Papers · Essays

Let Your Yes Be Yes

Oaths, Vows and the Courtroom

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“For all the promises of God find their Yes in him. That is why it is through him that we utter our Amen to God for his glory.” — 2 Corinthians 1:20, ESV


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the Concordia Triglotta of 1921 and cited by part and paragraph.1


I. “Do You Swear or Affirm?”

Anyone who has been a witness in court, sat on a jury, enlisted in the armed forces, become a citizen or taken a public office has been asked to raise his right hand. The question that follows usually offers a choice. Even the oath of the President, printed in the Constitution itself, begins “I do solemnly swear (or affirm).”2 The little word or is there for Christians who will not swear. Since the Reformation the Anabaptists and their Mennonite heirs, and since the seventeenth century the Quakers, have refused every oath because Jesus said, “Do not take an oath at all” (Matthew 5:34). The law in England and America slowly came to allow for them.

A Lutheran who knows his Bible may hear that verse and wonder whether the Quakers are right. Is a Christian allowed to swear? If Jesus said “not at all,” what are we doing with our hand raised in a courtroom, and what are the promises we make at the altar?

He is allowed to swear, when the government requires it or when his neighbor’s good calls for it. Our Confessions teach this in so many words. The Augsburg Confession permits Christians “to make oath when required by the magistrates,” the Large Catechism (Luther’s teaching of the Ten Commandments, the Creed and the Lord’s Prayer for pastors and heads of households) commends the true oath “for the support of good and the advantage of our neighbor,” and the Formula of Concord (the last of the Lutheran confessions, 1577) rejects the teaching that a Christian cannot take an oath with a good conscience.3 What Jesus forbids is the oath we reach for on our own, out of habit or to make a lie sound true. He also forbids us to talk as though our plain yes and no were worth less than a sworn word. The promises we make before God at the altar, at a wedding or at confirmation, are good and they bind us. They lean on God’s grace and earn nothing from Him.


II. What an Oath Is

Before we argue about oaths we should know what one is. Noah Webster’s dictionary of 1828 defines an oath as “a solemn affirmation or declaration, made with an appeal to God for the truth of what is affirmed.” He writes that the appeal to God implies that the person “imprecates his vengeance and renounces his favor if the declaration is false.”4 In other words, an oath does two things at once. It calls God as a witness to what I say and calls down His judgment on me if I am lying. To imprecate is to pray a curse, here a curse on oneself.

Some oaths swear to what is true now or what happened before. The witness in court swears to what he saw. Other oaths swear to what a person will do. The President swears that he will faithfully execute his office and the soldier that he will support and defend. A vow is a promise made to God Himself, as when Hannah vowed to give her son to the LORD (1 Samuel 1:11). Strictly speaking, then, the promises a bride and groom make to each other are not vows to God but solemn promises made before God and in His name. We call them wedding vows and there is nothing wrong with that, as long as we remember that God is their witness and the spouse is the one to whom they are made.

The Old Testament does not merely permit the oath. It commands that, when Israel swears, it swear by the LORD and by no other god:

“It is the LORD your God you shall fear. Him you shall serve and by his name you shall swear.” (Deuteronomy 6:13)

The verse stands in the middle of the great call to love the LORD with all the heart (Deuteronomy 6:4–5). To swear by a god is to confess him as the one who sees what is hidden and judges the liar; therefore Israel was to swear only by the true God. Jeremiah tells how to do it, “if you swear, ‘As the LORD lives,’ in truth, in justice, and in righteousness” (Jeremiah 4:2). The same Law guards the oath from abuse. “You shall not swear by my name falsely, and so profane the name of your God: I am the LORD” (Leviticus 19:12). Over all of it stands the Second Commandment, “You shall not take the name of the LORD your God in vain, for the LORD will not hold him guiltless who takes his name in vain” (Exodus 20:7).

God Himself swears. When Abraham had laid Isaac on the altar, the LORD said, “By myself I have sworn” (Genesis 22:16). The Epistle to the Hebrews explains why He did so:

“For people swear by something greater than themselves, and in all their disputes an oath is final for confirmation. So when God desired to show more convincingly to the heirs of the promise the unchangeable character of his purpose, he guaranteed it with an oath, so that by two unchangeable things, in which it is impossible for God to lie, we who have fled for refuge might have strong encouragement to hold fast to the hope set before us.” (Hebrews 6:16–18)

God did not need an oath to make His word true, but swore for our sake, because we are slow to believe. He used the oath just as human beings use it, as the thing that is “final for confirmation” and ends a dispute. This is worth holding onto as we turn to the hard text, because the writer to the Hebrews speaks of the human oath without any embarrassment.


