Chapter 28—Article XXVIII: Ecclesiastical Power (The Power of Bishops)
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
In the old world, before instant communication, a king’s word reached distant cities through a herald. The herald would stand in the square and read the king’s decree, and his words carried real authority (to ignore the herald was to defy the king). Yet the authority was never his. He had not written the decree; he could not change a syllable of it; the moment he departed from the king’s words, he had no authority at all, only the sound of his own voice. His office was to deliver a message that belonged to someone else. He possessed authority but not ownership.
That is a picture of the authority Christ gave His Church, and losing sight of it is the abuse that Article XXVIII, the last article of the Augsburg Confession, was written to correct. Over the medieval centuries the Church’s ministers had in many ways stopped acting like heralds and started acting like kings, wielding not only the Word but the sword, and not only preaching the King’s decree but issuing decrees of their own and binding consciences to them as though they were the King’s. Article XXVIII asks the deepest question of authority: what power did Christ actually give His Church, and where does it end?
The answer is the heart of this chapter, and it is the note on which the doctrinal portion of this book will close: Christ alone is Lord of the conscience. Every authority in His Church exists to deliver His gifts, not to replace His voice. The power of the Church is the herald’s power. It is God-given and is to be honored, but it is the authority of the message, never a lordship over the people who hear it. This is not, finally, a chapter about bishops or popes. It is a chapter about your conscience, where its true Lord is found and where every human authority reaches its limit.
1. What the Article Says
Article XXVIII is long, but its argument rests on a single distinction: there are two kinds of power, and they must never be confused.
Its core paragraphs read this way in the Triglotta.
Therefore our teachers, for the comforting of men’s consciences, were constrained to show the difference between the power of the Church and the power of the sword, and taught that both of them, because of God’s commandment, are to be held in reverence and honor, as the chief blessings of God on earth. But this is their opinion, that the power of the Keys, or the power of the bishops, according to the Gospel, is a power or commandment of God, to preach the Gospel, to remit and retain sins, and to administer Sacraments. …
This power is exercised only by teaching or preaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments, according to their calling either to many or to individuals. For thereby are granted, not bodily, but eternal things, as eternal righteousness, the Holy Ghost, eternal life. These things cannot come but by the ministry of the Word and the Sacraments, as Paul says, Rom. 1:16: The Gospel is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth. Therefore, since the power of the Church grants eternal things, and is exercised only by the ministry of the Word, it does not interfere with civil government; no more than the art of singing interferes with civil government. For civil government deals with other things than does the Gospel. The civil rulers defend not minds, but bodies and bodily things against manifest injuries, and restrain men with the sword and bodily punishments in order to preserve civil justice and peace.
Therefore the power of the Church and the civil power must not be confounded. The power of the Church has its own commission to teach the Gospel and to administer the Sacraments. Let it not break into the office of another; let it not transfer the kingdoms of this world; let it not abrogate the laws of civil rulers; let it not abolish lawful obedience; let it not interfere with judgments concerning civil ordinances or contracts; let it not prescribe laws to civil rulers concerning the form of the Commonwealth. (AC XXVIII.4–5, 8–13; core paragraphs only)
I want you to see the reason the Confession gives for drawing this line at all. Its teachers did it “for the comforting of men’s consciences,” because the keys give eternal things that the sword cannot give, and those gifts come only through the Word and the Sacraments.
The power of the keys is spiritual. The God-given power of bishops (that is, of the ministry) is the power to preach the Gospel, to forgive and retain sins, to administer the Sacraments, to judge doctrine, and where necessary to exclude from the communion of the Church those who openly refuse to repent (what the old books call “the ban”). It is real authority, exercised only through the Word and never by force (John 20:21–23 and Mark 16:15, the texts AC XXVIII itself cites; compare Matthew 16:19). It is the power of a herald and a physician, not of a magistrate or a king. The Church carries keys, not swords.
The Confession puts the grant in a single sentence. By divine right there belongs to bishops “no jurisdiction except to forgive sins, to judge doctrine, to reject doctrines contrary to the Gospel, and to exclude from the communion of the Church wicked men, whose wickedness is known, and this without human force, simply by the Word” (AC XXVIII.21). It adds at once that in these things “the congregations of necessity and by divine right must obey them,” and it cites Christ’s own word: “The one who hears you hears me” (Luke 10:16, ESV; AC XXVIII.22). Only “when they teach or ordain anything against the Gospel” does God forbid that obedience (AC XXVIII.23). In other words, the herald’s word binds his hearers because it is the King’s decree, and only for as long as it is.
