may commend the tithe as a goal and a Christian may adopt it gladly. If the tenth were God’s command, the member who gives less would be robbing God, as the resolution says, and this is exactly where a Lutheran must say that God has not bound him.


V. What the New Testament Asks Instead

A Christian who hears that the tithe does not bind him may conclude that he has been let off. The New Testament does not ask for less than Moses, but for something different, giving that comes from the Gospel and is measured by love. Too often Lutherans have heard “you are not under the tithe” as “you may give whatever is convenient,” and our giving has sometimes shown it. The fullest teaching is in 2 Corinthians 8 and 9, where Paul asks the Corinthians to finish a collection for the poor believers in Jerusalem. He begins with the churches of Macedonia, which were poor themselves:

“We want you to know, brothers, about the grace of God that has been given among the churches of Macedonia, for in a severe test of affliction, their abundance of joy and their extreme poverty have overflowed in a wealth of generosity on their part. For they gave according to their means, as I can testify, and beyond their means, of their own accord, begging us earnestly for the favor of taking part in the relief of the saints—and this, not as we expected, but they gave themselves first to the Lord and then by the will of God to us.” (2 Corinthians 8:1–5)

Paul calls their giving a “grace” (charis), the same word he uses for God’s grace in Christ, and he calls the Corinthians’ collection an “act of grace” (8:6–7). He will not command it. “I say this not as a command, but to prove by the earnestness of others that your love also is genuine” (8:8). Instead he gives them a reason, which is Christ. “For you know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though he was rich, yet for your sake he became poor, so that you by his poverty might become rich” (8:9). The Son of God emptied Himself for us and we have been made rich by His poverty, with forgiveness, life, and salvation. From that center Paul draws out the marks of Christian giving. It is proportionate, “For if the readiness is there, it is acceptable according to what a person has, not according to what he does not have” (8:12). It is regular and planned. He had already written to Corinth, “On the first day of every week, each of you is to put something aside and store it up, as he may prosper” (1 Corinthians 16:2). In addition, it is willing and cheerful:

“The point is this: whoever sows sparingly will also reap sparingly, and whoever sows bountifully will also reap bountifully. Each one must give as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver. And God is able to make all grace abound to you, so that having all sufficiency in all things at all times, you may abound in every good work.” (2 Corinthians 9:6–8)

The Greek word for cheerful is hilaros, from which we get “hilarious.” God does not want a gift wrung out of us. The Formula of Concord, the last of the Lutheran confessions (1577), explains in what sense good works are “necessary” and draws the distinction this whole question needs: the word means “a necessity of Christ’s ordinance, command, and will, and of our obligation, but not a necessity of coercion.”21 Then it quotes this very verse: “the people of the New Testament are to be a willing people, Ps. 110:3, and sacrifice freely, Ps. 54:6, not grudgingly or of necessity, but are to be obedient from the heart, 2 Cor. 9:7; Rom. 6:17. For God loveth a cheerful giver.”22 A few lines later it rejects the opposite error, that good works are “free to believers in the sense that it were optional with them to do or to omit them.”23 Giving is neither optional for a Christian nor extracted from him; it is the fruit of a heart the Holy Spirit has made willing.

Paul ends the collection chapters not with the Corinthians’ generosity but with God’s, “Thanks be to God for his inexpressible gift!” (2 Corinthians 9:15). Luther puts the same order into the Small Catechism. God has given me body and soul, clothing and shoes, house and homestead, “and all my goods,” and He has done it “out of pure, fatherly, divine goodness and mercy, without any merit or worthiness in me; for all which I owe it to Him to thank, praise, serve, and obey Him.”24 The Apology calls such works “eucharistic sacrifices” (sacrifices of thanksgiving) and writes that they “are not satisfactions for those making them… For they are made by those who have been reconciled.”25 An offering does not purchase anything from God, but thanks Him for what Christ has already purchased.

What, then, is the Christian bound to do? He is bound to support those who teach him the Word and to help his neighbor in need. The Seventh Commandment forbids taking what is our neighbor’s, but Luther writes in the Large Catechism (his longer catechism for pastors and heads of households) that it also commands “that we advance and improve his possessions, and in case he suffers want, that we help, communicate, and lend both to friends and foes.”26 Paul tells the thief to stop stealing and work instead, “so that he may have something to share with anyone in need” (Ephesians 4:28). The duty to give is firm, although the amount is left to each Christian’s faith and love.