III. “But I Say to You”

The hard text is in the Sermon on the Mount:

“Again you have heard that it was said to those of old, ‘You shall not swear falsely, but shall perform to the Lord what you have sworn.’ But I say to you, Do not take an oath at all, either by heaven, for it is the throne of God, or by the earth, for it is his footstool, or by Jerusalem, for it is the city of the great King. And do not take an oath by your head, for you cannot make one hair white or black. Let what you say be simply ‘Yes’ or ‘No’; anything more than this comes from evil.” (Matthew 5:33–37)

James repeats it almost word for word, “But above all, my brothers, do not swear, either by heaven or by earth or by any other oath, but let your ‘yes’ be yes and your ‘no’ be no, so that you may not fall under condemnation” (James 5:12).

These words have to be read in their place. Matthew 5 gives six sayings that begin “You have heard that it was said” and continue “But I say to you.” In each one Jesus takes a commandment that the teachers of His day had shrunk to an outward rule and shows how deep it really goes. The commandment against murder reaches to anger and insult (5:21–22) and the commandment against adultery reaches to the lustful look (5:27–28). In the fourth saying He shows that the commandment about oaths was always after the truth.

The teachers of the day had built a system for deciding which oaths counted. Jesus exposes it later in Matthew:

“Woe to you, blind guides, who say, ‘If anyone swears by the temple, it is nothing, but if anyone swears by the gold of the temple, he is bound by his oath.’ … And whoever swears by heaven swears by the throne of God and by him who sits upon it.” (Matthew 23:16, 22)

In other words, a man could swear by heaven or by Jerusalem or by his own head and later say he had not meant it, because he had not used the name of God. Some oaths were binding and others were not and everyone learned which was which. Jesus tears the system down. Heaven is God’s throne, the earth His footstool, Jerusalem His city, and even your own hair is in His hand and not yours. Since there is nowhere you can swear that God is not present, every oath binds. If every word you speak is already spoken before God, why should some of your words need an oath to be believed, when Jesus says, “Let what you say be simply ‘Yes’ or ‘No’”? I have argued in But I Say to You that reverence for God’s name and for the truth would make oaths unnecessary, and I still think that is the heart of the passage.5 It is important to add that this word convicts every one of us before it instructs us. No one keeps it. The man who has never stretched the truth when no oath was on him has not yet been born, and Jesus’ “Let your yes be yes” drives us to Him for mercy before it teaches us how to speak.

How sweeping is “not at all”? Here the rest of the New Testament has to be heard, because the Holy Spirit does not contradict Himself. Jesus did not volunteer an oath. When the high priest said to Him, “I adjure you by the living God, tell us if you are the Christ, the Son of God,” He had been silent until then, and He answered under that oath (Matthew 26:63–64). To “adjure” someone is to put him under oath. This is exactly the place of a witness in court. Paul goes further. He writes, “For God is my witness, whom I serve with my spirit in the gospel of his Son” (Romans 1:9). He writes, “But I call God to witness against me” (2 Corinthians 1:23) and “In what I am writing to you, before God, I do not lie!” (Galatians 1:20). In the second of these Paul calls God to witness against him if he is lying, which is the self-curse of Webster’s definition. He wrote these words in letters to churches, with no magistrate present, on matters that touched his apostleship and the Gospel. Luke also tells us that Paul cut his hair at Cenchreae, “for he was under a vow” (Acts 18:18).

Augustine saw this in the fourth century. He writes that Paul “often swore in this way,” and he concludes that Jesus forbade oaths “lest any one should eagerly seek after an oath as a good thing, and by the constant use of oaths sink down through force of habit into perjury.” Swearing, he writes, belongs “not among things that are good, but among things that are necessary.” He reads the last clause of Matthew 5:37 with care. Jesus did not say that whatever is more than yes and no is evil, but that it “comes from evil.” When I am forced to swear, the evil is not in my oath; it lies in the unbelief and dishonesty of a world that will not take my word, “from which we daily pray to be delivered, when we say, Deliver us from evil.”6

This reading fits the text and the rest of Scripture. A courtroom needs oaths because people lie. The oath comes from evil in the sense that it would not be needed in a world without sin, any more than locks or police or divorce law would be needed. Jesus calls His disciples to speak already as citizens of a kingdom where no oath is needed, while the world they live in still needs them.


IV. The Case Against Every Oath

Not every Christian reads the passage that way. The Anabaptists and the Quakers read it as a command that admits no exception, and their case comes down to a few convictions. Christ’s word is absolute and He named no exception for the courts. A sworn promise claims a power over the future that no man has. An oath makes two grades of truth, so that words spoken without one count for less. Oaths of allegiance can bind a Christian to a lord other than Christ. Lastly, the oath belonged to the old covenant and passed away with it.

