Freedom and Form in Worship
How Much Liberty Does a Congregation Have to Change Its Liturgy?
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“For you were called to freedom, brothers. Only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another.” — Galatians 5:13 (ESV)
A Note on Citations
Scripture is quoted from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise noted. The Lutheran Confessions are cited by the standard abbreviations (AC, Ap, SA, Tr, SC, LC, Ep, SD) with article and paragraph numbers as in the Tappert and Kolb–Wengert editions; quotations follow the English text of the Concordia Triglotta (1921). Where the Triglotta numbers a passage differently (chiefly the second half of Apology IV, which it prints as “Article III”), the note gives both numbers. The early fathers are quoted from the Ante-Nicene Fathers (ANF) and Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers (NPNF) series, and Luther from the American Edition of Luther’s Works (LW) unless a note names another translation. The preface and close of Luther’s German Mass are quoted in the 1911 translation of B. J. Kidd, with the place in LW 53 noted.
The Question Before Us
In Article VII of the Augsburg Confession, after confessing that the Church is the assembly of saints in which the Gospel is rightly taught and the Sacraments rightly administered, Melanchthon adds: “Nor is it necessary that human traditions, that is, rites or ceremonies, instituted by men, should be everywhere alike.”1 Our Confessions do not hand us a single required order of service.
Therefore people ask a fair question. If the Confessions do not prescribe a liturgy, how much freedom does a congregation actually have to change its worship? Some ask it hopefully. They want to know why a congregation cannot set the old forms aside and start over with something that feels more natural to the people who are here today. Others ask it anxiously. They have watched churches change their worship until nothing familiar was left and they want to know whether anything holds it in place. Both questions deserve an honest answer and the answer has to come from the same Confessions that wrote Article VII.
The Lutheran answer is that the freedom is real and that it is larger than many of us were taught. However, it is a particular kind of freedom. It is the freedom of the Gospel and the Gospel gives it for a purpose. In this paper I want to take up five questions in order: 1) What do we mean by liturgy, ceremony, and adiaphora? 2) What has God left free in our worship, and how free is it? 3) What is not free at all? 4) What limits does Christian freedom set for itself? 5) Who in a congregation exercises this freedom? Along the way we will listen to how the Reformed, the Anglican, and the Roman churches, together with the contemporary worship movement, have answered the same question. We will close by asking what all of this means for a congregation that wants to be faithful.
I. The Words Themselves
Liturgy and ceremony
We begin with the words. Webster’s defines liturgy as “all public ceremonies that belong to divine service,” and adds that among Protestants it means “the common prayer, or the formulary of public prayers.”2 The English word comes from the Greek leitourgia (“public service, ministry”), built from leitos (“public,” related to laos, “people”) and ergon (“work”). In the ancient world a leitourgia was a public service performed for the good of the city. In the New Testament the word is used of the priestly service in the temple (Luke 1:23; Hebrews 9:21), of the ministry of Christ Himself (Hebrews 8:6), and of the gifts the churches sent to the poor in Jerusalem (2 Corinthians 9:12).3 It is interesting that the New Testament uses the word for what God does through His servants as often as for what the people do, so “the work of the people” is only half the truth.
Webster’s defines a ceremony as an “outward rite; external form in religion.” A ceremony is a way of doing something in public worship: standing for the Gospel, making the sign of the cross, lighting candles, chanting the Psalm, kneeling at the rail. The ceremony is the form. It carries something and is never the thing it carries.
Adiaphora
The Lutheran Confessions use a Greek word for ceremonies that God has neither commanded nor forbidden. They call them adiaphora (singular adiaphoron), from adiaphoros (“indifferent, not differing, making no difference”). The Formula of Concord defines them as “ceremonies and church rites which are neither commanded nor forbidden in God’s Word, but are introduced into the Church with a good intention, for the sake of good order and propriety, or otherwise to maintain Christian discipline.”4
We must be careful with the word indifferent. In everyday English it can mean “unimportant” or “I do not care.” That is not what the Confessions mean. An adiaphoron is indifferent in the sense that it does not make a person righteous before God and that God has not bound the conscience to it. It may still matter a great deal for teaching, for order, and for love of the neighbor. In other words, the question of an adiaphoron is never “Does God require this?” but rather “Does this serve the Gospel and the neighbor here and now?”
Freedom
Lastly, the word freedom. Paul’s word is eleutheria (“liberty, freedom”), the condition of one who is no longer a slave.5 “For freedom Christ has set us free; stand firm therefore, and do not submit again to a yoke of slavery” (Galatians 5:1). Yet the same chapter goes on: “For you were called to freedom, brothers. Only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another” (Galatians 5:13). Christian freedom is freedom from the law as a way of earning God’s favor. It is never freedom from the neighbor. Luther famously put both halves of this into two sentences: a Christian is a perfectly free lord of all, subject to none, and a Christian is a perfectly dutiful servant of all, subject to all.6
II. The Freedom Is Real
What the Augsburg Confession and the Apology say
We should state the freedom fully before we speak of its limits. AC VII says that to the true unity of the Church “it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments,” and that human rites need not be everywhere alike.7 AC XV adds that church usages “ought to be observed which may be observed without sin, and which are profitable unto tranquillity and good order in the Church, as particular holy days, festivals, and the like.” Yet “consciences are not to be burdened, as though such observance was necessary to salvation.”8
In the Apology Melanchthon answered the Roman theologians, who had tried to distinguish between “particular” rites, which might differ, and “universal” rites, which they thought must be kept everywhere. Melanchthon refused the distinction. True unity in the Church is spiritual, he said, and “similarity of human rites, whether universal or particular, is not necessary, because the righteousness of faith is not a righteousness bound to certain traditions.”9 Then he gives one of the most memorable images in the Confessions: “just as the dissimilar length of day and night does not injure the unity of the Church, so we believe that the true unity of the Church is not injured by dissimilar rites instituted by men.”10
What Scripture says
The Apology grounds this in Paul. “Therefore let no one pass judgment on you in questions of food and drink, or with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath. These are a shadow of the things to come, but the substance belongs to Christ” (Colossians 2:16–17). Paul goes on to warn against rules that “have indeed an appearance of wisdom in promoting self-made religion and asceticism and severity to the body” (Colossians 2:23). Melanchthon explains that human traditions “are not instruments through which God moves hearts to believe, as are the divinely given Word and Sacraments.”11 Therefore they cannot be made necessary for righteousness. Jesus Himself quoted Isaiah against those who did exactly that: “in vain do they worship me, teaching as doctrines the commandments of men” (Matthew 15:9).
