Papers · Essays

A Particular Confession of the Apostolic Faith

Is Lutheranism One Brand of Generic Christianity, or a Trust to Be Kept?

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“Beloved, although I was very eager to write to you about our common salvation, I found it necessary to write appealing to you to contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints.” — Jude 3


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation. Luther’s Galatians is also quoted once in Theodore Graebner’s translation.


The Question Before Us

People often ask some form of this question and they usually ask it kindly. “Aren’t we all Christians in the end? The Methodists, the Baptists, the Catholics, and the Lutherans all believe in Jesus. Isn’t being Lutheran simply one way of being Christian, the way one family prefers a certain style of worship and another family prefers a different one?” A thoughtful member may press the point further. If the Lutheran Church is one acceptable expression of a larger Christianity, then a congregation should hold its Lutheran identity loosely. It might keep the name, the hymns, and the Catechism out of affection and habit. However, it would have no business asking its pastor to teach the Augsburg Confession, or asking its council to guard it, or writing it into its constitution as something to be kept. On the other hand, if Lutheranism is a particular confession of the apostolic faith, then a congregation has been handed something it did not invent, does not own, and may not give away.

The question deserves a careful answer, because the motive behind it is often a good one. Christians are right to rejoice in one another across the lines of church bodies and to be ashamed of the divisions in Christ’s Church. Lutherans share that charity and our own Confessions teach it. Therefore the question is not whether we love Christians in other churches. The question is what the Lutheran confession actually is and what it asks of a congregation that bears its name.

Several papers in this series already stand near this ground. On Denominationalism weighs the goods and harms of the many church bodies and “Just Jesus”: The Confession Behind the Claim shows that there is no Christianity without a confession. The companion paper Confessing the Confessions takes up subscription (quia or quatenus) and the difference between an error and a heresy, while Catholic and Reformed asks why the Lutheran churches separated from Rome. Where those papers have made a point at length, I refer to them. In this paper I want to take up five questions in order: 1) What is the case for a “generic” Christianity, stated fairly? 2) Does Scripture present the Christian faith as a general outlook, or as a deposit entrusted to the Church’s keeping? 3) Is the truth of the Gospel particular, so that one teaching can be right and another wrong? 4) What do the Lutheran Confessions claim to be, a denomination among denominations or the catholic faith rightly confessed? 5) What obligation does this lay on a congregation, its pastor, and its council? At each step we will listen first to Holy Scripture, then to the Lutheran Confessions, and then to the fathers of the early Church and the teachers of the Reformation who help us hear Scripture rightly. We will close by asking what all of this means for us.


I. The Case for a Generic Christianity

The words themselves

We begin with the words. Webster’s defines generic as “pertaining to a genus or kind; comprehending the genus, as distinct from species.”1 A generic name covers a whole family of things without naming any one of them in particular. To speak of a “generic Christianity” is to say that there is a common Christian faith (the genus) and that the various churches are its species. On this view Lutherans, Presbyterians, Methodists, and Baptists are like varieties of one plant. Each has its own color and shape. Yet the plant is the same and the differences are matters of history, temperament, and taste.

There is truth in part of that picture. Scripture does speak of “one Lord, one faith, one baptism” (Ephesians 4:5) and every Christian who confesses the Apostles’ and Nicene Creeds holds a great deal in common with every other. The question is whether that common faith is a genus that the churches may express in different ways, or a definite content that some churches confess more faithfully than others. Before we answer, we should hear the case for the first view in its strongest form. It has at least four strands.

“Mere Christianity”

The first is the instinct that C. S. Lewis made famous. In his wartime broadcast talks, later gathered as Mere Christianity, the Anglican layman set out the faith held in common by Christians and deliberately left aside the questions that divide the churches. Many readers have taken his “mere Christianity” as a generic faith that a person could hold instead of belonging to any particular church. Lewis himself refused that reading. In his preface he compared mere Christianity to a hall out of which doors open into several rooms and said that the hall is a place to wait in and not a place to live in. It is in the rooms, he wrote, that there are fires and chairs and meals. He urged his reader to choose a door by asking which one is true, not which one pleases him.2 “Just Jesus” quotes the passage in full. Here it is enough to say that the most famous champion of a common Christianity did not believe in a generic one.

“Reconciled diversity”

The second strand is the ecumenical movement of the twentieth century and in particular a model of church unity that Lutherans themselves helped to shape. In 1973 a number of Lutheran, Reformed, and United churches in Europe adopted the Leuenberg Agreement, which declared church fellowship among them on the basis of a common understanding of the Gospel, while each church kept its own confession. A few years later the Lutheran World Federation, meeting at Dar es Salaam in 1977, described the goal of ecumenism as “unity in reconciled diversity.”3 The idea is that the historic confessions need not be abandoned. Instead, each church keeps its confession as its own heritage and recognizes that the differences that once divided the churches no longer need to divide them.

This model deserves a fair hearing. Its authors studied the old disputes with care and believed that the condemnations of the sixteenth century no longer applied to the teaching of their partners. No Christian should be sorry that churches which once persecuted one another now pray together. Yet we must say plainly where we cannot follow it. Above all, Leuenberg declared that the old difference over the Lord’s Supper no longer divides the churches, and that the condemnations on that article no longer apply to the present teaching of the churches that signed it. The Formula of Concord cannot be read that way, for it rejects and condemns “all Sacramentarian opinions” that deny the true presence of Christ’s body and blood in the Supper (SD VII 112). Underneath that judgment lies an assumption that the generic view shares. It treats a confession as the heritage of a particular community rather than as a statement of what is true for all Christians. When a confession becomes a heritage, the differences between confessions become differences of heritage and those can be reconciled without anyone being wrong.