The first Anabaptist confession, drawn up by the Swiss Brethren at Schleitheim in 1527, gives its seventh and last article to the oath. It grants, “In the Law it is commanded to be performed in God’s Name, but only in truth, not falsely.” It goes on, “Christ, who teaches the perfection of the Law, prohibits all swearing to His (followers), whether true or false.” Because Jesus said we cannot make one hair white or black, the Brethren conclude that “all swearing is forbidden: we cannot fulfill that which we promise when we swear, for we cannot change (even) the very least thing on us.” When others point to Paul, Schleitheim answers that “Testifying and swearing are two different things,” and it explains the difference with care. “For when a person swears he is in the first place promising future things… But when a person bears testimony he is testifying about the present, whether it is good or evil.”7 The confession ends the article on Christ Himself, “Christ is simply Yea and Nay.”

Menno Simons, the Dutch pastor whose followers became the Mennonites, wrote that Christ points His disciples “from the law to yea and nay, as in the perfect,” and that before His words “all human laws and regulations concerning swearing must stand back and be abolished.” Menno knew the argument of the learned men of the state churches, the same one Lutherans made, and he quotes it back at them: “Thou mayest swear when the love, profit and need of thy neighbor require it.” He asks whether that is not “teaching contrary to Christ.”8 He also asks the magistrates why they demand more than yes and no from people “who esteem every word which comes from their mouths as an oath, and keep their yea and nay unto death,” and he offers that anyone whose yes and no proves false should be punished as a perjurer. Menno could point to men and women in the Netherlands who went to the stake when “with one word they could escape all these if they would but break their yea and nay.” Lutheran rulers had their own share in that persecution, as Bearing the Sword records, and the Mennonite “unto death” was not a figure of speech.9

The Quakers came to this position by another road in seventeenth-century England. George Fox, who founded the Society of Friends, described standing in court: “And they gave me the Book, and I took it and was turning to a place that was against swearing, and they took it from me again.” He told the court that if they could show “that Christ and the apostles commanded to swear after they had forbidden it… we would swear. It was Christ’s command that we should not swear.”10 Their book of discipline still teaches that “Friends believe that their word should be accepted at any time among all persons.”11 Robert Barclay, the Scottish Quaker theologian, made the strongest argument from the text. In the same chapter of Matthew Jesus forbade divorce “saving for the cause of fornication.” If He had meant to allow oaths in court, Barclay writes, “certainly he had then expressed, adding, ‘except in judgment, before the magistrate,’ or the like; as he did in that of divorcement.” It is important to see what Barclay did and did not refuse. Quakers would gladly say, “We speak the Truth in the fear of God, and before him, who is our Witness, and the searcher of our hearts.” What they refused was the ceremony of the hand on the Book and “this common form of imprecation, ‘So help me God.’”12

Today the confession adopted in 1995 by the Mennonite Church and the General Conference Mennonite Church (now Mennonite Church USA and Mennonite Church Canada) says, “We commit ourselves to tell the truth, to give a simple yes or no, and to avoid swearing of oaths.” Its reason is one every Christian ought to take to heart. “An oath is often sworn as a guarantee that one is telling the truth. This implies that when one has not taken an oath, one may be less careful about telling the truth.” It adds that oaths of allegiance can collide with the believer’s first loyalty. “As Christians, our first allegiance is to God.”13 The Quakers, as their own book of discipline puts it, “underwent much hardship” before English law in 1696 allowed them to declare “in the Presence of Almighty God” instead of swearing.14


V. Why Lutherans May Swear

Lutherans do not swear because we care less about Jesus’ words than the Mennonite does. We read these words as seriously as he does and hear in them a word to the disciple about his own speech, which leaves standing the office God has given the magistrate. God rules His Church by the Gospel, forgiving sins through Word and Sacrament; He rules the world by the Law and the sword, through governments that restrain evil (Romans 13:1). The Christian lives under both at once.15 The Apology of the Augsburg Confession (Melanchthon’s defense of it, 1531) writes that the kingdom of Christ “permits us outwardly to use legitimate political ordinances of every nation in which we live,” and that “Neither does the Gospel bring new laws concerning the civil state.”16

On that ground the Augsburg Confession teaches in its sixteenth article that “lawful civil ordinances are good works of God,” and among them that it is right for Christians “to make oath when required by the magistrates.” The Apology calls these ordinances “good creatures of God and divine ordinances, which a Christian can use with safety.”17 Nearly fifty years later the Formula of Concord rejected, among errors that “cannot be tolerated in the government,” the teaching “that a Christian cannot with a good conscience take an oath, nor with an oath do homage [promise fidelity] to the hereditary prince of his country or sovereign.”18 For a confessional Lutheran the question is settled. A Christian may swear when the government requires it and to teach that he may not is an error.

