Chapter 22—Article XXII: Both Kinds in the Sacrament
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Picture a family gathered at the supper table. The father has cooked the whole meal and he serves all of it to each of his children. He does not set a full plate before the eldest and a half-portion before the youngest, and he does not tell one child, “The bread is for you, but the cup is for your brother.” Whatever else a loving father does, he does not hand his own children a partial share of what he prepared for them. He gives the meal as he made it, to everyone at the table.
We must be careful with that picture. A reader might think that the Christians who once received only the bread were given half a meal of Christ. That would be wrong. As we will see, the Church that gave them the bread alone taught that they received the whole Christ. This chapter is about Christ’s intention for His whole family, that the gift He instituted be given to all His people the way He gave it.
For most of the Church’s history, and in most of the Church today, Christians who come to the Lord’s Supper receive both the bread and the cup. For several centuries in the medieval West, however, the cup was withdrawn from ordinary believers; only the priest drank it, while the people received the bread alone. Article XXII of the Augsburg Confession corrects that practice. It asks that the Supper be given the way the Lord gave it, in both kinds, to all His people. “Both kinds” is the Church’s old name for the two forms of the Sacrament, the bread and the wine. The “laity,” or laypeople, are all the baptized who are not clergy.
The heart of the chapter is this: Christ’s gifts are given completely to all His people exactly as He instituted them. The Reformation invented no new Supper and added nothing of its own. It simply restored the cup to the laypeople from whom a later age had taken it, so that every Christian receives the Sacrament given as Christ gave it. You are not a second-class guest at this Table. What the Lord commanded for all His people is placed into your hands, too.
A word about Part II and how to read it
With this chapter the book crosses a threshold. The first twenty-one articles of the Augsburg Confession set out what we believe: God, sin, Christ, justification, the Church, the Sacraments, and the last things. The seven that remain (AC XXII–XXVIII, which this book calls the “Abuses Corrected” articles) turn to the abuses that had crept into the Church’s practice and the reforms that corrected them. The Confession says so itself: “our churches dissent in no article of the faith from the Church Catholic, but only omit some abuses which are new” (AC, before Art. XXII). These articles are often misread as a list of Protestant complaints. However, a single question runs beneath every one of them, and it is the key to all that follows.
The Reformers did not ask, “What would we like to change?” They asked, “Where have later practices obscured Christ’s institution?”
The Reformers were not innovators hunting for things to overturn. In their own eyes they were conservatives, clearing away later human additions so that Christ’s institution, Christ’s promises, and Christ’s Gospel could stand at the center of the Church’s life again. Whether the matter is the cup (this chapter), the marriage of pastors, the Mass, confession, fasting, monastic vows, or the power of bishops, the question is always the same: Has this later practice clarified what Christ gave, or has it obscured it? This chapter, on the gentlest of the disputed matters, is the place to learn that question, because with it the rest of Part II reads as one coherent effort and not a string of quarrels.
1. What the Article Says
Article XXII is short and almost entirely practical. It makes one claim and supports it from Christ’s command and from the ancient Church. Then it draws a conclusion for consciences.
To the laity are given Both Kinds in the Sacrament of the Lord’s Supper, because this usage has the commandment of the Lord in Matt. 26:27: Drink ye all of it, where Christ has manifestly commanded concerning the cup that all should drink. And lest any man should craftily say that this refers only to priests, Paul in 1 Cor. 11:27 recites an example from which it appears that the whole congregation did use both kinds. And this usage has long remained in the Church, nor is it known when, or by whose authority, it was changed; although Cardinal Cusanus mentions the time when it was approved. Cyprian in some places testifies that the blood was given to the people. The same is testified by Jerome, who says: The priests administer the Eucharist, and distribute the blood of Christ to the people. Indeed, Pope Gelasius commands that the Sacrament be not divided (dist. II., De Consecratione, cap. Comperimus). Only custom, not so ancient, has it otherwise. But it is evident that any custom introduced against the commandments of God is not to be allowed, as the Canons witness (dist. III., cap. Veritate, and the following chapters). But this custom has been received, not only against the Scripture, but also against the old Canons and the example of the Church. Therefore, if any preferred to use both kinds of the Sacrament, they ought not to have been compelled with offense to their consciences to do otherwise. And because the division of the Sacrament does not agree with the ordinance of Christ, we are accustomed to omit the procession, which hitherto has been in use. (AC XXII.1–12, the whole article)
The “procession” in the last sentence was the carrying of the consecrated host through the streets, as on the feast of Corpus Christi. The Reformers dropped it because it carried about one part of the Sacrament apart from the other, which is the very division the article rejects.
