Chapter 23—Article XXIII: The Marriage of Priests
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Begin with a wedding, not with a priest at an altar or a monk at his vows. A man and a woman stand before God and their neighbors and promise themselves to each other for life. It is the oldest human ceremony there is. “It is not good that the man should be alone,” God said in the garden. He made a helper fit for him, and a few lines later Scripture draws the conclusion: “Therefore a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and they shall become one flesh” (Genesis 2:18, 24, ESV). Marriage is older than ordination, older than monasticism, and older than the Fall. God thought of it Himself, in a world He had just called “very good” (Genesis 1:31), and He gave it to the human race as a gift.
The Augsburg Confession’s twenty-third article defends the right of those who serve in the ministry to marry, and for almost five hundred years it has been filed under a narrow heading: may priests marry? However, that is not really what the article is about, and to read it so is to miss its gift. This is not the chapter about priests getting married. It is the chapter about receiving God’s good gifts with thanksgiving, and marriage is its clearest example. The question underneath is far larger than the clergy. Are God’s good gifts obstacles to holiness, to be renounced by those who would draw near to Him, or are they part of His gracious design for human life, to be received with gratitude and used faithfully in the callings He gives?
God’s gifts are never obstacles to holiness. Marriage is one of the good gifts He gives, and no human law may forbid what He has blessed. The Reformers did not lower the bar of Christian devotion or make the ministry easier; they refused to let a human rule declare unfit for God’s servants what God Himself had called good. It is a gift given, not a law imposed.
A Brief Word, and a Pair to Notice
The last chapter (chapter 22, on Article XXII) opened the second half of the Augsburg Confession, the articles that take up the abuses corrected (practices the Reformers believed had crept into the Church and needed setting right). It did so by teaching the one question that runs beneath them all. The Reformers did not ask, “What would we like to change?” They asked, “Where have later practices obscured Christ’s institution?” This chapter asks the same question in a slightly different key: has a later human law forbidden what God left free?
The two chapters belong together. Article XXII said that Christ’s gifts are given completely to all His people, with the cup of the Lord’s Supper withheld from no one. Article XXIII says that God’s good gifts are not obstacles to holiness but part of His gracious design, and so marriage is forbidden to no servant of Christ to whom God has not given a different calling. Together they set the pattern for everything in Part II. The Reformers are not subtracting from Christian devotion or lowering the standards of discipleship. They are asking whether later human requirements have obscured the goodness of God’s institutions and the freedom of the Gospel.
1. What the Article Says
Article XXIII is a practical article, and its argument runs on three tracks: the widespread reality of the problem, the command and gift of God, and the practice of the ancient Church. The whole article runs to twenty-six paragraphs in the Triglotta, too long to give here, so I quote its opening argument (paragraphs 1–11), where the reasons are laid out:
There has been common complaint concerning the examples of priests who were not chaste. For that reason also Pope Pius is reported to have said that there were certain causes why marriage was taken away from priests, but that there were far weightier ones why it ought to be given back; for so Platina writes. Since, therefore, our priests were desirous to avoid these open scandals, they married wives, and taught that it was lawful for them to contract matrimony. First, because Paul says, 1 Cor. 7:2,9: To avoid fornication, let every man have his own wife. Also: It is better to marry than to burn. Secondly Christ says, Matt. 19:11: All men cannot receive this saying, where He teaches that not all men are fit to lead a single life; for God created man for procreation, Gen. 1:28. Nor is it in man’s power, without a singular gift and work of God, to alter this creation. [For it is manifest, and many have confessed that no good, honest, chaste life, no Christian, sincere, upright conduct has resulted (from the attempt), but a horrible, fearful unrest and torment of conscience has been felt by many until the end.] Therefore, those who are not fit to lead a single life ought to contract matrimony. For no man’s law, no vow, can annul the commandment and ordinance of God. For these reasons the priests teach that it is lawful for them to marry wives.
It is also evident that in the ancient Church priests were married men. For Paul says, 1 Tim. 3:2, that a bishop should be chosen who is the husband of one wife. (AC XXIII.1–11)
The rest of the article tells how celibacy was forced on the German clergy, how harshly the law was enforced, what Paul says of those who forbid marriage, and how Cyprian counseled women who could not keep a vow of chastity. We meet those paragraphs below.
Three things are plain on the surface.
