Books · The Augsburg Compass

Chapter 14—Article XIV: Church Order (The Called and Ordained Ministry)

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Picture an installation service on an ordinary Sunday. A congregation has gathered, a man kneels, older pastors lay hands on his head, and words are spoken over him. To a visitor it can look like a small ceremony, a warm welcome for the new minister. However, something larger is happening, and it is the congregation that is saying it. In effect the people are declaring: we did not go out and hire a religious celebrity, and this man did not appoint himself over us. We called someone to serve Christ’s gifts among us (the preaching, the Baptism, the Supper, the word of forgiveness), and he stands here not on his own authority, but on Christ’s.

That is the whole of Article XIV, and on the page it is smaller than almost any other article of the Augsburg Confession: a single sentence. That sentence answers a question the last chapters have been pressing toward. Article V said that God instituted the office of preaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments as the very means through which the Holy Spirit creates faith (chapter 5). Article XI said that through that office Christ personally speaks forgiveness (“your sins are forgiven”) to the troubled conscience (chapter 11). Article XIV now asks the next, unavoidable question: how do I know the man doing these things is authorized to do them? How do I know I am hearing Christ’s Word, and not merely one person’s opinions?

The Confession’s answer is the doctrine of the call. It is easy to hear “the doctrine of the ministry” and expect a discussion of clergy, rank, and power. Article XIV, however, exists to move the reader’s confidence in the opposite direction, away from the personality of the minister and back to the promise of Christ who sends him. In the end it is one more chapter about the certainty of the Gospel, here the certainty that the Gospel handed to you really is Christ’s, delivered by one Christ has rightly called.


1. What the Article Says

Article XIV is a single sentence:

Of Ecclesiastical Order they teach that no one should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments unless he be regularly called. (AC XIV)

What does “regularly” mean here? It does not mean “often.” It is the old sense, “according to rule” (Latin regula, a rule). The Latin for “regularly called” is rite vocatus (“rightly called,” called through right order). We will use the plain English from here on: called through the Church. Two small words carry most of the sentence’s weight.

The first is “publicly.” The article does not say that only clergy may speak of Christ, teach their children, or comfort a neighbor with the Gospel; every Christian may and must do those things (§5). Article XIV governs the public exercise of the office: standing up in the assembly, on behalf of the whole congregation, to preach and to administer the Sacraments. That is the act which requires a call.

The second is “called.” No one helps himself to this office. The minister does not install himself on the strength of his own gifts, his own zeal, or a private conviction that God has spoken to him alone. He is called through the Church, which acts here as the instrument of God’s own calling.

That one word guards against two dangers. The first is the self-made preacher who needs no call because he is sure of his own gifts; against him the article says that no one sends himself. The second is the office turned into a caste, a class of men whose power rests in themselves rather than in the Word they are called to serve; against it the article says that no minister stands above Christ’s Church. Article XIV walks between the two. Its ministry is neither self-appointed nor self-important: a man is called through the Church, to serve the Church.


2. Biblical Theology

Scripture never pictures the ministry as a position a gifted person takes for himself. It pictures it as a sending and an appointment, a gift given and always something received.

No one runs unsent. Paul’s classic chain runs backward from faith to its source. People call on the Lord because they believe, they believe because they hear, and they hear because someone preaches. Then comes Paul’s last question: “And how are they to preach unless they are sent?” (Romans 10:15, ESV). The last link is a sending. Paul’s verb is apostellō, the root of our word apostle. Thayer’s defines it “properly, to send off, send away,” and first of all “to order (one) to go to a place appointed” (Thayer, Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, s.v. ἀποστέλλω). The one who is sent, then, goes to the place appointed for him, a place he did not choose for himself. Faith comes from hearing the Word (Romans 10:17), and the Word comes through a preacher who has been sent. Paul does not yet say how one is sent (the question of church order), but the principle is fixed: the preacher stands under a commission, and the message he carries is Christ’s.

All things in order. When Corinth had turned its worship into a contest of spiritual gifts, Paul’s summary rule was simple: “all things should be done decently and in order” (1 Corinthians 14:40). Paul does not silence the congregation (“For you can all prophesy one by one,” 1 Corinthians 14:31), but he will not let it become a contest of voices. “Rightly called” is that same order applied to the public preaching and the altar.

Ministers are appointed with prayer and against a standard. The apostolic pattern is that ministers are set into office through an orderly process. Paul leaves Titus in Crete “so that you might put what remained into order, and appoint elders in every town” (Titus 1:5). He and Barnabas “appointed elders for them in every church,” and “with prayer and fasting they committed them to the Lord in whom they had believed” (Acts 14:23), the seed of what the Church would call ordination. The office also carries public qualifications (1 Timothy 3:1–7). In other words, the call is examined, prayed over, and conferred by the Church against a standard.

