Catholic and Reformed
Why the Lutheran Church Separated from Rome
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“There is one body and one Spirit—just as you were called to the one hope that belongs to your call—one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is over all and through all and in all.” — Ephesians 4:4–6
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation. The decrees of the Council of Trent are quoted from the translation of J. Waterworth (1848).
The Question Before Us
Every Sunday we stand and confess, “I believe in one holy catholic and apostolic Church.” Lutherans have always said that they did not start a new church in the sixteenth century. We say that the Lutheran Church is the catholic Church of the apostles and the fathers, cleansed of certain abuses and gathered again around the pure Gospel and the Sacraments rightly administered. Yet anyone who knows a little history can see the difficulty at once. If we are a continuation of the historic catholic Church, why are we not in communion with the bishop of Rome? The Church of Rome is the largest Christian body on earth. It has an unbroken line of bishops reaching back to the first centuries and for a thousand years the Western Church and the Church of Rome were the same thing. Luther himself was a Roman priest and a monk. How can a church that separated from Rome claim to be the catholic Church? Is that not simply what every breakaway group says about itself?
This is a fair question and it deserves a careful answer. A Roman Catholic friend might put it even more sharply. Either the Church of Rome is the catholic Church and the Lutherans left it, or the Lutherans are right and the Church disappeared for centuries until Wittenberg found it again. The first answer makes us schismatics. The second makes Christ a liar, since He promised that the gates of hell shall not prevail against His Church (Matthew 16:18). Is there another way to see it?
I believe there is and it is the way our own Confessions see it. In this paper I want to take up five questions in order:
- What does the word catholic mean?
- Did the Lutherans leave Rome, or were they put out?
- On what issues did the separation finally turn?
- Where is the catholic Church to be found, if not in communion with the bishop of Rome?
- Where do things stand between Lutherans and Rome today, and what does it mean for us to be evangelical catholics?
At each step we will listen first to Holy Scripture, then to the Lutheran Confessions, and then to the fathers and the Reformers who help us hear Scripture rightly. Two related matters belong to other papers in this series: the relationship of Scripture and tradition (Scripture Alone and Its Interpreter), and what it means for a pastor and a congregation to subscribe to the Confessions (Confessing the Confessions). I will touch on them only where this question requires it.
I. What Does “Catholic” Mean?
The word itself
We begin with the word. Webster’s defines catholic as “universal or general; as the catholic church,” and notes that the epithet was originally given to the Christian Church in general, though in common speech it had come to be applied to the Church of Rome.1 That second observation is already the problem in miniature. A word that belongs to the whole Church has come to be used as the name of one part of it.
The English word comes from the Greek katholikos (καθολικός, “general, universal”), which is built from kata (“according to, throughout”) and holos (“whole”).2 In other words, catholic means “according to the whole.” The adjective does not appear in the New Testament. However, the related adverb katholou (“wholly, at all”) does appear once, in a setting worth remembering. When the Sanhedrin released Peter and John, “they called them and charged them not to speak or teach at all in the name of Jesus” (Acts 4:18). The word katholou is the “at all.”3 The apostles’ answer is the first catholic principle we meet in the history of the Church: “We must obey God rather than men” (Acts 5:29).
What, then, is “according to the whole”? Scripture does not leave us guessing. The Church is “built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Christ Jesus himself being the cornerstone” (Ephesians 2:20). “For no one can lay a foundation other than that which is laid, which is Jesus Christ” (1 Corinthians 3:11). The first believers “devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers” (Acts 2:42). The whole that the word catholic points to is the whole faith of the apostles, held by the whole Church in every place, gathered around the one Lord who gives Himself in Word and Sacrament. Jude calls it “the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints” (Jude 3). The catholic Church is the Church that holds that faith whole.
The fathers on catholicity
The word appears in Christian writing very early. Around the year 110, Ignatius of Antioch, on his way to martyrdom in Rome, wrote to the Christians at Smyrna: “Wherever the bishop shall appear, there let the multitude [of the people] also be; even as, wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.”4 This is the first surviving use of the phrase. It is interesting what Ignatius makes the center of catholicity. He says “wherever Jesus Christ is,” not “wherever Rome is.” Ignatius certainly prized the bishop as the center of unity in each local congregation. Yet the Church is catholic because Christ is present in her and the bishop is honored because he serves that presence.
In the middle of the fourth century, Cyril of Jerusalem explained the word to his catechumens in a passage that has never been bettered:
“It is called Catholic then because it extends over all the world, from one end of the earth to the other; and because it teaches universally and completely one and all the doctrines which ought to come to men’s knowledge, concerning things both visible and invisible, heavenly and earthly; and because it brings into subjection to godliness the whole race of mankind … and because it universally treats and heals the whole class of sins.”5
Cyril gives the word four dimensions: the Church is catholic in her extent (the whole world), in her teaching (the whole faith), in her people (the whole human race), and in her healing (the whole of sin). Only one of those four is geographical. In other words, a church may be large and spread across the world and still fail to be catholic in the fuller sense, if it does not teach the whole faith or heal the whole of sin with the whole Gospel.
A century later, Vincent of Lérins, a monk of southern Gaul, gave the Church its most famous rule for recognizing catholic teaching: “in the Catholic Church itself, all possible care must be taken, that we hold that faith which has been believed everywhere, always, by all.”6 Vincent wrote against novelty. He wanted to know how a Christian could tell the ancient faith from a clever innovation and his answer was universality, antiquity, and consent. The Reformers were glad to take up this rule, because it applies to every teacher in the Church. If the test of catholic doctrine is what has been believed everywhere, always, and by all, then every teaching that cannot show itself in Scripture and the ancient Church has a heavy burden to bear, no matter who now teaches it.
