Chapter 24—Article XXIV: The Mass
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
“When Jesus had received the sour wine, he said, ‘It is finished,’ and he bowed his head and gave up his spirit” (John 19:30, ESV). The word He spoke is tetelestai, from the verb teleō, “to finish, to complete,” which was also the ordinary word for paying what was due, as when a tax was paid (Matthew 17:24; Romans 13:6). He was not merely announcing that His suffering had ended. He was declaring that a work was complete: the one sacrifice for the sin of the world, offered once, and now finished.
There was nothing left to add and nothing left to pay. Paul puts it in the language of a debt. God has forgiven “us all our trespasses, by canceling the record of debt that stood against us with its legal demands. This he set aside, nailing it to the cross” (Colossians 2:13–14).
Hold on to that word from the cross. Article XXIV of the Augsburg Confession takes up the Mass (the Church’s celebration of the Lord’s Supper), and one question runs underneath the whole article: if Christ’s sacrifice is finished, what happens when we come to the Lord’s Table? Do we come to offer something to God, to present Christ’s sacrifice to the Father, to add our own offering to His, to do a work that moves God to be gracious, or do we come to receive something from God, the finished work of Christ, His body and blood “given and shed for you,” placed into open and empty hands?
The answer the reformers confessed is pure comfort: Christ’s sacrifice is complete. At the Lord’s Table you do not offer Christ to the Father—you receive the Christ whom the Father has already given for you.
One phrase to carry through, and a pattern to notice
God gives. Faith receives. That is the shape of the Gospel itself, and as we will see, it is the shape of the Lord’s Supper. It is also what the chapter on justification (Article IV) said: a sinner is not made right with God by offering God his works, but by receiving what Christ has done.
Notice the pattern the articles on abuses (Part II) have been teaching since chapter 22. The reforms ask one steady question: Where have later practices obscured what Christ instituted? In Article XXIV it becomes this: Has a way of understanding the Mass obscured the finished sufficiency of Christ’s one sacrifice, and turned a gift we receive into a work we perform?
1. What the Article Says
The first surprising thing about Article XXIV is how it begins. A reader expecting a Protestant demolition of the Mass finds, instead, a defense of keeping it.
The article is long, so I give its core paragraphs here rather than the whole. In the Triglotta’s English rendering of 1530 it reads:
Falsely are our churches accused of abolishing the Mass; for the Mass is retained among us, and celebrated with the highest reverence. … (AC XXIV.1–2)
There was also added the opinion which infinitely increased Private Masses, namely that Christ, by His passion, had made satisfaction for original sin, and instituted the Mass wherein an offering should be made for daily sins, venial and mortal. From this has arisen the common opinion that the Mass takes away the sins of the living and the dead by the outward act. … (AC XXIV.21–23)
Concerning these opinions our teachers have given warning that they depart from the Holy Scriptures and diminish the glory of the passion of Christ. For Christ’s passion was an oblation and satisfaction, not for original guilt only, but also for all other sins, as it is written to the Hebrews 10:10: We are sanctified through the offering of Jesus Christ once for all. Also, Hebrews 10:14: By one offering He hath perfected forever them that are sanctified. … (AC XXIV.24–27)
Scripture also teaches that we are justified before God through faith in Christ, when we believe that our sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake. Now if the Mass take away the sins of the living and the dead by the outward act justification comes of the work of Masses, and not of faith, which Scripture does not allow. But Christ commands us, Luke 22:19: This do in remembrance of Me; therefore the Mass was instituted that the faith of those who use the Sacrament should remember what benefits it receives through Christ, and cheer and comfort the anxious conscience. … (AC XXIV.28–30)
The Mass is retained. The Lutherans did not throw out the historic liturgy. They kept the same basic shape of the service, celebrated, the article says, with the highest reverence (the German text says, with greater devotion and earnestness than among their opponents). They added preaching and hymns in the language of the people and restored the people’s own communion, so that the Supper was received and not merely watched. The Reformation was a reform within the Mass, and its target was the teaching that the Mass is a sacrifice offered to earn grace for the living and the dead. However, one practice did not survive the reform. Private masses, said by a priest with no one communing and often for a fee, were given up, and the congregation gathered instead for one common celebration at which the people received the Sacrament (AC XXIV.10–13, 34–39).
