Bearing the Sword
War, Police Work and Self-Defense
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“Soldiers also asked him, ‘And we, what shall we do?’ And he said to them, ‘Do not extort money from anyone by threats or by false accusation, and be content with your wages.’” — Luke 3:14, ESV
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the Concordia Triglotta of 1921 and cited by part and paragraph, with the abbreviations and editions explained in the first note.1
I. The Soldiers’ Question
When the crowds came out to the Jordan to hear John the Baptist, soldiers came with them and asked him the question every hearer of a sermon should ask, “And we, what shall we do?” The same question comes to a pastor today from a young man thinking about enlisting, from a deputy who may one day have to fire her weapon, from a veteran, and from a father who wonders whether he may keep a gun in the house and whether he could ever use it. Behind all of them stands a harder question. Jesus said, “Do not resist the one who is evil” (Matthew 5:39). How can any Christian carry a weapon at all?
A Christian may serve as a soldier or a police officer with a clear conscience. The Augsburg Confession, the chief confession of the Lutheran Church, teaches this in so many words and condemns the opposite teaching. The Fifth Commandment also binds every Christian to protect those in his care. Whether he may use force to defend his own life our Confessions do not say, but I believe Scripture and sound reason allow it. Whatever sword a Christian bears serves God’s purpose of protecting life and punishing wrong, and it may never be used for revenge. A Christian may not fight in a war he knows to be unjust; for his own sake he also remains free to suffer wrong rather than return it.
The Mennonites and other heirs of the sixteenth-century Anabaptists, who love the Lord Jesus and read their Bibles as carefully as we do, have come to the opposite conclusion. They teach that a follower of Christ may not take human life at all, even to defend the innocent, and many of them died for teaching it. Therefore I want to take up five questions: 1) What does the Fifth Commandment forbid? 2) What do the Mennonites believe about the sword, and why? 3) Where exactly do Lutherans differ from them? 4) What does this mean for the soldier, the officer and the homeowner? and 5) What does the Gospel say to those who have had to use the sword, or who could not?
II. The Sword Belongs to God
Lutherans approach every question about government by remembering that God rules the world in two ways. By His Word and Sacraments He rules His Church, forgiving sins and creating faith. By law, reason and the sword He rules the world, restraining evil and preserving life through governments, families and callings.2 The center of that teaching for our question is Romans 13:
“Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God. Therefore whoever resists the authorities resists what God has appointed, and those who resist will incur judgment. For rulers are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Would you have no fear of the one who is in authority? Then do what is good, and you will receive his approval, for he is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain. For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God’s wrath on the wrongdoer.” (Romans 13:1–4)
Paul wrote these words to Christians in Rome under Nero. Even so, he calls the pagan magistrate “God’s servant” twice in one verse. Peter writes in the same way when he tells believers to be subject “to governors as sent by him to punish those who do evil and to praise those who do good” (1 Peter 2:14). It is important to notice that neither apostle treats the sword as something God merely puts up with; God appointed it. Therefore the Augsburg Confession can say without hesitation that a Christian may hold it:
“Of Civil Affairs they teach that lawful civil ordinances are good works of God, and that it is right for Christians to bear civil office, to sit as judges, to judge matters by the Imperial and other existing laws, to award just punishments, to engage in just wars, to serve as soldiers, to make legal contracts, to hold property, to make oath when required by the magistrates, to marry a wife, to be given in marriage.” (AC XVI.1–2)3
Notice that soldiering stands in one list with marrying and owning a house. The Reformers did not treat it as a necessary evil to be tolerated, but as one of the ordinary callings in which God puts Christians to serve their neighbors. Also, the other churches of the Reformation agreed. The Church of England’s Articles of Religion teach that “It is lawful for Christian men, at the commandment of the Magistrate, to wear weapons, and serve in the wars,” and the Westminster Confession of the Presbyterians teaches that magistrates “may lawfully, now under the new testament, wage war, upon just and necessary occasion.”4 On this point the Anabaptists stood alone among the churches of the Reformation.
III. “You Shall Not Murder”
If the sword is God’s, what then does the Fifth Commandment forbid? In English the commandment is four words long, “You shall not murder” (Exodus 20:13). The older English translations of the Catechism render it “Thou shalt not kill,” and many Christians have supposed from this that every taking of human life breaks it. Scripture will not let us read it that way. The law that says “You shall not murder” also says, “Whoever strikes a man so that he dies shall be put to death” (Exodus 21:12), and the God who gave both commands sent Israel’s armies into the field. Long before Sinai He gave Noah a command for every nation descended from him.
“Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed, for God made man in his own image.” (Genesis 9:6)
The reason God gives for punishing the murderer is the image of God in the victim. In other words, the sword exists to guard human life because it is precious. I wrote in On the Dignity of the Human Being that the Fifth Commandment “forbids the deliberate taking of innocent human life and commands us to help and sustain our neighbor’s life,” and nothing in this paper takes back a word of it.5 The magistrate’s sword is one of the ways God protects the innocent.