Four things are plain on the surface.
The claim is about the laity. No one disputed that the priest received both kinds. The question was whether ordinary believers should receive the cup as well as the bread. Article XXII says yes.
The ground is Christ’s command. The Confession appeals first to the words of institution, not to preference or even to fairness. When Christ gave the cup He said, “Drink of it, all of you” (Matthew 26:27, ESV), and the Reformers took that all to mean what it says. Anticipating the objection that the command was addressed only to the apostles as priests, the article points to Paul, who delivered the same institution to an ordinary congregation at Corinth (1 Corinthians 11:27; AC XXII.3).
The reform is a return and not a novelty. The article insists that the usage of both kinds “has long remained in the Church,” citing Cyprian and Jerome (the blood was given to the people) and Pope Gelasius (the Sacrament must not be divided), and it calls the withholding of the cup a “custom, not so ancient.” The Reformers believed they were restoring the older practice, not breaking with the Church’s tradition.
Consciences are not to be forced. A custom “introduced against the commandments of God is not to be allowed,” the article says, and those who wished to receive both kinds “ought not to have been compelled with offense to their consciences to do otherwise” (AC XXII.9, 11). The Confession does not ask for a privilege. It asks that no Christian be made to act against Christ’s word at His own Table.
Therefore the article’s plain sense is modest: the Lord’s Supper should be given to all Christians in both kinds, because that is how Christ instituted it and how the ancient Church observed it.
2. Biblical Theology
The scriptural case is unusually direct, because it rests on the words of institution themselves, the words the Church repeats at every celebration of the Supper.
The command at the table. “And he took a cup, and when he had given thanks he gave it to them, saying, ‘Drink of it, all of you’” (Matthew 26:27). At the first Supper, Christ hands over the cup with an explicit, universal imperative. He does not say “let the leaders drink”; He says “all of you.” Mark records that the command was obeyed: “and they all drank of it” (Mark 14:23). Matthew goes on to say what the cup gives: “for this is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins” (Matthew 26:28). Luke records the words Christ spoke over the cup: “This cup that is poured out for you is the new covenant in my blood” (Luke 22:20). The cup carries the covenant and the covenant is the forgiveness of sins, poured out “for you.”
The apostolic practice in a whole congregation. The objection was always that Christ spoke those words to His apostles, so that (it was argued) the command belongs to priests and not to people. Paul answers it before it is raised. Writing to the church at Corinth, an ordinary congregation of laypeople, he hands on the institution he “received from the Lord,” including the cup, and then instructs the whole church: “Let a person examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup” (1 Corinthians 11:28). The congregation ate the bread and drank the cup, which Paul assumes as a matter of course. The Augsburg Confession and its Apology make exactly this argument (AC XXII.3; Ap XXII.3). The same apostle names both together as the church’s shared communion: “The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ?” (1 Corinthians 10:16).
The one text pressed the other way. One passage is sometimes brought forward in support of giving the bread alone. In John 6 the Lord promises life to eating alone: “If anyone eats of this bread, he will live forever” (John 6:51; compare 6:58). The Council of Trent cites these verses beside the rest of the discourse. That reasoning belongs to the doctrine of concomitance and we take it up in §5. For now, two points are enough. The same discourse also says, “unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you” (John 6:53), so it cannot be pressed for the bread alone. Nor do Lutherans press it for the cup. The Lutheran Confessions read John 6 as speaking especially of the spiritual eating of faith, that is, receiving Christ by believing His promise, which occurs “with the Spirit and faith, in the preaching and meditation of the Gospel, as well as in the Lord’s Supper” (FC SD VII.61). Therefore the question is settled where the Lord settled it, at the institution, in which Christ hands the cup to His disciples and tells them all to drink.
