Confessing the Confessions
Can One Knowingly Reject Them and Remain a Faithful Lutheran?
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“So everyone who acknowledges me before men, I also will acknowledge before my Father who is in heaven, but whoever denies me before men, I also will deny before my Father who is in heaven.” — Matthew 10:32–33
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation.
The Question Before Us
Every pastor eventually hears some form of this question. A member who has been Lutheran all her life says, “I don’t believe everything in the Book of Concord. I’m not even sure I believe what the Catechism says about Baptism. Am I still a Lutheran?” Or a man who joined from another church says, “I like it here, but I could never accept that the bread is really Christ’s body. Does that matter?” Or a seminary graduate asks, more quietly, whether he can take the ordination vow while holding some of the Confessions at arm’s length.
The question has a sharper form and it deserves to be stated fairly. If the Lutheran Confessions are true, can a person knowingly reject them and still be a faithful Lutheran? A thoughtful critic will press it from several sides. Isn’t the Bible our only rule and norm? Why then should a book written by sixteenth-century theologians bind anyone’s conscience? Isn’t it a kind of legalism to make people sign a document most of them have never read? Doesn’t Jesus save us by grace through faith, not by agreement with the Formula of Concord? And if we insist on the Confessions, aren’t we fencing people out of the Church whom Christ has welcomed in?
These are honest objections and they deserve honest answers. I believe the answers are found where Lutherans have always looked for them, in Holy Scripture first and then in the Confessions themselves, with the help of the fathers of the early Church and the teachers of the Reformation. In this paper I want to take up the question in five steps: 1) What is a confession, according to Scripture? 2) What do the Lutheran Confessions claim for themselves? 3) What does it mean to subscribe to them, quia or quatenus? 4) Who is bound by them, and in what way: the pastor, the confirmed layperson, and the weak or untaught? 5) What is the difference between an error and a heresy? Then we will draw these together and ask what all of this means for us as a congregation.
I. What Is a Confession?
The word itself
We begin with the word. Webster’s 1828 dictionary gives several senses of confession. The second is “avowal; the act of acknowledging; profession,” and Webster illustrates it with Paul’s words about Christ, “who before Pontius Pilate witnessed a good confession.” The fourth sense is “a formulary in which the articles of faith are comprised; a creed to be assented to or signed, as a preliminary to admission into a church.”1 Both senses matter for our question. A confession is first something a person does with his mouth and then something a church writes down so that its members can say it together.
The Greek word behind “confess” in the New Testament is homologeō. It is built from homos (“same”) and legō (“to say”). Thayer defines it as “to say the same thing as another, i.e. to agree with, assent.”2 To confess the faith is to say the same thing God has said in His Word and to say it together with the Church. The noun is homologia (“confession, profession”). In other words, a confession is never a private opinion. It is agreement spoken aloud.
Confession in the mouth of Christ and His apostles
Our Lord makes confession a matter of eternal weight. “So everyone who acknowledges me before men, I also will acknowledge before my Father who is in heaven, but whoever denies me before men, I also will deny before my Father who is in heaven” (Matthew 10:32–33). The word translated “acknowledges” is homologēsei, the same verb. Jesus does not say “whoever privately admires me.” He speaks of the public word, said before others, which He will answer with His own word before the Father. When He asked His disciples, “But who do you say that I am?” Peter answered for them all: “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God” (Matthew 16:15–16). That answer was a confession and the Church has been repeating it ever since.
Paul ties confession to salvation itself. “If you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For with the heart one believes and is justified, and with the mouth one confesses and is saved” (Romans 10:9–10). Faith lives in the heart. However, faith does not stay there. It comes out of the mouth as confession. Paul does not set the two against each other. He holds them together as the root and the fruit of one living faith.
Paul reminds Timothy of the day he made his own confession: “Take hold of the eternal life to which you were called and about which you made the good confession in the presence of many witnesses.” Then he points Timothy to Christ, “who in his testimony before Pontius Pilate made the good confession” (1 Timothy 6:12–13). This is the passage Webster cited. Our Lord’s confession before Pilate is the pattern of every Christian confession. He spoke the truth about Himself before an authority that could kill Him and He did not take it back.
Confession has content
A confession is not only an act. It has content and the content is handed down. Paul tells Timothy, “Follow the pattern of the sound words that you have heard from me, in the faith and love that are in Christ Jesus. By the Holy Spirit who dwells within us, guard the good deposit entrusted to you” (2 Timothy 1:13–14). The word pattern (hypotypōsis, “outline, sketch, model”) tells us that apostolic teaching has a shape that can be kept or lost. The word deposit (parathēkē, “something entrusted to another’s care”) tells us that this teaching does not belong to Timothy. He has been given it to guard and to pass on. Jude writes in the same way: “contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints” (Jude 3). The faith here is not the act of believing (fides qua, “the faith by which we believe”) but the content believed (fides quae, “the faith which is believed”). It was given once and it is not revised.
The first Christians lived this way from the beginning. “They devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers” (Acts 2:42). Doctrine comes first in the list. Paul appeals to the Corinthians “that all of you agree, and that there be no divisions among you, but that you be united in the same mind and the same judgment” (1 Corinthians 1:10). The Greek phrase behind “that all of you agree” is literally “that you all say the same thing” (to auto legēte pantes). That is very nearly the definition of homologeō.
The early Church confessed
The early Church received this pattern and wrote it down. Within a century of the apostles Irenaeus of Lyons could describe the faith that the churches everywhere held in common: one God the Father Almighty, one Christ Jesus the Son of God made flesh for our salvation, and one Holy Spirit who proclaimed through the prophets. He then wrote that the Church, “although scattered throughout the whole world, yet, as if occupying but one house, carefully preserves it. She also believes these points [of doctrine] just as if she had but one soul, and one and the same heart.”3 This is what confession looks like across a whole Church. Many voices say the same thing.