Many Lutherans have found the tithe a good starting point for proportionate giving. It is simple to reckon, it has a long history among God’s people, and it teaches us to give first rather than last, as Proverbs counsels, “Honor the LORD with your wealth and with the firstfruits of all your produce” (Proverbs 3:9). For some Christians ten percent is a stretch that teaches them to trust God, and for others it is far too little. Zacchaeus gave half his goods to the poor (Luke 19:8). The widow at the temple treasury gave two small coins, and Jesus said she had given more than all the rich, “For they all contributed out of their abundance, but she out of her poverty put in all she had to live on” (Luke 21:4). The Lord does not measure a gift by its size or its percentage, but sees the faith that gave it. A congregation may therefore teach the tithe as a goal and encourage members to grow toward it, provided it is taught as a guide and not as law, and never as the mark of a higher grade of Christian. The difference shows in how we speak to the one who falls short. If he is told that he is a thief because his gift was nine percent and not ten, the tithe has become law. If he is told that God gave His Son for him and invited to grow in the grace of giving, it has remained a guide.


VI. The Congregation and Its Pastor

Scripture is clear that a congregation owes its pastor a living. “Let the one who is taught the word share all good things with the one who teaches” (Galatians 6:6). Paul tells Timothy that elders “who labor in preaching and teaching” are worthy of double honor. He quotes both Moses and Jesus, “You shall not muzzle an ox when it treads out the grain,” and, “The laborer deserves his wages” (1 Timothy 5:18). The Small Catechism’s Table of Duties (the list of Bible verses at the back of the catechism that gives each calling its duties) gathers these verses under the heading “What the Hearers Owe to Their Pastors,” in the older English of the King James Bible: “Even so hath the Lord ordained that they which preach the Gospel should live of the Gospel… Let him that is taught in the Word communicate unto him that teacheth in all good things.”27 In other words, God has ordered that those who preach the Gospel be supported by those who hear it.

Luther was sharp with congregations that ignored this. In the preface to the Large Catechism he complains of people who “are content to let the parishes decay and become desolate, and pastors and preachers to suffer distress and hunger.”28 In his explanation of the Fourth Commandment he writes that those who would be Christians are obligated to provide for those who minister to their souls, and that “God is willing to add to you sufficient blessing and will not let you come to want.”29 I have written more fully on what a congregation owes its pastor in Stewards of the Mysteries of God. The support of the ministry is not a fee for religious services, but the fellowship of people who have received one Gospel and share it together. In addition, the pastor’s support is only one purpose of the offering. The congregation’s gifts also keep a place for the Word to be preached and the Sacraments given; send the Gospel beyond its own walls; train future pastors; and care for the poor, including the poor in its own pews. The Levites shared the third-year tithe with the sojourner, the fatherless, and the widow, and Paul’s great collection was for poor believers in another city. For his part, a pastor must not be “a lover of money” (1 Timothy 3:3). This is why a pastor who preaches on giving should preach Christ first and money second and should never preach the Law about money in order to fill a budget.


VII. Owe No One Anything

Many households, including many in our pews, carry more debt than they can comfortably pay.30 They want to give and cannot, because so much of each paycheck is already spoken for. What does Scripture say about debt? It does not say that all borrowing is sin. The Law of Moses regulated lending to the poor and forbade charging them interest (Exodus 22:25) and ordered a release of debts every seventh year (Deuteronomy 15:1–2). Jesus Himself commands, “Give to the one who begs from you, and do not refuse the one who would borrow from you” (Matthew 5:42). If lending can be an act of love, then borrowing cannot be a sin in itself. A family that takes a mortgage it can repay, or a student who borrows for training in a vocation, has not broken God’s Law.

Paul’s command “Owe no one anything, except to love each other” (Romans 13:8) is often read as a ban on all debt. In context it follows directly on “Pay to all what is owed to them” (Romans 13:7). Its point is that a Christian keeps his obligations, so that the only debt left standing is the debt of love, which can never be paid off. What Scripture does forbid is borrowing without intending or being able to repay. “The wicked borrows but does not pay back, but the righteous is generous and gives” (Psalm 37:21). The Large Catechism counts it as theft under the Seventh Commandment when we wrong our neighbor “by curtailing, forestalling, and withholding his possessions and property.”31 To run up a debt we know we cannot pay is to take our neighbor’s money under another name. Scripture also warns that debt is a kind of bondage even when it is lawful. “The rich rules over the poor, and the borrower is the slave of the lender” (Proverbs 22:7). Christians who have been set free by Christ should be slow to hand their freedom over to a lender. Proverbs gives this as wisdom and not as a command.

