Books · The Augsburg Compass

Chapter 27—Article XXVII: Monastic Vows

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

The world says: that’s ordinary. God says: that is holy.

A mother kneels beside a crib in the middle of the night and changes a diaper. It goes unseen and unrewarded, the kind of thing no one notices. Now picture, across the same night, a monk rising in a cold chapel to chant the psalms. The world has a word for that. It calls it holy: devout, set apart, the higher path.

For centuries, and above all in the medieval West, the Church largely agreed with the world’s ranking. It taught, in effect, that there were two tiers of Christian life. There was an ordinary tier, where most believers married and worked and raised children, and there was a higher tier, the “religious” life of the monk and the nun, who left the world behind for the cloister (the enclosed life of a monastery or convent) to pursue perfection. The mother at the crib was doing something permitted; the monk in the chapel was doing something better.

Article XXVII belongs to the second half of the Augsburg Confession, the articles that name abuses in church practice and explain why the Lutherans corrected them. It is one of the longest of them and it was written to overturn that ranking. Its verdict is the reverse of the world’s. There is no “second-class” Christian and no “first-class” Christian. Every believer is called to holiness, and God is glorified as much in faithful daily vocation as in the cloister. The mother changing the diaper in faith and love is not living a lower Christianity than the monk. She is doing holy work, because God has called her to it and He is served in it.

This chapter is not an attack on monasteries. Monasticism is a serious and often beautiful tradition and we will honor it before we say a word of criticism. It is a chapter about discovering holiness in ordinary vocation, about the dignity God has hidden in the everyday callings where most of us spend our lives. The sentence to carry through it is this: holiness is not found by leaving your calling, but by faithfully living it.

A Truth Already Learned

We do not have to build the doctrine of vocation from the ground up, because we have already learned it. Chapter 16 (on Article XVI) set out the Reformation’s recovery of vocation: every lawful calling is a God-pleasing station and an arena of love for the neighbor, so that the public official, the factory worker, the parent, and the employee each serve God in their work. This chapter takes that truth as settled and asks a sharper question. If every calling is holy, why did the Reformers reject the idea of a higher spiritual state? Why did they empty the monasteries? The answer lies in the medieval doctrine of merit and in the Gospel that overturns it. Other chapters take up the neighboring questions: clerical celibacy in chapter 23, fasting in chapter 26, and the pastoral office in chapters 5 and 14. Here we keep to the vowed life and the question of two tiers.


1. What the Article Says

Article XXVII is long because the abuse it addresses was large and deeply rooted. Its claim can still be stated simply, in two movements, one negative and one positive.

The article runs to sixty-one paragraphs, too long to print here whole, and so I give its core paragraphs in the Triglotta’s wording. The first states the teaching the Reformers opposed, the second gives the reason they rejected it, and the third says where a good and perfect life is found:

Yea, they added that the monastic life not only merited righteousness before God but even greater things, because it kept not only the precepts, but also the so-called “evangelical counsels.” Thus they made men believe that the profession of monasticism was far better than Baptism, and that the monastic life was more meritorious than that of magistrates, than the life of pastors, and such like, who serve their calling in accordance with God’s commands, without any man-made services. (AC XXVII.12–13)

For every service of God, ordained and chosen of men without the commandment of God to merit justification and grace, is wicked, as Christ says Matt. 15:9: In vain do they worship Me with the commandments of men. And Paul teaches everywhere that righteousness is not to be sought from our own observances and acts of worship, devised by men, but that it comes by faith to those who believe that they are received by God into grace for Christ’s sake. (AC XXVII.36–37)

Neither did they see that God ought to be served in those commandments which He Himself has given and not in commandments devised by men. A good and perfect kind of life is that which has for it the commandment of God. (AC XXVII.57–58)

The negative movement is that monastic vows do not make a higher, meritorious life. The medieval church taught that the monastic life was a “state of perfection.” By taking the vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience, a person was thought to enter a higher way of following Christ and, in the teaching the Reformers opposed, to earn grace by it. Article XXVII denies this. No vow and no counsel merits grace or makes a Christian more acceptable to God; to trust the monastic life for that is to fall from grace (Galatians 5:4). Article XXVII is here applying the doctrine of justification (Article IV) to the cloister.

The positive movement is that holiness belongs to every calling. Against the two-tier ranking the article sets the doctrine of vocation. Christian perfection is not a special state. The Confession places it first in the fear of God and faith in Christ, then in faithful work in one’s calling (AC XXVII.49), and every believer may live it in the calling God has given. There are not two classes of Christians.

