Papers · Essays

Speak Now

When Someone Objects at a Wedding: History, Theology, and Pastoral Practice

HA HA: Human-written; AI-assisted
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

“So they are no longer two but one flesh. What therefore God has joined together, let not man separate.” — Matthew 19:6


The Question Before Us

Pastors are often asked, usually with a laugh, “Has anyone ever actually objected?” The question comes from the words many couples still expect to hear near the beginning of the service: “If any one can show just cause why they may not lawfully be joined together, let him now speak, or else forever hold his peace.” The movies have made that moment famous and the real thing is far rarer than the movies suggest. However, it does happen and the pastor who stands at the front of the church ought to know ahead of time what he will do if it happens to him.

[Pastor: if you have a story of your own (an objection you witnessed, or a rehearsal-dinner question that set you thinking about this), it would fit here.]

The question is more than a practical one. What is marriage, that a stranger’s word can halt it? Who has the right to say that two people may not marry, and on what grounds? What is the pastor doing when he stands before a couple with a marriage license in one hand and the Word of God in the other?

In this paper I want to take up five questions in order: 1) What do the words of the charge mean? 2) Where did the charge come from, and what was it meant to do? 3) What is marriage, and why can an objection stop it? 4) What counts as “just cause,” and what does not? 5) What should the pastor actually do if someone objects? We will then consider where objections properly belong (before the wedding day, in the pastor’s study), what couples and families should know, and whether the charge should remain in the rite at all.

At each step we will listen first to Holy Scripture, then to the Lutheran Confessions, and then to the witnesses of the Church’s history who help us hear Scripture rightly.


I. The Words Themselves

The older form of the charge speaks of an impediment and the newer forms speak of just cause. Webster’s defines an impediment as “that which hinders progress or motion; hinderance; obstruction; obstacle; applicable to every subject, physical or moral.”1 The word comes from the Latin impedimentum, which first meant the baggage that slowed down an army on the march. In the Church’s law of marriage it became a technical term: a fact about one or both of the parties that hinders them from being lawfully married. In other words, an impediment is a fact that stands in the way.

The phrase just cause says the same thing in plainer English. The cause must be just, that is, grounded in law and not in feeling. In addition, the charge asks why the couple “may not lawfully be joined together.” The question put to the congregation is a narrow one: Do you know of a reason, recognized by God’s law or by the laws of the land, why these two cannot marry? Much of the confusion around objections comes from forgetting how narrow that question is.


II. Where the Charge Came From

Witnesses at the gate

Scripture does not give us a wedding liturgy and it does not contain the charge of impediment. However, it does show us that marriage among God’s people was a public matter, entered before witnesses. When Boaz takes Ruth as his wife he does it at the city gate, before the elders and the people: “You are witnesses this day that I have bought from the hand of Naomi all that belonged to Elimelech and all that belonged to Chilion and to Mahlon. Also Ruth the Moabite, the widow of Mahlon, I have bought to be my wife, to perpetuate the name of the dead in his inheritance… You are witnesses this day.” The people answer, “We are witnesses. May the LORD make the woman, who is coming into your house, like Rachel and Leah, who together built up the house of Israel” (Ruth 4:9–11). Before Boaz could do this, the nearer kinsman had to be given the chance to claim his prior right and decline it in front of those same witnesses (Ruth 4:1–8). The community heard the matter, any prior claim was settled in the open, and only then did the people bear witness and pray for the couple. A marriage was a public estate (a way of life God has set up) entered before God and the community and the community had both a stake in it and a responsibility for it.

The banns

The charge as we know it grew out of the medieval practice of the banns (from an old word for a public proclamation). In 1215 the Fourth Lateran Council (a general council of the medieval Western Church) made the custom of some regions the rule for the whole Church. Its fifty-first canon reads in part: “we absolutely forbid clandestine marriages; and we forbid also that a priest presume to witness such. Wherefore… we decree that when marriages are to be contracted they must be announced publicly in the churches by the priests during a suitable and fixed time, so that if legitimate impediments exist, they may be made known. Let the priests nevertheless investigate whether any impediments exist. But when there is ground for doubt concerning the contemplated union, let the marriage be expressly forbidden until it is evident from reliable sources what ought to be done in regard to it.”2

The canon did three things: 1) it made the announcement public so that impediments would come to light before the wedding, 2) it required the priest to investigate for himself rather than depend on the announcement alone, and 3) it postponed a doubtful marriage until the facts were known instead of cancelling it or hurrying it through. The same canon also threatened punishment for anyone who “maliciously presents an impediment for the purpose of frustrating a legitimate marriage.”3

