Papers · Essays

The Eighth Commandment Online

Speech, Gossip and Social Media

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“So also the tongue is a small member, yet it boasts of great things. How great a forest is set ablaze by such a small fire!” — James 3:5, ESV


A Note on Citations

Bible passages are quoted from the English Standard Version. Quotations from the Lutheran Confessions (the Small and Large Catechisms and the other confessions in the Book of Concord) are from the 1921 Concordia Triglotta, and the notes give the details.1


I. The Commandment and the Screen

Long before anyone could forward a message, the law of Moses said, “You shall not spread a false report. You shall not join hands with a wicked man to be a malicious witness” (Exodus 23:1). The Eighth Commandment, “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor” (Exodus 20:16), was first given for Israel’s courts, where a lying witness could cost a man his life or his land. Moses guarded those courts carefully; a single witness could not convict anyone (Deuteronomy 19:15), and a witness who was shown to have lied was to suffer the penalty he had meant for his neighbor (Deuteronomy 19:18–19). However, the book of the covenant (the first collection of Israel’s laws, in Exodus 20–23) already knew that a man’s name could be ruined without a judge ever hearing his case. A report only had to be spread. The next verse warns, “You shall not fall in with the many to do evil” (Exodus 23:2), and anyone who has watched a story race across the internet in an afternoon knows what that crowd looks like now.

Is it gossip if it is true? What should I do about a post I wish I had never written? Behind those two questions stand others, about screenshots, about politicians and church leaders, and about writing under a made-up name.

The Eighth Commandment governs every post, comment, text, forward and screenshot as it governs every spoken word, and Luther gave us the rule we need nearly five hundred years before anyone owned a phone. In the Large Catechism (his longer catechism of 1529, written for pastors and heads of households) he teaches that a sin which is secret should stay secret or be taken privately to the one who committed it. Nothing should be published that cannot be proved. What is already public may be spoken of publicly, but truthfully and for the good of the neighbor. In everything else we are to defend our neighbor, speak well of him and put the best construction on what we hear. Although the screen did not invent a new sin, it has given an old one a reach that no village gossip ever had.

This paper walks through Luther’s explanation of the commandment and then applies it to private sins, to public sins and public people, to anonymity and the online crowd, and to the hard case of abuse that has been kept quiet. Most of us will find ourselves somewhere in it. It does not end with the Law. Its last pages are about the forgiveness Christ gives to those who have sinned with their tongues, and the comfort He gives to those who have been sinned against.


II. What Does Luther’s Explanation Forbid?

The Small Catechism explains the commandment in one sentence that most of us memorized as children:

“We should fear and love God that we may not deceitfully belie, betray, slander, or defame our neighbor, but defend him, [think and] speak well of him, and put the best construction on everything.”2

To belie a neighbor is to tell a lie about him, which is false witness in its narrowest sense. To betray him is to give away what he entrusted to us; the forwarded private email and the screenshot of a friend’s message sent to a group belong here, even if every word in them is true. To slander is to speak against him behind his back, and to defame is to take away his good name among the people who know him. On the other side Luther names three things God asks of us: to defend our neighbor when he is spoken against and cannot answer, to speak well of him, and to put the best construction on what we hear about him. The words “think and” stand in brackets because they come from the Latin text of the catechism and not the German. They remind us that the commandment reaches back behind the tongue into the heart, where the worst construction is usually put long before anything is typed.

Why does God care so much about a reputation? Luther writes that after our bodies, our marriages and our property we have “yet another treasure, namely, honor and good report… with which we cannot dispense. For it is intolerable to live among men in open shame and general contempt. Therefore God wishes the reputation, good name, and upright character of our neighbor to be taken away or diminished as little as his money and possessions.”3 In other words, a good name is property, and the Eighth Commandment guards it as the Seventh guards a man’s house and car. Moses joined slander to violence when he wrote, “You shall not go around as a slanderer among your people, and you shall not stand up against the life of your neighbor: I am the LORD” (Leviticus 19:16).