“No creed but Christ”

The third strand is the non-denominational instinct. Many Christians today belong to congregations that have no historic confession and describe themselves simply as “Bible-believing.” Their members are often earnest and generous and they suspect that creeds divide people who would otherwise get along. “Just Jesus” answers this at length: a church that rejects every creed still teaches something definite about Baptism, the Supper, and the will, and so it has a confession whether it writes one down or not. This is the most popular form of the generic view in America today and it often grows out of a real hunger for unity.

A charity Lutherans share

The fourth strand is the strongest and the most important, because it is a pastoral motive and our own Confessions share it. The person who asks whether Lutheranism is simply one expression of Christianity often means something like this: “I know Christians in other churches who love the Lord. Surely you are not saying they are not Christians?” The Lutheran answer to that is no, we are not saying that.

The Apology of the Augsburg Confession explains that the Creed calls the Church catholic “in order that we may not understand the Church to be an outward government of certain nations,” but rather “men scattered throughout the whole world, who agree concerning the Gospel, and have the same Christ, the same Holy Ghost, and the same Sacraments, whether they have the same or different human traditions.”4 It insists that this Church really exists and is not an ideal, for “we are not dreaming of a Platonic state,” but this Church is “the truly believing and righteous men scattered throughout the whole world.”5 In other words, true believers are found wherever the Word and the Sacraments are, even in churches whose teaching is mixed with error. The Preface to the Book of Concord says the same thing. Its authors wrote that they had no design “to condemn those men who err from a certain simplicity of mind, but are not blasphemers against the truth of the heavenly doctrine, much less, indeed, entire churches.”6 Charles Porterfield Krauth, who did as much as any man to recover the Lutheran Confessions in nineteenth-century America, could write: “we freely call systems and men Christian, though they lack a sound sacramental doctrine.”7

Therefore the Lutheran Church does not answer the generic view by saying that only Lutherans are saved. That answer would be false and it would contradict our own Confessions. Yet the charity we share with the generic view does not settle the question. We can love Christians in other churches and still ask whether the faith itself is a genus with many acceptable species or a definite deposit that can be kept whole or lost. That is a question about the faith and not about the people who hold it and Scripture answers it plainly.


II. The Faith Is a Deposit

Parathēkē

At the end of his first letter to Timothy, Paul gathers everything he has written into one charge: “O Timothy, guard the deposit entrusted to you” (1 Timothy 6:20). The word “deposit” translates the Greek parathēkē (“deposit, something entrusted”). Paul uses it again in his second letter: “Follow the pattern of the sound words that you have heard from me, in the faith and love that are in Christ Jesus. By the Holy Spirit who dwells within us, guard the good deposit entrusted to you” (2 Timothy 1:13–14). Thayer defines the word as “a deposit, a trust or thing consigned to one’s faithful keeping,” used here “of the correct knowledge and pure doctrine of the gospel, to be held firmly and faithfully, and to be conscientiously delivered unto others.”8

The word comes from the world of law and banking. The one who received a deposit did not own it. He could not spend it, improve it, or trade it for something he liked better, and his duty was to give it back whole. Webster’s captures both halves of the idea. A deposit is “any thing entrusted to the care of another,” and a trust is “something committed to a person’s care for use or management, and for which an account must be rendered.”9 (Confessing the Confessions discusses the “pattern” of sound teaching in the same passage.) A deposit is particular by its nature. Nobody deposits money in general; one deposits a definite sum and expects to receive that same sum back.

Paul applies the same pattern to the next generation: “what you have heard from me in the presence of many witnesses entrust to faithful men, who will be able to teach others also” (2 Timothy 2:2). Four generations appear in that verse and the duty at each step is faithfulness. “This is how one should regard us, as servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God. Moreover, it is required of stewards that they be found faithful” (1 Corinthians 4:1–2). Paul describes his own preaching the same way: “For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures” (1 Corinthians 15:3). In other words, the apostle does not think of himself as the author of the Gospel. He received it and he handed it on.

Once for all

Jude says the same thing in a single phrase. He had meant to write about “our common salvation,” but he found it necessary to urge his readers “to contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints” (Jude 3). The faith here is the content believed and not only the act of believing. The words “once for all” translate the Greek hapax (“once, once for all”), the same word the letter to the Hebrews uses of Christ’s sacrifice, offered once and never repeated (Hebrews 9:26–28). The faith was given whole and it was given once. It is not revised by later generations any more than the cross is repeated. Therefore the letter to the Hebrews can say in one breath, “Jesus Christ is the same yesterday and today and forever. Do not be led away by diverse and strange teachings” (Hebrews 13:8–9).

This is where the generic view and Scripture part company. The generic view assumes that the Christian faith is a broad outlook which each church expresses in its own way. Scripture describes it as a definite deposit, entrusted once, which the Church is to guard and pass on without loss. A deposit can be kept whole, it can be diminished, or it can be exchanged for something else. However, it cannot be “expressed” in a variety of equally acceptable ways that contradict one another.