The Book of Common Prayer

The English Book of Common Prayer is the source of the words most English speakers still have in their ears, and its 1662 edition gives the fullest form. The banns are ordinarily read on three Sundays beforehand: “If any of you know just cause, or just impediment, why these two persons should not be joined together in holy Matrimony, ye are to declare it.”4 On the wedding day, after the exhortation on the purposes of marriage, the priest says to the congregation: “Therefore if any man can shew any just cause, why they may not lawfully be joined together, let him now speak, or else hereafter for ever hold his peace.”5

The priest then turns and puts the same question to the couple themselves, and in the most solemn terms: “I require and charge you both, (as ye will answer at the dreadful day of judgement, when the secrets of all hearts shall be disclosed) that if either of you know any impediment, why ye may not be lawfully joined together in Matrimony, ye do now confess it.”6 The charge was never only a question for the pews, since the two people most likely to know of an impediment are the two standing at the front.

The Prayer Book also tells the priest what to do if someone answers. The objector had to name an impediment “by God’s Law, or the Laws of this Realm,” and he had to stand behind it, either by binding himself (with others as sureties) or by depositing security to cover the couple’s costs if he failed to prove his charge. If he did, the wedding was postponed. The rubric (the printed instruction to the minister) reads:

At which day of Marriage, if any man do allege and declare any impediment, why they may not be coupled together in Matrimony, by God’s Law, or the Laws of this Realm; and will be bound, and sufficient Sureties with him, to the Parties; or else put in a Caution (to the full value of such charges as the Persons to be married do thereby sustain) to prove his allegation; then the Solemnization must be deferred, until such time as the truth be tried.7

In other words, an objection started an inquiry rather than ending a marriage, and the objector carried real risk if he had spoken carelessly. The bond was meant to discourage careless charges, although it could not show that a charge was true, and the rubric leaves the trial of the truth to the Church’s courts rather than to the priest at the church door.

Luther and the Lutheran orders

In Luther’s Order of Marriage for Common Pastors (1529), which he appended to the Small Catechism, the invitation to object belongs to the banns. The names are announced from the pulpit beforehand and anyone who knows a reason against the marriage is asked to speak in time or afterward hold his peace. There is no charge to the congregation at the wedding itself. The couple exchange their promises at the church door, the pastor pronounces them joined in marriage, and then he brings them before the altar to read God’s Word over them and bless them.8 In the preface Luther says that marriage is a worldly matter, so that each land should keep its own customs in the ceremony. He insists, however, that the Church should bless it, pray for it, and adorn it, because it has God’s Word on its side and is not a human invention.9

The Confessions reflect the same distinction. The Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope (1537) observes that jurisdiction over “cases of matrimony” belonged to the bishops only “by human right,” that under Justinian “decisions concerning marriage at that time belonged to the magistrates,” and that “by divine right worldly magistrates are compelled to make these decisions if the bishops [judge unjustly or] are negligent.”10 The Treatise then names several of the Pope’s marriage laws as unjust: “the traditions concerning spiritual relationship [the prohibition of marriage between sponsors] are unjust. Unjust also is the tradition which forbids an innocent person to marry after divorce. Unjust also is the law which in general approves all clandestine and underhanded betrothals in violation of the right of parents.”11 The Reformers did not abolish impediments but pruned them back to those that Scripture and sound civil law actually support.

Later Lutheran and Anglican rites in America handled the charge in different ways. Some kept it in the service, often in the Prayer Book wording, and others left it out on the reasoning that the civil license and the pastor’s own preparation had taken the place of the banns.12 Both kinds of rite are in use today.


III. What Marriage Is, and Why an Objection Can Stop It

An estate of God’s own making

The reason an objection matters is that marriage is not ours to define. Jesus answered the Pharisees’ question about divorce by going back to the beginning: “Have you not read that he who created them from the beginning made them male and female, and said, ‘Therefore a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh’? So they are no longer two but one flesh. What therefore God has joined together, let not man separate” (Matthew 19:4–6; Genesis 2:24). Marriage is God’s institution before it is the Church’s rite or the state’s contract.