It is not the power of the sword. The power that governs this passing world by law, courts, and force belongs to the civil order (the two kingdoms, chapter 16). Where churchmen have held it, they have held it by human arrangement and not by the divine right of their spiritual office (AC XXVIII.19). The confusion of the two powers is the first thing the article corrects (AC XXVIII.1–3, 12–13).
Church authority may not bind the conscience beyond the Word. The second and deeper correction is that the ministry has no authority to impose new laws on the Church as necessary for salvation, or to bind consciences with human traditions (the point of chapters 15 and 26). It is deeper because the Gospel itself is at stake. Such laws make grace depend on human works, and the Confession answers that “it is necessary that the chief article of the Gospel be preserved, to wit, that we obtain grace freely by faith in Christ, and not for certain observances or acts of worship devised by men” (AC XXVIII.52). Where any authority, churchly or civil, commands what God forbids, the Christian must refuse. “We must obey God rather than men” (Acts 5:29) is the apostolic rule the Confession itself invokes against the bishops of its day (AC XXVIII.75; compare AC XVI.7).
2. Biblical Theology
What is this power? The New Testament’s word for it is exousia (“authority”). Thayer’s lexicon gives as one of its senses “the power of authority (influence) and of right,” notes that it is “spoken of the authority of an apostle,” and cites 2 Corinthians 10:8 and 13:10; under the same heading it lists “delegated authority” (Thayer’s Greek Lexicon, s.v. ἐξουσία). That is the herald’s kind of power, real and binding but received from another.
“My kingdom is not of this world.” When Christ stood before Pilate, He located His reign outside the sphere of force: “My kingdom is not of this world. If my kingdom were of this world, my servants would have been fighting” (John 18:36). The Church’s authority shares that character; it does not advance by the sword.
“Not so with you.” Christ explicitly forbade His ministers the lordly power of worldly rulers: “The kings of the Gentiles exercise lordship over them… But not so with you. Rather, let the greatest among you become as the youngest, and the leader as one who serves” (Luke 22:25–26). Authority in the Church is service, not domination, and Peter himself later pressed the same truth on the elders, who are to shepherd the flock “not domineering over those in your charge, but being examples to the flock” (1 Peter 5:2–3). The Confession turns this very text on the bishops of 1530 (AC XXVIII.76). Paul described his own apostolic authority as given “for building up and not for tearing down” (2 Corinthians 13:10; compare 10:8), and the weapons of his warfare as “not of the flesh” (2 Corinthians 10:4).
The keys, and the question of Peter. The keys are Christ’s gift, and the texts that give them are read in more than one way. The Roman Catholic Church reads Christ’s words to Peter in their fullest sense. Jesus renames Simon and says, “you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church” (Matthew 16:18), and to him He promises, “I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven” (Matthew 16:19). To Peter He says, “I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail. And when you have turned again, strengthen your brothers” (Luke 22:32), and to Peter, after the resurrection, He gives the charge, “Feed my sheep” (John 21:17). On this reading Peter receives a unique and lasting office as the rock and shepherd of the whole Church, an office continued in his successors, the bishops of Rome (CCC 552–553, 881–882).
Lutherans, with the Orthodox, raise two questions about that reading. The first is what the rock is. Many of the Fathers read the rock as Peter’s confession of Christ, or as Peter in the act of confessing Him, and the Orthodox speak of every faithful bishop as sitting in the chair of Peter, because every faithful bishop holds Peter’s confession. Melanchthon’s Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope (1537), a Lutheran confession, names Origen, Cyprian, Augustine, Hilary, Bede, and Chrysostom for this reading (Tr 27–28). Many modern scholars, Protestant as well as Catholic, take the rock to be Peter himself, and Rome’s own Catechism can also say, “On the rock of this faith confessed by St. Peter, Christ built his Church” (CCC 424). The Treatise answers that the Church is built “upon the ministry of the confession which Peter made” (Tr 25), and even a rock that is Peter confessing Christ leaves no heir by divine right in Rome.