The fathers kept the deposit

The early Church understood this from the beginning. Irenaeus of Lyons, writing about the year 180 against the Gnostics, used the very image Paul’s word suggests. “The apostles, like a rich man [depositing his money] in a bank, lodged in her hands most copiously all things pertaining to the truth: so that every man, whosoever will, can draw from her the water of life.”10 Irenaeus did not think of that deposit as something that varied from place to place. The companion paper Confessing the Confessions quotes his description of the Church preserving the faith “as if occupying but one house.” The sentences that follow are just as striking: “For the Churches which have been planted in Germany do not believe or hand down anything different, nor do those in Spain, nor those in Gaul, nor those in the East, nor those in Egypt, nor those in Libya.” No leader of the churches, he adds, will teach doctrines different from these, “for no one is greater than the Master.”11 It is interesting that Irenaeus measured the unity of the Church by sameness of doctrine. The churches spoke different languages and kept different customs, yet they handed down one faith.

Tertullian, writing a generation later in North Africa, made the same argument with a lawyer’s precision. The apostles founded churches in every city and all the other churches derived from them “the tradition of the faith, and the seeds of doctrine.”12 From this he drew his rule: “all doctrine which agrees with the apostolic churches—those moulds and original sources of the faith must be reckoned for truth.” He added the sentence that sums up his whole case: “We hold communion with the apostolic churches because our doctrine is in no respect different from theirs.”13 Later in the same work Tertullian used the language of an inheritance held in trust. Speaking as the Church to the heretics who claimed the Scriptures for themselves, he wrote, “I am the heir of the apostles. Just as they carefully prepared their will and testament, and committed it to a trust, and adjured (the trustees to be faithful to their charge), even so do I hold it.”14

Vincent of Lérins, in the fifth century, wrote a whole chapter on Paul’s charge to Timothy. He asked who the Timothy of his own day was and he answered, “either generally the Universal Church, or in particular, the whole body of The Prelacy, whom it behooves either themselves to possess or to communicate to others a complete knowledge of religion.” In other words, the charge to guard the deposit falls on the whole Church and in a particular way on those who teach. Vincent described the deposit as “a matter brought to you, not put forth by you, wherein you are bound to be not an author but a keeper.” Then he gave the charge in plain terms: “You have received gold; give gold in turn. Do not substitute one thing for another.”15 None of these fathers thought of the churches as species of a genus, each free to express the faith in its own way. They thought of the churches as trustees of one deposit.


III. Truth Is Particular

Another gospel

If the faith is a deposit, it follows that one teaching can be faithful to it and another unfaithful. Scripture says so in the plainest terms. Paul is astonished that the Galatians are “turning to a different gospel—not that there is another one,” and he writes, “even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed” (Galatians 1:6–8). Then he repeats the curse so that no one can mistake him (Galatians 1:9).

What were the Galatian teachers actually teaching? They did not deny that Jesus was the Messiah, nor His death and resurrection. They added one requirement, circumcision, to the Gospel Paul had preached. By the standards of a generic Christianity they were Christians with a different emphasis. Paul called their teaching a different gospel and he placed even himself and the angels under the same judgment if they should preach it. In other words, the apostle measured the Gospel by its content and not by the sincerity of the one who preached it. Why did Paul care so much about one added requirement? Because that one addition sent the Galatians back to look at themselves and a sinner who has to look at himself can never be sure of grace. Paul says it without softening it: “You are severed from Christ, you who would be justified by the law; you have fallen away from grace” (Galatians 5:4). A generic gospel cannot say “for you” with any confidence, because it will not say what Christ has done and given. The particular Gospel points the sinner away from himself to Christ crucified and risen for him, and so it is the only one that can comfort.

The teaching of Christ

John speaks with the same clarity. “Everyone who goes on ahead and does not abide in the teaching of Christ, does not have God. Whoever abides in the teaching has both the Father and the Son. If anyone comes to you and does not bring this teaching, do not receive him into your house or give him any greeting” (2 John 9–10). The danger John names is a teaching that “goes on ahead,” thinking itself more advanced than the apostolic one. Paul likewise urges the Romans “to watch out for those who cause divisions and create obstacles contrary to the doctrine that you have been taught; avoid them” (Romans 16:17). The cause of division in that verse is the false teacher and not the one who keeps the teaching.

When Paul said farewell to the elders of Ephesus, he said, “I did not shrink from declaring to you the whole counsel of God,” and he warned them that “from among your own selves will arise men speaking twisted things, to draw away the disciples after them. Therefore be alert” (Acts 20:27, 30–31). Paul did not teach a minimal Christianity that left the rest to taste. He taught “the whole counsel of God” and he laid the duty of guarding it on the elders of a particular congregation.

“A little leaven”

Paul gives the reason all of this matters in a proverb: “A little leaven leavens the whole lump” (Galatians 5:9). Luther lectured on this verse in 1531 and his lectures were published in 1535. In Theodore Graebner’s translation he imagines the Galatians saying to themselves, “What if we did deviate a little from the doctrine of Paul?” and Luther answers, “Small faults grow into big faults. To tolerate a trifling error inevitably leads to crass heresy. The doctrine of the Bible is not ours to take or to allow liberties with.” He then draws a distinction that is very important for our question: “When it comes to life we are ready to do, to suffer, to forgive anything our opponents demand as long as faith and doctrine remain pure and uncorrupt.”16 In the fuller American Edition of the same lectures Luther presses the contrast between doctrine and life as far as the contrast between heaven and earth. In life we bear with one another’s faults and forgive daily. In doctrine we have no authority to yield anything, because the doctrine is not ours but God’s.17

Luther’s distinction answers much of the confusion in the generic view. The generic view rightly sees that Christians must be patient with one another’s weaknesses and then applies that patience to doctrine as well. Luther keeps the patience and puts it in its proper place. Toward people he is ready to forgive anything. Toward the Word he has no authority to yield anything, because he is its steward and not its owner.