The Confessions teach the same. The Large Catechism says that God “has instituted it before all others,” and therefore married life “is no jest or presumption; but it is an excellent thing and a matter of divine seriousness.”13 Luther adds that it is “not a peculiar estate, but the most common and noblest estate, which pervades all Christendom, yea which extends through all the world.”14 The Apology grounds it in creation itself: “because this creation or divine ordinance in man is a natural right, jurists have accordingly said wisely and correctly that the union of male and female belongs to natural right.”15 Paul says that “this mystery is profound, and I am saying that it refers to Christ and the church” (Ephesians 5:32). The Apology is careful here as well. Marriage, it says, “has, moreover, God’s command; it has also promises, not indeed properly pertaining to the New Testament, but pertaining rather to the bodily life.”16

If marriage is God’s own institution, then not every union two people might wish to enter is a marriage God has joined. That is the theological ground of the charge: what God joins is His work (Matthew 19:6) and the Church cannot bless what God has forbidden. The Prayer Book says the same thing bluntly in its charge to the couple: “so many as are coupled together otherwise than God’s Word doth allow, are not joined together by God, neither is their Matrimony lawful.”17

A gift to be guarded

Although the charge looks like a piece of church law, what it protects is a gift. Luther’s own order does not end with the vows. It reads over the couple the cross that marriage carries (Genesis 3:16–19) and then the comfort God gives in it: “And God saw everything that he had made, and behold, it was very good” (Genesis 1:31), and “He who finds a wife finds a good thing and obtains favor from the LORD” (Proverbs 18:22). It then prays for them in the name of Christ, who loves His Church.18 The first marriage was God’s own gift, given and received with joy: the LORD God “brought her to the man. Then the man said, ‘This at last is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh’” (Genesis 2:22–23). The Church asks about impediments because it wants nothing to stand between a couple and that gift.

Humanly speaking, the free consent of the man and the woman is indispensable to a marriage. The Roman lawyers put it in a maxim the medieval Church adopted: Nuptias non concubitus sed consensus facit (“Not the bedding but the consent makes the marriage”).19 Medieval canon law generally held that this consent made the marriage even when it was exchanged privately. The Church forbade such clandestine (secret) marriages and punished those who made them, but it did not treat them as void.20

The Reformers objected to how that worked in practice. The Treatise counts it unjust that the old law “approves all clandestine and underhanded betrothals in violation of the right of parents,” and Luther went further, holding that secret engagements made without the parents’ knowledge should not bind at all.21 The weight they gave to parental consent belongs in part to their own time and to the civil law of their lands. However, their deeper concern still holds: marriage is a public estate, and the civil authority may rightly regulate how it is entered. My own conclusion is more modest than Luther’s. The proper Christian practice is for consent to be freely given and publicly solemnized, before witnesses and in good order, without holding that every privately contracted marriage is automatically invalid. That is why the banns mattered and why the congregation is present at all.

The couple therefore give themselves to each other before God and the witnesses, and the pastor receives their promises, publicly declares what God has joined, and blesses them. This is also why the most serious objection of all is the one that comes from the bride or the groom. If either one does not freely consent, there is no marriage to bless. A “yes” given under pressure, or a “no” swallowed out of embarrassment in front of a full church, is not the free consent the estate requires.

Public, and under two authorities

Marriage is also public, as Ruth 4 already showed. The congregation is the company of witnesses and the charge is the moment the rite asks those witnesses to do their duty.

The pastor, too, stands under two authorities at once. The Augsburg Confession teaches that “it is right for Christians… to make legal contracts… to marry a wife, to be given in marriage,” and that “Christians are necessarily bound to obey their own magistrates and laws save only when commanded to sin.”22 It also teaches that “the power of the Church and the civil power must not be confounded,” and that the Church should “not interfere with judgments concerning civil ordinances or contracts.”23 Paul writes, “Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God” (Romans 13:1). In the United States the laws of each state authorize ministers to solemnize (that is, to conduct) marriages and the pastor who officiates signs and returns the marriage license under those laws. Therefore an objection may rest on God’s law or on civil law and the pastor is accountable under both. Civil lawfulness is necessary but it is not sufficient. Because Christians obey the magistrate “save only when commanded to sin,” a pastor may decline to solemnize a union the civil law allows and God’s Word forbids.


IV. What Counts as “Just Cause”

Impediments that are real

Scripture, the Lutheran tradition, and ordinary civil law all recognize the following in some form: 1) a prior marriage still in force; 2) too close a relationship; 3) the absence of free consent; 4) legal incapacity.

