The Lutheran Reformation
A study of the Reformation with a focus on the life of Martin Luther
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Historical material taken from the following sources:
Needham N.R., 2000 Years of Christ’s Power: Renaissance and Reformation,
(London: Grace Publications Trust, 2004)
Gritsch, Eric, A History of Lutheranism,
(Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2002)
The call for reformation was not new to Martin Luther. In fact, for over 200 years before Luther’s time, the call for reformation rang throughout many different sectors of the western world. France and Spain were battling for control. The papacy was not as powerful as it once had been and began to reassert itself as an authority in the world. The Ottoman Empire began expanding westward and was knocking on the door of the Holy Roman Empire. The fragmented civil, social, and ecclesiastical climate caused a great uproar among the people. In addition to this upheaval, the invention of the printing press by Johann Guttenberg in the 1450’s provided a low cost method to communicate ideas quickly and efficiently, not only within one’s own borders, but also to people throughout the western world. Western Europe was poised for an explosion of reformation throughout all aspects of life.
The universities were experiencing a change as well. Since the latter part of the Middle Ages (~ 1100), Scholasticism was the prominent type of theology taught. Scholasticism was marked by a commitment to explore and state rationally the full content of individual Christian doctrines and fit them together in a comprehensive system of truth.1 Beginning in the thirteenth century, a more focused approach on the philosophical teachings of Aristotle began to invade the scholastic system. This systematizing of knowledge and teaching, named as via moderna, rejected universal truths and emphasized the individual. Based on this teaching, a reinforced teaching of Neo-Pelagianism began to take root which taught that God accepts man based on the efforts of man. The Scholastics denied original sin and emphasized man’s works. According to the Scholastics, God ultimately accepts man based on the merits of good works accumulated during one’s lifetime. Shortly before Luther’s time, men such as Johannes Reuchlin began questioning the teachings at the universities. Reuchlin believed that truth was found, not in the philosophical teachings of Aristotle or in the works of man, but in God alone as He is understood in the original sources of the Scriptures. As such, Reuchlin turned to the Hebrew and Greek manuscripts in order to understand God’s desire for man. This movement became known as Humanism, or via antiqua, and it spread across the western world. Intellectuals were turning back to the teachings of the Church Fathers, especially the teachings of Augustine of Hippo, in order to understand God’s Word to man. The humanists were anti-scholastic and openly opposed the teachings at the universities. The western world was ripe for revolution and reformation, but a strong and intelligent leader would be necessary to light this powder keg.
Martin Luther was born in 1483 in Eisleben, Saxony. Soon after his birth, his family moved to Mansfeld, Germany’s mining center, where his father worked in the mining and smelting businesses.2 Luther was well educated at schools in Mansfeld and Eisenach, which later enabled him to enroll at the University of Erfurt in 1501 at the age of eighteen. At Erfurt, Luther originally intended to become a lawyer, a profession his father greatly desired for Luther. However, after a month of legal studies, Luther forsook university life, renounced the world, and joined the Augustinian order of friars in Erfurt.
Numerous factors and influences on Luther’s life caused him to join the Augustinian order of friars. Primarily, the influence of Scholasticism caused Luther to question his own salvation. If, as the Scholastics teach, God accepts man based on man’s own merits, at what point has a person gained enough merit with God to be accepted? How does one know that he has done enough? This question plagued Luther as he grappled with his own sense of sinfulness. For Luther, joining a religious order seemed to be the next logical step, since joining these orders was the most popular way of increasing one’s chances of salvation. Soon after taking his vows, Luther continued his studies at Erfurt with a focus on Biblical studies.
In 1507, Luther was ordained a priest and became the junior lecturer at the new university of Wittenberg. During this time, Luther would be under the care of his vicar of the Augustinian friars, Johannes von Staupitz, but Staupitz was not an ordinary professor of theology. Whereas Erfurt professors’ taught Luther theology based on the ways of Scholasticism, Staupitz would teach Luther theology based on the ways of Humanism and via antiqua. Staupitz was a disciple of Augustine of Hippo and opposed via moderna. He would encourage Luther to read the Scriptures in their original languages and through the lens of the early Church Fathers, such as Augustine.