The claim is modest. The article does not say that clergy must marry, or that celibacy is worthless, or that the single life is unspiritual. It says only that clergy may marry, because the freedom Scripture gives is not the Church’s to take away. The Reformers ask for the removal of a prohibition, not the imposition of a new rule.
The ground is God’s institution. The Confession opens with the public scandal, but its decisive appeal is to what God made and commanded (Genesis 1:28; Matthew 19:11; 1 Corinthians 7:2, 9; 1 Timothy 3:2; 1 Timothy 4:3). What God has instituted and blessed, the article argues, no human authority may declare off-limits to a whole class of Christians.
The reform restores an older practice. As with the cup in the previous chapter, the Reformers believed they were recovering the older practice rather than inventing a new one. Married clergy were the norm for centuries; the requirement of celibacy came later.
In other words, because marriage is God’s good gift, honored in Scripture and known among the clergy of the ancient Church, no human law may forbid it to those who serve in the ministry.
2. Biblical Theology
Scripture honors marriage and warns sharply against forbidding it. It honors celibacy too, as a genuine gift given to some and never as a universal law. I want you to see both, because the Reformers held both.
Marriage is God’s good institution. We have already stood at its origin: God instituted marriage in the garden, before the Fall, as part of a creation He called good (Genesis 2:18, 24). The Confession roots its argument in that creation. When God made man and woman, “God blessed them,” and He said to them, “Be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth” (Genesis 1:28). Because God made them for each other, the Confession argues, it is not in man’s power to alter that creation “without a singular gift and work of God,” and “no man’s law, no vow, can annul the commandment and ordinance of God” (AC XXIII.5–8). No one can decide by himself to live without what God built into him; only God’s special gift makes the single life possible. The New Testament never revokes that blessing. “Let marriage be held in honor among all, and let the marriage bed be undefiled, for God will judge the sexually immoral and adulterous,” says the letter to the Hebrews (13:4). The phrase is among all (Greek en pasin, which some translations render “in all things” or “in every way”), with no estate carved out as too holy for it. Marriage is not a concession to weakness that stronger Christians outgrow; it is a gift God gives, and Paul’s word for such gifts is that they are “to be received with thanksgiving” (1 Timothy 4:3–4).
Scripture warns against forbidding marriage. Writing to Timothy, Paul warns of teachers who will “depart from the faith.” “Now the Spirit expressly says that in later times some will depart from the faith by devoting themselves to deceitful spirits and teachings of demons… who forbid marriage and require abstinence from foods that God created to be received with thanksgiving by those who believe and know the truth” (1 Timothy 4:1–3). Paul is not condemning anyone who chooses the single life. His target is a false teaching, an early asceticism that treated God’s good creation (marriage and food alike) as impure and defiling. The verse condemns the prohibition of marriage, not celibacy: the idea that to be holy one must treat a gift of God as unclean. Paul goes on: “For everything created by God is good, and nothing is to be rejected if it is received with thanksgiving, for it is made holy by the word of God and prayer” (1 Timothy 4:4–5). Marriage is made holy the same way food is, by the word of God and prayer, and the Apology applies the verse to marriage itself (Ap XXIII.30–31). That is why the Church blesses marriages with the Word and with prayer.
The Confessions apply this passage directly to the celibacy law of their own day, and they do not soften it. The Augsburg Confession says, “Paul, in 1 Tim. 4:3, calls that a doctrine of devils which forbids marriage” (AC XXIII.22). The Apology says the killing of married priests shows “that this law is a doctrine of demons” (Ap XXIII.58), and Luther writes that those who forbade marriage to priests “have acted like antichristian, tyrannical, desperate scoundrels” (SA III.xi.1; see also III.xi.3). These are hard words and they should be read for what they are: the Confessions’ judgment on a sixteenth-century law and on those who enforced it, at times by putting married priests to death (AC XXIII.21), and not a verdict on Roman Catholics today. In their judgment a law that forbids marriage to those whom God has commanded to marry falls under Paul’s warning, whatever the piety of its intent. Rome, which honors marriage as a sacrament, rejects that application; its answer, and the Lutheran reply, are given in §5.