The article does not condemn monasticism wholesale. The Confession grants that the monasteries began well: “in Augustine’s time they were free associations,” and “aforetime they were schools of theology and other branches, profitable to the Church; and thence pastors and bishops were obtained” (AC XXVII.2, 15). It objects to the theology that made that life a higher, meritorious state, and to the practice of telling people their consciences were bound before God by vows, even vows that conflicted with God’s Word. The plain sense, then, is this: the monastic life is not a superior tier of Christianity; every lawful calling is holy, and no vow merits grace or binds the conscience against God’s Word.


2. Biblical Theology

Scripture knows nothing of two tiers of Christians. It calls every believer to the same holiness, dignifies ordinary work as God’s good gift, and locates “perfection” in the wholehearted love commanded of all rather than in a special state.

Remain in your calling. Paul’s steady counsel to the Corinthians is not to leave one’s station for a higher one. He writes, “Each one should remain in the condition in which he was called” (1 Corinthians 7:20, ESV). What does Paul mean by a calling? Where the ESV says “condition,” Paul’s word is klēsis (“a calling”), from the same root as “was called” (kaleō, “to call”) at the end of the verse. Thayer’s Greek Lexicon defines klēsis as “a calling, calling to,” and notes that in this verse Paul uses it “somewhat peculiarly, of the condition in which the calling finds one, whether circumcised or uncircumcised, slave or freeman.” In other words, Paul tells the Corinthians to stay where God’s call found them. The calling itself (circumcised or uncircumcised, slave or free, in Paul’s examples, and married or single in the chapter around them) is where the Christian serves God.

Ordinary work is God’s good gift. Work is neither a consequence of the Fall nor a lower estate to be escaped. God placed the man in the garden “to work it and keep it” (Genesis 2:15), so labor was part of the good creation before sin entered. The New Testament sweeps all of ordinary life into the service of God: “whether you eat or drink, or whatever you do, do all to the glory of God” (1 Corinthians 10:31); “walk in a manner worthy of the calling to which you have been called” (Ephesians 4:1).

“Perfection” is for everyone. The word that anchored the whole two-tier system was perfection. When Jesus speaks of perfection, however, He does not address a spiritual elite. “You therefore must be perfect, as your heavenly Father is perfect” (Matthew 5:48) is spoken to the whole crowd on the mountain, and it is defined by love, even love of enemies. The Greek word is teleios (“brought to its end, complete, mature”), the same word Jesus uses to the rich young man in 19:21. The perfection the Law asks is wholehearted love of God and neighbor (Matthew 22:37–40), and it is commanded of all Christians rather than offered as an optional higher path for a few. No one has a surplus beyond it, because no one, monk or mother, has yet fulfilled it. The Apology places perfection instead in faith and in growth: “perfection is growth in the fear of God, and in confidence in the mercy promised in Christ, and in devotion to one’s calling” (Ap XXVII.27).

The single life: a gift, not a higher rank. As we saw in the chapter on clergy marriage (chapter 23), Scripture honors the celibate life, but as a gift given to some (Matthew 19:11–12; “each has his own gift from God,” 1 Corinthians 7:7) and not as a higher tier of holiness. Paul says that the one who marries “does well,” and that the one who refrains “will do even better” (1 Corinthians 7:38). The “better” is that of being freer for undistracted service; it does not mean holier or more meritorious. The Apology says as much from the other side. It will not make virginity and marriage equal, and calls virginity “a more excellent gift than marriage,” yet it adds at once that “a virgin does not merit justification by virginity more than a married person” (Ap XXIII.38–39; see chapter 23). A more excellent gift is not a higher class of Christian.

The one text pressed the other way. The classic proof-text for a higher path is Jesus’ word to the rich young man: “If you would be perfect, go, sell what you possess and give to the poor… and come, follow me” (Matthew 19:21). It was this verse, heard in church, that sent Anthony into the desert, and Catholic teaching still reads it as Christ’s invitation to the counsels, while also teaching that every Christian is bound to keep the commandments. Read in context, however, this is not the founding of a two-tier ethic. Jesus exposes the one thing the young man will not surrender (his wealth, his true god) and calls him to the wholehearted discipleship required of everyone. What He asks of every disciple is to let go of whatever stands in the place of God, and for this man that was his money. The Apology adds that the perfection lies in Christ’s last words, “Follow Me,” a call that “pertains properly to that person with whom Christ there speaks,” so that “perfection with us is that every one with true faith should obey his own calling” (Ap XXVII.48–50). The passage does not end with the demand, either. “When the disciples heard this, they were greatly astonished, saying, ‘Who then can be saved?’ But Jesus looked at them and said, ‘With man this is impossible, but with God all things are possible’” (Matthew 19:25–26). Jesus answers their despair by pointing them to God, who does in Christ what no one can do for himself.