The generic view is itself a particular claim

The generic view presents itself as neutral, as if it stood above the quarrels of the churches. However, it is not neutral. To say that the differences between churches over Baptism, the Supper, and justification do not matter is itself a definite teaching about Baptism, the Supper, and justification. It says that it makes no difference whether Baptism gives the forgiveness of sins or only signifies it, whether Christ’s body is given in the Supper or only remembered, and whether the sinner is justified by faith alone or by faith and works. Each of those is a position and each contradicts what one of the churches confesses.

Krauth saw this clearly. He described the course error takes in a church: it first asks only to be tolerated and then asks for equal rights. Krauth puts the claim of this second stage in its own words: “What the friends of truth and error hold in common is fundamental. Anything on which they differ is ipso facto non-essential.” From there, he says, error goes on “to assert supremacy.”18 The middle stage is the generic view exactly. It decides in advance that whatever two churches share is the faith and whatever they dispute is a matter of taste. Yet that rule is not found in Scripture. Paul did not ask whether the Galatians and he held most things in common. He asked whether they had kept the Gospel.

The fathers confessed particular truth

The fathers of the fourth century faced the same pressure. When Arius taught that the Son was a creature, many wished to settle the matter with words broad enough for both sides. The Council of Nicaea in 325 confessed instead that the Son is homoousios (“of one substance”) with the Father. Athanasius spent most of his life defending that one word and he did not think it a matter of taste. Writing late in life to Bishop Epictetus of Corinth, he said that “the Faith there confessed by the Fathers according to the divine Scriptures is enough by itself at once to overthrow all impiety, and to establish the religious belief in Christ.”19 To those who claimed the name of Nicaea while teaching against it he wrote, “if you wish to be children of the fathers, do not hold the contrary of what they wrote.”20

Hilary of Poitiers gives us a moving witness to how particular truth and Scripture belong together. He was a bishop in Gaul who was sent into exile in 356 for his resistance to the Arian party. He admitted that he had not even heard of the Nicene Creed until then. “Though long ago regenerate in baptism, and for some time a bishop, I never heard of the Nicene creed until I was going into exile, but the Gospels and Epistles suggested to me the meaning of ὁμοούσιον.”21 In other words, Hilary did not experience the Nicene confession as an addition to the Bible. He recognized in it what he had already learned from the Gospels and Epistles.

Basil the Great put the same conviction in a single sentence when he wrote to the church at Antioch about the faith he taught: “Now I accept no newer creed written for me by other men, nor do I venture to propound the outcome of my own intelligence, lest I make the words of true religion merely human words; but what I have been taught by the holy Fathers, that I announce to all who question me.”22 Basil understood that a confession becomes “merely human words” when a teacher invents it, and remains God’s Word when a teacher receives it and hands it on.


IV. Not a Denomination, but the Catholic Faith Rightly Confessed

What the Augsburg Confession claims

If Lutheranism were one species of a generic Christianity, we would expect its Confessions to describe themselves as the heritage of a particular people. They do the opposite. The Augsburg Confession of 1530 opens with a preface to the Emperor Charles V. The princes and cities who signed it offered “the Confession of our preachers and of ourselves, showing what manner of doctrine from the Holy Scriptures and the pure Word of God has been up to this time set forth in our lands.”23 They did not ask to be recognized as a new church with its own heritage. They asked for a hearing so that the dissension might “be done away and brought back to one true accordant religion; for as we all are under one Christ and do battle under Him, we ought to confess the one Christ.”24 The goal was one confession of one Christ by the whole Church.

At the end of the doctrinal articles, after Article XXI, the Confession sums up what it has said. “This is about the Sum of our Doctrine, in which, as can be seen, there is nothing that varies from the Scriptures, or from the Church Catholic, or from the Church of Rome as known from its writers. This being the case, they judge harshly who insist that our teachers be regarded as heretics.”25 Catholic and Reformed traces how this claim was made before the Emperor. For our question the point is simple. The Lutherans did not claim to be one acceptable expression of Christianity alongside Rome. They claimed to confess the faith of the catholic Church, the same faith Irenaeus said was held in Germany, Spain, and Egypt alike.

Article VII of the same Confession says that “to the true unity of the Church it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments.” The word enough (satis est) is sometimes read as though a short list of shared beliefs were all that mattered. On Denominationalism shows why that reading is mistaken: the Formula of Concord explains that the agreement required is agreement “in the doctrine and all its articles” and in the right use of the Sacraments, while ceremonies may differ.26

The Rule and Norm

The Formula of Concord makes the claim more precise in its opening section on the “Rule and Norm.” It places Scripture above every other writing as “the sole rule and standard according to which all dogmas together with [all] teachers should be estimated and judged.” Every other writing is received only “as witnesses.”27 The Creeds and the Lutheran Confessions are “not judges, as are the Holy Scriptures, but only a testimony and declaration of the faith.”28 Confessing the Confessions treats this distinction at length. What matters here is the kind of testimony the Confessions claim to give. The Solid Declaration says that its authors “will not make or receive a separate or new confession of our faith, but confess the public common writings” which had always been held in the churches of the Augsburg Confession.29 It then names the Augsburg Confession “as our symbol for this time, not because it was composed by our theologians, but because it has been taken from God’s Word and is founded firmly and well therein.” It adds that the Lutherans received it “after the custom and usage of the early Church, whereby succeeding councils, Christian bishops and teachers appealed to the Nicene Creed, and confessed it.”30 In other words, the Formula places the Augsburg Confession beside the Nicene Creed. It is “our” confession in the sense that we confess it and not in the sense that we invented it.

