Chapter 26—Article XXVI: The Distinction of Foods (Human Traditions)
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Picture a Christian who keeps every rule. She fasts on the appointed days and abstains from the forbidden foods. She observes the seasons, keeps the calendar, and watches her diet with great care. By every outward measure she is devout and yet she is exhausted, because she is never quite sure she has done enough. Was the fast strict enough? Did she keep the day rightly? Is there some observance she has neglected? Beneath all her discipline lies a question she cannot answer: Have I done enough to make God pleased with me?
The problem is not her discipline. Discipline is a good thing and this chapter will end by commending it. The problem is where she is looking for assurance. She is trying to find, in her own careful keeping of rules about food and days, a security those rules were never able to give and that only Christ can give.
Article XXVI of the Augsburg Confession is written for her. It takes up “the distinction of foods,” the mandatory fasts, dietary rules, and obligatory observances that by the sixteenth century had multiplied across the church calendar and were being taught not merely as good order but as necessary services of God that merit grace and make satisfaction for sin. The center of the chapter is a word of freedom: nothing you eat, avoid, or observe can make God love you more. In Christ you are already fully accepted, and therefore you are free to use spiritual disciplines wisely rather than anxiously.
That freedom is easy to mistake. The Reformation did not free Christians from fasting; it freed them to fast rightly, to use fasting and every bodily discipline not as an anxious way to earn God’s favor but as a glad tool in the hands of those who already have it. Free to fast. Free to feast. Always free in Christ.
A principle already learned
I do not intend to build the argument again from the ground up, because we have already learned the principle. Chapter 15 (on Article XV) laid down the Lutheran doctrine of adiaphora (“things indifferent”), matters neither commanded nor forbidden by God, which the Church may keep or change for good order but must never bind on the conscience as necessary for salvation. This chapter applies that settled principle to one part of the Christian life, what you eat and when you fast, and adds what chapter 15 did not, the recovery of fasting as a good and free Christian discipline.
1. What the Article Says
Article XXVI is one of the longer articles of the Confession, forty-five paragraphs in the Triglotta, and so I quote only its core here, the abuse it names and the teaching it sets against it:
It has been the general persuasion, not of the people alone, but also of those teaching in the churches, that making Distinctions of Meats, and like traditions of men, are works profitable to merit grace, and able to make satisfactions for sins. And that the world so thought, appears from this, that new ceremonies, new orders, new holy-days, and new fastings were daily instituted, and the teachers in the churches did exact these works as a service necessary to merit grace, and did greatly terrify men’s consciences, if they should omit any of these things. From this persuasion concerning traditions much detriment has resulted in the Church. (AC XXVI.1–3)
For the Gospel compels us to insist in the churches upon the doctrine of grace, and of the righteousness of faith; which, however, cannot be understood, if men think that they merit grace by observances of their own choice. Thus, therefore, they have taught that by the observance of human traditions we cannot merit grace or be justified, and hence we must not think such observances necessary acts of worship. (AC XXVI.20–21)
Its structure is simple: it names an abuse, describes the harm the abuse did, and states the reform.
The abuse. Human traditions concerning foods, fasts, and days had come to be taught as necessary services of God, observances that merit grace (earn God’s favor as a reward) and make satisfaction for sin (pay off the punishment thought still to be owed after forgiveness, as chapter 25 explained). What might have been kept freely, for order and discipline, had been fastened onto the conscience as a condition of God’s favor. In other words, a fast that might have helped a Christian to pray had become something he thought he owed to God.
The threefold harm. The Confession names the damage in a deliberate order. First, such teaching obscured “the doctrine of grace and of the righteousness of faith,” which the Confession calls “the chief part of the Gospel.” That doctrine must stand out in the Church “in order that the merit of Christ may be well known, and faith, which believes that sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake be exalted far above works” (AC XXVI.4). If keeping the fasts merits grace, then grace is no longer free and the conscience is turned back to its own performance.
Second, it obscured the commandments of God. The traditions were set far above God’s own commands, so that Christianity seemed to consist in holy days, rites, and fasts. Meanwhile the works God commands in each one’s calling, a father raising his children, a mother bearing them, a ruler governing, were counted worldly and imperfect, “far below those glittering observances,” and devout people were “greatly tormented” by the thought that marriage and civil office left them in an imperfect state of life (AC XXVI.8–11). This is Christ’s own charge against the Pharisees: “You leave the commandment of God and hold to the tradition of men” (Mark 7:8, ESV). (chapter 27 takes up the “more perfect life” of the monastic vows.)