Where has God already called me to be faithful? Scripture’s answer is that He has called you right where you are, in the calling you already have, forgiven in Christ and sent to love God and your neighbor there.


3. Historical Context

The debt the Church owes. Christian monasticism arose in the deserts of Egypt in the third and fourth centuries, spread across the whole Church, and has been one of the great preserving and civilizing forces in Christian history. The monasteries kept prayer alive. They preserved and copied the Scriptures and the writings of antiquity through centuries when little else did; they founded schools and hospitals, gave hospitality to the traveler and the poor, and sent missionaries to the ends of the known world, so that whole nations were evangelized by monks. The Church owes an enormous debt to faithful monks and nuns. When the Reformers criticized the theology of the monastic life they were not despising the prayer and devotion of the cloister; many of them had lived it.

How devotion became a higher tier. The trouble came from a theology that grew up around the vows. Christian teaching had long distinguished commands binding on everyone (the precepts, such as “You shall not steal,” Exodus 20:15) from invitations meant for those who wished to go further (the counsels, such as giving away all one’s goods). Over the medieval centuries this hardened into a two-tier system. The evangelical counsels of poverty, chastity, and obedience (“evangelical” here means drawn from the Gospels, not the modern movement) came to define a distinct “state of perfection,” entered by vow. The vows were reckoned works of supererogation, a long word for doing more than God requires: deeds beyond His commands, and especially meritorious. Medieval theologians held that such merit was itself the fruit of grace. The Reformers answered that the doctrine itself, as it was taught in the schools and defended against them, made the vowed life a way of earning favor and even a surplus of merit.

The monastic profession was also taught to be “equal to Baptism,” a second baptism. Thomas Aquinas, in whom the Apology says the claim “is read” (Ap XXVII.20), meant something narrower: that a person who entered a religious order was released from the penalties still owed for past sins, as at Baptism. The Confession charges that the monks went further: “They taught that vows were equal to Baptism; they taught that by this kind of life they merited forgiveness of sins and justification before God” (AC XXVII.11). It adds, “None of these things can be denied; for they appear in their own books” (AC XXVII.14). The result was two grades of Christian: the “religious,” who pursued perfection, and everyone else, on a lower, merely permitted plane.

The Reformation, and a change in the conversation. The Reformers, many of them former monks and nuns (Luther had been an Augustinian friar), rejected this theology from the inside. Article XXVII (1530) argues that the vows do not merit grace or perfection, that the two-tier ranking is false, and that vows do not bind when they conflict with God’s Word. Many left the cloister and the Reformers defended their freedom to do so. The conversation did not stop in the sixteenth century, however. At the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965) the Roman Catholic Church itself taught, in Lumen Gentium, the universal call to holiness: all the faithful, in every state of life, “are called to the fullness of the Christian life and to the perfection of charity” (Lumen Gentium 40). The Council did not abolish the religious state. It still teaches that the counsels foster the Church’s holiness “in a special way” (Lumen Gentium 42), and that the religious state “more fully manifests” the life to come (Lumen Gentium 44). It placed that state within the one call to holiness that belongs to every Christian, however, and it denied that the religious form a middle class between clergy and laity (Lumen Gentium 43). On Rome’s own authority, then, the old two-tier framing that Article XXVII attacked has been significantly qualified, though not withdrawn.


4. Early Church Witness

The early Church’s testimony is two-sided. It gives us the founders of monasticism, whom we honor, and it gives us clear witnesses that the holiness Christ commands belongs to all Christians rather than to a spiritual elite, which is the Reformers’ point.

On the one hand stand the great monastic figures. Anthony of Egypt (whose life Athanasius wrote) drew multitudes into the desert; Basil of Caesarea gave Eastern monasticism its enduring rule; Benedict of Nursia ordered Western monastic life around prayer and work (summed up much later in the motto ora et labora, “pray and work”) in a rule of extraordinary wisdom and moderation. In their origins these were disciplined schools of devotion, freely entered, and they deserve our honor.

