What’s Going On Among the Lutherans?
A report and response to the book by Patsy A. Leppien and J. Kincaid Smith
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Recently, I read the book What’s Going on Among the Lutherans by Patsy A. Leppien and J. Kincaid Smith. The groundwork for the book started in 1984 by a group of conservative Lutherans who were concerned about the upcoming merger of the American Lutheran Church (ALC), the Lutheran Church of America (LCA), and the Association of Evangelical Lutheran Churches (AELC). In 1988, the merger became a reality and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) formed. This book claims to identify the doctrinal differences between traditional Lutheranism (and Christianity) as taught by Martin Luther and held by the more conservative Lutheran denominations1 versus the new theology of post-modernism as taught by the liberal theologians within the seminaries of the ELCA.
The book contains three sections: Doctrinal Controversies, Approach to Interpreting Scripture, and Recent Changes in American Lutheranism. The bulk of the book exists in the first section that outlines the doctrinal differences between the historic Lutheran faith (Position A) and the New Thinking (Position B). To support Position A the book quotes from the Bible, the Lutheran Confessions, the writings of Martin Luther, and other prominent Lutheran theologians. To support Position B the book quotes from many references used throughout the seminaries of the ELCA and other writings published by Augsburg Fortress. This paper will focus on the first section of the book (Doctrinal Controversies) and itemize some of the differences cited within the book. Since this book is over twenty years old, I have chosen to interact with the book’s claims and attempt to identify more recent support for the viewpoint documented on the New Thinking (Position B).
Biblical Hermaneutic
The foundational problem causing all of the doctrinal controversies between Position A and Position B is the method of interpreting the Bible. How a theologian or scholar views the Holy Scriptures will prejudice his interpretation of what he reads in the Bible.
Position A utilizes a hermeneutic named the Historical-Grammatical method. This method of Biblical interpretation “begins with the presupposition that all things are possible with God. God is the ultimate author of the Bible – which was inspired by the Holy Spirit working through human writers.”2 Because God is the author, the Bible is different from all other books in that it is infallible and inerrant. Clear passages of Scripture must be used to interpret less clear passages and the most accurate Greek or Hebrew manuscripts are used to translate and interpret the texts. Luther and Melanchthon were convinced that this is the only true method to interpret the Bible. In order to understand what God is saying to us today, the meaning and context of the words must be studied in their ordinary and biblical usage.
ESV 2 Timothy 3:16 All Scripture is breathed out by God [inspired] and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, 17 that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work.3
ESV 2 Peter 1:21 For no prophecy was ever produced by the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.
ESV John 10:35 If he called them gods to whom the word of God came—and Scripture cannot be broken— 36 do you say of him whom the Father consecrated and sent into the world, ‘You are blaspheming,’ because I said, ‘I am the Son of God’?
Therefore, concerning this religious matter, we offer this Confession. It is ours and our preachers’. It shows, from the Holy Scriptures and God’s pure Word, what has been up to this time presented in our lands, dukedoms, and cities, and taught in our churches. (AC, Preface)4
…contrary to the clear Scripture of the Holy Spirit… (Ap, Greeting)
Because we know that God does not lie. I and my neighbor and, in short, all people, may err and deceive. But God’s Word cannot err. (LC, Part IV)
I confidently believe that not one of their authors erred…For it is certain that the Scriptures do not lie…Scripture agrees with itself everywhere. (Luther, Wider Hans Worst, quoted in C.F.W. Walther, Die Evengelish-Lutherische Kirche Aug Erden, St Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1981, 131ff)
There is not a superfluous letter in …our scriptural texts…. They are God’s Scriptures and God’s Word [Die Schrifft…es ist Gottes schrifft und Gottes wort]. (Martin Luther, The Tree Symbols or Creeds of the Christian Faith (1528), Luther’s Works 34:227)
Mark you, so much emphasis does the apostle lay upon Scriptural authority, we are under no obligation to accept anything the Bible does not assert…. [And if] we are under no obligation to accept anything not presented in the Scriptures, we also reject all doctrines not taught therein…. [So] be certain you have full Scripture authority for all you accept. Of whatever is not in the Scriptures, ask as does the apostle…, “What did God ever assert it?” (Martin Luther, Sermon on Hebrews 1:1-12(1522), Sermons of Martin Luther, ed. J.N. Lenkey, 6:185-186)
Position B utilizes a hermeneutic named the Historical-Critical method. This method of Biblical interpretation arose during the Enlightenment Period when the theories of science seemed to contradict the Bible. Based upon this premise science, instead of the Holy Scriptures, is held as the infallible source and the Bible is examined in such a way as to explain why there is a contradiction. As such, scholars employing this method of Biblical interpretation will claim that the Bible contains many errors and consists of much folklore that was passed down through generations. The end result is that scholars holding to the Historical-Critical method claim that many of the books of the Bible were not written by those individuals who have claimed to have written them. Instead, many of the books of the Bible were written by a vast array of individuals of a period of many years (or decades or centuries) who incorporated biases and tales to propagate their own personal agendas into the texts.
