Books · The Augsburg Compass

Chapter 13—Article XIII: The Use of the Sacraments

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

A wedding ring is a small thing and everyone understands it. It does not make two people married; the vows do that. Yet a spouse in a hard season (far from home, or tempted, or simply weary) may turn the ring on a finger and remember a promise that holds them. We are the kind of creatures for whom a tangible thing can carry a relational promise, and God knows this about us, because He made us this way.

We must say at once where the analogy stops. A wedding ring only reminds you of a promise made elsewhere. A sacrament does something a ring cannot, because God uses it to deliver the promise it signifies. That distinction, between a sign that merely points to a reality and a sign through which God actually gives the reality it signifies, is the Lutheran doctrine of the sacraments.

This is the chapter that gathers up the four before it. We have watched God claim a person in Baptism (chapter 9), feed him at the Supper (chapter 10), speak forgiveness to him in Absolution (chapter 11), and receive him home in daily repentance (chapter 12). Article XIII stands back and asks the question underneath all of them: what is a sacrament, what is it for, and why did God give us such things at all? God knows our weakness, so He gives His promises in forms we can see, hear, touch, and receive. The movement of the chapter is from “I must climb up to God” to “God stoops down to strengthen me.” It is the same downward movement as the Incarnation (chapter 3), where God came to us because we could never have come to Him. This chapter does define a sacrament, yet I want you to see first why God gives us sacraments at all.

As we go, keep one question in mind: Who is acting here? The answer, every time, will be God.


1. What the Article Says

What is a sacrament for? Article XIII answers in a short article that turns on a single contrast:

Of the Use of the Sacraments they teach that the Sacraments were ordained, not only to be marks of profession among men, but rather to be signs and testimonies of the will of God toward us, instituted to awaken and confirm faith in those who use them. Wherefore we must so use the Sacraments that faith be added to believe the promises which are offered and set forth through the Sacraments. They therefore condemn those who teach that the Sacraments justify by the outward act, and who do not teach that, in the use of the Sacraments, faith which believes that sins are forgiven, is required. (AC XIII.1–3)1

In other words, the sacraments are not chiefly our badge before others. They are God’s pledge to us, given to start and strengthen faith, and we are to receive them by trusting the promise they carry. The article also warns that simply going through the rite, without faith, makes no one right with God.

Everything is in the phrase “not only… but rather.” A “mark of profession among men” is something we do: a badge we wear, a public act by which we identify ourselves as belonging to Christ. The Confession does not deny that the sacraments do this. When you are baptized or come to the Supper, you do profess your faith before others. That, says Article XIII, is not their first purpose. They were ordained “rather to be signs and testimonies of the will of God toward us,” and a testimony of God’s will toward us is something God does, a pledge He gives and a promise He holds out. The direction that matters runs from God to us, not from us to God. The article names the purpose: “to awaken and confirm faith.” The sacraments exist to do something to our faith, to kindle it where it is cold and steady it where it wavers.

Then comes the guardrail, which the article states twice. It says positively that “we must so use the Sacraments that faith be added to believe the promises,” and it condemns those who teach “that the Sacraments justify by the outward act.” The sacrament carries a promise and the promise is received by faith. This fends off the two errors that shadow the whole chapter. It refuses to let the sacrament shrink into a mere symbol, for it is God’s testimony, offering a promise. It equally refuses to let it harden into magic, for its promise is received by faith and not by the bare performance of the rite. Put briefly, a sacrament is neither magic nor a mere symbol.