Luther widens the commandment in three steps. It applies first to the courts, where judges and witnesses must not be bought or frightened into twisting a poor man’s case. It applies next to the Church, where faithful preachers are slandered as heretics. In the third place, he writes, “what concerns us all, this commandment forbids all sins of the tongue whereby we may injure or approach too closely to our neighbor.”4 To “approach too closely” is to pry into what is not ours or press in where we have no business. A post is a work of the tongue in Luther’s sense, although it is typed rather than spoken. This is why the Small Catechism’s own form of confession asks each of us “whether you have grieved any one by words or deeds,” and why typed words belong in that confession as much as spoken ones.5

Scripture takes our words more seriously than we do. Jesus says, “I tell you, on the day of judgment people will give account for every careless word they speak, for by your words you will be justified, and by your words you will be condemned” (Matthew 12:36–37). Solomon writes that “When words are many, transgression is not lacking, but whoever restrains his lips is prudent” (Proverbs 10:19), and I doubt there has ever been a place where words are as many as they are online. The New Testament’s word for the devil, diabolos, means “slanderer” or “false accuser.” Paul uses the same word for ordinary church members when he writes that older women are to be “not slanderers” (Titus 2:3).6

It is important to say one more thing before going further. The neighbor we are told to defend is someone Christ has defended first. The devil accuses us; Christ speaks for us before the Father (1 John 2:1). The charity we owe in our speech is not a toll we pay to be accepted by God, but the fruit of a defense we have already received.


III. Knowing a Sin and Judging It

Luther calls slander “the detestable, shameful vice of speaking behind a person’s back.” He observes that “every one prefers hearing evil to hearing good of his neighbor,” although none of us can bear to have anything bad said about ourselves.7 Solomon had said it first: “The words of a whisperer are like delicious morsels; they go down into the inner parts of the body” (Proverbs 18:8). The post that begins “I probably shouldn’t share this, but…” is usually read by more people than the one that begins with good news.

At the heart of Luther’s treatment is a distinction that every Christian with a phone needs to learn:

“[N]o one is allowed publicly to judge and reprove his neighbor, although he may see him sin, unless he have a command to judge and to reprove. For there is a great difference between these two things, judging sin and knowing sin. You may indeed know it, but you are not to judge it. I can indeed see and hear that my neighbor sins, but I have no command to report it to others. Now, if I rush in, judging and passing sentence, I fall into a sin which is greater than his. But if you know it, do nothing else than turn your ears into a grave and cover it, until you are appointed to be judge and to punish by virtue of your office.”8

To know a sin is not itself a sin. Christians see one another fall and some of what they see is ugly. The question is what we do with what we know, and Luther’s answer is that a private person who passes sentence on his neighbor has taken an office God never gave him. He calls it “meddling with the judgment and office of God.” He adds, “although you do not wield the sword, you employ your poisonous tongue to the shame and hurt of your neighbor.”9 A comment that pronounces sentence on someone on the strength of rumor or a few seconds of video (“He’s a fraud,” “She’s a liar,” “He’s a hypocrite”) is a small act of judging by someone who holds no office to judge.

Luther expected the reply we would make and answered it in a little dialogue:

“But you say: Shall I not say it if it be the truth? Answer: Why do you not make accusation to regular judges? Ah, I cannot prove it publicly, and hence I might be silenced and turned away in a harsh manner [incur the penalty of a false accusation]. ‘Ah, indeed, do you smell the roast?’ If you do not trust yourself to stand before the proper authorities and to make answer, then hold your tongue. But if you know it, know it for yourself and not for another. For if you tell it to others, although it be true, you will appear as a liar, because you cannot prove it, and you are, besides, acting like a knave. For we ought never to deprive any one of his honor or good name unless it be first taken away from him publicly.”10

“Do you smell the roast?” was a proverb in Luther’s day, meaning something like, “Do you see what is really going on here?” A knave is a scoundrel. In other words, the one who will spread a story but will not stand behind it before someone with authority to act on it has shown what he is really after. Luther then gives the sentence that settles most of what crosses our screens: “False witness, then, is everything which cannot be properly proved. Therefore, what is not manifest upon sufficient evidence no one shall make public or declare for truth.”11

That answers the question “Is it gossip if it is true?” The Small Catechism names betraying and slandering alongside lying, and Luther says that the sum of the commandment is that we speak no evil of our neighbor, “no matter whether it be true or false, unless it be done by commandment or for his reformation.”12 The question is whether a thing is mine to tell and whether telling it serves the neighbor or only my appetite for the story. A true report given to the police, to a pastor, to an employer who must know, or to the person himself may be what love requires. The same report sent to the group chat is gossip. “Whoever covers an offense seeks love, but he who repeats a matter separates close friends” (Proverbs 17:9).

