Halloween, Christmas Trees and Yoga
Pagan Roots and Christian Freedom
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“For ‘the earth is the Lord’s, and the fullness thereof.’” — 1 Corinthians 10:26, ESV
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version. The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the Concordia Triglotta of 1921 and cited by part and paragraph.1
I. Is It Pagan?
Is Halloween the devil’s night? Does the prophet Jeremiah forbid the tree that stands in the living room every December? May a Christian go to a yoga class at the gym or the community center, or is stretching on a mat a kind of idolatry? These questions come every autumn and winter and each comes with a story about where the custom came from. Some of those stories are true. Many are not. They are repeated with equal confidence by people who want the custom kept and by people who want it gone.
A Christian may let children dress up and collect candy on the eve of All Saints, and a Christian household may keep Christmas with a tree, with a good conscience. Neither custom is the worship of a false god. Much of the pagan history claimed for them is modern, and where it is real it does not decide what the custom means now, as Paul taught the Corinthians about meat from the temple. Yoga is a different kind of question, because with yoga much of the religion is still present. Stretching and breathing are free, since the body belongs to God who made it. However, yoga as its classical texts and many Hindu teachers present it is a spiritual discipline and not only exercise, and where a class carries that discipline (chant, devotion, or meditation that seeks a divine Self within) the First Commandment governs it. Near the end of section VI there are a few plain questions to ask about any class. In other words, the origin of a custom matters when the worship it came from is still present in it, and it does not matter when that worship has gone.
This paper begins with Scripture and the Confessions and then takes the three customs in turn. The Lutheran teaching on things neither commanded nor forbidden, and on the weaker brother, is set out more fully in Wine, Cards and Christian Liberty.
II. Meat from the Temple
The New Testament question that comes closest to ours was asked in Corinth. Much of the meat sold in a Greek city’s market came from animals sacrificed at a temple, and Christians who had been rescued out of that worship wanted to know whether they could eat it. Paul begins with what every Christian knows:
“Therefore, as to the eating of food offered to idols, we know that ‘an idol has no real existence,’ and that ‘there is no God but one.’ For although there may be so-called gods in heaven or on earth—as indeed there are many ‘gods’ and many ‘lords’—yet for us there is one God, the Father, from whom are all things and for whom we exist, and one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom are all things and through whom we exist.” (1 Corinthians 8:4–6)
The meat itself was never the idol’s. It belonged to the God who made the animal and the idol had no power to take it from Him. Therefore, Paul tells the Corinthians, “Eat whatever is sold in the meat market without raising any question on the ground of conscience. For ‘the earth is the Lord’s, and the fullness thereof’” (1 Corinthians 10:25–26). He writes to Timothy in the same spirit, “For everything created by God is good, and nothing is to be rejected if it is received with thanksgiving, for it is made holy by the word of God and prayer” (1 Timothy 4:4–5). I do not believe a thing carries an idol’s ownership the way cloth carries a stain. Logicians call this mistake the “genetic fallacy,” which means judging a thing by where it came from rather than by what it is, and a great part of what is said about pagan roots commits it.
However, the chapter that frees the Christian to buy the meat forbids him to share the meal at the idol’s altar:
“What do I imply then? That food offered to idols is anything, or that an idol is anything? No, I imply that what pagans sacrifice they offer to demons and not to God. I do not want you to be participants with demons. You cannot drink the cup of the Lord and the cup of demons.” (1 Corinthians 10:19–21)
The idol is nothing, but the worship offered to it is something, and the Christian may not take part in it. The difference lies not in the meat but in the act. Buying a roast that came from the temple is eating; sitting at the temple’s table while its god is honored is worship. Paul then adds a third case that falls between the two. At a private dinner a Christian may eat what is served, but if someone at the table says, “This has been offered in sacrifice,” he should decline, “for the sake of the one who informed you, and for the sake of conscience” (1 Corinthians 10:28). The meat has not changed. Eating it would now say something to a neighbor and love governs what we say. The passage ends with the rule that covers everything after it, “So, whether you eat or drink, or whatever you do, do all to the glory of God” (1 Corinthians 10:31).
Paul gives the Christian freedom with days as well. “One person esteems one day as better than another, while another esteems all days alike. Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind. The one who observes the day, observes it in honor of the Lord” (Romans 14:5–6). To the Colossians he writes, “Therefore let no one pass judgment on you in questions of food and drink, or with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath. These are a shadow of the things to come, but the substance belongs to Christ” (Colossians 2:16–17).
The Christians who keep no holy days have a text of their own and it should be read with care. Paul writes to the Galatians, “But now that you have come to know God, or rather to be known by God, how can you turn back again to the weak and worthless elementary principles of the world, whose slaves you want to be once more? You observe days and months and seasons and years!” (Galatians 4:9–10). Read alone, it sounds like a rebuke to anyone who keeps a calendar at all. Did Paul mean it that way? The whole letter is about Christians who were being told that circumcision and the calendar of the Law were required for their righteousness before God, and Paul’s answer is, “For freedom Christ has set us free” (Galatians 5:1). He is not forbidding the keeping of a day, but forbidding the keeping of any day as though salvation hung on it, which is why Paul can also tell the Romans that the one who observes the day does so in honor of the Lord.