Romans 14 teaches the same freedom from the other side. “One person esteems one day as better than another, while another esteems all days alike. Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind” (Romans 14:5). “For the kingdom of God is not a matter of eating and drinking but of righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit” (Romans 14:17). Paul does not say that days and customs are worthless, only that Christians must not condemn one another over them.
What the Formula of Concord says
The Formula of Concord took up the question again after a bitter controversy. After Luther’s death the Augsburg and Leipzig Interims pressed Roman ceremonies back on the Lutheran lands. Some Lutheran theologians were willing to restore them to keep the peace; others refused. Article X settled the matter. It begins by confessing that genuine adiaphora “in and of themselves, are no worship of God, nor any part of it.”12 Then it states the Church’s freedom in words that every congregation should know: “the congregation of God of every place and every time has, according to its circumstances, the good right, power, and authority [in matters truly adiaphora] to change, to diminish, and to increase them, without thoughtlessness and offense, in an orderly and becoming way, as at any time it may be regarded most profitable, most beneficial, and best for [preserving] good order, [maintaining] Christian discipline … and the edification of the Church.”13 The Epitome puts it more briefly: the congregation of God in every place has the power “to change such ceremonies in such manner as may be most useful and edifying to the congregation of God.”14
The Formula also guards this freedom from both directions. It condemns those who force ceremonies on the congregation “by coercion … as necessary.” It also condemns those who abolish ceremonies “in such a manner as though it were not free to the congregation of God at any time and place to employ one or more in Christian liberty.”15 In other words, the person who says “we must keep this” and the person who says “we must get rid of this” can make the same mistake. Both turn a free thing into a law.
There is one great exception. In a “time of confession,” when enemies of the Gospel demand a ceremony as a sign that the Church has given up the truth, an adiaphoron is no longer indifferent. Then “it is no longer a question concerning adiaphora, but concerning the truth of the Gospel.”16 The Formula appeals to Paul, who circumcised Timothy freely (Acts 16:3) and yet refused to circumcise Titus when false brothers demanded it: “to them we did not yield in submission even for a moment, so that the truth of the gospel might be preserved for you” (Galatians 2:5).17 In other words, the same ceremony may be free in one situation and forbidden in another, depending on what it is being made to confess.
What the early Church did
The Confessions found this freedom in the history of the Church. The most famous example is the second-century dispute over the date of Easter. The churches of Asia kept the feast on the fourteenth day of the Jewish month, whatever day of the week it fell on, while Rome kept it on the following Sunday. When Victor of Rome tried to cut the Asian churches off from communion, Irenaeus of Lyons rebuked him in a letter Eusebius preserves. He reminded Victor that the earlier bishops of Rome had kept peace with those who observed a different day, and that when Polycarp of Smyrna visited Anicetus of Rome they could not persuade each other, “But though matters were in this shape, they communed together, and Anicetus conceded the administration of the eucharist in the church to Polycarp, manifestly as a mark of respect.” Irenaeus summed it up: “the disagreement in regard to the fast confirms the agreement in the faith.”18 The Augsburg Confession cites this very history, and the Formula of Concord closes Article X with the Latin proverb that grew out of it: Dissonantia ieiunii non dissolvit consonantiam fidei, “Disagreement in fasting does not destroy agreement in the faith.”19
Augustine gave the classic pastoral rule. His friend Januarius had asked him how to handle the different customs he found from place to place. Augustine answered that some things are commanded in Scripture, some are kept by the whole Church everywhere, and some “are different in different places and countries.” Concerning these last, “there is no better rule for the wise and serious Christian in this matter, than to conform to the practice which he finds prevailing in the Church to which it may be his lot to come.”20 Then he told a story about his mother. When Monica followed him to Milan she was troubled that the church there did not fast on Saturday as the church in Rome did. Augustine asked Ambrose, and Ambrose answered: “When I visit Rome, I fast on Saturday; when I am here, I do not fast. On the same principle, do you observe the custom prevailing in whatever Church you come to, if you desire neither to give offense by your conduct, nor to find cause of offense in another’s.”21 Our saying “When in Rome, do as the Romans do” is usually traced to this story. Augustine’s own judgment was that he had always esteemed it “as if I had received it by an oracle from heaven.”
So the freedom is real. A Lutheran congregation is not bound by divine law to a single book of worship. However, that is only half of what the Confessions teach.
III. What Is Not Free
The Word and the Sacraments
Read AC VII again. The freedom of rites is given in the same sentence that names what is not free. The Church is the assembly “in which the Gospel is rightly taught and the Sacraments are rightly administered,” and unity consists in agreement “concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments.”22 These are not ceremonies. They are the means of grace, the instruments by which the Holy Spirit creates and keeps faith (AC V). No congregation has freedom to preach another gospel (Galatians 1:8), to baptize in another name than the Triune Name (Matthew 28:19), or to celebrate the Supper in a way that departs from Christ’s institution.