Luther’s rule also means that a Christian who shares an accusation he has not checked has borne false witness, even if it later turns out to be true, because he declared for truth what he could not prove. Solomon warns, “If one gives an answer before he hears, it is his folly and shame” (Proverbs 18:13). In addition, he describes how a story sounds before the other side has spoken: “The one who states his case first seems right, until the other comes and examines him” (Proverbs 18:17). The viral post is nearly always the first to state its case. A screenshot shows a few lines and hides everything before and after them. When a question is asked so that others will believe the answer (“Has anyone else noticed how much time he spends with the youth group?”), it is an accusation wearing a question mark. The post that names no one belongs here too. Someone writes, “Some people at church need to learn to keep their opinions to themselves,” and everyone who reads it knows who is meant. This is slander that has kept a way of escape for itself, carried into every corner while it refuses to stand before the one it accuses.

The prayer chain needs a word, because Christians gossip most comfortably in the name of concern. A request for prayer that tells the whole congregation about a member’s marriage, drinking or diagnosis, when he never asked for it to be shared, betrays him however kindly it is meant. “Whoever goes about slandering reveals secrets, but he who is trustworthy in spirit keeps a thing covered” (Proverbs 11:13). God hears a prayer for “a family in our congregation going through a hard time” as well as one that names them.

What should we do when the gossip comes to us? Luther writes, “[I]f you encounter an idle tongue which betrays and slanders some one, contradict such a one promptly to his face, that he may blush.”13 This is the defend him of the Small Catechism. Online it may mean a short reply under a cruel post (“Do you know this is true?” or “Have you talked to her?”). More often it means simply refusing to pass the story along. “For lack of wood the fire goes out, and where there is no whisperer, quarreling ceases” (Proverbs 26:20).


IV. Going to Your Brother

None of this means that a Christian must pretend not to see sin. The commandment forbids private persons to judge, but not those whose office it is to judge. Luther names “the civil government, preachers, father and mother.” If those whose office it is fail to act, he writes, “they sin as well as he who would do so of his own accord, without such office.”14 In addition, brothers, sisters and friends are bound to warn one another. How then is a brother to warn? Luther sends us to the order Christ gave:

“If your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained your brother. But if he does not listen, take one or two others along with you, that every charge may be established by the evidence of two or three witnesses. If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church. And if he refuses to listen even to the church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector.” (Matthew 18:15–17)

Luther calls this “a precious and excellent teaching for governing well the tongue,” and he applies it to every secret sin a Christian knows of, not only to wrongs done to himself. His rule is “that you do not too readily spread evil concerning your neighbor and slander him to others, but admonish him privately that he may amend.” When someone reports to you what another has done, you are to teach him “to go and admonish him personally, if he have seen it himself; but if not, that he hold his tongue.”15 The one who saw it goes to the person, and the one who only heard about it says nothing. Luther pictures a master who, instead of speaking to his lazy servant, goes out into the street to complain about him to the neighbors. They would answer, “You fool, what does that concern us? Why do you not tell it to him?”16 The public post makes everyone who reads it into those neighbors, handed a quarrel that does not concern them by someone who has not yet spoken to the one he is complaining about.

Christ’s order keeps the accused at the center of the process. “He whom it concerns is always to be treated with personally, and not to be spoken of without his knowledge.”17 Only when that fails do others come in, and then the matter goes to the church or to the civil court, where there are witnesses and a judge who can act. Luther adds, “If you were acting for your neighbor’s reformation or from love of the truth, you would not sneak about secretly nor shun the day and the light.”18

The Christian deciding whether to post about a sister-in-law, a coworker, a former friend or the council of his own congregation should ask first whether he has spoken to the person himself. If he has not, that is where Christ sends him, and the post is not the place to begin. The purpose of the first step is the one Jesus names, “you have gained your brother,” and Luther asks, “do you think it is a little matter to gain a brother?”19 Shaming him before four hundred followers is not one of the steps Christ gave.