Third, it endangered consciences. No one could keep all the traditions, yet they were taught as necessary, so that (as with the requirement to list every sin in confession, in the last chapter) the rules meant to sanctify produced only anxiety. The Confession cites Jean Gerson, chancellor of the University of Paris a century before, as witness that many fell into despair. It gives two causes: “they felt that they were not able to satisfy the traditions, and they had all the while not heard any consolation of the righteousness of faith and grace” (AC XXVI.12–13).
The reform. The evangelical churches (the churches of the Reformation, which took their name from the Gospel, the evangelium) keep many traditions that serve good order, “as the Order of Lessons in the Mass and the chief holy-days.” Yet they teach “that such observances do not justify before God, and that in such things it should not be made sin if they be omitted without offense” (AC XXVI.40–41). Such observances do not merit grace (AC XXVI.21), make satisfaction, or bind the conscience, and the doctrine of grace and of the righteousness of faith must be guarded above every human tradition. Fasting and bodily discipline are not abolished.
The Confession goes further than permission. The true mortification, it says, is first the cross God lays on us, “to be exercised with divers afflictions” (that is, with troubles of many kinds), “and to be crucified with Christ” (AC XXVI.32). It teaches that every Christian “ought to train and subdue himself with bodily restraints, or bodily exercises and labors that neither satiety nor slothfulness tempt him to sin, but not that we may merit grace or make satisfaction for sins by such exercises,” and that “such external discipline ought to be urged at all times, not only on a few and set days” (AC XXVI.33–34). That is, the Confession does not merely allow fasting. It expects every Christian to keep the body in check, so that neither a full stomach nor laziness leads him into sin, and to do so all year round and not only on a few set days, never as a way to earn anything. What it rejects it states in its own words: “we do not condemn fasting in itself, but the traditions which prescribe certain days and certain meats, with peril of conscience, as though such works were a necessary service” (AC XXVI.39).
Rules about foods and fasts are therefore matters of Christian freedom. They may be kept freely and usefully but they may never be imposed as necessary for salvation or trusted to merit God’s favor.
2. Biblical Theology
The Scriptures speak directly here, because Christ Himself and His apostles addressed the question of foods and days.
When the Pharisees faulted His disciples over ritual washing and food, Jesus answered that defilement is not a matter of diet: “There is nothing outside a person that by going into him can defile him” (Mark 7:15). Mark adds, “Thus he declared all foods clean” (Mark 7:19). Jesus taught that defilement comes from the heart and not from food and He drew the line the Reformation would echo: “in vain do they worship me, teaching as doctrines the commandments of men” (Matthew 15:9, citing Isaiah 29:13).
Paul writes to the same effect. Against those who would bind the conscience with dietary and calendar rules, he writes: “let no one pass judgment on you in questions of food and drink, or with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath. These are a shadow of the things to come, but the substance belongs to Christ” (Colossians 2:16–17). The old observances were a shadow. The substance has come in Christ and no one clings to the shadow once the reality has arrived. Such man-made regulations (“Do not handle, Do not taste, Do not touch”) have “an appearance of wisdom in promoting self-made religion and asceticism and severity to the body, but they are of no value in stopping the indulgence of the flesh” (Colossians 2:21–23). In other words, rules like these may look holy but they cannot change the heart.
To Timothy he writes that some will devote themselves “to deceitful spirits and teachings of demons,” led by those who “require abstinence from foods that God created to be received with thanksgiving,” and he answers them, “for everything created by God is good, and nothing is to be rejected if it is received with thanksgiving” (1 Timothy 4:1–4). The Confession applies the verse to the fasting laws of its own day without softening it: “Paul calls the prohibition of meats a doctrine of devils; for it is against the Gospel to institute or to do such works that by them we may merit grace, or as though Christianity could not exist without such service of God” (AC XXVI.29). That is the Confession’s judgment on the teaching and practice of the sixteenth century. It is not a verdict on the Roman Catholic neighbor who keeps a Friday abstinence today.
“For the kingdom of God is not a matter of eating and drinking but of righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit” (Romans 14:17). Both the one who eats and the one who abstains are to act in faith, “fully convinced in his own mind” (Romans 14:5–6), without despising or judging the other. The freedom has a limit. It is set by love for the weak brother whose conscience is still bound, not by the demand of anyone who would make the rule a law: “take care that this right of yours does not somehow become a stumbling block to the weak” (1 Corinthians 8:9). Christian liberty is exercised in love, under the apostle’s charter, “For freedom Christ has set us free… do not submit again to a yoke of slavery” (Galatians 5:1).