During Luther’s education, Staupitz sent him to Rome to appeal the merger of two divergent chapters of Augustinian Hermits in Germany.3 Luther, still under the influence of Scholastic teaching, believed that going to Rome would be spiritually meritorious. He would have the chance to touch relics and visit the sacred sites in Rome. It took Luther forty days to make the 850 mile journey to Rome. Once he arrived, Luther was shocked at the moral decay he found in Rome and returned from his journey with a cynical attitude toward Rome, and the papacy.4
Staupitz, Luther’s mentor, continued to encourage Luther to study for a doctorate in theology. By 1512, Luther had received his first degree from Wittenberg and took over teaching Biblical studies at the university. Luther began studying the Bible utilizing the grammatical-historical method taught by the Humanists. By reading the Scriptures in Greek and Hebrew, Luther suddenly understood books such as Psalms, Romans, Galatians, and Hebrews much better than he previously did. Luther soon realized that the methods of Scholasticism betrayed the Biblical message of Holy Scriptures. Suddenly, Luther found himself a fervent disciple of Augustine, especially Augustine’s doctrine of the sovereign grace of God. According to Augustine, it is the sovereign grace of God that chooses helpless sinners for salvation by His unmerited mercy. This lead Luther to interpret the “righteousness of God” not as the righteousness in which God punishes sinners, but as the righteousness which He graciously gives to sinners as a free-gift of salvation.5 In addition, Luther began to understand faith as a personal trust in Christ rather than an assent to the Church’s teachings.6 When these two points are taken as a whole, Luther understood that it is a man’s trust in Christ which imputes7 Christ’s righteousness to the believer’s account. This imputation of Christ’s righteousness changes the believer’s legal status before God. The believer gains entry into heaven based upon faith alone and not by any merit earned during one’s lifetime.
As Luther was beginning to sharpen his theology, the indulgence controversy was brewing in Germany. An indulgence was a certificate of pardon issued by the papacy. Since the western church taught that entry into heaven was based upon merits earned during one’s lifetime, the question had arisen, long ago, concerning one’s sins committed during a lifetime that did not prevent a person from entering heaven, but were unaccounted for at their death. The western church taught that these sins needed to be “paid off” through suffering before a person could enter into God’s presence. This place of suffering was called Purgatory and the payment took place after a person died, but before they arrived in heaven. Throughout a person’s lifetime, many of these sins accumulated and were paid off after they died. An indulgence was a certificate of forgiveness, offered by the Pope. Originally, indulgences were seen as a sign of grace, but over time, the church began to issue indulgences for favors, either political or financial. In 1515, Pope Leo X authorized the sale of a special set of indulgences in Germany. Pope Leo was collecting money to build Saint Peter’s basilica in Rome and sent one of his finest preachers, Johann Tetzel, to Germany to preach on indulgences. Tetzel was an overwhelming preacher who was also manipulative. Tetzel also preached that indulgences could be purchased on behalf of deceased family members. One of Tetzel’s famous sayings was, “As soon as the coin in the money-box rings, the soul from purgatory springs”.8 This style of preaching irritated Luther and on October 31st, 1517 Luther wrote a disputation9 against the sale of indulgences entitled Disputation on the Power and Efficacy of Indulgences (a.k.a. 95 Thesis). Luther posted the disputation on the door of Wittenberg’s castle, not as a dramatic gesture, but as the normal way of posting a public announcement. Within months, the whole of German was in an uproar. Luther was under attack from bishops, universities, monks, and all upholders of Scholastic theology. However, Luther also gained a wide array of support. Humanists, especially those who despised indulgences, sympathized strongly with Luther. In addition, German nationalists who thought that Rome was draining away finances from Germany to Rome held Luther as a leader for their voice. Lastly, many ordinary German Christians who longed for the Church to be purified from its abuses looked to Luther to bring change.
In 1518, charges were formally brought against Luther by the Pope and he was ordered to appear in Heidelberg to defend his teachings amongst the Augustinian Order. Here, Luther presented his “Heidelberg Disputation”, forty theses in which he defended Augustine’s doctrines of sin and grace, and attacked the way that the schoolmen had subjected Christian theology to Aristotle’s philosophy.10 The “Heidelberg Disputation” also set out Luther’s contrast between the “theology of glory” and the “theology of the cross”. By “theology of glory”, he meant a theology that glorifies human achievement (whether the intellectual achievement of human philosophy in seeking to understand God, or the moral achievements of human goodness in seeking to earn its own salvation). By “theology of the cross”, Luther meant God’s rejection of human achievement, a rejection revealed in the cross of Jesus Christ. Only through Jesus Christ can a true knowledge of God and true salvation be found. Luther was sharpening his rhetorical skills as a debater. In addition, he gained favor with many young observers such as Martin Bucer.