It is important to say clearly where this order does not apply, because it has been misused. Christ’s steps are for sin between Christians that can be dealt with in private. A crime that endangers a neighbor is another matter. Abuse of a child, assault, and fraud belong at once to those who hold the office to judge, to the government that “does not bear the sword in vain” (Romans 13:4), and, where the church’s own workers are involved, to the church’s leaders as well. Luther’s reason is the office itself, for those whose office it is to punish “sin as well” if they fail to do it.20 The Fifth Commandment points the same way. Luther writes that it condemns not only the one who does harm, “but he also who can do him good, prevent, resist evil, defend and save him, so that no bodily harm or hurt happen to him, and yet does not do it.”21 Therefore the Christian who reports such a crime to the authorities is not breaking the Eighth Commandment, but keeping it, along with the Fifth. A congregation that tells a victim to go privately to the one who harmed her, or that hides an accusation under a pious appeal to the best construction, has turned this commandment against the very neighbor it was given to protect. Churches of every confession, our own among them, have at times done this, and no one in our care should ever hear Matthew 18 as a command to keep silent about a crime.


V. Public Sin, Public Figures and Pastors

Everything Luther has said so far concerns secret sins. Then he adds:

“But where the sin is quite public so that the judge and everybody know it, you can without any sin avoid him and let him go, because he has brought himself into disgrace, and you may also publicly testify concerning him. For when a matter is public in the light of day, there can be no slandering or false judging or testifying; as, when we now reprove the Pope with his doctrine, which is publicly set forth in books and proclaimed in all the world. For where the sin is public, the reproof also must be public, that every one may learn to guard against it.”22

In other words, what someone has done or taught in public may be answered in public. A senator’s vote, a governor’s executive order, a celebrity’s published statement, a theologian’s book and a church body’s official resolution have all been “set forth in books and proclaimed in all the world.” A Christian may discuss them, criticize them and warn others about them without first making a private appointment. When Peter withdrew from eating with Gentile believers in Antioch, Paul writes, “I opposed him to his face, because he stood condemned,” speaking to him “before them all” (Galatians 2:11, 14). Scripture records no private step before that public rebuke, and Luther did not think he had to visit Rome before answering what Rome had published.

However, Luther’s permission has limits written into it. It covers the public thing (the vote, the sermon, the book, the published statement) and not the man’s private life, his family, his health or the rumors about him. It still requires that the public thing be reported accurately and quoted in context, not cut down to the five words that make the speaker look worst. Also, it does not permit us to invent motives. A Christian may say that a public official’s policy is unjust and explain why; when he claims to know that the official secretly hates the poor, he is judging a heart no one has shown him. The best construction still applies to whatever is not “notoriously evil,”23 and most of what public people do is not notorious at all, but simply something we disagree with.

Scripture also asks us to speak of those in authority with respect, even when we oppose them. When the high priest ordered Paul struck on the mouth during his hearing before the Sanhedrin (the Jewish council), Paul answered hotly, “God is going to strike you, you whitewashed wall!” (Acts 23:3). When he learned who the man was, he took it back: “I did not know, brothers, that he was the high priest, for it is written, ‘You shall not speak evil of a ruler of your people’” (Acts 23:5). An apostle spoke in anger against a ruler who had wronged him, and then he withdrew the insult. Paul’s instruction to Titus covers everyone, including those we vote against, for Christians are “to speak evil of no one, to avoid quarreling, to be gentle, and to show perfect courtesy toward all people” (Titus 3:2).

The mocking meme and the insult need a separate word, because many Christians who would never tell a lie think nothing of ridicule. Jesus places contempt under the Fifth Commandment, “whoever insults his brother will be liable to the council; and whoever says, ‘You fool!’ will be liable to the hell of fire” (Matthew 5:22). Luther explains that “we must not kill, neither with hand, heart, mouth, signs, gestures, help, nor counsel.”24 An edited picture that makes a public figure look like an animal or a fool is a sign and a gesture of that kind. It may be clever and many will share it. However, it is not the reproof of a public sin “that every one may learn to guard against it,” but contempt for a person made in God’s image. We should be honest that Luther himself did not always keep this line. In 1545 he published Against the Papacy at Rome, Founded by the Devil, with a title page from Lucas Cranach’s workshop showing the pope with the ears of an ass, enthroned at the mouth of hell, and in the same year a series of satirical woodcuts against the papacy.25 Those pictures were the mocking memes of his day, and his own catechism judges them more truly than his printer did. James writes of the tongue, “With it we bless our Lord and Father, and with it we curse people who are made in the likeness of God… My brothers, these things ought not to be so” (James 3:9–10).