…we also find in the Bible human emotion, testimony, opinion, cultural limitation and bias. ELCA Lutherans recognize that human testimony and writing are related to and often limited by culture, customs and world view. (ELCA website, The Bible -http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/New-or-Returning-to-Church/Dig-Deeper/The-Bible.aspx)
Because Biblical writers, editors and compilers were limited by their times and world views, even as we are, the Bible contains material wedded to those times and places. It also means that writers sometimes provide differing and even contradictory views of God’s word, ways and will. (ELCA website, The Bible - http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/New-or-Returning-to-Church/Dig-Deeper/The-Bible.aspx)
Listening to the living Jesus in the context of the church, we therefore have the task of deciding among these. Having done this listening, we sometimes conclude either that the writer’s culture or personal experience (e.g., subordination of women or keeping of slaves) seems to have prompted his missing what God was saying or doing, or that God now is saying or doing something new. (ELCA website, The Bible - http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/New-or-Returning-to-Church/Dig-Deeper/The-Bible.aspx)
Based on these two hermeneutical positions, it becomes easy to understand why theologians cannot agree on the meaning of the Bible. Is the Bible God’s revealed, infallible, and inerrant Word to man or is it simply a fairy tale? If the answer lies somewhere in between these two views, who decides what God’s truth is and what is man’s distortion? Since this fundamental Biblical hermeneutic cannot be agreed upon between the two differing positions, the book What’s Going on Among the Lutherans underscores that all traditional understandings of Christianity are open for discussing and debate. It is important to understand that Position A is typically backed by Scripture and Position B is typically backed by scientific theories and human reason.
Creation
Position A holds that God created all things, including man, within a span of six twenty four hour days.5 Therefore, contrary to Scripture, man could not have evolved from some lower life form. Evolution, at least from a micro-level, is a scientific teaching that is contrary to Scripture and scientifically unproven.
ESV Genesis 1:27 So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them.
ESV Exodus 20:11 For in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, the sea, and all that is in them, and rested on the seventh day. Therefore the LORD blessed the Sabbath day and made it holy.
ESV Matthew 19:4 He answered, “Have you not read that he who created them from the beginning made them male and female,
Position B holds that the creation account in Genesis is a myth used to explain man’s origins to a scientifically ignorant and simple people.
What is the ELCA official position concerning the origin of life and evolution?