The apostles and early ministers were married. The New Testament simply assumes married ministers. The qualifications for an overseer take a married man as the ordinary case. He must be “the husband of one wife” (1 Timothy 3:2; likewise Titus 1:6), a requirement most often read today as concerning the character of his marriage (faithful, “a one-woman man”); older interpreters took it to exclude polygamy or a second marriage, a question of order on which churches have differed. The apostles themselves were married. “Do we not have the right to take along a believing wife,” Paul asks, “as do the other apostles and the brothers of the Lord and Cephas?” (1 Corinthians 9:5). Cephas is Peter, and we learn elsewhere that Jesus healed Peter’s mother-in-law (Matthew 8:14–15), which means Peter had a wife. The apostle whom Roman Catholics honor as the first pope was a married man! (Some early writers, Jerome among them, held that Peter and the other married apostles gave up marital relations with their wives after their call; Scripture itself does not say.)
Celibacy is a genuine gift, honored by Christ and by Paul. Jesus Himself, unmarried, spoke of “eunuchs who have made themselves eunuchs for the sake of the kingdom of heaven,” that is, men who freely forgo marriage to give themselves wholly to God’s work (Matthew 19:12). Paul, also unmarried, wished in one sense that more shared his freedom. “I wish that all were as I myself am,” he writes (1 Corinthians 7:7), and he commended the single life as leaving a person less encumbered and freer for the Lord’s work (1 Corinthians 7:32–35). When he says that the married man’s “interests are divided” (1 Corinthians 7:33–34), he is describing the cares that come with a household, not a defilement that unfits a man for God’s service. The celibate calling is no second-class discipleship. Across the centuries the Church has been greatly blessed by faithful men and women who never married and poured their whole lives into prayer, mission, teaching, and mercy.
A gift is given to some; it is not a law for all. Scripture is equally clear that celibacy is a gift given to some, not a duty laid on all. Listen to how Jesus frames it: “Not everyone can receive this saying, but only those to whom it is given… Let the one who is able to receive this receive it” (Matthew 19:11–12). Paul agrees: “each has his own gift from God, one of one kind and one of another” (1 Corinthians 7:7). To those without the gift of continence (the God-given ability to live chastely without marriage) he gives a plain command: “if they cannot exercise self-control, they should marry. For it is better to marry than to burn with passion” (1 Corinthians 7:9). Paul’s verb is enkrateuomai, which Thayer’s defines as “to be self-controlled, continent” and, with the negative as here, “said of those who cannot curb sexual desire.” Earlier in the same chapter he writes, “because of the temptation to sexual immorality, each man should have his own wife and each woman her own husband” (1 Corinthians 7:2). The Apology calls this “an express command pertaining to all who are not fit for celibacy” (Ap XXIII.14), and no human law can set aside what God commands. Even when Paul commends the single life, he refuses to make it a rule: “I say this for your own benefit, not to lay any restraint upon you, but to promote good order and to secure your undivided devotion to the Lord” (1 Corinthians 7:35). God has not distributed the same gifts to everyone, and to require of all His ministers a gift He has given only to some is to legislate against His own arrangement.
Has God called me to reject His gifts—or to receive them with thanksgiving? The Bible’s answer, on marriage and singleness alike, is to receive what God has given you, with thanks.
3. Historical Context
If Scripture assumed married ministers and the early Church ordained them, how did mandatory celibacy become the law of the Western Church? The development was gradual. This matters, because the Reformers’ whole claim was historical: they were restoring an older freedom, not inventing a new license.
For the first several centuries, married men were ordained across the Church as a matter of course. The pastoral epistles presume it, the apostles practiced it, and the historical record confirms that bishops, priests, and deacons were commonly married men.1
From the fourth century onward, a powerful movement exalted virginity and continence as the higher path. Monasticism spread, and the celibate life came to be admired as the most complete form of devotion. In the Latin West especially, influential voices (Jerome and Ambrose among them) pressed the superiority of virginity, and regional councils and Roman bishops began to require continence of the higher clergy, that is, that married clergy in the higher orders abstain from marital relations with their wives. Historians draw a distinction here. Much of this early legislation asked married clergy to abstain from marital relations; it did not ask that unmarried men be ordained in place of married ones. Some Catholic historians argue that this continence was itself apostolic, so that the later law only enforced what the Church had always asked of its married clergy (Christian Cochini, The Apostolic Origins of Priestly Celibacy; Alfons Maria Stickler, The Case for Clerical Celibacy; Stefan Heid, Celibacy in the Early Church). The outright prohibition of clergy marriage came later. The Eastern Church took a different road and has kept it to this day. At the Council in Trullo (692) it settled that priests and deacons already married may remain so (canon 13), while a bishop must live apart from his wife (canons 12 and 48). In time the East came to choose its bishops from the celibate clergy, who are monks.
