The Fruit of the Vine
Wine, Grape Juice and the Cup of the Lord's Supper
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ?” — 1 Corinthians 10:16, ESV
I. What Is in the Cup?
On the night He was betrayed, our Lord took a cup at the Passover table and gave it to His disciples.
“And he took a cup, and when he had given thanks he gave it to them, saying, ‘Drink of it, all of you, for this is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins. I tell you I will not drink again of this fruit of the vine until that day when I drink it new with you in my Father’s kingdom.’” (Matthew 26:27–29)
Every congregation that obeys His command has to put something in that cup. For most of the Church’s history it was wine, the wine of the country, poured from the same jars that served the family table. The question of what else might be used became a live one in America in the nineteenth century. The temperance movement was fighting real misery in American homes. In 1869 a Methodist dentist named Thomas Welch found a way to keep grape juice from fermenting, so that his church could give the Lord’s Supper without alcohol. The Methodists had already been urging “the pure juice of the grape” for the Supper, and in 1916 they required it. Many other Protestant churches followed.1 Today a Lutheran who moves from one congregation to another may find a chalice of red wine at one altar, a tray of small glasses at the next, and at a third a tray with two kinds of cup (one of wine and one of juice) so that each communicant can choose.
People ask good questions about all of this. Is wine required, or is juice just as good? If a church offers both, what is the harm? Must the wine be red? May a congregation use a sweet wine, a dry one, or a wine with something added to it? Above all, what are we to do for the brother or sister who is fighting to stay sober and is afraid of the cup?
This paper gives my answers. The Church should use wine, because wine is what our Lord took and blessed, while grape juice is doubtful. A congregation should not set grape juice beside the wine as an equal choice for anyone who prefers it. Within the boundary of wine made from grapes the color and the sweetness are free and no one’s conscience should be troubled by them. The question of the cup belongs to the pastors and congregations who set the Table, and anyone who has received grape juice in good faith has not sinned. The Christian in recovery is not to be turned away from the Lord’s Table, and section VII is written to him and to his pastor.
I have written elsewhere about wine at the Christian’s own table, about drunkenness, and about the weaker brother (see Wine, Cards and Christian Liberty). That paper said in a sentence that the wine at the altar is not ours to change. This paper explains why and what follows from it.
II. What Our Lord Took and Blessed
The Gospels do not use the word “wine” in their accounts of the Supper. Jesus calls what is in the cup “this fruit of the vine” (Matthew 26:29; Mark 14:25; Luke 22:18). Those who use grape juice read the phrase as including the fresh juice of the grape. However, their strongest reason is not about words at all.
The churches that brought grape juice to the altar did it out of love for families that drink was destroying. The United Methodist Church tells the story candidly. Its teaching document on the Supper says that “the historic and ecumenical church uses wine,” and that “During the movement against beverage alcohol in the late nineteenth century, the predecessor bodies of The United Methodist Church turned to the use of unfermented grape juice. This continues to be the position of the denomination.”2 Behind that choice stands Paul’s own word, “It is good not to eat meat or drink wine or do anything that causes your brother to stumble” (Romans 14:21). If the cup can harm the brother, the argument runs, then love should change the cup.3
The argument from love is a serious one. It still has to answer what our Lord actually did. “Fruit of the vine” was not a phrase He invented for the occasion. It comes from the blessing the Jewish people said, and still say, over the cup. The Mishnah, the earliest written collection of rabbinic teaching, gives the blessing for fruit, “except for wine, over which one says, ‘Who creates the fruit of the vine.’”4 The rabbis did allow that blessing over grapes freshly squeezed at the table in their season.5 Passover, however, falls in the spring, several months after the grape harvest. Before refrigeration or pasteurization, keeping the juice of the autumn vintage from fermenting until spring was difficult and uncommon. What a family in Jerusalem ordinarily had in its jars at Passover was wine. The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod’s Commission on Theology and Church Relations put it simply in 1983: “The content of this cup was most definitely wine.”6
The New Testament assumes as much. When Paul rebukes the Corinthians for the way they were keeping the Lord’s Supper, he writes, “For in eating, each one goes ahead with his own meal. One goes hungry, another gets drunk” (1 Corinthians 11:21). The cup on those tables could make a man drunk. Paul does not answer the abuse by changing what is in the cup. He teaches the Corinthians to wait for one another, to eat their suppers at home, and to “examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup” (1 Corinthians 11:28).