None of this makes fasting worthless. Paul disciplines his own body: “I discipline my body and keep it under control, lest after preaching to others I myself should be disqualified” (1 Corinthians 9:27). He does it to master the flesh for the sake of the ministry, not to earn grace. What, then, is a fast? The New Testament word is nēsteuō (“to fast”), which Thayer’s defines as “to abstain as a religious exercise from food and drink: either entirely, if the fast lasted but a single day, … or from customary and choice nourishment, if it continued several days.” A fast, then, may be a whole day without food or several days without one’s usual fare. Jesus, for His part, simply assumes His disciples will fast. He teaches them how (“when you fast, anoint your head and wash your face,” Matthew 6:17), and He says that when the bridegroom is taken away, “then they will fast” (Matthew 9:15). Christ freed His people from the food laws and forbade anyone to bind the conscience with rules about eating and days (Mark 7:19; Colossians 2:16; 1 Timothy 4:4), and His Word also expects them to practice a free and humble fasting (Matthew 6; 1 Corinthians 9:27).
3. Historical Context
The Reformers had no quarrel with fasting, which is ancient and universal. Their quarrel was with what a later age had done to it.
The apostolic Church settled early that Gentile believers were not bound to the Mosaic food laws. Christ had declared all foods clean (Mark 7:19), Peter was taught not to call unclean what God had cleansed (Acts 10), and the Jerusalem Council laid on the Gentiles “no greater burden” than a few concessions for fellowship (Acts 15:28–29). The Church practiced fasting from the first but its forms varied widely. The second-century dispute over the paschal fast prompted Irenaeus to observe that “the disagreement in regard to the fast confirms the agreement in the faith” (Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 5.24.13), a saying the Confessions themselves invoke (AC XXVI.44; FC Ep X.7). The very diversity showed that the form of fasting was churchly custom, not divine law.
Over the medieval centuries fasting and abstinence hardened into an elaborate obligatory system and came increasingly to be taught as meritorious and as making satisfaction for sin, part of the same penitential system we saw in the last chapter. The observances multiplied past keeping and (in the Reformers’ judgment) obscured grace and burdened consciences.
The Reformers rejected the teaching that such observances merit grace, while keeping fasting as a free and useful discipline. Article XXVI (1530) makes the case. The Apology (Melanchthon’s defense of the Confession) answers the critics in its Article XV, “Of Human Traditions in the Church.” Rome retained the precepts of fasting and abstinence as Church discipline, much relaxed after the Second Vatican Council (§6). The practical distance between a modern Catholic and a Lutheran on fasting is smaller than the sixteenth-century dispute suggests.
4. Early Church Witness
The early Church’s testimony again favors the Reformers, because it affirms both things they held: that fasting is good, and that its forms are free. (Both Fathers appear in chapter 15; here they are cited only on fasting.)
The Church fasted from the beginning and that consensus is the reason the Reformers kept fasting rather than discarding it. The form of the fast, however, was diverse and unlegislated from the earliest centuries. Irenaeus’s saying, quoted in §3, belongs here as well. Augustine, asked about differing local customs, gave the classic counsel: in matters neither commanded nor forbidden by Scripture, follow the custom of the place, and do not bind consciences or judge others (his letters to Januarius). Article XXVI cites both Fathers itself (AC XXVI.16–17, 44).
The Fathers support the Lutheran position, for they kept fasting as ancient and good and let its forms vary from place to place. The specific medieval move that AC XXVI resists, treating fasts and food rules as meritorious and necessary, is a later development and not the mind of the early Church. The obligation itself is old, for the Apostolic Canons already bind the Lenten, Wednesday, and Friday fasts under penalty (Apostolic Canon 69; see §6). The later move was to teach the keeping of them as a service that merits grace and makes satisfaction for sin.
5. Lutheran Confessional Theology
The Lutheran teaching turns on a distinction that governs the whole article, the difference between a discipline that trains faith and a discipline trusted to establish righteousness before God. The first is good and free; the second is the error. Fasting that serves faith (quieting the flesh, aiding prayer, preparing the heart) is a gift. Fasting trusted to earn God’s favor or pay for sin is a return to the yoke Christ removed.
Foods and fasts are therefore adiaphora, neither commanded nor forbidden by God. They may be kept for good order and discipline, but they may not be imposed as necessary for salvation or as meriting grace, for the conscience is free (Colossians 2:16; Galatians 5:1).