The decisive hardening came in the West with the reforming movement of the eleventh century associated with Pope Gregory VII. Amid a broad campaign to purify the clergy and free the Church from lay control, celibacy was pressed with new vigor. Then the First Lateran Council (1123) and, decisively, the Second Lateran Council (1139) declared the marriages of subdeacons, deacons, priests, and bishops not merely unlawful but invalid, legally no marriages at all. With that, mandatory celibacy became the settled law of the Latin rite (the Western branch of the Catholic Church, to which nearly all Catholics in the West belong), and so it remained when Luther’s generation arrived.
Judging this law a human tradition that bound consciences God had left free, the Reformers permitted clergy to marry, and many did. Luther himself married Katharina von Bora, a former nun, in 1525. The Augsburg Confession states the case in 1530, and the Apology defends it at length. Rome answered a generation later at the Council of Trent, Session XXIV (1563). Trent defended the honor of virginity and clerical celibacy, held that clergy in sacred orders (subdeacons and above, by church law) and members of religious orders under solemn vows cannot validly marry (that is, any marriage they attempt is no marriage at all), and rejected the charge that its position is nothing else than “to condemn marriage” (canon 9). However, Rome’s official teaching today frames priestly celibacy as a discipline, a church rule it regards as fitting and could also change, and not as a doctrine, a truth God has revealed. Rome’s own practice shows this. The Eastern Catholic churches (the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church among them), which are in communion with the Pope but keep their own Eastern traditions, ordain married men to the priesthood. Since the Second Vatican Council, married men may be ordained deacons (the “permanent” diaconate, so called because these men do not go on to the priesthood). Married clergy who come into the Catholic Church from Anglicanism and some other communions may, by dispensation, be ordained Catholic priests, now chiefly through the Personal Ordinariates established under Anglicanorum coetibus (2009). The Catholic communion therefore has married priests and married deacons of its own, a point we take up again in §6.
Rome had not always put it so plainly. In 1530 the Confutation, the Roman theologians’ official reply to the Augsburg Confession, went further. The Apology reports that it claimed the law of perpetual celibacy had been “divinely revealed,” and answers that the law is “contrary to manifest testimonies of Scripture” (Ap XXIII.63); elsewhere it calls the law “simply of human right” (Ap XXIII.56), that is, made by men and not by God. On the law’s origin, Rome’s present teaching agrees with the Apology that it is a law of the Church and not of God, though it grounds that law in Christ’s own counsel and example (Presbyterorum Ordinis 16).
4. Early Church Witness
The strongest early witness is simply what the Church did. The apostles included married men (1 Corinthians 9:5), the pastoral epistles legislate for married overseers (1 Timothy 3:2; Titus 1:6), and for centuries married men were ordained East and West. This is the witness of the Church’s settled practice rather than of one Father’s opinion, which is why the Reformers could appeal to antiquity with confidence (Presbyterorum Ordinis 16; see the note in §3).
On the other side, the fourth and fifth centuries produced a genuine and influential exaltation of the celibate life. Jerome (c. 347–420) defended the superiority of virginity with great force, most sharply in his treatise against Jovinian, who had argued that the married and the celibate states were of equal worth. He was a brilliant scholar and a man of deep devotion, but also a fierce controversialist whose ascetic zeal colored his words on marriage. We should hear him as evidence of a developing ideal, not as the mind of the whole early Church. Ambrose (c. 339–397) likewise promoted virginity and clerical continence in the Latin West, helping prepare the ground for the medieval discipline. However, the Apology quotes him on its own side: “Virginity is only a thing that can be recommended, but not commanded” (Ap XXIII.20, quoting Ambrose, Exhortation to Virginity 3.17).
The Confession’s own witnesses come from this same early Church. AC XXIII cites Cyprian’s counsel to women who had promised chastity and could not keep it: “if they be unwilling or unable to persevere, it is better for them to marry than to fall into the fire by their lusts” (AC XXIII.25; Cyprian, Epistle 61.2 in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, Epistle 4 in modern editions). The Apology points out that the ancient canons “do not prohibit marriage, neither do they dissolve marriages that have been contracted” (Ap XXIII.23). AC XXIII even reports, on the authority of the historian Platina, that Pope Pius II said there were certain reasons why marriage was taken away from priests but far weightier ones why it ought to be given back (AC XXIII.2). These are the witnesses on which the Reformers rested their claim to be restoring an older practice.
