Books · The Augsburg Compass

Chapter 25—Article XXV: Confession (Its Reform)

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Try, for a moment, to remember every sin you have ever committed.

I do not mean only the large ones, which come easily enough. Try to remember them all: every unkind word, every selfish thought, every neglected duty, every prayer you meant to pray and did not, and every person you failed to love. Try to list them by name and number, leaving nothing out.

You cannot do it. The sins you remember are a fraction of the sins you have committed, and beneath them lie faults you have never even noticed: motives you dressed up as virtues, and habits so deep you no longer feel them. “Who can discern his errors?” the psalmist asks (Psalm 19:12, ESV), and the honest answer is that no one can.

Now imagine that your forgiveness depended on the completeness of that list, so that you could be sure of God’s mercy only if you had confessed every sin by name and number. You would never be sure of anything. You would leave every confession wondering what you had forgotten, and whether the thing you forgot was the thing that would undo you.

In the late-medieval confessional many a tender conscience lived with exactly that fear. It is the burden Article XXV of the Augsburg Confession was written to lift. The article answers the question a troubled conscience actually asks: Can I know that I am forgiven? Its answer is this: the certainty of forgiveness rests on Christ’s word of absolution, not on the completeness of your confession or the sufficiency of your repentance. In other words, Christ’s word is stronger than my memory.

What this chapter is, and what it is not

We have already met confession in this book, and met it warmly. Chapter 11 (on Article XI) introduced the great gift the Reformers treasured: the Office of the Keys, by which Christ authorizes His Church to forgive sins in His name, and holy absolution, the living voice of the Gospel spoken to one troubled sinner, telling him that his sins are forgiven. We have already seen there why private confession is a precious gift. This chapter takes all of that for granted and does not argue it again. Chapter 11 also showed, from Psalm 19:12, why an enumeration of all sins cannot be required. Here we ask what that requirement, and the satisfaction tied to it, did to the conscience, and how the reform set it free.

This chapter asks a different question: What needed reform? If absolution is such a gift, how had it become a source of torment rather than comfort for so many? How did the Reformers set it free? The Reformers did not throw the gift away. They cleared away what had been piled on top of it, so that a frightened conscience could once again hear Christ’s I forgive you and believe it.


1. What the Article Says

Like the article on the Mass, Article XXV begins by denying that the Reformers have abolished anything. In the Triglotta’s English rendering it reads in full:

Confession in the churches is not abolished among us; for it is not usual to give the body of the Lord, except to them that have been previously examined and absolved. And the people are most carefully taught concerning faith in the absolution, about which formerly there was profound silence. Our people are taught that they should highly prize the absolution, as being the voice of God, and pronounced by God’s command. The power of the Keys is set forth in its beauty and they are reminded what great consolation it brings to anxious consciences, also, that God requires faith to believe such absolution as a voice sounding from heaven, and that such faith in Christ truly obtains and receives the forgiveness of sins. Aforetime satisfactions were immoderately extolled; of faith and the merit of Christ and the righteousness of faith no mention was made; wherefore, on this point, our churches are by no means to be blamed. For this even our adversaries must needs concede to us that the doctrine concerning repentance has been most diligently treated and laid open by our teachers.

But of Confession they teach that an enumeration of sins is not necessary, and that consciences be not burdened with anxiety to enumerate all sins, for it is impossible to recount all sins, as the Psalm 19:13 testifies: Who can understand his errors? Also Jeremiah 17:9: The heart is deceitful; who can know it? But if no sins were forgiven, except those that are recounted, consciences could never find peace; for very many sins they neither see nor can remember. The ancient writers also testify that an enumeration is not necessary. For in the Decrees, Chrysostom is quoted, who says thus: I say not to you that you should disclose yourself in public, nor that you accuse yourself before others, but I would have you obey the prophet who says: “Disclose thy way before God.” Therefore confess your sins before God, the true Judge, with prayer. Tell your errors, not with the tongue, but with the memory of your conscience, etc. And the Gloss (Of Repentance, Distinct. V, Cap. Consideret) admits that Confession is of human right only [not commanded by Scripture, but ordained by the Church]. Nevertheless, on account of the great benefit of absolution, and because it is otherwise useful to the conscience, Confession is retained among us. (AC XXV)

(The Triglotta’s Psalm 19:13 is verse 12 in the ESV.)