There are things, however, that no change of time or meaning makes free. When Israel entered Canaan the LORD said, “There shall not be found among you anyone who burns his son or his daughter as an offering, anyone who practices divination or tells fortunes or interprets omens, or a sorcerer or a charmer or a medium or a necromancer or one who inquires of the dead, for whoever does these things is an abomination to the LORD” (Deuteronomy 18:10–12). These practices are forbidden not because of where they came from, but because of what they do, which is to seek knowledge and help from powers other than God. This is the First Commandment, “You shall have no other gods before me” (Exodus 20:3), and not a law for Israel only. The New Testament repeats it (Galatians 5:20 lists sorcery among the works of the flesh). Because it is the moral law written on every heart, it binds us as fully as it bound them.2
Paul’s sermon in Athens shows what a Christian may do with the things of a pagan culture. Walking through the city he found an altar inscribed, “To the unknown god,” and he began from it, “What therefore you worship as unknown, this I proclaim to you” (Acts 17:23). He quoted their own poets, “‘In him we live and move and have our being’; as even some of your own poets have said, ‘For we are indeed his offspring’” (Acts 17:28).3 He filled a pagan inscription and a line written in praise of Zeus with the God who made heaven and earth, and then called the Athenians to repent (Acts 17:30–31).
III. Customs in the Confessions
The Augsburg Confession took up the Church’s own festivals, and its rule is the right place to start:
“Of Usages in the Church they teach that those ought to be observed which may be observed without sin, and which are profitable unto tranquillity and good order in the Church, as particular holy-days, festivals, and the like. Nevertheless, concerning such things men are admonished that consciences are not to be burdened, as though such observance was necessary to salvation.” (AC XV.1–2)
In other words, the Church’s festivals that can be kept without sin ought to be kept, for the sake of good order, and no one may be told that keeping them earns his salvation. The Apology says the Lutherans “cheerfully maintain the old traditions,” and it names “the three high festivals” (Christmas, Easter and Pentecost) among them.4 Household customs such as a tree or a costume stand a step further off. The Apology (Melanchthon’s defense of the Augsburg Confession) teaches that “neither sin nor righteousness should be placed in meat, drink, clothing, and like things, the use of which Christ wished to be left free.”5 Customs of that kind may be kept or left alone.
The Formula of Concord, the last of the Lutheran confessions (1577), calls such free things adiaphora (Greek, “things indifferent”) and teaches three things about them, which Wine, Cards and Christian Liberty treats at length. No one may make them a law. Love may give them up for the sake of a weaker brother. Also, when someone demands that Christians keep or give up a free thing as though their faithfulness depended on it, they must not yield, because then “it is no longer a question concerning adiaphora, but concerning the truth of the Gospel.”6 The Formula adds a warning that bears on every custom in this paper:
“Namely, when under the title and pretext of external adiaphora such things are proposed as are in principle contrary to God’s Word (although painted another color), these are not to be regarded as adiaphora, in which one is free to act as he will, but must be avoided as things prohibited by God.” (FC SD X.5)
Calling a thing indifferent does not make it free. If a practice carries worship that God forbids, a new label does not change what it is.
What makes a practice worship is taught in the Large Catechism, where Luther explains the First Commandment. Luther writes that “the confidence and faith of the heart alone make both God and an idol,” and he goes on, “That now, I say, upon which you set your heart and put your trust is properly your god.”7 Idolatry, he adds, “consists not merely in erecting an image and worshiping it, but rather in the heart, which stands gaping at something else, and seeks help and consolation from creatures, saints, or devils.”8 Among the worst idolaters he names “sorcerers and magicians, whose idolatry is most gross, and who make a covenant with the devil.”9 The Small Catechism teaches children this under the Second Commandment, that we should fear and love God “that we may not curse, swear, use witchcraft, lie, or deceive by His name.”10 It is important to ask this of any custom, and it is a better question than where the custom came from: where is the heart being taught to look for help?
The Church has faced the question since her missionaries first reached the northern peoples. In 601 Pope Gregory the Great wrote to the monks he had sent to England, and the historian Bede preserved the letter. Gregory said “that the temples of the idols in that nation ought not to be destroyed; but let the idols that are in them be destroyed,” and that the English might keep their feasts, so that instead of slaughtering cattle to their gods they would “kill cattle and glorify God in their feast.”11 Gregory saw that a building, a feast or a day is a creature of God, and that once the idol is gone it can be given back to its Maker. Lutherans have no quarrel with that. At the same time, we Lutherans have sometimes answered every question of this kind with the single word adiaphora, as though naming the category ended the conversation, and left our members to work out the First Commandment questions alone.