The ELCA has not officially taken a position about evolution. The ELCA teaches that the scriptures witness that all of life is a gift of God. However, the scriptures do not say, for example, how God’s creating word, “Let there be…,” brings creatures into being. Lutheran tradition has respected the work of the natural sciences in investigating phenomena in the natural world and explaining how they work and how they originated. Because our knowledge both of God and of other things is partial (I Corinthians 13:9), what is accepted at any one time as valid scientific knowledge and theory can be either added to or corrected by further scientific investigation and better theories to explain the phenomena we see in the world. (ELCA Website, Faith, Science, and Technology - http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/Social-Issues/Faith-Science-and-Technology/Ask-a-Scientist.aspx#anchor5)
Lutherans have tended to keep their preaching more focused on the Bible than not. It is, fortunately,
rare to hear a Lutheran sermon that does not at least present itself as an exposition of a
biblical passage. But our question is: how do we, as post-Enlightenment interpreters, preach the
gospel from the Scriptures? I grew up in a fundamentalist arm of Lutheranism. The readings
were preached as if they presented factually accurate accounts of God’s people. It was as though
we believed the stories because they really happened, as if faith was accepting the historical facticity
of the Bible. (ELCA Website, media used for Worship 2000 jubilee - http://www.elca.org/~/media/Files/Worship/ramshaw_worship_2000_jubilee.ashx)
It is not as if for the Israelites this sea monster was forever destroyed. The Bible includes
several water stories that are most likely versions of the Tiamat myth. In the story of Noah’s
flood, God uses the chaotic seas to destroy the earth, and in the Exodus narrative of the crossing
of the sea, the Egyptian army, drowned in the sea, functions as the historic instance of mythic
evil. In the biblical versions of the myth, water is both the place of death and the way to new
life. Noah is saved from the watery chaos, but the earth is born anew from the waters, repeating
the creative miracle described in Genesis. In the exodus, the evil army, like Tiamat, is drowned
in the sea, but the water becomes the people’s pathway to freedom. The great fish both swallowed
up but then granted rebirth to the prophet Jonah, and when Jesus cited this story, he used
the belly of the fish as a symbol both of his coming death and of the birthplace of the resurrection.
All this data suggested to me that the New Testament writers mean to connect fish with
the messianic age. All the gospel accounts of the multiplication of loaves include fish as the food
Christ serves on the mountain. In two resurrection appearances Jesus eats fish with the disciples.
In John’s account, Jesus even cooks the fish. It is hard to judge whether the tie between a fish
meal and the life of Christ is based upon Old Testament allusions to fish at the endtime, Roman
cults of sacred fish meals, or genuine historic memories connecting Jesus with fish suppers. (ELCA Website, media used for Worship 2000 jubilee - http://www.elca.org/~/media/Files/Worship/ramshaw_worship_2000_jubilee.ashx)
Adam and Eve
Position A holds that Adam and Eve were two real historical individuals created by God.6 In addition, the Biblical accounts of people such as Noah, Jonah, and Job are also historically accurate.
ESV 2 Peter 1:16 For we did not follow cleverly devised myths when we made known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but we were eyewitnesses of his majesty.
Position B holds that Adam and Eve are symbols of humanity and not real people – they never really existed.7 The Biblical accounts of certain people and some places are nothing more than mythical stories or allegories used to explain a spiritual truth.
The Old Testament – Moses as Author
Position A holds that Moses was the author of the first five books of the Bible.
ESV John 7:19 Has not Moses given you the law? Yet none of you keeps the law. Why do you seek to kill me?”
ESV Mark 10:4 They said, “Moses allowed a man to write a certificate of divorce and to send her away.”
Position B holds that the first five books of the Bible were written centuries after Moses died. In fact, the first five books of the Bible, commonly referred to as the Pentateuch, were compiled from different sources and various authors. These various sources are identified as J, D, E, and P8 based on the differing interests of the authors.
The Old Testament – Prophecy and Authorship
Position A holds that the Old Testament prophets foretold the coming of Jesus Christ, God’s Son and Savior of the world.9 In addition, the Old Testament teaches about the authorship of its books, such as Isaiah and Daniel. These individuals, under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, authored the books that bear their names.
ESV Genesis 3:15 I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and her offspring; he shall bruise your head, and you shall bruise his heel.”
ESV Isaiah 7:14 Therefore the Lord himself will give you a sign. Behold, the virgin shall conceive and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel.
ESV Daniel 7:13 “I saw in the night visions, and behold, with the clouds of heaven there came one like a son of man, and he came to the Ancient of Days and was presented before him. 14 And to him was given dominion and glory and a kingdom, that all peoples, nations, and languages should serve him; his dominion is an everlasting dominion, which shall not pass away, and his kingdom one that shall not be destroyed.
ESV Luke 24:44 ¶ Then he said to them, “These are my words that I spoke to you while I was still with you, that everything written about me in the Law of Moses and the Prophets and the Psalms must be fulfilled.”
Position B holds that there are no prophecies in the Old Testament that refer to Jesus Christ. Any words that appear prophetic were probably written by an anonymous individual after the time in which the event occurred. Also, books that bear an individual’s name do not necessarily reflect authorship by that individual. Anonymous authors probably added and contributed to texts many years after they were originally written.