Luther worked this out in his sermons on Matthew 5–7, preached in 1530 and 1531. He preached that the Sermon on the Mount forbids swearing “in exactly the same sense” as it forbids killing and lust. A Christian may not kill out of his own anger, but the judge who punishes a murderer does not sin, since God has given him the sword. Likewise, “Of himself no one is to curse or swear, unless he has God’s word for it.” When a judge demands an oath from a witness, or a prince an oath of allegiance, “then it is your duty to take the oath.” Luther then answers the obvious objection in the voice of an ordinary reader:

“But do you say; Yes, but here stands a different word, that Christ says: Thou shalt not swear. Answer, as above said concerning killing and being angry: Thou, thou shalt not do it, as for thyself. Here, however, it is not thou that swearest, but the judge who orders thee to do it, and it amounts to the same thing as if he did it himself, and thou art now the mouth of the judge.”19

In other words, the witness on the stand does not volunteer an oath to make his word more impressive, but answers the authority God has set over him. The oath belongs to the court’s office of finding the truth. In addition to obedience, Luther gives a second reason for swearing, which is love. If a neighbor is “weak in faith, or conscientiously fearful, or seriously doubting,” a pastor may say to him, “As sure as God lives and Christ died, so surely this is the truth and the word of God.” Luther adds that this is what Christ and Paul did when they “called God to witness.”20

The Large Catechism puts the whole matter in a few sentences under the Second Commandment. Luther first defines the sin. It is misusing God’s name “when we call upon the Lord God, no matter in what way, for purposes of falsehood or wrong of any kind,” as “among those who take oaths in court, where one side lies against the other.” Then he turns to the right use of the name, which the commandment requires as surely as it forbids the wrong one, “as when one swears truly where there is need and it is demanded.” This, he writes, settles “the question with which many teachers have troubled themselves… why swearing is prohibited in the Gospel, and yet Christ, St. Paul, and other saints often swore.”

“The explanation is briefly this: We are not to swear in support of evil, that is, of falsehood, and where there is no need or use; but for the support of good and the advantage of our neighbor we should swear. For it is a truly good work, by which God is praised, truth and right are established, falsehood is refuted, peace is made among men, obedience is rendered, and quarrels are settled. For in this way God Himself interposes and separates between right and wrong, good and evil.”21

Notice the last sentence. When two neighbors contradict each other in court, the oath sets the matter before the God who knows the truth and separates right from wrong. This is why Hebrews calls an oath “final for confirmation,” and why Luther can call it “a truly good work.” The Church of England agreed about the magistrate’s oath. The last of its Thirty-Nine Articles confesses “that vain and rash Swearing is forbidden Christian men by our Lord Jesus Christ, and James his Apostle,” and yet judges “that a man may swear when the Magistrate requireth, in a cause of faith and charity, so it be done according to the Prophet’s teaching, in justice, judgement, and truth.” The prophet is Jeremiah 4:2, and the Reformed churches and Rome teach the same.22

What, then, of the Anabaptist and Quaker convictions? Barclay is right that Jesus named no exception in Matthew 5:34, as He did for divorce. However, Barclay himself did not take “not at all” to forbid every appeal to God as witness, since Quakers made such appeals “in matters of consequence,” and the 1696 affirmation was made “in the Presence of Almighty God.” Paul did the same in his letters. Therefore the real dispute is narrower than the words “not at all” suggest. It concerns the imprecation, “So help me God,” and the ceremony of the Book. The ceremony is free. The law permits a Christian to affirm without it and nothing in Scripture requires a hand on a Bible. The imprecation needs a fuller answer, because Webster is right that an oath “imprecates his vengeance” on the one who lies. “So help me God” asks God’s help to speak the truth and places me under His judgment if I do not. Although that sounds bold, it claims nothing that is not already true of every word I speak. Jesus says, “on the day of judgment people will give account for every careless word they speak” (Matthew 12:36). The oath does not invent God’s judgment on lying; it confesses it aloud, before people who cannot see my heart. Paul did this when he called God “to witness against” him, and God Himself “guaranteed it with an oath” for our sake (Hebrews 6:17). A Christian who submits himself to God’s judgment at the court’s lawful demand is not presuming on God, but confessing what the Second Commandment already says.