The same section explains why a church needs such a confession at all: “that we should have a unanimously accepted, definite, common form of doctrine, which all our evangelical churches together and in common confess, from and according to which, because it has been derived from God’s Word, all other writings should be judged.”31 A generic Christianity has no definite form of doctrine and therefore no way to judge a new teaching when it appears.

Luther’s testimony

Luther wanted no church named for himself, as “Just Jesus” and On Denominationalism both recall. Yet he cared intensely that the doctrine he had confessed be kept after his death. In 1537 he wrote the Smalcald Articles for a council that the Pope had called. In his preface he explained that he was publishing them so that, if he should die before a council met, “those who live and remain after me may have my testimony and confession to produce, in addition to the Confession which I have issued previously, whereby up to this time I have abided, and, by God’s grace, will abide.”32 Luther was not founding a denomination. He was leaving a testimony for the next generation.

The Lutheran teachers who followed him understood their confession the same way. Martin Chemnitz, in his Examination of the Council of Trent, answered Rome’s appeal to unwritten tradition by showing that the “rule of faith” to which Irenaeus and Tertullian appealed contained nothing other than the doctrine of Scripture.33 The Lutherans claimed the fathers as witnesses that their faith was the faith of the ancient Church. In the twentieth century Hermann Sasse made the same argument against those who wished to dissolve the Lutheran confession into a broader Protestantism. He insisted that the Lutheran Church understands itself as the Church of the pure Gospel and not as one denomination among many, and that the most honest service it can give to the rest of Christendom is to keep confessing what it confesses.34

A confession, not a brand

Here, then, is the difference between a denomination in the generic sense and a confession. A denomination in the generic sense is a brand. It names a particular style of Christianity, valued by those who belong to it and making no claim on anyone else. A confession is a public statement of what Scripture teaches, made in the conviction that it is true for every Christian. The Lutheran Church is organized into denominations like every other church (and On Denominationalism is honest about how divided Lutherans are). Yet the Lutheran confession has never claimed to be a brand. It claims to be the catholic faith, the deposit of the apostles, rightly confessed.

Is that claim arrogant? It would be, if it meant that Lutherans had invented something better than other Christians possess. However, a confession claims nothing for the confessors and everything for the Word. Such a claim submits the confessors to Scripture and asks every reader to test the confession by the same Scripture (Acts 17:11).


V. The Obligation on a Congregation and Its Leaders

If the faith is a deposit and the Lutheran confession is a faithful statement of it, then the confession is a trust to be kept. However, it is fair to ask who keeps it and how. Scripture and the Confessions lay this obligation on three parties: the pastor, the congregation as a whole, and those the congregation elects to oversee its life.

The pastor

The first to be bound is the one who teaches. Paul tells Timothy, “Keep a close watch on yourself and on the teaching. Persist in this, for by so doing you will save both yourself and your hearers” (1 Timothy 4:16). An overseer “must hold firm to the trustworthy word as taught, so that he may be able to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to rebuke those who contradict it” (Titus 1:9). In Lutheran ordination the candidate is asked, before God and the congregation, whether he will preach and teach in accordance with the Holy Scriptures and the Lutheran Confessions. That promise is a vow. Confessing the Confessions discusses how Lutheran church bodies bind their pastors and what it means to subscribe quia.35 The point here is simpler. A pastor who takes that vow has received a deposit and he may not spend it on his own opinions. If he comes to believe that the confession is false, honesty requires him to say so and not to go on teaching under a promise he no longer keeps.

The Formula of Concord gives the pastor a double task. It says that “for the preservation of pure doctrine” it is necessary “not only that the pure, wholesome doctrine be rightly presented, but also that the opponents who teach otherwise be reproved,” and it gives Luther’s reason, that “faithful shepherds … should do both, namely, feed or nourish the lambs and resist the wolves.”36 A pastor who only resists wolves will starve his sheep and a pastor who never warns them leaves them unguarded. Paul did both at Ephesus, where for three years he did not cease “night or day to admonish every one with tears” (Acts 20:31).

The congregation judges doctrine

The second party is the congregation itself. This may surprise people who think of doctrine as the pastor’s business. Yet Scripture lays the duty of judging teaching on the whole flock. “Beware of false prophets” (Matthew 7:15). “Test everything; hold fast what is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21). Our Lord said of His sheep, “A stranger they will not follow, but they will flee from him, for they do not know the voice of strangers” (John 10:5).

The Augsburg Confession teaches this in its article on the power of bishops. By divine right the ministry has authority “to judge doctrine, to reject doctrines contrary to the Gospel,” and that “herein the congregations of necessity and by divine right must obey them.” Then it adds the limit: “But when they teach or ordain anything against the Gospel, then the congregations have a commandment of God prohibiting obedience,” citing Matthew 7:15 and Galatians 1:8.37 The article closes the point with a sentence of Augustine’s: “Neither must we submit to Catholic bishops if they chance to err, or hold anything contrary to the Canonical Scriptures of God.”38 In other words, the congregation owes its pastor obedience when he teaches the Gospel and owes him none when he teaches against it. To know the difference, it has to know the Gospel.

The Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope, written at Smalcald in 1537, says the same thing in broader terms. It insists that “the power of judging and decreeing from the Word of God” must not be “wrested from the Church.”39 It teaches that the right to call pastors belongs to the Church: “For wherever the Church is, there is the authority [command] to administer the Gospel. Therefore it is necessary for the Church to retain the authority to call, elect, and ordain ministers.”40 When bishops “teach and defend a godless doctrine,” the Treatise says, citing Galatians 1:7–8, they are to be regarded as accursed and the churches must provide faithful pastors for themselves.41

Luther had made this argument fourteen years earlier in a short treatise whose title states its thesis: That a Christian Assembly or Congregation Has the Right and Power to Judge All Teaching and to Call, Appoint, and Dismiss Teachers, Established and Proven by Scripture (1523). He wrote it for the congregation at Leisnig. Luther argued from John 10, Matthew 7:15, and 1 Thessalonians 5:21 that Christ gave the right to judge teaching to the sheep and not only to the bishops and councils. A congregation that hears false doctrine from its teachers has both the right and the duty to judge it by the Word and to call a teacher who will preach the Gospel.42 Luther did not mean that every member is free to believe whatever he likes. He meant that every member is responsible to the Word and so has a share in guarding it.

What does this mean for a congregation that bears the Lutheran name? It means that the confession is not only the pastor’s concern. A congregation that calls a pastor is choosing who will handle the deposit entrusted to it. When it asks whether a candidate will teach in accordance with Scripture and the Confessions, it is doing what the Treatise and Luther say it has the right and duty to do. A congregation that treats its confession as a heritage to be admired, but not as a standard to be applied, has given up the very right the Reformation recovered for it.

Those who oversee the congregation’s life

The third party is the body the congregation elects to oversee its life, which most of our congregations call a council. Paul’s charge to the Ephesian elders was not only to preach but to “pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock” (Acts 20:28). A Lutheran congregation’s constitution commonly gives its council general oversight of the congregation’s life and especially of its worship, so that everything is done according to the Word of God and the congregation’s confession. It usually gives the council a part in calling a pastor as well. In other words, the people who serve on a council are trustees of the confession as well as of the building and the budget.

However, we should be clear about where that charge comes from. The Augsburg Confession gives the judging of doctrine to those “to whom has been committed the ministry of the Word and the Sacraments,” and it says this is theirs “by divine right” (AC XXVIII 21). The same article sets apart from this any other jurisdiction the bishops held, which they had “by human right” (AC XXVIII 29). A council’s charge belongs on that second side of the line. It is given by the congregation’s constitution, which is a human arrangement. A council therefore does not judge doctrine in the pastor’s place. It sees that the congregation calls and keeps pastors who will teach according to the confession. This trust is kept chiefly by calling a faithful pastor and by hearing him gladly, not by suspicion. A council member who loves the confession is not asked to audit sermons. He is asked to see that the pulpit is filled by a man bound to the Word and to the Confessions, and then to sit under that preaching with the rest of the flock.

The constitution as a confessional trust

Lutheran congregations commonly write their confession into their constitutions, usually in a chapter of its own. Such a chapter confesses the Triune God and the Gospel as the power of God for the salvation of all who believe. It accepts the canonical Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments as the inspired Word of God and the norm of the congregation’s proclamation, faith, and life. It accepts the Apostles’, Nicene, and Athanasian Creeds as true declarations of its faith, the Unaltered Augsburg Confession as a true witness to the Gospel, and the other writings of the Book of Concord as further valid interpretations of the faith. Many such chapters go on to acknowledge as one with the congregation in faith and doctrine all churches that accept the teaching of the Unaltered Augsburg Confession. A constitution written that way measures unity the way Irenaeus and Article VII do, by sameness of confession. It presents the confession as the Gospel itself, by which God creates and keeps His Church, and not as a family heritage. Many constitutions also name among a congregation’s purposes the preserving and handing on of the Gospel faithfully to future generations, which is very nearly Paul’s charge to Timothy in modern words.

Therefore a congregation’s constitution, at least in its confessional chapter, is more than a set of bylaws. It is a confessional trust in the sense Webster’s gives the word: something committed to a person’s care “for use or management, and for which an account must be rendered.” The members who adopted it made a promise to one another and to those who would come after them. The words of the chapter were adopted by the congregation, yet the faith they confess was received before it was adopted. It is the faith of the apostles and the constitution says that the congregation intends to keep it.

Firmness and gentleness

Does all of this make a congregation suspicious and quarrelsome? It should not. The Formula of Concord distinguishes “unnecessary and useless wrangling … whereby the Church ought not to be disturbed” from the “necessary controversy” that arises when “the articles of faith or the chief heads of the Christian doctrine” are at stake.43 Most of what Christians argue about belongs to the first and should be left alone. Paul tells us to speak “the truth in love” so that we are no longer “tossed to and fro by the waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine” (Ephesians 4:14–15). Truth and love are not rivals in that verse. Confessing the Confessions describes the patience owed to the weak and the untaught and that patience applies here too. Keeping the confession is not the same as interrogating every member. It means teaching the confession, measuring the teaching of the pulpit by it, and calling pastors who will keep it.


What This Means for Us

The generic view of Christianity grows from a real charity and Lutherans share it. However, Scripture describes the faith as a deposit, entrusted once for all, which the Church is to guard and pass on whole, and not as a genus with many acceptable species. Truth is particular, so that one gospel can be the Gospel and another a “different gospel” (Galatians 1:6). The Lutheran Confessions claim to be the catholic faith of the apostles, drawn from Scripture and confessed as Nicaea was confessed. Therefore the Lutheran confession is a trust to be kept by the pastor, by the congregation, and by those it elects to oversee its life.