Luther saw this when he explained the commandment in the Large Catechism (his longer catechism for pastors and heads of households). Before he says anything else, he sets the government outside its prohibition.
“Therefore God and government are not included in this commandment, nor is the power to kill, which they have, taken away. For God has delegated His authority to punish evil-doers to the government instead of parents, who aforetime (as we read in Moses) were required to bring their own children to judgment and sentence them to death. Therefore, what is here forbidden is forbidden to the individual in his relation to any one else, and not to the government.” (LC I.181)6
Then he says what the commandment is for. God gave it because He “well knows that the world is evil,” and He means it to stand “as a wall, fortress, and refuge about our neighbor, that we do him no hurt nor harm in his body.”7 The Small Catechism puts it in a sentence every confirmand learns, “We should fear and love God that we may not hurt nor harm our neighbor in his body, but help and befriend him in every bodily need.”8
The second half of that sentence is the half we forget. Luther presses it hard. Under this commandment, he writes, “not only he is guilty who does evil to his neighbor, but he also who can do him good, prevent, resist evil, defend and save him, so that no bodily harm or hurt happen to him, and yet does not do it.” He goes on, “if you see any one innocently sentenced to death or in like distress, and do not save him, although you know ways and means to do so, you have killed him.”9 Proverbs gives the duty in one line, “Rescue those who are being taken away to death; hold back those who are stumbling to the slaughter” (Proverbs 24:11). The Fifth Commandment therefore not only forbids the soldier and the officer certain things, but also explains why their callings exist. Someone must stand between the innocent and the one who would harm them, which the commandment counts as love.
IV. The Mennonite Confession of the Sword
In the 1520s a group of believers in and around Zurich broke with Zwingli’s reformation and began to baptize one another as adults. Their opponents called them Anabaptists (“rebaptizers”). In February 1527 a gathering of these Swiss Brethren at Schleitheim agreed on seven articles drafted chiefly by Michael Sattler, a former monk, who was burned at the stake less than three months later.10 The Dutch Mennonites, who took their name from Menno Simons, adopted a longer confession at Dordrecht in 1632.11
The sixth article of Schleitheim opens with words a Lutheran could almost sign.
“The sword is ordained of God outside the perfection of Christ. It punishes and puts to death the wicked, and guards and protects the good. In the Law the sword was ordained for the punishment of the wicked and for their death, and the same [sword] is [now] ordained to be used by the worldly magistrates.”12
The Brethren did not deny that God appointed government. What they denied is that a disciple may take part in it. “In the perfection of Christ,” the article continues, “only the ban is used” (that is, the church’s discipline of excluding an unrepentant member), “without putting the flesh to death.” Then it asks our question directly, “whether a Christian may or should employ the sword against the wicked for the defense and protection of the good, or for the sake of love.” The answer is no. Christ “teaches and commands us to learn of Him, for He is meek and lowly in heart,” He did not stone the woman taken in adultery, and He withdrew when the crowd wanted to make Him king. Peter wrote that “Christ has suffered (not ruled) and left us an example.” The article sets the magistrate and the Christian side by side, and among its contrasts is this one, “the weapons of their conflict and war are carnal and against the flesh only, but the Christians’ weapons are spiritual, against the fortification of the devil.”13
The Dordrecht Confession honors government at length. Its thirteenth article teaches that God “has ordained power and authority, and set them to punish the evil, and protect the good,” that Christians must obey and pay their taxes, and that they “must constantly and earnestly pray to the Lord for them and their welfare.” Its fourteenth article, “Of Revenge,” then defines its term with care: “As regards revenge, that is, to oppose an enemy with the sword, we believe and confess that the Lord Christ has forbidden and set aside to His disciples and followers all revenge and retaliation.” The Christian “must not inflict pain, harm, or sorrow upon any one, but seek the highest welfare and salvation of all men.”14 For the Mennonite, then, “revenge” does not mean only paying back a wrong already done. It means opposing an enemy with the sword at all, even to protect someone else. This is what Mennonites call nonresistance, from the Lord’s word, “Do not resist the one who is evil.”
Mennonites today state it more briefly still. Their confession of 1995 says, “As disciples of Christ, we do not prepare for war, or participate in war or military service.” The same article commits them “to resist evil without violence,” and its commentary grounds this not only in Jesus’ teaching but in His cross: “A biblical understanding of peace is also based on the atoning sacrifice of Christ.”15 In other words, nonresistance is not passivity. The Mennonite means to defend his neighbor by every means short of killing, and then to entrust the outcome to God, as Christ did.