I want you to notice how the article begins and how it ends. It opens by saying that confession “is not abolished among us,” and it closes, “Confession is retained among us” (AC XXV.1, 13), that is, in the evangelical churches. Evangelical here means “of the Gospel,” the churches of the Reformation, and not the modern Evangelical movement. Between those two sentences the people are taught to prize the absolution “as being the voice of God, and pronounced by God’s command,” and they are reminded that God requires faith “to believe such absolution as a voice sounding from heaven” (AC XXV.3–4). In the Reformers’ own churches, the article says, the Sacrament was not given to anyone who had not first been examined and absolved (AC XXV.1). That examination served faith and was never a test of merit, for the Small Catechism says that “he is truly worthy and well prepared who has faith in these words: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins” (SC VI.10).

The article reforms two burdens that had been fastened to confession, and leaves confession itself in place.

The burden of enumeration. Medieval practice pressed the penitent to confess all his mortal sins (the grave sins thought to cut a person off from God’s grace, as distinct from lesser, “venial” ones), listed by kind and number, and the Council of Trent would later require it by divine law. This was called integral confession. The intention was serious and, in its way, reverent. Laid on a tender conscience, however, the effect was cruel, because the task is impossible. “Who can discern his errors?” (Psalm 19:12). Article XXV releases the requirement, since the enumeration of all sins is neither necessary nor possible. Its reason is the conscience: “if no sins were forgiven, except those that are recounted, consciences could never find peace; for very many sins they neither see nor can remember” (AC XXV.8–10).

The burden of earning certainty. In addition, behind the enumeration lay a deeper problem, the sense that forgiveness had to be secured by the penitent’s own thoroughness and satisfaction, as though peace with God waited on how completely I confessed and how sufficiently I had paid for my sins. Against this the article sets the free word of absolution, received by faith.

In other words, confession and absolution are kept and treasured, but forgiveness is received through Christ’s word by faith and is not earned by the completeness of confession or the sufficiency of satisfaction.


2. Biblical Theology

The Scriptures set two truths side by side: our sin is deeper than we can know, and God’s forgiveness is surer than we can feel.

Our sin runs past our knowing. “Who can discern his errors? Declare me innocent from hidden faults” (Psalm 19:12). Article XXV itself appeals to this psalm, and chapter 11 has already shown why it rules out any complete inventory of sin.

Confession is honesty, not accounting. “If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves… If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness” (1 John 1:8–9). What does it mean to confess? John’s word is homologeō, which Thayer’s lexicon defines first as “to say the same thing as another, i. e. to agree with, assent,” and, where sins are its object as in this very verse, “to admit or declare oneself guilty of what one is accused of” (Thayer, Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, s.v. ὁμολογέω). To confess my sins, then, is to say about them what God already says, and to say it to Him. Confession here is honest acknowledgment before God that we have sinned. The promise attached to it rests on the faithfulness of God rather than on the fullness of our list. John says at once why God can be just in forgiving: “we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous. He is the propitiation for our sins” (1 John 2:1–2). A propitiation is a sacrifice that turns away God’s just anger at sin.

Forgiveness is complete and final. When God forgives, He does not keep a running account. “You will cast all our sins into the depths of the sea” (Micah 7:19). Against the endless reckoning of a penitential ledger, the prophet pictures forgiveness as total removal.

Confession is met at once. Notice how quickly the word of forgiveness follows confession in Scripture. David says, “I have sinned against the LORD,” and Nathan answers in the same breath, “The LORD also has put away your sin” (2 Samuel 12:13; cf. Psalm 32:5). There is no interval in which David works off his debt before the pardon comes. A hard chastening did follow (2 Samuel 12:14), but it was not a payment toward the pardon. It was a father’s discipline, “for the Lord disciplines the one he loves, and chastises every son whom he receives” (Hebrews 12:6). As the Apology says of this very scene, “a punishment is also added, but this punishment does not merit the remission of sins” (Ap XII.56). This is the same gift Christ gave His Church in the Office of the Keys (“If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them,” John 20:23), the doctrine already unfolded in chapter 11.