The first needs the most care. “A married woman is bound by law to her husband while he lives… Accordingly, she will be called an adulteress if she lives with another man while her husband is alive” (Romans 7:2–3). The man or woman who is still legally married to someone else cannot marry again. In practice this usually means a divorce that was never finalized, a decree that cannot be produced, or a spouse in another state.

The second rests on God’s Law, which forbids marriage within certain degrees of kinship: “None of you shall approach any one of his close relatives to uncover nakedness. I am the LORD” (Leviticus 18:6, and the list that follows). Lutherans do not treat the civil laws of Moses as binding on Christians. However, Luther kept these degrees as the boundary set by natural law and dropped the many further degrees that canon law had added.24 Civil law sets its own degrees and they differ from state to state.

The third and fourth go together. Force, threat, or fraud about who a person actually is all destroy consent. So does the inability to understand what one is promising (e.g. intoxication at the time of the vows or serious mental incapacity). A party below the legal age of marriage, or a marriage the license does not cover, falls under the “Laws of this Realm.”

Causes that are not just

Just as important is what does not count. A great deal of grief in families comes from confusing disapproval with impediment. None of the following is a just cause:

  • dislike of the bride or groom, or of the families
  • the opinion that the couple are too young, too old, too hasty, or badly matched
  • the objector’s own love for one of the parties
  • a past sin of one of the parties that has been confessed and forgiven (although its consequences may remain, as below)
  • relationships the medieval law treated as impediments and the Reformers rejected, such as the “spiritual relationship” between sponsors25

A sin that has been confessed and absolved is not itself an impediment and the pastor should not allow it to be reopened in public by someone in the pews. However, absolution forgives the sin without necessarily removing its consequences. A man who has been absolved for deceiving his bride about a prior marriage may still be legally married to another woman and that is still an impediment. A man truly sorry for that deceit will not want to marry until it is set right and the pastor can help him do so. In every case the question is whether a fact stands in the way of a lawful marriage now, and not whether there is a sin in someone’s past.

A divorce in the past does not by itself keep anyone from marrying in the Church. A marriage that ended in death leaves the survivor free (Romans 7:2–3). Divorce is harder and Jesus speaks to it directly: “whoever divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality, and marries another, commits adultery” (Matthew 19:9). The Treatise counts it unjust to forbid “an innocent person to marry after divorce,” and Luther allowed remarriage in cases of adultery and desertion.26 So each divorce is a question the pastor works through with the couple in preparation, according to God’s Word, and where there has been sin it is met there with confession and absolution.

Some of the concerns in the list above may be serious and worth raising with the couple or the pastor long before the wedding. A parent may have good reason to worry and a friend may see what the couple cannot. None of them, however, is a reason why the two “may not lawfully be joined together.” The charge asks whether the marriage is lawful, not whether it is wise.

True testimony and false

A true answer that names a real impediment is not a sin. Luther forbids speaking evil of a neighbor “unless it be done by commandment or for his reformation,”27 and here the Church itself asks. Where the fact is already public, he adds, one “may also publicly testify concerning him.”28 Truth alone does not make speech right (Luther says “no matter whether it be true or false”), which is why a forgiven sin still has no place in an answer to the charge.

However, a false or malicious charge is sinful. The Eighth Commandment says, “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor” (Exodus 20:16), and Luther explains it: “We should fear and love God that we may not deceitfully belie, betray, slander, or defame our neighbor, but defend him, [think and] speak well of him, and put the best construction on everything.”29 That is why Lateran IV threatened punishment and the Prayer Book asked the objector to stand bond for his charge.

Keeping silent about a real impediment raises a different question. Luther teaches that the ordinary way to deal with a neighbor’s sin is to go to him privately first (Matthew 18:15), then with witnesses, and only then before the proper authority.30 Where it is safe to do so, the person who knows of a real impediment should speak early and privately, to the couple or to the pastor, rather than wait for the charge to be read. However, Matthew 18 concerns a brother who has sinned against us and it does not lay down a fixed procedure for every impediment to marriage. A woman who knows the groom is already married may fear what he will do if she confronts him. Someone who learns that the bride is being coerced should not be asked to go first to the one coercing her. The Eighth Commandment asks for truthful testimony given responsibly, without requiring a witness to put himself or herself in danger. In such cases the right course is to go to the pastor directly, and as early as possible. Luther allows for this himself. He says that governments, parents, and “other good friends” are “under obligation to each other to reprove evil wherever it is needful and profitable,” and that a matter may be brought “before the civil or the ecclesiastical tribunal.”31


V. When It Happens: The Pastor’s Practice in the Moment

It is unlikely the pastor will ever need what follows, so he can easily put off deciding what he would do. However, the moment itself gives him no time to think and the people present will remember how he handled it for the rest of their lives.