When Arius taught that the Son was a creature, the bishops gathered at Nicaea in 325 did not simply restate the faith in the words of Scripture. They found that Arius could repeat the words of Scripture and mean something else by them. Therefore they wrote a creed with a precise word (homoousios, “of one substance”) and attached a condemnation: “And whosoever shall say that there was a time when the Son of God was not, or that before he was begotten he was not, or that he was made of things that were not … all that so say, the Catholic and Apostolic Church anathematizes them.”4 The Arians complained that the fathers had used words not found in Scripture.5 Athanasius answered that the council had expressed in those words the very sense of what Scripture says of the Saviour.6 He was so confident of this that he could write to the bishops of Africa, “But the word of the Lord which came through the ecumenical Synod at Nicæa, abides forever.”7 He did not mean that the council was equal to Scripture. He meant that the council had confessed what Scripture teaches and so its confession shared in the permanence of the Word it confessed.
Hilary of Poitiers felt the weight of this. He would rather have adored God in silence. However, he wrote, “the errors of heretics and blasphemers force us to deal with unlawful matters, to scale perilous heights, to speak unutterable words, to trespass on forbidden ground.”8 The Church does not write confessions because it loves to argue. It writes them because the truth has been denied and the flock must be taught what to believe.
Basil the Great shows us how such a confession was used. When a bishop named Eustathius, whose orthodoxy was in doubt, wished to be received in fellowship, Basil set down a statement of the faith for him to sign. It begins: “Both men whose minds have been preoccupied by a heterodox creed and now wish to change over to the congregation of the orthodox, and also those who are now for the first time desirous of being instructed in the doctrine of truth, must be taught the creed drawn up by the blessed fathers in the Council which met at Nicæa.” The heading of the letter in the manuscripts tells us that it was “subscribed by Eustathius.”9 Here, in the fourth century, is a written confession, a teacher asked to put his name to it, and two kinds of people distinguished: those coming out of error and those being taught for the first time. We will meet each of these again.
II. What Do the Lutheran Confessions Claim for Themselves?
If we want to know whether a person can reject the Confessions and remain a faithful Lutheran, we need to know what the Confessions say they are. A critic sometimes imagines that Lutherans have raised a sixteenth-century book to the level of Scripture. The Confessions themselves say something quite different.
Witnesses, not judges
The Formula of Concord opens with a short section called “Rule and Norm.” It states first, “We believe, teach, and confess that the sole rule and standard according to which all dogmas together with [all] teachers should be estimated and judged are the prophetic and apostolic Scriptures of the Old and of the New Testament alone.”10 Every other writing, ancient or modern, is to be received only “as witnesses, [which are to show] in what manner after the time of the apostles, and at what places, this [pure] doctrine of the prophets and apostles was preserved.”11 Later the same section draws the line as sharply as it can be drawn. The Holy Scriptures “alone remain the only judge, rule, and standard,” while “the other symbols and writings cited are not judges, as are the Holy Scriptures, but only a testimony and declaration of the faith, as to how at any time the Holy Scriptures have been understood and explained in the articles in controversy in the Church of God by those then living.”12
Lutheran teachers have long summed this up in two Latin phrases. Scripture is the norma normans (“the norming norm”), the rule that rules everything else. The Confessions are the norma normata (“the normed norm”), a rule that is itself ruled by Scripture. The companion paper Scripture Alone and Its Interpreter takes up how Scripture interprets itself and why it alone is the judge. Here we need only say that the Confessions never ask to be believed apart from Scripture. They ask to be tested by it.
Yet they bind
However, the same Formula that calls the Confessions witnesses also says that Lutherans bind themselves to them. Of the three ecumenical Creeds it says, “we pledge ourselves to them, and hereby reject all heresies and dogmas which, contrary to them, have been introduced into the Church of God.”13 It then names the Unaltered Augsburg Confession, its Apology, and the Smalcald Articles as “the symbol of our time.”14 And because these matters “concern also the laity and the salvation of their souls,” it confesses Luther’s Small and Large Catechisms “as the Bible of the laity, wherein everything is comprised which is treated at greater length in Holy Scripture, and is necessary for a Christian man to know for his salvation.”15
The Solid Declaration explains why a church needs such a standard at all. “For thorough, permanent unity in the Church it is, above all things, necessary that we have a comprehensive, unanimously approved summary and form wherein is brought together from God’s Word the common doctrine,” just as “the ancient Church always had for this use its fixed symbols.” This summary is not to rest on private writings but on books “received in the name of the churches which pledge themselves to one doctrine and religion.”16 The Augsburg Confession is received “not because it was composed by our theologians, but because it has been taken from God’s Word and is founded firmly and well therein.”17 The purpose of all of it is “that we should have a unanimously accepted, definite, common form of doctrine, which all our evangelical churches together and in common confess.”18
Is this a contradiction? Can the Confessions be only witnesses and yet bind? They can and the reason is simple. A witness who tells the truth binds the conscience, not by his own authority, but by the authority of the truth he tells. The Augsburg Confession binds a Lutheran because it says what Scripture says. If it did not say what Scripture says, it would bind no one. No one is saved by subscribing to anything. We are saved by the Christ whom the Confessions confess, and a church’s subscription is its promise to keep telling us about Him.