IV. Where Did Halloween Come From?
The name tells most of the story. “Halloween” is a Scottish shortening of “All Hallows’ Even,” the evening before All Hallows, which is the old English name for All Saints’ Day on November 1.12 The Church kept a feast of all the martyrs in the East from the fourth century, and by the ninth century November 1 was kept as All Saints’ Day across the West. All Souls’ Day, on which the Church prayed for all the faithful departed, followed on November 2 about two centuries later.13
The popular story is that the Church chose November 1 to take over Samhain, a Celtic festival of the dead, and that Halloween is Samhain in disguise. Is it true? There was a Samhain. It is the Old Irish name of the first day of November, and in the medieval Irish stories, written down by Christian monks, it is the start of winter, a time for royal assemblies, and a night on which the boundary with the otherworld might open. However, the historian Ronald Hutton, who has written the standard history of the British ritual year, finds very little evidence that it was a festival of the dead or a “Celtic New Year.” Both ideas, he shows, came from Victorian scholars. He also argues that the November date of All Saints spread from England and the Germanic lands and did not come from Ireland at all.14 There was also no Celtic god of the dead named Samhain, though the claim is often repeated, since Samhain is the name of the day.
The customs that gathered around the night have a mixed and mostly Christian history. In England by the sixteenth century the poor went door to door on All Souls’ Day asking for “soul cakes,” and they promised in return to pray for the dead of the household.15 Although Lutherans reject purgatory and the Mass offered for the dead, this custom was born among Christians and not among druids.16 In Scotland and Ireland people also told fortunes on Halloween night, mostly to learn whom they would marry, and that divination is the part of the old Halloween a Christian should not carry forward. Irish immigrants brought the festival to America in the nineteenth century. The trick-or-treating most American children know became common only after the Second World War.17
Since the middle of the twentieth century some people have also kept October 31 as a religious festival. Modern Wicca, a religion of witchcraft that took shape in England in the 1940s and 1950s, and other forms of modern paganism keep Samhain as a sacred night for honoring the dead and the turning of the year.18 For them it is worship. I think the Christian should respect their honesty about it and decline to join in.
Many faithful Christians keep their families home on October 31, or hold a harvest party instead. They do not want to make light of death, of demons, or of witchcraft. They read “Take no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead expose them” (Ephesians 5:11) and “test everything; hold fast what is good. Abstain from every form of evil” (1 Thessalonians 5:21–22). Their deeper worry is not the candy but the night as it is now kept, with its witches and devils and the dead made into play, and they fear that joining in gives that culture a kind of approval. A parent who sits the night out for those reasons has done nothing wrong.
However, the costume and the candy are not the works of darkness Paul names. A child dressed as a pirate is not worshiping anything and a neighbor handing out candy is not offering it to the dead. The hard case is the child who wants to go as a witch or a devil. A costume that makes a game of the devil or of witchcraft teaches the opposite of what we confess about him, and I believe a Christian household may reasonably say no to it while saying yes to the pirate. Some of what is sold around Halloween is just what Deuteronomy 18 forbids. The Ouija board, the séance played as a party game, the tarot reading and the spell cast for fun are attempts to inquire of the dead or to learn the future from powers other than God, and selling them in a toy store does not make them free. A Christian household should have nothing to do with them, at Halloween or any other time. The same is true of decorations and entertainments that delight in cruelty or mock what is holy. A Christian who has come out of Wicca or the occult may find the whole season a temptation, and those who are free to enjoy it should not press him. The line falls not between Halloween and the rest of the year, but between the things God has left free and the things He has forbidden.
The night also belongs to the Church. It is the Eve of All Saints and it is the day in 1517 when Luther sent out the Ninety-Five Theses, the evening before the festival when crowds would come to the Castle Church at Wittenberg. Many Lutheran congregations keep Reformation Day on October 31 and All Saints on November 1, and some read the names of members who died in the past year. A family can let the children go door to door and also bring them to church to hear those names. As for the devil, the Christian does not fear him on October 31 any more than on any other night. Christ “disarmed the rulers and authorities and put them to open shame, by triumphing over them in him” (Colossians 2:15), and “he who is in you is greater than he who is in the world” (1 John 4:4).
V. Is the Christmas Tree Pagan?
The objector to the Christmas tree has some history on his side. Around the year 200 Tertullian of Carthage scolded the Christians of his city for hanging laurel wreaths and lamps on their doors during the public festivals of the emperor. “You are a light of the world,” he wrote, “and a tree ever green. If you have renounced temples, make not your own gate a temple.”19 In the sixth century Martin, bishop of Braga in what is now Portugal, counted among the pagan customs his people should give up “to keep the Vulcanalia and the Kalends, to deck tables, and to set out laurels.”20 The Kalends of January were the Roman New Year. Midwinter greenery had a pagan use and the Church once forbade it. The decorated fir in the parlor is something else, as we will see, but the objector is right about the laurel.