The abuse corrected. What the article rejects is not the liturgy but the Mass understood as a propitiatory sacrifice, that is, a sacrifice offered to turn away God’s anger and win His forgiveness, whose benefits could be applied to particular people (living and dead), and which, in the practice of the day as the reformers saw it, was said privately and even purchased. Its root was the opinion quoted above, that Christ’s passion made satisfaction for (paid the debt of) original sin while the Mass was an offering for daily sins, venial and mortal (lesser sins and grave ones) (AC XXIV.21–22). Against it the article sets the letter to the Hebrews, with its offering “once for all” (Hebrews 10:10, 14; AC XXIV.24–27), and the Supper as a gift received by faith.
The reform serves the chief article. Underneath the whole discussion is justification (Article IV). If forgiveness is received as a free gift for Christ’s sake through faith, then the Supper cannot also be a work the Church performs to earn or apply that forgiveness. The Supper was instituted so that faith would remember Christ’s benefits and anxious consciences would be comforted (AC XXIV.30–31).
2. Biblical Theology
The biblical case rests, above all, on one letter: the letter to the Hebrews. Its argument is a sustained comparison between the many sacrifices of the old covenant and the one sacrifice of Christ. The words the inspired author keeps reaching for are once, once for all, and a single sacrifice, and he gives us one image, a priest who sits down.
The many sacrifices, and the one. Under the old covenant, the priests offered sacrifices without end. Hebrews says that “every priest stands daily at his service, offering repeatedly the same sacrifices, which can never take away sins” (Hebrews 10:11). The endlessness was the point, since a sacrifice that must be repeated is a sacrifice that never finishes the job. Against this stands Christ: “He has no need, like those high priests, to offer sacrifices daily… since he did this once for all when he offered up himself” (Hebrews 7:27).
“He sat down.” Then comes the image that settles it. “But when Christ had offered for all time a single sacrifice for sins, he sat down at the right hand of God… For by a single offering he has perfected for all time those who are being sanctified” (Hebrews 10:12, 14). The old priest stands, because his work is never done and there is always another sacrifice to bring. Christ sits down, because His work is finished. What a picture of a completed salvation that is! There is no altar in heaven where Christ is sacrificed again. He reigns from a throne because the offering is complete, and from that throne “he always lives to make intercession for them” (Hebrews 7:25). He intercedes on the ground of a sacrifice already finished and does not offer it again.
The sacrifice is not repeated. Of Christ’s entry into heaven itself the letter says, “Nor was it to offer himself repeatedly, as the high priest enters the holy places every year with blood not his own… But as it is, he has appeared once for all at the end of the ages to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself” (Hebrews 9:25–26). To repeat the sacrifice would be to deny that the first was enough.
“It is finished.” All of this is gathered into the word from the cross, “It is finished” (John 19:30), tetelestai, “it has been accomplished.” Paul says the same in the language of the temple. God put Christ forward, he writes, “as a propitiation by his blood, to be received by faith” (Romans 3:25). A propitiation (hilastērion) is the sacrifice that turns away God’s wrath against sin. Christ is the propitiation, and that sacrifice is “received by faith,” not performed again.
The Supper: a death proclaimed, a gift received. What, then, of the Lord’s Supper? When Paul hands on the words of institution, he describes what the Supper does: “This is my body, which is for you… as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes” (1 Corinthians 11:24, 26). The Supper proclaims the Lord’s death (announces it), and it gives, for the body is the one “which is for you.” It is a testament (a last will), a gift bequeathed and delivered to the heirs. Hebrews says that “a will takes effect only at death” (9:17), and Christ’s death has put His in force. The words of institution name what it delivers: “this is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins” (Matthew 26:28).
Two texts cited on the other side. The first is Jesus’ word, “Do this in remembrance of me” (Luke 22:19). What is this “remembrance”? The Greek is anamnēsis (“a remembering, recollection”), and at this verse Thayer’s lexicon renders the phrase “to call me (affectionately) to remembrance” (Thayer, Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, s.v. ἀνάμνησις). I want you to see where else the word appears. Hebrews uses it of the old sacrifices: “But in these sacrifices there is a reminder of sins every year” (Hebrews 10:3), which Thayer explains as “the memory of sins committed is revived by the sacrifices.” The old offerings called sins to mind year after year, while the Supper calls to mind the Christ who put them away. Some traditions read the word as a memorial, others as a making-present of the one sacrifice. The word alone cannot settle the question, and it certainly cannot overturn the letter to the Hebrews. The Lutheran Confessions read the word a third way. To remember Christ in the Supper, the Apology says, “is to remember the benefits of Christ and receive them by faith, so as to be quickened by them” (Ap XXIV.72; cf. AC XXIV.30–31). The remembrance is faith receiving the gift, and not an offering made to God.