1. Stop and listen

The pastor should stop the service and let the person speak briefly, without arguing and without raising his voice. “Let every person be quick to hear, slow to speak, slow to anger” (James 1:19). “A soft answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger” (Proverbs 15:1). He does not need to hear the whole case at the front of the church. He only needs to know whether the person is claiming an impediment at all.

2. Do not try the case in the sanctuary

One of the worst things that can happen is for the accusation to be argued out in front of the congregation. Luther’s teaching on the Eighth Commandment gives the pastor his principle: a person is “not to be spoken of without his knowledge.”32 The matter is not aired in public before the one concerned has been heard. Jesus’ words about taking “one or two others along with you, that every charge may be established by the evidence of two or three witnesses” (Matthew 18:16; cf. Deuteronomy 19:15) are the reason the pastor brings responsible witnesses with him. In addition, the pastor at the altar is not a marriage court. The Treatise holds that the Church’s jurisdiction over marriage is only by human right and that the civil authority must judge where the church courts fail.33 His task in the moment is only to decide whether he can proceed.

In practice the pastor should say something simple to the congregation (for example, “Please remain seated. We will be back with you shortly.”) and ask the objector and the couple to step aside with him into the sacristy (the room near the front of the church where the pastor gets ready) or his study, with one or two responsible witnesses. If there is a musician, a quiet piece of music helps the congregation wait. Nothing about the substance of the objection should be said aloud in the sanctuary.

If the concern is a matter of record (an unfinished divorce, a family relationship), the parties can usually be heard together. Coercion, abuse, or threats are different and the pastor should not put everyone in the same room. He should speak with the objector and with each of the couple separately, and above all with the one who may be under pressure, away from the person who may be applying it.

3. Hear both sides and ask the one question that matters

In private (together or separately, as above) the pastor hears the objector and then the couple. “The one who states his case first seems right, until the other comes and examines him” (Proverbs 18:17). The question he is trying to answer is the one the charge asked: Is this an impediment by God’s Law or by civil law? He is deciding whether he has enough confidence to proceed lawfully and in good conscience today, which is a smaller question than the truth of the whole matter (that may take days or a court).

The pastor should ask for specifics. Who is the prior spouse, and where is the divorce decree? What is the family relationship? Who is forcing whom? Luther’s counsel applies here as well, since he asks whether the one reporting a fault has “seen it himself.”34 A vague charge (“she isn’t who you think she is,” “he shouldn’t be marrying anyone”) does not by itself establish an impediment. Vagueness alone, however, is not a reason to dismiss it. A frightened person may not be able to say at first what she knows and a vague charge may be the beginning of a real disclosure. The pastor should ask gently and give the person room to say more. If nothing more comes, he may say kindly and plainly that what he has heard is not a reason the couple may not marry.

4. Reach one of three outcomes

The objection is not a just cause. Often the objector is a former partner who is grieving or jealous, or a relative who disapproves. The pastor thanks the person for speaking, tells them that what they have raised is not a reason the couple may not marry, and asks them to return to their seat quietly or to leave. If the objector is drunk or angry, the ushers should walk him out kindly. The service then resumes. The pastor does not repeat the charge and does not explain to the congregation what was said. A brief word is enough (for example, “There is no impediment to this marriage and we will continue.”). The couple’s good name is protected and the objection is not given a second hearing in public.

The objection raises a credible concern that cannot be resolved on the spot. The objector says, with specifics and apparent knowledge, that the groom’s divorce was never finalized, or that the bride is being forced into the marriage, and the couple cannot show otherwise. Under the 1662 rubric the objector’s bond guarded against careless charges and the truth was to be tried elsewhere. The modern pastor has no such bond and no such court, so he must make the first judgment himself. It is enough that he cannot proceed with confidence, even if he is far from certain that the impediment is real. Here he should follow the wisdom of both Lateran IV and the Prayer Book and postpone the wedding until the truth is known. He cannot sign a marriage license for a union he has good reason to believe is unlawful and he should not pronounce in God’s name what he has reason to think God has not joined. He returns to the congregation and says only that the marriage will not take place today, without giving reasons. If the impediment proves false, the couple can be married quietly another day. If it proves true, everyone has been spared a far greater harm.