In response to Position B, according to the Historical-Grammatical hermeneutic, the Bible must be examined as any other source of literature. Since prophecy cannot be scientifically explained, the apparent Biblical prophecies must have been added after the event actually occurred. Therefore, all prophetic writings must be examined under scientific scrutiny and suspect to being historical truth.
The Words of Jesus
Position A holds that Jesus Christ made all the statements attributed to Him in the New Testament.10
Position B holds that many, if not all, of the statements attributed to Jesus Christ and recorded in the New Testament were probably added by the early church. Many of these alleged quotations were added as “interpretive traditions”.
Mark 10:45 has Jesus say that the Son of Man came to give his life “as a ransom for many” and the accounts of the Last Supper speak of Jesus’ blood as his “blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many” and “my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for the forgiveness of sins”. Such passages, in their present form at least, are usually regarded as having come not from Jesus himself, but from later interpretive traditions. The same is true of the instances where Jesus predicts his own death and resurrection, such as Mark 8:31ff and 9:31, and parallels in the other Synoptics. They are attributed to Jesus after the fact. But aside from such scanty references, the Synoptics even in their final form afford little explicit interpretation of Jesus’ work.11
The picture we have of Jesus’ life is made of bits and pieces taken from various Gospels, with generous portions of imagination added.12
Miracles
Position A holds that all miracles recorded in the Old and New Testaments actually and historically occurred.13 God created all things, but is not bound to the scientific realities that man is. Therefore, turning water into wine, growing and mending body parts, or separating a body of water are miraculous and achievable only by God.
Position B holds that miracles are “spiritual truths”, but not actual historical events. Scholars repeatedly look for the underlying meaning in the documented miracle to interpret what the author intended to say. In other words, the miracles are vehicles for communicating a deeper meaning than the miraculous event itself communicates.
Many of the stories told in Acts were probably well known to most of the readers. The author wastes no effort trying to prove that these things really happened. A few of the stories may have even seemed strange to Luke. The miracles performed by those who carried handerchiefs away from Paul’s body and the evil spirit that beat up the traveling exorcists seem to simply be a part of the lore of Paul.14
The Virgin Birth
Position A holds that Jesus Christ did not have a human father, but was miraculously conceived in the womb of Mary by the Holy Spirit. In addition to Scripture supporting this miraculous incarnation of God in man, the Creeds, the early church Fathers, tradition, and the Lutheran Confessions also support and declare belief in this infallible claim.
ESV Matthew 1:18 ¶ Now the birth of Jesus Christ took place in this way. When his mother Mary had been betrothed to Joseph, before they came together she was found to be with child from the Holy Spirit.
ESV Luke 1:35 And the angel answered her, “The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you; therefore the child to be born will be called holy—the Son of God.
On account of this personal union, Mary, the most blessed Virgin, did not bear a mere man. But, as the angel testifies, show bore a man who is truly the Son of the most high God. He showed His divine majesty even in His mother’s womb, because He was born of a virgin, without violating her virginity. Therefore, she is truly the mother of God and yet has remained a virgin. (FC SD, VIII, 24)
I believe in God the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth. And in Jesus Christ, His only Son, our Lord; who was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary… (Apostles Creed)
I believe…in one Lord Jesus Christ, the only begotten Son of God,…who for us men, and for our salvation, came down from heaven, and was incarnate by the Holy Ghost of the Virgin Mary, and was made made… (Nicene Creed)
Position B holds that Jesus Christ was not born of a virgin. In fact, the father of Jesus was probably Joseph or a Roman soldier. The early church simply perpetuated this myth in order to honor Jesus. Belief in a virgin birth of Jesus Christ is simply not necessary for Christians.
If belief in the virgin birth of Jesus Christ is not necessary for Christian theologians today, how can the deity of Christ be explained? After all, Christ is said to be “of one substance with the Father.”
The Deity of Christ
Position A holds that Jesus Christ is God. Again, along with the Scriptures, this truth is professed in the Creeds and the Lutheran Confessions.