Before the judgment seat of Christ
The men who signed the Formula did not think of their signatures as a formality. At the end of the Solid Declaration they wrote, “Since now, in the sight of God and of all Christendom … we wish to testify to those now living and those who shall come after us that this declaration herewith presented concerning all the controverted articles aforementioned and explained, and no other, is our faith, doctrine, and confession, in which we are also willing, by God’s grace, to appear with intrepid hearts before the judgment-seat of Jesus Christ, and give an account of it; and that we will neither privately nor publicly speak or write anything contrary to it, but, by the help of God’s grace, intend to abide thereby.”19 The Preface to the Book of Concord says the same thing in its own words: the signers resolved “not to depart even a finger’s breadth either from the subjects themselves, or from the phrases which are found in them.”20
That language did not begin with the Formula. It comes from Luther. In 1528, in his Confession Concerning Christ’s Supper, Luther closed with a statement of his whole faith. The Formula of Concord quotes its opening in full: “I mean by this writing to confess my faith, point by point [concerning all the articles of our religion], before God and all the world, in which I intend to abide until my death, and therein (so help me God!) to depart from this world and to appear before the judgment-seat of Jesus Christ.” He anticipated that after his death some would say he would have changed his mind. Against this he wrote that he had compared these articles with the Scriptures “time and again” and added, “I am not drunk nor thoughtless; I know what I say; I also am sensible of what it means for me at the coming of the Lord Christ at the final judgment.”21 Luther ends that same confession by calling what he has written his faith and the faith of all true Christians, as the Holy Scriptures teach.22
This is the mood of the Lutheran Confessions. They speak as men who expect to give an account to Christ for what they have taught, and not as the opinions of a school. In other words, they took our Lord’s word in Matthew 10:32 to be spoken to them.
Not a new faith
Lastly, the Confessions insist that they introduce nothing new. The Augsburg Confession closes by saying that its articles were presented “in order that it might be understood that in doctrine and ceremonies nothing has been received on our part against Scripture or the Church Catholic.”23 The Preface to the Book of Concord says the signers were “not introducing a new confession,” but wished “to lead our churches and schools, first of all, to the fountains of Holy Scripture, and to the Creeds, and then to the Augsburg Confession.”24 The Book of Concord itself places the three ecumenical Creeds at the front. A Lutheran who confesses the Book of Concord confesses the faith of Nicaea, of Irenaeus, and of the apostles.
III. Quia or Quatenus?
Two ways to sign
If a church asks its teachers to subscribe to a confession, the next question is how. Lutherans have used two Latin words to describe the answer. To subscribe quatenus (“insofar as”) is to say, “I accept the Confessions insofar as they agree with Scripture.” To subscribe quia (“because”) is to say, “I accept the Confessions because they agree with Scripture.”
The difference sounds small, yet in practice it is very large. A quatenus subscription leaves each reader to decide for himself where the Confessions agree with Scripture and where they do not. It is often pointed out that a man could subscribe the Koran quatenus, insofar as it agrees with the Bible, and promise nothing at all. A quia subscription says that I have tested the doctrinal content of the Confessions against Scripture and found it to be a true exposition of Scripture, and so I stand behind it as a whole and not only where I happen to agree.
Walther and Krauth
The classic statement of the quia position in America came from C. F. W. Walther in an essay of 1858, Why Should Our Pastors, Teachers and Professors Subscribe Unconditionally to the Symbolical Writings of Our Church? Walther defined the matter this way: “An unconditional subscription is the solemn declaration which the individual who wants to serve the church makes under oath that he accepts the doctrinal content of our Lutheran Confessions, because he recognizes the fact that they are in full agreement with Scripture and do not militate against Scripture in any point, whether the point be of major or minor importance; and that he therefore heartily believes in this divine truth and is determined to preach this doctrine.”25
Walther was careful about what the subscription covers. It covers the doctrinal content of the Confessions. Walther did not ask a pastor to swear to every historical remark in them, to every exegesis of a particular verse, or to the scientific assumptions of the sixteenth century. He asked him to swear to the doctrine, all of it, the articles of major importance and the articles of minor importance alike.26 That distinction keeps quia subscription from becoming a kind of bibliolatry of the Book of Concord. The Confessions themselves draw it when they call Scripture the only judge.
Charles Porterfield Krauth, who did more than anyone to recover the Confessions among the English-speaking Lutherans of the nineteenth century, made the moral point plainly. “We do not say, that any man shall believe that the Confession of our Church is Scriptural. We only contend, that he should neither say nor seem to say so, if he does not believe it. The subscription to a Confession is simply a just and easy mode of testifying to those who have a right to ask it of us, that we are what we claim and profess to be.”27 Krauth is not interested in forcing anyone’s conscience. He is interested in honesty. A man may disagree with the Augsburg Confession. However, he may not say that he confesses it when he does not.
Not a Lutheran oddity
It helps to remember that churches outside our own have understood this too. For instance, Rome required of its clergy, after the Council of Trent, a formal profession of the Tridentine faith (the Professio fidei Tridentinae of 1564).28 Presbyterian ministers are asked at ordination whether they sincerely receive and adopt the Westminster Confession and Catechisms as containing the system of doctrine taught in Holy Scripture. Anglican clergy have long been required to give their assent to the Thirty-Nine Articles and the Book of Common Prayer. The Articles themselves describe what they are as “agreed upon” for “the establishing of consent touching true religion.”29 Each of these churches confesses something we do not confess at certain points. However, all of them understand that a church which asks its teachers to teach must also be able to say what they will teach.
Why quia?