The exaltation of celibacy was real and eventually powerful, but it began as an ideal urged by particular influential voices and by regional Western law, not as a universal apostolic command. To say “the early Church honored celibacy” is true. To say “the early Church required its clergy to be celibate” is not, and Article XXIII contests the second.
5. Lutheran Confessional Theology
What exactly did the Reformers object to? Was it celibacy itself, or something else? I think the Lutheran answer is best put in a single distinction:
Voluntary celibacy is a gift. Mandatory celibacy is a discipline. The Reformers objected only when the discipline bound consciences where God had left freedom.
First, the Confession honors celibacy. It does not disparage the single life, and neither do we. Jesus honored it and lived it; Paul honored it and lived it; and the Church has been greatly enriched by faithful Christians who gave up marriage to serve God with undivided attention. To choose celibacy freely, as a gift received from God for the sake of the Kingdom, is a good and beautiful thing, and Lutherans say so without reservation. Many of the Reformers had lived the celibate life themselves.
What the Confession opposes is compulsory celibacy, the turning of a gift into a law. Voluntarily renouncing a good gift for the sake of a calling is very different from declaring that good gift unfit for those who serve Christ. The first is a free and honorable calling, in which a man or woman who has been given the gift uses it to serve God and neighbor with fewer cares, without earning anything by it before God. The second is a human law that in effect treats what God has blessed as unfit for the ministry and imposes it on people to whom God has not given the gift of continence. The Reformers had no quarrel with the first. They resisted the second, and only the second, because it “forbids marriage” where God has left His people free (1 Timothy 4:3). The Apology states the Lutheran position in its own words:
The Gospel allows marriage to those to whom it is necessary. Nevertheless, it does not compel those to marry who can be continent, provided they be truly continent. We hold that this liberty should also be conceded to the priests, nor do we wish to compel any one by force to celibacy, nor to dissolve marriages that have been contracted. (Ap XXIII.61)
Rome would answer that it forbids marriage to no one. It normally calls to the Latin priesthood men who already live the celibate life and intend to remain in it (CCC 1579), trusting, in Trent’s words, that God “refuses not that gift to those who ask for it rightly” (Session XXIV, canon 9). The Lutheran reply is that the gift is God’s to give and not the Church’s to promise, for Christ said that not everyone can receive it, “but only those to whom it is given” (Matthew 19:11). A rule built on that hope leaves the man who struggles to conclude that he did not pray rightly, and to make celibacy the condition of the ministry is still to bind where God has left His people free.
The Apology adds a further, pastoral consideration (Ap XXIII.51–55). It offers this on top of its arguments from Scripture and creation, as a reason that would still count even if the law itself were fair: dangers to souls and public scandals, which, “though the law were not unjust,” ought to deter good men from approving such a burden (Ap XXIII.51). A law that requires a gift not everyone has been given does real harm. This does not mean that celibacy causes scandal, or that celibate priests are more prone to sin. Rather, when a discipline is imposed without regard to differing gifts, some consciences are burdened and some people are placed under temptations they were never called to bear. A rule that asks the same continence of every minister, whether or not God has equipped him for it, sets a weight on some shoulders that God did not place there, and a burdened conscience is exactly what the Gospel comes to relieve.
Some will say that permitting marriage makes the ministry easier. However, to insist that God’s gifts be received as He gives them (some called to marriage, some to the single life, each according to the gift given) is faithfulness, and it protects the freedom of the Christian conscience, which Christ purchased and the Gospel gives, and which no human tradition may take back. (This is the same freedom taught in chapter 15, on Article XV: human traditions, however useful, may never be imposed as though they were God’s own commands.) The Reformers were asking the Church to stop requiring of all what God had given only to some.
Article XXIII is finally a confession about God’s goodness, not a grievance about clergy rights. God does not make holiness depend on renouncing what He Himself has called good. The Apology puts the root of the matter in one sentence: “we are justified neither on account of virginity nor on account of marriage, but freely for Christ’s sake, when we believe that for His sake God is propitious to us” (Ap XXIII.36–37). Propitious is the old word for gracious or favorable. The Apology adds at once that this does not make the two gifts equal, as Jovinian had claimed; it denies only that either one earns righteousness before God (Ap XXIII.37–39). Christ praises those who forgo marriage for the kingdom of heaven so that they may have leisure to learn or teach the Gospel, not because the single life merits the forgiveness of sins (Ap XXIII.40). Neither marriage nor the single life earns God’s favor; each is a place to serve Him by faith. God gives some the gift of the single life and some the gift of marriage, and He is honored when each is received with thanksgiving and lived faithfully in its calling.