The early Church kept the same practice. Justin Martyr, writing about the year 150, describes the Sunday service of the Christians in Rome, where after the prayers “there is then brought to the president of the brethren bread and a cup of wine mixed with water.”7 The water was added because that was how wine was ordinarily drunk in the ancient world. When some in the third century began to offer water alone in the cup, Cyprian of Carthage answered them that “in offering the cup, the tradition of the Lord must be observed, and that nothing must be done by us but what the Lord first did on our behalf.”8 For eighteen centuries after that the churches of East and West used wine. The dispute between Rome and the Reformation over the cup was about whether the laity should receive it, not about what was in it. Rome now permits Communion under both kinds in many circumstances, although Communion under the form of bread alone remains a normal practice there. Its law provides that Communion be given “under the form of bread alone, or under both species according to the norm of the liturgical laws, or even under the form of wine alone in a case of necessity.”9
Rome also counts fresh, unfermented grape juice (mustum) as “valid matter” for those who cannot take alcohol. It does not accept the pasteurized grape juice sold in American grocery stores.10 None of this makes juice the ordinary cup of the Church. Christ’s Word certainly includes wine. Whether it includes juice, it does not say.
III. Why Certainty Matters at the Altar
Lutherans care about this because of what we confess the Supper to be. Luther’s Large Catechism asks, “Now, what is the Sacrament of the Altar?” and answers, “It is the true body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, in and under the bread and wine which we Christians are commanded by the Word of Christ to eat and to drink.” He goes on to say that the Sacrament “is bread and wine, but not mere bread and wine, such as are ordinarily served at the table, but bread and wine comprehended in, and connected with, the Word of God.”11 The Word does the work. It is the Word of Christ that makes the bread His body and the wine His blood and the same Word tells us what He joined to His promise. “The Word must make a Sacrament of the element,” Luther writes, “else it remains a mere element.”12 The Formula of Concord describes what our Lord commanded us to do: “that in an assembly of Christians bread and wine are taken, consecrated, distributed, received, eaten, drunk, and the Lord’s death is shown forth at the same time.”13
The Supper is Christ’s testament. A man’s last will is carried out as he wrote it and his heirs do not substitute what they would have preferred. The Apology makes that argument about the cup: “But if it is not allowable to annul man’s testament, much less will it be allowable to annul the testament of Christ.” It adds that “the Church does not assume to itself the liberty to convert the ordinances of Christ into matters of indifference.”14 Luther was asked whether a sick man who could not take wine because of nausea might be given something else in its place, and his answer at table was short: “Nothing else but wine should be used.”15 When the Missouri Synod encouraged its congregations in 2001 to use only wine, it gave the reason in the language of conscience. The use of another element “brings about doubt whether the Sacrament is offered or not.”16
Grape juice in the Lord’s Supper is doubtful. Christ’s Word gives no promise for it and a pastor must not give at the altar what he cannot promise from the Word. A Christian comes to the Supper troubled by his sins and needing to hear that Christ’s blood was shed for him. The Supper is given to make him certain of that, so the pastor should not hand him a cup about which anyone has to ask whether it is what Christ appointed. I do not go further and say that a cup of juice is no Sacrament at all. The Confessions never faced that question, because grape juice that would keep was unknown in the sixteenth century. I am not willing to pronounce a verdict that the Church has not given me. These are two different questions. What a pastor ought to place on the altar is settled, because Christ’s Word tells him. What God has done at every altar where something else was placed is a judgment He has not entrusted to me, and I leave it to Him.
Therefore, wine is not one choice among several equal choices. The adiaphora, the things God has neither commanded nor forbidden, are many in the Divine Service: vestments, candles, the shape of the cup, whether the people kneel or stand.17 What Christ instituted is not among them. Where God has spoken the Church obeys, and where He has left a matter free she orders it in love. The element belongs to the first kind of question. The color and sweetness of the wine belong to the second.
What, then, of the many Christians who have received grape juice for years, some in churches that use nothing else and some at a Lutheran rail where they took the juice glass? The question of the cup belongs to those of us who set the Table and not to those who came to it. The Apology draws that line in a related case, when Rome had taken the cup away from the laity: “We indeed excuse the Church which has borne the injury… since it could not obtain both parts.”18 The same holds here by analogy. Whoever received in good faith what his church set before him did not sin. His sins are forgiven in the Gospel and the absolution and he was baptized into Christ. Those communions I leave to the Lord who gave the Supper. When he comes to an altar where wine is given, he receives Christ’s own institution with certainty.
IV. Two Cups at One Table
Many congregations now offer both wine and grape juice at every celebration, usually in individual glasses on the same tray or in separate chalices. Lutheran churches are among them. The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America teaches that “Communicants normally receive both elements, bread and wine,” and then allows that “In certain circumstances, congregations might decide to place small amounts of non-wheat bread or non-alcoholic wine or grape juice on the altar,” adding that “Such pastoral and congregational decisions are delicate.”19 The Missouri Synod’s commission acknowledged in 2025 that in some of its own congregations “wine is used by most members and grape juice is available for alcoholics and others who avoid alcohol for medical reasons.”20 They do this out of love. They want no one to stay away from the Table, they know there are alcoholics and people on medication in the pews, and they have decided that offering both is the kindest way to serve them all. I do not doubt the motive. However, I believe the practice causes more problems than it solves.