Why should a Lutheran subscribe quia and not quatenus? There are three reasons and each goes back to Scripture. The first is the nature of confession itself. To confess is to “say the same thing.” A quatenus subscription does not say the same thing as anyone; it says only what the subscriber himself already thinks, which is the opposite of homologeō. The second is the duty of the teacher. “Keep a close watch on yourself and on the teaching. Persist in this, for by so doing you will save both yourself and your hearers” (1 Timothy 4:16). A congregation that calls a pastor has a right to know what he will teach before he stands in the pulpit (Hebrews 13:7–9). A quatenus subscription cannot tell them. The third is the comfort of the flock. Paul warns that a time is coming when people “will not endure sound teaching, but having itching ears they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own passions” (2 Timothy 4:3). A confession subscribed without reservation is a promise to the people of God that they will not be handed over to whatever their pastor happens to think this year. Paul wants believers to be no longer “children, tossed to and fro by the waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine” (Ephesians 4:14). A quia subscription is one of the ways the Church keeps that promise.
IV. Who Is Bound, and How?
Our question asks whether a person can reject the Confessions and remain a faithful Lutheran. Webster defines faithful as “firm in adherence to the truth and to the duties of religion,” and in another sense as “observant of compact, treaties, contracts, vows or other engagements; true to one’s word.”30 Both senses help us. To be a faithful Lutheran is to adhere to the truth the Lutheran Church confesses and to keep whatever promise one has made concerning it. However, not everyone has made the same promise. We need to distinguish three groups.
1) Pastors and teachers
The first group is those who teach. James writes, “Not many of you should become teachers, my brothers, for you know that we who teach will be judged with greater strictness” (James 3:1). Paul charged the elders of Ephesus, “Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers,” and he warned them that “from among your own selves will arise men speaking twisted things, to draw away the disciples after them” (Acts 20:28, 30). The teacher’s confession is not only his own. It is the confession he gives to the flock.
The Lutheran church bodies of our day confess the Book of Concord in their constitutions and ask their pastors to do the same. The constitution of Lutheran Congregations in Mission for Christ (LCMC), for example, says, “We believe, teach, and accept the Unaltered Augsburg Confession and the Small Catechism as true witnesses to the Word of God, normative for our teaching and practice.” It continues, “We believe, teach, and confess the other confessional writings in the Book of Concord, namely, the Apology of the Augsburg Confession, the Smalcald Articles, the Treatise, the Large Catechism, and the Formula of Concord, as further valid expositions of the Holy Scriptures.”31 We should be careful here. LCMC names the Augsburg Confession and the Small Catechism as the normative standards and receives the rest of the Book of Concord as further expositions of Scripture. Many Lutheran congregational constitutions follow a similar pattern, receiving the Unaltered Augsburg Confession as a true witness to the Gospel and the other writings of the Book of Concord as further valid interpretations of the faith of the Church.
None of these statements uses the word quia. A pastor may hold the Confessions as Walther did or may hold them with less precision than Walther wished. For my part, I subscribe the whole Book of Concord quia and I believe every pastor should, even where his church body’s constitution asks less. However, every one of these statements says something that would make no sense if the Confessions were optional for the teacher. They are “normative for our teaching,” “true witnesses,” “valid expositions.” A pastor who stands at the altar and promises to preach and teach in accordance with them has made a vow. If he knowingly rejects what they teach (say, the bodily presence of Christ in the Supper confessed in AC X, or the gift of Baptism confessed in SC IV), and continues to teach under that vow, he is not being faithful in Webster’s sense. He is not true to his word.
What should such a man do? Krauth’s answer is the honest one. He should neither say nor seem to say that he confesses what he does not believe. In addition, he should tell those to whom he has made the promise. He should not teach against the Confessions from the pulpit he received because he promised to teach them. Paul says that a divisive person should be warned once and then a second time (Titus 3:10). The order matters. Patience comes first. However, the Church cannot let a man go on teaching against its confession indefinitely and still say that it confesses anything at all.
2) The confirmed layperson
The second group is the baptized and confirmed member. Most laypeople have never been asked to sign the Book of Concord and most have never read all of it. They have been taught the Small Catechism, often by a pastor who asked them to memorize it. They have been asked at confirmation to confess the faith into which they were baptized. What binds them?
The Formula of Concord itself answers this when it calls the Small and Large Catechisms “the Bible of the laity.”32 The layperson’s confession is the Catechism: the Ten Commandments, the Creed, the Lord’s Prayer, Baptism, Confession and Absolution, and the Sacrament of the Altar. These are not small things. They contain the whole Gospel. The Solid Declaration says that the laity, “inasmuch as they are Christians, must for their salvation distinguish between pure and false doctrine,” and so the Church gives them the Catechisms, in which “the Christian doctrine from God’s Word is comprised … in the most correct and simple way.”33
Luther himself was firm about this and his firmness may surprise us. In the preface to the Small Catechism he told pastors that those who are unwilling to learn the Catechism “should be told that they deny Christ and are no Christians, neither should they be admitted to the Sacrament.” Yet in the very next breath he added, “For although we cannot and should not force any one to believe, yet we should insist and urge the people that they know what is right and wrong with those among whom they dwell.”34 Luther’s severity is aimed at the person who refuses to learn, not at the person who is still learning. He wanted the Catechism taught slowly, one part at a time, “and take your time to it.”35
What then of the layperson who says, “I have read what the Catechism says about the Lord’s Supper, I understand it, and I do not believe it”? This is a real case and it should be answered with patience and honesty. Such a person has not taken the teacher’s vow. While he is still asking and still listening he is a learner and not a heretic. However, he should know that his disagreement touches a point the Lutheran Church confesses as the teaching of Christ Himself. He should keep asking, keep reading, and keep coming to be taught, and his pastor should keep teaching him from Scripture. If after patient teaching he settles in his heart against Christ’s words, he has passed from learner to dissenter. We still do not call him a heretic in the public sense unless he teaches his error or presses it on others, because the Preface to the Book of Concord reserves its condemnation for “obstinate and blasphemous teachers.”36 Yet he can no longer say that he confesses what the Lutheran altar confesses.