The biblical shape is therefore simple and hard to evade: Christ instituted the Supper in both kinds and told His disciples that all should drink the cup, and the apostolic church did exactly that.
Has Christ withheld any of His gifts from me? The words over the cup were “poured out for you,” and they were spoken to the whole table.
3. Historical Context
If Scripture and the early Church gave both kinds, how did the cup come to be withheld? The history explains the reform and it explains one of the most powerful symbols in the Reformation’s memory.
The ancient practice: both kinds as the rule. For roughly the first twelve centuries the Church, East and West, ordinarily communed the laity in both kinds at the public liturgy. There were exceptions, such as the sick communed from reserved bread, communion carried home, and infants given the cup alone. Historians broadly agree, however, that these were exceptions and that both kinds was the norm. The Reformers’ claim to be restoring the older way was accurate.
The medieval withdrawal of the cup. Over the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, the Western church gradually withdrew the cup from the laity. The motives were largely reverent. There was a growing fear of spilling the consecrated wine as congregations grew, and practical concerns as well, such as the difficulty of giving one cup safely to a large crowd. To justify the change theologically, medieval theologians leaned on the doctrine of concomitance (explained in §5), and Thomas Aquinas gave it its classic expression (Summa Theologiae III, q. 76, a. 2). On that reasoning, withholding the cup deprived the laity of nothing essential while it reduced the risk of irreverence, and over time an occasional practice became the rule. Two further reasons appear in the sixteenth-century debate. The Confutation argued that when “the heresy arose which taught that both forms were necessary,” the Church “forbade both forms to laymen,” as it sometimes answers a heresy with a contrary rule. The Apology reports that Gabriel Biel counted among the reasons “that a distinction should be made between laymen and presbyters” (Ap XXII.9).
Constance, Hus, and the chalice. The change became formal church law at the Council of Constance in 1415. This was the great council that ended the papal schism. It also condemned the Bohemian reformer Jan Hus, who was then handed to the secular authorities and burned. Constance decreed that the laity should receive in one kind only. It acknowledged that Christ had instituted the Supper in both kinds and that the early Church had received it so, but it held that the later custom “was sensibly introduced in order to avoid various dangers and scandals” and “should be held as a law which nobody may repudiate or alter at will without the church’s permission.”
Hus’s followers in Bohemia would not accept the decree and for them the cup was no mere detail but a banner. They took their name from the Latin for “under both kinds” (sub utraque specie) and called themselves Utraquists. The chalice became the emblem on their seals, shields, and standards (František Šmahel, “The War of Symbols: The Goose and the Chalice Against the Cross,” The Bohemian Reformation and Religious Practice 4, pp. 153–54). To ordinary Bohemian Christians the cup meant that the Supper belonged to them and not to the clergy alone, that they were full members of Christ’s family at His table. More than a century before Luther, the cup had already become a symbol of whether Christ’s gift belonged to the whole people of God. Article XXII was written with that history behind it.
The Reformation restoration, and Trent’s reply. When the Reformers restored the cup, they were not doing something unheard of. They were doing what the ancient Church had ordinarily done and what Hus’s Bohemian followers had demanded for a century. Luther would not have the cup forced on anyone either. In his Invocavit sermons of March 1522, preached after changes had been made at Wittenberg in his absence, he urged that the cup be restored by teaching and not by compulsion, for the sake of weak consciences: though the Sacrament should be received in both kinds, “it must not be made compulsory nor a general law” (Fifth Invocavit Sermon, 13 March 1522, Works of Martin Luther, Philadelphia ed., 2:414).