On the other hand, the same era bears witness that the ordinary Christian is held to the same holiness as the monk. John Chrysostom, himself an admirer and defender of monastic life, insisted from the pulpit that laypeople are bound to keep all of Christ’s commands. There is not one morality for monks and a lower one for the married and working; the difference lies in circumstance, not in the holiness required. The Reformers took up this teaching. Their claim was never that monastic devotion was worthless, but that the holiness God seeks is one and belongs to every Christian in his calling.

I want you to see that the Reformers found the same witness in the desert itself. The Apology retells a story from the lives of the hermits. When Anthony asked God how far he had progressed in his way of life, he was shown a shoemaker in Alexandria to whom he should be compared, and he found a man who “early in the morning … prayed in a few words for the entire state [that is, the whole community], and then attended to his trade” (Ap XXVII.38). “Here Anthony learned,” the Apology concludes, “that justification is not to be ascribed to the kind of life which he had entered” (Ap XXVII.38). For the same reason it says that “monasticism will be no more a state of perfection than the life of a farmer or mechanic” (Ap XXVII.37).

The Reformers did not deny monasticism’s early integrity. The developed theology of a higher, meritorious state is a later development of the medieval universities and their theologians. It is not the teaching of the desert or the early rules, which framed the monastic life as counsel, discipline, and freedom, and alongside which the Fathers insisted that the same holiness is asked of all. The same Fathers did already rank consecrated virginity above marriage (Jerome’s reading of the parable of the sower, which gave virgins the hundredfold harvest and the married the thirtyfold; Augustine, On Holy Virginity), and Rome and Orthodoxy read that ranking as ancient. What the Confession calls new is the system built on it: a “state of perfection” entered by vow, and works beyond God’s command that earn merit. It cites Jean Gerson, who “testifies that in his day it was a new saying that the monastic life is a state of perfection” (AC XXVII.60).


5. Lutheran Confessional Theology

The Lutheran teaching turns on a distinction, and I find it helpful to keep it in view through the rest of this chapter. It is the difference between choosing a disciplined form of life and claiming that such a life possesses greater spiritual merit before God. The first is a matter of Christian freedom and can be good; the second is the error. The Apology says that obedience, poverty, and celibacy (so long as the celibacy is truly chaste) are, “as exercises, adiaphora” (things neither commanded nor forbidden by God), so that “the saints can use these without impiety, just as Bernard, Franciscus [Francis of Assisi], and other holy men used them” (Ap XXVII.21). A woman who rises early every day to pray the psalms, or a family that keeps a weekly fast, is choosing a discipline and may do it to God’s glory. If either begins to think that this makes them better Christians than their neighbors, and that God owes them for it, the discipline has turned into the very error Article XXVII rejects. The neighbor who keeps no such discipline is not a lesser Christian for it.

No two tiers: the doctrine of vocation. The article’s main teaching is the truth already set out in chapter 16. Every lawful calling is a God-pleasing vocation, and holiness is faith working through love in one’s station. The Christian does not ascend to God by climbing out of ordinary life; he serves God within it. The parent, the laborer, the ruler, and the servant each stand in a calling that is holy ground, because God has placed them there and works through them for the neighbor. There is no higher Christian life than faith active in love, and it is lived in the home and the workplace as truly as in the cloister.

No merit: justification again. Beneath the vocation point lies the chief article. To make the monastic life a way of meriting grace or perfection is to lose the Gospel. Grace is given freely, for Christ’s sake, and received by faith; it is not earned by vows or counsels or works of supererogation. “You are severed from Christ, you who would be justified by the law; you have fallen away from grace” (Galatians 5:4). The Confession applies the verse directly: “To those, therefore, who want to be justified by their vows Christ is made of no effect, and they fall from grace” (AC XXVII.42). The faith that receives this grace does not have to be strong. Peter, sinking, could only cry out, “Lord, save me,” and “Jesus immediately reached out his hand and took hold of him” (Matthew 14:30–31). Christ did not wait for Peter’s faith to grow strong before He saved him. The Reformers had no quarrel with prayer or discipline, only with the merit that had been attached to them.

Baptism needs no second. The claim that the profession was “equal to Baptism” (AC XXVII.11) touched the Sacrament itself. Scripture says that “as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ” (Galatians 3:27), and that “we were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life” (Romans 6:4). A Christian who has put on Christ has nothing higher to put on. The Large Catechism therefore sends him back to the Baptism he already has: “Repentance, therefore, is nothing else than a return and approach to Baptism, that we repeat and practise what we began before, but abandoned” (LC IV.79).