2. Biblical Theology

A sign that also seals. Scripture shows God attaching His promises to signs from the beginning and shows those signs both giving what they promise and being received by faith. Paul’s word for it is in Romans 4:11, where Abraham “received the sign of circumcision as a seal of the righteousness that he had by faith” (ESV). Notice that Abraham already had the righteousness before he received the sign. Paul’s word is sphragis (“seal”), and Thayer’s lexicon lists this very verse under the sense “that by which anything is confirmed, proved, authenticated, as by a seal (a token or proof)” (Thayer’s, s.v. σφραγίς). A sign points; a seal confirms and guarantees. Circumcision did not earn Abraham’s righteousness. God gave it as His own pledge, stamping the promise with a visible guarantee. That is the biblical shape of a sacrament, God’s confirming seal on His promise rather than a bare token we display. The Apology argues the same way from the same passage (Romans 4:9–11): circumcision “was a sign presented for exercising faith,” and the sacraments are “the signs [and seals] of the promises” (Ap XIII.19–20). Therefore Romans 4:11 answers both errors. The sign is God’s efficacious seal (that is, it does what it says), and the righteousness it seals is received by faith.

Signs that do something. The New Testament does not speak of the sacraments as decorations. Baptism is “the washing of regeneration” by which “he saved us” (Titus 3:5); “be baptized and wash away your sins” (Acts 22:16); the cup is “a participation in the blood of Christ” (1 Corinthians 10:16). These are the specific sacraments, argued in their own chapters (14 and 15). Here they establish the general point, that when God attaches His word to a sign, the sign conveys what it says.

Signs received by faith, not automatically. Scripture refuses the mechanical view just as firmly. Paul reminds the Corinthians that Israel in the wilderness had the signs (“all were baptized into Moses… all ate the same spiritual food, and all drank the same spiritual drink… and the Rock was Christ”), and yet “with most of them God was not pleased” (1 Corinthians 10:1–5). Having the sign did not save those who would not believe. The same holds at the Lord’s table, where one may eat and drink “without discerning the body” and so eat judgment (1 Corinthians 11:29). The sign gives what it promises. It gives it to our blessing only where faith receives it.

Put the strands together and the doctrine is clear. God has always given His people signs that seal His promises (Romans 4:11; Genesis 17:11); these signs deliver what they promise (Titus 3:5); and they bless those who receive them trusting the promise (1 Corinthians 10–11). A sacrament is a sign through which God actually gives the reality it signifies, and not a sign that merely points to it.

In Romans 4:11 it is God who gave Abraham the seal, and it is God who still seals His promise on a person and gives His Word a form that weak faith can see and hold.


3. Historical Context

Augustine gives the West its definition. The whole Western vocabulary descends from Augustine (354–430), who called a sacrament a “visible word” (verbum visibile) and a “sacred sign.” His most quoted line makes the mechanism clear: “the word comes to the element, and it becomes a sacrament” (accedit verbum ad elementum et fit sacramentum). Notice that the power was never in the water or the bread as such, but in the word God joins to them. This is the definition Luther and the Confessions gladly inherited, quoting Augustine by name (Ap XIII.5; LC IV.18; SA III.v.1), and it is the image this chapter keeps returning to: a sacrament is the visible Word, God’s promise joined to a visible sign.

The medieval count of seven. For centuries the term was used loosely, and Augustine himself could call many things “sacraments.” Only in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries was the number fixed at seven: Baptism, Confirmation, the Eucharist, Penance, Extreme Unction (the anointing of the dying), Holy Orders, and Matrimony. Peter Lombard’s Sentences (c. 1150) is the usual landmark and councils later confirmed the count. Rome holds that the Church did not invent the seven but, guided by the Spirit, “gradually recognized” them as instituted by the Lord, much as she discerned the canon of Scripture (CCC 1117). The Lutheran reading of the same history is that the sevenfold count is a medieval systematization, not an apostolic given.

The Reformation applies a stricter test. The Reformers did not so much reduce the number as define the term more strictly, and then count. If a sacrament is a rite that has Christ’s institution, carries His promise of the forgiveness of sins, and joins that promise to a visible sign, then only Baptism and the Lord’s Supper clearly qualify, with Absolution joining them when, as in the Apology, institution and promise are the test. The rest, whatever their goodness, lack that specific combination.