We should be honest here. Rome also appeals to the fathers and with good reason. Augustine once wrote against the Manichaeans, “I should not believe the gospel except as moved by the authority of the Catholic Church.”7 Roman Catholic theologians have long cited this sentence as proof that the Church’s authority stands above the individual’s reading of Scripture. Chemnitz answered it carefully in his Examination of the Council of Trent. Augustine was describing how the Church’s witness first brought him to the Gospel, as the Samaritan woman’s witness brought her townspeople to Jesus, after which they believed “because of his word” (John 4:39–42). He was not teaching that the Church’s authority makes the Gospel true. Elsewhere Augustine says plainly that “the sacred canon of Scripture” stands “so absolutely in a superior position to all later letters of the bishops” that all the letters of bishops, and even the councils, may be corrected by it.8
Catholic is a confession, not only a location
Our Confessions take up this ancient understanding of the word. The Apology of the Augsburg Confession explains why the Creed calls the Church catholic:
“And it says Church Catholic, in order that we may not understand the Church to be an outward government of certain nations, but rather men scattered throughout the whole world, who agree concerning the Gospel, and have the same Christ, the same Holy Ghost, and the same Sacraments, whether they have the same or different human traditions.”9
That is the Lutheran answer to the first question. The word catholic describes the Church that holds the whole apostolic faith, scattered throughout the world and united by the same Christ, the same Gospel, and the same Sacraments. It does not, in the first place, name an organization or a city. Therefore the question is not whether the Lutherans were in communion with Rome. The question is whether they held the catholic faith. That is exactly the claim they made, as we shall see and they made it in front of the Emperor.
II. Did the Lutherans Leave, or Were They Put Out?
A protest from within
The popular picture of the Reformation is of a monk who stormed out of the Church and started his own. The history does not support that picture. When Martin Luther posted his Ninety-Five Theses on the door of the Castle Church in Wittenberg on October 31, 1517, he was doing what university professors did. He was calling for a public academic debate on the preaching of indulgences and he sent the theses to his own archbishop asking him to correct the abuse.10 The first of the Theses is a sentence about repentance and not a cry of revolt: when our Lord and Master Jesus Christ said “Repent,” He willed the entire life of believers to be one of repentance.11
In the years that followed, Luther appealed again and again to the Church’s own courts. After his meeting with Cardinal Cajetan at Augsburg in 1518, he appealed from the pope poorly informed to the pope better informed, and then to a general council of the whole Church. In 1520 he wrote an open letter to Pope Leo X and sent it with his treatise The Freedom of a Christian. The letter is sharp about the Roman curia. However, it is respectful toward Leo himself, whom Luther called a lamb in the midst of wolves.12 Luther was a priest and doctor of theology trying to call his Church back to the Gospel, not a man trying to found a church.
Put out of the Church’s fellowship
Rome answered with a bull. On June 15, 1520, Leo X issued Exsurge Domine (“Arise, O Lord”). It opened with the words of Psalm 74: “Arise, O Lord, and judge your own cause,” and it described Luther as a wild boar from the forest that “seeks to destroy” the vineyard of the Lord. The bull condemned forty-one propositions drawn from Luther’s writings, ordered his books burned, and gave him sixty days to recant or be declared a heretic.13 Luther did not recant. On December 10, 1520, he burned the bull, together with books of canon law, outside the Elster Gate of Wittenberg. On January 3, 1521, Leo issued Decet Romanum Pontificem, which formally excommunicated him.
In April 1521, Luther stood before the Emperor Charles V at the Diet of Worms. When he was asked to recant, he answered that unless he was convinced “by the testimony of the Scriptures or by clear reason,” he was bound by the Scriptures he had quoted, “and my conscience is captive to the Word of God.”14 The Edict of Worms that followed declared him an outlaw of the Empire. In other words, Luther did not walk out of the Roman Church. He was excommunicated by the pope and outlawed by the Emperor for refusing to recant teaching he believed was the teaching of Scripture. It is true that he had become fierce in his writing by then and he did not go quietly. Yet the excommunication was Rome’s act and not his.
What were the people of Saxony and the other evangelical territories to do then? Their pastors had been condemned for preaching justification by faith. Their bishops would not ordain men who taught it. Were they to stop preaching the Gospel because the bishops refused it? The apostles had already answered that question in Acts 5:29.
The confession at Augsburg
The clearest evidence that the Lutherans did not intend to leave the catholic Church is the Augsburg Confession itself. In 1530 the Emperor summoned a Diet at Augsburg and asked the evangelical princes to give an account of what was being taught in their churches. Philip Melanchthon drafted the Confession and on June 25, 1530, it was read aloud in German before the Emperor and the estates of the Empire.
Its whole spirit is reconciliation. The Preface says the princes have come “in order that, after the removal and correction of such things as have been treated and understood in a different manner in the writings on either side, these matters may be settled and brought back to one simple truth and Christian concord,” so that “as we all are under one Christ and do battle under Him, so we may be able also to live in unity and concord in the one Christian Church.” If agreement could not be reached at the Diet, the princes offered to “appear and defend our cause in such a general, free Christian Council.”15 The princes were asking the whole Church to judge their cause.
The first twenty-one articles set out the chief articles of faith and nearly all of them would have been accepted by any catholic Christian of the time: the Trinity, original sin, the Person of Christ, Baptism, the Lord’s Supper, the civil order, the return of Christ. At the end of Article XXI, Melanchthon states the Lutheran claim plainly:
“This is about the Sum of our Doctrine, in which, as can be seen, there is nothing that varies from the Scriptures, or from the Church Catholic, or from the Church of Rome as known from its writers. This being the case, they judge harshly who insist that our teachers be regarded as heretics.”