Should such a man come to the Sacrament? Paul warns against eating and drinking “without discerning the body” (1 Corinthians 11:29), and the Catechism says that “he that does not believe these words, or doubts, is unworthy and unfit.”37 To receive the Supper is to confess what is given there, so while he denies it he should not commune. He and his pastor should talk this through together and privately (see A Free Gospel and a Guarded Table). It is not a reason for him to leave. He belongs in the pew and the Bible class under the Word, because only the Word can persuade him, and the altar is open to him on the day he can say Amen to Christ’s own words. The member who believes those words and fears only that she is unworthy is in a different place altogether. The Formula calls such people “the truly worthy guests for whom this highly venerable Sacrament [and sacred feast] has been especially instituted and appointed.”38
3) The weak and the untaught
The third group is the largest. It includes the new Christian, the child, the person who has never been taught, the member who is troubled by a hard teaching and does not know what to think, and the person who came to us from another church and has not yet heard the Lutheran answer. Scripture is very gentle with these. “As for the one who is weak in faith, welcome him, but not to quarrel over opinions” (Romans 14:1). Of the weak brother Paul says, “by your knowledge this weak person is destroyed, the brother for whom Christ died” (1 Corinthians 8:11). Of Christ the prophet says, “a bruised reed he will not break, and a faintly burning wick he will not quench” (Isaiah 42:3).
Luther knew this well. When he returned from the Wartburg in 1522 and found that others had forced changes in the Mass on people who were not ready for them, he preached a series of sermons (the Invocavit Sermons) urging that faith must be taught and love must be patient with the weak, and that consciences must be won by the Word and not driven by compulsion.39 In his preface to Romans he summed up chapters 14 and 15 as teaching that weak consciences are to be led gently and spared.40 Luther could be very hard on a stubborn teacher and still patient with a weak hearer.
The Apology of the Augsburg Confession makes room for this as well. Speaking of the true Church built on the foundation of Christ, it says, “there are also many weak persons, who build upon the foundation stubble that will perish, i.e., certain unprofitable opinions, which, nevertheless, because they do not overthrow the foundation, are both forgiven them and also corrected.” It adds that “the writings of the holy Fathers testify that sometimes even they built stubble upon the foundation, but that this did not overthrow their faith.”41 In other words, our own Confessions expect that true believers will hold some errors. The errors are forgiven for Christ’s sake and corrected by the Word over time.
V. Error and Heresy
The word heresy
We now come to the heart of the question. Is everyone who rejects some part of the Lutheran Confessions a heretic? The word needs defining before we use it. The Greek hairesis comes from the verb haireomai (“to choose, to take for oneself”). Thayer gives its senses as “choosing, choice,” then “an opinion chosen,” and then a body of people following their own chosen tenets, a sect or party.42 Webster notes that in its earliest use the word meant simply a sect or party “implying no reproach,” but in its proper religious sense heresy is “a fundamental error in religion,” and in law “a denial of some of its essential doctrines, publicly avowed and obstinately maintained.”43 Tertullian, near the year 200, made the same observation about the word: a heretic is one who has chosen for himself what he will believe instead of receiving what has been handed down.44
These definitions agree on two marks: the error touches a fundamental doctrine and it is held with obstinacy against correction. Paul says that there “must be factions” (haireseis) among the Corinthians “in order that those who are genuine among you may be recognized” (1 Corinthians 11:19). He tells Titus to warn “a person who stirs up division” (hairetikon anthrōpon) once and then twice, and after that to have nothing more to do with him. Then he gives the reason: “such a person is warped and sinful; he is self-condemned” (Titus 3:10–11). The heretic has been warned and has refused. He condemns himself by choosing his own opinion over the Word that has been set before him.
Augustine’s distinction
Augustine gave the Church the distinction it has used ever since. Writing during the Donatist controversy, he said: “But though the doctrine which men hold be false and perverse, if they do not maintain it with passionate obstinacy, especially when they have not devised it by the rashness of their own presumption, but have accepted it from parents who had been misguided and had fallen into error, and if they are with anxiety seeking the truth, and are prepared to be set right when they have found it, such men are not to be counted heretics.”45 In the City of God he described the other side: “Those, therefore, in the Church of Christ who savor anything morbid and depraved, and, on being corrected that they may savor what is wholesome and right, contumaciously resist, and will not amend their pestiferous and deadly dogmas, but persist in defending them, become heretics.”46
Augustine’s distinction is exactly what our question needs. A false opinion is one thing. A false opinion inherited without knowing better, held while seeking the truth, and open to correction is still an error, and errors are serious. However, it is not heresy. Heresy is the false opinion defended against correction. Theologians later called this quality pertinacia (“stubbornness, obstinacy”). The difference is not in the content of the error but in the will of the one who holds it.
Vincent of Lérins
In the fifth century Vincent of Lérins gave a rule for knowing what the catholic faith is: “in the Catholic Church itself, all possible care must be taken, that we hold that faith which has been believed everywhere, always, by all.”47 He also took Paul’s word to Timothy about the deposit and asked, “What is The deposit? That which has been entrusted to you, not that which you have yourself devised: a matter not of wit, but of learning; not of private adoption, but of public tradition.”48 Vincent did not forbid growth in understanding. He told the teacher to “teach still the same truths which you have learned, so that though you speak after a new fashion, what you speak may not be new.”49 This is the same posture the Lutheran Confessions take when they say they introduce nothing new. It is also a warning to anyone tempted to make his own private judgment the rule of the Church’s faith. Martin Chemnitz, answering the Council of Trent, used the fathers in exactly this way. He received their consent as a witness to how Scripture had been understood and he refused to let any tradition, however old, stand as a judge beside Scripture.50
The condemnations are aimed at teachings
The Lutheran Confessions contain many condemnations. The Augsburg Confession repeatedly says of false teachings, “they condemn” (damnant), and the Formula of Concord closes each article with a list of rejected errors. A critic may hear these as a list of people bound for hell. They are not that.