The ministry is Christ’s gift. The ministry is a gift of the ascended Lord: “he gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry” (Ephesians 4:11–12). The office is Christ’s provision rather than a human invention, which guards at once against clericalism and against despising the ministry. Its purpose is to equip the saints, so that the whole body grows up into Christ.

A whole people of priests. This brings us to the doctrine that might seem to make the office unnecessary. Peter lays words once spoken of Israel on the whole Church: “you are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people for his own possession, that you may proclaim the excellencies of him who called you out of darkness into his marvelous light” (1 Peter 2:9). Every baptized Christian is a priest, with access to the Father through the one Mediator, Christ Jesus (1 Timothy 2:5), and with a calling to proclaim Christ. This is the great Reformation recovery, and it is the text most often misread as though it abolished the public office (“if we are all priests, who needs pastors?”). Read in context, with the Church as living stones built into a spiritual house (1 Peter 2:4–10), it says something corporate, and far from competing with the office, it grounds it (§5).


3. Historical Context

Article XIV is, in origin, a defensive article, and knowing what it defended clears away a common misunderstanding.

Rome had accused the evangelicals (as the Lutheran reformers called themselves, from evangelium, “gospel”) of tearing down the ministry by ordaining men without lawful authority, letting anyone preach, and abolishing the priesthood. Article XIV is the flat denial: on the contrary, we require an orderly call. The same sentence also answers opponents of a very different kind, on the radical wing of the Reformation. Some were enthusiasts, who trusted an inner word of the Spirit apart from the external Word (the error Article V had already condemned, AC V.4; compare Ap XIII.13). Others were the self-appointed “corner-preachers” Luther warned against, who slipped into parishes uncalled. Not every radical fits that picture. The Swiss Brethren (an early Anabaptist group) required in their Schleitheim Confession (1527) that a congregation choose its shepherd. The article therefore answers both at once. To Rome it says that the evangelicals keep an ordered, called ministry; to the enthusiasts it says that the ministry is not thrown open to anyone who feels moved. Rome’s Confutation received the article only in its own sense: he is “rightly called who is called in accordance with the form of law and the ecclesiastical ordinances and decrees hitherto observed everywhere in the Christian world.” The Apology sums up that answer: they receive the article, “but with the proviso that we employ canonical ordination” (Ap XIV.1).

Many readers will be surprised to learn that the reformers wanted to keep the bishops. In the Apology Melanchthon answers that “it is our greatest wish to maintain church-polity and the grades in the Church… even though they have been made by human authority,” provided the bishops “allow our doctrine and receive our priests” (Ap XIV.1). It was the bishops who forced the break, he says, because they “compel our priests to reject and condemn this kind of doctrine… or… put to death the poor innocent men” (Ap XIV.2). The Lutherans “will gladly maintain ecclesiastical and canonical government, provided the bishops only cease to rage against our Churches” (Ap XIV.5).1 On the Lutheran telling, the break was forced on them by the bishops’ refusal. This is why Lutheranism is not, in its own self-understanding, an anti-episcopal movement. It was reforming the Church it had received, not inventing a new one.

When the bishops would not ordain evangelical pastors, the reformers acted on a principle they found in Scripture and the Fathers. The ministry and the “keys” (Christ’s authority to forgive and to retain sins, which chapter 11 treated) were given to the whole Church and not to one order alone, so the churches themselves had the right to call and ordain their ministers (Tr 66–69, 72; compare SA III.x.1–3). The results varied, exactly as the principle would predict. In Sweden the historic line of bishops was retained unbroken; in much of Germany, where the bishops were hostile, the reformers governed through superintendents and councils (a consistorial arrangement). The doctrine was the same in both places and the form was left free. (A generation later the Council of Trent would define the Roman doctrine against them: Holy Orders a sacrament imprinting a character (a permanent mark on the soul; see §5), with a hierarchy of bishops, priests, and ministers instituted by divine ordinance. We weigh it in §6.)


4. Early Church Witness

On this article I think the Fathers must be read with special care, for the same texts are claimed by the churches that require episcopal succession and by the reformers who did not. The picture is one of development, and each Father should be heard in his own place.

Clement of Rome (c. 96) gives the earliest witness to an ordered ministry. Writing to quiet a revolt in Corinth, where a faction had deposed its faithful presbyters, he appeals to good order: the apostles appointed leaders and provided for an orderly succession after them, so that the office would not depend on a congregation’s moods. This supports Article XIV’s insistence on a rightly ordered call against the self-appointed, though Clement still uses “bishop” (episkopos, “overseer”) and “presbyter” (presbyteros, “elder”) interchangeably, with no single ruling bishop over the rest.