The abuse is serious because it touches the chief article again, justification, in which God declares sinners righteous for Christ’s sake through faith. To teach that fasting merits grace is to make God’s favor depend on my performance, and that is to lose the Gospel itself. The articles near the end of the Confession that correct abuses in church practice (Articles XXII–XXVIII) keep returning to one error in different forms: a human ordinance set above God’s Word, and, in the Mass, confession, the fasts, and the vows, a human work asked to do what only Christ’s work can do. For this reason the Confession sets “the doctrine of grace and of the righteousness of faith,” which it calls “the chief part of the Gospel,” above every tradition (AC XXVI.4).
Most Protestants have inherited only two options, mandatory fasting (rejected as legalism) or no fasting at all. I am convinced that the Lutheran Confessions offer a better way, free fasting. Jesus assumed His disciples would fast (“when you fast…,” Matthew 6:16); the Reformers assumed Christians might fast; the difference between the medieval error and the evangelical practice is not whether one fasts but why. Alongside the cross God lays on us (AC XXVI.32), fasting is retained as a wholesome discipline, freely undertaken by those who already stand in grace. It disciplines the body (1 Corinthians 9:27). Paul kept his body “in subjection and fitted for spiritual things, and for the discharge of duty according to his calling” (AC XXVI.38), and fasting serves the same end for us. It aids prayer and it prepares the heart for the Supper or a holy season. On the Supper the Small Catechism puts the matter exactly: “Fasting and bodily preparation is, indeed, a fine outward training; but he is truly worthy and well prepared who has faith in these words: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins” (SC VI.10). The faith the Catechism means does not have to be strong. A weak faith that clings to those words still receives what they promise, for “a bruised reed he will not break, and a faintly burning wick he will not quench” (Isaiah 42:3). Fasting is not a ladder by which we climb toward God, but a tool that helps quiet the noise of our hearts so we may listen more attentively to Him.
The limit is love. As in chapter 15, freedom is not license. It is exercised in love for the weaker brother (1 Corinthians 8; Romans 14; FC Ep X.5). The freedom must also be confessed. When the enemies of the Gospel demand a free thing as necessary, or force it on the Church in order to suppress the pure doctrine, “it is no longer a question concerning adiaphora, but concerning the truth of the Gospel” (FC Ep X.6). At such a time (the casus confessionis, “the occasion for confessing”) the Christian may have to refuse even a harmless custom, so that no one is taught that it is required (FC SD X.10; developed in chapter 15).
6. Comparative Theology
On this article the traditions differ less in whether they value fasting than in how they understand it. (The general doctrine of tradition and worship is chapter 15; here the subject is foods, fasts, and observances.)
Eastern Orthodox. Orthodox Christians have preserved one of Christianity’s richest traditions of disciplined fasting. Four fasting seasons (Great Lent, the Apostles’ Fast, the Dormition Fast before the August feast of Mary’s falling asleep, and the Nativity Fast), with the weekly Wednesday and Friday fasts, structure the Orthodox year. They are understood not as a way to purchase merit but as ascetic formation, the training and healing of the whole person, body and soul together, in cooperation with God’s grace, so that the appetites are ordered toward Him. The fasts carry the weight of the canons (Apostolic Canon 69), yet in practice they are applied pastorally (the Orthodox speak of oikonomia, the fitting of a rule to the person). The Lenten Triodion says that the rules “should be relaxed in the case of anyone elderly or in poor health” and that “in cases of uncertainty each should seek the advice of his or her spiritual father” (“The Rules of Fasting,” trans. Mother Mary and Kallistos Ware [London: Faber & Faber, 1978], 35–37, as quoted at oca.org). The Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America names “the very old, the very young, the sick, the nursing mothers and other people in extraordinary circumstances or with special needs,” with exceptions made “with discretion and appropriate guidance by the parish priest” (Peter A. Chamberas, “Not by Bread Alone: Fasting Today in the Orthodox Christian Way,” goarch.org, 2015). A Lutheran should honor the seriousness of this and has much to learn from it. The Lutheran concern is narrow, that the conscience remain free, with fasting received as gift and discipline and never bound as necessary for salvation. On the practice itself, the Lutheran stands nearer to the Orthodox than to churches where fasting has quietly fallen out of use, Lutheran ones among them.
Roman Catholic. Rome, too, has long kept days of fasting and abstinence, but as precepts of the Church, a discipline and not a claim that foods are impure (CCC 2041–2043). After the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965) they were markedly relaxed, by Paul VI’s Paenitemini (1966) and then by the 1983 Code of Canon Law. Under the present Code the obligatory fast falls on only two days, Ash Wednesday and Good Friday, for those aged eighteen to fifty-nine, with abstinence from meat (from age fourteen) on those days and on Fridays. Catholics also fast for an hour before Communion (CIC 919). Friday abstinence remains the universal rule but bishops’ conferences may allow another act of penance in its place outside Lent, as the United States did in 1966 under Paenitemini (National Conference of Catholic Bishops, Pastoral Statement on Penance and Abstinence, 18 November 1966, §§13, 24–26; CIC 1250–1253). Agreement: fasting is good; foods are not unclean; the precepts are discipline, not dogma. Divergence: whether the Church may bind such observances as duties, and their link with satisfaction for sin, which Rome still teaches (CCC 1459–1460).