The objection comes from the bride or the groom. This rarely sounds like an objection. One of them may not answer the question, may say “I can’t do this,” or may say “yes” in a way that is plainly not free. Because free consent is indispensable, the pastor must not coax or pressure an answer out of anyone. He should take each of them aside separately and ask, gently and directly, whether he or she is willing. If either is not, the service ends and the pastor turns his attention to two people who are having one of the hardest days of their lives.

5. Keep order and keep people safe

A person who refuses to step aside, or who is threatening or violent, is no longer raising an objection but disturbing a service of worship. “All things should be done decently and in order” (1 Corinthians 14:40). Ushers should be asked to escort the person out and, if necessary, the police should be called. The pastor should not physically engage anyone himself. It is wise to tell the head usher before any wedding where there is known family conflict, an estranged former spouse, or a protective order.

6. Afterward

Whatever the outcome, the pastor’s word to the couple is finally the Gospel’s promise: Christ’s love for them does not depend on how this day went. A postponed wedding is not a rejected marriage. If there has been sin (deceit about a prior marriage, pressure on an unwilling partner) he calls it what it is and then speaks absolution to the one who repents. Otherwise he prays with them and stays. The one who could not say yes has not sinned by saying so and should hear that from him plainly. If there has been pressure or threat, he also makes sure that person has somewhere safe to go that night.

The objector, too, is a soul for whom Christ died. If the objection was malicious, the objector has sinned against the Eighth Commandment and needs to hear the Law and be called to repentance. If he repents, he needs to hear just as plainly that Christ’s blood covers this sin too, and the pastor will declare it forgiven. The aim is to win him back (“If he listens to you, you have gained your brother,” Matthew 18:15). Luther’s teaching on the Eighth Commandment, which asks every one “to cover up his neighbor’s sins and infirmities,” applies to the objector as much as to the couple.35 If the objection was sincere and true, the objector may have done something costly and right and deserves to be thanked. If it was sincere but mistaken, or came out of grief, the objector needs a pastor who will sit with him more than he needs a rebuke. “If anyone is caught in any transgression, you who are spiritual should restore him in a spirit of gentleness. Keep watch on yourself, lest you too be tempted” (Galatians 6:1).

The pastor should also write down, the same day, what was said, by whom, and what he decided, and keep the record with his other confidential notes. He should know ahead of time how marriage law works in his own state: whether a license expires if a wedding is postponed, what his duties are if he declines to solemnize, and to whom he should report a suspected crime such as bigamy or coercion. A short conversation with the county clerk, done once and in advance, will answer many of these questions.


VI. Before the Day: Where Objections Belong

The charge in the service was meant to be the last opportunity for an impediment to come to light. Lateran IV required public banns and the priest’s own investigation, the Prayer Book ordinarily required banns on three Sundays, and Luther published them from the pulpit. By the time the couple stood at the church door, the question had normally been asked already.

Most American congregations no longer read banns and the civil license has taken over part of their work. However, the license does not check everything and the pastor’s preparation of the couple is the nearest modern heir of the banns. The pastor should see the marriage license before the wedding day. In addition, he should ask directly about prior marriages and see the decree for any divorce. He should meet with each party alone at least once (as a matter of course, with every couple) and ask, without the other present, whether he or she is entering the marriage freely. He may also ask the couple plainly whether they know of anyone who might object, and why.

[Pastor: what you actually ask in premarital sessions, if you want to say it here.]

That private interview should make it plain that whatever is confessed there will be met with forgiveness and help. A couple who know their pastor receives such things with grace are far more likely to bring them out in the study.

A congregation that wishes to keep something of the old practice may also announce upcoming marriages in the bulletin or the prayers of the Church for a Sunday or two beforehand. Nothing in Scripture or the Confessions requires this. It does, however, recover the public character of marriage and give the congregation the chance to pray for the couple before they come to be married.

For couples and families

If you have a real concern about a marriage (you believe one of the two is still married, or is being pressured into it), call the pastor. Do it early and do it privately. He will listen, he will keep it as private as he can, and he will tell you honestly if the law requires him to report it. Please do not wait for the service.

If you are the one with doubts, or someone is pushing you to marry, tell the pastor. You may do it at any point, even on the morning of the wedding, and he will stand with you.

Couples sometimes ask whether a pastor can refuse to marry them. He can. A pastor may decline or postpone a wedding when he believes it would be unlawful under God’s Word or the civil law and he will tell you why in private. That is part of the care he owes you and it is far better done weeks before the wedding than at the altar.