The Augsburg Confession (1530) states the case calmly. The Apology and the Smalcald Articles speak more sharply, and I want you to see where their severity falls. The Apology distinguishes the people from their teachers: “We indeed excuse the Church which has borne the injury [the poor consciences which have been deprived of one part by force], since it could not obtain both parts; but the authors who maintain that the use of the entire Sacrament is justly prohibited, and who now not only prohibit, but even excommunicate and violently persecute those using an entire Sacrament, we do not excuse” (Ap XXII.16). Luther goes further, writing that “we especially condemn and in God’s name execrate those who not only omit both forms but also quite autocratically [tyrannically] prohibit, condemn, and blaspheme them as heresy, and so exalt themselves against and above Christ, our Lord and God” (SA III.vi.4). That is the Confessions’ judgment on the teaching and practice of the sixteenth century, on those who forbade the cup and punished the people who asked for it. It is not a judgment on Roman Catholics today, many of whom now receive the cup themselves.
Rome answered the Augsburg Confession a generation later, at the Council of Trent, Session XXI (1562). Trent reaffirmed that communion in one kind is licit (permitted by church law), that Christ is wholly received under either species (either form, the bread or the wine), and that the Church has authority over how the sacraments are given out, though not over what they are. It also denied that both kinds are required of the laity by divine command. Trent left the door open, however. It referred the petition of several nations for the cup to the pope (Session XXII), and in 1564 Pius IV allowed it in parts of the Empire for a time.
The modern turn. At the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965) the Roman Catholic Church itself moved to restore the cup to the laity of the Latin rite. Sacrosanctum Concilium (1963) opened the way and later liturgical law extended it, so that in many celebrations of the Mass today Roman Catholic laypeople receive both the bread and the cup. As a result, the practical difference between many Lutheran and Roman Catholic congregations today is much smaller than it was in the sixteenth century. In many parishes, both now do what Article XXII asked. We return in §6 to what this does and does not settle.
4. Early Church Witness
The early Church’s witness here is chiefly to a practice and the practice was both kinds.
Cyprian of Carthage (c. 210–258) testifies that the cup was given to the people. In his writings on the lapsed and in his letters, the laity’s reception of the blood of Christ is simply assumed as the Church’s practice.
Leo the Great (c. 400–461) bears witness indirectly. He warned against the Manichaeans, who refused the cup out of contempt for the material creation (they held wine to be impure). For Leo the ordinary believer received both kinds as a matter of course, and that is why refusing the cup could expose a Manichaean hiding in the congregation.
Pope Gelasius I (bishop of Rome 492–496) is the sharpest witness and the Augsburg Confession cites him by name. He confronted people who took the bread but refused the cup out of a superstitious scruple, most likely the Manichaean one Leo had met, and he declared that to divide “one and the same mystery” could not be done “without great sacrilege.” Roman Catholic writers have answered in two ways. The Confutation (the Roman theologians’ official reply to the Augsburg Confession in 1530), following Gratian’s heading on the canon, replied that “Gelasius speaks of priests, and not of laymen.” Later interpreters have argued that he was rebuking a superstitious refusal of the cup and not a practice ordered by the Church, and that is a fair reading of his occasion. The Reformers’ point stands even so. In the fifth century a bishop of Rome assumed that the faithful drank the cup and called dividing the mystery a sacrilege, and withholding the cup came later.
We are not resting the case on one teacher’s private opinion. The practice of both kinds was broad, ancient, and well attested, while the withdrawal of the cup was a later and largely Western development.
5. Lutheran Confessional Theology
The whole disagreement here turns on one distinction and it has to be stated precisely.
Both kinds, by Christ’s institution. The positive teaching is simply the words of institution taken at face value. Christ gave the Supper in both kinds and told all His disciples to drink the cup; therefore both kinds are given to all His people (AC XXII). The Apology presses the same ground. Christ “instituted both parts… not for a part of the Church, but for the entire Church,” and the Supper is His testament: “if it is not allowable to annul man’s testament, much less will it be allowable to annul the testament of Christ” (Ap XXII.1–2). Fear of spilling, it adds, does not have “force sufficient to change the ordinance of Christ” (Ap XXII.14).