Underneath both reckless debt and stingy giving there is often one sickness of the heart. Paul names it in his letter to Timothy:

“But godliness with contentment is great gain, for we brought nothing into the world, and we cannot take anything out of the world. But if we have food and clothing, with these we will be content. But those who desire to be rich fall into temptation, into a snare, into many senseless and harmful desires that plunge people into ruin and destruction. For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evils.” (1 Timothy 6:6–10)

Luther saw that this is a First Commandment matter before it is a Seventh Commandment matter. A god, he writes in the Large Catechism, is that “upon which you set your heart and put your trust.” Then he gives the commonest example. “Many a one thinks that he has God and everything in abundance when he has money and possessions; he trusts in them and boasts of them with such firmness and assurance as to care for no one. Lo, such a man also has a god, Mammon by name, i.e., money and possessions, on which he sets all his heart, and which is also the most common idol on earth.” He adds that the one who has money feels secure and the one who has none despairs, “as though he knew of no God.”32 The rich man who trusts his money and the poor man who is terrified for lack of it are tempted by the same idol. Jesus puts the whole matter in a sentence, “You cannot serve God and money” (Matthew 6:24). Against that idol God sets His promise. “Keep your life free from love of money, and be content with what you have, for he has said, ‘I will never leave you nor forsake you’” (Hebrews 13:5). Paul tells Timothy to charge the rich “not to be haughty, nor to set their hopes on the uncertainty of riches, but on God, who richly provides us with everything to enjoy” (1 Timothy 6:17). Every Christian prays for daily bread. The Small Catechism teaches us to pray it so that God “would lead us to know it, and to receive our daily bread with thanksgiving.”33


VIII. When the Plate Comes By

What should a pastor say to the member who is deep in debt and ashamed to put so little in the plate? First of all, he should speak the Gospel. Your standing before God has never rested on your giving. Christ became poor for you and you are rich in Him whatever your bank statement says. Much debt is not the fruit of sin at all. If yours came from a hospital bill, a layoff, a divorce you did not want, or the care of a parent, there is nothing to confess, only a burden to carry, and your congregation should help you carry it. This is what the Seventh Commandment means when it tells us to “help, communicate, and lend” to the neighbor in want, and the neighbor in the next pew is the first of them. If the debt came from foolishness or greed, confess it, and hear the absolution, for the blood of Jesus covers that sin too. Either way, make a plan with your family to pay what you owe, because your creditors are your neighbors and the Seventh Commandment protects them, and ask your pastor or a trusted member of the congregation to help with the plan.

May you give nothing for a while? Paul writes that a gift “is acceptable according to what a person has, not according to what he does not have,” and he did not want the Corinthians eased at the expense of others or burdened beyond what they had (2 Corinthians 8:12–13). A Christian who has nothing to spare after feeding his family and paying his creditors does not sin by giving nothing for a season. Many find that a small gift, even a very small one, is a good confession of trust in the God who provides, and I would encourage it, but it is not a debt you owe. I would rather you give a little faithfully, or nothing for now, and pay your bills, than borrow in order to give. As your burden lightens, let your giving grow.

The Christian who has tithed for years should keep doing it if it is his joy and should not let anyone tell him that his faithfulness is legalism. However, he should not measure his fellow members by it or suppose that God loves him more for it, since the widow’s two coins weighed more in the Lord’s sight than all the gifts of the rich. The Christian who has a steady income and has simply never thought much about giving, who drops in whatever is in his wallet, can ask himself the questions Paul asks. Do I give regularly, in proportion to what God has given me? Do I give first, or from whatever is left? Is my giving a thank offering for the One who became poor for me? Here the Law does speak, as Luther spoke to those who would not support the Word, and the answer is not a percentage but repentance and a new beginning; a percentage that stretches his trust in God is a good place to begin. Those who serve on church councils and stewardship committees should put the Gospel before the budget and teach giving as the fruit of grace and the tithe as a goal, never as a threat. Although Malachi 3 belongs in the pulpit, it should not be used as a lever on the consciences of Christians to whom Christ has already opened the windows of heaven.


Conclusion

I have argued that the tithe was part of the law God gave Israel for its life in the land of promise, for the support of the Levites, the sanctuary, and the poor, and that it does not bind the Christian conscience as a command of God. What does bind us is older and deeper than the tithe. We owe our neighbor what we have borrowed from him and help when he is in need; we owe those who teach us the Word a share of all good things; and we owe God thanks, praise, service, and obedience for everything He has given. Within that freedom one Christian may give a tenth with a glad heart and another may give more or less, and neither may judge the other.