Trent answers. Rome defined its sacramental doctrine at the Council of Trent, Session VII (1547). There are seven sacraments, neither more nor fewer, all instituted by Christ; they contain and confer the grace they signify; and they work ex opere operato (“by the work worked”). Its canons pronounce an anathema (a solemn condemnation) on any count “more, or less, than seven” (canon 1) and on the teaching that grace is not conferred “through the act performed, but that faith alone in the divine promise suffices” (canon 8). Canon 6 is mixed. It condemns the view that the sacraments are merely “marks of the Christian profession.” On that point Rome and Wittenberg agreed. The Roman Confutation of 1530 had already approved Article XIII’s rejection of that view (Ap XIII.1). The same canon also condemns anyone who denies that the sacraments “confer that grace on those who do not place an obstacle thereunto.” That is the teaching the Apology had attacked (Ap XIII.18).


4. Early Church Witness

On this article the Fathers are chiefly definitional. They support the Lutheran instinct while undercutting the medieval count. Augustine, as we saw, gave the West its very concept of a sacrament, the word joined to the element. (As with the Supper in chapter 10, Augustine also speaks strongly of the sacraments as signs, language that Zwingli (the Zurich Reformer who taught that the Supper is chiefly a memorial) would later seize on; he must be read whole, holding the reality and the sign together.) Ambrose, in On the Sacraments and On the Mysteries, makes the same point in his own key. It is the word of Christ that makes the element a sacrament (On the Mysteries 9.52).

Two things should be noted. First, the Fathers clearly held that God works through instituted signs joined to His word, which is solid ground for the Lutheran definition of an efficacious sign. Second, they did not fix the number at seven. Augustine used “sacrament” broadly and the sevenfold list is a much later development. The early Church therefore supports what a sacrament is far more clearly than it supports how many there are, which is the order Article XIII keeps.


5. Lutheran Confessional Theology

The definition: three questions. Ask three questions of any proposed sacrament. Does it have Christ’s institution? Does it carry Christ’s promise, the forgiveness of sins? Does it join that promise to a visible sign? Where the answer to all three is yes, you have a sacrament, properly speaking. The three questions sort the cases:

  • Baptism is instituted by Christ (Matthew 28:19), carries the promise of forgiveness and new birth (Acts 2:38; Titus 3:5), and is joined to the sign of water. Yes.
  • The Lord’s Supper is instituted by Christ (Matthew 26:26–28), carries the promise “for the forgiveness of sins,” and is joined to the signs of bread and wine. Yes.
  • The five others in the medieval list (confirmation, matrimony, ordination understood as a sacrificing priesthood, extreme unction, and penance understood as the medieval system of satisfactions rather than Absolution itself) are good or useful in various ways. They lack, however, that combination of institution by the Lord Himself, the promise of forgiveness, and a divinely given sign. They are therefore not sacraments in the strict sense, however the tradition once used the word (on the Apology’s willingness to call ordination a sacrament when it is understood of the ministry of the Word, see chapter 14).
  • Absolution is instituted by Christ (John 20:23) and carries the promise of forgiveness itself, yet its only sign is the spoken word of pardon. It meets the Apology’s test of command and promise, and whether it is counted with the two depends on whether a visible element is also required, as the next paragraph explains.

The number: two, or three. Here the Confessions teach something many Lutherans are surprised to learn. Lutherans ordinarily speak of two sacraments, Baptism and the Lord’s Supper, because in these two the promise is joined most clearly to a physical element. However, the Apology of the Augsburg Confession (Melanchthon’s 1531 defense of it) sometimes counts three. It defines sacraments as “rites which have the command of God, and to which the promise of grace has been added,” and so names “Baptism, the Lord’s Supper, and Absolution, which is the Sacrament of Repentance” as “truly Sacraments” (Ap XIII.3–4; chapter 11). The difference is not confusion. Where institution and the promise of forgiveness are the test, as in the Apology, Absolution qualifies, for the Apology means “the promise of grace, which is peculiar to the New Testament” (Ap XIII.4). Where a visible element is also required, the count is two. Luther himself, in the Large Catechism, speaks of “our two Sacraments instituted by Christ” (LC IV.1) and treats repentance, “the third Sacrament,” as “really nothing else than Baptism” (LC IV.74–75). Later Lutheran teachers made this the standard definition. Therefore Lutheran writers can count differently and still teach the same thing, because they begin with the definition and let the number follow from it. The Apology itself warns that “no prudent man will strive greatly concerning the number or the term, if only those objects still be retained which have God’s command and promises” (Ap XIII.17).