The first problem is the most important. A congregation that offers both presents two different substances as equally fitting elements of Christ’s institution. It sets a doubtful cup beside a certain one. The pastor speaks the Words of Institution once over both and every communicant is asked to choose between them without being told that the choice matters.
The second problem is what the practice teaches over time. When both are offered every Sunday, the choice can become a matter of habit or taste. A generation raised at that tray may learn that the element is whatever the communicant prefers. The ELCA’s own worship office has seen the danger. It warns that many different chalices, “if not used thoughtfully, can regard communion more as a matter of consumer choice than a common feast.”21 No one intends to teach that. A congregation is free to do many things in its worship but it ought to ask what its practice confesses.
The third problem concerns the unity of the Table, and it follows from the first. Paul writes, “Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread” (1 Corinthians 10:17). Differences in how people receive do not divide the body of Christ. Some kneel and some stand, some drink from the chalice and some from a small glass, and all receive the same body and blood. The difficulty with two cups is not that people receive in different ways but that they are offered different things. Where the element itself differs, the outward form of the Supper no longer shows that all partake of one cup of blessing.
The fourth problem is practical and it falls hardest on the very people the practice is meant to protect. Wine and juice look alike in a small glass. Those who fill the trays are faithful people doing careful work, but over many Sundays a glass of wine can end up in the juice ring, and an assisting minister holding a chalice in each hand can offer the wrong one. For a communicant who chose juice out of preference the mistake does no harm. For someone fighting to stay sober it may do great harm.
The fifth problem is privacy. The person in recovery often does not want the whole congregation to know it. When the juice ring is understood to be the alcoholic’s ring, choosing it in front of his neighbors can feel like announcing his history. Those who defend offering both answer that when many people take juice for many reasons no one is singled out. That is partly true, although it means that the protection of the few depends on the preference of the many.
Some have proposed giving de-alcoholized wine or grape juice to the whole congregation, so that everyone “expresses solidarity with those who cannot safely drink alcoholic beverages in any amount.”22 That does solve the problems of the divided tray and of privacy. With grape juice, however, it removes the certain cup from everyone in order to spare a few. De-alcoholized wine is taken up in section VII.
The better way is for the cup of the congregation to be wine, offered to all. The few who cannot drink wine should be cared for one by one, quietly, by their pastor, in the ways section VII describes. A separate cup for one person is different from the divided tray. Every cup at the altar holds wine, so no one is asked to choose between a certain cup and a doubtful one. The separate cup is not offered to the congregation as an option. The pastor gives it privately to the person who needs it and no one else need know.
V. Red or White?
Scripture does not say what color of wine was in the cup at the Last Supper, and nothing in the Words of Institution depends on it. Red wine is the most natural guess for a Passover table in Judea, and the Old Testament sometimes calls wine “the blood of grapes” (Genesis 49:11; see also Deuteronomy 32:14). Many Christians have found that red wine fits the Lord’s words, “This is my blood,” and that is a good reason to prefer it.23
However, the Sacrament is not a picture. The cup is Christ’s blood because He says so and not because it looks like blood. White wine is as truly wine as red. Luther made fun of Andreas Karlstadt, who wanted the Supper copied in every outward detail, by asking whether we must stop celebrating it until we learn “whether red or white wine was used.”24 No one can know the color, and nothing hangs on it. White wine is also easier on the altar linens.
Therefore, the color is free. The Missouri Synod’s commission wrote in 1983, “The color, type, or origin of the grape wine is a matter which Christians can select in accord with their situation,” and the ELCA says, “The wine may be white or red.”25 A congregation may prefer red for the sake of the sign or white for the sake of the linens. What it should not do is make its preference a test of faithfulness or let a quarrel over color divide it. The Formula of Concord, writing about ceremonies, asks that “no Church should condemn another because one has less or more external ceremonies not commanded by God than the other,” and the same charity applies to the color of what is poured into the cup.26
VI. Sweet or Dry, Fortified or Flavored?
The same principle answers most of the remaining questions. The cup must hold wine, and wine is the fermented juice of grapes. Within that there is a great deal of freedom. An old Roman Catholic reference work says of altar wine, “It may be white or red, weak or strong, sweet or dry,” and Lutherans can agree.27
Sweet or dry does not matter. A dry wine is one in which the yeast has turned nearly all the sugar into alcohol, while a sweet wine still has some sugar left. Both are wine. Many American congregations use a sweet wine at the altar, often a sweet red or a fortified dessert wine, while others prefer a dry table wine. The choice can be left to the pastor and the altar guild and to the custom of the congregation.
Fortified wines, such as port, sherry and many of the wines sold as altar or communion wine, are wines to which some grape brandy has been added. In some, such as port, the spirit is added during fermentation and stops it, leaving some sweetness. In others, such as most sherry, it is added after fermentation is complete and the wine stays dry. Either way the added spirit helps an opened bottle keep. Since the brandy is itself distilled from wine, the result is still the fruit of the vine and may be used with a good conscience. Rome has allowed it for well over a century. A Roman ruling of 1896 permitted spirit distilled from the grape to be added during fermentation, so long as the whole did not exceed eighteen percent alcohol.28 The caution is that fortified wines are stronger. The label tells you: a fortified wine usually runs from about fifteen to twenty percent alcohol, a table wine from about twelve to fourteen. That is worth remembering for the sake of the communicant in recovery.