When vows do, and do not, bind. The Reformers did not teach that promises may be lightly broken. God values truthfulness, and a vow freely and rightly made is to be kept; the Apology says, “we hold that lawful vows ought to be observed” (Ap XXVII.9). In what follows the Reformers were speaking of monastic vows (lifelong celibacy, poverty, and obedience to a rule), which God never commanded. They were not loosening the vow of marriage, which is made within God’s own ordinance and is to be kept. Where that promise has been broken, the vow is not made lighter, and Christ still forgives the one who repents of breaking it (1 John 1:9; see chapter 25). Of monastic vows they taught that a vow does not bind the conscience when it conflicts with God’s Word, or is impossible, or was not freely and rightly made, such as the vow of a child not yet able to judge, or a vow of celibacy by one to whom God has not given that gift. The Confession puts the principle in one line: “vows cannot annul the ordinance and commandment of God” (AC XXVII.18). It adds that the false opinions attached to the vows of its day, “that they justify, that they constitute Christian perfection,” made those vows “null and void” (AC XXVII.61). No human vow can overturn God’s commands or negate the Gospel, and God does not want an oath kept against His Word. The monk or nun bound by a vow taken before the age of judgment, or under compulsion, or a vow of celibacy beyond the gift God has given, is not bound by it before God (1 Corinthians 7:2, 9; AC XXVII.4, 27–32, 40; Ap XXVII.51).

The perfection that is open to all. In this way the article relocates “perfection,” and it defines the word itself: “Christian perfection is to fear God from the heart, and yet to conceive great faith, and to trust that for Christ’s sake we have a God who has been reconciled, to ask of God, and assuredly to expect His aid in all things that, according to our calling, are to be done; and meanwhile, to be diligent in outward good works, and to serve our calling. … It does not consist in celibacy, or in begging, or in vile apparel” (AC XXVII.49–50). In other words, perfection is to fear God and to trust Him, to believe that for Christ’s sake He is our reconciled Father, to pray to Him and expect His help in the work of our calling, and meanwhile to do that work faithfully. It is found neither in giving up marriage, nor in begging, nor in wearing a monk’s rough habit. Such perfection begins in trust and bears fruit in love. It is given to every believer and grown into in every calling. The mother and the monk are called to the one holiness, and each may live it where God has placed them.


6. Comparative Theology

On this article the traditions differ over a single question. Is there a higher Christian life, a distinct state of perfection, or is there one call to holiness lived out in many callings? As always, we honor each tradition from its own sources before drawing the Lutheran distinction.

Eastern Orthodox. In Orthodoxy, monasticism is not a peripheral option but the spiritual heart of the tradition. From the desert fathers to Mount Athos to the beloved startsy (spiritual elders), the monastic life is honored as the “angelic life,” set on the age to come, a life of prayer, fasting, and struggle against the passions, and as “a standing witness” that the Kingdom of God is not of this world. Its gifts are meant for the whole Church. When God initiates monks and nuns “into the deep mysteries of faith,” the Orthodox Church in America teaches, “this is not for their own benefit, but so that they can arise and go—to preach the word, find the lost, and bind the broken.” In Orthodox self-understanding the monastery is the center of a spirituality that all the faithful share in their measure (“the life of askesis … is of course not confined to monks”), and its labors are not counted as the monk’s achievement, for “spiritual pride in one’s accomplishments is the worst of all faults” (Essential Orthodox Christian Beliefs [2023], 143–145, 163). The rite of the Great Schema, the highest degree of the monastic profession, calls the profession a “second baptism” and speaks of the monk as cleansed from his sins, but it ascribes this to the gifts of God’s love for mankind received in repentance, not to the merit of the vow: “You are receiving a second baptism today, brother, in the abundance of the gifts of God who loves mankind, and you are cleansed of your sins and become a son of light, and Christ our God Himself rejoices with His holy angels over your repentance” (Order of the Great Schema, Euchologion to mega, ed. Spyridon Zervos [Venice: Phoenix, 1862], 208–209, translated here). Article XXVII’s charge of merit (AC XXVII.11; Ap XXVII.20) therefore does not reach this rite, though a Lutheran would not call any profession a second baptism, because Baptism lacks nothing (see §5). A Lutheran can only regard this tradition of prayer with deep respect, and has much to receive from it. Orthodoxy honors the monk as the exemplar of a way of life that its own teachers, from Chrysostom on, say the Gospel asks of every Christian. The Lutheran question is a narrow one: whether the monastic path is a higher holiness than the layperson’s, or the same holiness in a particular form.