The Formula of Concord is very concrete about the Supper. It confesses that the words Christ spoke at the first Supper “are still efficacious,” so that “in all places where the Supper is celebrated according to the institution of Christ, and His words are used, the body and blood of Christ are truly present, distributed, and received.”23 Therefore “the words of institution are to be publicly spoken or sung before the congregation distinctly and clearly, and should in no way be omitted,” both in obedience to Christ’s command and so that the faith of the hearers may be “excited, strengthened, and confirmed by Christ’s Word.”24 The whole action is to be kept: bread and wine taken, consecrated, distributed, received, eaten, and drunk. The companion paper One Body at Many Altars treats the presence of Christ in the Supper at length. Whatever else a congregation changes, it has no authority over the words and action that Christ Himself gave. Paul could only deliver what he had received: “For I received from the Lord what I also delivered to you” (1 Corinthians 11:23).
The shape the Church received
There is also a basic shape to Christian worship that the Church has received from its earliest days. Luke describes the first Christians: “And they devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers” (Acts 2:42). About a hundred years later Justin Martyr described a Sunday service to the Roman emperor. On the day called Sunday, he wrote, all gather together, “and the memoirs of the apostles or the writings of the prophets are read, as long as time permits; then, when the reader has ceased, the president verbally instructs, and exhorts to the imitation of these good things. Then we all rise together and pray.” Bread and wine are brought, the president “offers prayers and thanksgivings, according to his ability, and the people assent, saying Amen,” and the gifts are distributed, with portions carried by the deacons to those who are absent.25 There it is: readings, sermon, prayers, thanksgiving over the bread and cup, the people’s Amen, and communion.
The document long known as the Apostolic Tradition and attributed to Hippolytus of Rome is a disputed witness. Scholars no longer agree on its date, author, or place of origin, and it may gather material from several generations. Yet it preserves a eucharistic prayer that opens with the dialogue the Church still sings (“The Lord be with you … Lift up your hearts … Let us give thanks to the Lord”), and it allows the bishop to pray in his own words so long as what he prays is sound.26 In other words, the shape was already settled by custom (Word, then Supper, with prayer and thanksgiving) while the wording within the shape still had room for freedom. This shape is received rather than commanded, and it belongs among the things the Church keeps freely. Yet it is ancient and it teaches the Gospel, which is reason enough to love it.
Not every ceremony is an adiaphoron
The Formula adds two warnings that are often forgotten. The first is that something can be called an adiaphoron when it is not one. “When under the title and pretext of external adiaphora such things are proposed as are in principle contrary to God’s Word (although painted another color), these are not to be regarded as adiaphora.”27 A ceremony that teaches a false doctrine is not indifferent, no matter how old or how new it is. The second warning is that “useless, foolish displays, that are profitable neither for good order nor Christian discipline, nor evangelical propriety in the Church” are also “not genuine adiaphora.” In other words, the category of adiaphora does not cover everything a congregation might want to do. It covers what serves order, discipline, and the Gospel. Something done only to entertain or impress is not an adiaphoron at all.
IV. The Limits Freedom Sets for Itself
If the freedom is real, what governs its use? The Confessions do not answer with a new law. They answer with the purposes for which God gave the freedom in the first place. I find four of them.
1) Ceremonies must teach rightly
The first purpose is teaching. The Augsburg Confession says it plainly in Article XXIV: “Falsely are our churches accused of abolishing the Mass; for the Mass is retained among us, and celebrated with the highest reverence. Nearly all the usual ceremonies are also preserved, save that the parts sung in Latin are interspersed here and there with German hymns, which have been added to teach the people. For ceremonies are needed to this end alone that the unlearned be taught [what they need to know of Christ].”28 The Apology repeats the claim: “we do not abolish the Mass, but religiously maintain and defend it. For among us masses are celebrated every Lord’s Day and on the other festivals, in which the Sacrament is offered to those who wish to use it, after they have been examined and absolved. And the usual public ceremonies are observed, the series of lessons, of prayers, vestments, and other like things.” It then explains why: “ceremonies, however, ought to be observed both to teach men Scripture, and that those admonished by the Word may conceive faith and fear [of God, and obtain comfort], and thus also may pray (for these are the designs of ceremonies).”29
This is a high view of ceremony and a modest one at the same time. It is modest because ceremonies do not earn anything. The Apology rejects the idea that they “profit … ex opere operato, because they are thus performed or are looked upon.” It is high because ceremonies teach. What a congregation does every week preaches something whether we intend it or not. If the Words of Institution are hurried, the people learn that the Supper is an add-on; if the service is arranged around performers, they learn that worship is something to watch.
The early Church put this in a phrase that has become famous. In the fifth century Prosper of Aquitaine, arguing against the Pelagians, pointed out that the Church everywhere prays for unbelievers to be converted. If the Church prays for God to give faith, then faith must be God’s gift. He wrote that the rule of praying should establish the rule of believing: ut legem credendi lex statuat supplicandi.30 Today it is usually shortened to lex orandi, lex credendi (“the law of praying is the law of believing”). Prosper’s original point was narrow. He was arguing from the Church’s intercessions to the doctrine of grace. Yet the principle behind it is sound. The way the Church prays both shows and shapes what it believes.
Basil the Great made a related argument in the fourth century. When the Pneumatomachians objected to the doxology “Glory to the Father with the Son, together with the Holy Spirit,” Basil defended it by appealing to customs that had come down in the Church without being written in Scripture: the sign of the cross, facing east at prayer, the words of the eucharistic invocation, the threefold immersion in Baptism.31 We must read Basil with care. He says that the written teaching and the unwritten tradition “have the same force,” and Lutherans cannot grant that. Chemnitz, in his Examination of the Council of Trent, sorted the many things called “tradition” and gladly received the ancient rites as witnesses, while refusing to place any unwritten tradition beside Scripture as a source of doctrine.32 Yet Basil saw something true. He saw that to give up the Church’s way of praying would injure “the Gospel in its very vitals,” because the doxology carried the confession of the Trinity. When forms of worship are changed carelessly, doctrine goes with them.