Ignatius of Antioch (c. 107), a little later, gives the first clear picture of the threefold ministry (one bishop, a council of presbyters, and deacons), urging the churches to “do nothing without the bishop” (Philadelphians 7.2; compare Trallians 2.2–3.1 and Magnesians 6.1). This is early evidence for episcopal order. However, Ignatius’s bishop oversees a single local congregation, not a region, and the later hierarchy cannot simply be read back into him.

Cyprian of Carthage (c. 250) gives the strongest early witness the episcopal traditions cite. He held a high doctrine of the bishop as the center and guarantee of the Church’s unity, from whom one cannot tear away without tearing the Church (On the Unity of the Church 5; Letter 66.8, numbered 68 in the Ante-Nicene Fathers). His episcopate, however, is collegial, a fellowship of equal bishops. He honored the church of Rome as the chair of Peter and the source of the Church’s unity. Even so, he openly resisted Stephen, the bishop of Rome in his day, when he thought him wrong. Scholars still debate the two surviving versions of the chapter on Peter in his On the Unity of the Church, and so how much he gave to Rome.

Jerome (c. 400), coming last, is the Father the reformers cited most. Writing centuries into the development, he still testifies that presbyter and bishop were originally one and the same. The elevation of one bishop over the presbyters came, he says, “more by custom than by the truth of the Lord’s appointment” (Commentary on Titus 1:5, Patrologia Latina 26:563, translated here), and it was done “to remedy schism” (Letter 146). In that letter he also grants that ordination was by then the bishop’s alone: “For what function, excepting ordination, belongs to a bishop that does not also belong to a presbyter?” In other words, by Jerome’s day a bishop and a presbyter were alike in everything except ordaining. The Treatise quotes that very letter, exception and all (Tr 62). It still concludes that the grades of bishop and pastor are distinct only “by human authority,” so that ordination by a pastor “in his own church is valid by divine law” (Tr 63–65). This is why the reformers could hold presbyteral ordination (ordination by pastors, without a bishop) valid and the episcopal form, however ancient and useful, not of divine necessity.

Two conclusions follow, and Article XIV keeps them in order. The early Church clearly held to an ordered ministry with a succession from the apostles, which is solid ground against the self-sent. However, it did not hold from the first that one particular form of that order was essential to a valid ministry. The monarchical bishop (one bishop ruling over the other presbyters of a city) emerged over time, and Jerome could still point to Scripture to show that things had once been otherwise. The Fathers settle that the ministry must be orderly and apostolic far more clearly than which form it must take.


5. Lutheran Confessional Theology

The Lutheran teaching gathers into three claims: the call is required and comes through the Church; the office is Christ’s institution while its form is the Church’s freedom; and the priesthood of all believers, far from abolishing the office, is what authorizes the Church to call. All three serve the pastoral center, that the hearer may be certain he receives Christ’s gifts.

Called through the Church, and by God through the Church. Article XIV requires that no one preach or administer the Sacraments publicly unless he is called through right order. Who, then, does the calling? God does, and God issues His call, as He does nearly everything else in the Christian life, through means: the Church that examines, calls, and ordains. This is the same instinct that runs through the whole Confession, that God works through His appointed external means. The apostles received what theologians call an immediate call, meaning one with nothing in between (not “instant”). It came straight from God’s mouth and was attested by miracles. The ongoing ministry receives a mediate call, one that comes through a go-between, for it is God’s summons delivered through His Church. A man who claims the apostles’ kind of call for himself, bypassing the Church because he has heard directly, is in the Bible’s own image running unsent (compare Jeremiah 23:21).

The office is Christ’s institution; the outward form is the Church’s freedom. That the Church has a ministry of Word and Sacrament is not up for debate. God instituted it (Article V), and it stands by divine right. How that ministry is ordered, whether by bishops, by assemblies of elders, or by the local congregation, is a matter of good order and Christian freedom. Its polity (the way a church is governed: who decides, and who ordains) is to be arranged for the sake of the Gospel and honored where it serves the Gospel, but never treated as though God had commanded one form for all time (Ap XIV.1; SA III.x.1; Tr 63–65). This position follows directly from the distinction between what God instituted and what He left free. It is why the reformers could keep the bishops in Sweden and do without them in Germany with an equally clear conscience. The ministry was intact in both.