The second is Malachi’s prophecy that among the nations, “in every place incense will be offered to my name, and a pure offering” (Malachi 1:11), cited since ancient times for the eucharistic sacrifice. Read in context it prophesies the worldwide worship and thanksgiving of God’s people in the messianic age. It cannot be made to say more than Hebrews allows.
When I come to the Lord’s Table, do I come to give—or to receive? Hebrews has already answered. The offering was finished at the cross, and at the Table God gives and we receive.
3. Historical Context
If the finished sacrifice is the plain teaching of Hebrews, how did the Mass come to be understood as a sacrifice the Church offers? The history matters because it shows how theology becomes practice and practice becomes an economy (a whole system of money and payment).
The early Church: thanksgiving and offering. The early Church called the Eucharist a sacrifice chiefly in the sense of thanksgiving (the very word “eucharist” means thanksgiving), of offering the gifts, and of the commemoration of Christ’s one sacrifice.
The medieval development: from thanksgiving to a sacrifice offered and applied. Over the medieval centuries the Mass came to be seen as a true and proper sacrifice offered by the priest, whose fruits could be applied to particular persons and intentions. If each Mass applied a measure of grace, then more Masses meant more grace, and so Masses multiplied: private masses with no congregation communing, votive masses for a particular request, masses for the dead to shorten the sufferings of souls in purgatory, and stipends (a fee given to a priest to say a Mass for a stated intention) and endowments (gifts left to pay for Masses in perpetuity) by which Masses could in effect be purchased. A doctrine (the Mass as an offered, applicable sacrifice) produced a practice (multiplied private and votive masses), which produced an economy (stipends, endowments, the buying of Masses).
The Reformation: reform, not abolition. The reformers corrected the doctrine and kept the liturgy. Article XXIV (1530) retains the Mass and rejects the propitiatory-sacrifice understanding and the private-mass economy, the Apology (Ap XXIV) develops the distinction between sacrifice and sacrament at length, and the Smalcald Articles (SA II.ii) contain Luther’s sharpest words on the subject.
Trent’s response. Rome answered a generation later, at the Council of Trent, Session XXII (1562), in its “Doctrine and Canons on the Most Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.” Trent defined the Mass as a true and proper propitiatory sacrifice. It also defined it as the same sacrifice as the cross, offered now in an unbloody manner, and not a repetition of Calvary, and it affirmed that the Mass in no way detracts from the cross. Trent did not adopt the opinion Augsburg had singled out, that the cross atoned for original sin and the Mass for daily sins.
Trent also took up the abuses. Its decree on the celebration of Mass condemned avarice and ordered bishops to “wholly prohibit all manner of conditions and bargains for recompenses” for Masses, while it defended Masses at which only the priest communicates as “truly common” offerings for the whole Church (Sess. XXII, ch. 6, and the decree on things to be observed and avoided in the celebration of Mass). Rome reformed the economy without withdrawing the doctrine, and it was the doctrine the reformers contested.
4. Early Church Witness
This is contested ground. It will not do for a Lutheran book to pretend that the early Church avoided the language of sacrifice, because it did not. The right question is not whether they used such language but what they meant by it.
They used sacrificial language. From the Didache (an early church manual, about A.D. 100), which applies Malachi’s “pure offering” to the Christian assembly, through Justin Martyr (about 150) and Irenaeus, bishop of Lyons (about 180), who speaks of the Church’s oblation (offering) of the firstfruits of creation, the bread and wine offered with thanksgiving, the early witnesses freely call the Eucharist an offering.
What did they mean? The earliest sacrificial language centers on the thanksgiving of the Church and the offering of the gifts with prayer, together with the commemoration of the one sacrifice of Christ. It is not yet the developed medieval doctrine that the priest offers Christ as a propitiation, to apply His merit. John Chrysostom, preaching on Hebrews, faces the question directly: “Do not we offer every day?” His answer: “We offer indeed, but making a remembrance of His death, and this [remembrance] is one and not many,” because that sacrifice “was once for all offered.” “It is not another sacrifice,” he says, ”… but we offer always the same, or rather we perform a remembrance of a Sacrifice” (Homilies on Hebrews 17.6). Augustine speaks of the Eucharist as the sacrifice “which the Church continually celebrates in the sacrament of the altar,” in which “she herself is offered in the offering she makes to God” (City of God 10.6). The Church, “being His body, learns to offer herself through Him” (10.20), and Christ’s one sacrifice “is also commemorated by Christians, in the sacred offering and participation of the body and blood of Christ” (Against Faustus 20.18). That is the Church’s self-offering of thanksgiving, not a sacrificing of Christ all over again.