ESV John 1:1 ¶ In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. 2 He was in the beginning with God. 3 All things were made through him, and without him was not any thing made that was made.
ESV Galatians 4:4 But when the fullness of time had come, God sent forth his Son, born of woman, born under the law,
ESV John 10:30 I and the Father are one.”
ESV Matthew 16:16 Simon Peter replied, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.”
I believe that Jesus Christ, true God, begotten of the Father from eternity, and also true man, born of the Virgin Mary, is my Lord. (SC, The Creed)
Position B holds that the deity of Jesus Christ is not taught in the Bible, but was developed by pious Christians in the first and second centuries.15 When asked about the Biblical claims of deity, scholars replied that these Biblical entries are simply myths that have been perpetuated through the generations.
What do Christians mean today when they confess (in the words of the Nicene Creed) that Jesus Christ “came down from heaven…and was made man?” When we no longer understand the universe to consist of heaven “up above, “ the earth in the middle, and an “underworld” beneath us, it is at least difficult and more likely impossible for Christians to take this language literally. But what does it mean to speak of Jesus as “divine”? Does not this word also call for some interpretation? Theologians today are concerned to interpret the divinity of Jesus in a manner which avoids turning him into a bizarre, mythological creature who contains both a divine nature and a human nature. (Paul Jersild, Invitation to Faith (Minneapolis: Augsburg Fortress, 1978), pp 99, 100) Paul Jersild retired in 2008 from Lutheran Theological Southern Seminary, Columbia, SC.
If belief in Jesus’ deity is not necessary for scholars holding to Position B, how can the Trinity be explained and understood?
The Trinity
Position A holds that the doctrine of the Trinity is clearly taught in Scripture.16 Although the word “Trinity” is never used, the doctrine and concept was understood and documented by the authors of the Bible.
ESV Matthew 28:19 Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit,
ESV 2 Corinthians 13:14 The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ and the love of God and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be with you all.
ESV 1 Peter 1:1 ¶ Peter, an apostle of Jesus Christ, To those who are elect exiles of the Dispersion in Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia, 2 according to the foreknowledge of God the Father, in the sanctification of the Spirit, for obedience to Jesus Christ and for sprinkling with his blood: May grace and peace be multiplied to you.
ESV Romans 8:9 ¶ You, however, are not in the flesh but in the Spirit, if in fact the Spirit of God dwells in you. Anyone who does not have the Spirit of Christ does not belong to him.
Position B holds that the doctrine of the Trinity is not taught in the Bible. Instead, the Trinity is nothing more than a belief that was added by early Christians in the fourth century during the “Trinitarian Controversy”.
Together, Father, Christ and Holy Spirit are the manifestations of the one God whom we know and understand to be revealed in a trinity of persons. For ELCA Lutherans, the Holy Spirit — as person — might be said to be one of God’s “three faces.” (ELCA Website, The Holy Spirit - http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/New-or-Returning-to-Church/Dig-Deeper/The-Holy-Spirit.aspx)17
It is important to note that these last three differences (the Virgin Birth, the Deity of Christ, and the Trinity) between Position A and Position B are all hinged together. Each belief holds the others together and to attack or deny any one of them disproves the other two. In fact, refuting the doctrinal stance on any one of these questions a man’s worship of a Christian God. Denying the Virgin Birth, the Trinity, and/or the Deity of Christ invalidates the reciting of the Apostles’ Creed, the Nicene Creed, and the Athanasius Creed. These Creeds have been used around the world for over a thousand years to unite Christians who worship the one true God of the Bible.
The Atonement
Position A holds that Jesus Christ died for the sins of the world.18 Jesus Christ suffered the wrath of God for our sins and removed the Father’s anger toward man. This act of substitution is called substitutionary atonement or propitiation. Without Jesus Christ’s substitutionary death, man could never stand before God based on our own righteousness.
ESV Romans 5:19 For as by the one man’s disobedience the many were made sinners, so by the one man’s obedience the many will be made righteous.
ESV Romans 5:8 But God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. 9 Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God.
ESV Hebrews 9:22 Indeed, under the law almost everything is purified with blood, and without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness of sins.