The priesthood of all believers: the ground of the call, not its rival. The priesthood of all believers is one of the most beautiful doctrines the Reformation recovered and one of the most misunderstood. Because all the baptized are priests (1 Peter 2:9), it is often supposed that the priesthood of all believers makes the pastoral office unnecessary. If all are priests, why call any to preach? I want you to see that the Confession says something close to the reverse. The priesthood of all believers is what gives the Church the authority to call pastors (Tr 67–69).

The Treatise sets out the reasoning. Christ gave the keys “to the Church, and not merely to certain persons” (Tr 68). He gave the Church pastors and teachers as His gift (Ephesians 4:11; Tr 67). Because the whole Church is a royal priesthood, it “certainly has the right to elect and ordain ministers since it alone has the priesthood” (Tr 69). In other words, the Church may call pastors precisely because all its members are priests. Not all may exercise the keys publicly at once, for Christ Himself gave the office (Ephesians 4:11), and “all things should be done decently and in order” (1 Corinthians 14:40). Therefore the priestly people calls certain of its members into the office Christ gave it, to exercise publicly, in Christ’s name (Ap VII–VIII.28) and on behalf of all (Tr 67–69), the gifts that belong to all. The pastor is not a priest of a higher order than the people; he is a member of the priestly people, publicly called to do among them, in good order, what Christ has given to the whole body.

The priesthood is not idle while the pastor preaches. Every Christian is called “to offer spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ” (1 Peter 2:5), prays “for all people” (1 Timothy 2:1), and speaks the Gospel to the neighbor. The Smalcald Articles count “the mutual conversation and consolation of brethren” among the ways the Gospel gives counsel and aid against sin (SA III.iv). In an emergency the Word does not wait for the office, for the Treatise says that “in a case of necessity even a layman absolves, and becomes the minister and pastor of another” (Tr 67), and any Christian may baptize a dying child. The public office serves that Word.

This answers two common errors. Against “the priesthood of all believers means we need no pastors,” the Confession insists that the public office is God’s institution and not a human option (Article V; Ephesians 4:11). Against the opposite reduction, that the pastor is merely a functionary the congregation hires and may unmake at pleasure, it insists that the office is Christ’s, even though the call to it comes through the Church. The office serves the priesthood, and the priesthood calls pastors into the office Christ gave.

Ordination, rightly understood. The Lutherans kept ordination (the laying on of hands, with prayer) as the Church’s public act of placing a called man into the office (SA III.x.3; Tr 66–67, 70). For them it was the Church’s public ratification of the call. In the early Church, the Treatise says, the bishop “confirmed the one elected by the laying on of hands; and ordination was nothing else than such a ratification” (Tr 70). They did not understand it as placing him in a priesthood “like the Levitical, to sacrifice for the people” (Ap XIII.7), the priesthood of the Old Testament sons of Levi who offered sacrifices in the temple. Luther rejected the scholastic teaching that ordination imprints an indelible character (a permanent spiritual mark on the soul) in The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520), but the Confessions themselves are silent on the character. What the Church has in the ministry into which it ordains is God’s command and promise. The Apology says that the Church has the command to appoint ministers, “which should be most pleasing to us, because we know that God approves this ministry, and is present in the ministry” (Ap XIII.12). The Apology will even call ordination a sacrament, “if ordination be understood as applying to the ministry of the Word,” because “the ministry of the Word has God’s command and glorious promises” (Ap XIII.11–12; on the number of the sacraments, see chapter 13).

The two dangers are therefore answered together. The self-appointed man is ruled out, because no one may take this office to himself; he must be called through the Church. The self-important caste is ruled out, because the office holds no treasure that does not already belong to the whole priestly people; it is Christ’s appointed way of handing that treasure out among them. The minister serves what belongs to all, and his authority is borrowed from the Word, never lodged in his person.

Who sent him? God did, through the Church, which is a priesthood calling one of its own to serve the rest in good order.


6. Comparative Theology

Church order is one of the most visibly divided areas of Christendom, and the divisions are real, though they do not fall where many expect. I want to say two things first.

First, on the dignity of the pastoral office, the Lutheran stands much closer to Rome, Orthodoxy, and Anglicanism than to many free-church traditions. The Lutheran holds a high view of the office as a divine institution, entered by the Church’s call and ratified by ordination, through which Christ Himself acts. The disagreements that follow are not the disagreement of a “low” church with a “high” one.

Second, the phrase apostolic succession means two different things, and it helps to separate them. It can mean an unbroken chain of episcopal consecrations, hands on heads back to the apostles (sometimes called tactile succession, or the succession of hands). It can also mean faithful continuity in the apostles’ doctrine, the Gospel handed on intact. All agree that the ministry must be continuous with the apostles, so the real question between the traditions is not the flat “does succession matter?” It is rather this: what must continue—the hands, or the Gospel?