His strongest text is not usually the one quoted. Jeremiah 10 opens with the LORD’s command, “Learn not the way of the nations” (Jeremiah 10:2), and then goes on:
“…for the customs of the peoples are vanity. A tree from the forest is cut down and worked with an axe by the hands of a craftsman. They decorate it with silver and gold; they fasten it with hammer and nails so that it cannot move. Their idols are like scarecrows in a cucumber field, and they cannot speak; they have to be carried, for they cannot walk. Do not be afraid of them, for they cannot do evil, neither is it in them to do good.” (Jeremiah 10:3–5)
Careful objectors in the Reformed churches and elsewhere do not claim that anyone worships the tree. They join verse 2 to Deuteronomy 12, where the LORD warns Israel against asking, “‘How did these nations serve their gods?—that I also may do the same.’ You shall not worship the LORD your God in that way” (Deuteronomy 12:30–31). Their argument is that God forbids taking the customs of the nations into His own worship and festivals, even when they are meant for Him. The answer has to come from the texts themselves. Jeremiah’s tree is an idol carved by a craftsman and covered with metal. His point is that idols are powerless and need not be feared. In other words, the verse that is used to frighten Christians about their tree was written to tell them not to be afraid. In addition, Deuteronomy 12 forbids worshiping the LORD in the way the nations served their gods, and verse 31 names the way: “for they even burn their sons and their daughters in the fire to their gods.” It does not forbid every custom the nations also had. Israel kept harvest feasts, as the farming peoples around it did, and Solomon built the temple with the help of Phoenician craftsmen (1 Kings 5). The Apology even notes that the apostles took the Jewish festivals of Passover and Pentecost and “adapted [them] to the history of the Gospel.”21 What Moses forbade was the nations’ worship, and what Paul freed was the meat.
The history of the Christmas tree is late and Christian and it is mostly German. In the late Middle Ages December 24 was the day of Adam and Eve in the German calendars, and the plays performed around Christmas often showed the Fall with a “paradise tree” hung with apples.22 Records of trees used at Christmas appear in the Baltic and in Alsace in the early 1500s, and in 1605 a writer in Strasbourg described fir trees set up in the parlors at Christmas and hung with paper roses, apples, wafers, gold foil and sweets.23 The custom spread through the German lands, into England with the royal family in the nineteenth century, and into America with German immigrants.
Two pious legends have grown up around the tree and neither is history. The first says that St. Boniface, after felling the sacred oak of the German thunder god, pointed the people to a little fir as a sign of the Christ child. Boniface’s earliest biographer tells how he cut down the oak at Geismar around 723 and used its timber to build a chapel; he says nothing about a fir, and the fir story was popularized by the American writer Henry van Dyke in the 1890s.24 The second says that Luther, walking home under the stars, cut a fir and set candles on it for his children. It cannot be traced earlier than the nineteenth century and was spread by a popular engraving of 1843.25 It is a charming story, but it is not history.
The date of Christmas has its own legend, that the Church took December 25 from the Roman feast of the Saturnalia or of the Unconquered Sun. The Saturnalia fell earlier in December. As for the Sun, scholars still debate whether the Church set the date with the pagan feast in view or by counting nine months from March 25, the day on which early Christians believed Christ was conceived and also died. I think the second explanation is at least as old as the first; Augustine records it.26
Some Christians have refused Christmas for conscience’ sake for centuries. The Westminster Assembly’s Directory for the Public Worship of God (1645), which shaped the English and Scottish Puritans, declared, “Festival days, vulgarly called holy-days, having no warrant in the Word of God, are not to be continued.”27 They held that in worship the Church may do only what God has commanded, and that the Lord’s Day alone is commanded under the Gospel. The same Directory made room for days of public fasting and thanksgiving as occasions required, so they did not object to special days as such, only to fixed holy days that God had not commanded. They read Colossians 2:16 and Galatians 4:10 as texts against such days, while Lutherans read the same verses as texts for freedom. The Lutheran answer, I think, is not that the Puritans were careless with Scripture, but that they asked more of it than it asks of us. Scripture commands the preaching of Christ’s birth. It neither commands nor forbids a day for it, and AC XV confesses that such holy-days “ought to be observed which may be observed without sin.” The Book of Common Prayer, which the Directory was meant to replace, kept it too. As for the tree at home, no one is bound to have one. Although it saves no one, a family that sets one up and blesses it with God’s Word and prayer is using a creature of God for its Maker’s glory, which is the whole of 1 Timothy 4:4–5. Isaiah’s picture of “the cypress, the plane, and the pine” brought “to beautify the place of my sanctuary” (Isaiah 60:13) is no command for a living room, but it is a good picture to pray with beside the tree.
VI. What Is Yoga?
Yoga is the hardest of the three, because here the question is less where a practice came from than what a particular class still carries.