Where the language grows. Cyprian, bishop of Carthage (died 258), already speaks of the priest who “offers” in imitation of Christ, in terms that point toward a sacrificing priesthood: “that priest truly discharges the office of Christ, who imitates that which Christ did; and he then offers a true and full sacrifice in the Church to God the Father” (Epistle 63.14; numbered 62 in the Ante-Nicene Fathers). Here both Rome and the reformers can fairly claim a witness. The picture is one of development, in which stronger notions of a sacrificing priesthood gradually took shape until the medieval doctrine emerged. However, the reformers did not claim that the Fathers never spoke of sacrifice. They claimed that the propitiatory sacrifice offered and applied by the priest was a later development, and that the Fathers’ own best instinct (Chrysostom’s “remembrance of a Sacrifice”; Augustine’s Church that “learns to offer herself through Him”) pointed back to the one finished offering.
5. Lutheran Confessional Theology
The Lutheran confession here turns on one distinction, and I find it helpful to learn it as a picture before learning it as a definition. A sacrifice ascends; a sacrament descends. A sacrifice is something offered up, from us to God: we bring it to Him. A sacrament is something handed down, from God to us, and He gives it and we receive it. The whole question of the Mass is which way the gift is moving at the Lord’s Table. The Lutheran answer, drawn straight from the words of institution, is that the movement is downward: “This is my body, which is given for you” (Luke 22:19).
Two kinds of sacrifice, and only one that propitiates. The Apology (Ap XXIV) draws the distinction. What is a sacrament, and what is a sacrifice? It defines both: “A Sacrament is a ceremony or work in which God presents to us that which the promise annexed to the ceremony offers… A sacrifice, on the contrary, is a ceremony or work which we render God in order to afford Him honor” (Ap XXIV.18). In other words, in a sacrament God gives us what His promise offers, and in a sacrifice we give something to God to honor Him. The Confessions do not reject sacrificial language altogether. They distinguish two kinds of sacrifice. A propitiatory sacrifice is one that atones for sin and turns away God’s wrath, and of these there is exactly one, offered once: the death of Christ. “There has been only one propitiatory sacrifice in the world, namely, the death of Christ” (Ap XXIV.22). The Apology’s own text for it is Isaiah’s prophecy of the Servant, “when his soul makes an offering for guilt” (Isaiah 53:10; Ap XXIV.23; see also Romans 3:25 and Hebrews 10).
There is a second kind, the eucharistic sacrifice, the sacrifice of thanksgiving, which “does not merit the remission of sins or reconciliation, but is rendered by those who have been reconciled” (Ap XXIV.19). The Apology names these sacrifices of praise: “the preaching of the Gospel, faith, prayer, thanksgiving, confession, the afflictions of saints, yea, all good works of saints” (Ap XXIV.25). With them goes the offering of one’s very self (“present your bodies as a living sacrifice,” Romans 12:1; “a sacrifice of praise to God, that is, the fruit of lips that acknowledge his name,” Hebrews 13:15). These the Christian and the Church do offer, gladly and continually.
Therefore the Lutheran does not object to calling the Christian life, or the Supper itself when it is received with thanksgiving, a sacrifice of praise. The Apology says that the reception itself of the Lord’s Supper “can be praise or thanksgiving; but it does not justify ex opere operato” (Latin, “by the work performed,” that is, by the outward act alone, apart from faith), and that, used rightly, “the ceremony becomes a sacrifice of praise” (Ap XXIV.33, 74).
Sacrifice and sacrament: do not confuse the direction. Notice what happens if the Mass is made a propitiatory sacrifice. The direction of the gift is reversed, and a sacrament (which God gives to us) is turned into a sacrifice (which we offer to God). The Apology names two things wrong with that idea. The first is that the Mass was held to benefit ex opere operato, by the outward act without the faith of the one who receives. The second is that it could be “applied on behalf of others, alive or dead.” A sacrament, however, is a promise, and a promise benefits only the one who believes it: “without faith the Mass is of service not even to the living” (Ap XXIV.11, 64). The faith that receives need not be strong, for the Formula of Concord says the Supper “was instituted especially for Christians weak in faith, yet penitent, for the consolation and strengthening of their weak faith” (FC Ep VII.19).