What is concomitance? Rome’s defence of giving the bread alone rested on two claims. The first, its theological rationale, was the doctrine of concomitance. The second was the Church’s authority over how the sacraments are given out (Trent, Session XXI, ch. 2). Concomitance is explained first, because it is the one most often misunderstood. The word comes from the Latin for “to accompany,” and Webster’s 1828 dictionary defines concomitance as “A being together, or in connection with another thing” (Webster’s 1828, “concomitance”). In the Sacrament it means that where Christ’s body is, His blood is with it, and the whole Christ with both. Because the risen Christ is one and indivisible, His whole body, blood, soul, and divinity are present under each element, so that a person who receives only the consecrated bread nevertheless receives the whole Christ and is “not defrauded of any grace necessary to salvation” (Trent, Session XXI, ch. 3). In the Catechism’s words, communion under the bread alone “makes it possible to receive all the fruit of Eucharistic grace” (CCC §1390).
This is often misunderstood. Rome never believed the laity received “half of Christ.” The medieval Church did not think it was handing the people a partial or diminished Sacrament. It believed and taught the opposite, that the layperson who received the host (the consecrated wafer) alone received Christ entirely (body and blood, soul and divinity, the living and undivided Lord). Whatever else is to be said, the charge that Rome starved the laity of grace, or gave them a fraction of Christ, is false. The Lutheran Confessions do not rest their case on denying concomitance. Lutherans, too, confess that Christ is not divided and that the whole Christ is present in the Sacrament. However, the Confessions build nothing on the doctrine either way. Luther says “we do not need that high art” of “the sophists and the Council of Constance,” by which he means their reasoning about concomitance. Then he grants it for argument’s sake: “even if it were true that there is as much under one as under both, yet the one form only is not the entire ordinance and institution [made] ordained and commanded by Christ” (SA III.vi.2–3).
Where the objection actually lies. The Lutheran objection therefore falls on the second claim and not the first. It is about authority, not about the presence. I find it helpful to put it in one sentence:
The Church has no authority to withhold from Christ’s people what Christ Himself instituted and commanded for them all.
The Apology says it in one line: “the Church does not assume to itself the liberty to convert the ordinances of Christ into matters of indifference” (Ap XXII.15). What is commanded is the cup given to all His people. Kneeling or standing, and much else in how the Supper is given, the Church orders in freedom (chapter 15, on Article XV), so long as nothing withholds the gift. Whether the cup should be one common chalice is debated among Lutherans, and Article XXII does not decide it. Suppose we agree with what concomitance protects, that the whole Christ is truly received under the bread alone. Even so, it does not follow that the Church may set aside the Lord’s own institution. Christ did not merely make the cup available; He commanded it: “Drink of it, all of you.” A gift the Giver placed in His people’s hands is not the Church’s to take back, however good the intention. In other words, the Reformers restored the cup not because Christ was absent from the bread alone, but because Christ’s Church is not free to withhold what He freely gave.
Why this is not legalism. Someone might hear all this as a fuss over ceremony. The first answer is that the cup is not a ceremony of the Church’s making at all. It belongs to Christ’s own institution, which is why the Apology will not let it be treated as a matter of indifference. The second answer is pastoral. Fidelity to Christ’s institution does not matter because the ceremony is a work we offer to God (it is not), or because getting the ritual exactly right earns anything from Him (it does not). What gives forgiveness in the Supper is Christ’s own word and promise. Fidelity matters for the reason any love attends to a gift: love delights in receiving a gift exactly as the giver intended.
The gift, given to all. The article’s deepest note is gift rather than correction. The cup that says “poured out for you” is placed into the hands of every believer, young or old, layperson or pastor. No one at this Table receives a reduced portion of what Christ promised. (What the Supper is, the true body and blood of Christ given and shed for the forgiveness of sins, is the subject of chapter 10 [AC X]. Here the concern is only that this gift reach all His people the way He gave it.)
6. Comparative Theology
On this article the striking fact is how much the traditions agree. Both kinds is the practice of the Eastern Church, the Reformation churches, Anglicanism, and Protestantism generally, and increasingly of the Roman Catholic Church itself. The historic outlier was the medieval Latin West and even that has largely changed. We map the traditions from their own sources. (What the Supper is, and the question of the Mass as sacrifice, belong to chapters 10 and 24; this comparison concerns only the distribution of the elements.)