The second is whether what was given to Peter passes by divine right to the bishop of Rome alone. Rome agrees that binding and loosing was given also to the apostles together, “united to its head” (CCC 881), so the question is whether Peter’s headship over them is a lasting office with an heir in Rome. The Lutheran answer begins from the same texts. After “tell it to the church,” Jesus says, “whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven” (Matthew 18:17–18), and in the Greek the verb is plural, spoken to all of them and not to Peter alone. On the evening of the resurrection He says to the apostles together, “If you forgive the sins of any…” (John 20:23). The Treatise holds these together: “In all these passages Peter is the representative of the entire assembly of apostles” (Tr 23); Christ gave the keys “principally and immediately to the Church” (Tr 24), that is, directly, with no one standing between; and the charge “Feed my sheep” is the charge to teach the Word, “which Peter has in common with the other apostles” (Tr 30). In Luke 22:32 Christ prays for Peter’s faith on the night Peter would deny Him, so that the restored apostle might strengthen his brothers, and the promise names no successor. Peter receives the keys as the Church’s spokesman, not as a monarch set over it.
The limit of obedience, the charter of the conscience. Scripture also sets a clear boundary on all human authority, church and civil alike. Brought before the supreme religious council of their day (the Sanhedrin) and ordered to stop preaching Christ, the apostles answered, “We must obey God rather than men” (Acts 5:29). Obedience to rightful authority is a duty, and it ends where a human command would require disobedience to God.
Whose voice finally binds my conscience? Scripture’s answer runs from Pilate’s hall to the Sanhedrin: Christ’s voice, in His Word, and no human authority beyond it.
3. Historical Context
If Christ gave His Church the keys and not the sword, how did so much of the sword come to be gathered into the hands of churchmen?
The early Church: the keys, and a collegial episcopate. The early Church exercised the power of the keys spiritually (preaching, forgiving, and, in grave cases, the ban) and governed largely by councils of bishops who shared one office. Rome held a precedence (a place of first rank among the churches), though whether that precedence was one of honor, of appeal, or of supremacy is the question that later divided East and West.
The medieval blurring, and the Reformation’s response. Over the following centuries the papacy’s precedence developed into claims of universal jurisdiction (the right to govern the whole Church), and the two powers grew entangled: bishops became temporal lords, popes crowned and deposed kings, and at the height came Boniface VIII’s bull Unam Sanctam (1302), which declared submission to the Roman pontiff necessary for salvation. AC XXVIII (1530) redraws the line (§1). The Treatise, a confessional document in its own right and the essential companion to this article, answers the papacy’s claims from Scripture, history, and reason (§5).
Rome’s later definitions, read from Rome itself. The Council of Florence (1439) had already ascribed to the Roman pontiff full power to tend, rule, and govern the whole Church. The papacy’s fullest definitions came after the Reformation, at the First Vatican Council (1870) and the Second (1964), and §6 sets them out. The Reformers of 1530 never saw them; their quarrel was with the papacy of their own day. Rome today puts the necessity that Unam Sanctam asserted in different terms. The Second Vatican Council teaches that a person cannot be saved who knows that Christ made the Catholic Church necessary and still refuses to enter it or remain in it (Lumen Gentium 14). It recognizes baptized Christians outside its visible communion as in communion with it, though an imperfect one (Lumen Gentium 15; Unitatis Redintegratio 3).
4. Early Church Witness
Cyprian (c. 250), in On the Unity of the Church, grounds the Church’s unity in the shared episcopate: the bishops hold one office together, for “the episcopate is one, each part of which is held by each one for the whole.” Peter appears as a symbol of that unity. His text survives in two versions, which scholars call recensions, and most now think Cyprian wrote both. In one he adds that “the rest of the apostles were also the same as was Peter, endowed with a like partnership both of honour and power”; in the other, that “the primacy is given to Peter.” Neither meant a Roman jurisdiction over other bishops for Cyprian himself, who resisted Pope Stephen over the rebaptism of heretics.