Roman Catholic. The Roman Catholic Church teaches that Holy Orders (its name for ordination) is a sacrament conferring an indelible character, in three degrees (bishop, priest, and deacon), and that apostolic succession through the bishops is essential to a valid ministry. The ministerial priesthood and the common priesthood of the baptized “differ from one another in essence and not only in degree” (Lumen Gentium 10, from the Second Vatican Council), that is, in kind and not merely in rank, though the Catechism adds at once that “the ministerial priesthood is at the service of the common priesthood” (CCC §1547; see also Trent, Session XXIII; Catechism §§1536–1600). The agreement is substantial: the ministry is divinely willed, an orderly call and ordination are required, and continuity with the apostles matters. The divergence is precise, and it is not that Lutherans think the office less holy. It is, first, whether ordination creates a distinct sacramental order of priests marked off from the laity by an indelible character. The Lutheran says no: the office is a ministry Christ instituted (AC V) and the Church confers by its call, and the one who holds it remains one of the priestly people rather than entering a distinct sacramental order. It is, second, whether the succession of hands is essential to validity. Rome keeps the hands for the sake of the Gospel, for “in order that the full and living Gospel might always be preserved in the Church the apostles left bishops as their successors” (CCC §77). The Lutheran honors that purpose and still says no, because the Gospel’s continuity does not depend on the succession of hands. The sacrificing priesthood tied to the Mass, and the papacy under which this structure is ordered, belong to later chapters (29 and 33).

Eastern Orthodox. The Eastern Orthodox Church holds the threefold ministry in apostolic succession, ordination as a sacred mystery, and governance by the shared counsel of bishops rather than a single universal head (Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. 2, Worship, “Holy Orders”). The Confession of Dositheus (1672) states the point at full strength: the bishop is “so necessary in the Church, that without him, neither Church nor Christian could either be or be spoken of” (Decree 10). The people have their part as well. When the bishop presents the newly ordained to them, they answer Axios! (“He is worthy!”), and the Lutheran hears in that acclamation his own conviction that the call comes through the Church. Orthodoxy agrees with Rome here, and with the Lutheran on the high view of the office. It parts from the Lutheran on whether episcopal succession, which Orthodoxy does not separate from the Church’s continuing faith, is necessary to a true ministry.

Anglican. The Anglican tradition retains the historic episcopate and holds that no man may “take upon him the office of publick preaching, or ministering the Sacraments in the Congregation, before he be lawfully called, and sent to execute the same,” and counts as lawfully called those “chosen and called to this work by men who have publick authority given unto them in the Congregation, to call and send Ministers into the Lord’s vineyard” (Thirty-Nine Articles XXIII). The Chicago–Lambeth Quadrilateral (1886–1888), the Anglican statement of four things necessary for the reunion of the churches, names the historic episcopate, “locally adapted in the methods of its administration,” as one of them. On the call, this is close to the Lutheran line.2 The Ordinal (the Anglican services for ordaining bishops, priests, and deacons) adds that “from the Apostles’ time there have been these Orders of Ministers in Christ’s Church; Bishops, Priests, and Deacons,” and every Anglican church requires episcopal ordination of its clergy. Anglicans differ on why. Anglo-Catholics hold the historic episcopate to be of the very being (esse) of the Church. Others, many evangelicals among them, hold it to be for the Church’s well-being (bene esse), and they stand very near the Lutheran position. Still others speak of its fullness (plene esse), a position between the two.

Reformed and Presbyterian. The Reformed churches order the ministry through assemblies of elders (presbyteries), with parity (equal rank) among ministers and no separate order of bishops; ordination is by the presbytery (Calvin, Institutes IV.3; the Westminster standards). The Reformed agree with the Lutheran that the call comes through the Church and that ordination is required, and, sharing Jerome’s reading, they deny the necessity of episcopal succession. The difference is that many Presbyterians regard presbyterian polity itself as divinely prescribed (ius divinum), a firmer claim than the Lutheran “the form is free.”

Methodist. American Methodism (the United Methodist Church, for example) keeps a connectional episcopacy (bishops who oversee a network, or “connection,” of congregations and assign their pastors) without treating the succession of hands as essential to validity. British Methodism has no bishops and ordains through the Conference (the yearly assembly of its ministers and lay representatives). Wesley himself, persuaded that presbyter and bishop were one order, ordained for America as a presbyter in 1784. The Methodist Articles of Religion leave out Article XXIII.