Roman Catholic. Rome teaches that Christ is wholly present and wholly received under each species (concomitance), that communion in one kind is therefore valid and licit, and that the Church has authority over the administration of the sacraments (Council of Trent, Session XXI; Catechism of the Catholic Church §1390). The Catechism adds that “the sign of communion is more complete when given under both kinds, since in that form the sign of the Eucharistic meal appears more clearly” (CCC §1390). Historically this teaching grounded the withholding of the cup in the Latin rite; in the Eastern Catholic Churches (Catholics who follow the Eastern liturgies while in communion with Rome), both kinds is the usual form (CCC §1390). When the Second Vatican Council opened the way to the cup, it did so “the dogmatic principles which were laid down by the Council of Trent remaining intact” (Sacrosanctum Concilium §55, 1963). In other words, Rome gave back the cup without withdrawing Trent’s teaching that the whole Christ is received under the bread alone. Through the liturgical law that followed, the cup has been restored to the laity in many circumstances at the bishop’s discretion, and in many parishes today Roman Catholics receive both kinds. Agreement: the real presence; the whole Christ received; the Supper as Christ’s gift; and, increasingly, both kinds in practice. Divergence: whether both kinds are required for the laity by Christ’s institution, and whether the Church may withhold the cup. The remaining disagreement is chiefly about authority, not practice.
Eastern Orthodox. The Eastern Orthodox Church has always given both kinds and never withdrew the cup, a fact the Reformers themselves pointed to (Ap XXII.4). In the Divine Liturgy the consecrated bread is placed in the chalice and both are given together from a spoon (in Greek, labis), a practice Western writers often call intinction. The Orthodox commune all who have been baptized and chrismated, “including small children and infants” (Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. 2, “Communion”). Agreement: both kinds for all, strong and ancient. Divergence: chiefly the mode. Both elements are given to every communicant, though from a spoon rather than a separate cup.
Anglican. The Anglican tradition administers both kinds to the laity on the same ground the Lutherans do. Its historic formulary, Article XXX of the Thirty-Nine Articles (“Of both Kinds”), states: “The Cup of the Lord is not to be denied to the Lay-people: for both the parts of the Lord’s Sacrament, by Christ’s ordinance and commandment, ought to be ministered to all Christian men alike.” Anglicans of every school, whatever weight they give the Articles, administer both kinds. Agreement: strong; both kinds, by Christ’s institution.
Methodist. The Methodist Articles of Religion, John Wesley’s abridgment of the Anglican Articles, say the same: “The cup of the Lord is not to be denied to the lay people; for both the parts of the Lord’s Supper, by Christ’s ordinance and commandment, ought to be administered to all Christians alike” (Article XIX). Agreement: strong; both kinds, by Christ’s ordinance.
Reformed, Baptist, and Evangelical. These traditions distribute both elements to every communicant (the bread and the cup, whether wine or grape juice). The Reformed and Baptist confessions name the withholding of the cup as an error. Westminster lists “the denial of the cup to the people” among practices “contrary to the nature of this sacrament, and to the institution of Christ” (WCF 29.4), and the Second London Baptist Confession (1689) says the same of “this ordinance” (30.4). Agreement: large; both kinds for all. Their differences from the Lutheran confession concern the understanding of the Supper rather than its distribution. The Reformed confess a true but spiritual feeding on Christ by faith (Westminster Confession 29.7), many Baptists and Evangelicals a memorial of His death, and the Lutherans the true body and blood under the bread and wine. Chapter 10 takes up that question.
The shape of the comparison. On the narrow question of Article XXII (should the laity receive both kinds?) the answer across the traditions is now very nearly unanimous: yes. In practice, the sixteenth-century dispute has largely been resolved in the direction the Reformers urged. What remains between Lutherans and Rome is the underlying question of authority. May the Church alter what Christ instituted for His people? That question does not vanish with the restored chalice and it returns in the chapters ahead (the Mass, chapter 24; the power of bishops, chapter 28).