Gregory the Great (bishop of Rome c. 590–604) refused the title “universal bishop” when the bishop of Constantinople took it and rebuked its use as a mark of pride. Gregory did not deny Rome’s precedence; in his letters he treats even the see of Constantinople as subject to the Apostolic See. He refused any title that made one bishop the bishop of all.
Jerome (c. 400) held that presbyter (elder, the office we would call pastor) and bishop were originally one order, and that the elevation of the bishop was a matter of the Church’s arrangement for good order rather than a distinct divine institution. His view bears on the Reformers’ point that the form of church government is, in large part, a human arrangement (chapter 14), and the Treatise itself cites Jerome for this point (Tr 62–65).
Rome has its own witnesses among the Fathers. Irenaeus (c. 180) wrote that “it is a matter of necessity that every Church should agree with this Church, on account of its preeminent authority” (Against Heresies III.3.2), and at Chalcedon (451) the bishops greeted Leo’s letter with the cry, “Peter has spoken thus through Leo” (Session II). The Lutheran reply is that both honor Rome for keeping the apostles’ teaching, and neither makes submission to Rome’s bishop necessary for salvation.
The early Church’s order was still developing, and it was conciliar. It is anachronistic to read either a fully formed papacy or a fully formed Protestant polity back into it. What the Fathers do give the Reformers is the collegial episcopate and Gregory’s refusal, evidence that supremacy by divine right over the whole Church was not the plain faith of the ancient Church.
5. Lutheran Confessional Theology
The Lutheran confession here can be gathered under the image that governs the whole article: the Church carries keys, not swords.
The keys: spiritual power, by divine right. The ministry truly holds Christ’s authority by divine right (ius divinum); it is not the Church’s invention, and it is not to be despised. When the pastor absolves, it is Christ who absolves; when he preaches the Gospel, it is Christ’s own Word. The Apology says that ministers, on account of the call of the Church, “represent the person of Christ, and do not represent their own persons,” and it cites Luke 10:16 (Ap VII–VIII.28). To honor this authority is to honor Christ, who gave it.
The sword: a different power, never exercised by the Church’s spiritual office. The Church’s authority is exercised through the Word alone. It warns and forgives. At most it excludes the impenitent from the communion of the Church (AC XXVIII.21), and even that only to call him to repentance and to receive him back. Of a man the Corinthian church had disciplined, Paul wrote, “For such a one, this punishment by the majority is enough, so you should rather turn to forgive and comfort him, or he may be overwhelmed by excessive sorrow. So I beg you to reaffirm your love for him” (2 Corinthians 2:6–8). The Church does not imprison, confiscate, or compel, and where the two powers were fused, the Gospel was obscured.
The office is divine; the structure is free. Here is one of the more surprising and elegant Lutheran distinctions. The office of the ministry (the preaching of the Word and the administration of the Sacraments) is Christ’s institution (ius divinum, chapters 5 and 14). The outward structure by which that office is ordered, whether bishops, presbyteries, or congregational assemblies, is in the main a human arrangement (ius humanum), to be judged by whether it serves the Gospel and good order. This is why confessional Lutherans are remarkably flexible about polity (the way a church organizes its government). The Reformers were glad to keep the historic episcopate if the bishops would allow the Gospel, for the freedom of the Gospel was the one thing they would not negotiate (AC XXVIII.77; Ap XIV.1, 5; chapter 14). Where the bishops would not, the churches kept their own right to call and ordain ministers, for wherever the Church is, the Treatise argues, there is the authority to administer the Gospel. That authority is “a gift which in reality is given to the Church, which no human power can wrest from the Church” (Tr 66–67). Since bishop and pastor differ only by human right, ordination by a pastor is valid by divine right (Tr 63–65). In the Lutheran lands the oversight the bishops refused passed in practice to the princes, who acted as “emergency bishops,” and the territorial churches that followed were a human arrangement, one that sometimes let the sword reach further into the Church than this article allows.
The limit of all authority: the conscience belongs to Christ. I believe this is the article’s great pastoral gift, that no authority in this world may command a Christian to sin, or bind his conscience where God has left it free. When any authority commands what God forbids, or forbids what God commands, or when a bishop teaches a gospel other than Christ’s (Galatians 1:8, which AC XXVIII.24 cites), the Christian not only may but must refuse (Acts 5:29). This is not a license for the restless to defy every authority they dislike, for the Reformers honored rightful authority and obeyed it gladly.