Why Luther spoke so sharply. The Augsburg Confession is irenic (peaceable) here. It answers that the charge of abolishing the Mass is false, and that the Mass is kept among them with reverence (AC XXIV.1–2). The Apology repeats it: “we do not abolish the Mass, but religiously maintain and defend it” (Ap XXIV.1). The Smalcald Articles, drawn up seven years later, contain some of Luther’s sharpest language in all the Confessions. He writes that “the Mass in the Papacy must be the greatest and most horrible abomination, as it directly and powerfully conflicts with this chief article” (SA II.ii.1). That is the Confessions’ judgment on the Mass as it was taught and practiced in the sixteenth century, and not a verdict on the Roman Catholic Christian who kneels at Mass today.
The two are not in conflict, and the difference in tone is not a change of doctrine. The Augsburg Confession was presented to the Emperor as an offer of peace. The Smalcald Articles were written to state clearly, for the council Pope Paul III had summoned to Mantua, what could and could not be surrendered. Even Augsburg, for all its gentleness, already calls the sacrificial opinion contrary to Scripture and a detraction from Christ’s passion (AC XXIV.24–25).
Luther’s sharpness has a precise cause. If the Mass is a work that earns and applies grace, then the finished sufficiency of Christ’s cross and the freeness of the Gospel are lost. In his own words, the Mass so understood is a human work “by which one attempts to reconcile himself and others to God” (SA II.ii.7). Luther spoke that sharply because he believed this touched justification itself, the article on which the sinner’s comfort depends.
The same article governs purgatory, which the Smalcald Articles treat with the Mass. Rome teaches that those who die in God’s grace but “still imperfectly purified” undergo a final purification, and that the Church offers for them “above all the Eucharistic sacrifice” (CCC 1030–1032). Luther answered that “Christ has instituted the Sacrament alone for the living,” and that purgatory, with “every solemnity, rite, and commerce connected with it,” conflicts “with the chief article [which teaches] that only Christ, and not the works of men, are to help [set free] souls” (SA II.ii.12).
The positive: the Supper as gift and comfort. The confessional teaching therefore ends in comfort and not in polemic. The Large Catechism calls the Sacrament food for the soul and a wholesome medicine, given to the hungry and received by faith (LC V.23–24, 68).
6. Comparative Theology
Fairness matters most here, because this disagreement has been, for centuries, one of the most misrepresented in all of Christianity. Therefore we begin not with the Lutheran objection but with what Rome does not teach, and I would rather let Rome speak in its own words before we weigh them. (What the Supper is, the real presence, belongs to chapter 10, and the distribution of both kinds to chapter 22. Here the single question is sacrifice.)
Roman Catholic. Roman Catholics do not believe that Christ dies again. The Mass is not, in Catholic teaching, a new crucifixion. It does not repeat Calvary, and it casts no doubt on the sufficiency of the cross. What Rome teaches is that the Mass is the same one sacrifice of Calvary made present (“re-presented,” set before God and the congregation) under the sacramental signs: “the same Christ who offered himself once in a bloody manner on the altar of the cross is contained and is offered in an unbloody manner” (Council of Trent, Session XXII, ch. 2, as quoted in the Catechism of the Catholic Church [CCC] §1367). The sacrifice of the cross and the sacrifice of the Eucharist are “one single sacrifice” (CCC §1367). The Eucharist, in this understanding, makes the one sacrifice present so that its fruits may be applied to the faithful, living and dead.
Lutherans and Roman Catholics agree on much here. Both confess the once-for-all sufficiency of Calvary, the true body and blood of Christ present and received in the Sacrament (chapter 10), the Supper as Christ’s gift to His Church, and the Church’s offering of thanksgiving and of itself.
The disagreement is not over whether Calvary was sufficient; both sides confess that it was. The disagreement is over what the Eucharist is. Rome holds that it is also a true and propitiatory sacrifice, in which Christ, the one priest, offers Himself through the ministry of the priest, the Church offers with Him, and its fruits are applied to particular persons, living and dead. The Lutheran confesses that the Supper is Christ’s testament, His body and blood given to us, with only our thanksgiving ascending, and remains unconvinced that an offering of the sacrifice, applied for the living and the dead, can be squared with Hebrews’ “once for all… he sat down.” The question is the direction of the gift, and that is a genuine, church-dividing difference.