Roman Catholic. Rome honors the consecrated life and the evangelical counsels (poverty, chastity, and obedience) as a genuine following of Christ. As noted above, the Second Vatican Council taught the universal call to holiness: all the baptized are called to the perfection of charity, and the consecrated life is a particular way of living that single call (Lumen Gentium 39–47). The Council still speaks of the counsels as fostering holiness “in a special way,” and of the religious state as manifesting heavenly goods “more fully” (Lumen Gentium 42, 44). John Paul II went further in Vita Consecrata (1996): “As a way of showing forth the Church’s holiness, it is to be recognized that the consecrated life, which mirrors Christ’s own way of life, has an objective superiority” (32). Agreement: all Christians are called to holiness, and the vowed life can be a real and fruitful devotion. Divergence: two questions remain. Is the vowed life a distinct state, in some sense a fuller or higher form of the Christian life? May the language of merit be attached to it? (Rome keeps that language, while teaching that all merit rests wholly on grace.) The gap is real, but since Vatican II it is markedly narrower than it was in 1530.

Anglican and Protestant. In England the monasteries were dissolved by the Crown under Henry VIII (1536–1541) and the Church of England’s Articles of Religion later said, “Voluntary Works besides, over, and above, God’s Commandments, which they call Works of Supererogation, cannot be taught without arrogancy and impiety” (Article XIV). The Methodist Articles of Religion, John Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine, keep the same article (Article XI). The nineteenth century then saw a revival of religious orders out of the Oxford Movement (a movement to recover the Church of England’s catholic heritage), beginning with sisterhoods in the 1840s: vowed communities living within a Reformation church that does not regard them as a higher grade of Christian. Most of Protestantism has had no monasticism at all, resting instead on the priesthood of all believers and the dignity of secular vocation, and has sometimes lost the goods of disciplined community in the process. In Lutheran lands some convents continued as evangelical foundations, without the vows of merit. There has also been a genuine Protestant recovery of intentional community (Taizé, founded in the twentieth century by a Reformed pastor, is the best known), to which we turn in §7. Across these traditions the shared conviction, which Lutherans hold too, is that the ordinary Christian’s calling is not a lower Christianity.

Where the line falls. The real dividing line is not whether one may live a disciplined or vowed life (Lutherans do not deny that freedom). It is whether such a life is a higher tier of holiness, and whether anything in it merits before God. Once that is seen, the traditions stand closer than the old polemics assumed. All confess, and Rome since Vatican II has made it central to its teaching, that the call to holiness belongs to every baptized Christian. The second question is not a small one, for wherever merit is attached to the vowed life the chief article is at stake (AC XXVII.36–37; Galatians 5:4).


7. Pastoral and Practical Significance

The two-tier instinct did not die with the Middle Ages. You may quietly believe it yourself: that the “real” Christians are the missionaries, the clergy, and the people who left good careers “for ministry,” and that your own life of ordinary work and family is, spiritually, the minor leagues. Article XXVII speaks to you. The pastoral office is a real and distinct calling, instituted by Christ for the Word and the Sacraments (chapters 5 and 14), but the pastor who holds it is not a higher grade of Christian.

The dignity of the ordinary calling. Return to the mother at the crib. The world calls her work ordinary and God calls it holy. She is loving a helpless neighbor in the calling God gave her, and through her love God Himself is caring for that child. The same is true of the farmer in his field and the nurse on her shift, and it is true of the work God has given you. Each is a station in which God has placed a person to love the neighbor and to serve Him.

Why God hides holiness in the ordinary. Why does God work this way? God delights to serve the world through ordinary people doing ordinary things in faith. When He feeds the hungry, He usually does it through a farmer and a baker and a parent at a stove; when He heals, through a doctor and a nurse; when He protects, through a judge and a police officer; when He raises children in the faith, through mothers and fathers at kitchen tables. God hides His care for the world inside the ordinary callings of ordinary people, so that the plainest work, done in faith and love, becomes the very instrument of His goodness to the neighbor. That is why the ordinary calling is holy: God is at work in it, and the one who does it in faith is already His in Christ, so that the plain work pleases Him for His Son’s sake. God has hidden extraordinary holiness inside ordinary faithfulness.