The phrase “as known from its writers” matters. The Lutherans were not claiming to agree with every practice in the Church of Rome in 1530. They were claiming to agree with the Church of Rome as the fathers and the ancient writers knew it. The Confession goes on: “There is, however, disagreement on certain abuses, which have crept into the Church without rightful authority.” And again: “our churches dissent in no article of the faith from the Church Catholic, but only omit some abuses which are new, and which have been erroneously accepted by the corruption of the times, contrary to the intent of the Canons.”16
The second part of the Confession (Articles XXII through XXVIII) reviews those abuses: communion in one kind, the forced celibacy of priests, the private Mass, compulsory confession of every sin, the distinction of foods, monastic vows, and the power of bishops. Even here the tone is careful. Article XXIV begins, “Falsely are our churches accused of abolishing the Mass; for the Mass is retained among us, and celebrated with the highest reverence. Nearly all the usual ceremonies are also preserved.”17 Article XXVIII makes a remarkable offer to the bishops: “It is not our design now to wrest the government from the bishops, but this one thing is asked, namely, that they allow the Gospel to be purely taught, and that they relax some few observances which cannot be kept without sin. But if they make no concession, it is for them to see how they shall give account to God for furnishing, by their obstinacy, a cause for schism.”18 The Conclusion says once more that nothing has been received “against Scripture or the Church Catholic.”19
The Roman theologians answered with the Confutation, which the Emperor accepted and the Lutherans were not permitted to keep a copy of. Melanchthon replied with the Apology of the Augsburg Confession. In the Apology the same desire is stated even more plainly. Concerning the order of bishops, Melanchthon writes, “it is our greatest wish to maintain church-polity and the grades in the Church, even though they have been made by human authority.” What prevented it? The bishops either compelled the evangelical priests to condemn the doctrine they had confessed, or put them to death. “Thus the cruelty of the bishops is the reason why the canonical government, which we greatly desired to maintain, is in some places dissolved.”20 Luther said the same in the Smalcald Articles of 1537: if the bishops would be true bishops and devote themselves to the Church and the Gospel, they might be permitted “for the sake of love and unity, but not from necessity, to ordain and confirm us and our preachers.”21 Only because they refused did the evangelical churches ordain their own pastors, as the ancient Church had sometimes done.
Therefore the answer to the second question is clear. The Lutherans did not set out to leave the catholic Church or even the Roman obedience. They asked for reform, appealed to a council, confessed the catholic faith before the Emperor, and offered to keep the bishops. They were excommunicated, outlawed, and refused ordination for their pastors. When the separation came, it came because they would not stop preaching what they believed the Scriptures taught.
III. On What Did the Separation Turn?
It would be a mistake to think that the whole quarrel was about bad behavior in Rome. Luther was shocked by what he saw in Rome as a young monk and there was certainly corruption in the late medieval Church. However, the Reformers did not separate over the morals of popes. Wycliffe and Hus had attacked bad popes before Luther was born. The Lutheran Reformation was different because it was about doctrine, and about one doctrine above all. Three issues stand at the center: justification, the Mass, and the authority of the papacy.
Justification
The first and chief issue was how a sinner is made right with God. Article IV of the Augsburg Confession states it in a single sentence:
“Also they teach that men cannot be justified before God by their own strength, merits, or works, but are freely justified for Christ’s sake, through faith, when they believe that they are received into favor, and that their sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake, who, by His death, has made satisfaction for our sins. This faith God imputes for righteousness in His sight. Rom. 3 and 4.”22
This is the teaching of Saint Paul: “for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, and are justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus” (Romans 3:23–24), and “we hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law” (Romans 3:28). The Apology calls this “the chief topic of Christian doctrine,” which “illumines and amplifies the honor of Christ” and “brings necessary and most abundant consolation to devout consciences.” In the Smalcald Articles Luther wrote that “of this article nothing can be yielded or surrendered, even though heaven and earth, and whatever will not abide, should sink to ruin,” because “upon this article all things depend which we teach and practice in opposition to the Pope, the devil, and the world.”23
Why was this article the hinge of everything? Because every abuse the Reformers objected to grew out of the same root. If a sinner must contribute his own merits to his justification, then he needs a system for gathering merit and paying off the debt of sin, and the late medieval Church had built one: indulgences, Masses offered for the living and the dead, pilgrimages, vows, and satisfactions. If, however, the sinner is justified freely for Christ’s sake through faith, then the whole system is unnecessary and a burden on consciences. In other words, the abuses grew out of an error in the doctrine of grace and could not be corrected without correcting it.
The Council of Trent took up justification in its Sixth Session and on January 13, 1547 (eleven months after Luther’s death) it issued its decree. We should read Trent fairly. The council taught that “none of those things which precede justification, whether faith or works, merit the grace itself of justification.” Lutherans should say so plainly and should not accuse Trent of teaching that a sinner saves himself without grace. Yet the Apology had good reason for its warning. Before Trent the scholastic teachers taught “that men merit the remission of sins by doing what is in them” and that “without the Holy Ghost reason can love God above all things.”24 Trent also defined justification as “not remission of sins merely, but also the sanctification and renewal of the inward man.”25 It then attached canons with anathemas to the very points the Augsburg Confession had confessed:
“CANON IX. If any one saith, that by faith alone the impious is justified; in such wise as to mean, that nothing else is required to co-operate in order to the obtaining the grace of Justification … let him be anathema.”
“CANON XII. If any one saith, that justifying faith is nothing else but confidence in the divine mercy which remits sins for Christ’s sake; or, that this confidence alone is that whereby we are justified; let him be anathema.”
Canon XI condemned anyone who said that men are justified “by the sole imputation of the justice of Christ,” and Canon XXIV condemned anyone who said that good works are “merely the fruits and signs of Justification obtained, but not a cause of the increase thereof.”26 Whatever their intention, these canons condemned the teaching of AC IV as Lutherans understood it. The question was no longer whether some preachers had abused indulgences. The question was whether the Gospel of Romans 3 could be preached in the Roman Church and on that question Trent spoke with an anathema.
The decree touched the troubled conscience most painfully in its ninth chapter. Trent granted that “no pious person ought to doubt of the mercy of God, of the merit of Christ, and of the virtue and efficacy of the sacraments.” Yet it taught that each one, when he regards himself and his own weakness, “may have fear and apprehension touching his own grace; seeing that no one can know with a certainty of faith, which cannot be subject to error, that he has obtained the grace of God.”27 Then the sinner is sent back to look at himself after all. The Treatise names this very complaint, that the adversaries “bid us doubt whether the remission takes place.”28 The Reformers would not leave him there, because Christ’s promise is spoken for you and faith rests on the promise and not on its own worthiness.