First guardrail: not a mere symbol. Against the view that the sacraments are only signs (pictures of a grace received elsewhere, or badges we wear to profess our faith), the Confession insists they are “testimonies of the will of God toward us” that God uses to awaken and confirm faith. They are the visible Word, God’s promise joined to a visible sign and delivering what it promises. On this point the Lutheran stands with Augustine and, as we will see, closer to Rome than to those Protestants who see the sacraments only as memorials (the memorialists).

Second guardrail: not magic. Against the view that the sacraments work automatically, by the mere performance of the act, the Confession insists that “faith be added.” The Confessions reject ex opere operato (“by the work worked”) as the scholastics taught it, and the Apology says so sharply: “Here we condemn the whole crowd of scholastic doctors, who teach that the Sacraments confer grace ex opere operato, without a good disposition on the part of the one using them, provided he do not place a hindrance in the way” (Ap XIII.18). That is the Confessions’ judgment on what the schools taught in the sixteenth century, not a verdict on Roman Catholics today. By a good disposition the Apology means faith in the promise, not a sufficient degree of devotion, and it says so in the next sentence: “without a good disposition of the heart, i.e., without faith.” The Confessions hold just as firmly to what the phrase was meant to protect, that the gift is there because Christ put it there. Two things must be held together:

  • Lutherans reject grace conferred apart from faith, by the bare doing of the rite. A sacrament received without faith brings no blessing to the one who receives it (1 Corinthians 11:29).
  • Lutherans affirm that the gift rests on Christ’s word and institution. They therefore equally reject making the sacrament’s validity hang on the worthiness of the minister or on how strongly the recipient feels it. The gift does not fail because the pastor is a hypocrite or because the communicant’s feelings are weak. This was the Church’s old answer to the Donatists, who said a sinful priest’s sacraments were void (chapter 8, on Article VIII). Luther says that even if a knave takes or distributes the Sacrament, “he receives the true Sacrament… For it is not founded upon the holiness of men, but upon the Word of God” (LC V.16; AC VIII).

Therefore, because the gift is objectively given, I need not doubt whether it is offered to me. It is also received by faith, so it is not a spell that works on the indifferent. If you fear your faith is too weak for this, remember that the faith the article requires is trust in the promise and not a strength you must bring before you may come. The sacrament was given to awaken and confirm that very trust, and Christ did not turn away the father who cried out, “I believe; help my unbelief!” (Mark 9:24).

Why God gives visible signs at all. Why signs? Why does God not simply speak, or work invisibly in the soul? The answer has to do with us: God made us bodily creatures. He made human beings, with eyes and ears and hands and tongues, and He saves human beings and not disembodied minds. He therefore comes to us in the way that fits what He made, in a word we hear and also in water we feel, bread we taste, and a pardon spoken aloud into our ears. The Apology says the same with Augustine’s image: “just as the Word enters the ear in order to strike our heart, so the rite itself strikes the eye, in order to move the heart. The effect of the Word and of the rite is the same” (Ap XIII.5). This is the same logic as the Incarnation (chapter 3). The Son of God took on flesh to save us and still uses water and bread and a human voice to strengthen us.


6. Comparative Theology

The usual party lines mislead here, because the divide does not run simply between Catholic and Protestant. As always, each tradition is stated first from its own sources and in its strongest fair form.