Therefore, because our sin is deeper than our memory (Psalm 19:12), forgiveness cannot rest on the completeness of our confession. It rests on the faithful God who, for the sake of Jesus Christ, the propitiation for our sins (1 John 2:2), forgives us and cleanses us “from all unrighteousness” (1 John 1:9).

Does my peace rest on my confession—or on Christ’s word? Scripture points away from the ledger and toward the word.


3. Historical Context

How had so gracious a gift become so heavy a burden? The history is a study in how a good thing, overbuilt, became a weight on the conscience it was meant to comfort.

The early Church took sin seriously and practiced a solemn discipline of repentance and reconciliation for grave sins. At first it was often public; later it gave way to private, repeatable confession to a priest. The forms varied. That matters, because the shape of penance was never fixed by Christ but grew over time. By the high Middle Ages it had been systematized. The Fourth Lateran Council (1215) required every believer old enough to know right from wrong to confess all his sins faithfully to his own priest at least once a year and to perform the penance imposed (canon 21).

The medieval theologians of the universities (the “schoolmen”) taught penance in three parts: contrition, confession, and satisfaction. The Council of Florence set that scheme down in 1439. Confessors’ handbooks pressed for a complete confession of every mortal sin by kind and number, which the Council of Trent would later define as required by divine law. Satisfaction meant works (prayers, fasts, alms, and pilgrimages) that paid down the temporal punishment thought to remain after the guilt was forgiven. The idea was that the guilt is forgiven in the absolution while a penalty is still owed, to be paid in this life or in purgatory.

Where satisfaction fell short, indulgences drawn on the Church’s “treasury of merit” remitted the balance. By the early sixteenth century indulgences were being preached and sold, promising the remission of punishment for the living and even for the dead. It was precisely here that the Reformation began. In 1517 Martin Luther, himself once tormented by the confessional (that story belongs to chapter 11), objected, and the very first of his Ninety-Five Theses reframed the whole question:

“When our Lord and Master Jesus Christ said, ‘Repent,’ he willed the entire life of believers to be one of repentance.”

In one sentence Luther moved repentance out of the confessional transaction and into the whole of the Christian life, a daily turning to the God who forgives. The Reformation’s opening move was a protest on behalf of troubled consciences. (Rome itself later condemned the abuse, and Pius V abolished the sale of indulgences in 1567. Chapters 21 and 24 touch on indulgences, the treasury of merit, and purgatory.)

The Reformers kept confession and absolution, released the requirement of enumeration (Psalm 19:12), and rejected the tying of forgiveness to satisfaction and indulgences. Article XXV (1530) states the reform and the Apology defends it. Rome answered at the Council of Trent, Session XIV (1551), which set out its doctrine of the sacrament of penance and required the integral confession of all mortal sins by divine law. Later, following the Second Vatican Council, the Rite of Penance (1973) set the sacrament in the language of reconciliation and mercy. That is a gentler register than the late-medieval system, though the requirement to confess, in kind and number, every grave sin one remembers after careful examination remains (CCC 1456; Code of Canon Law, can. 988 §1).


4. Early Church Witness

The early Church is often summoned to one side or the other of this debate, so we should say clearly what it does and does not settle. It witnesses clearly to repentance and reconciliation for sin after Baptism. That much is not in dispute and the Reformers never disputed it. What it does not witness to is the later machinery of required enumeration and satisfaction.

The forms of penance varied and changed even in antiquity. The ancient Church often practiced a public discipline and over time this gave way to private confession. In one striking case the patriarch Nectarius of Constantinople simply abolished the office of the penitentiary priest, the priest who oversaw public penance, in his city around 391 after a scandal. It is a reminder that the outward form of penance was a matter of churchly order and not of divine command.