I hope that those of us who can will give more than we do now, and that those who cannot will give what they can without shame. Both hopes rest not on the number ten but on the Priest “after the order of Melchizedek” (Hebrews 7:17), who did not receive a tenth from us but gave Himself for us entirely, and who still sets bread and wine before His people.


Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture and Confessions

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.
  • Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
  • Kolb, Robert, and Timothy J. Wengert, eds. The Book of Concord. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000.

The Early and Medieval Church

  • Augustine. Expositions on the Psalms. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 8. New York: Christian Literature, 1888.
  • Cyprian. On the Unity of the Church. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 5. Buffalo: Christian Literature, 1886.
  • The Didache, or Teaching of the Twelve Apostles. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 7. Buffalo: Christian Literature, 1886.
  • Irenaeus. Against Heresies. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1. Buffalo: Christian Literature, 1885.
  • Thomas Aquinas. Summa Theologiae. Translated by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province. 2nd ed. London: Burns Oates & Washbourne, 1920–1925.
  • Fanning, William. “Tithes.” In The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 14. New York: Robert Appleton, 1912.

Church Statements

  • Southern Baptist Convention. “On Tithing, Stewardship, and the Cooperative Program.” Resolution, Houston, Texas, 2013.
  • Southern Baptist Convention. The Baptist Faith and Message. 2000.
  • Seventh-day Adventist Church. Fundamental Beliefs, no. 21, “Stewardship.”

Data

  • Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Center for Microeconomic Data. Quarterly Report on Household Debt and Credit, 2026: Q3. November 2026.

Footnotes

  1. Scripture is quoted from The Holy Bible, English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Augsburg Confession; Ap, Apology of the Augsburg Confession; SC and LC, Small and Large Catechism; FC SD, Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF), and Thomas Aquinas from the English Dominican translation of the Summa Theologiae. ↩

  2. Jewish tradition counted a first tithe for the Levites, a second tithe eaten at the sanctuary, and a poor tithe that replaced the second tithe in the third and sixth years of each seven-year cycle. Some modern scholars think Numbers and Deuteronomy describe one tithe from different periods. The point made here does not depend on settling the question. ↩

  3. Southern Baptist Convention, “On Tithing, Stewardship, and the Cooperative Program,” resolution adopted at Houston, Texas, June 11–12, 2013. The full clause reads: “Tithing predates the Law of Moses (Genesis 14:20; 28:22; Hebrews 7:2) and is affirmed in the Old Testament (Numbers 18: 21–24) as well as in the New Testament (Luke 11:42).” The resolution also reports that Southern Baptists then gave about 2.5 percent of annual income to their churches, which it calls a reason “to teach and faithfully obey the biblical command to tithe.” ↩

  4. The Baptist Faith and Message (2000), Article XIII, “Stewardship.” The full phrase is “a binding stewardship in their possessions.” The proof texts also include Leviticus 27:30–32, Matthew 23:23, and Matthew 6:19–21. ↩

  5. Seventh-day Adventist Church, Fundamental Belief 21, “Stewardship,” and the church’s explanation “What Is Biblical Stewardship?” (adventist.org). ↩

  6. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 87, a. 1: the Church established the tithe “lest the people of the New Law should give less to the ministers of the New Testament than did the people of the Old Law to the ministers of the Old Testament; for the people of the New Law are under greater obligations, according to Matthew 5:20.” Augustine, Exposition on Psalm 147 13 (NPNF 1/8): “He whose righteousness you ought to exceed, gives a tenth: you give not even a thousandth.” ↩

  7. AC XXVIII.59. ↩

  8. Ap XXIV.21. The Apology lists these as the Old Testament’s “eucharistic sacrifices” (thank-offerings), as distinct from the sin-offerings. ↩

  9. Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 87, a. 1. Aquinas writes that the duty to support the ministers of worship is “partly moral and instilled in the natural reason,” but that “the fixing of the proportion to be offered to the ministers of divine worship does not belong to the natural law, but was determined by divine institution, in accordance with the condition of that people to whom the law was being given,” because the tribe of Levi “had no possessions whence to derive a livelihood.” He concludes that “man’s obligation to pay tithes arises partly from natural law, partly from the institution of the Church; who, nevertheless, in consideration of the requirements of time and persons might ordain the payment of some other proportion.” ↩

  10. SC II.2. ↩

  11. LC I.163. In the paragraphs before, Luther writes that Christians “are under obligation in the sight of God” to provide for those who minister to their souls (LC I.161). ↩