Schleitheim’s argument from the hair is aimed at promises about the future. Here its own definition matters. By Schleitheim’s account, a witness who tells the court what he saw is “testifying about the present,” not “promising future things.” The witness’s oath is testimony under oath. On the Brethren’s own terms, then, their strongest reason does not touch it; their refusal of it rests on the bare command. For the oath that does promise, such as the soldier’s or the President’s or the bride’s, the answer is that “So help me God” is not a claim to control the future. It confesses that I cannot keep my promise without God and asks Him to keep me in it. The bride and groom do not know what is coming, and they promise anyway, because God commands faithfulness and gives grace to keep it.

The Mennonite warning about two grades of truth is the most searching point the other side makes, and Lutherans should agree with it. If Christians treat unsworn words as less binding, then the oath has done harm, and that is exactly the corruption Jesus attacked in Matthew 23. Luther saw it too. In his sermons he condemns those who add oaths to yes and no “as if a mere yea and nay were not valid or binding unless the name of God were added.”23 Even so, before God there is only one grade of truth; every word I speak is spoken before Him. The oath makes my word public and accountable before others who cannot know my heart, and it reminds the court and the witness both that God is listening. The remedy for the abuse the Mennonites fear is to tell the truth always, sworn or unsworn.

It is also true that our first allegiance is to God. The Augsburg Confession teaches this in the very article that permits oaths. Christians obey their magistrates “save only when commanded to sin; for then they ought to obey God rather than men. Acts 5:29.”24 An oath to do evil does not bind, for, as the Augsburg Confession teaches of vows, “no vow ought to bind men to wickedness.”25 Therefore a Christian may promise loyalty to his country in an oath of citizenship or enlistment, and the promise carries its limit within it. An oath that binds a man to secrets and loyalties above his Lord is another matter.

Lastly, Barclay placed the oath beside circumcision and the sacrifices as a ceremony that passed away when Christ came.26 Lutherans agree that the ceremonial law of Moses no longer binds us. However, the New Testament, written after Christ came, shows apostles calling God to witness and presents God’s own oath as the comfort of believers who “have fled for refuge” to Christ. An oath that Hebrews uses to describe the gospel promise cannot be a shadow that the gospel abolished.

Where we part, then, is over whether Christ’s word to His disciples binds them even when the magistrate lawfully summons them to swear. The Anabaptists said that it does, just as it bars them from the magistrate’s sword. Lutherans say that the Christian who swears at the court’s command speaks as “the mouth of the judge,” in an office God has ordained, and so does not break Christ’s word about his own speech. This is why the oath stands in the sixteenth article of the Augsburg Confession beside the judge’s office and the soldier’s service.

We have been quicker to defend the right to swear than to fear the misuse of God’s name that Luther warned against. Many of us who would never refuse an oath in court say “I swear to God” over trifles, which is the very “swearing” the Small Catechism forbids.27 The Quaker and the Mennonite who keep their yes and no “unto death” are a rebuke to that, and we should receive it.


VI. Vows

A vow is a promise made to God. The Old Testament treats it with great seriousness:

“If you make a vow to the LORD your God, you shall not delay fulfilling it, for the LORD your God will surely require it of you, and you will be guilty of sin. But if you refrain from vowing, you will not be guilty of sin. You shall be careful to do what has passed your lips, for you have voluntarily vowed to the LORD your God what you have promised with your mouth.” (Deuteronomy 23:21–23)

Two things stand side by side here. A vow is free; no one sins by declining to make one and God does not ask for vows as though He needed them. However, once a vow is made it binds and God will require it. The Preacher of Ecclesiastes puts it more briefly, “It is better that you should not vow than that you should vow and not pay” (Ecclesiastes 5:5). Proverbs warns against the vow made in the heat of a moment, “It is a snare to say rashly, ‘It is holy,’ and to reflect only after making vows” (Proverbs 20:25). The psalmist praises the man “who swears to his own hurt and does not change” (Psalm 15:4), the man who keeps his word even when keeping it costs him.

Scripture also shows us vows that should never have been made and never kept. Jephthah vowed to offer as a burnt offering “whatever comes out from the doors of my house to meet me” (Judges 11:31) and his daughter came out. When Herodias’s daughter asked for the head of John the Baptist, Herod “was exceedingly sorry, but because of his oaths and his guests he did not want to break his word to her” (Mark 6:26). A vow to do what God forbids does not bind and keeping it adds a second sin to the first.