A command to sin must be refused. A rule the Church makes for good order (an hour of worship, a festival, an order of service) is another matter. The Confession teaches that “it is lawful for bishops or pastors to make ordinances that things be done orderly in the Church,” and that “it is proper that the churches should keep such ordinances for the sake of love and tranquillity” (AC XXVIII.53–55); its own example is Sunday. What the Christian refuses is only the claim that keeping such a rule merits grace or is necessary for salvation. He is also free of the fear that he sins when he breaks such a rule without offense to others (AC XXVIII.53, 56). When such a rule is imposed as necessary, or forced on the Church by enemies of the Gospel to suppress its doctrine, yielding is no longer free, for then “it is no longer a question concerning adiaphora, but concerning the truth of the Gospel” (FC Ep X.6; SD X.10–14).
The evaluation of the papacy. From these principles the Treatise sets out the case against the papacy. Three claims are denied (Tr 1–4). The first is that the pope is supreme over all bishops and pastors by divine right, for the keys were given to the whole Church (Tr 24), not to one bishop as monarch. The second is that he holds “both swords” by divine right, which is the very confusion of keys and sword this article corrects (Tr 31: Christ gave the apostles “only spiritual power” and “did not give the power of the sword”). The third is that to believe this is necessary for salvation, which binds the conscience where Christ has left it free and makes a human office the gate of grace. Whether a primacy by human right could ever be tolerated the Confessions leave unresolved. Melanchthon, signing the Smalcald Articles, allowed it if the pope would permit the Gospel, while Luther judged that such a head would not help, for “the Church can never be better governed and preserved than if we all live under one head, Christ” (SA II.iv.9). The Treatise adds that even if the bishop of Rome “had the primacy by divine right,” yet “since he defends godless services and doctrine conflicting with the Gospel, obedience is not due him” (Tr 57). On the ground of these claims, and above all because the office condemned the Gospel that God forgives sinners freely for Christ’s sake, the Confessions use the strongest term the Reformers had (Ap XV.18; SA II.iv.10–11; Tr 39–41; FC SD X.20). Luther’s words are these: “This teaching shows forcefully that the Pope is the very Antichrist, who has exalted himself above, and opposed himself against Christ because he will not permit Christians to be saved without his power, which, nevertheless, is nothing, and is neither ordained nor commanded by God” (SA II.iv.10). He wrote it of the papacy’s teaching and practice in his own day.
The identification with the antichrist—precisely stated. The Lutheran Confessions identify the papacy—understood as the office claiming universal jurisdiction by divine right and requiring submission for salvation—with the biblical description of the antichrist (2 Thessalonians 2). Two things must be said plainly about what this judgment means, and what it does not. It concerns specific doctrinal claims of the office—supremacy by divine right, salvation bound to the pope, the condemnation of the Gospel—not the personal salvation or sincerity of individual popes or of Roman Catholic Christians, many of whom trust Christ and are our brothers and sisters. And it should be said, with equal honesty, that faithful confessional Lutherans today differ in how they understand and apply this confession historically, while agreeing that the Book of Concord contains it. Having said this clearly, we may leave the controversy where it belongs—as one grave application of a larger truth—and return to the truth itself, which is the point of the whole article: Christ alone is Lord of the conscience, and every authority in His Church exists to serve His Word, never to sit in its place.
6. Comparative Theology
Every Christian tradition must answer the question of where authority sits.
Roman Catholic. Rome’s teaching on the papacy is narrower than many Protestants suppose. The First Vatican Council (1870, Pastor Aeternus) defined two things: the pope’s primacy of jurisdiction (a “full and supreme” power of governance over the whole Church, “ordinary and immediate” over every church and every believer, that is, his own and reaching each church directly, not through its bishop) and papal infallibility. Infallibility especially is widely misunderstood. It does not mean the pope is sinless, or that his every opinion is protected from error, or that he is personally inspired. It means that when the pope, in his office as pastor of all Christians, solemnly and deliberately defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole Church, speaking ex cathedra (“from the chair”), he is preserved from error in that definition. Such definitions, the Council adds, are irreformable “of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church” (Pastor Aeternus 4; repeated in Lumen Gentium 25). Defined in this way, the gift is hedged with conditions and has been formally exercised only rarely (the two teachings about Mary, her Immaculate Conception in 1854 and her Assumption in 1950, are the usual examples).