ESV Romans 3:25 …whom God put forward as a propitiation by his blood, to be received by faith. This was to show God’s righteousness, because in his divine forbearance he had passed over former sins. 26 It was to show his righteousness at the present time, so that he might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus.
God “Made him to be sin for us” (2 Corinthians 5:21). Christ is the one who stepped into the place of our sinful nature, loaded upon Himself, and appeased for us all, the wrath of God which we had deserved by all our works. (What Luther Says, 3 vols., ed. Ewald M. Plass, St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1959, 3:1418)
Paul teaches this in Galatians 3:13, when he says, “Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us.” (Ap, Article V, 58)
Position B holds that Jesus did not die as a substitution, but died like any good friend would die for another. God is not wrathful and there is no need for God to be upset with man. Instead, sin is only a weakness found in all men. God loves everyone and wants all His people to be happy. Since God loves everyone, there is no need for anyone to die in place of anyone else.
Jesus did not have to die as a condition of God’s forgiveness of sins. Mark knew that Jesus knew that God had always forgiven the sins of “many/all,” and that God would keep on forgiving their sins. (Dr. David J. Lull, Professor of New Testament at Wartburg Theological Seminary, lecture from 2010, p 9 - http://www.wartburgseminary.edu/uploadedfiles/Events/Lullone.pdf)
…I can’t get past the idea that God had a thirst for innocent blood that had to be quenched, or that God’s justice required a death-penalty for sinners until Jesus’ death satisfied God’s wrath. Even if Bible passages can be made to support these ideas, I can’t get past the idea that God had been unforgiving before Jesus died. That’s not the God I find in the Bible.” (Dr. David J. Lull, Professor of New Testament at Wartburg Theological Seminary, lecture from 2010, p 1 - http://www.wartburgseminary.edu/uploadedfiles/Events/Lullone.pdf)
So, an alternative to traditional substitutionary or satisfaction atonement theories is to think of “Good Friday,” not as the beginning of God’s saving action in Jesus, but as its “end,” in the sense that it represents the aim and purpose, the “first passion,” of what God was doing in Jesus’ life all along: namely, entering in full solidarity and accompaniment with the marginalized and oppressed.” (Dr. David J. Lull, Professor of New Testament at Wartburg Theological Seminary, lecture from 2010, p 2 - http://www.wartburgseminary.edu/uploadedfiles/Events/Lullone.pdf)
The Resurrection
Position A holds that the resurrection of the body will occur on the last day of history when all the souls of all who died in faith will be reunited with their glorified bodies to live forever in heaven with Jesus Christ.19
ESV John 2:19 Jesus answered them, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.” 20 The Jews then said, “It has taken forty-six years to build this temple, and will you raise it up in three days?” 21 But he was speaking about the temple of his body.
ESV Luke 24:39 See my hands and my feet, that it is I myself. Touch me, and see. For a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see that I have.”
Position B holds that no one really knows what the “body” is. The dead corpse that is buried when we die is certainly not the body. Therefore, “resurrection” must involve something spiritual and not physical.20 The account of Jesus’ resurrection in the Bible is a myth and not a truly historical event. The account of Lazarus’ resurrection was referring to a “dormant” body that was resuscitated and not resurrected.
In four passages (Mark 16:12, Luke 24:16, John 20:14 and 21:4) the witnesses fail to recognize the risen Christ. Nor is Jesus seen by any who are not in his wider circle of disciples (with the exception of St. Paul). Clearly, Jesus’ resurrection was not simply a return to his previous condition of life. All of this has led some scholars to write that the risen Jesus (and apparitions of the risen Jesus) is a supernatural reality which does not belong to this world and cannot be the object of historic investigation. Rather, Jesus’ resurrection is an object of faith. Accordingly, ELCA members believe that what history does is to demonstrate the disciples’ faith in the resurrection. Their witness and testimony to Jesus’ post-death appearances make it abundantly clear that the resurrection was a primary object of the apostolic proclamation from Christianity’s very beginning. (ELCA Website, The Resurrection - http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/New-or-Returning-to-Church/Dig-Deeper/The-Resurrection.aspx)
Basically, all beliefs held and taught in traditional Christianity have come under question. If the New Thinking no longer holds the true deity of Christ, His atonement, and His resurrection, how can man get to heaven?