The texts behind this teaching are not hard to find. Jesus said, “You have heard that it was said, ‘An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth.’ But I say to you, Do not resist the one who is evil. But if anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also” (Matthew 5:38–39). He said, “Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you” (Matthew 5:44). When Peter drew a sword to defend Him, He said, “Put your sword back into its place. For all who take the sword will perish by the sword” (Matthew 26:52). Paul wrote, “Beloved, never avenge yourselves, but leave it to the wrath of God” (Romans 12:19). Isaiah foresaw the day when the nations “shall beat their swords into plowshares, and their spears into pruning hooks” (Isaiah 2:4) and the Mennonite reads the Church as the place where that day has already begun.
They can also point to the early Church. Several important teachers of the first three centuries taught that Christians should not fight. Tertullian asked, “Shall it be held lawful to make an occupation of the sword, when the Lord proclaims that he who uses the sword shall perish by the sword?” Origen answered the pagan critic Celsus that Christians serve the emperor better by their prayers, as “an army of piety,” than soldiers do by the sword.16 At the same time there were Christians in the army throughout this period. Tertullian himself admits that men who were already soldiers when they came to faith were received, and how widely the stricter view was held is still debated. Our own Apology recalls that the pagan objection “wonderfully exercised” Origen and others.17
The Mennonite case, then, comes to this. Jesus is Lord of the whole of a disciple’s life. He taught His disciples not to resist evil and to love their enemies. He Himself went to the cross rather than let a sword be drawn for Him. Because His death made peace with God and between enemies, the Church is the people that lives now by that peace. God has given the sword to the world for the world’s sake. Christians should honor it, pray for it, and obey it in everything that is not sin. They may not wield it, even for the innocent. Although Lutherans cannot accept it, it is a costly belief, and those who hold it have accepted prison, exile and death rather than give it up.
V. Where We Part
Lutherans agree with more of this than one might expect. We agree that the Church’s weapons are the Word and the Sacraments and never the sword. Jesus told Pilate that His kingdom is not of this world, which is why His servants were not fighting to save Him (John 18:36). The Augsburg Confession quotes this very verse when it forbids the Church to take up the work of the state, and a few lines later it quotes the words of Paul about the weapons of our warfare that stand behind Schleitheim’s contrast.18 We agree that a Christian may never take revenge, that government is ordained of God, and that Christians must pray for those in authority. In addition, we agree that the Christian must be ready to suffer wrong for Christ’s sake and must obey God rather than men when the government commands sin (Acts 5:29).
Lutheran princes, with the support of Lutheran theologians, turned the magistrate’s sword against Anabaptists for their faith. Our Confession teaches that civil rulers “defend not minds, but bodies,” and yet the Treatise in the same Book of Concord had charged kings and princes “to see to it that errors be removed.” In 2010 the Lutheran World Federation, a worldwide communion of Lutheran churches to which the Missouri Synod does not belong, formally asked the Mennonites’ forgiveness for this persecution.19
The difference between us lies in one phrase of Schleitheim, that the sword is “outside the perfection of Christ.” The Mennonite places the disciple’s life on one side of a line and the magistrate’s office on the other. The Lutheran Confessions deny that line. The Augsburg Confession condemns the Anabaptists “who forbid these civil offices to Christians.” It condemns also “those who do not place evangelical perfection in the fear of God and in faith, but in forsaking civil offices.”20 That second condemnation was aimed chiefly at the monks, who taught that a higher Christian life was found by leaving the ordinary callings behind. The Anabaptists taught no higher class of Christians; they held every believer to the same discipleship. However, they too held that the disciple must stay out of an office God has ordained, and to that extent the condemnation touches them. The Confession gives its own definition of perfection elsewhere:
“For Christian perfection is to fear God from the heart, and yet to conceive great faith, and to trust that for Christ’s sake we have a God who has been reconciled, to ask of God, and assuredly to expect His aid in all things that, according to our calling, are to be done; and meanwhile, to be diligent in outward good works, and to serve our calling.” (AC XXVII.49)21
This is to say that faith does not take the Christian out of his calling but sends him into it, including the calling that bears the sword. The Formula of Concord names as an error that “a Christian cannot with a good, inviolate conscience hold or discharge the office of magistrate.”22
How then do Lutherans read Matthew 5? The Apology of the Augsburg Confession, Melanchthon’s defense of it, gives the key.
“Therefore private redress is prohibited not by advice, but by a command, Matt. 5, 39; Rom. 12, 19. Public redress, which is made through the office of the magistrate, is not advised against, but is commanded, and is a work of God, according to Paul, Rom. 13, 1 sqq. Now the different kinds of public redress are legal decisions, capital punishment, wars, military service.” (Ap XVI.59–60)23
The word translated “redress” is the Latin vindicta, “vengeance.” In other words, Christ forbids me absolutely to take vengeance on my own authority, while God Himself is acting when the magistrate punishes through his office. Paul puts the two side by side. At the end of Romans 12 he tells believers, “never avenge yourselves, but leave it to the wrath of God, for it is written, ‘Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord’” (12:19). A few sentences later, with no change of subject, he calls the governing authority “an avenger who carries out God’s wrath on the wrongdoer” (13:4). Paul uses the same family of words for the vengeance the believer must not take and the avenger God appoints, and the same word for God’s wrath in both places.24 Paul did not write two contradictory rules, but one: vengeance belongs to God. Then he told the Romans one of the ways God exercises it.