7. Pastoral and Practical Significance
This doctrine belongs at the rail, with the hand that receives the cup and the ear that hears “shed for you.” Every argument in this chapter exists to protect that moment, so that you, an ordinary Christian with nothing to commend you but your need, may take the cup Christ gives and hear that His blood was poured out for you, for the forgiveness of your sins.
In defending the people’s cup the Reformers were defending the people’s place at Christ’s table. This is why the article is not, in the end, “the chapter about the cup.” It is the chapter about receiving Christ’s gifts exactly as He intended, and the cup is simply the clearest illustration of the principle. The same instinct that restored the chalice runs through the whole Christian life. God’s gifts are not reserved for a spiritual elite or for the specially devout. The Word, Baptism, absolution, and the Supper are given, whole, to every believer. When your conscience is troubled, go where Christ has promised to be found, to the preaching of His Word, to the water of your Baptism, to the absolution your pastor speaks in His name, and to His Table.
That reframes the anxious question you may carry to the Table without ever speaking it: Is this really for me? Am I too ordinary, too weak, or too far back in the line to receive the whole of what Christ gives? Article XXII answers with the cup itself, placed in the hand. Christ’s gifts are given completely to all His people exactly as He instituted them. He has kept nothing back, and there is no inner circle to whom His gifts are given more fully than to you.
Some of you cannot drink from the cup, because of illness or because wine has been a snare to you. Article XXII forbids the Church to withhold the cup; it does not condemn a believer who cannot take it. The Apology excused even the people from whom the cup was kept by force, and the fault it named was the withholding (Ap XXII.16). Speak with your pastor about how the Sacrament can be given to you.
Has Christ withheld any of His gifts from me? Come to the Table and see, for the words spoken over the cup are spoken to you.
8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading
8.1 Summary
Article XXII, the first of the articles on abuses corrected, restores the cup to the laity. The Lord’s Supper is given to all Christians in both kinds, because Christ instituted it so and commanded “Drink of it, all of you” (Matthew 26:27), and because the ancient Church observed it so (Cyprian and Jerome; Leo against the Manichaeans; Pope Gelasius, who called dividing the Sacrament a “sacrilege”). No Christian’s conscience is to be forced to receive otherwise. The center of the article is a gift: Christ’s gifts are given completely to all His people exactly as He instituted them. The Supper is for every believer: the body and blood of Christ for the forgiveness of sins, so that none is a second-class guest at the Table.
The medieval West withdrew the cup over the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, chiefly from fear of spilling, and justified the change by concomitance, the teaching that the whole Christ is present under each element. The Council of Constance (1415), which also condemned Jan Hus, made communion in one kind law, and Hus’s Bohemian followers, the Utraquists, made the chalice their banner. Trent (Session XXI, 1562) reaffirmed that communion in one kind is lawful and that both kinds are not required of the laity by divine command. Since the Second Vatican Council (Sacrosanctum Concilium §55, 1963), Rome has restored the chalice to the laity of the Latin rite in many settings, so the practical difference today is much smaller than in the sixteenth century.
Rome never believed the laity received “half of Christ,” and the Lutheran Confessions do not rest their case on denying concomitance (Luther grants it for argument’s sake, SA III.vi). The Lutheran objection therefore does not accuse Rome of denying Christ. It concerns authority: the Church has no authority to withhold what Christ instituted for all His disciples. The Reformers restored the cup not because Christ was absent from the bread alone, but because Christ’s Church is not free to withhold what He freely gave. Fidelity to Christ’s institution is gratitude and not legalism: faith clings to the gift where Christ promised to give it, and love delights in receiving a gift exactly as the giver intended.
On the practice the traditions now nearly agree. Both kinds is the norm in the East (from the chalice by a spoon), among Anglicans (Thirty-Nine Articles, XXX) and Methodists (Articles of Religion, XIX), and across Protestantism; the remaining disagreement with Rome is chiefly about authority, not practice. The chapter keeps to distribution. The real presence is chapter 10 (AC X) and the Mass as sacrifice is chapter 24 (AC XXIV). As the door into Part II, it teaches the reforming method that governs all that follows: the Reformers did not ask “What would we like to change?” but “Where have later practices obscured Christ’s institution?” The cup is the gentlest first case of a gift given as Christ gave it.