Water may be mixed with the wine, as the ancient Church did. Among Lutherans it is neither required nor forbidden and it makes the cup no less wine.
Flavored wines are a different matter. Wine made from blackberries, cherries or other fruit is not the fruit of the vine. Neither is a wine cooler, a sangria, a mulled or spiced wine, or a “wine product” in which grape wine is only one ingredient among flavorings and other juices. The question is not whether such drinks are good or bad, but whether they are what our Lord took and blessed. The ordinary small additions of winemaking (a preservative, a little sugar in a sweet wine) do not make a wine something else, and no one should trouble his conscience over the label on the back of the bottle. Buy a wine made from grapes, and serve it as it comes or with water.
VII. The Christian in Recovery
The person who has fought addiction to alcohol is the one who most needs the Supper. Luther wrote that the Sacrament “is given for a daily pasture and sustenance, that faith may refresh and strengthen itself so as not to fall back in such a battle,” and he added, “If, therefore, you are heavy-laden and feel your weakness, then go joyfully to this Sacrament and obtain refreshment, consolation, and strength.”29 The Formula of Concord calls those who feel their weakness “the truly worthy guests for whom this highly venerable Sacrament [and sacred feast] has been especially instituted and appointed.”30 Few people at the rail know their weakness as well as the man or woman in recovery. The Supper is for them.
If the cup endangers you, you may receive the bread alone and you still receive Christ. The Small Catechism asks how bodily eating and drinking can do such great things, and answers, “It is not the eating and drinking, indeed, that does them, but the words which stand here, namely: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins. Which words are, beside the bodily eating and drinking, as the chief thing in the Sacrament; and he that believes these words has what they say and express, namely, the forgiveness of sins.”31 Those words are spoken to you at the rail. The body of Christ is given to you, and you are not deprived of the forgiveness promised in His Word. The Church must still keep the whole institution, in which Christ commands His people both to eat and to drink, and the bread alone should not be confused with that full administration. However, the Christian who for a serious reason receives what he is able to receive is not being refused anything by the Church. The cup is offered, and his pastor cares for him in his need. The same is true of the member with celiac disease who receives the cup and passes the host. Rome’s own law makes room for that, giving Communion “under the form of wine alone in a case of necessity.”
Some will remember that the Lutheran Confessions speak sharply against Communion in one kind. Their objection is to withholding from Christ’s people what He instituted, and the case before them was a Church that had taken the cup from all the laity by law. A pastor who arbitrarily withheld the cup from even one communicant otherwise admitted to the Sacrament would violate the same principle. The Christian who cannot drink without danger, and who asks to receive the bread alone, is a different case. When grape juice is put in the cup, the Church changes what she administers to everyone. When this Christian passes the cup, the Church still administers the Sacrament as Christ instituted it, and he receives what he can safely receive. The Smalcald Articles say “that not only one form is to be given,” and they reserve their strongest words for those who “not only omit both forms but also quite autocratically [tyrannically] prohibit, condemn, and blaspheme them as heresy.”32 The Christian in recovery who passes the cup prohibits and condemns nothing. The Apology faults Rome because, instead of “instructing consciences to whom only a part of the Sacrament could be granted,” it defended the prohibition, and that concern for troubled consciences reaches him as well.33 The Missouri Synod’s commission found Luther’s openness to Communion in one kind “difficult in view of confessional texts,” while admitting that “the Confessions do not address the extreme situation.”34 Faithful confessional Lutheran pastors and theologians have differed over how to handle such exceptional cases, and the commission’s own words show the difficulty. My conclusion is therefore a pastoral judgment and not a rule the Confessions lay down. I believe the texts, read for what they condemn, leave the person in recovery free to receive the bread alone with a good conscience.
The same commission admitted that in the hardest cases “no fully satisfactory answer” can be given.35 There is no single answer for every person in recovery. There are several faithful ways a pastor and a Christian in recovery can work out how to receive, and none of them should be chosen without that person’s consent. The choice may change as recovery goes on.
The bread alone. The communicant receives the body of Christ and passes the cup, with a quiet word to the pastor beforehand so that no one at the rail is surprised. This is the simplest way and it puts no wine of any kind in the mouth. For that reason I list it first. No one in recovery should feel that he must risk his sobriety in order to be faithful. The ELCA calls it “appropriate” for those recovering from alcoholism.36
Wine diluted with water. The pastor pours a little wine into a separate cup and adds a good deal of water, so that the alcohol in a sip is very small. There is no rule for how much water; the pastor and the communicant decide it together. The 1983 commission named this among the preferable ways. It is still wine.