Pastors stand in a special place. Their public teaching is public in the fullest sense, and false doctrine publicly taught may be publicly answered, “that every one may learn to guard against it.” James warns that “we who teach will be judged with greater strictness” (James 3:1), and that strictness applies to what a teacher publishes as much as to what he preaches. A private sin is different. If you have seen a pastor sin, Christ’s first step applies to him as to anyone, and you go to him yourself.26 A charge that must come before others goes to those who can examine it with witnesses, for Paul writes, “Do not admit a charge against an elder except on the evidence of two or three witnesses. As for those who persist in sin, rebuke them in the presence of all, so that the rest may stand in fear” (1 Timothy 5:19–20). Those are the congregation’s elders and the district president or bishop, not a blog or a Facebook group where there are no witnesses and no one can render a verdict. Abuse or a crime goes straight to those leaders and to the civil authorities. Some church-watch writers have documented public matters accurately, and some have brought hidden abuse to light after supervisors failed to act; that is a different thing from trading private accusations. A public error also does not make the man who taught it fair game. We may answer his teaching without attacking his character, and the best construction is owed to a pastor we disagree with as much as to any other neighbor.27


VI. Anonymity and the Crowd

Scripture and Luther both assume that an accuser stands where he can be answered. Moses required witnesses whose testimony could be examined (Deuteronomy 19:15–19). Even the Roman governor Festus could say, “it was not the custom of the Romans to give up anyone before the accused met the accusers face to face and had opportunity to make his defense concerning the charge laid against him” (Acts 25:16). Luther’s rule that the accused is not to be spoken of without his knowledge points the same way. An anonymous account that exists to accuse, mock or expose others is a way of speaking against a neighbor without ever having to answer for it.

At the same time, writing without one’s name is not a sin in itself. The author of the Letter to the Hebrews never tells us who he is, and the Church has received his letter as Holy Scripture. Christians under persecution have often had to write and worship without giving their names, and a victim of abuse may have good reason to keep her name private, and never to face the one who harmed her, while she speaks to those who can help. The test is Luther’s. Would I be willing to answer for this before those who have the authority to judge it? A victim who has gone to the police or to the church’s leaders has already met that test. If I would not, the made-up name is protecting me from the Eighth Commandment rather than from persecution.

The crowd is the other new thing. Exodus 23 forbids not only the false report but falling in “with the many to do evil.” Online a single accusation can gather ten thousand replies in an afternoon. Each person replying may feel that he has added only one small voice, although a pile of small voices is how a crowd destroys a name. Luther’s explanation of the Fifth Commandment says that we are to “neither use nor assent to any kind of means or methods whereby any one may be injured.”28 To press “like” under a cruel post, to share it with a laughing face, or to add one more insult to a hundred others is to assent. The Christian is free not to join, and usually that is the best thing he can do. When the crowd is moving fast, James gives the counsel, “let every person be quick to hear, slow to speak, slow to anger” (James 1:19), and many of the stories that sweep the internet in a day look different by the end of the week.

Permanence makes all of this weigh more. Luther warns that “honor and a good name are easily taken away, but not easily restored,”29 although he was speaking of a village where gossip at least faded with time. What is posted online is copied, saved and searchable for years. A young person’s worst moment, caught on a classmate’s camera and shared, can follow him into every job interview he ever has. Parents who give a child a phone are also giving him a printing press, and teaching the Eighth Commandment at home now includes teaching what not to photograph, what not to forward, and what to do when a friend sends something cruel about someone else.


VII. When Silence Protects the Guilty

The strongest objection to all of this comes from those who have worked with victims of abuse. They do not say that Luther’s teaching is wrong. They say that, as churches have often applied it, the commandment has been used as a gag. Abusers in churches, schools and families have been shielded for years because people who knew were told not to gossip, not to judge, and to go privately to the one who had harmed them. In many cases, they point out, the only thing that finally stopped them was a victim’s public account or a reporter’s investigation. Scripture itself says, “Take no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead expose them” (Ephesians 5:11), and “Open your mouth for the mute, for the rights of all who are destitute” (Proverbs 31:8).

I agree with much of this. Nothing in the Large Catechism tells a victim to keep silent or a witness to hide a crime. Luther insists that those whose office it is to judge must act and that they sin if they do not. He sends the one who knows of wrongdoing to the “regular judges,” and he teaches that public sin must be publicly reproved. Therefore the question is whether the one who speaks is seeking a remedy or only an audience.