The Second Vatican Council (1964, Lumen Gentium) set the papal office within the collegiality of the bishops, in which the college of bishops, together with its head and never without him, is “the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church” (Lumen Gentium 22), that is, it holds that power. It also teaches that the same infallibility “resides also in the body of Bishops” when, with the pope, they teach definitively (Lumen Gentium 25).
Agreement: the ministry holds real, Christ-given spiritual authority; the Church has a teaching office; oversight serves unity. Rome, too, teaches that its teaching office “is not above the word of God, but serves it, teaching only what has been handed on” (Dei Verbum 10). Since the Second Vatican Council, Rome itself has also taught that the Church is bound to no political system and that no one may be coerced in matters of religion (Gaudium et Spes 76; Dignitatis Humanae 2), so Rome no longer claims for the Church’s office the power over rulers and the civil coercion of belief that the medieval papacy claimed. Divergence: whether the pope holds supremacy over the whole Church by divine right, whether that jurisdiction may bind the conscience, whether an office whose definitions are irreformable “of themselves” can still be judged by the Word it serves, and whether communion with him is necessary, in the terms Rome now uses (Lumen Gentium 14–15; Unitatis Redintegratio 3; §3). These are the questions that still divide the churches, and beneath them lies the deepest one, justification (Article IV), which AC XXVIII calls “the chief article of the Gospel” (AC XXVIII.52). On justification itself, the Lutheran World Federation and the Roman Catholic Church signed the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification in 1999, which chapter 4 treats; confessional Lutheran bodies such as the LCMS did not receive it.
Eastern Orthodox. The Christian East holds that authority rests in the councils of the Church and the shared witness of the bishops (conciliarity). It gives the see of Rome, the bishop’s seat and so the church of Rome, the first place among the churches of the undivided Church, a “first among equals” with a primacy of honor and, for some Orthodox writers, of appeal (a right to hear cases brought from other churches), but not a universal jurisdiction. Since the break between East and West (traditionally dated 1054) that first place in the Orthodox communion has belonged to Constantinople. Conciliarity is also more than the bishops, because a council’s teaching is confirmed by its reception in the whole Church; the Eastern Patriarchs wrote in 1848 that “the protector of religion is the very body of the Church, even the people themselves.” The papal claim to universal jurisdiction is, for the East, a chief cause of the schism between East and West. Agreement (with the Lutheran): the rejection of papal supremacy by divine right; authority exercised collegially and under the tradition. Divergence: the Orthodox retain the historic episcopate and a sacramental view of the hierarchy, in which the ordained ranks of bishop, priest, and deacon are given by God in their very form, a form the Lutheran treats, in its outward form, as ius humanum.
Anglican, Reformed, and Free Church. The other Western traditions place authority in different hands. Anglicans kept the historic episcopate without the papacy (“The Bishop of Rome hath no jurisdiction in this Realm of England,” Article XXXVII). Their Ordinal holds that bishops, priests, and deacons have existed “from the Apostles’ time,” and the Lambeth Quadrilateral (1888) names “the Historic Episcopate, locally adapted” as one of four articles on which reunion might be sought. Anglicans differ among themselves on whether the episcopate belongs to the Church’s very being or to its well-being. On the limits of church authority, however, Article XX says nearly what AC XXVIII says, for the Church may not “ordain any thing that is contrary to God’s Word written,” nor “enforce any thing to be believed for necessity of Salvation.” Article XXXVII draws AC XXVIII’s own line between keys and sword. It gives the civil ruler authority over “all estates and degrees,” but “we give not to our Princes the ministering either of God’s Word, or of the Sacraments,” and leaves him the duty to “restrain with the civil sword the stubborn and evil-doers.” The Methodist Articles of Religion, Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine, leave out Article XX, and American Methodism put an article on the rulers of the United States (Article XXIII) where Article XXXVII had stood.