The Way to Heaven
Position A holds that Jesus Christ is the only way to heaven and those that die without Him are lost in Hell.21
ESV John 3:16 ¶ “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life.
ESV John 14:6 Jesus said to him, “I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.
ESV John 3:36 Whoever believes in the Son has eternal life; whoever does not obey the Son shall not see life, but the wrath of God remains on him.
The command (Matt 28:19) pertains to all: “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them…” Hence whereas circumcision was commanded only to the descendents of Abraham, Baptism is commanded to all the nations, with the promise of salvation if they believe. (Martin Luther, Lectures on Genesis 15-20, Luther’s Works 3:104)
Position B holds that Jesus Christ is not the only way to heaven. Followers of non-Christian religions may also get to heaven. In fact, it is quite possible that all people will get to heaven. Hell may only be another mythological addition by the early church. After all, the Reformation changed thinking concerning the belief in a literal Purgatory. Perhaps Hell is simply another fabricated legend used to deter evil in the world.
Braaten says, “The Christian hope for salvation, whether for the believing few or the unbelieving many, is grounded in the person and meaning of Christ alone, not in the potential of the world’s religions to save, nor in the moral seriousness of humanists and people of good will, not even in the good works of pious Christians and church people… There is a universalist thrust in the New Testament, particularly in Paul’s theology. How else can we read passages such as ‘for as all die in Adam, so all will be made alive in Christ’ (1 Cor 15:22)?” (See also Colossians 1:15-20, Ephesians 1:9-10, 1 Corinthians 15:28.) (ELCA Website, Salvation - http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/New-or-Returning-to-Church/Dig-Deeper/Salvation.aspx)
For ELCA Lutherans, Braaten’s words ring true: “The special quality of Jesus’ uniqueness is best grasped in terms of his universal meaning. This concrete person, Jesus of Nazareth, is unique because of his unequaled universal significance. The point of his uniqueness underlines his universality. If Jesus is the Lord and Savior, he is the universal Lord and Savior, not merely my personal Lord and Savior. Because Jesus is the unique and universal Savior, there is a large hope for salvation, not only for me and others with the proper credentials of believing and belonging to the church, but for all people whenever or wherever they might have lived and no matter how religious or irreligious they may have proved to be themselves. It is clearly God’s announced will that all people shall be saved and come to the knowledge of truth (1 Timothy 2:4).” (ELCA Website, Salvation - http://www.elca.org/What-We-Believe/New-or-Returning-to-Church/Dig-Deeper/Salvation.aspx)
Jesus now sends the disciples to make disciples of all nations. That does not mean make everyone disciples. Most people who are helped by Jesus and believe in him never become disciples. Jesus includes in salvation people who do not believe in him or even know about him. (Lutheran Study Bible, First Printing (Augsburg Fortress, Minneapolis, MN, 2009, 1658)
Let us pray for those who do not share our faith in Jesus Christ. Almighty and eternal God, gather into you embrace all those who call out to you under different names. Bring an end to inter-religious strife, and make us more faithful witnesses of the love made known to us in your Son. (Evangelical Lutheran Worship: Leaders Desk Edition, Augsburg Fortress, Minneapolis, MN, 2006, 637)
Rev. Hanson, in August of 2006 wrote “An Open Letter to Jewish, Muslim, and Christian Leaders” in which he said, “(t)he one God whom we worship is a God not only of judgment, but of mercy and peace.” Hanson goes on to say, “(i)t is time for us together to publicly, clearly, and courageously give witness that the One in whom we believe unites us in our diversity rather than divides us in our hostilities.” (ELCA Website, An Open Letter to Jewish, Muslim, and Christian Leaders - http://www2.elca.org/bishop/messages/m_060809letter.html)
God’s universal salvation: Difficult as it is—because I always think of it as unfair—I’ve come to accept God’s universal salvation as the final consequence of Jesus’ resurrection. I think of all the best and worst, the innocent and the guilty, Holocaust victims and the evil perpetrators, those killed in all of our senseless wars and the misguided leaders who send them into battle. Christ will raise us all—and somehow bend us into shape so we become the human beings we were intended to be. (The Lutheran – magazine of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, Counting the Last Days, Walter Bouman, November 2005 - http://www.thelutheran.org/article/article.cfm?article_id=5534 subscription required)
Conclusion
The New Thinking is more than a scholarly look at what we believe. It is an attempt by Satan to pull people away from Christ and salvation. Clearly, the teachings held by Position B go against the Lutheran Confessions, therefore, those holding to these teachings are not Lutheran at all. In addition, the teachings held by Position B go against the ancient Creeds and the Holy Scriptures, therefore, those holding to these teachings are not Christian. It is important for Christians, especially Lutheran Christians, to stand up against this post-modern teaching from liberal scholars.