The Fathers most often frame confession pastorally, as the bringing of a sinner to God’s mercy, rather than as a legal tally. Article XXV itself appeals to them. “The ancient writers also testify that an enumeration is not necessary,” it says, and it cites Chrysostom from the Decrees, the standard medieval collection of church law: “confess your sins before God, the true Judge, with prayer” (AC XXV.10–11). The same passage cites the Gloss, the standard medieval commentary on that law, which “admits that Confession is of human right only” (AC XXV.12). In other words, the rule requiring every sin to be listed was made by the Church, not commanded by God. That does not make absolution a human arrangement, for the Apology calls absolution “the word of God which, by divine authority, the power of the keys pronounces upon individuals” (Ap XII.99). Ambrose, writing against the Novatianists (who refused to readmit Christians who had fallen away), defends the Church’s power to forgive and to restore the penitent. Tertullian’s early treatise On Repentance is a key witness to the ancient discipline, though he later joined the severe sect of the Montanists, and his later severity should not be taken for the mind of the Church.

However, Rome reads this history differently. Trent holds that the confession of each mortal sin to a priest was required from the beginning by Christ’s own institution (Sess. XIV, ch. 5), and Chrysostom himself, who urges confession to God, also exalts the priest’s power to loose sins (On the Priesthood III.5). The Lutheran reading of the evidence is that the early Church universally practiced repentance and reconciliation, in changing forms, with a pastoral aim, the restoration of the sinner. The specific burdens Article XXV lifts (integral enumeration, and satisfaction as the ground of certainty) are later developments. Reforming them did not break with the ancient Church.


5. Lutheran Confessional Theology

The Lutheran reform of confession is best understood through one distinction: the difference between confession as a way of receiving Christ’s forgiveness and confession as an attempt to earn certainty through one’s own thoroughness. The reform keeps the first and lifts the second.

Enumeration released. Because no one can discern all his errors (Psalm 19:12), the requirement to confess every sin is dropped. The penitent confesses the sins he knows and that trouble him, to unburden his conscience and receive the word of forgiveness. The Small Catechism puts it with pastoral simplicity: “Before God we should plead guilty of all sins, even of those which we do not know, as we do in the Lord’s Prayer. But before the confessor we should confess those sins alone which we know and feel in our hearts” (SC V).

Satisfaction released. The medieval three parts of penance (contrition, confession, and satisfaction) gave way to the two parts of true repentance, contrition and faith (AC XII.3–5). (The inner structure of repentance is the subject of chapter 12, on Article XII.) Satisfaction, as a work by which the penitent pays down his own punishment, is therefore set aside. That does not make sin trivial. The debt is real, but Christ made the one full satisfaction for it on the cross, and forgiveness is received by faith, not earned by works. What is rejected is satisfaction as a payment owed to God, whether for guilt or for the punishment thought to remain. The Apology knew that Rome did not claim satisfaction for guilt (Ap XII.118), and it answered that the penances the Church’s canons assigned (“canonical satisfactions”) “are not necessary by divine Law for the remission of guilt, or eternal punishment, or the punishment of purgatory” (Ap XII.147). God may still chasten a forgiven sinner, as He chastened David, but such chastening is His fatherly discipline and not a debt the confessional assigns or collects (Ap XII.156). The fruits of repentance are not rejected. Article XII says that “good works are bound to follow, which are the fruits of repentance” (AC XII.6), and the Apology does not object if someone wishes to call these good fruits, which follow forgiveness, a third part of repentance (Ap XII.28–29). The forgiven sinner will still want to make right what he can and to amend his life, but he does so as the fruit of forgiveness and never as its price. Tying the certainty of forgiveness to my satisfaction places my assurance on myself.

Assurance relocated. Most important of all, the reform moves the ground of assurance. In the old system the anxious question was inevitable: Have I confessed enough? Have I done enough to make it right? There was no sure answer, because the answer depended on me. The reform answers the question by changing where it rests. Forgiveness is sure because Christ has spoken. The Apology says that the absolution reaches even the sins “that we do not remember,” since absolution, “which is the voice of the Gospel remitting sins and consoling consciences, does not require judicial examination” (Ap XII.105). This is nothing other than justification (Article IV) applied to the confessional, and it is the same movement we saw at the Lord’s Table in the chapter on the Mass (chapter 24): God gives; faith receives.