8.2 Tables
Table 22.1—Communion in One Kind vs. Both Kinds: History and Rationale
| Both kinds (the Lutheran Reformers, and the ancient Church) | One kind for the laity (the medieval West) | |
|---|---|---|
| What the laity receive | The bread and the cup | The host (the consecrated wafer) alone |
| Rationale | Christ’s institution and command: “Drink of it, all of you” (Matthew 26:27); the ancient practice | Concomitance: the whole Christ is present under each element; reverence (fear of spilling); the Church’s authority over administration |
| Key authority | Scripture; Cyprian; Jerome; Gelasius; AC XXII | Council of Constance (1415); Council of Trent, Session XXI (1562) |
| On the presence | The whole Christ is present and received | The whole Christ is present and received (not “half of Christ”) |
| Current practice | The norm across Protestantism, Anglicanism, and the East | Rome has restored the cup to the laity of the Latin rite in many settings since Vatican II (1963) |
The disagreement is not about whether the whole Christ is received, but about the Church’s authority to withhold what Christ instituted for all.
Table 22.2—How the Elements Are Distributed Across Traditions
| Tradition | Both kinds to the laity? | Mode | Primary source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lutheran | Yes | Bread, then a separate cup (common or individual) | AC XXII (both kinds); the mode of the cup varies in practice |
| Eastern Orthodox | Yes, always | Together, from the chalice by a spoon | The Divine Liturgy |
| Anglican | Yes | Bread, then the cup | Thirty-Nine Articles, XXX |
| Methodist | Yes | Bread, then the cup | Articles of Religion, XIX |
| Reformed / Baptist / Evangelical | Yes | Bread, then the cup (wine or juice) | Westminster Confession 29.4; Second London Baptist Confession 30.4; common practice |
| Roman Catholic | Latin rite: historically the host alone; since Vatican II, both kinds in many settings. Eastern Catholic Churches: both kinds, as the usual form | Latin rite: host; the chalice at the bishop’s discretion (or by intinction). Eastern Catholic: from the chalice by a spoon, as in the Orthodox Churches | Trent Sess. XXI; Sacrosanctum Concilium §55; General Instruction of the Roman Missal |
On the practice of both kinds, the traditions now largely agree; the historic exception (the medieval Latin West) has itself substantially restored the cup.
8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)
- Concomitance: the whole Christ present under each element.
- Communion in one kind / both kinds: the bread alone, or the bread and the cup.
- Utraquism: communion in both kinds (sub utraque specie); the Hussite chalice.
- Intinction: the bread dipped in the wine; Western writers also use the word for the Orthodox practice of giving both together from a spoon.
- Species: the outward form (bread; wine).
8.4 Further reading
- The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XXII; Apology XXII; Smalcald Articles III.vi; Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration VII.
- Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3 (the Lord’s Supper; both kinds).
- The Fathers and early witnesses, from their own texts: Cyprian, On the Lapsed and Letters; Leo the Great, Sermons (against the Manichaeans); Pope Gelasius I, Comperimus (in Gratian, Decretum, De Consecratione dist. II).
- On the history of the cup and the Hussite chalice, František Šmahel, “The War of Symbols: The Goose and the Chalice Against the Cross,” The Bohemian Reformation and Religious Practice 4; the decree of the Council of Constance, Session 13 (in Tanner, Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils).
- For the comparisons, from their own sources: the Council of Trent, Session XXI (“On Communion under Both Species”), and the Catechism of the Catholic Church §1390; the Second Vatican Council, Sacrosanctum Concilium §55, and the General Instruction of the Roman Missal; the Thirty-Nine Articles, XXX; the Methodist Articles of Religion, XIX; the Westminster Confession of Faith, ch. 29, and the Second London Baptist Confession, ch. 30; on the Divine Liturgy, Timothy Ware, The Orthodox Church, 3rd ed. (Penguin, 2015).
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.