The Mennonite will answer that this proves only that God uses the sword, and that the disciple must leave its use to others. Here Luther’s treatise Temporal Authority (1523) comes to the point that matters most to the Mennonite, which is love.
“In what concerns you and yours, you govern yourself by the Gospel and suffer injustice for yourself as a true Christian; in what concerns others and belongs to them, you govern yourself according to love and suffer no injustice for your neighbor’s sake; this the Gospel does not forbid, but rather commands in another place.”25
The Mennonite asks how a Christian can love his enemy and kill him. Luther asks how a Christian can love his neighbor and leave him to be killed. The Mennonite replies that he does not leave him; he will stand in the way, plead, take the blow himself, and then entrust the outcome to God, as Christ entrusted Himself “to him who judges justly” (1 Peter 2:23). This is a serious answer. Peter wrote those words about how Christ bore what was done to Him. They describe “you and yours,” the wrongs a disciple may bear in his own body. When the attacker has already chosen his victim and nothing short of force will stop him, the neighbor’s life is not mine to entrust to God by standing aside, since the Fifth Commandment has told me to “defend and save him” by the means I have.
The rest of the New Testament fits this reading. When the soldiers asked John what repentance required of them, he did not tell them to leave the army (Luke 3:14). The Mennonite replies that John belonged to the old order, since “the one who is least in the kingdom of heaven is greater than he” (Matthew 11:11). However, the soldiers of the New Testament who met Jesus and His apostles were treated the same way. Jesus said of a centurion, “with no one in Israel have I found such faith” (Matthew 8:10). The first Gentile household baptized by an apostle was that of Cornelius, “a centurion of what was known as the Italian Cohort, a devout man who feared God with all his household” (Acts 10:1–2). Nothing in Acts says he resigned. That is an argument from silence, but the silence is striking in a book that does record what conversion cost others, such as the Ephesians who burned their books of magic (Acts 19:19).
What about Peter’s sword? The reason Jesus gives is His Passion. “Do you think that I cannot appeal to my Father, and he will at once send me more than twelve legions of angels? But how then should the Scriptures be fulfilled, that it must be so?” (Matthew 26:53–54). The Lord was not to be defended from His own cross. Peter’s sword was drawn to stop the very thing Christ had come to do, and against men sent by the high priest to arrest Him. The saying “all who take the sword will perish by the sword” was spoken over that sword, and I take it as a warning against trusting the sword. It does not undo Romans 13, which Paul wrote years later to the same Church. Isaiah’s swords beaten into plowshares are likewise a promise about the day when the Lord Himself “shall judge between the nations” (Isaiah 2:4). The Church longs for that day and prays for it. Until it comes, the sword keeps the peace in which the Gospel is preached.
The Christian who serves as a soldier or officer has not chosen a lower kind of Christian life, and no one may teach that his calling is sin. The Confessions are firm here. In addition, the Mennonite neighbor who refuses the sword is not thereby outside the Church. We reject the teaching and we do not judge his heart.
VI. The Soldier
The soldier’s calling is the clearest case. Luther wrote a whole treatise on it for a knight who had asked whether a man could be a soldier and be saved. Whether Soldiers, Too, Can Be Saved (1526) begins by separating the office from the man, since “a distinction must be made between an occupation and the man who is in it, between a work and the doer of it.”26 The office is good, although a good office can be filled by a bad man or used for a bad end. Luther writes that the soldier’s work, looked at from the side of the enemy it strikes, “seems an unchristian work and entirely contrary to Christian love.” If you think instead of “how it protects the good and keeps and preserves house and home, wife and child, property and honor and peace,” it appears “how precious and godly this work is.” He compares it to a surgeon who takes off a limb to save the body, and then writes something that has startled readers ever since, that “the hand that wields this sword and slays with it is then no more man’s hand, but God’s.”27 Luther does not mean that a soldier may do anything at all and call it God’s work. He means that when the sword is used for its God-given purpose the soldier is God’s instrument and not a murderer.
For that reason Luther insists that a war must be fought for the right purpose. He writes that “he who starts war is wrong,” and distinguishes wars of desire from wars of necessity. “War is not right, even between equal and equal, unless it is fought with such a good conscience that one can say, ‘My neighbor compels and forces me to fight, though I would rather avoid it.’”28 The Church had asked these questions long before him. Augustine and later Thomas Aquinas taught that a war is just only when it is declared by lawful authority, for a just cause, and with a right intention, which is to say for the sake of peace and not for plunder or hatred.29 The Augsburg Confession’s phrase “just wars” (in its Latin, iure bellare, “to wage war by right”) assumes this whole tradition. It does not call every war just, but says that Christians may fight in the ones that are.