The gift retained, and a Lutheran irony. Many people are surprised to learn that the Reformers did not abolish private confession. They kept it and commended it to their people. In 1522 Luther told his Wittenberg congregation, “I will let no one take private confession from me, and I would not give it up for all the treasure of the whole world, for I know what comfort and strength it has given me” (Eighth Invocavit Sermon, 16 March 1522, WA 10/3:61–62, translated here). One of the great ironies of church history is that Lutherans have often practiced private confession less than the Reformers themselves envisioned. They have let a treasure lie unused out of a mistaken sense that it was “too Catholic,” when in fact the Reformers had labored precisely to keep it, cleansed of its burdens. There is a real pastoral case for recovering it, not as a new requirement but as a gift freely offered. A Christian crushed by a particular sin does not always need a general assurance that God forgives sinners; sometimes he needs to hear from a called servant of Christ that his sin, this one, named, is forgiven. That is what absolution is for. The absolution spoken at the beginning of the Sunday service is the same word of Christ, spoken to the whole congregation at once. If you want to hear it spoken to you alone, ask your pastor to hear your confession privately; the Small Catechism gives a short form for it (SC V).


6. Comparative Theology

Confession is one of the places where the traditions are most easily caricatured, so I want to begin with what is not true.

Roman Catholic. Roman Catholics do not buy forgiveness. Rome treasures confession as a sacrament of grace and healing; genuine sorrow for sin matters; and in the sacrament the priest truly pronounces absolution, a real word of forgiveness. Satisfaction, in Catholic teaching, does not purchase the forgiveness of guilt (which is given in the absolution) but addresses the temporal consequences of sin, and the modern Rite of Penance (1973) frames the whole sacrament around reconciliation and mercy. Rome also does not teach that a forgotten sin remains unforgiven. The penitent confesses the mortal sins he recalls after careful examination, and the sins that do not come to mind are “understood to be included” in that confession (Trent, Sess. XIV, ch. 5; CCC 1456). Absolution in Rome does not wait on perfect sorrow either. Imperfect contrition (attrition), sorrow born of “the fear of eternal damnation,” is called “a gift of God, a prompting of the Holy Spirit,” and although by itself it “cannot obtain the forgiveness of grave sins,” it “disposes one to obtain forgiveness in the sacrament of Penance” (CCC 1453; Trent, Sess. XIV, ch. 4).

The Lutheran concern is neither that confession is worthless (Lutherans keep it) nor that Rome “sells” grace. The concern is where assurance finally rests. When forgiveness is bound to the integral confession of all mortal sins, and the penitent’s own satisfaction is still required for the temporal punishment that remains, the conscience is pointed back toward its own completeness and effort for its certainty; the reform points it instead to the free word of Christ. The disagreement is about the ground of assurance, and it is genuine. The Council of Trent teaches that “no pious person ought to doubt of the mercy of God, of the merit of Christ, and of the virtue and efficacy of the sacraments,” and also that “each one, when he regards himself, and his own weakness and indisposition, may have fear and apprehension touching his own grace; seeing that no one can know with a certainty of faith, which cannot be subject to error, that he has obtained the grace of God” (Sess. VI, ch. 9). The Lutheran answer is that God gives the absolution to be believed “as a voice sounding from heaven” (AC XXV.4). The difference is far more precise than the old slander supposed, but it is not small.

Eastern Orthodox. In the Orthodox Church, confession is made before a spiritual father and is framed less as a courtroom verdict than as healing for the soul, with the priest standing as witness and physician rather than judge. In the Russian service book the priest tells the penitent before confession, “I am but a witness, bearing testimony before him of all things which thou dost say to me,” and warns him not to “depart unhealed,” having “come to the physician” (Isabel F. Hapgood, trans., Service Book of the Holy Orthodox-Catholic Apostolic (Greco-Russian) Church [Boston: Houghton, Mifflin, 1906], 289). The Orthodox Church in America teaches the same today: the priest “is called a spiritual father,” and the penitent confesses “in the presence of the priest as witness,” while “Christ receives the confession and brings forgiveness and healing” (Essential Orthodox Christian Beliefs [2023], 163, 235). Modern Orthodox teaching generally does not frame confession as an integral enumeration by number and kind in the Western legal sense, though some seventeenth-century Orthodox statements borrowed Western language and practice varies between jurisdictions. Agreement (with the Lutheran): the pastoral, healing character of confession and the reality of absolution. Difference: the Orthodox number repentance among the holy mysteries (their word for sacraments) with its own rite, and the spiritual father may assign epitimia (“penances”), understood as medicine for the soul and not as payment for sin.