This is why the Lutheran Reformation reformed the Mass rather than replacing it. Luther opened his Formula Missae of 1523 by saying that it had never been his intention “to abolish the liturgical service of God completely, but rather to purify the one that is now in use from the wretched accretions which corrupt it.”33 He removed the offertory prayers and the canon, because they spoke of the Mass as a sacrifice offered for the living and the dead, and he kept nearly everything else. In other words, he kept the shape of the historic Mass because the shape teaches the Gospel. The companion paper Catholic and Reformed shows how much else the Lutheran churches kept and why they kept it.
2) Love for the weak
The second purpose is love. Paul’s discussion of freedom in Romans 14 and 15 is dominated by the weaker brother. “As for the one who is weak in faith, welcome him, but not to quarrel over opinions” (Romans 14:1). “Therefore let us not pass judgment on one another any longer, but rather decide never to put a stumbling block or hindrance in the way of a brother” (Romans 14:13). “We who are strong have an obligation to bear with the failings of the weak, and not to please ourselves. Let each of us please his neighbor for his good, to build him up” (Romans 15:1–2). To the Corinthians he says, “But take care that this right of yours does not somehow become a stumbling block to the weak” (1 Corinthians 8:9).
The Confessions apply this directly to worship. The Epitome says that when a congregation changes ceremonies, “all frivolity and offense should be avoided, and special care should be taken to exercise forbearance towards the weak in faith.”34 The Apology goes further. It says that the abolition of traditions “has its own evils and its own questions,” because “the common people need outward discipline and instruction.” Therefore “the use of liberty is to be so controlled that the inexperienced may not be offended,” and “without a reasonable cause nothing in customary rites be changed, but that, in order to cherish harmony, such old customs be observed as can be observed without sin or without great inconvenience.”35 In other words, the burden of proof lies on the change and not on the custom.
Augustine said the same thing more than a thousand years earlier in the same letter to Januarius. If a custom is against faith or morals, it must be changed. “But mere change of custom, even though it may be of advantage in some respects, unsettles men by reason of the novelty: therefore, if it brings no advantage, it does much harm by unprofitably disturbing the Church.”36
Luther learned this lesson in Wittenberg. While he was hidden at the Wartburg in 1521 and 1522, Andreas Karlstadt and others in Wittenberg pressed ahead with sweeping changes. They abolished the Mass vestments, gave the cup to people who had not been taught, and stirred up crowds to tear down images. Luther came back to Wittenberg and preached eight sermons in the week of Invocavit Sunday, 1522. He did not say the changes were wrong in themselves. He said they were made without love and without teaching, and that the weak had been forced into things their consciences could not yet bear. Faith must come first and love must govern how faith uses its freedom. He would preach and teach and write but he would compel no one by force. “I simply taught, preached, and wrote God’s Word; otherwise I did nothing,” he said, and the Word did the work.37 Three years later, in Against the Heavenly Prophets, he answered Karlstadt at length. His complaint was that Karlstadt had turned Christian freedom into a new law. He commanded the removal of images and the abolition of the elevation as if God required it, and so he bound consciences just as the papacy had, only in the opposite direction.38
Those two lessons belong together. Changing worship to please the strong at the expense of the weak is a failure of love, and so is refusing every change when the old form has stopped teaching the Gospel.
3) Order and peace
The third purpose is order. Corinth was a congregation full of gifts and short on order, and Paul corrected it in words that have shaped Christian worship ever since: “When you come together, each one has a hymn, a lesson, a revelation, a tongue, or an interpretation. Let all things be done for building up” (1 Corinthians 14:26). “For God is not a God of confusion but of peace” (1 Corinthians 14:33). “But all things should be done decently and in order” (1 Corinthians 14:40). The Greek is euschēmonōs kai kata taxin (“decently, becomingly, and according to an arrangement”).39 Paul is asking for an order that builds up the church.
Paul also appeals to the practice of the other churches. He teaches his ways “everywhere in every church” (1 Corinthians 4:17), and against the contentious he answers, “we have no such practice, nor do the churches of God” (1 Corinthians 11:16). Corinth was not to invent its own worship as though no other church existed. The Augsburg Confession uses the same reasoning in Article XXVI. “Very many traditions are kept on our part, which conduce to good order in the Church, as the Order of Lessons in the Mass and the chief holy-days.” Yet the people are taught that such observances do not justify, “and that in such things it should not be made sin if they be omitted without offense.”40 Both halves are there: keep the order and keep consciences free.
4) Unity with the wider Church
The fourth purpose is unity. Ceremonies need not be alike everywhere, yet Christians have always found value in praying with one voice. Paul prays “that together you may with one voice glorify the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ” (Romans 15:6). The Apology, right after saying that diversity of rites does not injure unity, adds that “it is pleasing to us that, for the sake of tranquillity, universal rites be observed, just as also in the churches we willingly observe the order of the Mass, the Lord’s Day, and other more eminent festival days.”41 The Lutherans were eager to show that “there is nothing that varies from the Scriptures, or from the Church Catholic, or from the Church of Rome as known from its writers.”42 Keeping the common forms of the Western Church was part of how they made that case.