The Mass and the cup
The second issue was the Lord’s Supper, in two parts. The first concerned the cup. Our Lord said of the cup, “Drink of it, all of you” (Matthew 26:27) and Paul assumes that the whole congregation at Corinth both ate the bread and drank the cup (1 Corinthians 11:26–28). For more than a thousand years the Church gave both to the people. The Augsburg Confession points out that Cyprian and Jerome testify to it and that Pope Gelasius forbade the dividing of the Sacrament. By the later Middle Ages, however, the cup had been withheld from the laity and the Council of Constance confirmed the practice in 1415. The Reformers asked only that Christ’s institution be followed. Trent answered in 1562 by anathematizing anyone who said that all the faithful ought by God’s command to receive both kinds.29
The second part concerned the Mass as a sacrifice. The Lutherans kept the Mass, as we have seen. What they rejected was the teaching that in the Mass the priest offers Christ to God as a sacrifice that merits forgiveness for the living and the dead, apart from faith, and that such Masses could be multiplied and purchased. Scripture says that Christ was “offered once to bear the sins of many” (Hebrews 9:28), and “by a single offering he has perfected for all time those who are being sanctified” (Hebrews 10:14). The Supper is first of all God’s gift to us, His body and blood given and shed “for the forgiveness of sins” (Matthew 26:28) and the sacrifice we bring is thanksgiving.30 Luther had made the same point in The Babylonian Captivity of the Church in 1520.31
Here too fairness is required. Roman Catholic theology teaches that the one sacrifice of the cross is made present in the Mass, not that Christ is killed again, and Trent says so. However, Trent also anathematized anyone who said that the Mass is not “a propitiatory sacrifice” or that it “ought not to be offered for the living and the dead for sins, pains, satisfactions, and other necessities.”32 The Lutherans could not accept that, because it put the Mass back into the system of merit and took the Supper out of the hands of faith. In the Smalcald Articles, Luther’s language about the sacrifice of the Mass is among the harshest in the Book of Concord.33 We need not repeat the heat to agree with the point. Christ gives Himself to us in the Supper; we do not offer Him to the Father to earn what He has already won.
The papacy
The third issue was the authority of the pope. The Lutherans did not begin with the papacy. They came to it because the pope claimed the authority to condemn their teaching on justification and they had to ask by what right. Luther stated the conclusion in the Smalcald Articles: “the Pope is not, according to divine law or according to the Word of God the head of all Christendom (for this belongs to One only, whose name is Jesus Christ), but is only the bishop and pastor of the Church at Rome,” and other bishops are to be “not under him as a lord, but with him as brethren and comrades, as the ancient councils and the age of St. Cyprian show.”34 Melanchthon’s Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope (1537) argued the point from Scripture and history at length.
The argument from Scripture is this. Christ sends all the apostles in the same way: “As the Father has sent me, even so I am sending you” (John 20:21). Paul received his apostleship without confirmation from Peter (Galatians 1:15–2:10), and when Peter erred at Antioch, Paul “opposed him to his face, because he stood condemned” (Galatians 2:11). As for “on this rock I will build my church” (Matthew 16:18), the Treatise points out that many of the fathers (it names Origen, Cyprian, Augustine, Hilary, and Bede) understood the rock to be Peter’s confession, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God” (Matthew 16:16), and it quotes Chrysostom: Christ “built His Church not upon man, but upon the faith of Peter.”35 We should say honestly that the fathers read this text in more than one way and that some of them also gave Peter’s person a place of honor. Yet none of them read it the way the medieval papacy did, as a grant of jurisdiction over the whole Church by divine right.
The argument from history is just as strong. The Council of Nicaea arranged the authority of the great sees by human decision. Jerome wrote that “wherever there has been a bishop, whether at Rome, or Eugubium, or Constantinople, or Rhegium, or Alexandria, he is of the same dignity and priesthood.”36 Cyprian of Carthage, whom Rome rightly honors as a martyr and a teacher of the Church’s unity, resisted Pope Stephen to his face. At the Council of Carthage in 256 he said, “neither does any of us set himself up as a bishop of bishops, nor by tyrannical terror does any compel his colleague to the necessity of obedience.”37 Writing against Stephen’s letter, he said that “custom without truth is the antiquity of error.”38 Here we must be careful. On the question Cyprian and Stephen were arguing about (whether those baptized by heretics must be baptized again) the later Church, Augustine included, sided with Stephen and not with Cyprian. Yet even where Cyprian was wrong, the greatest bishop of third-century Africa did not believe the bishop of Rome could settle the question by his own authority.
The most striking witness is a pope. Around the year 595, John, the patriarch of Constantinople, began to call himself “ecumenical” or “universal” patriarch. Gregory the Great, bishop of Rome, protested to John himself, to the Emperor Maurice, and to the other patriarchs. To the Emperor he wrote, “I confidently say that whosoever calls himself, or desires to be called, Universal Priest, is in his elation the precursor of Antichrist, because he proudly puts himself above all others.”39 When Eulogius of Alexandria then addressed Gregory as “Universal Pope,” Gregory refused the title for himself:
“For my honour is the honour of the universal Church: my honour is the solid vigour of my brethren. Then am I truly honoured when the honour due to all and each is not denied them. For if your Holiness calls me Universal Pope, you deny that you are yourself what you call me universally. But far be this from us. Away with words that inflate vanity and wound charity.”40
The Treatise cites this very correspondence.41 To be fair to Rome, Gregory also believed that Peter had received “the care and principality of the whole Church,” and he did not think of himself as merely one bishop among many.42 Yet he rejected the title that later popes would claim and he rejected it because it took from the other bishops the honor that was theirs.