Luther continued to write defenses of his teachings. A popular pamphlet written in 1518 to explain the 95 theses also cast doubt on the Pope’s ability to release souls from Purgatory. This infuriated the papacy and Luther was ordered to appear in Rome to answer for his errors. Frederick the Wise, leader of Saxony, would not turn Luther over to the pope, but agreed to let the papacy send someone to Augsburg for a meeting with Luther. The papacy sent Cardinal Cajetan to Augsburg. Luther and Cajetan openly lost their tempers with each other. Cajetan ordered Luther to recant his erroneous teachings, but Luther would not. Instead, Luther took his teachings one step further and insisted that the pope was subject to correction by the Scriptures and ecumenical councils of the whole Church. Cajetan became irate, since the western church held that the pope was infallible. Their meeting in Augsburg came to an impasse with neither side willing to give in. Luther left the debate and appealed to an ecumenical council to settle the dispute.
In June and July of 1519, a disputation between the Humanists and the Scholastics took place in Leipzig. The Humanists sent Karlstadt (who held a more senior position than Luther at Wittenberg) while the Scholastics sent Johann Eck. Eck was a professor of theology and one of the greatest debaters of the day. The debates opened with a dispute between Karlstadt and Eck concerning Augustine’s doctrine of sin and grace and the freedom of the will. Eck easily got the better of Karlstadt. Soon, Luther stepped in. Luther and Eck debated over 13 theses. Luther took up the subject of the papacy and attempted to prove that neither Scripture nor the early Church supported the absolute supremacy of the pope. However, Eck, being a clever debater, cornered Luther into admitting his views were similar to John Huss. In 1415, the Council of Constance had found John Huss guilty of heresy and burned him at the stake for holding similar views concerning the fallibility of the pope. This forced Luther to admit that the Council of Constance erred in condemning Huss. Luther appealed to the Scriptures as the sole source of infallible authority (Sola Scriptura). Luther pointed out that all other sources, however useful and even indispensible they may be, are subordinate to the Scriptures.11 Luther’s comments during the debate forced the papacy to issue a Papal Bull12 against Luther for forty-one errors concerning Luther’s views on papal authority and denial of free will. Luther now had sixty days to submit to the papacy or be excommunicated and burned as a heretic.
The length of time between when the pope issued the Papal Bull until Luther received it took several months. During this period of time, Luther’s life was influenced by his close companion, Philip Melanchthon. Melanchthon’s study and knowledge of Greek would lead Luther toward a new understanding of “justification”. Melanchthon’s study convinced him that “justify” meant to “declare righteous” in a legal sense. When a judge pronounced a “not guilty” verdict on an accused person, the law has no more quarrel with that person.13 Up until Melanchthon’s time, the theological understanding of “justification” was “to make righteous”. Scholastic theologians understood this to mean “the process by which a sinner is changed spiritually in his soul into a just, holy, and godly person”.14 Therefore, the act of spiritually changing required “merit”. Melanchthon broke from this understanding of merit and understood “justification” as an imputation of Christ’s righteousness to the believer. This is an act of God’s grace upon the sinner and the guilty sinner is declared by a holy and just Judge to be “righteous” on account of Christ. A sinner does not have to strive to acquire a sufficient “merit” in order to secure a place in heaven. Because of trust in Jesus, a sinner knows that his place is secure through Christ’s perfect work. Luther agreed with Melanchthon and his writings from this time on reflected this new understanding of justification by faith through grace. Luther wrote four treatises in 1520 which cemented his understanding of justification by faith.15
Luther’s first work in 1520 was Treatise on Good Works. This was a response to basic concerns such as (1) if one is justified by grace alone, why perform good works at all? Many thought that Luther’s stance on justification would lead to the demise of the moral fabric of life in the world.16 In this treatise, Luther wrote that good works are a natural consequence of a truly lasting relationship between the faithful and God.
Luther’s next work was Address to the Christian Nobility of the German Nation, published in August 1520. In it, Luther declared that popes and ecumenical councils had failed to reform the Church, therefore, it was the duty of secular rulers to step in. Luther defined three “walls” in which the papacy had defended its power. First, the papacy claimed that the clergy were superior to the laity and the laity could not exercise the power of the church. Luther claimed that the “priesthood of all believers” held that every believer was a true priest before God. A clergyman was simply the one priest chosen by the assembly through a process of ordination. The next “wall” Luther attacked was the papal claim of infallibility. If the pope was the only infallible ruler, then only the pope could interpret Scripture without error. Luther claimed that interpretation belongs to all believers and that the pope was not infallible. Lastly, the third “wall” Luther attacked was the claim that only the papacy could summon an ecumenical council. Luther argued that the government of the church lay in the hands of the whole church, laity and clergy alike.