6. Comparative Theology
On the practice at issue (may clergy marry?) the traditions today largely agree that they may. The real remaining difference is a narrow one, and the Roman Catholic position is often misunderstood. (The theology of monastic vows belongs to chapter 27, on Article XXVII; here the subject is clergy marriage.)
Roman Catholic. The Roman Catholic Church does not teach that marriage is evil or defiling. On the contrary, it honors marriage as a sacrament, a sacred sign of the union of Christ and the Church. Nor does it teach that a married ministry is unlawful in principle. Priestly celibacy in the Latin rite is a discipline, an ecclesiastical law the Church regards as a fitting sign of undivided devotion to Christ, and not a doctrine or dogma. The Second Vatican Council’s decree on the priesthood grants that celibacy “is not demanded by the very nature of the priesthood,” while insisting in the same place that it “has a many-faceted suitability for the priesthood” (Presbyterorum Ordinis 16). Trent also ranked the two estates, teaching that it is “better and more blessed to remain in virginity, or in celibacy, than to be united in matrimony” (Session XXIV, canon 10). The Apology itself calls virginity “a more excellent gift than marriage” and denies only that either one merits justification (Ap XXIII.38–39; see chapter 27).
Agreement: marriage is good and holy; celibacy is honored; and a married ministry is not, in principle, unlawful. Divergence: whether the Church may require celibacy of its Latin-rite priests. That is the remaining question, and it is far narrower, and fairer, than “does Rome think marriage unworthy of its priests?” The Lutheran answer is that a gift God gives to some may not be made a universal condition of the ministry. Rome answers that the Church has authority to ask this discipline of those it calls to the Latin priesthood. The Apology gave its own verdict on the law of its day without hedging: the Reformers could not assent to it “because it conflicts with divine and natural law” (Ap XXIII.60). A real difference remains. It does not concern the goodness of marriage, on which both sides agree. It concerns whether the Church may bind as a condition of the ministry what God has left free, and for the Lutheran Confessions that is no small matter, because it touches Christian freedom and how far the Church’s authority reaches (AC XV; AC XXVIII; see chapter 15, on Article XV, and chapter 28, on Article XXVIII).
Eastern Orthodox. The Eastern Orthodox Church has kept the ancient practice of a married priesthood: men already married may be ordained priests and deacons. Agreement: married clergy are proper and apostolic, which is strong common ground with the Lutheran confession. Divergence: marriage may not be entered after ordination (a widowed priest may not remarry and continue to serve), and bishops are chosen from the celibate clergy. The Orthodox regard these as holy canons (rules handed down from the ancient councils, here the Council in Trullo) rather than as a “discipline” in the Western sense. Trullo also rejected the Roman rule that married priests abstain from their wives (canon 13).
Anglican. The Anglican tradition permits clergy to marry on the same scriptural ground the Lutherans hold. Article XXXII of the Thirty-Nine Articles states: “Bishops, Priests, and Deacons, are not commanded by God’s Law, either to vow the estate of single life, or to abstain from marriage: therefore it is lawful for them, as for all other Christian men, to marry at their own discretion, as they shall judge the same to serve better to godliness.” Since the nineteenth century the Anglican Communion has also had religious orders whose members freely vow celibacy. Agreement: strong and explicit.
Methodist. The Articles of Religion that John Wesley abridged for American Methodism (1784) repeat the Anglican article almost word for word: “The ministers of Christ are not commanded by God’s law either to vow the estate of single life, or to abstain from marriage; therefore it is lawful for them, as for all other Christians, to marry at their own discretion, as they shall judge the same to serve best to godliness” (Article XXI, “Of the Marriage of Ministers”). Agreement: full.
Reformed, Baptist, and Evangelical. Across these traditions married clergy are the norm. Marriage is honored as a creation ordinance, and no vow of celibacy is required. The Westminster Confession states that “it is lawful for all sorts of people to marry, who are able with judgment to give their consent” (24.3), and the Second London Baptist Confession repeats it (25.3). Agreement: large; on this question there is no difference of substance.
7. Pastoral and Practical Significance
You are most likely not a pastor, and the temptation is to treat Article XXIII as an old rule about who may marry, of interest chiefly to clergy. However, it carries a truth that reaches every Christian: marriage itself is holy, a calling and not a concession.