Intinction. The pastor dips the edge of the host lightly in the wine. The amount of wine is very small and the commission named this as well.
De-alcoholized wine. This is wine that has been fermented in the ordinary way and then had nearly all its alcohol removed. In the United States a wine may be labeled “dealcoholized” only if it “contains less than 0.5 percent alcohol by volume.”37 The Missouri Synod’s commission concluded in 2025 that “low or non-alcoholic wines” “may be used without objection,” affirming that “only wine, of whatever alcohol content, should be used.”38 My own reasoning is this. Removing the alcohol does change the wine, and it would be foolish to pretend otherwise. However, the question is not whether the wine has been changed by processing, since every wine is processed in some way. It is whether what remains is still grape wine. De-alcoholized wine was made from grapes by fermentation and is still that wine, with one of its parts taken out. A flavored “wine product” is different, because other things have been mixed in until it is no longer simply wine. For that reason I believe de-alcoholized wine does not raise the doubt that grape juice raises. The same test applies to the label. Some makers add a little grape juice or sugar afterward, much as some ordinary wines are sweetened, and that alone does not make it something other than wine. A product that is mostly juice with a little wine in it is another matter, and the pastor should read the label with that question in mind. It may also contain a trace of alcohol, which the person in recovery should know. A pastor may keep a small separate cup of it, consecrated with the rest and given privately to the communicant who needs it. I would not make it the cup of the whole congregation. The many who can receive wine should receive it and the separate cup should be kept for those who need it.
There is a caution about the three ways that bring wine, or its taste, to the mouth. No study I could find has measured whether a sip of communion wine, a dipped host, or a cup of de-alcoholized wine at the altar leads to relapse. However, studies of non-alcoholic beer and wine in daily life have found that for people with alcohol use disorder such drinks can increase craving, and one recent study found more relapse among those who drank them, although an observational study of that kind shows an association and cannot prove that the drinks caused it.39 For some, the taste and smell of wine may be dangerous even without the alcohol. That is why the choice belongs to the person in recovery, made with the pastor and with the counsel of a sponsor and doctor. What helps one person may endanger another, and for some the bread alone will be the right way.
Grape juice. Some congregations give juice to those in recovery and to no one else. For the reasons given in sections II and III I do not counsel it, and the other ways above make it unnecessary. What section III said holds here too. Anyone who has received juice in good faith at a pastor’s direction has not sinned.
Whatever way is chosen, a few things should be true. It should be worked out privately between the Christian and the pastor and the history should go no further. It should be arranged so that no one ever has to explain himself at the rail, because the pastor and any assisting ministers already know what to do. It should respect the counsel of the sponsor and the doctor. A pastor who is himself in recovery faces the same question every time he communes and the same ways are open to him. Above all, no one in recovery should ever come to think that his illness makes him a second-class communicant. He is a forgiven sinner coming to his Lord’s Table, like everyone else at the rail.
The one who has been sober and has fallen should know that the Table is still for him. His Baptism has not been undone. He may go back to the absolution and back to the Supper as often as he falls, and his pastor will help him find the way again. The Lord who invites him says, “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28).
A word to congregations as well. Paul wrote, “It is good not to eat meat or drink wine or do anything that causes your brother to stumble” (Romans 14:21). Those words do not tell the Church to change the Supper but they do tell her to care for the brother. A congregation can guard his sobriety by training those who fill the trays and serve the cup, by marking any separate cup so that it cannot be mistaken, by having the same trusted hands prepare it, and by making sure that its fellowship never depends on alcohol.
VIII. Counsel for a Congregation
For a church council or altar guild deciding these things, my counsel comes down to this:
- Use wine made from grapes as the cup of the congregation, offered to all.
- Do not offer grape juice beside it as an equal choice for anyone who prefers it.
- Let the color, the sweetness and the brand be decided by custom, taste and practicality. Red is a fitting sign, and white is equally wine. Fortified altar wine may be used. Water may be added.
- Do not use fruit wines, flavored wines, coolers or mixed “wine products.”
- Provide for those who cannot drink wine through the pastor, privately, by diluted wine, intinction, a separately consecrated cup of de-alcoholized wine, or the bread alone.
- Train those who prepare and serve the elements, and mark any separate cup so clearly that it cannot be mistaken.
- If your congregation has offered juice and now changes, change slowly and teach first. Tell the congregation plainly that no one who received juice in good faith has sinned. Before the juice is set aside, invite anyone who has taken it for reasons of health or recovery to speak with the pastor privately, so that each one knows how he will receive.
- Teach the congregation why, so that the practice is understood as obedience to Christ’s institution and not as a rule for its own sake.
Luther faced a harder version of the seventh point in 1522, when changes to the Mass in Wittenberg had been forced on the people while he was away. He came back and preached for eight days, asking for patience with the weak. In one of those sermons he said of the Reformation, “I did nothing; the Word did it all.”40 A congregation that changes its cup can take the same counsel.