Eastern Orthodox. The Divine Liturgy of St John Chrysostom calls the Eucharist “this liturgical and bloodless sacrifice,” offered with the words “Yours of Your Own, in behalf of all and for all,” and confesses to Christ, “it is You, O Christ, Who offer and are offered, Who receive and are received” (as translated by the American Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Diocese). The East holds that the anamnēsis makes present Christ’s one offering, and it offers the Liturgy for the living and the departed. However, it does not teach purgatory as Rome defines it, and it did not share the late-medieval Western system.
The Synod of Jerusalem (1672), an Orthodox council answering a Calvinist-leaning confession issued under the Patriarch Cyril Lucaris’s name, calls the Eucharist “a true and propitiatory Sacrifice offered for all Orthodox, living and dead” (Decree 17; J. N. W. B. Robertson, trans., The Acts and Decrees of the Synod of Jerusalem [London: T. Baker, 1899], 148). The synod is widely received in the East, but the Orthodox rank such seventeenth-century texts below the ancient councils. The Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America counts the councils of Jassy (1642) and Jerusalem (1672) as “councils of relative importance,” and of the “Symbolic Books” that came from them it says that “their authority is subjected to the authority of the Ecumenical Councils and the ancient Fathers of the Church” (“The Dogmatic Tradition of the Orthodox Church,” goarch.org). The Orthodox stand with us in confessing that Christ’s death was sufficient once for all and that the Supper is His gift. The Apology does not forbid prayer for the dead, but it rejects the application of the Supper for the dead by the act performed (Ap XXIV.94). There the Lutheran parts company with the East.
Anglican. The Anglican tradition has no single teaching office and speaks with more than one voice. Its historic statements of faith stand close to the Lutheran. Article XXXI of the Thirty-Nine Articles calls “the Offering of Christ once made” “that perfect redemption, propitiation, and satisfaction, for all the sins of the whole world,” and judges “the sacrifices of Masses, in the which it was commonly said, that the Priest did offer Christ for the quick and the dead, to have remission of pain or guilt” to be “blasphemous fables, and dangerous deceits.” (“The quick,” in the old English of the Creed, are the living.) The 1662 Book of Common Prayer confesses Christ’s “one oblation of himself once offered” as “a full, perfect, and sufficient sacrifice, oblation, and satisfaction,” and only after all have communicated offers to God, in the first of two prayers from which the priest may choose, “this our sacrifice of praise and thanksgiving.”
However, the Caroline divines (Church of England theologians of the 1600s) spoke of the Eucharist as a commemorative sacrifice, and the nineteenth-century Anglo-Catholic movement went further, reading Article XXXI as rejecting a popular doctrine of the Mass rather than eucharistic sacrifice itself, as John Henry Newman’s Tract 90 (1841), a leading paper of the Oxford Movement, argued. The Anglican–Roman Catholic International Commission, a dialogue commission and not a teaching body of either church, spoke of the making-present of the one sacrifice in its Eucharistic Doctrine (1971), while insisting that “there can be no repetition of or addition to what was then accomplished once for all by Christ” (§5). The 1988 Lambeth Conference recognized it, with ARCIC’s other agreed statements on ministry and ordination, “as consonant in substance with the faith of Anglicans” (Resolution 8). The tradition ranges from the Reformation pole, near the Lutheran and Reformed, to the catholic pole, near Rome.
Methodist. Methodist churches received Article XXXI almost word for word in the Articles of Religion (Art. XX), Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine Articles for the American Methodists, which the United Methodist Church still holds.
Reformed, Baptist, and Evangelical. The Reformed tradition rejects the propitiatory sacrifice of the Mass as firmly as the Lutheran. The Westminster Confession denies that “any real sacrifice [is] made at all, for remission of sins of the quick or dead,” and confesses instead “a commemoration of that one offering up of himself, by himself, upon the cross, once for all: and a spiritual oblation of all possible praise unto God, for the same” (29.2), which is the Apology’s own distinction. Worthy receivers “spiritually, receive, and feed upon, Christ crucified” (29.7). Baptist confessions agree that no propitiatory sacrifice is offered, though they differ on what the believer receives. The Second London Confession (1689) follows Westminster almost word for word, calling the Supper “only a memorial” of the one offering (30.2) and teaching spiritual feeding on Christ (30.7). The Southern Baptist Baptist Faith and Message (2000) calls the Supper “a symbolic act of obedience” (Art. VII), and many non-denominational evangelical churches share this memorial understanding.