The Reformed and Presbyterian churches commit the keys to church officers, ministers and ruling elders, who exercise them in a ladder of assemblies, from the session or consistory of one congregation up to a general assembly, distinct from the civil magistrate (Westminster Confession 30–31; Belgic Confession 30–32). On the limits of that authority they agree with the Lutheran in their own words. Synods and councils “may err; and many have erred” (Westminster Confession 31.3; 31.4 in the text of 1646), and no law may “bind and force our consciences in any way” (Belgic Confession 32). Westminster even says, close to this chapter’s refrain, “God alone is Lord of the conscience” (20.2). Many classical Presbyterians held this order to be prescribed by Scripture itself and not merely permitted, which differs from the Lutheran view of polity as largely ius humanum.
Baptists and Congregationalists locate authority in the local congregation gathered under Christ and His Word, with wider associations advisory rather than governing (Second London Confession 26; Baptist Faith and Message VI, XIV). Methodists govern by conferences that bind their congregations together, in America with bishops as well, and Pentecostal bodies range from episcopal to congregational.
7. Pastoral and Practical Significance
Most readers will never stand before a pope or a council, but every Christian sooner or later meets a smaller version of Acts 5:29, the moment when some human authority, holding rightful power, asks for what belongs to God alone. It may be an employer who requires a dishonest act, a government that commands what God forbids, or a religious leader who turns rules Christ never gave into conditions of His favor, or who uses guilt to control people. In that moment this article is the Christian’s charter of freedom. Honor rightful authority gladly, as the Reformers did, but when the line is reached, stand with the apostles and say that we must obey God rather than men. Your conscience belongs to Christ. He bought it, and He keeps it by forgiving it. When your pastor forgives your sins in Christ’s name, he is speaking Christ’s word to you, for Christ gave His Church this charge: “If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them” (John 20:23). No bishop, council, or pope may take that word from you or add a condition to it. If you have known the kind of leader who used guilt to control you, that guilt was not Christ’s voice. His voice is the one that forgives, and the abuse of the keys does not take the keys away from you.
This cuts the other way as well, toward those of us who hold authority in the Church, for the article that frees the conscience also limits the pastor’s office. The minister, for his part, exercises his office not as a lord but as a servant, knowing that his authority reaches only as far as the Word he carries.
The Reformers’ criticism of ecclesiastical authority was never contempt for it. They criticized its abuse because the authority is holy, and holy precisely because it belongs to Christ. It is His Word, His forgiveness, and His Sacraments, entrusted to His Church, and for that reason it may not be made a lordship or turned against the Gospel it exists to serve. Rejecting abusive claims to authority is not the same as rejecting Christ’s gift of pastoral oversight.
The practical fruit of this article, then, is a rightly ordered confidence. You honor your pastors and the good order of the Church and receive through them the gifts Christ sends. At the same time you rest in a freedom no earthly power can touch, because your conscience is bound, in the end, to Christ alone. When your conscience is troubled, go where Christ has promised to be found: to His Word, to your Baptism, to the absolution your pastor speaks in His name, and to the Supper, where His body and blood are given for you. Every true exercise of church authority ends by directing the sinner away from human power and toward Christ’s promises.
Whose voice finally binds my conscience? It is not the herald’s voice but the King’s, whom the herald serves, and the King’s decree is a pardon.
8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading
8.1 Summary
Article XXVIII, the capstone of the Augsburg Confession, asks what authority Christ gave His Church and where it ends, and it answers with a single governing distinction: the Church carries keys, not swords. The power of the keys is spiritual, exercised through the Word and held by divine right (ius divinum); the temporal power of the sword belongs to the civil order (chapter 16). Where bishops teach the Gospel, the churches owe them obedience by divine right (Luke 10:16; AC XXVIII.22), but no church authority may bind consciences with human ordinances as necessary for salvation, and all obedience ends where it would require sin (Acts 5:29).
The office of the ministry is divine; the outward structure (episcopal, presbyterian, or congregational) is largely a human arrangement (ius humanum). Confessional Lutherans were therefore glad to keep the historic episcopate if the bishops would permit the Gospel (chapter 14).
The papacy is evaluated with the Treatise as the essential companion: the Reformers deny the pope’s supremacy and his claim to both swords by divine right, and deny that submission to him is necessary for salvation, and the Confessions’ judgment that the office so understood is the antichrist concerns its doctrinal claims and not persons (§5). Rome’s own teaching comes from Vatican I and Vatican II, and the traditions differ over where authority sits, yet most agree that the Church’s power is spiritual and that no human authority may bind the conscience against God’s Word (§6).