Conclusion
The question of wine and grape juice can sound like a small one, and in one sense it is. However, it touches the center of the Lutheran confession, which is that the Supper is Christ’s own testament, given by His Word to make troubled consciences certain of His forgiveness. The Church should give what He gave, wine in the cup, because she can give that with certainty. The question of the cup belongs to those of us who set the Table and not to those who came to it. Pastors and congregations answer for what they place on the altar, and grape juice should not be placed there. Those who received it in good faith have not sinned and need carry no anxiety about it. Within the boundary of wine, the Church is free to choose red or white, sweet or dry, the chalice or the glass, and she should not bind anyone’s conscience where Christ has not. For the brother or sister in recovery there are faithful ways to come to the Table without endangering their sobriety. Christ invites every one of them.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture and Confessions
- The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001.
- Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921.
Luther and the Fathers
- Cyprian. Epistle 62, “To Caecilius.” Translated by Robert Ernest Wallis. Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 5. Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing, 1886.
- Justin Martyr. First Apology. Translated by Marcus Dods and George Reith. Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1. Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing, 1885.
- Luther, Martin. Against the Heavenly Prophets in the Matter of Images and Sacraments (1525). Luther’s Works, American Edition, vol. 40. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1958.
- Luther, Martin. Eight Sermons Preached at Wittenberg in Lent, 1522. Translated by A. Steimle. In Works of Martin Luther (Philadelphia Edition), vol. 2.
Lutheran Church Statements
- Commission on Theology and Church Relations. Theology and Practice of the Lord’s Supper. St. Louis: The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, 1983.
- Commission on Theology and Church Relations. Proper Administration of the Lord’s Supper: Applying Scripture and the Confessions to Contemporary Issues. St. Louis: The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, 2025.
- Concordia Theological Seminary, Department of Systematic Theology. “The Fruit of the Vine in the Sacrament of the Altar.” Concordia Theological Quarterly 45 (1981): 77–80.
- Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. The Use of the Means of Grace. Chicago, 1997.
- Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, Worship. “What kinds of wine are used for Holy Communion?” Revised 2018.
Other Churches
- Code of Canon Law. 1983. Canons 924–925.
- Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Circular Letter on low-gluten altar breads and mustum. July 24, 2003.
- Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments. Redemptionis Sacramentum. 2004.
- Schulte, A. J. “Altar Wine.” The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 1. New York: Robert Appleton, 1907.
- United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Committee on Divine Worship. “Celiac Disease, Alcohol Intolerance, and the Church’s Pastoral Response.” 2016.
- The United Methodist Church. This Holy Mystery: A United Methodist Understanding of Holy Communion. Nashville: General Board of Discipleship, 2004.
Jewish Sources
- Mishnah Berakhot. Translated by Joshua Kulp. Sefaria.
- Talmud Bavli, Bava Batra. William Davidson Edition. Sefaria.
History, Medicine and Law
- Tait, Jennifer Woodruff. “Raise a Juice Box to the Temperance Movement.” Christian History 125 (2018).
- Caballeria, E., et al. “‘Doctor, Can I Drink an Alcohol-Free Beer?’” Nutrients 14, no. 19 (2022): 3925.
- Yokoyama, A., et al. “Self-help group participation, avoidance of nonalcoholic beer, and nonsmoking independently predict better drinking outcomes in Japanese alcohol-dependent men.” Alcohol, Clinical and Experimental Research 50, no. 2 (2026): e70227.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Compliance Policy Guide Sec. 510.400, “Dealcoholized Wine and Malt Beverages—Labeling.”