What should a soldier do if he believes his country’s war is unjust? Luther’s answer is clear and costly. “If you know for sure that he is wrong, then you should fear God rather than men,” he writes of the soldier’s lord, “and not fight or serve, for you cannot have a good conscience before God.” He admits that this may cost the man his pay and his name, and tells him to trust God to restore what he loses. However, Luther does not ask the ordinary soldier to judge every decision of his government. “If you do not know, or cannot find out whether your lord is wrong,” he writes, “you ought not to weaken an uncertain obedience with an uncertainty of right, but should think the best of your lord, as is the way of love.”30 The Augsburg Confession agrees, teaching that Christians must obey their magistrates and laws “save only when commanded to sin; for then they ought to obey God rather than men.”31 A Christian soldier owes his commanders the benefit of the doubt; he does not owe them his conscience. No order can make it right to kill a prisoner or a civilian who is no threat, and the Christian soldier must refuse such an order. This is what John meant when he told the soldiers not to use their power to extort or accuse falsely.
Luther closes the treatise with a prayer he wanted every soldier to pray before battle. It shows where the Christian soldier’s confidence finally rests.
“Heavenly Father, here I am, according to Thy divine will, in the external work and service of my lord, which I owe first to Thee and then to my lord for Thy sake… But because I know and have learned from Thy gracious Word that none of our good works can help us and no one is saved as a soldier but only as a Christian, therefore, I will rely not at all on this obedience and work of mine, but put myself freely at the service of Thy will and believe from the heart that only the innocent blood of Thy dear Son, my Lord Jesus Christ, redeems and saves me.”32
VII. The Officer
What is true of the soldier is true of the police officer. In some ways it is clearer still, since Romans 13 describes the magistrate’s sword first of all as the means of punishing wrongdoers at home. When the government commissions an officer, she is “God’s servant for your good” in the most literal sense, bearing the sword so that ordinary people can live “a peaceful and quiet life” (1 Timothy 2:2). Luther went so far as to say that a qualified Christian should be willing to seek such an office: “should you see that there is a lack of hangmen, beadles, judges, lords, or princes, and find that you are qualified, you should offer your services and seek the place, that necessary government may by no means be despised and become inefficient or perish.”33 A beadle was a minor officer who kept order and carried out the court’s decisions, which is close to what a police officer does now.
This answers the deputy who wonders whether she would have sinned if she had fired. If she fired to stop a threat to life, under the law she serves, she would have been doing her office, and the Fifth Commandment would not accuse her. It is important to say what this does not mean, however. The officer’s authority is borrowed and extends only as far as the office. Force used to punish a man who has already been subdued, to settle a personal grudge, or to frighten someone who has done nothing wrong is outside the office. Then it is the officer’s own act and falls under the Fifth Commandment like anyone else’s. Luther made this point about soldiers who “slay and smite needlessly,” that this “is the fault of the persons, not of the office.”34 The Christian officer answers for his conduct to God as well as to his department, although the same God forgives him whatever he does wrong in it.
A Christian officer also does not stop being a Christian in uniform. Everything Luther wrote about “you and yours” still applies. An insult hurled at an officer during an arrest is a wrong done to him personally, and as a Christian he may bear it without paying it back. The danger to the public, however, is his neighbor’s concern, where love will not let him stand aside.
VIII. The Homeowner
Although most of us will never serve in the army or wear a badge, any of us could be attacked on the street or wake to the sound of someone breaking into the house. May a Christian defend himself and his family with force, even deadly force?
Here we must be careful to say where the Confessions speak and where they do not. They speak of the magistrate’s office (AC XVI, Ap XVI, FC XII) and of the neighbor’s life (LC I.189–191). They say nothing directly about a private man defending his own life. The defense of those in our care rests on the Fifth Commandment, which binds us to “defend and save” our neighbor by the means we have. The defense of one’s own life rests on Scripture read with sound judgment, which I believe allows it. The law of Israel already distinguished between killing a thief in the act and killing him after the danger had passed.
“If a thief is found breaking in and is struck so that he dies, there shall be no bloodguilt for him, but if the sun has risen on him, there shall be bloodguilt for him.” (Exodus 22:2–3)
This was part of Israel’s civil law, which does not bind Christians as law.35 However, it shows a moral judgment that reason still recognizes. The householder who strikes an intruder in the dark, when he cannot know whether the man has come to steal or to kill, does not bear guilt for his death. In daylight, when the danger could be seen and measured, the householder who kills a thief does bear it. Luther appealed to the same common judgment when he argued that a prince may fight a defensive war: “Self-protection is a proper cause of war and therefore all laws agree that self-defense shall go unpunished, and he who kills another in self-defense is innocent in everyone’s eyes.”36 Defense of this kind is not the private vengeance the Apology forbids, since it stops a wrong that is still being done. The Mennonite does not accept that distinction, as we have seen. For that reason the Lutheran ground for defense is finally the neighbor’s life and not the distinction alone.