That principle was at the center of the Reformation’s quarrel with monastic vows. The Augsburg Confession did not reject vows as such. Its twenty-seventh article sets out what was wrong with the vows of the monasteries as the Reformers saw them taught and practiced in their day. They were taught as a way to merit forgiveness and righteousness, and even as “equal to Baptism.” They were laid on boys and girls “before the lawful age,” who could not judge what they were promising. They promised lifelong celibacy, which God does not give to everyone, against His own ordinance that those without that gift should marry. The Confession reminds its opponents that by their own rules a vow “ought to be in a thing possible, that it ought to be free, and chosen spontaneously and deliberately,” and it teaches that “a wicked vow, taken against the commandment of God, is not valid.”28 The Smalcald Articles (Luther’s statement of faith of 1537) go further. Because such vows claim to earn heaven, “this is to deny Christ,” and so monastic vows “must be absolutely abolished.”29 The Apology could still praise the Rechabites of Jeremiah 35, who kept their father’s command to drink no wine and live in tents. Their obedience honored the Fourth Commandment, and their custom had a godly purpose, to keep them from “the impiety of their countrymen.” “Such an end is lawful,” the Apology writes.30

The Lutheran Church did not abolish solemn promises. She still hears several at her altars, promises made before God and in His name. At a wedding a man and a woman promise each other faithfulness, and Malachi writes that in marriage “the LORD was witness between you and the wife of your youth” (Malachi 2:14). Speak Now treats the wedding in more detail. Luther in the Large Catechism names among the misuses of God’s name the couple who “secretly betroth themselves to one another, and afterward abjure [their plighted troth].”31 At ordination and installation a pastor promises to preach according to Holy Scripture and the Lutheran Confessions.

At confirmation young people who were baptized as infants confess the faith into which they were baptized and promise, by God’s grace, to remain in it. A careful reader will ask why a fourteen-year-old’s promise should stand when the Augsburg Confession objected to vows made before fifteen or eighteen.32 The answer is that the confirmand promises nothing beyond what God already asks of every baptized Christian, which is to continue in Christ and His Word. This is not a new obligation of his own choosing, like the vow of celibacy, made against God’s ordinance or offered to earn grace. In addition, the confirmand’s promise rests on a promise older and stronger than his own. As I have written in Baptism and Confirmation, his promises are a response to God’s promise in Baptism and not a foundation beside it.33 Paul writes, “if we are faithless, he remains faithful— for he cannot deny himself” (2 Timothy 2:13). The confirmand’s promise is serious and it binds, but the one who holds him is the God who named him at the font.


VII. When an Oath or a Vow Weighs on the Conscience

A Christian who is called as a witness or a juror may take the oath with a good conscience. When he raises his hand he is not disobeying Christ, since he answers the authority God has placed over him and calls on God to help him tell the truth. Some Lutherans cannot bring themselves to swear even so. If that is your conscience, affirm rather than act against it (Romans 14:23). Ask your pastor to show you from the Word that the oath is not sin, so that your conscience may in time be set free. The one thing you may not do is teach others that swearing is forbidden, since that is the error our Confessions reject. Whichever you choose, do not treat the affirmation as a lighter thing, because perjury is perjury whether one swore or affirmed. A Mennonite or Quaker neighbor deserves the same honor. We think he is wrong about what Matthew 5 requires, but a man who keeps his yes and no without an oath is keeping the heart of what Jesus taught.

The heaviest burden is the broken vow, whether a marriage vow or a promise made to God in a moment of fear. If you know that you broke it, call it what God calls it and confess it. Peter, on the night Jesus was betrayed, “denied it with an oath: ‘I do not know the man.’” Then he “began to invoke a curse on himself and to swear,” and when the rooster crowed “he went out and wept bitterly” (Matthew 26:72, 74–75). Peter’s sin was a false oath in the very presence of his Lord’s suffering. After the resurrection Jesus asked him three times, “Do you love me?” and three times gave him back his office with the words “Feed my sheep” (John 21:17). A broken vow is forgiven like any other sin and a pastor is glad to speak that absolution by name. Forgiveness frees us to keep the promise where we still can, and from despair where we cannot. Not every broken marriage was broken by the one reading these words. If the vow was broken against you, this call to confession is not aimed at you; what you need to hear is that God saw it and has not forsaken you, and your pastor will gladly say more.

Many of those confirmed with us no longer come to the Lord’s Table. If that is you, or your child, the way back does not begin with what you promised at fourteen. It begins with what God promised you at the font, which He has not taken back. Come back to the Table and to the Church you left, where that promise is still spoken to you.