The Preface to the Book of Concord addresses this directly and its words should be better known among Lutherans than they are. It says that the condemnations had to be set forth so that all might guard against false doctrine. “Thus, as it is in no way our design and purpose to condemn those men who err from a certain simplicity of mind, but are not blasphemers against the truth of the heavenly doctrine, much less, indeed, entire churches … nay, rather has it been our intention and disposition in this manner openly to censure and condemn only the fanatical opinions and their obstinate and blasphemous teachers.” It continues: “For we have no doubt whatever that even in those churches which have hitherto not agreed with us in all things many godly and by no means wicked men are found who follow their own simplicity, and do not understand aright the matter itself.” The signers expressed the hope that such people, if they were rightly taught, would come to agree with them, and they laid a duty on all pastors to teach with moderation those who “from a certain simplicity or ignorance have erred from the truth.”51
This is Augustine’s distinction written into the front of the Book of Concord. The condemnations fall on teachings that contradict God’s Word and on teachers who obstinately defend them. They do not fall on the simple, the untaught, or whole churches in which Christ’s people are found. The Formula of Concord itself distinguishes between “unnecessary and useless wrangling … whereby the Church ought not to be disturbed” and “necessary controversy” when “the articles of faith or the chief heads of the Christian doctrine” are at stake.52
Firmness where it belongs
However, this gentleness should not be mistaken for indifference. The same Formula that will not condemn the simple says, “we have no intention of yielding aught of the eternal, immutable truth of God for the sake of temporal peace, tranquillity, and unity.”53 Paul speaks with the same firmness: “even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed” (Galatians 1:8). John writes, “Everyone who goes on ahead and does not abide in the teaching of Christ, does not have God” (2 John 9). Paul urges believers “to watch out for those who cause divisions and create obstacles contrary to the doctrine that you have been taught; avoid them” (Romans 16:17).
Luther’s firmness on the Supper is the clearest example. He could bear with the weak in matters of ceremony. However, when Zwingli and others taught that the bread only signified Christ’s body, Luther would not yield. He confessed the words of Christ, “This is my body,” as plainly as he could and said he would appear before Christ’s judgment seat with that confession.54 He did so, not because he loved to quarrel, but because he believed that the Supper was Christ’s own gift and that to deny it was to take a gift of Christ away from His people. That is why AC VII makes agreement “concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments” part of what the true unity of the Church requires. The Formula explains that this means agreement “in the doctrine and all its articles, also in the right use of the holy Sacraments,” and the Supper is just such an article.55
So, can a person knowingly reject them?
We can now answer the question directly. Suppose a person knows what the Lutheran Confessions teach on a point of doctrine, has been shown from Scripture why the Lutheran Church confesses it, understands it, and settles in his heart that it is false. Can he remain a faithful Lutheran?
If the Confessions are true (and that is the premise of the question), then he is rejecting a true teaching of God’s Word. If he is a pastor or teacher who has vowed to teach in accordance with them, he is also breaking his word. If he keeps his error to himself he is a dissenter, and if he teaches it against correction he is the divisive man of Titus 3:10. Either way he may still be a Christian. Faith in Christ saves and the Preface to the Book of Concord is happy to say that there are godly people in churches that do not agree with us. However, he cannot honestly call his position faithful Lutheranism, because the word Lutheran has never named a personal opinion. It names a confession. To reject the confession knowingly while keeping the name is to say what one does not believe, and Krauth’s rule applies: he should neither say nor seem to say it.
On the other hand, the person who does not yet understand, who is troubled, who has questions, who has never been taught, or who is wrestling with a hard teaching while still listening to the Word, is not in that place at all. He is a learner. Augustine would not call him a heretic and neither does the Preface to the Book of Concord. He belongs at the font, the pulpit, the rail, and the Bible class, where he can keep hearing the Word of God that alone can persuade him.
What This Means for Us
Let me gather up what we have heard.
-
A confession, according to Scripture, is saying the same thing God has said and saying it together with the Church. Jesus attaches eternal weight to it (Matthew 10:32–33) and Paul ties it to salvation (Romans 10:9–10).
-
The Lutheran Confessions do not claim to be Scripture. They claim to be faithful witnesses to Scripture, a common form of doctrine that the churches can confess together. Their authors were willing to stand before the judgment seat of Christ with them.
-
A quia subscription accepts the doctrinal content of the Confessions because it agrees with Scripture. It binds the teacher to the doctrine, not to every historical remark. It asks above all for honesty.
-
Pastors and teachers are bound by their vow. The confirmed layperson is bound by the Catechism, which is the Bible of the laity. The weak and the untaught are to be received, taught, and borne with patience.
-
An error held in ignorance and open to correction is not heresy. Heresy is a fundamental error obstinately defended against correction. A layman who still dissents after teaching is no longer a learner, yet the condemnation falls on those who teach the error. The condemnations in the Confessions are aimed at false teachings and their stubborn teachers, not at simple believers or whole churches.