If a wedding is postponed on the day, the practical questions will come quickly: the license, the reception, the guests who have traveled, the fees. Some licenses expire after a set time and may need to be renewed. Ask the church office what happens to any fees already paid. The reception is the family’s decision. The pastor will help the family decide what to tell guests and will walk with you through the rest.


VII. Should the Charge Remain in the Rite?

Pastors and congregations differ on this.

There are good reasons to keep it. It confesses that marriage is public and that the congregation are its witnesses. It gives a true impediment one more chance to come to light before vows are made in God’s name. In addition, it stands in continuity with eight centuries of Western practice and with the words most people expect to hear, and when it is paired with the charge to the couple (as in the Prayer Book) it reminds the bride and groom that they will answer to God for the truth of what they are about to promise.

There are also reasons to omit it. The banns it once concluded are gone and the pastor’s preparation now does their work. Because of the movies, the moment often draws nervous laughter, which works against the seriousness of the rite. Although a true answer is lawful testimony, the charge can also give a stage to a false or careless accusation. Lastly, Luther’s own order had no charge at the wedding itself and many Lutheran rites since have done without it.

The Formula of Concord teaches that ceremonies neither commanded nor forbidden by God’s Word may be kept or changed by the congregation of God in each place, in Christian freedom, so long as this is done in good order and without offense.36 The wording of the charge is such a matter. The congregation, through its rite and its pastor, may keep it or omit it with a good conscience. What is not free is the duty behind it. No pastor may solemnize what God’s Word forbids, whether or not the words are spoken aloud. If the charge is kept, the pastor should mean it, should have prepared the couple so that it is unlikely ever to be answered, and should know exactly what he will do if it is.

[Pastor: you put the charge back into your own wedding rite this year. A sentence or two on why, in your own words, would fit here.]


Conclusion: What This Means for Us

The charge “speak now or forever hold your peace” is the last echo of the Church’s long effort to protect two things at once: the estate of marriage, which God instituted and which belongs to Him, and the man and woman who come to enter it, whose good name God’s commandment also guards.

For the pastor this means preparation. Most of what the charge once guarded against is now caught, if it is caught at all, in the conversations he has with a couple in the weeks before they marry. It also means a settled plan. If someone does stand up, he stops, he listens, he takes the matter out of the sanctuary, he asks the one question that matters, and he either proceeds, postpones, or ends the service as the facts require. Then he speaks the Gospel to whoever needs it.

For the congregation it means remembering why they are there. They are witnesses, as the people at Bethlehem’s gate were witnesses for Boaz and Ruth, and their first duty is to pray as those people did: “May the LORD make the woman, who is coming into your house, like Rachel and Leah” (Ruth 4:11).

For the couple, and for all of us, it means that marriage is “held in honor among all” (Hebrews 13:4) because it is God’s work. The Church asks about impediments so that, when the pastor finally says “What therefore God has joined together, let not man separate,” nothing stands in the way and the couple can rest on God’s own Word. Their marriage is held by the faithfulness of Christ, who “loved the church and gave himself up for her” (Ephesians 5:25).


A Note on Citations

Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Augsburg Confession; Ap, Apology of the Augsburg Confession; Tr, Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope; SC and LC, Small and Large Catechisms; Ep and SD, the Epitome and Solid Declaration of the Formula of Concord) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Luther is quoted from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW). The Book of Common Prayer is quoted from the 1662 edition and the Fourth Lateran Council from the translation of H. J. Schroeder (1937).

Notes


Select Bibliography

Scripture and Confessions

  • The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.
  • Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
  • Kolb, Robert, and Timothy J. Wengert, eds. The Book of Concord. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000.

Luther

  • Luther, Martin. The Estate of Marriage (1522). In Luther’s Works, vol. 45. Philadelphia: Muhlenberg, 1962.
  • Luther, Martin. The Order of Marriage for Common Pastors (1529). In Luther’s Works, vol. 53. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1965.
  • Luther, Martin. On Marriage Matters (1530). In Luther’s Works, vol. 46. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1967.

Liturgical and Historical Sources

  • The Book of Common Prayer. London, 1662.
  • The Book of Common Prayer. New York: Church Hymnal Corporation, 1979.
  • Lutheran Book of Worship. Minneapolis: Augsburg, 1978.
  • Waterworth, J., trans. The Canons and Decrees of the Sacred and Oecumenical Council of Trent. London: Dolman, 1848.
  • Schroeder, H. J., trans. Disciplinary Decrees of the General Councils: Text, Translation, and Commentary. St. Louis: Herder, 1937.