The advocates press one case hardest. Suppose a woman did everything the Catechism asks. She went to the police, or to the elders, or to the district president or bishop, and nothing was done; perhaps the authority was the accused man’s friend, or the time allowed by law had run out. Now she tells her own story publicly, under her own name. Is she a gossip? I do not believe she is. Those whose office it was to judge have sinned by failing to act.30 Her matter is no longer a secret kept back from the judges, because she brought it to them and they refused it. When she speaks truthfully, under her own name, of what she can prove and what is hers to tell, she is defending herself and warning others who may be in danger. This is not the idle tongue Luther condemns. The Christians around her owe her the defense and the good word the Small Catechism asks for, not suspicion.

The reporter who publishes proven wrongdoing that was kept secret is a harder case still, and here I am reasoning beyond what the Catechism itself says. Although Luther permits public speech about sin that is already public, he also writes that “we ought never to deprive any one of his honor or good name unless it be first taken away from him publicly.”31 For a secret sin his route is the court, not the printing press. However, when those whose office it is have failed to act (the Fourth Commandment’s authorities, who answer to God for their office) and a neighbor is still in danger (the Fifth Commandment’s duty to “defend and save him”), I judge that a journalist who checks his facts, gives the accused a chance to answer, and publishes only what he can prove may be serving his neighbor and not slandering him. This is an argument from the Fourth and Fifth Commandments carried further than the Large Catechism goes. Christians may weigh it differently. The reader who forwards such a story should ask the same questions. Has it been checked? Does sharing it warn someone who needs warning, or only add to the noise? When he does not know, he can wait.

Two smaller objections can be answered briefly. Some Christians teach that Matthew 18 forbids anyone to criticize a pastor, author or church leader in public until the critic has first gone to him privately. Love does go to the person first, and many public quarrels would have ended with one phone call. However, Luther distinguishes secret sins from public teaching, which may be answered publicly because it was given publicly. A private word to a public teacher is often wise and kind, but it is not commanded, and no one may make it a law that binds the conscience. Others object that putting the best construction on everything is naive and calls evil good, against Isaiah’s warning, “Woe to those who call evil good and good evil” (Isaiah 5:20). Luther answered this himself. He calls it “an excellent and noble virtue for one always to explain advantageously and put the best construction upon all he may hear of his neighbor (if it be not notoriously evil).”32 It does not ask us to deny what has been proved.


VIII. Forgiveness for the Tongue

James is not flattering anyone when he writes, “For we all stumble in many ways. And if anyone does not stumble in what he says, he is a perfect man” (James 3:2). Most of us have broken the Eighth Commandment somewhere, and some of us have done it online where it cannot easily be taken back. The Law has done its work; what we need now is what God gives to sinners. The place to begin is confession, to God and, when the conscience is troubled, to the pastor, who speaks Christ’s absolution in His name. What is confessed to a pastor for absolution is kept by him and goes no further. That forgiveness is complete and does not wait until every bit of damage has been repaired.

Then, as the fruit of forgiveness and never as its price, love does what it can to repair the harm. Jesus says, “leave your gift there before the altar and go. First be reconciled to your brother, and then come and offer your gift” (Matthew 5:24). Take the post down. If what you spread was false, correct it where you said it, because a good name is “easily taken away, but not easily restored.” If you shared something you cannot prove, you do not have to wait to learn whether it was true; take it down and say that you should not have passed it on. If you betrayed a true secret, do not repeat it again in the name of correcting it. Go to the person privately and ask his forgiveness. He may not give it quickly; that has to be left with God. Your standing before God rests on Christ’s word to you, not on whether a screenshot of your words ever disappears from the internet.

The one who has been posted about needs a different word. God values your good name, and you are not wrong to grieve when it is taken. You may defend yourself truthfully, and where you have been seriously defamed you may seek the protection of the courts, since the commandment is given “that every one shall help his neighbor to secure his rights.”33 Even so, you do not have to answer every accusation. When Christ was reviled, Peter writes, “he did not revile in return; when he suffered, he did not threaten, but continued entrusting himself to him who judges justly” (1 Peter 2:23). In time you will be asked to forgive the one who did it, as we pray, “forgive us our debts, as we also have forgiven our debtors” (Matthew 6:12). Forgiving him does not mean pretending the harm was small, and it does not mean trusting him again at once. Trust is rebuilt slowly, and you are free to let it be slow.

Some whose sin was exposed online were not slandered at all, because what was said of them was true. They need to hear the Gospel as much as anyone. A congregation should receive such a member, cover what can still be covered, and refuse to keep the story alive, for “love covers a multitude of sins” (1 Peter 4:8). Whatever was said, true or false, one verdict stands that no post can overturn. Paul writes, “Who shall bring any charge against God’s elect? It is God who justifies. Who is to condemn? Christ Jesus is the one who died—more than that, who was raised—who is at the right hand of God, who indeed is interceding for us” (Romans 8:33–34).