Finally we must say a word about the hardest language in our Confessions. The Smalcald Articles and the Treatise call the papacy the Antichrist. To modern ears that sounds like name-calling and it was not meant as such. The Confessions rest the judgment on the claims of the papal office. The pope claims that “no Christian can be saved unless he obeys him and is subject to him in all things.” He takes to himself “the right to change the doctrine of Christ and services instituted by God,” and wants his own to be observed as divine. He defends godless doctrine and services and he has used cruelty against those who confess the Gospel.43 Paul speaks of one who “exalts himself against every so-called god or object of worship, so that he takes his seat in the temple of God” (2 Thessalonians 2:4), and the Treatise concludes that “it is necessary to resist him as Antichrist.” I subscribe the Smalcald Articles and the Treatise and I confess this judgment with them. It is a judgment about the claims of an office and not about the faith of Roman Catholic people, and the same Confessions confess that God has His people even where the Gospel is obscured.44 Gregory the Great used nearly the same language about the title “universal” a thousand years before Luther.
Trent makes the breach dogmatic
For years after Augsburg it was possible to hope that a council might heal the division. When Pope Paul III finally summoned a council to meet at Mantua in 1537, the Elector of Saxony asked Luther to prepare the articles the evangelical side could and could not yield and these became the Smalcald Articles. The council did not meet at Mantua. It finally opened at Trent in December 1545 and met in three periods until 1563. The Lutherans were not given a voice on equal terms and the council did not take the Augsburg Confession as the basis of its deliberation.
Trent was in many ways a reforming council. It addressed real abuses, required bishops to reside in their dioceses, founded seminaries, and abolished the office of the professional alms-collectors who had preached indulgences. Lutherans should be glad of those reforms. However, on the doctrines that the Reformation had raised, Trent answered with anathemas. What had been a dispute over abuses and open questions became a matter of binding dogma. After Trent, a Roman Catholic could not hold that a sinner is justified by faith alone without falling under the council’s curse.
Martin Chemnitz, the principal author of the Formula of Concord, took up the council’s decrees one by one in his Examination of the Council of Trent (1565–1573). He did not argue that Trent was wrong because Luther said so. He argued from Scripture first, and then from the fathers, that Trent had departed from the ancient catholic faith on Scripture and tradition, on justification, on the Sacraments, and on the Mass.45 In other words, Chemnitz turned Vincent’s rule back on the council. The Lutherans had not departed from what was believed everywhere, always, and by all. Trent had made binding what had never been so believed.
IV. Where Is the Catholic Church to Be Found?
We now come to the heart of the objection. If the Church is not defined by communion with the bishop of Rome, how do we know where she is? Is there not a danger that every group will simply declare itself the true Church?
The marks of the Church
The Augsburg Confession answers in Article VII:
“Also they teach that one holy Church is to continue forever. The Church is the congregation of saints, in which the Gospel is rightly taught and the Sacraments are rightly administered. And to the true unity of the Church it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments. Nor is it necessary that human traditions, that is, rites or ceremonies, instituted by men, should be everywhere alike. As Paul says: One faith, one Baptism, one God and Father of all, etc. Eph. 4:5–6.”46
Three things are said here. First, the one holy Church will “continue forever.” The Lutherans did not believe that the Church had disappeared and had to be refounded. Christ kept His promise (Matthew 16:18). Second, the Church is “the congregation of saints,” the people of God gathered by the Holy Spirit through faith. Third, she is known by her marks: the Gospel rightly taught and the Sacraments rightly administered. The Apology explains that the Church is “originally a fellowship of faith and of the Holy Ghost in hearts,” yet this fellowship “nevertheless has outward marks so that it can be recognized, namely, the pure doctrine of the Gospel, and the administration of the Sacraments in accordance with the Gospel of Christ.” It adds that “we are not dreaming of a Platonic state,” but “this Church exists, namely, the truly believing and righteous men scattered throughout the whole world.”47
The marks are not a Lutheran invention. Irenaeus wrote around the year 180, “where the Church is, there is the Spirit of God; and where the Spirit of God is, there is the Church, and every kind of grace; but the Spirit is truth.”48 Augustine taught that the Word is joined to the element and it becomes a Sacrament (accedit verbum ad elementum et fit sacramentum).49 Jesus Himself said, “My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me” (John 10:27), and Luther built on that verse in the Smalcald Articles: “a child seven years old knows what the Church is, namely, the holy believers and lambs who hear the voice of their Shepherd.”50 In his treatise On the Councils and the Church (1539), Luther listed seven marks by which the holy Christian people may be recognized: the Word of God, Baptism, the Sacrament of the Altar, the Office of the Keys, the called ministry, prayer and praise, and the holy cross of suffering.51 Wherever these are, there the Church is, because there Christ is at work.
Luther’s explanation of the Third Article in the Large Catechism puts the same truth in the language of faith. “I believe that there is upon earth a little holy group and congregation of pure saints, under one head, even Christ, called together by the Holy Ghost in one faith, one mind, and understanding.” The head of the Church is Christ. Her unity is the unity of faith and the Spirit. The Holy Spirit gathers her by the Word and Luther calls this congregation “the mother that begets and bears every Christian through the Word of God.”52
What about the succession of bishops?
Rome’s strongest answer to all this is the apostolic succession. The bishops of the Catholic Church stand in a line that reaches back to the apostles. Does that not prove where the Church is?
We should take this argument seriously, because it is ancient. Irenaeus himself used it. Against the Gnostics, who claimed a secret tradition from the apostles, he pointed to the public succession of bishops in the churches: if the apostles had known hidden mysteries, they would surely have handed them down to the men to whom they entrusted the churches. He named the bishops of Rome from Linus to his own day, and he said that every church should agree with the church at Rome “on account of its preeminent authority.”53 Lutherans should acknowledge that passage honestly.
Yet it is interesting what Irenaeus used the succession to prove. He was arguing that the Gnostics’ teaching could not be apostolic, because the churches the apostles founded had never heard of it, and not that a line of bishops guarantees true doctrine no matter what those bishops teach. In other words, the succession was a witness to the apostolic teaching, and its value lay in the teaching it carried. When Irenaeus wrote, the bishops of Rome taught what the apostles had taught. The argument works only so long as that remains true. Once a bishop teaches what the apostles did not teach, the line of names cannot make it apostolic. Paul had already said so: “even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed” (Galatians 1:8). The apostle places himself under the Gospel, and his successors stand under it as well.