Two qualifications follow. The first is that defense ends when the danger ends. The Christian may use the force needed to stop an attack and no more. Once the attacker has fled or can no longer do harm, any further blow is revenge, and Romans 12:19 forbids it. The second comes from Luther’s own distinction between “you and yours” and “your neighbor.” In 1523 Luther wrote that for himself the Christian may “suffer injustice.” That freedom remains. If a man is robbed on the street and hands over his wallet rather than fight, he has not failed in his duty; he has let the cloak go with the tunic (Matthew 5:40). The same freedom does not extend to the lives of others. A husband, a father or mother with children, or anyone who sees an innocent person attacked and is able to help, is bound to protect them as far as he is able. In other words, the more a Christian’s defense is for the sake of others, the more it is a duty and the less it is a matter of personal choice.
What about owning a gun? Since Scripture neither commands nor forbids a Christian to keep a firearm, the Church has no right to bind consciences either way. One Christian keeps a pistol in the nightstand with a clear conscience; another refuses to have one in the house with an equally clear conscience. The Fifth Commandment forbids the one who owns a weapon ever to draw it in anger or for show. Beyond that, what I would say to him is counsel and not law: learn to use it safely, keep it from children, and settle in your own heart before the crisis comes that you will use it only to protect life. Jesus’ words on the night of His arrest, “let the one who has no sword sell his cloak and buy one” (Luke 22:36), are sometimes quoted in this debate. I would not build anything on them, since within hours He rebuked Peter for using one of the two swords the disciples had with them.
IX. Those Who Have Carried the Sword
A soldier who has killed an enemy combatant in a lawful war, under lawful orders, has not murdered. His Church confesses that he served in a calling God approves, and if no one has ever told him so, he should hear it from his pastor. Many who have done right by every standard still carry the weight of what they saw and did. Luther was not ashamed to write that war “seems an unchristian work and entirely contrary to Christian love” when one looks at what it does to the enemy, and a soldier may grieve over a necessary act without being guilty of it. What he carries he may bring to Christ, who bore griefs as well as sins. “Surely he has borne our griefs and carried our sorrows” (Isaiah 53:4). He may bring it to the Lord’s Table, which is given to the burdened as well as the guilty. It is no failure of faith to seek help for the nightmares, the drinking, or the strain on a marriage that war so often leaves behind. If there were things done that were not right (an order that should have been refused, cruelty in the heat of battle, a life taken that did not need to be taken), those can be confessed by name and forgiven by name. “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness” (1 John 1:9).
Some veterans served in good faith and have since come to believe that their war was unjust. Luther’s rule that a man must not fight in a war he knows to be wrong does not reach back to accuse him. He could not know. He gave his government the benefit of the doubt, as Luther told him to, and did what love and obedience asked of him at the time. The guilt of an unjust war lies with those who chose it. Whatever he did that was wrong in itself, Christ forgives, and for the rest he may lay his grief where he lays every other burden.
The police officer who has had to use force, and especially one who has taken a life, should hear the same word. The office was God’s; the forgiveness of any sin committed in it is God’s too. Many officers now serve under suspicion, filmed and second-guessed, and some feel that their church does not see them. A congregation can say openly that their calling is honorable and pray for them by name in the Prayer of the Church, together with its soldiers. The families of those killed in the line of duty, and the parents of soldiers who did not come home, need more than a mention. They gave what cannot be repaid, and the congregation’s place is beside them in their grief, with the promise of the resurrection of the body.
The Christian who could not act, who froze, or who was not there when someone he loved was harmed, should hear mercy. The Fifth Commandment calls us to help our neighbor where we have the ways and means, and none of us has them for everything. Fear in the face of violence is not unbelief. A man who carries guilt for what he could not prevent should bring it to Christ and leave it there, since “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus” (Romans 8:1).
The Lutheran whose conscience will not let him bear arms is owed patience. Paul writes that “whatever does not proceed from faith is sin” (Romans 14:23) and no one should be pushed to act against his conscience. His pastor should teach him from the Word that the soldier’s calling is not sin and pray that his conscience will be set free. In addition, he may serve his country in other ways and is not to be despised. He may not, however, teach others that the soldier’s calling is sin, for that is the teaching the Augsburg Confession condemns. The young person considering the army or the police is entering an honorable calling. He should learn now what he will refuse to do, before anyone gives him the order.
Conclusion
The Fifth Commandment forbids us to take innocent life on our own authority and commands us to protect our neighbor’s life. Our Confessions condemn the teaching that a Christian cannot hold the sword, although they leave the defense of one’s own life to Scripture and sound judgment. I believe Scripture draws the line between the Christian’s own cause and his neighbor’s cause, so that a Christian may carry for others the sword he would gladly lay down for himself.