Luther’s preface to the German Mass of 1526 is the best guide here and it is often quoted only in half. He begins by begging that no one make his order “a compulsory law, or … ensnare or make captive thereby any man’s conscience; but to use it agreeably to Christian liberty.” Then he immediately turns. “As then always happens with Christian liberty, few use it for anything else than their own pleasure or profit: and not for God’s honour and the good of their neighbour.” Therefore “we must also take care that liberty be servant to love and to our neighbour. Where, then, it happens that men are offended or perplexed at such diversity of use, we are truly bound to put limits to liberty.” Since outward ordinances can serve the neighbor, “we ought in love, as St. Paul teaches, to endeavour to be of one and the same mind; and, to the best of our power, of like ways and fashion; just as all Christians have one baptism and one sacrament.”43 He did not ask all of Germany to adopt the Wittenberg order. However, he did hope that in each territory the service would be conducted in one fashion, with the towns and villages joining the city.
Why such concern? Luther answers: “above all, the Order is for the simple and for the young folk who must daily be exercised in the Scripture and God’s Word.”44 The simple learn by repetition. He made the same point in the preface to the Small Catechism, where he told pastors to choose one form of the Commandments, Creed, and Lord’s Prayer and keep it “year after year,” because “young and simple people must be taught by uniform, settled texts and forms, otherwise they easily become confused when the teacher to-day teaches them thus, and in a year some other way, as if he wished to make improvements.”45 What is true of the catechism is true of the liturgy. Those who have sung the same Kyrie, Gloria, and Agnus Dei every Sunday from childhood can often still sing them when much else has been forgotten.
Luther closed the German Mass with a warning in the other direction. If any order is misused, “it should be immediately done away with and another made,” the way Hezekiah broke the bronze serpent that God Himself had commanded (2 Kings 18:4). “Forms and Orders should be for the promotion of faith and the service of love, and not to injury of faith.”46 The form is a servant. It is to be kept because it serves and it may be changed when it no longer serves.
V. How Other Christians Have Answered
The Reformed: the regulative principle
The Reformed churches answered the question differently. The Westminster Confession of 1646 states what is called the regulative principle of worship: “the acceptable way of worshipping the true God is instituted by himself, and so limited by his own revealed will, that he may not be worshipped according to the imaginations and devices of men, or the suggestions of Satan, under any visible representation or any other way not prescribed in the Holy Scripture.”47 In other words, whatever Scripture does not command in public worship is forbidden. The older Reformed churches therefore sang only Psalms, often without instruments, and set aside the church year and most inherited ceremony. They appeal to texts such as the death of Nadab and Abihu, who “offered unauthorized fire before the LORD, which he had not commanded them” (Leviticus 10:1), and to the warning, “Everything that I command you, you shall be careful to do. You shall not add to it or take from it” (Deuteronomy 12:32).
This position deserves a fair hearing. Its concern is right: God is not to be worshiped by our inventions and the Lutherans agree that ceremonies are no part of the worship that makes us righteous (Matthew 15:9). Westminster also admits that “there are some circumstances concerning the worship of God … common to human actions and societies, which are to be ordered by the light of nature and Christian prudence.” So the Reformed do not think everything about a service is commanded. However, the Lutheran Confessions draw the line in a different place. What Scripture commands is binding; what Scripture forbids is forbidden; what Scripture neither commands nor forbids is free, to be used for teaching, order, and love. Lutherans have sometimes called this the normative principle. For the Reformed, an unprescribed ceremony is suspect until proven commanded. For the Lutheran, an ancient ceremony that teaches rightly is welcome until it is shown to teach wrongly. As we saw, the Formula even condemns those who abolish such ceremonies as though the Church were not free to use them.
Canterbury: the Book of Common Prayer
The Church of England took another path. Thomas Cranmer’s Book of Common Prayer (1549, revised 1552 and 1662) gave a whole nation one book, and Acts of Uniformity required its use. The preface “Of Ceremonies, why some be abolished, and some retained” explains the reasoning with great care. Some ceremonies were removed because they had grown so many and “so dark, that they did more confound and darken, than declare and set forth Christ’s benefits unto us.” Others were kept “for a decent order in the Church” and “because they pertain to edification.” Cranmer warned against both parties of his day: those “so addicted to their old customs” and those “so new-fangled, that they would innovate all things.” He insisted that the retained ceremonies “may be altered and changed, and therefore are not to be esteemed equal with God’s Law.”48 He also added a sentence that any Lutheran could sign: “in these our doings we condemn no other Nations, nor prescribe any thing but to our own people only.”
Article XXXIV of the Thirty-Nine Articles agrees with AC VII almost word for word: “It is not necessary that Traditions and Ceremonies be in all places one, and utterly like; for at all times they have been divers, and may be changed according to the diversities of countries, times, and men’s manners, so that nothing be ordained against God’s Word.” It also says that “every particular or national Church hath authority to ordain, change, and abolish, ceremonies or rites of the Church ordained only by man’s authority, so that all things be done to edifying.”49 Where the Anglicans differed from the Lutherans was not in principle but in the unit of decision. For Canterbury, the “particular or national Church” decides, and the individual minister may not depart from the common order. The preface puts it plainly: “The appointment of the which order pertaineth not to private men.”50 Lutheran territories often did much the same through their church orders (Kirchenordnungen). The Prayer Book’s uniformity was one way of exercising Christian freedom for the sake of order and the simple and it gave the English-speaking world some of the finest liturgical prose it has.