The word yoga comes from a Sanskrit root meaning “to yoke, to join.”28 Its classical text is the Yoga Sutras attributed to Patanjali, a set of short sayings compiled in the first centuries after Christ. There yoga is a discipline of the mind and body. Its second saying defines it as the stilling of the movements of the mind, and its goal is that the seer, the true self within, should rest in its own nature, wholly apart from matter and freed from the round of birth and death.29 The Sutras lay out eight “limbs” of the practice, from moral restraints and posture through control of the breath to concentration, meditation and absorption. Posture is only one of them, and the Sutras give it a single line, “Posture is that which is firm and pleasant.” They also commend devotion to the Lord, whose “manifesting word is Om” (the sacred syllable chanted in Hindu worship), and they teach that repeating Om and meditating on its meaning is a way to the goal.30 Later teachers read the Sutras in other ways. Swami Vivekananda, the Hindu teacher who first brought them to large Western audiences in the 1890s, read them through his own school of Hindu thought, as the discovery of a divine Self within. He wrote of the stilled mind, “The bottom of the lake is our own true Self.”31
Hindu teachers themselves disagree about whether yoga belongs to Hinduism alone. Some stress its Hindu roots. In 2010 the Hindu American Foundation began a campaign to remind Americans of them, and one of its leaders told a reporter, “It is a lifestyle, and it’s a philosophy.”32 Others have offered it to people of every faith, and the Foundation itself presents yoga as open to everyone. What the Foundation asks is that no one pretend yoga is only exercise. It does not say that a Christian in a posture class is worshiping, and the judgment that follows is mine, not theirs. Wherever yoga is taught in its fullness, with chant, breath and meditation ordered toward the realization of the Self, I believe it is a spiritual path that belongs to another religion.
Christians who practice yoga see it differently and their case deserves more credit than it usually receives. They point out that the posture-based yoga of an American gym is quite modern. The scholar Mark Singleton has argued that the flowing sequences most classes teach, the sun salutation among them, were developed largely in twentieth-century India and borrowed from European gymnastics and the physical-culture movement of the time; other scholars reply that some postures have older roots in medieval texts.33 A group called Christians Practicing Yoga, which draws on Singleton’s work, answers the fear that doing the poses means worshiping Hindu gods with a “no,” and adds, “We are guests to this practice.”34 They would say that the body is God’s creature, that a posture belongs to no god, and that Christians have bodily disciplines of prayer of their own. The Roman Catholic Church’s 1989 letter on Christian meditation names one of them, the Jesus Prayer of the Eastern Church, “which adapts itself to the natural rhythm of breathing.” The same letter says that methods from other religions should not be “rejected out of hand simply because they are not Christian,” and that “one can take from them what is useful so long as the Christian conception of prayer, its logic and requirements are never obscured.” It also warns that bodily exercises can produce feelings of calm and warmth, and that “to take such feelings for the authentic consolations of the Holy Spirit would be a totally erroneous way of conceiving the spiritual life.”35
I believe the Lutheran answer sorts the question into its parts, as Paul did at Corinth. The stretching itself is meat from the market. A body bending forward or lying still is a body God made. No posture became the property of a Hindu god because Hindu teachers used it first. A Christian may do physical exercise that resembles yoga, in a gym or at home, and the sun salutation done as a warm-up sequence is exercise. The greeting namaste that ends many classes means “I bow to you” and is an ordinary greeting in India; a Christian may return it as a courtesy or simply say “thank you.” However, the parts of yoga that are worship remain worship. Chanting Om, which the Sutras call the word that makes the Lord known, is not a sound without meaning. Bowing or chanting in praise of a Hindu deity, or the sun salutation offered as devotion to the sun, is the table of demons in Paul’s sense and not the meat. Meditation that aims to empty the mind and discover a divine Self within teaches the heart to look for help somewhere other than God. This is what Luther means when he says the heart “stands gaping at something else.” To call such a practice “only exercise” would be to do what the Formula calls painting a thing another color.
Christian meditation runs the other way. The Psalmist’s blessed man is the one whose “delight is in the law of the LORD, and on his law he meditates day and night” (Psalm 1:2). The LORD told Joshua, “This Book of the Law shall not depart from your mouth, but you shall meditate on it day and night” (Joshua 1:8). The Hebrew word pictures a man murmuring the words aloud to himself.36 Christian meditation does not empty the mind, but fills it with God’s Word until it shapes our prayer. Luther writes in the preface to the Large Catechism that it is “an exceedingly effectual help against the devil, the world, and the flesh and all evil thoughts to be occupied with the Word of God, and to speak of it, and meditate upon it.”37 Jesus warned against prayer that heaps up words “as the Gentiles do, for they think that they will be heard for their many words” (Matthew 6:7). He did not forbid repetition, for the Church repeats the Kyrie and the Litany to the God who has spoken to her. He forbade prayer that trusts its own technique.