Therefore the Lutheran Confessions place the apostolic succession where Irenaeus placed its value: in the succession of apostolic doctrine. The Treatise says that the ministry does not “avail on account of the authority of any person, but on account of the Word given by Christ.”54 This is why the Lutherans could say they had kept the catholic Church while losing the canonical bishops. They had not chosen to be without bishops. They had been refused them, because they would not condemn the Gospel to keep them.
The Lutherans kept what was catholic
It is easy to forget how much the Lutheran Reformation kept. The Lutheran churches kept the three ecumenical creeds and placed them at the front of the Book of Concord. They kept the Mass, the church year, the vestments, the lectionary, the ancient hymns, private confession and absolution, and the baptism of infants. The Apology says that “we willingly observe the order of the Mass, the Lord’s Day, and other more eminent festival days,” and that “with a very grateful mind we embrace the profitable and ancient ordinances.”55 When the Formula of Concord was published, a Catalog of Testimonies was added to show from the fathers that the Lutheran teaching on the Person of Christ was the ancient teaching of the Church.
Luther made the same argument in his treatise Against Hanswurst (1541). He set out what the Lutheran churches had and held: the same Baptism, the same Sacrament of the Altar, the same keys, the same office of preaching, the same Creed, the same Lord’s Prayer, the same Scriptures that the ancient Church had held. Therefore, he argued, it was the evangelical churches that had remained with the old Church, and those who had added new things were the ones who had departed from it.56 The same conviction stands behind the whole Book of Concord.
Was it schism?
What, then, of the charge of schism? A schism is a tearing of the Church’s fellowship, and it is a serious sin. Paul pleads with the Corinthians “that there be no divisions among you, but that you be united in the same mind and the same judgment” (1 Corinthians 1:10). Cyprian wrote that “he can no longer have God for his Father, who has not the Church for his mother,” and he meant it as a warning against those who divide the Church.57 Lutherans agree, when mother is understood as Luther explains it in the Large Catechism: the Church is “the mother that begets and bears every Christian through the Word of God.”58 Wherever the Word and the Sacraments are, that mother is still bearing children. The question is who caused the division. Our Confessions answer that the guilt rests with those who demanded that the evangelical preachers condemn the Gospel as the price of fellowship. Article XXVIII put it plainly: if the bishops make no concession, “it is for them to see how they shall give account to God for furnishing, by their obstinacy, a cause for schism.”59
We should also be honest about ourselves. The Lutheran side was not without sin in the sixteenth century. Political interests on both sides used the quarrel for their own ends. Luther’s own polemical writing grew harsh and sometimes cruel, and Lutherans have no reason to defend every word he wrote. The evangelical churches also divided among themselves. When we confess that the separation was forced on us, we mean only that on the article of justification our fathers could not yield, and should not have yielded, and that we cannot yield it today. We do not mean that they were saints in every respect.
V. Where Things Stand Today
What we share
Nearly five centuries have passed since the Diet of Augsburg, and a great deal has changed. Lutherans and Roman Catholics confess the same Triune God and the same creeds. We baptize in the same name and we recognize each other’s Baptism. We both confess that the body and blood of Christ are truly present in the Sacrament of the Altar. We both hold the Holy Scriptures to be the inspired Word of God. Rome itself has changed some of the practices our fathers protested. The Second Vatican Council (1962–1965) restored the vernacular to the Mass and permitted communion under both kinds in certain circumstances, which have since been widened.60 The trade in indulgences that set off the controversy in 1517 is gone, although the doctrine of indulgences remains. The Roman Catholic Church today speaks of Lutherans as separated brothers and sisters in Christ, and Lutherans should speak of Roman Catholics in the same way. The Preface to the Book of Concord already said in 1580 that “many godly and by no means wicked men” were to be found “even in those churches which have hitherto not agreed with us in all things.” It said this chiefly of the churches touched by the Formula’s condemnations on the Supper, and the same charity applies by extension to Roman Catholics.61
The Joint Declaration of 1999
The most important event of recent times is the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification, signed by the Lutheran World Federation and the Roman Catholic Church at Augsburg on October 31, 1999. Its central paragraph reads: “Together we confess: By grace alone, in faith in Christ’s saving work and not because of any merit on our part, we are accepted by God and receive the Holy Spirit, who renews our hearts while equipping and calling us to good works.”62 The Declaration concluded that the teaching of the Lutheran churches presented in it does not fall under Trent’s condemnations, and that the Lutheran condemnations do not apply to the Roman Catholic teaching presented in it.63
We should be thankful for every sentence in which Rome and Lutherans confess grace together. However, we must also be honest that the Declaration did not end the disagreement. It did not settle whether the sinner is justified by the imputation of Christ’s righteousness alone, or whether good works increase justification, and it left Trent’s canons in place while saying they did not apply to the teaching described. Many confessional Lutherans did not accept it. The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod’s Commission on Theology and Church Relations published a critical evaluation concluding that the Declaration did not achieve real agreement on the article of justification, and a large number of German Lutheran theologians publicly objected to it as well.64 Neither the North American Lutheran Church nor Lutheran Congregations in Mission for Christ existed as church bodies when it was signed and neither was a party to it. For a confessional Lutheran the measure of any such agreement is AC IV and Ap IV, and each of us should read the Declaration with those articles open beside it.
What still divides
Other matters also remain. Since the First Vatican Council (1870), Rome has taught as dogma that the pope possesses immediate jurisdiction over the whole Church and that his solemn definitions on faith and morals are infallible. Rome has also defined the Immaculate Conception of Mary (1854) and her bodily Assumption (1950) as dogmas necessary to believe. None of these can be shown from Scripture or from what was believed everywhere, always, and by all. The Mass is still taught as a propitiatory sacrifice. In some ways the distance on the papacy is greater now than it was in 1530. Honesty requires us to say so, even while we are glad for every real step toward one another.