Confession before Communion is also widely expected. In the Russian Church it long became the rule before every Communion, and the report that the bishops of the Orthodox Church in America received “with gratitude and approbation” in 1972, even while it encouraged more frequent Communion, kept “in all its strictness the obligation for confession before communion” for those who commune seldom (Alexander Schmemann, report to the Holy Synod, “On Confession and Communion,” oca.org). That custom stands close to the Lutheran practice of 1530 (AC XXV.1).

Lutherans, too, can call absolution a sacrament: “Baptism, the Lord’s Supper, and Absolution, which is the Sacrament of Repentance, are truly Sacraments” (Ap XIII.4; see chapter 12). Therefore the difference lies in how the remedy is applied rather than in whether confession is sacramental.

Anglican. The Anglican Prayer Book kept confession as available but not required. The Book of Common Prayer provides a general confession and absolution in the liturgy. Its exhortation before Communion invites anyone who “cannot quiet his own conscience” to come to a minister “and open his grief; that by the ministry of God’s holy Word he may receive the benefit of absolution,” and its Visitation of the Sick provides for a “special confession” and a personal absolution (BCP 1662). Anglicans often sum it up in the traditional saying all may, none must, some should, though they differ among themselves on how strongly to commend private confession. Agreement (with the Lutheran): strong, since confession is retained without the burden of enumeration, and absolution is prized. Difference: the Thirty-Nine Articles (1571) teach that “Those five commonly called Sacraments, that is to say, Confirmation, Penance, Orders, Matrimony, and extreme Unction, are not to be counted for Sacraments of the Gospel,” since “they have not any visible sign or ceremony ordained of God” (Article XXV). The Apology, by contrast, is willing to call absolution a sacrament (Ap XIII). It is a difference of naming more than of practice, for both churches keep the absolution. The Methodist Articles of Religion, which are Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine, keep the same sentence (Article XVI).

Reformed and Evangelical. The Reformed confessions treat the keys as the preaching of the Gospel and church discipline (Heidelberg Catechism, Q&A 83–85), and Calvin commended voluntary private confession to a pastor (Institutes III.4.12–14), though no formal rite of private absolution took hold. Most evangelical and free churches emphasize confession made directly to God, together with mutual confession among believers (“confess your sins to one another,” James 5:16), resting on the priesthood of all believers. Agreement (with the Lutheran): forgiveness by grace through faith, not earned by satisfaction, and no required enumeration. Difference: the Lutheran, however, is closer to the older practice of the Western Church, having kept private confession and absolution where much of Protestantism let it go.

On the reform itself (no required enumeration, and no forgiveness earned by satisfaction) the Protestant traditions largely agree with the Lutheran. The Lutheran path is distinctive because it reformed confession without discarding it. It kept the private word of absolution as a treasure, freed from the burdens, so that a frightened conscience could hear Christ’s pardon spoken personally and be sure of it.


7. Pastoral and Practical Significance

Every pastor has heard some version of it. A troubled Christian, having confessed, pauses at the door and says, “Pastor, I’m afraid I forgot something.”

That one sentence holds the whole of this chapter. Behind it lies the old fear that forgiveness hangs on the completeness of the list, that a sin left unnamed is a sin left unforgiven, and that the burden of being sure rests finally on my own memory and effort. The answer the Gospel gives is never “Try harder. Go back and remember more.” The answer is “Christ’s forgiveness does not depend upon your memory.” The sin you forgot is covered by the same blood as the sin you remembered. Your assurance does not rest on how well you confessed; it rests on the One who forgives. Christ’s word is stronger than my memory.