The shape of the comparison. On the question of sacrifice, then, the family of Christ divides roughly in two. On one side are the traditions that understand the Eucharist as also a sacrifice offered for the living and the dead (Rome, the East, and the catholic wing of Anglicanism). On the other are those that deny that any propitiatory sacrifice is offered in the Supper, with only the sacrifice of thanksgiving ascending (the Lutheran, Reformed, Methodist, Baptist, and Evangelical traditions, and the Reformation wing of Anglicanism). For the Baptist and much of evangelicalism the Supper is chiefly an ordinance of obedience and remembrance, a difference that belongs to chapter 10. The remaining question, real and church-dividing, is what the Supper is: Christ’s gift received with thanksgiving, or that gift and also a propitiatory sacrifice offered for the living and the dead.
7. Pastoral and Practical Significance
Set down the councils and the distinctions for a moment, and stand at the rail. You kneel with nothing in your hands, about to receive the body and blood of Christ, given and shed for you. You have not come to do something for God or to complete what Christ left undone, but to receive, and that is the Gospel itself.
Why we call it the Divine Service. In the Lutheran tradition the chief service of worship is called the Divine Service (in German, Gottesdienst). The phrase can be heard two ways, as our service to God or as God’s service to us, and the Lutheran hears it first the second way. Worship is not first something we do for God, climbing up to Him with our offerings, but something God does for us. He comes down to us in His Word and Sacrament, forgiving, feeding, strengthening, and giving Himself. Only then does worship become our glad response, the thanksgiving, praise, and self-offering that make up the sacrifice that ascends. The Apology says it in so many words: “Thus the worship and divine service of the Gospel is to receive from God gifts; on the contrary, the worship of the Law is to offer and present our gifts to God” (Ap IV.310). Sacrifice ascends. Sacrament descends. The Divine Service is named for the descent.
The finished work, delivered. The Lord’s Supper does not continue Christ’s sacrifice. It continually delivers the blessings of Christ’s completed sacrifice to His people. The sacrifice was accomplished once, on Calvary, and finished there: “It is finished.” What happens at the Table is the delivery of its blessings (the forgiveness of sins, and with it life and salvation) again and again, week after week. In other words, the account is closed, and what the Supper hands out is an inheritance Christ has already secured.
The comfort of a finished work. Now, a conscience that believes it must offer God something worthy, that must contribute something to its own forgiveness, can never rest, because it can never be sure it has offered enough. That is the torment the reformers found the multiplied Masses could never quiet. A finished sacrifice cannot be added to, and so no one who receives it can come up short. When Christ said, “It is finished,” He closed the account forever. You come to the rail bringing no payment. You receive a receipt marked paid in full, the record of debt canceled and nailed to the cross (Colossians 2:14), and with it you move from wondering whether enough has been done to resting in the finished work of Christ. When your conscience will not rest, do not stay with a sentence in a book, but go where Christ has promised to give Himself to you: to the preached Word, to your Baptism, to the absolution, and to this Supper. Empty hands are not careless hands, for the Supper was instituted for those “weak in faith, yet penitent” (FC Ep VII.19), and the one who means to keep his sin should hear Paul before he comes: “Let a person examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup” (1 Corinthians 11:28).
That rest is not idleness. Received grace overflows into the sacrifice that does belong to us. Paul appeals “by the mercies of God” and only then asks us “to present your bodies as a living sacrifice” (Romans 12:1), in thanksgiving, praise, prayer, and a life offered to God and poured out for the neighbor. The order matters. First God gives, then faith receives, and then the grateful heart offers. Reverse that order, putting our offering first as the thing that moves God, and the Gospel is lost.
When I come to the Lord’s Table, do I come to give—or to receive? Come with empty hands, as an heir comes when the will is read. God gives. Faith receives.
8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading
8.1 Summary
Article XXIV, the weightiest of the articles on abuses (Articles XXII–XXVIII), turns on one distinction: Christ’s sacrifice is complete, so at the Lord’s Table we do not offer Christ to the Father—we receive the Christ whom the Father has already given for us. The reformers did not abolish the Mass. AC XXIV retains the historic liturgy and corrects the understanding of the Mass as a propitiatory sacrifice the Church offers to obtain and apply grace. The biblical case is dominated by Hebrews, with its once for all and its High Priest who “sat down” (Hebrews 7:27; 9:24–28; 10:10–18).
Sacrifice ascends, from us to God. Sacrament descends, from God to us, and the Supper descends. The Confessions affirm the eucharistic sacrifices of praise, thanksgiving, prayer, and self-offering, rendered by the reconciled and meriting nothing (Ap XXIV.19), and reject only a propitiatory sacrifice offered by the Church, held to benefit by the act performed (ex opere operato) and applied to others, living and dead (Ap XXIV.11), because that reverses the direction of the gift and touches the chief article, justification (AC IV). Faith does not make the gift but receives what Christ’s word already gives.