Anglican. The Book of Common Prayer of 1662 sets out a full table of fasts (the forty days of Lent, the Ember days of seasonal prayer and fasting, the Rogation days of prayer before Ascension, the vigils of the great feasts, and every Friday except Christmas Day), enjoined by church order but never as merit. The Thirty-Nine Articles say that works of supererogation “cannot be taught without arrogancy and impiety” (Art. XIV). They hold, much as the Lutheran Confessions do (AC VII.3; FC Ep X.4), that ceremonies “may be changed according to the diversities of countries, times, and men’s manners, so that nothing be ordained against God’s Word,” and that each particular or national church “hath authority to ordain, change, and abolish, ceremonies or rites of the Church ordained only by man’s authority, so that all things be done to edifying” (Art. XXXIV). The same Article asks that ceremonies lawfully ordained be kept and not broken openly by private judgment, which is also the Lutheran counsel of love for the weak. The Methodist Articles of Religion, Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine, keep the sentence on the diversity of rites (Art. XXII). Modern prayer books keep a lighter form of the same order. The American Book of Common Prayer (1979) names Ash Wednesday and Good Friday as fasts and the weekdays of Lent and the Fridays of the year as days “of special devotion,” kept by “special acts of discipline and self-denial.”
Reformed and Wesleyan. The Reformed set aside the fasting calendar. In the Westminster tradition especially, this rested on the principle that only what Scripture commands may be imposed in worship. They kept the public fast, solemnly appointed “upon special occasions” (Westminster Confession 21.5; Calvin, Institutes 4.12.14–21). The Wesleyans recovered regular fasting (Wesley kept Wednesdays and Fridays) and Wesley counted it among the “means of grace,” by which he meant the ordinances through which God ordinarily works. Lutherans keep that term for the Word and the Sacraments (AC V) but the practice of a regular and unanxious fasting is close to the Lutheran positive use. Wesley’s General Rules expected it of every member of the Methodist societies, though never as a condition of salvation.
Seventh-day Adventist. Seventh-day Adventists abstain from the foods Scripture calls unclean (Leviticus 11; pork and shellfish, for instance), a distinction they trace back before Moses to Noah (Genesis 7:2). Many also commend vegetarianism, all of it grounded in a “health message” that honors the body as God’s temple. They hold these as a church standard of Christian behavior, not a condition of salvation. By their own account the concern is stewardship of the body, not the purchase of merit, and the impulse to care for God’s gift of the body is one a Christian can respect. The Lutheran difference is exegetical. We read Christ’s word that He “declared all foods clean” (Mark 7:19) and Paul’s that the food laws were “a shadow… the substance belongs to Christ” (Colossians 2:16–17) as having freed the Christian conscience from the clean/unclean distinction itself, whatever its origin. Peter’s vision confirms it (“What God has made clean, do not call common,” Acts 10:15), and Paul states it without exception (1 Timothy 4:4). Adventist interpreters read these texts otherwise. Ellen White called the reading of Peter’s vision as lifting the ban on unclean meat “a very narrow, and altogether erroneous interpretation,” and a 2015 Andrews University dissertation on Mark 7 concludes, in the summary of the General Conference’s own encyclopedia, that “neither Jesus nor Mark nullifies the clean and unclean food distinction of Leviticus 11” (Jiří Moskala, “Clean and Unclean (Leviticus 11),” Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists, 2020, encyclopedia.adventist.org). The vision, by Peter’s own account, taught him “that I should not call any person common or unclean” (Acts 10:28). The Lutheran reply is that the lesson about people is taught through food, and that Mark’s comment on Jesus’ word draws the same conclusion about food itself (Mark 7:19).