As the last article of the Confession and the last of this book’s doctrinal chapters, XXVIII gathers the whole Confession’s arc. It began with God (AC I), moved through the incarnate Son (AC III), justification by grace through faith (AC IV), and Christ’s gifts given through the ministry (AC V), reformed the abuses that had obscured those gifts, and now closes by insisting that every authority in the Church exists only to serve Christ’s Gospel, never to replace it. Throughout, the Confession has returned to one conviction: Christ gives. The Church receives. The Church serves. The doctrinal portion therefore ends by looking not at Rome or Wittenberg or any earthly office but at the One who alone is Head of the Church, for Christ alone is Lord of the conscience.
8.2 Tables
Table 28.1—Church Power: Spiritual Only vs. Spiritual and Temporal
| The keys (spiritual power) | The sword (temporal power) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Preaching, forgiving/retaining sins, the Sacraments, judging doctrine, the ban | Civil coercion: law, force, the magistrate |
| How exercised | Through the Word alone | Through compulsion |
| Given to | The Church / the ministry (ius divinum) | The civil order (Romans 13; chapter 16) |
| What it deals with | Eternal things, through the Word alone: forgiving and retaining sins, to give righteousness, the Holy Spirit, and eternal life (AC XXVIII.8) | Bodies and bodily things, defended by law (AC XXVIII.11) |
The abuse Article XXVIII corrects is the confusion of the two: civil rule claimed by the divine right of the spiritual office (AC XXVIII.12–19). The Church carries keys, not swords.
Two comparison tables, The Papacy and Where Authority Sits, are in Appendix C.
Table 28.2—The Limits of Obedience: When Must a Christian Refuse?
| The Christian owes obedience to… | …until the authority… | …because… |
|---|---|---|
| Rightful civil government (Romans 13) | commands sin, or forbids what God commands | “We must obey God rather than men” (Acts 5:29) |
| Rightful church authority (pastors, oversight) | teaches against the Gospel, or imposes human rules as necessary for salvation (such rules may still be kept freely, for love and order) | “even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed” (Galatians 1:8) |
| Employers, elders, all human offices | requires what God forbids | the conscience belongs to Christ alone |
Obedience is real and dutiful; its one limit is God’s Word, not personal preference.
8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)
- The power of the keys: the Church’s spiritual authority to preach, forgive and retain sins, and administer the Sacraments.
- The two kingdoms: spiritual and temporal governance.
- Ius divinum / ius humanum: by divine right (God’s own institution) / by human right (an arrangement the Church may make and change).
- Jurisdiction: the right to govern and to make binding decisions.
- Papal primacy of honor vs. supremacy of jurisdiction: a first place of respect among bishops vs. a right to govern the whole Church.
- Papal infallibility: Rome’s teaching that the pope is kept from error when he solemnly defines (ex cathedra) a doctrine of faith or morals for the whole Church; not that he is sinless or always right.
- The historic episcopate: bishops ordained by bishops in a succession that its churches trace to the apostles.
- Conciliarity: the conviction that the Church is governed by its bishops meeting in council, with their teaching received by the whole Church, rather than by one bishop over all.
8.4 Further reading
- The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XXVIII; Apology XXVIII (and Ap XIV); the Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope; Smalcald Articles II.iv.
- Charles Arand, Robert Kolb, and James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3 (the Church; the ministry; the keys; the papacy).
- The Fathers, from their own texts and with care: Cyprian, On the Unity of the Church (both recensions); Gregory the Great, Letters (rejecting “universal bishop”); Jerome on presbyter and bishop.
- For the comparisons, from their own sources: Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus (1870); Vatican II, Lumen Gentium (1964); the Catechism of the Catholic Church §§880–896; Timothy Ware, The Orthodox Church, 3rd ed. (Penguin, 2015); the Thirty-Nine Articles; the Westminster Confession; the Second London Confession (1689) and the Baptist Faith and Message (2000). On papal primacy in ecumenical dialogue, Papal Primacy and the Universal Church, Lutherans and Catholics in Dialogue V (1974).
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.