Baptist and Congregationalist. In congregational polity, the local gathered congregation calls, examines, and sets apart its own officers in “the way appointed by Christ” (Second London Baptist Confession [2LBCF] 26.9; Baptist Faith and Message [BFM], Article VI). Congregations confer in associations for counsel, without any body holding jurisdiction over them (Second London Baptist Confession 26.15; Baptist Faith and Message, Article XIV). The agreement here is often overlooked. Like the Lutheran, the Baptist rejects a hierarchy of succession, confesses the pastoral office as Christ’s appointment, and insists that the call come through the Church (here the local congregation) and be publicly examined. The difference is the locus of the call, the absence of any wider order, and what ordination is.

Pentecostal and independent. Among Pentecostal churches, the weight falls on the Spirit’s call and demonstrated gifting, but the larger bodies test that call through formal examination and credentialing by a district or general council (the Assemblies of God [AG], for example, moves from certification to license to ordination). The Church of God in Christ (COGIC) is the exception, governed by bishops. Independent and non-denominational congregations vary widely, and many follow a congregational or elder-led pattern.

Who may be called. Article XIV speaks of how a person is called, not of who (as to man or woman) may be called. Faithful Lutheran churches differ on who may hold the pastoral office. Because Article XIV addresses the necessity of an orderly call rather than the qualifications for those called, this chapter will not attempt to resolve that debate. Where it speaks of “a called man” or says “he,” it follows the Confession’s own language and does not settle the question. Our concern is the orderly call itself, and the certainty it gives to the one who receives Christ’s gifts.

Beneath the visible divisions lies a deeper agreement, that the minister is sent and not self-made. The Lutheran names the sender as Christ, working through His Church, with the outward form left free.


7. Pastoral and Practical Significance

Return to the installation service, and ask whom it is for. It is easy to assume such a service is for the pastor: his day and his recognition. Article XIV points the other way. The call is, first, for the congregation, and that means it is for you. The doctrine of the call exists primarily so that Christians may receive Christ’s gifts with confidence.

Think of what changes for you in the pew. When the pastor rises to preach, the question that matters is not whether he is eloquent or dull, magnetic or plain, but whether he brings Christ’s Word. The call assures you that he has been sent to bring it, so that his preaching and absolution are spoken in Christ’s stead. What he preaches is still measured by the Scriptures. The Apology says plainly that “impious teachers are to be deserted [are not to be received or heard], because these do not act any longer in the place of Christ, but are antichrists” (Ap VII–VIII.48). However, when he says “your sins are forgiven,” the weight of that word rests not on his personality or his private holiness but on Christ, who authorized the office and works through it (chapter 11). When he places the bread in your hand, you receive it from the Lord who sent him. The Apology says that because of the call of the Church, ministers “represent the person of Christ, and do not represent their own persons” (Ap VII–VIII.28), as Christ said, “The one who hears you hears me” (Luke 10:16). Article XIV moves your confidence off the minister and onto Christ.

That distinction, between confidence in the minister and confidence in Christ who sends the minister, matters to everyone in the church. It frees you from needing a spiritual celebrity, and it frees the pastor from the burden of being the source of grace, for he is a called servant of gifts that come from Christ. It also guards the Gospel itself from rising and falling with the gifts, or the failures, of the men who preach it. Article VIII confesses: “Both the Sacraments and Word are effectual by reason of the institution and commandment of Christ, notwithstanding they be administered by evil men” (AC VIII; see chapter 8). What you received in Christ’s name from an unworthy man, or from one who later fell, was never his to spoil. When your conscience is troubled, then, do not go looking for a more impressive pastor. Go where Christ has promised to give Himself to you: to the preaching of His Word, to your Baptism, to the absolution, and to His Supper.

Article V confessed that Christ established the office to deliver His gifts, and Article XI that through it Christ speaks forgiveness. Article XIV adds that the one who speaks was sent, and so the three move your confidence away from personalities and back to Christ’s promises.

Therefore, the Christian’s assurance rests not on the personality of the pastor, but on Christ’s promise to work through those He has rightly called. Who sent him? Christ did, through His Church, so that you may receive what your pastor hands you as Christ’s own gift.


8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading

8.1 Summary

Article XIV teaches, in a single sentence, that “no one should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments unless he be regularly called”: called through the Church. It guards against two dangers at once, the self-appointed man (no one sends himself) and a ministry that rests its power in itself (no minister stands above Christ’s Church), and confesses a ministry neither self-appointed nor self-important, called through the Church to serve the Church.

The call is God’s, issued through the Church (a mediate call), as distinct from the apostles’ immediate call, which came straight from God. Its governing principle is that the office is Christ’s institution (Article V), but its outward form (episcopal, presbyterian, or congregational) is the Church’s freedom.