The Sabbath. Paul’s sentence in Colossians 2:16 names, in one breath, “food and drink… a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath,” and calls them all together “a shadow of the things to come,” whose “substance belongs to Christ” (2:16–17). Because Paul treats them together, it would be artificial to separate them, and so the seventh-day Sabbath belongs here, as one application of the chapter’s principle. Adventist interpreters answer that Paul means the annual ceremonial sabbaths tied to the feasts, not the weekly Sabbath of the Ten Commandments. The Seventh-day Adventist Bible Commentary calls them “ceremonial rest days” that “have served their function now that Christ, the reality, has come,” and adds that “in all this argument Paul is in no way minimizing the claims of the Decalogue or of the seventh-day Sabbath” (7:205–206, as quoted in Ron du Preez, “Sabbaths, Annual (Ceremonial),” Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists, 2020, encyclopedia.adventist.org). The Lutheran reading notes that feast, new moon, and Sabbath is the Old Testament’s own grouping for the yearly, monthly, and weekly observances, named in that order or the reverse (1 Chronicles 23:31; 2 Chronicles 2:4; Hosea 2:11), so that the weekly Sabbath is included. In other words, Paul is naming the whole calendar, from the greatest observance to the most frequent: the yearly feasts, the monthly new moons, and the weekly Sabbath. The Apology reads the verse the same way, saying that Paul “embraces at the same time both the Law of Moses and human traditions” (Ap XV.30).
The Seventh-day Adventist Church, for which the Sabbath stands at the center of its life of worship, teaches that the Creator “rested on the seventh day and instituted the Sabbath for all people as a memorial of Creation” (Genesis 2:3), and that the Sabbath commandment still requires its keeping. Adventists receive the Sabbath as a gift. In their own confession it is “a symbol of our redemption in Christ” and “a foretaste of our eternal future in God’s kingdom,” and they deny that keeping it earns salvation. Here a Lutheran can recognize a serious desire to obey God’s commandment and to keep a day holy to Him.
Lutherans read the Sabbath by Colossians 2 and the shape of the whole New Testament. The Sabbath, like the food laws and festivals, was a shadow now fulfilled in Christ, who is Himself our rest (Matthew 11:28; Hebrews 4). Christians gather on the Lord’s Day (the day of resurrection) in evangelical freedom, to receive Christ’s gifts, and no renewed Mosaic command binds the conscience to the day. To the argument from Creation the Lutheran answers that the rest God entered on the seventh day is the rest Christ now gives: “there remains a Sabbath rest for the people of God, for whoever has entered God’s rest has also rested from his works as God did from his” (Hebrews 4:9–10; see 4:1–11). The Westminster tradition differs from both. It holds the Sabbath command still binding, but on the first day of the week, “the Lord’s day,” which “is to be continued to the end of the world, as the Christian Sabbath” (Westminster Confession 21.7). The abiding substance of the Third Commandment (the Fourth in the numbering used by the Orthodox, Anglicans, and most Protestants) is the hearing of God’s Word and rest in Him.
The Confessions say the same. Luther writes in the Large Catechism that this commandment, “according to its gross sense, does not concern us Christians; for it is altogether an external matter, like other ordinances of the Old Testament… and now have been made free through Christ” (LC I.82). The Church kept the Lord’s Day for good order, and partly “that men might have an example of Christian liberty” (AC XXVIII.60; see chapter 28). Luther adds all the same that “we also should continue the same, in order that everything be done in harmonious order” (LC I.85).
No day, any more than any food, can bind the Christian conscience. (Adventism’s other distinctive teachings are discussed in chapter 17, on Article XVII.)
7. Pastoral and Practical Significance
Return now to the anxious rule-keeper we began with. Many of us know her, though the particular rules change with the times, and some of us have been her. For one Christian it is fasting seasons and forbidden foods, for another a regimen of devotional performance, and for many today a near-religious scruple about diet and health. The question underneath is the same, and perhaps it is yours: If I am disciplined enough, will God be pleased with me?
To that question the article speaks its freeing word. Nothing you eat, avoid, or observe can make God love you more. In Christ you are already fully accepted, not because your discipline has earned it but because His grace has given it. Christ kept the Law in your place, and on the cross He bore the sins that no fast of yours could pay for (Galatians 4:4–5; 1 Peter 2:24). You will not find the certainty of that acceptance by looking harder at your own keeping. God has put it outside you. He speaks it in the word of Christ, “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28). He gave it to you in the water of your Baptism and He gives it again in the absolution spoken to you and in the body and blood given “for you” (Luke 22:19–20). The Confession names this very lack among the causes of the despair of its day: the burdened “had all the while not heard any consolation of the righteousness of faith and grace” (AC XXVI.13). When the old question comes back, go where Christ is given. Hear His Word, remember your Baptism, seek the absolution, and come to the Supper. Then take up the disciplines again as a child already secure in the Father’s love.