Only the Christian in the class can answer some questions about it. Is this an exercise class or a spiritual one? What does the teacher say at the beginning and the end of the hour? Is there chanting, or talk of energy and of the divine within? When the class turns to chant, to devotion, or to meditation on the Self, the Christian should step out of the room and come back for the stretching, or find another class. Staying on the mat in silence, or praying the Lord’s Prayer privately while the room meditates, is not enough. A chant or guided meditation led for everyone in the room is a common act, and a common prayer at a common altar is a common act of worship. If a class is clearly a spiritual practice from beginning to end, she should find another. There is also the weaker brother to think of. A Christian who came out of Hinduism or the New Age may find the whole thing a temptation back toward what he left, and those who are free to stretch should not press him to join them. Paul’s word was, “take care that this right of yours does not somehow become a stumbling block to the weak” (1 Corinthians 8:9). Lastly, a Christian should be honest with Hindu neighbors. We should not tell them that yoga is ours or that it means nothing, but that we have taken some exercises from it and left its worship behind, because we belong to Christ.
VII. For the Household
A parent who is still unsure about Halloween may keep the children home this year without guilt and take the question to the pastor, for “whatever does not proceed from faith is sin” (Romans 14:23), and no one should be pushed past his conscience. Past Halloweens kept in good faith were not sins to be repented of. Your children did not belong to the devil for an evening because they wore costumes; they were baptized, and they were His. A grandparent or a friend who objects to the costumes or to the tree is often the weaker brother of Romans 14 and should be answered with patience and kindness, not with a lecture on adiaphora. Honest unease about a custom is not judging. However, if someone insists that a family must give up its tree or its costumes in order to be faithful, the family should not yield, because that would make a free thing a law. To the one who does judge, Paul writes, “Who are you to pass judgment on the servant of another? It is before his own master that he stands or falls” (Romans 14:4).
Some members played at séances or with Ouija boards as teenagers, or once paid a fortune-teller, and still feel uneasy about it. Others have chanted in a yoga class for years, or practiced a meditation they now see was worship. For each of them the word is the Gospel. That was a sin against the First Commandment and it is forgiven in Christ like every other sin. Confess it and hear the absolution. Your Baptism “works forgiveness of sins, delivers from death and the devil, and gives eternal salvation to all who believe this.”38 At the font you renounced the devil and all his works and ways, and Christ claimed you. No old game and no old chant has a claim on you now.
The Christian who has been told that the Christmas tree is pagan, and can no longer enjoy it, may set it up without fear. As a Christmas custom it is Christian and German, the verse in Jeremiah is about an idol, and the earth is the Lord’s. If you do not want one, you are equally free, and no one should make the tree a law in either direction. The member who goes to a yoga class is free to stretch. Listen to what is being taught, keep your heart where your Baptism put it, and step out when the class turns from exercise to worship.
Conclusion
The answer to each of these questions depends less on where a custom came from than on what it is now. Halloween is the Eve of All Saints and most of its customs grew up among Christians, though the old Irish night left its mark on the folklore and some people keep a pagan Samhain today. The Christmas tree began as a German Christian custom, even though the Church once forbade the pagan laurels of midwinter; the date of Christmas has a Christian explanation at least as old as the pagan one. Neither the costume nor the tree is worship of a false god and both are among the things God has left free. Divination and the calling up of the dead are another matter. God has forbidden them, and I believe a Christian household should keep them out of its play as firmly as out of its prayers.
Yoga is the case in which the old worship is often still in the room. Although the body and its movements are God’s good creation and a Christian may use them freely, the chant, the devotion and the meditation that seeks the Self are worship, and the First Commandment forbids us to share in them however they are labeled. We do not need them. We have a God who has spoken to us in His Son, a Word to meditate on day and night, and a Savior who has already triumphed over every power that pagan worship ever served. Paul told the Corinthians to buy the meat, to stay away from the altar, and to do all to the glory of God, and that counsel still holds.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture and Confessions
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
- Kolb, Robert, and Timothy J. Wengert, eds. The Book of Concord. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000.
Early and Medieval Sources
- Augustine. On the Trinity. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, First Series, vol. 3.
- Bede. Ecclesiastical History of the English People. Translated by A. M. Sellar. London: Bell, 1907.
- Martin of Braga. De correctione rusticorum.
- Tertullian. On Idolatry. In Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3.
History of Halloween and Christmas
- Armstrong, Dave. “Christmas Trees: Christian Symbolism and Development of the Custom.” Catholic World Report, December 22, 2020.
- Hijmans, Steven. Sol: Image and Meaning of the Sun in Roman Art and Religion. Leiden: Brill, 2024.
- Hutton, Ronald. The Stations of the Sun: A History of the Ritual Year in Britain. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996.
- Hutton, Ronald. The Triumph of the Moon: A History of Modern Pagan Witchcraft. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999.
- Martin, Emily. “The History of Trick-or-Treating.” National Geographic, October 27, 2021.