Footnotes
-
Jennifer Woodruff Tait, “Raise a Juice Box to the Temperance Movement,” Christian History 125 (2018), dates Welch’s first successful batch to 1869 and notes that the American Methodists urged “the pure juice of the grape” from 1864 and required grape juice at the Supper in 1916. See also Wine, Cards and Christian Liberty, section IV. Bible passages in this paper are quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV). The Lutheran Confessions are quoted from the English text of the Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church (St. Louis: Concordia, 1921), as transcribed at bookofconcord.org, and cited by the standard abbreviations: SC and LC (Small and Large Catechisms), Ap (Apology of the Augsburg Confession), SA (Smalcald Articles), and FC Ep and FC SD (Formula of Concord, Epitome and Solid Declaration). Paragraph numbers follow that transcription. The statements of other churches are quoted from their own published texts, named in the notes. Neither the North American Lutheran Church nor Lutheran Congregations in Mission for Christ has issued a statement on the question that I have found. ↩
-
The United Methodist Church, This Holy Mystery: A United Methodist Understanding of Holy Communion (2004), Part Two, “The Elements,” 30–31. The document adds that “The term wine is used in this document because of its biblical and historical antecedents, although United Methodists customarily serve unfermented grape juice in Holy Communion.” ↩
-
Some in the temperance era went further and taught that the wine Scripture praises was always unfermented. Wine, Cards and Christian Liberty, section IV, answers that “two-wine” reading (William Patton, Bible Wines, 1871). ↩
-
Mishnah Berakhot 6:1, trans. Joshua Kulp (Mishnah Yomit), at sefaria.org. The Hebrew attaches the blessing borei pri hagafen (“who creates the fruit of the vine”) to yayin, wine. ↩
-
Babylonian Talmud, Bava Batra 97b, William Davidson translation, at sefaria.org, where Rava rules, “A person may squeeze the juice from a cluster of grapes and then recite the sanctification of the Shabbat day over it.” The Gemara (97a) is discussing whether “wine fresh from one’s press” may be used, and in rabbinic usage “wine” could include such juice. Scripture likewise knows the fresh “new wine” (tirosh) in the cluster (Isaiah 65:8), and also that new wine could intoxicate: “whoredom, wine, and new wine, which take away the understanding” (Hosea 4:11). BDB gives tirosh as “wine, fresh or new wine, must, freshly pressed wine.” ↩
-
Commission on Theology and Church Relations, Theology and Practice of the Lord’s Supper (St. Louis: The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, May 1983), Part II, B.2.b, “The Wine,” as transcribed by Project Wittenberg. Its note adds, “‘Fruit of the vine’ is, exegetically, synonymous with wine,” citing Büchsel and Seesemann in the Theological Dictionary of the New Testament and the commentaries of Lane and Taylor on Mark. ↩
-
Justin Martyr, First Apology 65, trans. Marcus Dods and George Reith, Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1 (Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing, 1885); see also ch. 67, “bread and wine and water are brought.” ↩
-
Cyprian, Epistle 62 (63 in some editions), “To Caecilius, on the Sacrament of the Cup of the Lord,” 2, trans. Robert Ernest Wallis, Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 5 (Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing, 1886). Cyprian continues, “the blood of Christ is assuredly not water, but wine.” ↩
-
Code of Canon Law (1983), can. 925, at vatican.va. ↩
-
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Circular Letter to Presidents of the Episcopal Conferences concerning the use of low-gluten altar breads and mustum (July 24, 2003), A.3 and C.1, at vatican.va, defines mustum as “grape juice that is either fresh or preserved by methods that suspend its fermentation without altering its nature (for example, freezing).” The bishop may give permission “for an individual priest or layperson,” and it “can be granted habitually, for as long as the situation continues which occasioned the granting of permission.” Rome otherwise requires wine “natural, from the fruit of the grape, pure and incorrupt” (Redemptionis Sacramentum [2004], 50; Code of Canon Law, can. 924 §3). The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops adds, “Pasteurized grape juice in which all alcohol has been evaporated through high temperature preparations is invalid matter for Mass” (Committee on Divine Worship, “Celiac Disease, Alcohol Intolerance, and the Church’s Pastoral Response,” updated April 20, 2016). The older Roman rubrics already counted juice freshly pressed from the grape as valid matter, though gravely wrong to use (A. J. Schulte, “Altar Wine,” The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 1 [New York: Robert Appleton, 1907], citing the Missale Romanum, De Defectibus). ↩
-
LC V.8–9. ↩
-
LC V.10. ↩
-
FC SD VII.84. ↩
-
Ap XXII.2, 15. ↩
-
Martin Luther, Tischreden, winter 1542–43, recorded by Kaspar Heydenreich, WA TR 5:203, no. 5509. The question put to him was about a sick man “who could not use wine because of nausea” (qui tamen non ex nausea posset uti vino). Luther’s answer goes on to say that if wine cannot be taken, the Sacrament should be omitted (so soll mans lassen bleiben) rather than anything new introduced. The English is that of the Concordia Theological Seminary opinion “The Fruit of the Vine in the Sacrament of the Altar,” Concordia Theological Quarterly 45 (1981): 77–80, reprinted in Commission on Theology and Church Relations, Proper Administration of the Lord’s Supper (St. Louis: The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, 2025), Appendix B. ↩
-