What the Reformers kept. It would be a mistake to hear all this as a rejection of discipline, community, or prayer. The Reformers rejected merit, the notion that a disciplined life earns a higher standing before God; they did not reject discipline itself. There is a real place, freely chosen, for a rule of life, for common prayer, and for intentional Christian community. The twentieth-century pastor Dietrich Bonhoeffer gathered an underground seminary community and wrote of it in Life Together, and he recovered exactly this: a shared life of prayer, confession, and service, ordered around the Word read together, and embraced freely as a gift and a support for faith. He did not treat it as a higher tier of Christianity or a way of earning grace. The same freedom is open to you if you want to order your devotion more deeply with a daily office, a covenant group, a retreat, or a rule, provided it is held as gift and not as merit and keeps bringing you back to the Word, to absolution, and to the Lord’s Supper. The Reformation removed the ladder and gave the disciplines back to the Church as gifts.

If you are troubled that your ordinary life counts for little before God, do not go looking for a higher rung; go where Christ gives Himself to you, in His Word, in your Baptism, in the absolution, and in His Supper.

Where has God already called me to be faithful? He has called you here, in the calling you already have, as His own baptized child.


8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading

8.1 Summary

Article XXVII, one of the longest of the articles on abuses, overturns a ranking the Church had long shared with the world: that the monastic life is a higher, more meritorious “state of perfection,” and ordinary Christian life a lower tier. Its verdict is that there is no “second-class” Christian and no “first-class” Christian; every believer is called to holiness, and God is glorified as much in faithful daily vocation as in the cloister.

The Church owes an enormous debt to faithful monks and nuns for preserving prayer, learning, Scripture, hospitality, missions, and charity. The objection is not to the vowed or communal life itself, but to the claim that it is a spiritually superior state, and to the theology of merit that made it so. Two correctives answer the abuse. The first is the Gospel itself, justification: no vow, counsel, or work merits grace (Galatians 5:4). The second is the doctrine of vocation (chapter 16), which gives back to ordinary life the dignity God gave it in creation. Every lawful calling is holy, and perfection is not a special state but faith in a reconciled God bearing fruit in one’s calling (AC XXVII.49–50; 1 Corinthians 7:20). The Reformers, many of them former monks, rejected the theology from the inside. They did not teach that promises may be broken lightly; they taught that a vow does not bind when it sets a person against God’s Word.

Orthodoxy, Rome (emphatically since Vatican II), and the Anglican and Protestant traditions all confess that the call to holiness belongs to every Christian; the remaining questions are whether the vowed life is a higher tier or one form of that single call, and whether any merit attaches to it, which touches the chief article itself. The Reformers rejected merit, not discipline, so a rule of life, common prayer, and intentional community may be recovered as gift (Bonhoeffer’s Life Together), never as a mark of rank. God has hidden extraordinary holiness inside ordinary faithfulness.

With Article XXIII this article forms a mirror pair. Article XXIII teaches that marriage is not an obstacle to holiness; Article XXVII teaches that ordinary vocation is not an obstacle to holiness. Together they dismantle the myth of higher and lower classes of believers, and they celebrate God’s sanctifying work in kitchens, classrooms, offices, farms, factories, hospitals, and homes. Holiness is not found by leaving your calling, but by faithfully living it.

8.2 Tables

Table 27.1—Two Callings or One? States of Perfection vs. the Doctrine of Vocation

The two-tier model (as the Reformers met it) The single-vocation model (Lutheran)
How many tiers? Two: the “religious” (higher) and the ordinary (lower) One: all Christians called to the same holiness
What is “perfection”? A state entered by the vows (poverty, chastity, obedience) Faith in a reconciled God, working through love, in every calling (AC XXVII.49–50; Galatians 5:6)
Where is holiness lived? Chiefly in the cloister, apart from the world In every lawful calling: home, work, church, and world
Do the counsels merit grace? Yes, in the theology the Reformers opposed: especially meritorious works of supererogation (Rome grounds all merit in prior grace) No: no work merits grace (justification; Galatians 5:4)
The ordinary Christian’s life Permitted, but a lower path Holy ground, where God is served in the neighbor

Sources: AC XXVII; Ap XXVII.