- McGowan, Andrew. “How December 25 Became Christmas.” Bible Review, December 2002.
- Morton, Lisa. Trick or Treat: A History of Halloween. London: Reaktion, 2012.
- Tait, Edwin Woodruff. “O Tannenbaum, O Tannenbaum!” Christian History 92 (2006).
- Talley, Thomas J. The Origins of the Liturgical Year. New York: Pueblo, 1986.
- The Directory for the Public Worship of God. 1645.
Yoga and Meditation
- Adler, Margot. “To Some Hindus, Modern Yoga Has Lost Its Way.” NPR, April 11, 2012.
- Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Letter to the Bishops of the Catholic Church on Some Aspects of Christian Meditation. October 15, 1989.
- Prymus, Renee Aukeman. “Where Does Yoga Come From?” Christians Practicing Yoga.
- Singleton, Mark. Yoga Body: The Origins of Modern Posture Practice. New York: Oxford University Press, 2010.
- Vivekananda, Swami. Raja Yoga. 1896. In The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda, vol. 1.
Reference
- Brown, Francis, S. R. Driver, and Charles A. Briggs. A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament. Oxford: Clarendon, 1906.
- Monier-Williams, Monier. A Sanskrit-English Dictionary. Oxford: Clarendon, 1899.
Footnotes
-
Abbreviations: AC (Augsburg Confession), Ap (Apology of the Augsburg Confession), SC and LC (Small and Large Catechism), FC Ep and FC SD (Formula of Concord, Epitome and Solid Declaration). Paragraph numbers follow the Triglotta and Tappert editions, as in Kolb–Wengert, so LC I.2 is the Large Catechism, Part I, paragraph 2. ↩
-
On the moral, ceremonial and civil law, see The Law in Three Parts and Tattoos and the Christian. ↩
-
The first line is usually traced to a poem attributed to Epimenides of Crete, the second to the Phaenomena of Aratus (third century B.C.), which opens with praise of Zeus. ↩
-
Ap XV.38. The bracketed words in the Triglotta read “as, the three high festivals, the observance of Sunday, and the like.” ↩
-
Ap XXVIII.7. ↩
-
FC Ep X.6; compare FC SD X.10–13, where the Formula cites Galatians 2:5. FC Ep X.1 defines adiaphora as “ceremonies or church rites which are neither commanded nor forbidden in God’s Word.” ↩
-
LC I.2–3. ↩
-
LC I.21. ↩
-
LC I.12. ↩
-
SC I, Second Commandment. ↩
-
Bede, Ecclesiastical History of the English People I.30, Gregory to Abbot Mellitus, June 17, 601; trans. A. M. Sellar (1907). In a letter to the English king written the same year (I.32), Gregory urged him instead to “overthrow the structures of the temples.” ↩
-
“Hallow” is the old English word for a saint, as in “hallowed be Thy name.” The forms “All Hallows’ Even” and “Allhallowe’en” are recorded in the sixteenth century. ↩
-
Pope Gregory III (731–741) dedicated a chapel in St. Peter’s to all the saints, and in 835, at the prompting of Pope Gregory IV, the emperor Louis the Pious ordered the feast kept on November 1 across his empire (Catholic Encyclopedia, 1907, “All Saints”). All Souls’ Day is credited to Odilo, abbot of Cluny, traditionally in 998; some historians place it after 1030. ↩
-
Ronald Hutton, The Stations of the Sun: A History of the Ritual Year in Britain (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996), chapter on Samhain and Hallowe’en. Hutton traces the “Celtic New Year” to the philologist John Rhys and the “feast of the dead” to James Frazer’s The Golden Bough. He finds the November date of All Saints in England by the time of Bede and in Germany, while early Irish churches kept a feast of all saints in April. ↩
-
Emily Martin, “The History of Trick-or-Treating,” National Geographic, October 27, 2021 (updated 2024), drawing on Lisa Morton, Trick or Treat: A History of Halloween (London: Reaktion, 2012). ↩
-
The Apology says, “we know that the ancients speak of prayer for the dead, which we do not prohibit; but we disapprove of the application ex opere operato of the Lord’s Supper on behalf of the dead” (Ap XXIV.94). Ex opere operato means “by the mere performance of the act.” On purgatory, see SA II.ii.12. ↩
-
Martin, National Geographic. The phrase “trick or treat” first appears in print in Alberta newspapers in November 1927 (Calgary Daily Herald, November 3; Lethbridge Herald, November 4), as traced by the etymologist Barry Popik. On the Scottish fortune-telling games, see Robert Burns’s poem “Halloween” (1785). ↩
-
Ronald Hutton, The Triumph of the Moon: A History of Modern Pagan Witchcraft (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999). ↩
-
Tertullian, On Idolatry 15, trans. S. Thelwall, Ante-Nicene Fathers 3. ↩
-