VI. What This Means for Us: Evangelical Catholics Today
What does all this mean for a congregation like ours? It means first that we do not need to be embarrassed when we confess “one holy catholic and apostolic Church.” We are confessing what our fathers confessed at Augsburg, not borrowing a word that belongs to someone else: that our churches “dissent in no article of the faith from the Church Catholic.”65 The early Lutherans called themselves evangelical, people of the Gospel, and they called the faith they confessed catholic. We are both. We are evangelical because the Gospel of free forgiveness for Christ’s sake is the center of everything we teach. We are catholic because that Gospel is the faith of the apostles and of the whole Church in every age, and because we receive it through the same Word and Sacraments by which Christ has always gathered His people.
It means also that we should treasure what we have been given. The liturgy we pray on Sunday, the creeds we confess, the church year we keep, the hymns of Ambrose and Gregory and Luther that we sing, are the catholic inheritance that our fathers refused to throw away, not Roman leftovers that we tolerate, and they belong to us. In the same way, the sermon that proclaims Christ crucified for sinners and the Supper given “for you” are what the Church has always lived on, not Lutheran novelties.
It means that we should speak of Rome with charity and with truth. We speak with charity because Roman Catholics are baptized into the same Christ and many of them trust in Him alone for their salvation, whatever the canons of Trent may say. We speak the truth because love does not pretend that the article of justification no longer matters. The Reformation was a recovery of the Gospel for the whole Church and not a victory of Wittenberg over Rome. Every Christian in every church needs that Gospel.
Finally, it means that we should grieve the division and pray for its healing. On the night before He died, our Lord prayed “for those who will believe in me through their word, that they may all be one, just as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be in us, so that the world may believe that you have sent me” (John 17:20–21). The division of the Western Church is a wound in the body of Christ and it does real harm to the Church’s witness. We should never be content with it. Yet the unity Christ prayed for is unity in the truth, the truth by which He sanctifies us: “your word is truth” (John 17:17). Therefore we pray for unity in the Gospel and we do not seek it apart from the Gospel.
How, then, do we live in the meantime? We live as the Church has always lived, by the Word and the Sacraments through which Christ gathers His one people. The Church has not failed, because Christ has not failed. Where His Gospel is preached and His Sacraments are given, He is present to forgive, and there the catholic Church is, whether in Wittenberg or Rome or in our own congregation. For the troubled conscience that wonders whether it stands in the true Church, the answer is found in the promise spoken to you at the font, in the absolution, and at the altar: your sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake. It is not found in a line of bishops or in the size of a church body. That promise was catholic before there was a Lutheran or a Roman Catholic, and it will be catholic when we all stand together before the Lamb, “a great multitude that no one could number, from every nation, from all tribes and peoples and languages” (Revelation 7:9).
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)
The Lutheran Confessions
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. (Text at bookofconcord.org.)
- The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Edited by Theodore G. Tappert. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1959.
- The Book of Concord. Edited by Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2000. (Especially: Augsburg Confession, Preface, IV, VII, XXI–XXVIII and Conclusion; Apology IV, VII–VIII, XIV, XXIV; Smalcald Articles II.i–iv, III.x, III.xii; Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope; Large Catechism, Creed.)
The Early Church
- Ignatius of Antioch. Epistle to the Smyrnaeans. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
- Irenaeus. Against Heresies. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
- Cyprian. On the Unity of the Church; Epistles; The Seventh Council of Carthage. In The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 5.
- Cyril of Jerusalem. Catechetical Lectures. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 7.
- Augustine. On Baptism, Against the Donatists; Against the Epistle of Manichaeus Called Fundamental. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 4.
- Augustine. Tractates on the Gospel of John. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 7.
- Vincent of Lérins. Commonitory. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 11.
- Gregory the Great. Epistles. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 12.
The Reformation and Lutheran Orthodoxy
- Luther, Martin. Ninety-Five Theses; Letter to Pope Leo X. Luther’s Works, vol. 31. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1957.
- Luther, Martin. Luther at the Diet of Worms. Luther’s Works, vol. 32. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1958.
- Luther, Martin. The Babylonian Captivity of the Church. Luther’s Works, vol. 36. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1959.
- Luther, Martin. On the Councils and the Church; Against Hanswurst. Luther’s Works, vol. 41. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1966.
- Chemnitz, Martin. Examination of the Council of Trent. Translated by Fred Kramer. 4 vols. St. Louis: Concordia, 1971–1986.
Roman Catholic and Ecumenical Documents
- Leo X. Exsurge Domine. 1520.
- Canons and Decrees of the Council of Trent. Translated by J. Waterworth. London: Dolman, 1848.
- Second Vatican Council. Sacrosanctum Concilium. 1963.
- Lutheran World Federation and the Roman Catholic Church. Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. 1999.
- Commission on Theology and Church Relations, Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod. The Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification in Confessional Lutheran Perspective. St. Louis, 1999.
Reference
- Liddell, Henry George, and Robert Scott. A Greek-English Lexicon. Revised by H. S. Jones. Oxford: Clarendon, 1940.
- Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
- Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. 1828.