Rome after the Second Vatican Council
The Roman Catholic Church holds that the regulation of the liturgy “depends solely on the authority of the Church, that is, on the Apostolic See and, as laws may determine, on the bishop,” and that “no other person, even if he be a priest, may add, remove, or change anything in the liturgy on his own authority.” At the same time, the Second Vatican Council made changes many Lutherans welcomed (worship in the language of the people, a richer lectionary, a renewed place for preaching), and its constitution on the liturgy says “there must be no innovations unless the good of the Church genuinely and certainly requires them; and care must be taken that any new forms adopted should in some way grow organically from forms already existing.” It says too that “even in the liturgy, the Church has no wish to impose a rigid uniformity in matters which do not implicate the faith or the good of the whole community.”51
Where we differ is in the source of authority. Rome locates the right to order worship in the hierarchy, and finally in the Apostolic See. The Lutheran Confessions locate it in the congregation of God in each place, served by its called ministers. Yet on the question of how worship should change (slowly, organically, for real need, with care for the people), Rome after the Council and the Lutheran Confessions say much the same thing.
The contemporary worship movement
In our own day the strongest pressure to change worship has come from what is often called the church growth movement and the contemporary worship that grew up with it. James F. White traced its roots to the revival meetings of the American frontier, where worship was arranged to bring sinners to a decision.52 In the late twentieth century many congregations, Lutheran ones among them, set aside the historic liturgy for a format designed with the unchurched visitor in mind.
We should be fair here too. The concern for the outsider is a Christian concern and a Lutheran one. Luther himself said that the public services of his day were held largely for people who were “not yet believers or Christians,” and that they served as “a public allurement to faith and Christianity.”53 Paul also wanted the unbeliever who wandered into the Corinthian assembly to understand what was said (1 Corinthians 14:23–25). The language of the people and clear preaching are Reformation principles.
However, the Confessions ask the questions this paper has been asking. Does the form teach rightly? Does it center the service on the Word preached and the Sacrament given? Does it serve the weak or offend them? Does it join the congregation to the wider Church or cut it off? The deepest question is about what worship is. The Apology teaches that “faith is the latreia [divine service], which receives the benefits offered by God,” and that “by faith God wishes to be worshiped in this way, that we receive from Him those things which He promises and offers.”54 That is why Lutherans call the service the Gottesdienst, the Divine Service: God serves us before we serve Him. A form of worship designed chiefly to produce a feeling, a decision, or an experience can easily turn that around, so that worship becomes our offering to God or our product for the visitor. Then the problem lies not in the guitar or the organ but in the doctrine the form is teaching. A Lutheran congregation is free to use new music. It is not free to let the new form preach that worship is something we do to get God’s attention or a visitor’s approval.
VI. Who Decides?
The congregation and the office
If the congregation has the freedom, who exercises it? The Formula of Concord gives the right to change ceremonies to “the congregation of God of every place,” not to the individual Christian, the musician, or the pastor acting alone. Yet in the very next paragraph it names “the ministers of the Word, as the leaders of the congregation of God,” as those especially bound to confess.55
The Augsburg Confession explains the pastor’s part in Article XXVIII. “It is lawful for bishops or pastors to make ordinances that things be done orderly in the Church, not that thereby we should merit grace or make satisfaction for sins, or that consciences be bound to judge them necessary services.” Such ordinances are kept “for the sake of love and tranquillity, so far that one do not offend another, that all things be done in the churches in order, and without confusion.”56 The Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope adds a limit: ministers are not to “burden the Church with traditions,” and “the authority of any” is not to avail more than the Word of God. AC XIV says that no one should publicly teach or administer the Sacraments in the Church “unless he be regularly called.”57 The public worship of the congregation is the place where the pastor’s office is exercised most visibly, and he will give an account for it (Hebrews 13:17). Paul calls the ministers “servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God” (1 Corinthians 4:1). The companion paper The Assembly of Believers and the Office of the Ministry treats the office and the call more fully.
The line between the office and the congregation’s freedom is worth drawing plainly. By divine right the ministry of the Word and the Sacraments is committed to the office Christ instituted (AC XXVIII 21), and no vote of a congregation or a council reaches it. The ordering of what is free is a matter of human right, made for love and good order (AC XXVIII 53–55) and exercised in an orderly way. In practice, then, a Lutheran congregation orders its worship through its called pastor, who has the duty to see that the Word is rightly preached and the Sacraments rightly administered, together with the congregation and its proper councils, which have the freedom and the responsibility to order what is free. The pastor may not use the congregation’s freedom as a cover for his own preferences. The congregation may not use its freedom to override what the pastor is bound by his ordination vows to keep. Cranmer’s sentence holds for Lutherans too: no one ought “to appoint or alter any publick or common Order in Christ’s Church, except he be lawfully called and authorized thereunto.”
Freedom belongs to the Church, not to the individual
Christian freedom in worship is the freedom of the Church. It is not the right of any individual to rearrange the service each week according to his own taste. Luther’s German Mass complained of exactly this: “every one makes his own, some with a good intention and others out of conceit to introduce something new themselves.”58 A congregation that changes its service every Sunday is not exercising Christian freedom so much as surrendering it to whoever is planning the service that week. Augustine’s warning in the same letter to Januarius, about those who press such questions “with such keenness, that they think all is wrong except what they do themselves,” applies as much to the innovator as to the traditionalist.59
What This Means for Us
Let me gather up what we have heard. 1) The freedom is real: the congregation of God in every place may change, diminish, and increase its ceremonies, and no one may bind consciences to a human rite. 2) The Word purely preached and the Sacraments administered according to Christ’s institution are not free at all. 3) Freedom sets its own limits for the sake of right teaching, love for the weak, good order, and unity with the wider Church. 4) The freedom belongs to the congregation and is exercised through the pastor’s office together with the people, not by the individual worship leader.
What follows from this for a congregation that wants to be faithful? First, a congregation should change slowly. The Apology says that nothing in customary rites should be changed “without a reasonable cause.” A good reason for change is that a form has stopped teaching the Gospel or has begun to teach something false. Boredom, fashion, and the wish to look like the church down the road are not good reasons. However, slowness is not paralysis. When a form needs to change, a faithful congregation will change it.