What does this mean for us as a congregation? It means, first, that the Confessions are not a fence to keep people out. They are the faith we hold in common. When we confess the Creed together on Sunday, we are doing what the Christians in Irenaeus’ day did, saying the same thing with one heart. The Book of Concord simply says at greater length what that same faith teaches about sin, grace, Baptism, the Supper, and the Church. It belongs to every one of us. A member who has never read it has not been shut out of it. He has an inheritance he has not yet opened.
It means, second, that we should be patient with the learner. Everyone in our congregation is a learner, including the pastor. Luther said that he himself remained a pupil of the Catechism and prayed it daily.56 The person who comes to Bible class with a hard question, the visitor who does not yet see what we see in the Sacrament, and the member who is troubled by something in the Catechism should all find that this congregation receives them as Paul received the weak (Romans 14:1). The Lord’s servant “must not be quarrelsome but kind to everyone, able to teach, patiently enduring evil, correcting his opponents with gentleness. God may perhaps grant them repentance leading to a knowledge of the truth” (2 Timothy 2:24–25).
It means, third, that we should expect firmness from those who teach. A congregation is right to ask its pastor and its teachers what they will teach and to hold them to it. This is not suspicion but love for the flock, the same love that made Paul warn the Ephesian elders. A pastor who cannot in good conscience teach what he has promised to teach owes his people the truth and the congregation owes him a patient hearing and an honest answer.
It means, lastly, that all of us are called to honesty. We should not pretend to believe what we do not believe and we should not pretend that it does not matter. Peter tells us to be “prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you; yet do it with gentleness and respect” (1 Peter 3:15). In other words, honesty and gentleness belong together.
We began with three people and they deserve an answer before we finish. To the woman who is not sure about Baptism: you are not asked to be sure of yourself. You are asked to hear what God says He did for you there. Baptism “works forgiveness of sins, delivers from death and the devil, and gives eternal salvation to all who believe this, as the words and promises of God declare.”57 Keep coming to hear it, because that is what a learner does and a learner is a Lutheran. To the man who cannot yet accept that the bread is Christ’s body: you are welcome under the Word for as long as it takes. To the seminary graduate: take the vow when you can make it without reservation, and until then say honestly where you stand to those who will ask it of you.
Underneath all of this is the Gospel and the Confessions themselves would want us to end there. The faith we confess is not a test we pass in order to be saved. It is the confession of what Christ has done for us: that He died for our sins and rose for our justification, that He gives Himself to us in Word and Sacrament, and that He forgives the sins of all who believe in Him. The Formula of Concord says that its whole purpose is that unity “by which His glory remains to God uninjured, nothing of the divine truth of the Holy Gospel is surrendered, no room is given to the least error, poor sinners are brought to true, genuine repentance, raised up by faith, confirmed in new obedience, and thus justified and eternally saved alone through the sole merit of Christ.”58 That is why we confess. Christ made the good confession before Pontius Pilate and went to the cross for us, and He has promised that those who acknowledge Him before others He will acknowledge before His Father in heaven (1 Timothy 6:13; Matthew 10:32).
Soli Deo Gloria.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)
The Lutheran Confessions
- Triglot Concordia: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by F. Bente and W. H. T. Dau. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
- The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
- The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Preface to the Book of Concord; Augsburg Confession VII, X, and Conclusion; Apology VII–VIII; Small Catechism, Preface; Large Catechism, Longer Preface; Formula of Concord, Epitome and Solid Declaration, Rule and Norm; Solid Declaration VII, XI, and XII.)
The Early Church
- Irenaeus. Against Heresies. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
- Tertullian. The Prescription Against Heretics. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3.
- Athanasius. Defence of the Nicene Definition and Letter to the Bishops of Africa. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 4.
- Hilary of Poitiers. On the Trinity. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 9.
- Basil the Great. Letters. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 8.
- Augustine. Letters. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 1.
- Augustine. The City of God. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 2.
- Vincent of Lérins. The Commonitory. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 11.
- The Creed of Nicaea (325). In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 14.
The Reformation and Lutheran Orthodoxy
- Luther, Martin. Confession Concerning Christ’s Supper (1528). Luther’s Works, vol. 37. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1961.
- Luther, Martin. Eight Sermons at Wittenberg (1522). Luther’s Works, vol. 51. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1959.
- Luther, Martin. Preface to the Epistle of St. Paul to the Romans (1522). Luther’s Works, vol. 35. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1960.
- Chemnitz, Martin. Examination of the Council of Trent. Translated by Fred Kramer. 4 vols. St. Louis: Concordia, 1971–1986.
- Walther, C. F. W. “Why Should Our Pastors, Teachers and Professors Subscribe Unconditionally to the Symbolical Writings of Our Church.” Translated by Alex Wm. C. Guebert. Concordia Theological Monthly 18 (1947). Reprinted in Matthew C. Harrison, ed., At Home in the House of My Fathers. St. Louis: Concordia, 2011.
- Krauth, Charles Porterfield. The Conservative Reformation and Its Theology. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott, 1871.
- Articles of Religion (the Thirty-Nine Articles), 1563/1571.
Church Constitution
- Constitution of Lutheran Congregations in Mission for Christ (LCMC).
Reference
- Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
- Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. 1828.