The commonest vow our people make is the bargain, “If God heals my mother, I will…” It is a small cousin of what the Augsburg Confession rejected, a promise offered to obtain something from God, and God’s favor is not bought. If what you promised is good, do it as thanks for a gift He has already given and not as payment. If your prayer was not answered as you asked, God has not broken a bargain with you or held a debt over you. A vow to do something sinful, such as a vow never to forgive someone, does not bind and should be repented of. A vow that is foolish but not sinful is a matter for counsel with your pastor.

The 1995 Mennonite confession applies the same teaching to “avoiding membership in oath-bound or secret societies,” and here Lutherans and Mennonites stand together.34 No oath can bind a Christian to sin or to a loyalty above Christ. A pastor will not shame him, but will help him see what the Word of God says.


Conclusion

A Lutheran may answer “I do” when the court asks and I believe he should answer without a troubled conscience. Jesus forbade His disciples to dress up their words with God’s name. He called them to a truthfulness so complete that their yes and no would need nothing added. Our Confessions stand with Him on both points. The Augsburg Confession permits the oath the magistrate requires; the Large Catechism forbids swearing “in support of evil… and where there is no need or use.”21 The Mennonites and Quakers have kept the call to truthfulness with a faithfulness we should admire, and they drew their refusal from a text we love as much as they do. Schleitheim ends its article on the oath, “Christ is simply Yea and Nay.”

Paul answered the charge that he said “Yes, yes” and “No, no” at the same time by pointing to that same Christ, “For the Son of God, Jesus Christ, whom we proclaimed among you… was not Yes and No, but in him it is always Yes” (2 Corinthians 1:19). Jesus calls Himself “the Amen, the faithful and true witness” (Revelation 3:14). God swore to Abraham by Himself so that we who have fled to Christ for refuge might have strong encouragement, and He kept that oath at the cross and the empty tomb, though our own words are weak and our promises often fail. Whether we stand at the altar to make a vow, or in a courtroom to swear, or simply say yes to a neighbor and mean it, “all the promises of God find their Yes in him. That is why it is through him that we utter our Amen to God for his glory.”


Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture and Confessions

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.
  • Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
  • Tappert, Theodore G., ed. The Book of Concord. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1959.
  • Kolb, Robert, and Timothy J. Wengert, eds. The Book of Concord. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000.

Luther and the Fathers

  • Luther, Martin. Commentary on the Sermon on the Mount. Translated by Charles A. Hay. Philadelphia: Lutheran Publication Society, 1892.
  • Augustine. Our Lord’s Sermon on the Mount. Translated by William Findlay. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series, vol. 6. New York: Christian Literature, 1888.

Other Confessions

  • Church of England. Articles of Religion (1571).
  • The Westminster Confession of Faith (1646; American revision).
  • Catechism of the Catholic Church. 2nd ed. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997.

Anabaptist and Quaker Sources

  • The Schleitheim Confession (1527). Translated by John C. Wenger. Crockett, KY: Rod and Staff, 1985.
  • Simons, Menno. The Complete Works of Menno Simon. 2 vols. Elkhart, IN: John F. Funk and Brother, 1871.
  • Barclay, Robert. An Apology for the True Christian Divinity. Aberdeen, 1678. Quaker Heritage Press edition.
  • Britain Yearly Meeting. Quaker Faith and Practice. 5th ed.
  • Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1995.

Law and Reference

  • The Constitution of the United States.
  • Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 603.
  • An Act that the Solemne Affirmation & Declaration of the People called Quakers shall be accepted instead of an Oath in the usual Forme, 7 & 8 Will. III, c. 34 (1696).
  • Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. New York: S. Converse, 1828.

Footnotes

  1. The Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations: AC (Augsburg Confession), Ap (Apology of the Augsburg Confession), SA (Smalcald Articles), LC and SC (Large and Small Catechism), FC Ep and FC SD (Formula of Concord, Epitome and Solid Declaration). Paragraph numbers are those of the Triglotta and the Tappert edition; in Apology XVI the Kolb–Wengert edition numbers differently (Ap XVI.53–55 here is Ap XVI.1–3 there). Luther’s sermons on Matthew 5–7 are quoted from the translation by Charles A. Hay (1892), and Augustine from the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers. Other writers are quoted from the editions named in these notes. ↩

  2. U.S. Constitution, Article II, Section 1; see also Article VI (“Oath or Affirmation”). The Federal Rules of Evidence require every witness to give “an oath or affirmation to testify truthfully” (Rule 603). ↩