Second, a congregation should teach before it changes. This is Luther’s lesson from the Invocavit sermons and it is the lesson Wittenberg learned at great cost. The people should understand why something is being added or removed before it happens. If a change cannot be shown to serve the Gospel and the neighbor, it should not be made. In other words, the conversation about worship is itself a chance to teach the faith.
Third, a congregation should hold fast to what Christ has given and keep the historic order freely. The Word preached and the Supper given according to Christ’s institution are not ours to change. Our churches confessed that the Sacrament is offered “every Lord’s Day and on the other festivals” to those who wish to use it (Ap XXIV 1), and we hold that up as the practice of the Lutheran Church and not as a new law. Around the Word and the Supper the Church has, for very good reasons, kept the readings, the confession of sins, the Creed, the prayers, and the blessing, though not all of them from the beginning. A corporate Confession and Absolution at the opening of the service took shape only in the late Middle Ages and the Reformation, and the Creed was sung in the Roman Mass only from the eleventh century. We keep these gladly because they teach the Gospel and we will not bind anyone’s conscience to them, for the churches do not condemn one another because one has more ceremonies and another fewer (SD X 30–31). Within that order there is room for many settings, many hymns, and many local customs. A congregation may sing new songs and old ones, chant or speak, and keep or lay aside many particular ceremonies.
Underneath all of this is the Gospel and we should end there. Our worship is not the work by which we make ourselves acceptable to God. That is why the Confessions can leave so much of it free. Christ has already made us acceptable by His death and resurrection and in the Divine Service He comes to give us what He won. He speaks His absolution, He preaches His Word, and He gives His body and blood for the forgiveness of sins. The forms are servants of that gift and the freedom is given so that the gift can reach people. A troubled conscience does not need to wonder whether it worshiped with the right ceremony. It needs to hear that Christ was “delivered up for our trespasses and raised for our justification” (Romans 4:25), and that the same Christ is present for us at His altar. That is why Paul could say both “For freedom Christ has set us free” (Galatians 5:1) and “through love serve one another” (Galatians 5:13). The freedom Christ gives is freedom for the Gospel and for the neighbor.
Soli Deo Gloria.
Notes
Select Bibliography
Scripture
The Holy Bible, English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2001. (Default translation throughout, cited as ESV.)
Lutheran Confessions
Concordia Triglotta: The Symbolical Books of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. St. Louis: Concordia, 1921. English text at bookofconcord.org.
Kolb, Robert, and Timothy J. Wengert, eds. The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000.
Tappert, Theodore G., ed. The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1959.
Early Church
Augustine. Letters 36 and 54. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 1.
Basil the Great. On the Holy Spirit. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 8.
Bradshaw, Paul F., Maxwell E. Johnson, and L. Edward Phillips. The Apostolic Tradition: A Commentary. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2002.
Eusebius. Church History. In Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 1.
Justin Martyr. First Apology. In Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1.
Prosper of Aquitaine (attrib.). Capitula Coelestini. In Heinrich Denzinger and Peter Hünermann, eds., Enchiridion Symbolorum, no. 246.
Reformation and Lutheran Orthodoxy
Chemnitz, Martin. Examination of the Council of Trent. Trans. Fred Kramer. 4 vols. St. Louis: Concordia, 1971–1986.
Kidd, B. J., ed. Documents Illustrative of the Continental Reformation. Oxford: Clarendon, 1911.
Luther, Martin. The Freedom of a Christian (1520). LW 31.
———. Eight Sermons at Wittenberg (1522). LW 51.
———. An Order of Mass and Communion for the Church at Wittenberg (1523). LW 53.
———. Against the Heavenly Prophets in the Matter of Images and Sacraments (1525). LW 40.
———. The German Mass and Order of Service (1526). LW 53.
Other Traditions
The Book of Common Prayer (1662), with the Articles of Religion (1571).
Second Vatican Council. Sacrosanctum Concilium: Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy. 1963.
The Westminster Confession of Faith (1646).
White, James F. Protestant Worship: Traditions in Transition. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1989.
Reference
Thayer, Joseph Henry. A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. New York: American Book Company, 1889.
Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language. New York: S. Converse, 1828.