Marriage is a vocation. The medieval mind ranked the vowed life above the married one; chapter 27, on Article XXVII, takes up that ranking. The Reformers recovered the biblical truth that God assigns callings (vocations) and that every lawful calling is a place to serve God and love one’s neighbor. (This is the doctrine of vocation taught more fully in chapter 16, on Article XVI.) Marriage is one such calling, and a high one. If you are married, you are exactly where God has placed you, doing the holy work He has given you. Roman Catholic teaching has since come to speak warmly of marriage as a vocation too, and of a call to holiness for every Christian (Lumen Gentium 40), though it still holds consecrated virginity to be the higher charism (Familiaris Consortio 16; see chapter 27).
What holy work it is, and how easy to overlook because it is so ordinary: rising in the night for a feverish child, keeping a promise on a day you would rather not, forgiving your spouse for the same small wound the hundredth time, raising children in the faith, teaching them to pray and carrying them to the font, sitting together in silence when there are no words, and praying at a kitchen table. None of this looks like the heroic renunciation the old system prized, and all of it is holy, because God has commanded it, blessed it, and placed His people in it, and because those who do it, often badly, are His forgiven children: “forgiving one another, as God in Christ forgave you” (Ephesians 4:32).
Christianity refuses to treat ordinary human life as something to escape, and the reason is that the Son of God entered one. When God came to save us, He was born to a mother, raised in a home under the care of an earthly guardian, and grew up in a family and a village, learning a trade and keeping the ordinary rhythms of human life for thirty years before He spoke a word in public. Christianity does not escape creation; it redeems it. If the eternal Son honored a human home, no human law may treat home and marriage as unfit for those who serve Him.
If God has given you the gift of the single life, receive it with thanksgiving and use it freely for the Kingdom. If He has given you marriage, family, and home, receive these with thanksgiving too. These are holy callings in which God is served and the neighbor is loved. Some are given neither as they would have chosen: the widowed, the divorced, the single who did not choose it. They have not missed God’s gifts. “Only let each person lead the life that the Lord has assigned to him, and to which God has called him” (1 Corinthians 7:17), and the calling given them in Baptism is as holy as any wedding vow. God does not ask His servants to despise His gifts in order to become holy. He calls them to receive His gifts with thanksgiving and use them faithfully in their vocation.
That is the freedom this short article guards, the freedom Christ won for a conscience that no longer has to earn God’s favor by giving up what God has blessed. “For freedom Christ has set us free; stand firm therefore, and do not submit again to a yoke of slavery” (Galatians 5:1). It is a gift given, not a law imposed.
When your conscience still accuses you, do not look for that freedom in yourself. Go where Christ gives Himself and His forgiveness: to His Word, to your Baptism, to the absolution, and to His Supper. If you fear your faith is too weak to hold on, remember that “a bruised reed he will not break” (Isaiah 42:3).
Has God called me to reject His gifts—or to receive them with thanksgiving? Look at the life He has given you and the calling He has placed you in, and receive it from His hand.
8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading
8.1 Summary
Article XXIII, the second of the Abuses-Corrected articles, defends the freedom of those who serve in the ministry to marry. Marriage is God’s own good institution, older than ordination, older than monasticism, and older than the Fall (Genesis 1–2), held “in honor among all” (Hebrews 13:4), and Scripture reserves its sharpest word for those who “forbid marriage” (1 Timothy 4:1–5). Its center is this: God’s gifts are never obstacles to holiness. Marriage is one of His good gifts, to be received with thanksgiving and lived faithfully as a vocation.
The article honors the celibate life and then draws the one distinction that governs everything: voluntary celibacy is a gift; mandatory celibacy is a discipline; the Reformers objected only when the discipline bound consciences where God had left freedom. It is the difference between voluntarily renouncing a good gift for a calling and declaring that good gift unfit for those who serve Christ. Celibacy is a gift God gives to some (Matthew 19:11–12; 1 Corinthians 7:7), never a law for all, and those without the gift are commanded to marry (1 Corinthians 7:2, 9). Neither marriage nor the single life earns anything before God, for we are justified neither on account of virginity nor on account of marriage but freely for Christ’s sake (Ap XXIII.36–37).
Historically, married clergy were ordinary for centuries. A fourth-century ascetic ideal hardened, through the Gregorian reform and the Lateran Councils of 1123 and 1139, into the Latin rite’s law that clergy marriages were invalid. The Reformation restored the freedom (Luther married in 1525), and Trent, Session XXIV (1563) reaffirmed celibacy. However, Rome today frames celibacy as a discipline, not a doctrine (Presbyterorum Ordinis 16), and the Catholic communion keeps married clergy of its own. The remaining question is precise: may the Church require celibacy for all Latin-rite priests?