Roman Catholics do not believe Christ dies again. The Mass, in Catholic teaching, is the one sacrifice of Calvary made present (Trent Sess. XXII; CCC 1362–1372), and the real, church-dividing difference is whether the Eucharist is also a sacrifice offered to God for the living and the dead. Lutherans call worship Gottesdienst because it is first God’s service to us.
8.2 Tables
Table 24.1—Sacrifice vs. Sacrament: Which Way Does the Gift Move?
| Sacrifice (ascends) | Sacrament (descends) | |
|---|---|---|
| Direction | From us, up to God | From God, down to us |
| Who acts | We offer, bring, present | God gives; we receive |
| The hands | Full, bringing an offering | Empty, receiving a gift |
| In the Supper | Our thanksgiving, praise, prayer, and self-offering (Romans 12:1): the eucharistic sacrifice, which the Confessions affirm, rendered by the reconciled and meriting nothing | Christ’s body and blood, “given and shed for you”: the gift received by faith |
| What it is not | Not a propitiatory sacrifice the Church offers to obtain grace | Not a work we perform to move God |
The one propitiatory sacrifice, Christ’s death, was offered once, on the cross (Hebrews 10:10–14). What ascends from the Table is thanksgiving; what descends to it is Christ’s gift.
Table 24.2—Is the Eucharist a Sacrifice? Across the Traditions
The chart of seven traditions, with each one’s primary source, stands in Appendix C. In short, Rome calls the Eucharist a true and proper propitiatory sacrifice and the East a bloodless sacrifice, which the Synod of Jerusalem calls “a true and propitiatory Sacrifice,” both offered for the living and the dead, Anglicans range widely, and the Lutheran, Methodist, Reformed, Baptist, and Evangelical traditions deny that any propitiatory sacrifice is offered in the Supper. (See Appendix C.)
Table 24.3—The One Sacrifice and the Late-Medieval Mass Economy: The Reformers’ Critique
| The one sacrifice (Hebrews) | The many masses (late-medieval practice, as the reformers saw it) | |
|---|---|---|
| How often | Once for all (Hebrews 7:27; 10:10) | Multiplied without number |
| The priest | Christ “sat down,” the work finished (Hebrews 10:12) | Masses multiplied, each offered and applied for particular intentions |
| Direction | God gives; we receive | An offering brought up to God |
| Applied how | Received by faith | Applied by the act, to particular persons (living and dead) |
| Result | A conscience at rest in a finished work | In the reformers’ judgment, a conscience left asking whether enough has been done |
The chain to notice: a doctrine (the Mass as an offered, applicable sacrifice) produced a practice (multiplied private and votive masses) and then an economy (stipends and endowments). Trent itself denies that the Mass repeats or detracts from the cross (Sess. XXII, ch. 2) and forbids bargaining over Mass stipends; see §3. Masses for the dead connect to purgatory (see §5).
8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)
- Propitiatory sacrifice—an offering that atones and turns away wrath, of which Christ’s death is the one.
- Eucharistic sacrifice / sacrifice of praise—the Church’s thanksgiving, prayer, and self-offering, rendered by the reconciled; it merits nothing.
- Re-presentation—in Roman theology, the making-present, not the repetition, of the one sacrifice.
- Anamnēsis—liturgical remembrance.
- Ex opere operato—“by the work performed”; the outward act held to benefit apart from the faith of the one who receives.
- Propitiation—the sacrifice that turns away God’s wrath against sin.
8.4 Further reading
-
The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XXIV; Apology XXIV (the sacrifice/sacrament distinction); Smalcald Articles II.ii; Large Catechism V.
-
Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3.
-
The Fathers, from their own texts, with care: the Didache 14; Irenaeus, Against Heresies 4; Cyprian, Letters (Ep. 63, read carefully); John Chrysostom, Homilies on Hebrews; Augustine, City of God 10.
-
For the comparisons, from their own sources: the Council of Trent, Session XXII, and the Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1362–1372; the Thirty-Nine Articles XXXI and the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; ARCIC, Eucharistic Doctrine (1971); the Methodist Articles of Religion XX; the Westminster Confession 29; the Second London Confession 30 and the Baptist Faith and Message (2000) VII; the Divine Liturgy of St John Chrysostom, and Timothy Ware, The Orthodox Church, 3rd ed. (Penguin, 2015).
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.