What does this mean for us? It means, first, that keeping the confession is an act of love for the next generation. The Psalmist says that we will “tell to the coming generation the glorious deeds of the LORD,” so “that the next generation might know them, the children yet unborn,” and “set their hope in God” (Psalm 78:4, 6–7). The authors of the Book of Concord understood their work the same way. They wrote that in subscribing the Augsburg Confession “we meant to provide for the interests of posterity.”44 They urged that the young men preparing for the ministry be taught the confession faithfully, “in order that the pure doctrine and profession of our faith may, by the help of the Holy Ghost, be preserved and propagated also to our posterity, until the glorious advent of Jesus Christ.”45 The Formula gave its explanations so that there might be “a public, definite testimony, not only for those now living, but also for our posterity.”46 Our children and grandchildren will receive whatever we keep. If we hand them a generic Christianity, they will inherit a faith that cannot tell them what Baptism gives, what the Supper is, or how a sinner is justified before God. If we hand them the confession whole, they will receive the Gospel in its fullness, the same gold that was handed to us.

It means, second, that keeping the confession is an act of love for other Christians. If the Lutheran confession is true, then it is true for Methodists, Baptists, Roman Catholics, and the Orthodox as well as for Lutherans. Our Lord prayed “that they may all be one” (John 17:21) and He also prayed, “Sanctify them in the truth; your word is truth” (John 17:17). The unity He prays for is unity in the truth. A Lutheran congregation that keeps its confession is keeping something for other Christians and not shutting them out: a clear confession of justification by grace through faith and of Christ’s gifts in Word and Sacrament, to which any Christian may come and test by Scripture. A congregation that gives its confession away in the name of charity has given away the clearest thing it had to offer.

It means, third, that keeping the confession is not sectarian pride. Pride would say that we are better than other Christians. The confession says that we are sinners, that we are justified freely for Christ’s sake through faith, and that everything we have is a gift. A confession that teaches us to boast only in Christ can hardly make us proud of ourselves. When we keep it, we are guarding a deposit that belongs to Another and we will give an account of it to Him.

Lastly, it means that the keeping does not finally depend on us. Paul charged Timothy to guard the good deposit “by the Holy Spirit who dwells within us” (2 Timothy 1:14). A few verses earlier he had written of his own life, “I know whom I have believed, and I am convinced that he is able to guard until that day what has been entrusted to me” (2 Timothy 1:12). We keep the deposit of the faith and Christ keeps us. Pastors fail, councils make mistakes, and congregations grow weary. Yet, Christ has promised that “the gates of hell shall not prevail against” His Church (Matthew 16:18) and He still gives Himself to us in the Word preached, the water poured, the absolution spoken, and His body and blood given for the forgiveness of sins. The confession we keep is the confession of that Gospel. For every troubled conscience that wonders whether it has kept the faith well enough, the answer is found in Christ who has kept us and Jude’s doxology is spoken for us: “Now to him who is able to keep you from stumbling and to present you blameless before the presence of his glory with great joy, to the only God, our Savior, through Jesus Christ our Lord, be glory, majesty, dominion, and authority, before all time and now and forever. Amen” (Jude 24–25).

Soli Deo Gloria.


Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)

The Lutheran Confessions

  • Triglot Concordia: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by F. Bente and W. H. T. Dau. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. English text as published at bookofconcord.org.
  • The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
  • The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Preface to the Book of Concord; Augsburg Confession, Preface, VII, Conclusion of Part One, and XXVIII; Apology VII–VIII; Smalcald Articles, Preface; Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope; Formula of Concord, Epitome and Solid Declaration, Rule and Norm; Solid Declaration X.)

The Early Church

  • Irenaeus. Against Heresies. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
  • Tertullian. The Prescription Against Heretics. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3.
  • Athanasius. Letters (Letter 59, To Epictetus). In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 4.
  • Hilary of Poitiers. On the Councils (De Synodis). In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 9.
  • Basil the Great. Letters. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 8.
  • Vincent of Lérins. The Commonitory. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 11.

The Reformation and Lutheran Orthodoxy

  • Luther, Martin. That a Christian Assembly or Congregation Has the Right and Power to Judge All Teaching and to Call, Appoint, and Dismiss Teachers (1523). Luther’s Works, vol. 39. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1970.
  • Luther, Martin. Lectures on Galatians (1535), chapters 5–6. Luther’s Works, vol. 27. St. Louis: Concordia, 1964.
  • Luther, Martin. Commentary on the Epistle to the Galatians (1535). Translated by Theodore Graebner. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1939.
  • Chemnitz, Martin. Examination of the Council of Trent. Translated by Fred Kramer. 4 vols. St. Louis: Concordia, 1971–1986.
  • Krauth, Charles Porterfield. The Conservative Reformation and Its Theology. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott, 1871.
  • Sasse, Hermann. Here We Stand: Nature and Character of the Lutheran Faith. Translated by Theodore G. Tappert. New York: Harper, 1938.

Other Works

  • Lewis, C. S. Mere Christianity. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1952.
  • Agreement between Reformation Churches in Europe (Leuenberg Agreement). 1973.

Reference

  • Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
  • Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. 1828.