None of this makes the sword a small thing. It is God’s instrument for a fallen world, and every use of it, even a righteous one, testifies that the world is not yet what God will make it. Therefore we pray for peace in every service and look for the day when the nations will learn war no more.
On the night Jesus told Peter to put away his sword, He also told the disciples what Zechariah had written: “I will strike the shepherd, and the sheep of the flock will be scattered” (Matthew 26:31). The prophet had heard the LORD say, “Awake, O sword, against my shepherd” (Zechariah 13:7). Christ did not use the sword to save us, but instead received the sword of God’s own judgment in our place. Therefore “he himself is our peace” (Ephesians 2:14), the peace our Mennonite neighbors also confess, and the peace in which every soldier, officer and frightened householder who trusts Him is kept, by the innocent blood of Jesus Christ shed for them.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture and Confessions
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
- Kolb, Robert, and Timothy J. Wengert, eds. The Book of Concord. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000.
Luther
- Luther, Martin. Secular Authority: To What Extent It Should Be Obeyed (1523). Translated by J. J. Schindel. In Works of Martin Luther, Philadelphia Edition, vol. 3. Philadelphia: A. J. Holman, 1930.
- ———. Whether Soldiers, Too, Can Be Saved (1526). Translated by Charles M. Jacobs. In Works of Martin Luther, Philadelphia Edition, vol. 5. Philadelphia: A. J. Holman, 1931.
Mennonite Confessions
- The Schleitheim Confession (1527). Translated by J. C. Wenger. Mennonite Quarterly Review 19, no. 4 (October 1945): 247–253.
- The Dordrecht Confession of Faith (1632). English translation from Thieleman J. van Braght, Martyrs Mirror.
- Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1995.
Other Sources
- The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion (1571).
- The Westminster Confession of Faith (1646).
- Origen. Against Celsus. Translated by Frederick Crombie. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 4. Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing, 1885.
- Tertullian. The Chaplet, and On Idolatry. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3. Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing, 1885.
- Thomas Aquinas. Summa Theologiae. Translated by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province. 2nd ed., 1920.
- Lutheran World Federation. “Action on the Legacy of Lutheran Persecution of ‘Anabaptists.’” Eleventh Assembly, Stuttgart, 2010.
Footnotes
-
The abbreviations are AC (Augsburg Confession, 1530); Ap (its Apology, or Defense, by Philip Melanchthon); LC and SC (Luther’s Large and Small Catechisms); Tr (the Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope, 1537); and FC Ep and FC SD (the Epitome and Solid Declaration of the Formula of Concord, 1577). Paragraph numbers follow the Triglotta and the Tappert edition; for Apology XVI these run 53–65, and the Kolb–Wengert edition (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000) numbers the same article 1–13. Luther’s two treatises on the sword are quoted from the Philadelphia Edition of his works, and the Mennonite confessions from the English translations named below. ↩
-
On the two kinds of rule see Render to Caesar. ↩
-
AC XVI.1–2. The article goes on to condemn “the Anabaptists who forbid these civil offices to Christians” (XVI.3). ↩
-
Thirty-Nine Articles, Article XXXVII, “Of the Civil Magistrates”; Westminster Confession of Faith 23.2. ↩
-
On the Dignity of the Human Being, ch. 4, “Life Honored,” §8. ↩
-
LC I.181. ↩
-
LC I.183, 185. ↩
-
SC I, Fifth Commandment. ↩
-
LC I.189–190. Luther goes on to say that God “rightly calls all those murderers who do not afford counsel and help in distress and danger of body and life” (LC I.191). ↩
-
The Schleitheim Confession of Faith (adopted February 24, 1527), trans. J. C. Wenger, Mennonite Quarterly Review 19, no. 4 (October 1945): 247–253. The date of Sattler’s death is given in the introduction to the reprint of Wenger’s translation by the Baptist Center for Theology and Ministry, New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary. ↩
-
The Dordrecht Confession of Faith (adopted April 21, 1632), in the English translation printed in Thieleman J. van Braght, Martyrs Mirror. Mennonites in Alsace adopted it in 1660 and in Pennsylvania in 1725. ↩
-
Schleitheim, Article VI. The brackets are the translator’s. ↩
-
Schleitheim, Article VI. Article IV had already said that “the unchristian, devilish weapons of force,” such as “sword, armor and the like,” would fall from the brethren “by virtue of the word of Christ, Resist not [him that is] evil.” Paul’s words in 2 Corinthians 10:4 stand behind the contrast. ↩
-
Dordrecht Confession, Articles XIII and XIV. Article XIV cites Matthew 5:39, 44; Romans 12:14; 1 Peter 3:9; Isaiah 2:4; Micah 4:3; and Zechariah 9:8–9. ↩