Reference

  • Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. New York: S. Converse, 1828.

Footnotes

  1. Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “impediment.” ↩

  2. Fourth Lateran Council (1215), canon 51, in H. J. Schroeder, Disciplinary Decrees of the General Councils (St. Louis: Herder, 1937). ↩

  3. Ibid. ↩

  4. Book of Common Prayer (1662), “The Form of Solemnization of Matrimony,” opening rubric. ↩

  5. Ibid., the exhortation. ↩

  6. Ibid., the charge to the persons to be married. ↩

  7. Ibid., rubric following the charge. ↩

  8. Martin Luther, The Order of Marriage for Common Pastors (1529), LW 53:110–15. ↩

  9. Ibid., preface, LW 53:111. ↩

  10. Tr 77 (Triglotta). ↩

  11. Tr 78 (Triglotta). ↩

  12. The 1979 Book of Common Prayer of the Episcopal Church retains both the charge to the congregation and the charge to the couple, without the 1662 rubric on sureties. Among Lutherans, the Lutheran Book of Worship (1978) does not include the charge. ↩

  13. LC I 207–208 (Triglotta). ↩

  14. LC I 210 (Triglotta). ↩

  15. Ap XXIII 9 (Triglotta). ↩

  16. Ap XIII 14 (Triglotta). ↩

  17. Book of Common Prayer (1662), the charge to the persons to be married. ↩

  18. Luther, The Order of Marriage for Common Pastors, LW 53:113–15. ↩

  19. Ulpian, in Justinian’s Digest 50.17.30. ↩

  20. The classic statement of this view comes from the Council of Trent, which ended it for Roman Catholics in 1563: “Although it is not to be doubted, that clandestine marriages, made with the free consent of the contracting parties, are valid and true marriages, so long as the Church has not rendered them invalid… nevertheless the holy Church of God has, for reasons most just, at all times detested and prohibited such marriages.” Council of Trent, Session XXIV, Decree on the Reformation of Marriage, ch. 1 (Tametsi), trans. J. Waterworth (1848). ↩

  21. Tr 78 (Triglotta). On secret engagements made without parental consent, see Luther, On Marriage Matters (1530), LW 46:259–320, the first article. ↩

  22. AC XVI 1–2, 6–7 (Triglotta). ↩

  23. AC XXVIII 12–13 (Triglotta). ↩

  24. Luther, The Estate of Marriage (1522), LW 45:22–25. ↩

  25. Tr 78 (Triglotta). See also Luther, The Estate of Marriage, LW 45:22–30, where he sets aside the impediments of canon law that have no ground in God’s Word. ↩

  26. Tr 78 (Triglotta); Luther, The Estate of Marriage, LW 45:30–35. ↩

  27. LC I 285 (Triglotta). ↩

  28. LC I 284 (Triglotta). ↩

  29. SC I, Eighth Commandment (Triglotta). ↩

  30. LC I 276–280 (Triglotta). ↩

  31. LC I 275, 280 (Triglotta). ↩

  32. LC I 279 (Triglotta). ↩

  33. Tr 77–78 (Triglotta). ↩

  34. LC I 276 (Triglotta). ↩

  35. LC I 285 (Triglotta). ↩

  36. FC SD X 8–9; Ep X 3–4. ↩

Topics
Marriage and FamilyChurch and Ministry
Scripture
Matthew 19:6Ruth 4:9–11Ruth 4:1–8Matthew 19:4–6Genesis 2:24Ephesians 5:32Genesis 3:16–19Genesis 1:31Proverbs 18:22Genesis 2:22–23Romans 13:1Romans 7:2–3Leviticus 18:6Matthew 19:9Exodus 20:16Matthew 18:15James 1:19Proverbs 15:1Matthew 18:16Deuteronomy 19:15Proverbs 18:171 Corinthians 14:40Galatians 6:1Ruth 4:11Hebrews 13:4Ephesians 5:25
Confessions
LC IAp XXIIIAp XIIIAC XVIAC XXVIIISD XEp XSCLC

Cite this

MacDonald, Dylan. “Speak Now: When Someone Objects at a Wedding: History, Theology, and Pastoral Practice.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/speak-now-when-someone-objects-at-a-wedding/.

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.