The priesthood of all believers (1 Peter 2:9) does not abolish the office. It is what authorizes the Church to call, for Christ gave the keys and the office to the whole priestly people, who call some to exercise them publicly, in order, for all (Tr 67–69). The priesthood is not idle meanwhile; every Christian prays, offers spiritual sacrifices, and speaks the Gospel to the neighbor.

Historically the article was defensive, answering Rome’s charge that the reformers had overthrown the ministry and the radicals who trusted an inner word or preached uncalled. The reformers wanted to keep the bishops (Ap XIV), breaking with them only when the bishops refused the evangelical doctrine. The Fathers support that the ministry must be orderly and apostolic more clearly than which form is essential.

On the office’s dignity the Lutheran stands nearer Rome, Orthodoxy, and Anglicanism than to many free-church traditions, while denying that ordination creates a distinct sacramental order or that the succession of hands is essential. The real question of succession is what must continue—the hands, or the Gospel? The Lutheran answers: the Gospel. Because the gifts rest on Christ’s institution and not on the minister, they remain His even when the man who gave them was unworthy or later fell (AC VIII). The whole doctrine exists for the congregation, so that Christians may receive Christ’s gifts with confidence, their assurance resting not on the personality of the pastor, but on Christ’s promise to work through those He has rightly called.

8.2 Tables

Table 14.1—Who May Preach and Administer the Sacraments? The Call and Ordination

Tradition How is one called? Who ordains? Required? Primary source
Roman Catholic Through the bishop, in succession; Holy Orders a sacrament Bishops (in apostolic succession) Yes—essential to validity Trent Sess. XXIII; CCC §§1536–1600
Eastern Orthodox Through the bishop, in succession; ordination a mystery Bishops (in succession) Yes—essential Apostolic Canon 1; Confession of Dositheus, Decree 10; the ordination rite
Anglican By those “who have public authority”; historic episcopate; threefold order retained Bishops (historic episcopate) Yes 39 Articles XXIII; the Ordinal
Lutheran Through the Church (a mediate call); ordination ratifies it The Church, through its ministers (presbyteral ordination valid) Yes—orderly call required; form free AC XIV; Ap XIV.1–5; SA III.x; Tr 63–72
Reformed / Presbyterian Through the Church; call inward and outward The presbytery (assembly of elders) Yes Calvin Inst. IV.3; Westminster
Methodist Through the connection; appointed by bishops (American); through the Conference (British) Bishops (connectional) or the Conference Yes Book of Discipline
Baptist / Congregationalist Through the local gathered congregation The local congregation (it chooses; its elders lay on hands) Yes (congregational) 2LBCF 26; BFM (2000) VI
Pentecostal (denominational) / independent The Spirit’s call, tested by credentialing (Pentecostal bodies); local recognition (independent churches) Credentialing body or local church Usually expected; varies by body AG credentialing; local practice

*Confidence: high on the Roman Catholic, Lutheran, Anglican, and Reformed rows; moderate on the Orthodox, Methodist, and Baptist rows (internal range / naming the body); limited on the Pentecostal / independent row (tendencies, not a fixed doctrine). *

Table 14.2—The Three Polities: Episcopal / Presbyterian / Congregational

Episcopal Presbyterian Congregational
Where authority rests In bishops, who govern and ordain In assemblies of elders (presbyteries) In the local gathered congregation
Who ordains Bishops The presbytery The local congregation
Bishops as a distinct order? Yes No (parity of elders) No
Held to be divinely prescribed? Rome/Orthodoxy: yes; Anglican: varies Many Presbyterians: yes (ius divinum) Generally held as Christ’s appointed pattern (2LBCF 26)
Representative traditions Roman Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, most American Methodists Reformed / Presbyterian Baptist, Congregationalist, most non-denominational

The Lutheran position is not a fourth column but a stance toward all three: the office is Christ’s institution; the outward form is the Church’s freedom. Lutheran churches have in fact lived under episcopal order (Sweden) and non-episcopal order (much of Germany) with equal conscience.