The pastoral heart is the recovery of marriage as a holy calling for every Christian, grounded in creation and the Incarnation: the Son of God entered a human home, and Christianity does not escape creation but redeems it. God does not ask His servants to despise His gifts in order to become holy; He calls them to receive His gifts with thanksgiving and use them faithfully in their vocation. The theology of vows is chapter 27 (AC XXVII), Christian freedom from human traditions chapter 15 (AC XV), and vocation chapter 16 (AC XVI). With Article XXII it forms a pair (Christ’s gifts given to all; God’s gifts no obstacle to holiness) that sets the pattern for Part II.
8.2 Tables
Table 23.1, Clergy Marriage Across Traditions, stands in Appendix C. It sets eight traditions side by side: Lutherans, Anglicans, Methodists, and the Reformed, Baptist, and Evangelical churches permit clergy to marry before or after ordination; the Orthodox, the Eastern Catholic churches, and the Latin rite’s permanent deacons ordain married men but allow no marriage after ordination; and the Latin rite requires celibacy of its priests as a discipline, with dispensation for married convert clergy. (See Appendix C.)
Table 23.2—Discipline vs. Doctrine: How Rome Frames Celibacy
| A discipline (what celibacy is, in Roman teaching) | A doctrine / dogma (what celibacy is not) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A church law regarded as fitting and valuable | A revealed truth binding always and everywhere |
| Can it change? | Yes, in principle; the Church established it and could alter it | No; dogma does not change |
| Does it apply everywhere? | No; the Latin rite only (Eastern Catholics ordain married men) | A dogma binds the whole Church |
| Exceptions? | Yes: permanent deacons, convert clergy, and Eastern Catholic priests | A dogma admits no such exceptions |
| On marriage itself | Marriage is good and holy, a sacrament | (Rome does not teach that marriage is evil or defiling) |
Understanding that Rome classes celibacy as a discipline, not a doctrine, is the key to a fair comparison: the disagreement is whether the Church may require of all its Latin-rite priests a gift God gives only to some, not about the goodness of marriage.
8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)
- Clerical celibacy: the unmarried state required of certain clergy.
- Continence: sexual self-restraint. In the Lutheran Confessions, “the gift of continence” is the God-given ability to live chastely without marriage (Ap XXIII); in the history of clerical discipline, the word also means the abstinence from marital relations once required of married clergy.
- Discipline vs. doctrine: in Roman theology, a changeable church law as distinct from an unchangeable revealed truth.
8.4 Further reading
- The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XXIII; Apology XXIII; Smalcald Articles III.xi.
- Charles Arand, Robert Kolb, and James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3 (marriage; the ministry; adiaphora).
- The Fathers, from their own texts and with care: Jerome, Against Jovinian; Ambrose, On Virginity and On the Duties of the Clergy (read with the cautions noted in §4).
- On the history of clerical celibacy: Herbert Thurston, “Celibacy of the Clergy,” The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 3 (1908); Christian Cochini, The Apostolic Origins of Priestly Celibacy; Stefan Heid, Celibacy in the Early Church; and, on the Eastern discipline, the canons of the Council in Trullo (692).
- For the comparisons, from their own sources: the Council of Trent, Session XXIV; the Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1579–1580 and Presbyterorum Ordinis 16 (celibacy as discipline); the Thirty-Nine Articles, Article XXXII; Timothy Ware, The Orthodox Church, 3rd ed. (Penguin, 2015).
Footnotes
-
Rome’s own sources grant this. The Second Vatican Council says celibacy “is not demanded by the very nature of the priesthood, as is apparent from the practice of the early Church and from the traditions of the Eastern Churches” (Presbyterorum Ordinis 16). The Catholic Encyclopedia allows that “in the Eastern Churches neither priests nor even bishops were bound to separate from their wives,” though it argues that in the West married clergy were bound to continence after ordination (Council of Elvira, which deposed those who “continue to live with their wives and beget children after their ordination”) (Herbert Thurston, “Celibacy of the Clergy,” The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 3 [New York: Robert Appleton, 1908]). The Confession makes the same historical claim: “It is also evident that in the ancient Church priests were married men” (AC XXIII). ↩
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.