This is why the Reformers cared so much about a matter that can look at first like a fine point of church order. The question underneath it is the most pastoral question there is: Can I know that I am forgiven? For all its seriousness, the medieval system could not finally answer yes, because it kept pointing the anxious conscience back to itself. The reform answered yes and grounded the yes outside the sinner altogether, in the word of Christ. That yes is spoken to the conscience troubled by its sin, and if you would confess a sin with no sorrow over it and every intention of returning to it, you have not yet heard the Law, for the same Keys that loose the penitent bind the impenitent (Matthew 16:19).

That brings us to a further question: Why did Christ give His Church the word of absolution, and why does the Church keep confession for its sake? He did not give it to burden consciences but to comfort them. He knew that a general truth (God forgives sinners) can seem meant for someone else: Yes, He forgives sinners, but does He forgive me? Christ therefore gave His Church a way to speak the forgiveness personally, to lay it on you by name: your sins are forgiven. The Church keeps confession to give you, when your sins frighten you, something concrete to hold, a word spoken to you that you can believe.

Perhaps the fear has only moved, so that you no longer ask whether you confessed enough but whether you believe enough. The father in the Gospel brought Jesus a faith that was mostly struggle, “I believe; help my unbelief!” (Mark 9:24), and he was not sent away, for of the Lord’s Servant it is written, “a bruised reed he will not break, and a faintly burning wick he will not quench” (Isaiah 42:3). Your certainty rests on the Christ your faith holds and not on the strength of your grip. When the old fear comes back, go where He has promised to be found: to His Word, to your Baptism, to the absolution, and to His Supper, where He gives Himself to you.

The comfort of confession rests not in remembering every sin, but in hearing Christ remember every promise.

Does my peace rest on my confession—or on Christ’s word? Lay down the impossible list. The word has been spoken over you.


8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading

8.1 Summary

Article XXV is the fourth of the articles on abuses corrected (Articles XXII–XXVIII, in which the Reformers explained which church practices they had corrected and why). It reforms the practice of confession, and like the article on the Mass before it, it begins by insisting that confession is retained and not abolished. It answers the question every troubled conscience asks, Can I know that I am forgiven? The certainty of forgiveness rests on Christ’s word of absolution, not on the completeness of your confession or the sufficiency of your repentance.

The medieval system had fastened two burdens to confession. One was the required enumeration of all sins, which is impossible (“Who can discern his errors?” Psalm 19:12). The other was the penitent’s own satisfaction for the punishment thought to remain. Both pointed the anxious conscience back to itself for its certainty. The reform releases enumeration and satisfaction and relocates assurance. Forgiveness is received through Christ’s word by faith and is not earned by the penitent’s thoroughness. A changed life follows forgiveness as its fruit.

The Reformers kept private confession and absolution, and Lutherans have often used the gift less than the Reformers envisioned. Rome does not sell forgiveness; it treasures confession, and its priests truly pronounce absolution. The real disagreement is over where assurance finally rests. With Article XI this article forms a before-and-after pair. In Article XI, Christ gives the Keys so that forgiveness may be personally spoken; in Article XXV, the Reformation removed the burdens around that gift so that frightened consciences could hear Christ’s absolution with confidence. The comfort of confession rests not in remembering every sin, but in hearing Christ remember every promise.

8.2 Tables

Table 25.1—Confession Reformed: Absolution Retained, Enumeration Released

The medieval penitential system The evangelical reform (AC XXV)
Is confession retained? Yes; required annually (Lateran IV, 1215) Yes; retained and treasured (not abolished)
Must all sins be enumerated? Yes; all mortal sins remembered, by kind and number (late-medieval practice; defined at Trent, 1551; still current law, CIC can. 988) No; it is impossible: “Who can discern his errors?” (Psalm 19:12)
On what does forgiveness rest? Contrition, confession of all mortal sins, and the priest’s absolution, with satisfaction still owed for temporal punishment¹ Christ’s word of absolution, received by faith
Where does assurance rest? In practice, on the penitent’s own completeness and effort² On Christ’s word, outside the sinner
The result for the conscience “Have I confessed enough? Done enough?” “Christ has spoken forgiveness to me.”

The reform keeps the gift (confession and absolution) and lifts the burden (enumeration and satisfaction as the ground of certainty).