Based on my studies at this time, I have not witnessed full blown support by the entire denomination or leadership within the ELCA on all of these issues. However, Position B and the New Thinking is taught in the seminaries of the ELCA by several of the professors. These beliefs are taught as valid alternatives to traditional Christianity. Based upon this alone, the ELCA recognizes and accepts truths that conflict and even deny one another, which of course is absurd. Truths that conflict with one another cannot both be correct, in fact, they may both be incorrect. My conclusion to the state of the ELCA based upon its teachings is that the ELCA simply does not know what the truth is. This is a very post-modern look at the world and God’s Word. The denomination and seminaries of the ELCA will permit a wide variety of teachings that even contradict one another. Therefore, the only teaching that will be unacceptable is one that teaches a belief in a single known truth – and yet this is what Christians have believed for the last 2000 years. Sadly, the denomination, its leaders and professors, its pastors and laypeople, stand side by side with Pontius Pilate and asked, “What is truth?” Like Pilate, they cast aside Jesus Christ, the only Lord and Savior that provides the answer to their question. Jesus Christ responds, “I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.” The answer they seek to find lies written in the book they refuse to believe.
Heresies come and go in Christendom. I believe that is why this book, written over twenty years ago, was able to pinpoint the wayward teachings of the ELCA. The outcome of these teachings is obvious to the authors of What’s Going on Among the Lutherans. However, the rest of the Lutherans in the ELCA are playing catch up and fighting for the doctrines that are vital for Lutheran Christianity. Can true Christians continue to worship and identify with the ELCA and its churches? There are still many, if not the majority of pastors and laity within the ELCA that continue to hold to traditional Lutheran teachings. However, as time marches on, each generation of ELCA members will fall farther and farther away from the beliefs and instruction of the early church Fathers and Lutheran theologians, such as Martin Luther.
Footnotes
-
According to the book, the conservative Lutheran denominations include the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (WELS), the Evangelical Lutheran Synod (ELS), and the Lutheran Church – Missouri Synod (LCMS). ↩
-
Patsy A. Leppien and J. Kincaid Smith, What’s Going on Among the Lutherans? (Milwaukee: Northwestern Publishing House, 1992) p. 32. ↩
-
All Scripture quotations, unless otherwise noted, come from (International Bible Society 1984). ↩
-
All quotations from the Book of Concord come from (McCain 2006). ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 61. ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 65. ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 67. ↩
-
Scholars in the nineteenth century became so focused on source criticism that they even identified “groups” of individuals that wrote the older manuscripts of the Old Testament. Specifically, these “sources” cobbled together the texts of the Pentateuch (the books of Moses). ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 74. ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 78. ↩
-
Gerhard O. Forde, Christian Dogmatics, 2 vols., eds., Carl E. Braaten and Robert W. Jenson (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1984), p2:12,13. ↩
-
Donald H. Juel, Search. Unit 5. Matthew 1-16, Leader’s Guide (Minneaopolis: Augsburg Publishing House, 1984), p. 17. ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 83. ↩
-
David Tiede, Search. Unit 1. Acts 1-8, Leader’s Guide (Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House, 1983), p.6. ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 97. ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 101. ↩
-
This heresy was refuted in the early church and known as Modalism. Sabellius taught that God revealed himself in three “faces”. ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 105. ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 113. ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 114. ↩
-
Leppien and Smith, What’s Going on, p. 159. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “What’s Going On Among the Lutherans?: A report and response to the book by Patsy A. Leppien and J. Kincaid Smith.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/whats-going-on-among-the-lutherans/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.