Table 27.2—Monasticism Across Traditions: Central, Prominent, or Absent

Tradition Place of monasticism In brief Source
Eastern Orthodox Central: the spiritual heart Monasticism as the pursuit of theosis (deification, union with God; see chapter 4); the desert, Athos, the startsy The monastic tradition; the Philokalia (a classic collection of Orthodox writings on prayer)
Roman Catholic Prominent The consecrated life and the counsels, but Vatican II teaches the universal call to holiness Lumen Gentium 39–47; CCC §§914–933; Trent, Session XXIV, canon 10; John Paul II, Vita Consecrata 32
Anglican Revived Dissolved under Henry VIII; religious orders revived in the 19th century Thirty-Nine Articles, Art. XIV; the revived religious communities (e.g., Society of St John the Evangelist, 1866)
Lutheran Largely absent Vocation instead of the cloister; some convents continued as Lutheran foundations; discipline recoverable as gift AC XXVII; Ap XXVII; Bonhoeffer, Life Together
Reformed Absent historically Taizé (founded by a Reformed pastor, now ecumenical) and Grandchamp in the 20th century Calvin, Institutes IV.13; Second Helvetic Confession 18
Anabaptist No monasticism; communal family life Married families holding goods in common (Hutterite) Riedemann, Confession of Faith

No tradition here teaches that only monastics can be holy; the difference is whether the monastic path is a higher tier or one form of the single call, and whether merit can be attached to it.

Table 27.3—The Evangelical Counsels and Their Evangelical Reappraisal

Counsel The “state of perfection” reading the Reformers opposed The evangelical reappraisal
Poverty Renouncing property merits a higher holiness Evangelical poverty “does not consist in the abandonment of property” but in not trusting in wealth (Ap XXVII.46); property is God’s gift, stewarded in love
Chastity (celibacy) The celibate state is higher and more meritorious A gift given to some for freer service (chapter 23); in the Apology’s words “a more excellent gift” (Ap XXIII.38), yet no higher rank before God and no merit (Ap XXVII.51; AC XXIII)
Obedience Submission to a rule or superior as a meritorious state All Christians owe obedience to God in their callings; freely chosen discipline is good, not meritorious (Ap XXVII.21)

Each counsel, freed from the merit-theology, becomes a gift or a freedom open to all rather than the ladder of a higher class.

8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)

  • Vocation: one’s calling or station, understood theologically.
  • Evangelical counsels: poverty, chastity, and obedience.
  • States of perfection: the religious life as a settled higher state, the framing AC XXVII rejects.
  • Works of supererogation: in medieval theology, good works beyond what God commands, held to be especially meritorious (Rome grounds all merit in grace); rejected by AC XXVII and by Article XIV of the Thirty-Nine Articles.
  • Counsels vs. precepts: the distinction between commands binding on all (precepts) and what Scripture recommends to some without commanding it (counsels; 1 Corinthians 7:25). In the medieval West it hardened into a two-tier ethic; the Confessions reject not the distinction but its use to build a higher, meritorious state (Ap XXVII.24–27).

8.4 Further reading

  • The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XXVII; Apology XXVII.
  • Gustaf Wingren, Luther on Vocation, trans. Carl C. Rasmussen (Philadelphia: Muhlenberg Press, 1957; repr. Wipf and Stock, 2004), the classic study of the doctrine of vocation.
  • Charles Arand, Robert Kolb, and James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3 (vows; vocation).
  • Martin Luther, The Judgment of Martin Luther on Monastic Vows (1521), the weighty private writing of a Reformer and background to AC XXVII (not a confessional norm).
  • The Fathers and founders, from their own texts and each represented whole (see §4): Athanasius, Life of Antony; Basil, Rules; the Rule of St. Benedict; John Chrysostom on the holiness required of all.
  • For the comparisons, from their own sources: Vatican II, Lumen Gentium 39–47 (the universal call to holiness); the Catechism of the Catholic Church §§914–933; the Thirty-Nine Articles, Article XIV; on Orthodox monasticism, Timothy Ware, The Orthodox Church, 3rd ed. (Penguin, 2015); Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Life Together (1939).
Topics
Vocation and Daily Life
Scripture
Galatians 5:41 Corinthians 7:20Genesis 2:151 Corinthians 10:31Ephesians 4:1Matthew 5:48Matthew 22:37–40Matthew 19:11–121 Corinthians 7:71 Corinthians 7:38Matthew 19:21Matthew 19:25–26Exodus 20:15Matthew 14:30–31Galatians 3:27Romans 6:41 John 1:91 Corinthians 7:2Galatians 5:61 Corinthians 7:25Matthew 15:9
Confessions
AC XXVIIAp XXVIIAp XXIIILC IVAC XXIIILC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.