¹ As the Smalcald Articles charge, late-medieval preaching often said these works merited forgiveness (Smalcald Articles III.iii.12).

² The Smalcald Articles’ charge: “they instructed men to repose confidence in their own works” (Smalcald Articles III.iii.12).

Sources: AC XXV; Ap XI–XII; Smalcald Articles III.iii.12; Lateran IV, canon 21; Trent, Session XIV; CIC can. 988.

Table 25.2—The Three Parts and the Two Parts

The medieval penance (three parts) The evangelical repentance (two parts)
1. Contrition (sorrow for sin) 1. Contrition (sorrow for sin, worked by the Law)
2. Confession (all mortal sins remembered, by kind and number) 2. Faith (which lays hold of the word of absolution)
3. Satisfaction (works paying down temporal punishment) (Christ’s satisfaction is complete; ours is not required for forgiveness or for remitting punishment (Ap XII.147). The fruits of repentance, a changed life, follow it: AC XII.6; Ap XII.28.)

In Roman teaching the three acts of the penitent are “as it were the matter” of the sacrament, and the priest’s “I absolve thee” is its form (Trent, Sess. XIV, ch. 3). The disagreement is not over whether absolution is spoken but over what is required of the penitent and where his certainty rests.

The inner structure of repentance, contrition and faith, is the subject of chapter 12 (Article XII).

8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)

  • The sacrament of penance—in Roman theology, the sacrament for post-baptismal sin: contrition, confession, satisfaction, and absolution.
  • Mortal sin—in Roman theology, a grave sin that cuts a person off from God’s grace, as distinct from venial sin.
  • Enumeration / integral confession—the confession of all mortal sins by kind and number.
  • Satisfaction—in Roman theology, works addressing the temporal punishment of sin. In Lutheran usage the one satisfaction for sin is Christ’s death (Ap XII.147), and the fruits of repentance follow forgiveness rather than paying for it.
  • Temporal punishment—in Roman theology, the penalty thought to remain after the guilt of sin is forgiven, paid in this life or in purgatory.
  • Indulgence—the remission of temporal punishment (touched on in chapters 21 and 24).
  • The Office of the Keys—the authority Christ gave His Church to forgive and retain sins.
  • Absolution—Christ’s forgiveness spoken to the penitent in His name.
  • Contrition / attrition—contrition is sorrow for sin; in Roman teaching, attrition is imperfect contrition, sorrow arising from fear of punishment (CCC 1453).

8.4 Further reading

Primary: The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XI, XII, and XXV; Apology XI–XII; Smalcald Articles III.iii (Of Repentance) and III.viii (Of Confession); the Small and Large Catechisms on Confession. Martin Luther, Ninety-Five Theses (1517), Thesis 1 on repentance (indulgences are touched on in chapters 21 and 24); the Eighth Invocavit Sermon (1522), LW 51.

Lutheran/systematic: Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3 (confession; the Office of the Keys).

The Fathers, from their own texts, read with care: Tertullian, On Repentance (with the Montanist caution); Ambrose, On Repentance (De Paenitentia); John Chrysostom on confession to God, and On the Priesthood.

For the comparisons, from their own sources: the Council of Trent, Session XIV, and the Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1422–1470; the Rite of Penance (1973); the Book of Common Prayer (1662: general confession and absolution, the Communion exhortation, the Visitation of the Sick); the Heidelberg Catechism, Q&A 83–85; the Westminster Confession 15; John Calvin, Institutes III.4; and, on Orthodox confession, Timothy Ware, The Orthodox Church, 3rd ed. (Penguin, 2015).

Topics
Sin and RepentanceConfession and AbsolutionForgivenessOther Churches and Traditions
Scripture
Psalm 19:12Psalm 19:13Jeremiah 17:91 John 1:8–91 John 2:1–2Micah 7:192 Samuel 12:13Psalm 32:52 Samuel 12:14Hebrews 12:6John 20:231 John 2:21 John 1:9James 5:16Matthew 16:19Mark 9:24Isaiah 42:3
Confessions
AC XXVAp XIIAC XIIAp XIIIAp XIAC XISC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.