Luther’s third work was The Babylonian Captivity of the Church, published in October 1520. In this work, Luther compared the western church to Israel exiled in Babylon. Luther attacked the papacy’s refusal to give up the cup to the laity. Luther argued from Scripture that both the bread and wine belonged to all Christians. In addition, Luther disagreed on the doctrine of transubstantiation (a teaching that the bread and wine actually change into Christ’s body and blood). This teaching was nothing more than a Scholastic invention, claimed Luther. The last item Luther attacked was the sacrifice of the mass. The papacy claimed that the priest offered up to God the sacrifice of Christ during each celebration of the Lord’s Supper. However, Luther believed communion to be a gift from God to His people. Communion was a gift given from God above to His people below instead of a sacrifice from His people below to Him up above.
Luther’s last treatise was The Freedom of the Christian. This publication was less of an attack on Rome and more of a positive exposition on the true meaning of the Christian life.
Luther eventually received the Papal Bull and the request for his presence in Worms to appear before the diet17 on April 16th, 1521. At Worms, all of Luther’s writings were laid out on the table before him. When Luther was asked if the writings were his, he agreed that they were. Luther was then asked if he still defended his writings. Luther requested some time to think about his answer. His request was granted. The following afternoon, Luther appeared before the diet again and was asked if he recanted his teachings. Luther justified what he had written and promised that if he was proven from Scripture that what he had written was in error, he would be the first to throw his writings into the fire. Anger filled the air and Luther was asked again if he would recant his teachings, which Luther so famously replied:
Unless I am refuted and convicted by testimonies of Scripture or by clear reason – since I believe neither the popes nor the councils by themselves, for it is clear that they have often erred and contradicted themselves – I am conquered by the holy Scriptures I have quoted, and my conscience is captive to the Word of God. I cannot and will not withdraw anything, since it is neither safe nor right to do anything against one’s conscience. Here I stand. God help me. Amen.
After several days of discussion between Luther and the diet, Luther was permitted to leave Worms on April 26th, 1521. Later that day, the committee officially condemned Luther as a heretic and outlaw and placed him under the ban of the Holy Roman Empire. This means that anyone within the Empire caught aiding Luther would also be treated as a criminal. Nonetheless, Frederick the Wise was determined to protect Luther. Frederick sent a party to intercept Luther and carried him off to the Wartburg castle in Eisenach. Luther stayed in the castle for eleven months, but this time proved to be his most creative. While in the castle, Luther translated the entire Greek New Testament into German.
The western world was changing and revolution and reformation was in the air. Melanchthon continued to write such classics as Loci Communes Rerum Theologicarum (Chief Points of Theological Matters). This became the supreme textbook of theology in Lutheran universities. The reformers began to produce other positive theology of their own, logically arranged and clearly stated, as a counterpoint to Rome’s teaching. The protest against Roman abuses was turning into the establishment of an alternative Church, the Lutheran Church. Luther continued to write theological publications such as the Small Catechism and the Large Catechism, which are still used in Lutheran churches today as a means of teaching the laity the truth of Jesus Christ. Luther would also continue to work with Melanchthon on writing the confessions of the Lutheran church, the Augsburg Confessions, in 1530.
Luther ushered in reformation in the Church. Although he did not set out to establish a new denomination, he would witness the first Lutheran church built at Torgau Castle Chapel in 1544. In 1546, Luther preached his last sermon on February 14th. Two days later, in Eisleben, Martin Luther died and was buried at Castle Church in Wittenberg. The Reformation would continue on without its great leader, but there is no doubt that God used the man named Martin Luther to ignite the Reformation.
Footnotes
-
N.R. Needham, 2000 Years of Christ’s Power: Renaissance and Reformation, (London: Grace Publication Trust), 2004, 576. ↩
-
Eric W. Gritsch, A History of Lutheranism, (Minneapolis: Fortress Press), 2002, 6. ↩
-
Ibid., 9. ↩
-
Needham, 2000 Years of Christ’s Power, 69. ↩
-
Ibid., 70. ↩
-
Ibid., 70. ↩
-
Credits or ascribes ↩
-
Ibid., 75. ↩
-
In the Scholastic system, a disputation was a formal, written debate with fixed rules to govern the process. ↩
-
Ibid., 77. ↩
-
Ibid., 82. ↩
-
A particular, public announcement or charter issued by the pope. ↩
-
Ibid., 85. ↩
-
Ibid., 87. ↩
-
Gritsch, A History of Lutheranism, 22. ↩
-
Ibid., 22. ↩
-
A council or governing assembly ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “The Lutheran Reformation: A study of the Reformation with a focus on the life of Martin Luther.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/lutheran-reformation/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.