Table 14.3—Apostolic Succession: Required, Valued, or Rejected

Tradition Succession of hands What “succession” essentially means
Roman Catholic Required—essential to validity Succession of bishops from the apostles, as the guarantee of the apostolic faith (CCC §77)
Eastern Orthodox Required—essential Succession of bishops within the Church’s continuing Orthodox faith; not mechanical
Anglican Required in practice for all; Anglo-Catholics: essential (esse); others: for the Church’s well-being (bene esse) The historic episcopate (essential or for the Church’s well-being)
Lutheran Valued, not necessary Succession in the apostolic Gospel, not merely the hands
Reformed / Presbyterian Rejected as necessary Continuity of doctrine and orderly (presbyteral) call
Baptist / Congregationalist Rejected Fidelity to apostolic teaching; congregational call
Pentecostal (denominational) / independent Not required; the International Pentecostal Holiness Church holds that “the New Testament establishes no line of apostolic succession” and gives its superintendents “the honorary title of bishop”; COGIC’s ordinal requires ordination by “bishops who are themselves duly qualified to confer Holy Orders” but does not call succession essential to the Church Continuity of the Spirit’s work and the Gospel

The dividing question is not whether the ministry must be continuous with the apostles (all agree it must) but what must continue: the hands, or the Gospel?

8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)

  • Rite vocatus—“rightly called”; in this book, called through the Church.
  • The call—mediate (God’s call through the Church) and immediate (the apostles’ call, directly from God). Immediate means “without a go-between,” not “instant.”
  • The office of the ministry—the public ministry of Word and Sacrament, instituted by Christ (Article V).
  • The priesthood of all believers—all the baptized as a royal priesthood (1 Peter 2:9); the ground of the Church’s right to call.
  • Ordination—the Church’s public ratification of the call, with prayer and the laying on of hands.
  • Apostolic succession—of the hands (an unbroken chain of episcopal consecrations) or of the Gospel (fidelity to the apostles’ doctrine).
  • The three polities—episcopal, presbyterian, and congregational.
  • Ius divinum / ius humanum—by divine right / by human right: the office divine, the form free.

8.4 Further reading

  • The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XIV; Apology XIV (retaining the grades of bishops, “made by human authority,” if the bishops allow the evangelical doctrine); Apology XIII.7–13 (ordination and the ministry of the Word); AC VIII and Apology VII–VIII.28 (ministers represent the person of Christ; the Word and Sacraments effectual even when administered by evil men); Smalcald Articles III.x; the Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope 60–72 (the keys given to the whole Church; presbyteral ordination; bishop = presbyter by divine right).
  • Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3; Edmund Schlink, Theology of the Lutheran Confessions.
  • The Fathers, from their own texts: 1 Clement 42–44; Ignatius, Letters (middle recension); Cyprian, On the Unity of the Church; Jerome, Letter 146 and Commentary on Titus 1:5.
  • For the comparisons, from their own sources: the Council of Trent, Session XXIII, the Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1536–1600, and Lumen Gentium 10, 18–29; Calvin, Institutes IV.3 and the Westminster Form of Presbyterial Church Government; the Confession of Dositheus (1672), Decree 10, and a modern Orthodox account such as Kallistos Ware, The Orthodox Church; the Thirty-Nine Articles (XXIII) and the Chicago–Lambeth Quadrilateral; the Second London Baptist Confession (ch. 26) and the Baptist Faith and Message (Article VI); the Methodist Book of Discipline; an Assemblies of God credentialing statement.

Footnotes

  1. In the Triglotta’s English the condition “provided the bishops allow our doctrine and receive our priests” (Ap XIV.1) stands in square brackets, the Triglotta’s mark for matter drawn from the German text of the Apology. The Latin states the wish to keep the grades “even though they have been made by human authority” and gives the condition in the paragraphs that follow, where the bishops’ cruelty is named as the cause of the break (Ap XIV.2, 5). ↩

  2. The closeness is historical. Article XXIII descends from AC XIV by way of the Thirteen Articles (1538), drafted in the Lutheran–English conversations of the 1530s, whose tenth article, De Ministris Ecclesiae (“Of the Ministers of the Church”), opens with the words of AC XIV: no one should publicly teach or administer the Sacraments nisi rite vocatus (“unless rightly called”) (Charles Hardwick, A History of the Articles of Religion, 1881, 270–71). In the Porvoo Common Statement (1992), Anglican churches of Britain and Ireland and Lutheran churches of the Nordic and Baltic lands said together that “the use of the sign of the historic episcopal succession does not by itself guarantee the fidelity of a church to every aspect of the apostolic faith, life and mission” (§51). ↩

Topics
Church and MinistryOther Churches and Traditions
Scripture
Romans 10:15Romans 10:171 Corinthians 14:401 Corinthians 14:31Titus 1:5Acts 14:231 Timothy 3:1–7Ephesians 4:11–121 Peter 2:91 Timothy 2:51 Peter 2:4–10Jeremiah 23:21Ephesians 4:111 Peter 2:51 Timothy 2:1Luke 10:16
Confessions
AC XIVAC VAp XIIIAp XIVSA IIIAp VIIAC VIII

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.