For all of us, Paul gives the measure of what we write, “Let no corrupting talk come out of your mouths, but only such as is good for building up, as fits the occasion, that it may give grace to those who hear” (Ephesians 4:29). Before posting about a person, ask:

  • Have I spoken to him myself?
  • Can I prove it?
  • Is it mine to tell?
  • Would I stand behind it, under my own name, before those who have the authority to judge it?
  • Will it build anyone up?

Paul’s reason is that “we are members one of another” (Ephesians 4:25), and the person on the other side of the screen is a member of Christ’s body or one for whom Christ died. David’s prayer is a good one to pray before typing anything at all: “Set a guard, O LORD, over my mouth; keep watch over the door of my lips!” (Psalm 141:3).


Conclusion

On the night He was betrayed, Jesus stood before the high priest while “many bore false witness against him, but their testimony did not agree” (Mark 14:56). The One whom Revelation calls “the faithful witness” (Revelation 1:5) was condemned on false testimony, and He did not answer His accusers with a slander of His own. He “committed no sin, neither was deceit found in his mouth” (1 Peter 2:22). He kept the Eighth Commandment perfectly for us who break it so easily, and He bore the judgment our careless words deserved. Now “the accuser of our brothers has been thrown down, who accuses them day and night before our God” (Revelation 12:10). Some of his accusations against us were true. Even so, “if anyone does sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous” (1 John 2:1). He does not excuse our sin; He covers it with His own blood and speaks for us before His Father.

Luther writes that there is nothing in a man “which can do both greater and more extensive good or harm in spiritual and in temporal matters than the tongue, though it is the least and feeblest member.”34 The rule he drew from the Eighth Commandment fits our screens as well as it fit his village. Keep secret sins secret, or take them to the one who committed them. Publish nothing you cannot prove. Speak of public things publicly, truthfully and without contempt. Send crimes to those whose office it is to judge them. In everything else, defend your neighbor, speak well of him and put the best construction on what you hear, as people whom Christ has defended first.


Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture and Confessions

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.
  • Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
  • Kolb, Robert, and Timothy J. Wengert, eds. The Book of Concord. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000.
  • Tappert, Theodore G., ed. The Book of Concord. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1959.

Luther

  • Luther, Martin. Abbildung des Bapstum. Wittenberg, 1545. Cornell University Library, Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections.
  • Luther, Martin. Wider das Bapstum zu Rom vom Teuffel gestifft. Wittenberg, 1545. Pitts Theology Library, Emory University.

Footnotes

  1. Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Confessions are quoted from the Concordia Triglotta (St. Louis: Concordia, 1921) and cited by the standard abbreviations, with paragraph numbers as in the Kolb–Wengert and Tappert editions: SC is the Small Catechism and LC the Large Catechism, so that LC I.266 means the Large Catechism, Part One (the Ten Commandments), paragraph 266. Words in square brackets inside a Triglotta quotation are the Triglotta’s own, except a bracketed capital letter, which marks a quotation that begins in the middle of the Triglotta’s sentence. ↩

  2. SC I.16 (Triglotta). The bracketed words translate the Latin text of the catechism, which reads “let us think and speak well of him”; the German has only “speak well of him.” ↩

  3. LC I.255–256 (Triglotta). The omitted words are the Triglotta’s bracketed gloss, “[the illustrious testimony of an upright and unsullied name and reputation].” ↩

  4. LC I.263 (Triglotta). On the courts and the Church, LC I.257–262. ↩

  5. SC V, “How the Unlearned Should be Taught to Confess,” the question “Which are these?” (Triglotta). ↩

  6. The same Greek word lies behind “slanderers” in 1 Timothy 3:11 and “slanderous” in 2 Timothy 3:3. In Revelation 12:9–10 “the devil” (diabolos) is also called “the accuser of our brothers.” ↩

  7. LC I.264 (Triglotta). ↩

  8. LC I.265–266 (Triglotta). The sentence in the Triglotta begins, “Therefore, to avoid this vice we should note that no one is allowed…” ↩

  9. LC I.267–268 (Triglotta). Luther also compares the slanderer to swine rooting in the dirt (LC I.267), and says that a private person who calls his neighbor “a thief, a murderer, a traitor” goes “just as far as the emperor and all governments” (LC I.268). ↩