Footnotes

  1. Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “generic.” ↩

  2. C. S. Lewis, Mere Christianity (London: Geoffrey Bles, 1952), Preface. The passage on the hall and the rooms is quoted in full in the companion paper “Just Jesus”: The Confession Behind the Claim, section VII. ↩

  3. Agreement between Reformation Churches in Europe (the Leuenberg Agreement), 1973; Lutheran World Federation, Sixth Assembly, Dar es Salaam, 1977, where “unity in reconciled diversity” was adopted as a description of the ecumenical goal. On the Lord’s Supper see the Agreement’s section on the condemnations of the Reformation era (Part III) and §32b, which states that the condemnations in the confessional writings no longer apply to the present doctrinal position of the assenting churches. The Agreement and the Dar es Salaam statement are summarized here rather than quoted. ↩

  4. Ap VII–VIII 10. ↩

  5. Ap VII–VIII 20. ↩

  6. Preface to the Book of Concord 20. The fuller passage, with its words about “many godly and by no means wicked men” in churches that do not agree with us, is quoted in Confessing the Confessions, section V. ↩

  7. Charles Porterfield Krauth, The Conservative Reformation and Its Theology (Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott, 1871), 195. ↩

  8. Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. παραθήκη. ↩

  9. Webster, American Dictionary (1828), s.v. “deposit,” noun, sense 2; s.v. “trust,” noun, sense 8. ↩

  10. Irenaeus, Against Heresies III.4.1, ANF, vol. 1. ↩

  11. Irenaeus, Against Heresies I.10.2, ANF, vol. 1. ↩

  12. Tertullian, The Prescription Against Heretics 20, ANF, vol. 3. ↩

  13. Tertullian, Prescription 21, ANF, vol. 3. ↩

  14. Tertullian, Prescription 37, ANF, vol. 3. ↩

  15. Vincent of Lérins, Commonitory 22 (§53), NPNF², vol. 11. Confessing the Confessions, section V, quotes other sentences from the same chapter. ↩

  16. Martin Luther, Commentary on the Epistle to the Galatians (1535), on Galatians 5:9, trans. Theodore Graebner (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1939). Graebner’s translation is condensed; the full text is in LW 27. ↩

  17. Luther, Lectures on Galatians (1535), on Galatians 5:9–10, LW 27. Paraphrased. ↩

  18. Krauth, Conservative Reformation, 195–196. ↩

  19. Athanasius, Letter 59, To Epictetus 1, NPNF², vol. 4. ↩

  20. Athanasius, To Epictetus 4, NPNF², vol. 4. ↩

  21. Hilary of Poitiers, On the Councils (De Synodis) 91, NPNF², vol. 9. ↩

  22. Basil the Great, Letter 140.2, To the Church of Antioch, NPNF², vol. 8. ↩

  23. AC Preface 8. ↩

  24. AC Preface 10–11. ↩

  25. AC, Conclusion of Part One (the summary following Article XXI), 1. The Triglotta prints this paragraph as a continuation of Article XXI. ↩

  26. AC VII 2; SD X 31. See On Denominationalism, “Augsburg Confession Article VII.” ↩

  27. Ep Rule and Norm 1–2. ↩

  28. Ep Rule and Norm 8. ↩

  29. SD Rule and Norm 2. ↩

  30. SD Rule and Norm 5. ↩

  31. SD Rule and Norm 10. ↩

  32. SA Preface 3. ↩

  33. Martin Chemnitz, Examination of the Council of Trent, Part I, Topic II, “Concerning Traditions,” trans. Fred Kramer (St. Louis: Concordia, 1971). Summarized, not quoted. ↩

  34. Hermann Sasse, Here We Stand: Nature and Character of the Lutheran Faith, trans. Theodore G. Tappert (New York: Harper, 1938). Summarized, not quoted. See also On Denominationalism, “Pieper, Sasse, and Bonhoeffer.” ↩

  35. See Confessing the Confessions, section IV, which quotes the confessional statements of two North American Lutheran church bodies. The wording of the ordination question differs among the rites in use, so it is described here rather than quoted. ↩

  36. SD Rule and Norm 14. ↩

  37. AC XXVIII 21–24. ↩

  38. AC XXVIII 28, citing Augustine, Against the Letter of Petilian. ↩

  39. Tr 56. ↩

  40. Tr 67. ↩

  41. Tr 72. The same judgment from Galatians 1:8, that godless teachers are to be held accursed, is laid on the papacy at Tr 38 and 41. ↩

  42. Martin Luther, That a Christian Assembly or Congregation Has the Right and Power to Judge All Teaching and to Call, Appoint, and Dismiss Teachers, Established and Proven by Scripture (1523), LW 39. Summarized, not quoted. ↩

  43. SD Rule and Norm 15. ↩

  44. Preface to the Book of Concord 7. ↩

  45. Preface to the Book of Concord 21. ↩

  46. SD Rule and Norm 16. ↩

Topics
The Lutheran Confessions
Scripture
Jude 3Ephesians 4:51 Timothy 6:202 Timothy 1:13–142 Timothy 2:21 Corinthians 4:1–21 Corinthians 15:3Hebrews 9:26–28Hebrews 13:8–9Galatians 1:6–8Galatians 1:9Galatians 5:42 John 9Romans 16:17Acts 20:27Galatians 5:9Acts 17:111 Timothy 4:16Titus 1:9Acts 20:31Matthew 7:151 Thessalonians 5:21John 10:5Galatians 1:8Galatians 1:7–8Acts 20:28Ephesians 4:14–15Galatians 1:6Psalm 78:4John 17:21John 17:172 Timothy 1:142 Timothy 1:12Matthew 16:18Jude 24Galatians 5:9–10
Confessions
SD VIIAC XXVIIIAp VIIAC VIISD X

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “A Particular Confession of the Apostolic Faith: Is Lutheranism One Brand of Generic Christianity, or a Trust to Be Kept?.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/a-particular-confession-of-the-apostolic-faith/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.