  12. Seventh-day Adventists hold that the seventh-day Sabbath, also older than Moses (Genesis 2:3), remains a binding ordinance of creation. Lutherans do not, for the reasons given in The Law in Three Parts (AC XXVIII.57–60); the argument here does not rest on that question. ↩

  13. Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 87, a. 1, reply to objection 3. ↩

  14. Aquinas reads “These you ought to have done” the same way: “i.e. during the time of the Law” (Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 87, a. 2, reply to objection 3). ↩

  15. Didache 13 (ANF 7). The Didache also says that “a true teacher is himself worthy, as the workman, of his support” and, where there is no prophet, tells the giver to “give it to the poor.” ↩

  16. Irenaeus, Against Heresies IV.13.3 (ANF 1). The bracketed words are the translator’s. Irenaeus calls these precepts “not [the injunctions] of one doing away with the law, but of one fulfilling, extending, and widening it among us.” ↩

  17. Cyprian, On the Unity of the Church 26 (ANF 5); Augustine, Exposition on Psalm 147 13 (NPNF 1/8). ↩

  18. The earliest church legislation on tithes is usually traced to the letter of the bishops at Tours (567) and the Council of Mâcon (585). See William Fanning, “Tithes,” The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 14 (New York: Robert Appleton, 1912). ↩

  19. AC XXVIII.50–51. ↩

  20. AC XXVIII.53–54. AC XXVIII.56 repeats the qualification: “or to judge that they sin when they break them without offense to others.” ↩

  21. FC SD IV.16. ↩

  22. FC SD IV.17–18. ↩

  23. FC SD IV.20. ↩

  24. SC II.2. ↩

  25. Ap XXIV.25. ↩

  26. LC I.251. ↩

  27. SC, Table of Duties, “What the Hearers Owe to Their Pastors,” citing 1 Corinthians 9:14 and Galatians 6:6; the section also lists 1 Timothy 5:17–18 and Hebrews 13:17. The Triglotta prints this section in square brackets, and its historical introduction judges that it is “probably not from Luther,” since it does not appear in the German editions and was first printed in the Latin translation (Concordia Triglotta, Historical Introductions, 89). The verses are Scripture, and LC I.161–163 makes the same point in Luther’s own words. ↩

  28. LC, Preface 6. ↩

  29. LC I.161. In the next paragraph Luther complains that people “cannot now support one respectable preacher, where formerly they filled ten fat paunches” (LC I.162). ↩

  30. In the third quarter of 2026 American households owed about $19.1 trillion, including about $1.29 trillion on credit cards (Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Quarterly Report on Household Debt and Credit, press release of November 10, 2026). ↩

  31. LC I.250. ↩

  32. LC I.3, 5–8. ↩

  33. SC III.12 (Fourth Petition). ↩

Scripture
2 Corinthians 8:9Genesis 14:18–20Genesis 28:22Leviticus 27:30Numbers 18:21Deuteronomy 14:23Deuteronomy 14:28–29Leviticus 27:31Malachi 3:8–10Malachi 3:62 Corinthians 9:6–7Malachi 3:8Matthew 23:23Hebrews 7:8Hebrews 7:171 Corinthians 9:13–14Matthew 5:20Luke 18:12Romans 10:4Psalm 24:11 Chronicles 29:14Romans 12:12 Corinthians 8:5Genesis 17Genesis 4Genesis 14:23Genesis 28:20–22Matthew 8:4Galatians 4:4–5Hebrews 7:10Hebrews 7:12Luke 18:14Acts 15:28–292 Corinthians 8:1–51 Corinthians 16:22 Corinthians 9:6–82 Corinthians 9:15Ephesians 4:28Proverbs 3:9Luke 19:8Luke 21:4Galatians 6:61 Timothy 5:181 Timothy 3:3Exodus 22:25Deuteronomy 15:1–2Matthew 5:42Romans 13:8Romans 13:7Psalm 37:21Proverbs 22:71 Timothy 6:6–10Matthew 6:24Hebrews 13:51 Timothy 6:172 Corinthians 8:12–13Genesis 14:20Hebrews 7:2Luke 11:42Leviticus 27:30–32Matthew 6:19–21Psalm 147Genesis 2:31 Corinthians 9:141 Timothy 5:17–18Hebrews 13:17Psalm 110:3Psalm 54:62 Corinthians 9:7Romans 6:17
Confessions
AC XXVIIIAp XXIVLC ISD IVSCLC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “Must Christians Tithe?: Money, Debt and the Generous Heart.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/must-christians-tithe/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.