Article XXV freed the conscience from the burden of earning forgiveness through the completeness of confession and the works of satisfaction, and Article XXVI frees it from the burden of earning God’s favor through religious disciplines and observances. Together they teach that the Gospel releases you from every attempt to secure God’s acceptance by your own performance. Having freed you, it gives back confession and fasting as gifts, though not as gifts of the same kind. The Church keeps confession for the sake of the absolution, Christ’s own word of forgiveness spoken to you (AC XXV.13), while fasting is a free help for the Christian who already has that word (AC XXVI.33).
Why, then, should a Christian fast at all? If none of this earns anything, why keep any discipline? The answer is pastoral. Christians do not fast or discipline themselves in order to become loved. They do so because people who are already loved still need wisdom, self-control, and habits that turn the heart toward God. The old Adam is still in us, to be drowned “by daily contrition and repentance” (SC IV.12), and so the Confession wants the body kept in check, “that neither satiety nor slothfulness tempt him to sin” (AC XXVI.33). The restless heart needs quieting too. A Christian might fast on Good Friday or before the Supper, or give up a meal each week in Lent and give its cost to the poor. In prayer an empty stomach can remind us of our hunger for God. The discipline does not create the relationship; it serves the relationship that God’s grace has already established.
The freedom Christ won reaches the table and the calendar and food is only the plainest example of it. This freedom does not make you careless. It makes you free to take up fasting as a glad servant and free to lay down any particular fast without guilt, never trusting it to do what Christ has already done. If you hear all this instead as permission never to deny yourself anything, Paul has a word for you as well: “For you were called to freedom, brothers. Only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another” (Galatians 5:13). Free to fast. Free to feast. Always free in Christ.
Am I using this discipline to earn God’s favor—or because I already have it?
If your honest answer is “some of both,” bring that mixture to Christ as well, for His acceptance of you does not wait for your motives to be pure, and He forgives the mixed motive along with every other sin.
8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading
8.1 Summary
Article XXVI, the fifth of the articles that correct abuses (XXII–XXVIII), applies the doctrine of Christian freedom to foods, fasts, and human observances. Its center is a word of release: nothing you eat, avoid, or observe can make God love you more; in Christ you are already fully accepted, and therefore free to use spiritual disciplines wisely rather than anxiously. The Confession charges that the medieval Church had taught mandatory fasts and dietary rules as necessary services of God that merit grace and make satisfaction. It names three harms in order: the doctrine of grace and the righteousness of faith, “the chief part of the Gospel,” was obscured; God’s own commandments in one’s daily calling were obscured (Mark 7:8); and consciences were driven toward despair.
Scripture answers directly. Christ “declared all foods clean” (Mark 7:19). Paul forbids anyone to bind the conscience over “food and drink, or… a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath,” calling them “a shadow… the substance belongs to Christ” (Colossians 2:16–17). Freedom is always limited by love (1 Corinthians 8).
Presupposing chapter 15’s doctrine of adiaphora, this chapter adds the recovery of free fasting. The Confession itself urges bodily discipline at all times and condemns not fasting but the traditions that bind days and foods on the conscience (AC XXVI.33–39). Jesus assumed His disciples would fast (Matthew 6:16), and the Reformers assumed Christians might. The Confession says that such discipline “ought to be urged at all times” (AC XXVI.33–34), and it leaves the day, the food, and the measure free. The difference is why, not whether. The governing distinction is between disciplines that train faith and disciplines trusted to establish righteousness.
Eastern Orthodoxy keeps a rich fasting tradition as ascetic formation, applied pastorally. Rome keeps fasting as a precept of the Church, much relaxed since the Second Vatican Council. The Anglican, Reformed, Wesleyan, and Adventist traditions keep their disciplines in different ways, none of them as merit. The Sabbath, which Colossians 2:16 names alongside food, is read by Lutherans as a shadow fulfilled in Christ, and the Lord’s Day is kept in freedom and for good order.
The pastoral heart answers why Christians still practice disciplines: not to become loved, but because people already loved still need wisdom, self-control, and habits that turn the heart toward God. The assurance the anxious rule-keeper looks for in her own keeping is given to her from outside, in Christ’s word, her Baptism, the absolution, and the Supper. With Article XXV it forms a pair, XXV freeing the conscience from earning forgiveness and XXVI from earning favor.
Related chapters: the general doctrine of adiaphora, chapter 15; Adventism’s other teachings, chapter 17; monastic vows, chapter 27; the bishops’ power and the Lord’s Day, chapter 28.