The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, 2001 Convention, Resolution 3-16, “To Encourage Use of Only Wine,” Proceedings 141–42, reprinted in Proper Administration of the Lord’s Supper, Appendix A. The resolution encourages congregations “to use only wine for the Sacrament” and asks the seminaries for guidelines “in meeting the needs of those who feel they cannot drink wine.” ↩
-
FC Ep X.1 speaks of “ceremonies or church rites which are neither commanded nor forbidden in God’s Word.” See also Wine, Cards and Christian Liberty, section II, and Freedom and Form in Worship. ↩
-
Ap XXII.16. The sentence continues, “but the authors who maintain that the use of the entire Sacrament is justly prohibited… we do not excuse.” The Apology speaks of laity deprived of the cup, not of a changed element; I apply it by analogy. ↩
-
Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, The Use of the Means of Grace (1997), Principle 44 and Application 44C. ↩
-
Proper Administration of the Lord’s Supper, 11. The same report says, “The Synod therefore rightly opposes the substitution of pasteurized grape juice for wine in the Sacrament” (13). ↩
-
ELCA Worship, “What kinds of wine are used for Holy Communion?” (revised May 2018). The ELCA describes these answers as “useful guides” and not “the final word on the topic.” ↩
-
The same, which offers this as something that “may be preferable” in some settings. ↩
-
Proverbs warns against wine “when it is red, when it sparkles in the cup and goes down smoothly” (Proverbs 23:31), and the rabbis read the verse to mean “that red wine is considered to be of a superior quality” (Babylonian Talmud, Bava Batra 97b). ↩
-
Martin Luther, Against the Heavenly Prophets (1525), WA 18:115, translated in Luther’s Works, American Edition, vol. 40, 132–33; the English as quoted in Proper Administration of the Lord’s Supper, 32: “Since we do not know and the text does not state whether red or white wine was used, whether wheat rolls or barley bread were used, we must by reason of doubt at this point refrain from observing the Last Supper, until we become certain about it, so that we do not make any external detail differ a hairsbreadth from what Christ’s example sets forth.” The report comments, “The kind of bread and the color of wine are adiaphora.” ↩
-
Theology and Practice of the Lord’s Supper, Part II, B.2.b; The Use of the Means of Grace, Application 44A. ↩
-
FC Ep X.7; see also FC SD X.31. The article concerns ceremonies, and I apply it to the choice of wine by analogy. It goes on to require “agreement among them in doctrine and all its articles, as also in the right use of the holy Sacraments.” ↩
-
Schulte, “Altar Wine.” ↩
-
The same, citing a decision of the Holy Office of August 5, 1896: the spirit “must have been distilled from the grape,” the total alcohol “must not exceed eighteen per cent of the whole,” and “the addition must be made during the process of fermentation.” ↩
-
LC V.24, 72. ↩
-
FC SD VII.69. ↩
-
SC VI.4. ↩
-
SA III.6.2, 4. SA III.6.2–3 also refuses Rome’s argument that “under the one form there is as much as under both,” since “the one form only is not the entire ordinance and institution [made] ordained and commanded by Christ.” Article XXX of the Thirty-Nine Articles of the Church of England, “Of both kinds,” likewise protests the denial of the cup to the laity. ↩
-
Ap XXII.6. The Apology speaks of laity deprived of the cup by Rome’s prohibition; its concern applies by analogy. ↩
-
Theology and Practice of the Lord’s Supper, Part II, B.2.b: “Luther’s openness to Communion in one kinds [sic] is difficult in view of confessional texts which strongly urge the Biblical paradigm of both kinds, though the Confessions do not address the extreme situation.” The commission also mentioned “foregoing Communion for a period of time,” and said that “The counsel of completely foregoing Communion is clearly unsatisfactory.” ↩
-
The same; see also Proper Administration of the Lord’s Supper, 33. The 1983 report says that “the actions of diluting the wine with water or intinction would be preferable” and that “the substitution of grape juice raises the question of whether the Lord’s instruction is being heeded.” ↩
-
The Use of the Means of Grace, Background 44D, which adds, “While our confessions speak against Communion ‘in one form,’ their intent is to protest the practice of withholding the cup from the whole assembly.” ↩
-
U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Compliance Policy Guide Sec. 510.400, “Dealcoholized Wine and Malt Beverages—Labeling.” For tax purposes, a wine product under one-half of one percent alcohol “is not taxable as wine” (27 CFR 24.10). ↩
-
Proper Administration of the Lord’s Supper, 12 and 36. The report cites “Is ‘Non-Alcoholic Wine’ Really Wine?” Concordia Journal 17, no. 1 (1991): 4–6. ↩
-
E. Caballeria et al., “‘Doctor, Can I Drink an Alcohol-Free Beer?’ Low-Alcohol and Alcohol-Free Drinks in People with Heavy Drinking or Alcohol Use Disorders: Systematic Review of the Literature,” Nutrients 14, no. 19 (2022): 3925, which found that “Craving and desire to drink have been found to increase after the consumption of NoLo drinks in patients with AUD”; A. Yokoyama et al., “Self-help group participation, avoidance of nonalcoholic beer, and nonsmoking independently predict better drinking outcomes in Japanese alcohol-dependent men,” Alcohol, Clinical and Experimental Research 50, no. 2 (2026): e70227, an observational study of 198 men. ↩
-
Martin Luther, Eight Sermons Preached at Wittenberg in Lent, 1522, Second Sermon, trans. A. Steimle, in Works of Martin Luther (Philadelphia Edition), vol. 2. See also Wine, Cards and Christian Liberty, which quotes the Fourth Sermon. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “The Fruit of the Vine: Wine, Grape Juice and the Cup of the Lord's Supper.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/the-fruit-of-the-vine/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.