Footnotes
-
AC VII 3. ↩
-
Noah Webster, An American Dictionary of the English Language (1828), s.v. “liturgy” and “ceremony.” ↩
-
Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament (New York: American Book Company, 1889), s.v. λειτουργία. ↩
-
FC SD X 1. Compare Ep X 1. ↩
-
Thayer, s.v. ἐλευθερία. ↩
-
Luther, The Freedom of a Christian (1520), LW 31:344. ↩
-
AC VII 2–3, citing Ephesians 4:5–6. ↩
-
AC XV 1–2. AC XV 3–4 adds that traditions “instituted to propitiate God, to merit grace, and to make satisfaction for sins, are opposed to the Gospel.” ↩
-
Ap VII–VIII 30–31. ↩
-
Ap VII–VIII 33. ↩
-
Ap VII–VIII 35–36, citing Colossians 2:16–17, 20–23 and Romans 14:17. ↩
-
FC SD X 8, citing Matthew 15:9. Compare Ep X 3. ↩
-
FC SD X 9. The bracketed words are in the Triglotta text; the ellipsis omits a bracketed Greek phrase. The paragraph goes on to cite Romans 14, Acts 16:3, Acts 21:26, and 1 Corinthians 9:19 on yielding to the weak. ↩
-
FC Ep X 4. ↩
-
FC SD X 27 and 30. Compare Ep X 10 and 12. ↩
-
FC Ep X 6. Compare SD X 10–16, and the rejection at SD X 28. ↩
-
FC SD X 11–13, citing Galatians 5:1, Galatians 2:4–5, Acts 16:3, Romans 14:6, and Colossians 2:16. ↩
-
Eusebius, Church History V.24.13–17, NPNF², vol. 1. The account of Victor’s attempted excommunication is at V.24.9–11. ↩
-
AC XXVI 42–44; FC SD X 31; compare Ep X 7. The Apology also discusses the early Easter controversies at Ap VII–VIII 42–44. ↩
-
Augustine, Letter 54 (to Januarius) 1.1–2.2, NPNF¹, vol. 1. The companion paper On the Frequent Reception of the Lord’s Supper draws on the same letter for what it says about the frequency of communion. ↩
-
Augustine, Letter 54.2.3, NPNF¹, vol. 1. Augustine tells the same story in Letter 36.32. ↩
-
AC VII 1–2. Compare AC V on the ministry through which the Holy Spirit works faith “where and when it pleases God, in them that hear the Gospel.” ↩
-
FC SD VII 75. SD VII 76 cites Chrysostom’s sermon on the Passion to the same effect. ↩
-
FC SD VII 79–81. On the whole action, see SD VII 83–84. ↩
-
Justin Martyr, First Apology 67, ANF, vol. 1. Compare chapters 65–66 on the Eucharist that follows Baptism. ↩
-
The Apostolic Tradition, in the eucharistic prayer that follows the ordination of a bishop and in the instruction on the bishop’s thanksgiving. See Paul F. Bradshaw, Maxwell E. Johnson, and L. Edward Phillips, The Apostolic Tradition: A Commentary (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2002), on the questions of date, authorship, and composition. ↩
-
FC SD X 5 and 7. ↩
-
AC XXIV 1–3. The bracketed words are in the Triglotta text. ↩
-
Ap XXIV 1, 3, and 5. ↩
-
Capitula Coelestini (also called the Indiculus), chapter 8, generally attributed to Prosper of Aquitaine (c. 435–442); Heinrich Denzinger and Peter Hünermann, Enchiridion Symbolorum, no. 246. The chapter argues from the Church’s prayers for unbelievers, heretics, and the impenitent that the beginning of faith is God’s gift. ↩
-
Basil, On the Holy Spirit 27.66, NPNF², vol. 8. The defense of the doxology runs through chapters 27–29. ↩
-
Martin Chemnitz, Examination of the Council of Trent, Part I, trans. Fred Kramer (St. Louis: Concordia, 1971), the Second Topic, “Concerning Traditions,” where he distinguishes eight kinds of tradition. ↩
-
Luther, An Order of Mass and Communion for the Church at Wittenberg (Formula Missae, 1523), LW 53:20. The order he kept and the parts he removed are laid out in the pages that follow. ↩
-
FC Ep X 5, citing 1 Corinthians 8:9 and Romans 14:13. ↩
-
Ap XV 49–51. The bracketed sentence about the common people is in the Triglotta text. Ap XV 52 adds that “for love’s sake we do not refuse to observe adiaphora with others.” ↩
-
Augustine, Letter 54.5.6, NPNF¹, vol. 1. ↩
-
Luther, Eight Sermons at Wittenberg (the Invocavit Sermons, 1522), LW 51:77. In the series, the first two set faith and love in order and the following ones apply them to the Mass, images, foods, and the Sacrament. ↩
-
Luther, Against the Heavenly Prophets in the Matter of Images and Sacraments (1525), LW 40. ↩
-
Thayer, s.v. εὐσχημόνως and τάξις. ↩
-
AC XXVI 40–41. ↩
-
Ap VII–VIII 33. ↩
-
AC XXI 5 (the conclusion of the first part of the Confession). ↩
-
Luther, The German Mass and Order of Service (1526), preface, in B. J. Kidd, ed., Documents Illustrative of the Continental Reformation (Oxford: Clarendon, 1911), 193–202, at the opening of the preface. Compare the translation in LW 53:61–90. ↩
-
Luther, German Mass (1526), preface, in Kidd, Documents; compare LW 53. ↩
-
SC Preface 7–8. ↩
-
Luther, German Mass (1526), close, in Kidd, Documents; compare LW 53. ↩
-
Westminster Confession of Faith XXI.1; the admission about circumstances is at I.6. ↩
-
Book of Common Prayer (1662), “Of Ceremonies, why some be abolished, and some retained.” The essay first appeared at the end of the 1549 book and was moved to the front in 1552. ↩
-
Articles of Religion (1571), Article XXXIV, “Of the Traditions of the Church.” ↩
-
Book of Common Prayer (1662), “Of Ceremonies.” Article XXXIV likewise says that whoever “through his private judgement” openly breaks the Church’s ceremonies “woundeth the consciences of the weak brethren.” ↩
-
Second Vatican Council, Sacrosanctum Concilium (1963), 22.1, 22.3, 23, and 37. ↩
-
James F. White, Protestant Worship: Traditions in Transition (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1989), on the frontier tradition. ↩
-
Luther, German Mass (1526), preface, in Kidd, Documents; compare LW 53. ↩
-
Ap IV 49. The Triglotta prints the Greek latreia with the gloss “divine service.” ↩
-
FC SD X 9–10. ↩
-
AC XXVIII 53–55, citing 1 Corinthians 11:5, 14:30, and 14:40. ↩
-
Tr 11, quoted in FC SD X 21; AC XIV. ↩
-
Luther, German Mass (1526), preface, in Kidd, Documents; compare LW 53. ↩
-
Augustine, Letter 54.2.3, NPNF¹, vol. 1. ↩
Cite this
MacDonald, Dylan. “Freedom and Form in Worship: How Much Liberty Does a Congregation Have to Change Its Liturgy?.” Given for You. https://givenforyou.org/papers/essays/freedom-and-form-in-worship/.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.