8.2 Tables
Table 26.1—Fasting and Food Laws Across Traditions
| Tradition | How fasting/food rules are understood | Binding on conscience? | Primary source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lutheran | A free discipline: to train the body and aid prayer; never merit | No; adiaphora, kept freely; bodily discipline itself urged at all times | AC XXVI; Ap XV; FC Ep X; SD X |
| Eastern Orthodox | Ascetic formation: four fasting seasons and weekly fasts; the healing of the whole person | Canonically expected; applied pastorally by the priest or spiritual father; not framed as buying merit | The Typikon and Lenten Triodion (the books of liturgical rules); Apostolic Canon 69; Ware, The Orthodox Church |
| Roman Catholic | Precepts of the Church: days of fasting and abstinence (a discipline); the hour’s fast before Communion | Obligatory as discipline; relaxed since 1966 (Paenitemini) | CCC 2041–2043; CIC 919, 1249–1253 |
| Anglican | A full table of fasts in the BCP of 1662 (Lent, Ember/Rogation days, vigils, Fridays); a lighter form in modern prayer books | Enjoined by church order, not as merit | BCP 1662 table of fasts; BCP 1979, p. 17; Articles XIV, XXXIV |
| Reformed | No fasting calendar (in Westminster, the regulative principle); solemn public fasts for special occasions | Calendar fasts not imposed; appointed fasts kept as public duty | WCF 21.5; Westminster Directory; Calvin, Inst. 4.12 |
| Wesleyan | Regular fasting, counted by Wesley among the “means of grace” | Expected of society members (General Rules); never a condition of salvation | Wesley, Sermons 16 and 27; the General Rules |
| Seventh-day Adventist | Diet: abstaining from the unclean foods of Scripture; healthful living; vegetarianism commended (stewardship of the body) · Sabbath: the seventh day, a memorial of Creation | Diet: a church standard of Christian behavior, not a condition of salvation · Sabbath: held binding by the Sabbath commandment (the Fourth in their numbering; the Third in the Lutheran) | Fundamental Beliefs 20, 22 |
The Lutheran keeps fasting as a free discipline, nearer the traditions that treasure it than to churches where it has lapsed, while insisting that the conscience remain free.
Table 26.2—Human Traditions: Binding, Beneficial, or Burdensome?
| The AC XXVI test | If a tradition is… | Then… |
|---|---|---|
| Is it commanded or forbidden by God? | Commanded / forbidden | Obey God; it is not adiaphora |
| If neither, is it taught as necessary for salvation or meritorious? | Imposed as necessary / meritorious | Burdensome: do not bind it on anyone; when it is forced as necessary, confess the freedom and do not yield (casus confessionis) |
| If not imposed, is it useful for good order, discipline, or love? | Kept freely for discipline/love | Beneficial: keep it gladly, bind no one |
The same tradition (a fast, a holy day) can be beneficial when kept freely and burdensome when imposed as necessary. The test is the claim made for the practice.
8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)
- Adiaphora—things neither commanded nor forbidden by God.
- Casus (or status) confessionis—“the occasion for confessing”: when a free thing is demanded as necessary or forced on the Church against the Gospel, so that the freedom must be confessed and the free thing not yielded.
- The precepts of the Church—in Roman Catholic teaching, the obligatory minimum of prayer and moral effort the Church sets for the faithful, among them days of fasting and abstinence (CCC 2041–2043).
- Fasting / abstinence—going without food, or without certain foods, for a time.
- Asceticism (askēsis)—disciplined spiritual training.
- Oikonomia—in Orthodox practice, the pastoral adjustment of a rule to a person’s circumstances.
8.4 Further reading
Primary: The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XXVI; Apology XV (Of Human Traditions); AC XXVIII; Small Catechism VI; Large Catechism I (the Third Commandment); Formula of Concord X (adiaphora); Smalcald Articles III.xv.
Lutheran/systematic: Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3 (adiaphora; Christian liberty).
The Fathers, from their own texts: Irenaeus via Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 5.24 (the diversity of the fast); Augustine, Letters 54–55 (to Januarius, on custom).
For the comparisons, from their own sources: the Catechism of the Catholic Church §§2041–2043, the Code of Canon Law (cc. 919, 1249–1253), and Paul VI, Paenitemini; The Lenten Triodion, trans. Mother Mary and Kallistos Ware (London: Faber & Faber, 1978), Timothy Ware, The Orthodox Church, 3rd ed. (Penguin, 2015), and the Apostolic Canons; the Book of Common Prayer’s table of fasts (1662) and its “Days of Special Devotion” (1979), and the Thirty-Nine Articles; the Westminster Confession 21 and Calvin, Institutes 4.12; Wesley’s General Rules and his Sermons 16 (“The Means of Grace”) and 27 (on fasting); the Seventh-day Adventist Fundamental Beliefs 20 and 22 (the Sabbath; Christian behavior), and the Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists (encyclopedia.adventist.org).
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.