  3. AC XVI.2; LC I.66; FC Ep XII.15, with FC SD XII.20. ↩

  4. Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “oath.” ↩

  5. See But I Say to You, the section “Oaths.” ↩

  6. Augustine, Our Lord’s Sermon on the Mount I.17.51, trans. William Findlay, NPNF¹ 6. ↩

  7. The Schleitheim Confession (1527), Article VII, trans. John C. Wenger (Mennonite Quarterly Review 19, 1945), as reprinted by Rod and Staff Publishers (Crockett, KY, 1985). Article VI, on the sword, holds that the sword is “ordained of God outside the perfection of Christ” for the worldly magistrates but forbids it to Christians. ↩

  8. Menno Simons, “The Swearing of Oaths,” in The Complete Works of Menno Simon, vol. 2 (Elkhart, IN: John F. Funk and Brother, 1871), 271–274. Menno’s opponents in print were chiefly Reformed and Catholic; the argument he quotes was common to the state churches. ↩

  9. Ibid., 273–274. ↩

  10. George Fox (1664), as printed in Quaker Faith and Practice, 5th ed. (Britain Yearly Meeting), §20.49. ↩

  11. Quaker Faith and Practice, §20.50, quoting Faith and Practice of North Carolina Yearly Meeting (Conservative), 1983. ↩

  12. Robert Barclay, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity (Latin 1676; English, Aberdeen, 1678), Proposition XV, §§10 and 12, text of the Quaker Heritage Press edition. ↩

  13. Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1995), Article 20, “Truth and the Avoidance of Oaths.” ↩

  14. Quaker Faith and Practice, §20.48. The Act of 7 & 8 William III, c. 34 (royal assent 1696), allowed Quakers to say, “I A.B. do declare in the Presence of Almighty God the Witnesse of the Truth of what I say,” but did not yet allow them to give evidence in criminal cases or serve on juries. ↩

  15. The two kingdoms are treated more fully in Render to Caesar. ↩

  16. Ap XVI.54–55. ↩

  17. AC XVI.1–2; Ap XVI.53. AC XVI.3 condemns “the Anabaptists who forbid these civil offices to Christians.” ↩

  18. FC Ep XII.15; compare FC SD XII.20, “That a Christian cannot with a good conscience take an oath before a court…” ↩

  19. Martin Luther, Commentary on the Sermon on the Mount, trans. Charles A. Hay (Philadelphia: Lutheran Publication Society, 1892), 177–182 (page numbers from the running heads of the scan). The sermons were preached in 1530–1531 and published in 1532; compare LW 21:99–103. ↩

  20. Luther, Sermon on the Mount (Hay), 183–184. ↩

  21. LC I.51, 64–66. ↩ ↩2

  22. Articles of Religion (1571), Article XXXIX. Compare the Westminster Confession of Faith, chapter XXII, and the Catechism of the Catholic Church, §2154, which teaches that the Church has understood Jesus’ words “as not excluding oaths made for grave and right reasons (for example, in court).” ↩

  23. Luther, Sermon on the Mount (Hay), 180. ↩

  24. AC XVI.6–7. ↩

  25. AC XXVII.40. ↩

  26. Barclay, Apology XV.11. ↩

  27. SC I, Second Commandment: “We should fear and love God that we may not curse, swear, use witchcraft, lie, or deceive by His name.” See also LC I.62. ↩

  28. AC XXVII.4, 11, 18–23, 27–28, 40. ↩

  29. SA III.XIV.1–2. ↩

  30. Ap XXVII.61–63. ↩

  31. LC I.53. ↩

  32. AC XXVII.31–32. ↩

  33. Baptism and Confirmation, §VI, “The Dangers.” Compare AC XXVII.36–40 on vows offered to merit grace. ↩

  34. Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, Article 20, commentary. ↩

Scripture
2 Corinthians 1:20Matthew 5:341 Samuel 1:11Deuteronomy 6:13Deuteronomy 6:4–5Jeremiah 4:2Leviticus 19:12Exodus 20:7Genesis 22:16Hebrews 6:16–18Matthew 5:33–37James 5:12Matthew 23:16Matthew 26:63–64Romans 1:92 Corinthians 1:23Galatians 1:20Acts 18:18Matthew 5:37Romans 13:1Matthew 12:36Hebrews 6:17Acts 5:29Deuteronomy 23:21–23Ecclesiastes 5:5Proverbs 20:25Psalm 15:4Judges 11:31Mark 6:26Jeremiah 35Malachi 2:142 Timothy 2:13Romans 14:23Matthew 26:72John 21:172 Corinthians 1:19Revelation 3:14
Confessions
Ap XVIAC XVILC IEp XIISD XIIAC XXVIISA IIIAp XXVIISCLC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “Let Your Yes Be Yes: Oaths, Vows and the Courtroom.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/let-your-yes-be-yes/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.