Martin of Braga, On the Correction of Rustics (De correctione rusticorum, about 572) 16: “Vulcanalia et Kalendas observare, mensas ornare, et lauros ponere… quid est aliud nisi cultura diaboli?” (“To keep the Vulcanalia and the Kalends, to deck tables, and to set out laurels… what is this but the worship of the devil?”). The translation is mine. ↩
-
Ap VII–VIII.40. ↩
-
Edwin Woodruff Tait, “O Tannenbaum, O Tannenbaum!” Christian History 92 (2006). ↩
-
The anonymous Strasbourg description of 1605, as quoted in Dave Armstrong, “Christmas Trees: Christian Symbolism and Development of the Custom,” Catholic World Report, December 22, 2020. On the Baltic (1510) and Alsatian (1521) records, Tait, “O Tannenbaum.” Both early records are disputed in their details. Some Lutheran pastors objected to the new custom, among them Johann Conrad Dannhauer of Strasbourg in the seventeenth century, who complained that it drew people away from the true evergreen, Jesus Christ (Tait). ↩
-
Willibald, Life of St. Boniface, chapter 6, where the tree is called the “oak of Jupiter.” Van Dyke’s story appeared in Scribner’s Magazine in 1891 and was later published as The First Christmas Tree (1897). ↩
-
The engraving by Carl August Schwerdgeburth, Luther in the Circle of His Family at Wittenberg on Christmas Eve 1536, is usually dated 1843. Tait judges that the Luther story “has little historical basis.” ↩
-
The Saturnalia began on December 17 and was later extended to December 23 (Macrobius, Saturnalia 1.10). The Roman calendar compiled in 354, the oldest witness that Christ’s birth was kept on December 25, also marks the “birthday of the Unconquered” on that day. Steven Hijmans, Sol: Image and Meaning of the Sun in Roman Art and Religion (Leiden: Brill, 2024), questions whether that entry refers to the Sun at all, finds no evidence for a feast of the Sun at the winter solstice before the emperor Julian (361–363), and suggests the pagan feast may have answered the Christian one. Augustine writes that Christ “is believed to have been conceived on the 25th of March, upon which day also He suffered… But He was born, according to tradition, upon December the 25th” (On the Trinity IV.5.9, NPNF1 3). On both explanations see Andrew McGowan, “How December 25 Became Christmas,” Bible Review (December 2002); Louis Duchesne, Origines du culte chrétien (1889); Thomas J. Talley, The Origins of the Liturgical Year (New York: Pueblo, 1986). ↩
-
The Directory for the Public Worship of God (1645), “An Appendix, touching Days and Places for Publick Worship.” The Directory also provides for days of public solemn fasting and of public thanksgiving. ↩
-
Monier Monier-Williams, A Sanskrit-English Dictionary (Oxford, 1899), s.v. yoga, from the root yuj. ↩
-
Yoga Sutras 1.2–3 and 4.34 (4.33 in Vivekananda’s numbering). The goal is called kaivalya (“aloneness” or “isolation”). Swami Vivekananda translates 1.3, “the seer (Purusha) rests in his own (unmodified) state.” The Sutras belong to the Samkhya school, which distinguishes the seer from matter; reading them as union with a divine Self belongs to later Vedantic interpreters. ↩
-
Yoga Sutras 2.29 (the eight limbs), 2.46 (posture), 1.23 and 1.27–28 (devotion to Ishvara, “the Lord,” and Om), in Vivekananda, Raja Yoga (1896), Complete Works, vol. 1. ↩
-
Vivekananda, commentary on Yoga Sutras 1.2, Raja Yoga. ↩
-
Sheetal Shah of the Hindu American Foundation, quoted in Margot Adler, “To Some Hindus, Modern Yoga Has Lost Its Way,” NPR, April 11, 2012. The same report describes the campaign as presenting yoga as universal and appropriate for everyone. ↩
-
Mark Singleton, Yoga Body: The Origins of Modern Posture Practice (New York: Oxford University Press, 2010). For a reply that finds non-seated postures in medieval texts, while accepting Singleton’s account of the sun salutation, see James Mallinson, “A Response to Mark Singleton’s Yoga Body” (2011). ↩
-
Renee Aukeman Prymus, “Where Does Yoga Come From? A Book Review on Yoga Body by Mark Singleton,” Christians Practicing Yoga (christianspracticingyoga.com). ↩
-
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Letter to the Bishops of the Catholic Church on Some Aspects of Christian Meditation (Orationis formas), October 15, 1989, §§16, 27 and 28. ↩
-
The Hebrew verb is hagah, “to murmur, utter, muse”: Francis Brown, S. R. Driver and Charles A. Briggs, A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament (Oxford, 1906), s.v. ↩
-
LC Preface 10. ↩
-
SC IV, Second Part. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Halloween, Christmas Trees and Yoga: Pagan Roots and Christian Freedom.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/halloween-christmas-trees-and-yoga/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.