Footnotes
-
Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “confession,” senses 2 and 4. ↩
-
Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. ὁμολογέω. ↩
-
Irenaeus, Against Heresies I.10.2, ANF, vol. 1. The summary of the faith that precedes it is in I.10.1. ↩
-
The Creed of Nicaea (325), with its anathema, NPNF², vol. 14. ↩
-
Athanasius, Defence of the Nicene Definition (De Decretis) 1, NPNF², vol. 4, where the objection is put: “Why did the Fathers at Nicæa use terms not in Scripture, ‘Of the essence’ and ‘One in essence?’” ↩
-
Athanasius, De Decretis 27, NPNF², vol. 4, speaking of “the reason and sense, with which the Council and the Fathers before it defined and published ‘of the essence,’ and ‘one in essence,’ agreeably to what Scripture says of the Saviour.” See also De Decretis 19–21. ↩
-
Athanasius, Letter to the Bishops of Africa (Ad Afros) 2, NPNF², vol. 4. ↩
-
Hilary of Poitiers, On the Trinity II.2, NPNF², vol. 9. ↩
-
Basil the Great, Letter 125.1 and heading, NPNF², vol. 8. ↩
-
FC Ep Rule and Norm 1. ↩
-
FC Ep Rule and Norm 2. ↩
-
FC Ep Rule and Norm 7–8. The Tappert translation renders the last sentence, “are not judges like Holy Scripture, but merely witnesses and expositions of the faith.” ↩
-
FC Ep Rule and Norm 3. ↩
-
FC Ep Rule and Norm 4. ↩
-
FC Ep Rule and Norm 5. ↩
-
FC SD Rule and Norm 1–2. ↩
-
FC SD Rule and Norm 5. ↩
-
FC SD Rule and Norm 10. ↩
-
FC SD XII 40. The rejected errors that precede this conclusion are gathered in SD XII 39. ↩
-
Preface to the Book of Concord 23 (Triglotta numbering). ↩
-
FC SD VII 29–31, quoting Luther, Confession Concerning Christ’s Supper (1528), LW 37. Compare SD VII 32–33. ↩
-
Luther, Confession Concerning Christ’s Supper (1528), Part III, LW 37. ↩
-
AC Conclusion 5. ↩
-
Preface to the Book of Concord 21 (Triglotta numbering). ↩
-
C. F. W. Walther, “Why Should Our Pastors, Teachers and Professors Subscribe Unconditionally to the Symbolical Writings of Our Church” (1858), trans. Alex Wm. C. Guebert, Concordia Theological Monthly 18 (1947). The translation is reprinted in Matthew C. Harrison, ed., At Home in the House of My Fathers (St. Louis: Concordia, 2011). The definition is quoted from Guebert’s translation as given at bookofconcord.org (“What is an ‘unconditional subscription’ to the Confessions?”). ↩
-
Walther, “Why Should Our Pastors … Subscribe Unconditionally,” in the same essay, where he distinguishes the doctrinal content of the Symbols from matters that are not doctrine. ↩
-
Charles Porterfield Krauth, The Conservative Reformation and Its Theology (Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott, 1871), 171. ↩
-
The Professio fidei Tridentinae was promulgated by Pius IV in the bull Iniunctum nobis (1564). ↩
-
Articles of Religion (1563/1571), title. The Westminster ordination question is in the ordination vows of the Presbyterian churches that hold the Westminster Standards (e.g. the Book of Church Order of the Presbyterian Church in America, 21-5). ↩
-
Webster, American Dictionary (1828), s.v. “faithful,” senses 1 and 4. ↩
-
Constitution of Lutheran Congregations in Mission for Christ, 2.05–2.06 (lcmc.net/constitution). ↩
-
FC Ep Rule and Norm 5. Compare SD Rule and Norm 8. ↩
-
FC SD Rule and Norm 8. ↩
-
SC Preface 11–13. ↩
-
SC Preface 16–18. ↩
-
Preface to the Book of Concord 20 (Triglotta numbering). ↩
-
SC V, “Who, then, receives such Sacrament worthily?” ↩
-
FC SD VII 69. ↩
-
Luther, Eight Sermons at Wittenberg (the Invocavit Sermons, 1522), LW 51. ↩
-
Luther, Preface to the Epistle of St. Paul to the Romans (1522), LW 35. ↩
-
Ap VII–VIII 20–21. ↩
-
Thayer, Greek-English Lexicon, s.v. αἵρεσις. ↩
-
Webster, American Dictionary (1828), s.v. “heresy,” senses 1 and 2. ↩
-
Tertullian, The Prescription Against Heretics 6, ANF, vol. 3. On the rule of faith that the heretic sets aside, see Prescription 13. ↩
-
Augustine, Letter 43.1, NPNF¹, vol. 1. ↩
-
Augustine, The City of God XVIII.51, NPNF¹, vol. 2. ↩
-
Vincent of Lérins, Commonitory 2.6, NPNF², vol. 11. ↩
-
Vincent of Lérins, Commonitory 22.53, NPNF², vol. 11, on 1 Timothy 6:20. ↩
-
Vincent of Lérins, Commonitory 22, NPNF², vol. 11. ↩
-
Martin Chemnitz, Examination of the Council of Trent, trans. Fred Kramer, part I (St. Louis: Concordia, 1971), the topic on traditions. Compare FC Ep Rule and Norm 2. ↩
-
Preface to the Book of Concord 20 (Triglotta numbering). The Tappert translation renders the key phrase, “many pious, innocent people are found even in those churches which have up to now admittedly not come to agreement with us.” ↩
-
FC SD Rule and Norm 15. ↩
-
FC SD XI 95. ↩
-
See note 21. Luther’s full argument on the words of institution fills Confession Concerning Christ’s Supper, LW 37, and his earlier That These Words of Christ, “This Is My Body,” etc., Still Stand Firm Against the Fanatics (1527), also in LW 37. ↩
-
AC VII 2; FC SD X 31. On the Supper as an article of faith, see FC SD VII. ↩
-
LC Longer Preface 7–8. ↩
-
SC IV, “What does Baptism give or profit?” ↩
-
FC SD XI 96. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Confessing the Confessions: Can One Knowingly Reject Them and Remain a Faithful Lutheran?.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/confessing-the-confessions/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.