  10. LC I.269–270 (Triglotta). LC I.269 states the principle the dialogue defends: God would have it prohibited “that any one speak evil of another even though he be guilty.” The proverb is riechst du den Braten? in Luther’s German. ↩

  11. LC I.271–272 (Triglotta). The sentence continues: “and, in short, whatever is secret should be allowed to remain secret, or, at any rate, should be secretly reproved.” ↩

  12. LC I.285 (Triglotta). ↩

  13. LC I.273 (Triglotta). The Triglotta’s sentence begins, “Therefore, if you encounter…” ↩

  14. LC I.274 (Triglotta). Luther compares these offices to the executioner, who does a man bodily harm without breaking the Fifth Commandment because God established his office, and to a physician who must examine a patient’s hidden wounds in order to cure him (LC I.274–275). He also says that “governments, father and mother, brothers and sisters, and other good friends, are under obligation to each other to reprove evil wherever it is needful and profitable” (LC I.275). ↩

  15. LC I.276 (Triglotta). Some ancient manuscripts of Matthew 18:15 lack the words “against you.” Luther’s use of the passage does not depend on them, since he applies Christ’s order to any secret sin a Christian has seen (LC I.276, 279). ↩

  16. LC I.277–278 (Triglotta). ↩

  17. LC I.279–281 (Triglotta). ↩

  18. LC I.283 (Triglotta). ↩

  19. LC I.278 (Triglotta). ↩

  20. LC I.274 (Triglotta). ↩

  21. LC I.189 (Triglotta), on the Fifth Commandment. LC I.190 goes on: “if you see any one innocently sentenced to death or in like distress, and do not save him, although you know ways and means to do so, you have killed him.” ↩

  22. LC I.284 (Triglotta). ↩

  23. LC I.289 (Triglotta). ↩

  24. LC I.182 (Triglotta). ↩

  25. Martin Luther, Wider das Bapstum zu Rom vom Teuffel gestifft (Wittenberg, 1545), title woodcut from the workshop of Lucas Cranach (Pitts Theology Library, Emory University, digital collections); Luther, Abbildung des Bapstum (Wittenberg, 1545), a series of satirical woodcuts (Cornell University Library, Rare Books BR332 .A15 1545). ↩

  26. Matthew 18:15; LC I.276, 279. ↩

  27. On how the Eighth Commandment binds pastors themselves, see Letters to a Young Pastor, chapter 10, “The Eighth Commandment Applies to Pastors, Too.” ↩

  28. LC I.188 (Triglotta). ↩

  29. LC I.273 (Triglotta). ↩

  30. LC I.274 (Triglotta). ↩

  31. LC I.270 (Triglotta); on public sin, LC I.284; on the secret sin and the court, LC I.280. ↩

  32. LC I.289 (Triglotta). The sentence goes on to condemn “the poisonous tongues that are busy wherever they can pry out and discover something to blame in a neighbor, and that explain and pervert it in the worst way.” ↩

  33. LC I.260 (Triglotta). ↩

  34. LC I.290 (Triglotta). ↩

Topics
The Ten CommandmentsVocation and Daily Life
Scripture
James 3:5Exodus 23:1Exodus 20:16Deuteronomy 19:15Deuteronomy 19:18–19Exodus 23:2Leviticus 19:16Matthew 12:36–37Proverbs 10:19Titus 2:31 John 2:1Proverbs 18:8Proverbs 17:9Proverbs 18:13Proverbs 18:17Proverbs 11:13Proverbs 26:20Matthew 18:15–17Romans 13:4Galatians 2:11Acts 23:3Acts 23:5Titus 3:2Matthew 5:22James 3:9–10James 3:11 Timothy 5:19–20Deuteronomy 19:15–19Acts 25:16James 1:19Ephesians 5:11Proverbs 31:8Isaiah 5:20James 3:2Matthew 5:241 Peter 2:23Matthew 6:121 Peter 4:8Romans 8:33–34Ephesians 4:29Ephesians 4:25Psalm 141:3Mark 14:56Revelation 1:51 Peter 2:22Revelation 12:101 Timothy 3:112 Timothy 3:3Revelation 12:9–10Matthew 18:15
Confessions
LC ISCLC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “The Eighth Commandment Online: Speech, Gossip and Social Media.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/the-eighth-commandment-online/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.