-
Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1995), Article 22, “Peace, Justice, and Nonresistance,” and its commentary, as published by Mennonite Church USA. The commentary cites Romans 5:10 and Ephesians 2:13–16, and it speaks also of “ministries of mediation, conciliation, and nonviolent resolution of everyday conflict.” ↩
-
Tertullian, The Chaplet (De Corona) 11, and compare On Idolatry 19, in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3; Origen, Against Celsus VIII.73, trans. Frederick Crombie, in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 4. Origen writes, “We do not indeed fight under him, although he require it; but we fight on his behalf, forming a special army,” and he prays “on behalf of those who are fighting in a righteous cause, and for the king who reigns righteously.” ↩
-
Tertullian, The Chaplet 11: “if faith comes later, and finds any preoccupied with military service, their case is different, as in the instance of those whom John used to receive for baptism, and of those most faithful centurions.” Ap XVI.58: “these questions wonderfully exercised Origen, Nazianzen, and others.” ↩
-
AC XXVIII.12–17, quoting John 18:36 and 2 Corinthians 10:4 (in the Triglotta, “The weapons of our warfare are not carnal, but mighty through God”). ↩
-
AC XXVIII.11; Tr 54 (written against the papacy’s errors); Lutheran World Federation, Eleventh Assembly (Stuttgart, July 22, 2010), “Action on the Legacy of Lutheran Persecution of ‘Anabaptists.’” The Federation’s report of the action says that Lutherans “repented for violent persecution of Anabaptists and for the ways in which Lutheran reformers supported persecutions with theological arguments.” Reformed Zurich had begun to execute the Swiss Brethren in 1527 and Roman Catholic rulers did the same, but Lutheran territories also put Anabaptists to death. ↩
-
AC XVI.3–4. The sentence continues: “for the Gospel teaches an eternal righteousness of the heart. Meanwhile, it does not destroy the State or the family, but very much requires that they be preserved as ordinances of God, and that charity be practised in such ordinances” (XVI.4–6). ↩
-
AC XXVII.49, in the article on monastic vows. ↩
-
FC Ep XII.13. The next article in the Formula’s list is “That a Christian cannot without injury to conscience use the office of the magistracy against the wicked…” (Ep XII.14; compare FC SD XII.17–21). The Formula lists these among the “Articles that Cannot be Tolerated in the Government.” The first article in that list, that the magistracy “is not an estate pleasing to God” (Ep XII.12), does not fit Schleitheim, which calls the sword “ordained of God.” ↩
-
Ap XVI.59–60 (Kolb–Wengert XVI.7–8). The paragraph begins, “The Gospel forbids private redress [in order that no one should interfere with the office of the magistrate].” The Latin is privata vindicta and publica vindicta. ↩
-
The believer is not to be ekdikountes (“avenging”) himself, because ekdikēsis (“vengeance”) belongs to God, and he is to give place to God’s orgē (“wrath”); the authority is God’s ekdikos (“avenger”) eis orgēn (“for wrath”). ↩
-
Martin Luther, Secular Authority: To What Extent It Should Be Obeyed (1523), Part One, trans. J. J. Schindel, in Works of Martin Luther, Philadelphia Edition, vol. 3 (Philadelphia: A. J. Holman, 1930), 242. The revised translation is Temporal Authority, in Luther’s Works, vol. 45. ↩
-
Martin Luther, Whether Soldiers, Too, Can Be Saved (1526), trans. Charles M. Jacobs, in Works of Martin Luther, Philadelphia Edition, vol. 5 (Philadelphia: A. J. Holman, 1931), 34. The revised translation is in Luther’s Works, vol. 46. ↩
-
Luther, Whether Soldiers, 36. ↩
-
Luther, Whether Soldiers, 56, 59. Luther also quotes Psalm 68:30 from the Latin, “The Lord scattereth the peoples who have desire for war.” ↩
-
Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 40, a. 1, where Thomas names the three conditions and quotes Augustine (Against Faustus XXII.75 and Questions on the Heptateuch VI.10) for the first two. ↩
-
Luther, Whether Soldiers, 67–68. Luther cites Acts 4:19 for the first sentence and 1 Corinthians 13:7 for the last. ↩
-
AC XVI.6–7. ↩
-
Luther, Whether Soldiers, 73. The ellipsis omits one sentence of thanksgiving. ↩
-
Luther, Secular Authority, Part One, 241. ↩
-
Luther, Whether Soldiers, 37. ↩
-
On why Israel’s civil law does not bind Christians, see The Law in Three Parts. ↩
-
Luther, Whether Soldiers, 58. The sentence is part of Luther’s argument that a war of self-defense is the only right war between equals, illustrated by Israel’s defense against the Amorites and Canaanites. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Bearing the Sword: War, Police Work and Self-Defense.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/bearing-the-sword/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.