Footnotes
-
Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “catholic.” ↩
-
Henry George Liddell and Robert Scott, A Greek-English Lexicon, rev. H. S. Jones (Oxford: Clarendon, 1940), s.v. καθολικός. ↩
-
Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. καθόλου. ↩
-
Ignatius, Epistle to the Smyrnaeans 8, ANF, vol. 1. ↩
-
Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lectures XVIII.23, NPNF², vol. 7. ↩
-
Vincent of Lérins, Commonitory 2.6, NPNF², vol. 11. ↩
-
Augustine, Against the Epistle of Manichaeus Called Fundamental 5, NPNF¹, vol. 4. ↩
-
Martin Chemnitz, Examination of the Council of Trent, trans. Fred Kramer, 4 vols. (St. Louis: Concordia, 1971–1986), vol. 1, on the First Decree of the Fourth Session (Holy Scripture), where Chemnitz treats Augustine’s saying and the example of the Samaritans in John 4. On the superiority of Scripture to the letters of bishops and to councils, Augustine, On Baptism, Against the Donatists II.3.4, NPNF¹, vol. 4. The fuller relationship of Scripture and tradition is taken up in Scripture Alone and Its Interpreter. ↩
-
Ap VII–VIII 10. The bracketed German additions of the Triglotta are omitted here. ↩
-
On the theses as an invitation to academic disputation and Luther’s letter to Archbishop Albrecht of Mainz of October 31, 1517, see LW 48 and the editor’s introduction to the Ninety-Five Theses in LW 31. ↩
-
Luther, Ninety-Five Theses (1517), thesis 1, LW 31:25 (paraphrased). ↩
-
Luther, Letter to Pope Leo X (1520), LW 31:334–343. ↩
-
Leo X, Exsurge Domine (June 15, 1520), opening paragraph, citing Psalm 74:22 and Psalm 80:13; on the forty-one propositions and the sixty days, the closing paragraphs of the bull. ↩
-
Luther at the Diet of Worms (1521), LW 32:112–113. The words “Here I stand” appear in the earliest printed account, though not in all the eyewitness reports. ↩
-
AC Preface 3–4, 21. The appeal to a council is repeated in AC Preface 22–23. ↩
-
AC XXI 5, 6, and 10 in the Triglotta numbering. In Tappert these are the “Summary” following Article XXI, 1–2, and the introduction to Articles XXII–XXVIII, 1. ↩
-
AC XXIV 1–2. ↩
-
AC XXVIII 77–78. ↩
-
AC Conclusion 5. ↩
-
Ap XIV 1–2 (the Triglotta numbers these paragraphs 24–25). Compare Ap XIV 5, where Melanchthon declares again “that we will gladly maintain ecclesiastical and canonical government, provided the bishops only cease to rage against our Churches.” ↩
-
SA III.x 1. In SA III.x 3 Luther appeals to Jerome’s report that the church at Alexandria was at first governed in common by presbyters. ↩
-
AC IV 1–3. ↩
-
Ap IV 2; SA II.i 5. ↩
-
Ap IV 9. ↩
-
Council of Trent, Session VI (January 13, 1547), Decree on Justification, chapters VIII and VII. ↩
-
Trent, Session VI, canons IX, XI, XII, and XXIV. ↩
-
Trent, Session VI, Decree on Justification, chapter IX. Compare canon XIII, which anathematizes anyone who says that a man must believe for certain, “without any wavering arising from his own infirmity and disposition,” that his sins are forgiven him. ↩
-
Tr 44. ↩
-
AC XXII 1–7. On Trent’s answer, see Session XXI (July 16, 1562), Doctrine on Communion under Both Kinds, canons I and II. On Constance, see Session XIII of that council (1415). ↩
-
AC XXIV 21–30; Ap XXIV 19–26, distinguishing the propitiatory sacrifice of Christ, which is His death alone, from the eucharistic sacrifice of praise and thanksgiving offered by those who have been reconciled. ↩
-
Luther, The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520), LW 36:35–57. ↩
-
Trent, Session XXII (September 17, 1562), Doctrine on the Sacrifice of the Mass, chapter I, and canons I and III. ↩
-
SA II.ii 1–10. ↩
-
SA II.iv 1. The bracketed German additions of the Triglotta are omitted. ↩
-
Tr 25–29. ↩
-
On Nicaea, Tr 12; on Jerome, Tr 18, citing Jerome, Letter 146, to Evangelus. ↩
-
Cyprian, The Seventh Council of Carthage under Cyprian (256), opening address, ANF, vol. 5. ↩
-
Cyprian, Epistle 73, to Pompey, Against the Epistle of Stephen 9, ANF, vol. 5. ↩
-
Gregory the Great, Epistles VII.33, to the Emperor Maurice, NPNF², vol. 12. Compare Epistles V.18, to John of Constantinople, and V.20, to Maurice. ↩
-
Gregory the Great, Epistles VIII.30, to Eulogius of Alexandria, NPNF², vol. 12. ↩
-
Tr 19. ↩
-
Gregory the Great, Epistles V.20, NPNF², vol. 12. ↩
-
SA II.iv 4 (the claim to obedience), 10–14; Tr 38–41. The quotations on changing doctrine and on resisting him as Antichrist are Tr 40 and 57. ↩
-
See AC VII 1; Ap VII–VIII 20; and the Preface to the Book of Concord. On confessional subscription and what it binds, see Confessing the Confessions. ↩
-
Chemnitz, Examination of the Council of Trent, vol. 1 (Scripture, tradition, original sin, free will, justification, good works) and vol. 2 (the Sacraments, including communion under both kinds and the sacrifice of the Mass). ↩
-
AC VII 1–4. ↩
-
Ap VII–VIII 5, 20. ↩
-
Irenaeus, Against Heresies III.24.1, ANF, vol. 1. ↩
-
Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 80.3, NPNF¹, vol. 7. ↩
-
SA III.xii 2. ↩
-
Luther, On the Councils and the Church (1539), LW 41:148–166. ↩
-
LC II 51, 42. ↩
-
Irenaeus, Against Heresies III.3.1–3, ANF, vol. 1. The Latin is propter potiorem principalitatem and its exact sense has been debated for centuries. ↩
-
Tr 26. ↩
-
AC XXIV 1–2; AC XXV 1; AC IX 2; Ap XXIV 1. The quotations are from Ap VII–VIII 33. ↩
-
Luther, Against Hanswurst (1541), LW 41 (paraphrased). ↩
-
Cyprian, On the Unity of the Church 6, ANF, vol. 5. ↩
-
LC II 42. ↩
-
AC XXVIII 78. ↩
-
Second Vatican Council, Sacrosanctum Concilium (1963), 36 and 55. ↩
-
Preface to the Book of Concord 20 (Triglotta numbering). Compare my On Denominationalism, which treats the wider question of how the one Church appears in many church bodies. ↩
-
Lutheran World Federation and the Roman Catholic Church, Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (1999), 15. ↩
-
Joint Declaration, 40–41 (paraphrased). ↩
-
Commission on Theology and Church Relations of the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, The Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification in Confessional Lutheran Perspective (St. Louis, 1999). The public statement of German Protestant university theologians against the Declaration was issued in 1998 and renewed in 1999. ↩
-
AC XXI 10. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Catholic and Reformed: Why the Lutheran Church Separated from Rome.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/catholic-and-reformed/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.