Roman Catholic. The Roman Catholic Church teaches seven sacraments, all instituted by Christ, each truly conferring the grace it signifies, working ex opere operato (Trent, Session VII; Catechism §§1113–1134). I want to say clearly what many Protestants do not realize. On the nature of the sacraments (that they are real, instituted means through which God gives grace, and not bare symbols) the Lutheran is closer to Rome than to memorialism. Wittenberg and Rome stand together against the view that a sacrament is only a memorial or a badge, and Rome’s own theologians said so in 1530, approving this article’s statement (Ap XIII.1). Rome’s own meaning for ex opere operato should be heard as well. The sacrament works “by virtue of the saving work of Christ,” so that it “is not wrought by the righteousness of either the celebrant or the recipient, but by the power of God,” though “the fruits of the sacraments also depend on the disposition of the one who receives them” (CCC 1128). Lutherans can affirm that the sacrament does not depend on the righteousness of the minister or the recipient but on the power of God.

Where, then, is the real disagreement? It lies on two points. The first is the number, since the sevenfold count does not survive the stricter definition of institution, promise, and sign. The second is how the gift is received. The Apology condemned the scholastic teaching that the sacrament confers grace “without a good disposition on the part of the one using them” (Ap XIII.18). Trent, for its part, teaches that the sacraments confer grace “through the act performed” on those who place no obstacle, and it anathematizes the claim that “faith alone in the divine promise suffices” (Session VII, canons 6, 8). Against this Article XIII insists that “faith be added,” because faith in the promise is the hand that receives the gift. The Catechism’s word that the fruits “depend on the disposition of the one who receives them” narrows the distance from the scholastic teaching the Apology condemned. It does not close it, for the canons of Trent remain Rome’s teaching, and the Catechism does not say that it is faith in the promise that receives the gift.

Eastern Orthodox. The Eastern Orthodox Church speaks of the “mysteries” and holds them, too, to be efficacious, instituted means of grace, which again is close to the Lutheran instinct on the nature of the thing. The East adopted the count of seven later than the West and partly under Western influence, but its own confessional documents do teach it (Confession of Dositheus, 1672, Decree XV; Philaret’s Longer Catechism). Many Orthodox theologians today nonetheless hold the number lightly. They count other rites (the blessing of waters, monastic tonsure, the funeral) as mysteries in a wider sense, and they speak of the mysteries apophatically, with reverent reserve about how they work (Kallistos Ware, The Orthodox Church, “Orthodox Worship: The Sacraments”). The Orthodox have in fact answered this article. When theologians at Tübingen sent a Greek translation of the Augsburg Confession to Patriarch Jeremias II of Constantinople, his reply, dated May 15, 1576, insisted on the seven mysteries (Philipp Meyer, “Jeremias II,” The New Schaff-Herzog Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge, vol. 6 [1910], 124–25; the whole correspondence is translated in George Mastrantonis, Augsburg and Constantinople, 1982). On the nature of the mysteries the two churches stand close. On their number they did not agree.

Reformed and Presbyterian. The Reformed hold two sacraments as “signs and seals” of the covenant of grace (Romans 4:11), efficacious by the Spirit and received by faith, and like the Lutherans they reject ex opere operato (Calvin, Institutes IV.14; Westminster Confession ch. 27; Heidelberg Catechism Q65–68). The “sign and seal” language is shared ground. The difference is real and the Formula of Concord, the last of the Lutheran Confessions, counts it serious enough to divide churches. The Reformed join the sign and the thing it signifies (Christ and His benefits) by “a spiritual relation, or sacramental union” (Westminster 27.2), and they teach that Christ, offered to all who receive the sign, is received only by faith. In the Supper, the Lutheran says, Christ’s body and blood are present in the sacrament itself and received by everyone who eats and drinks, to blessing where there is faith and to judgment where there is none (FC SD VII; chapter 10). That difference is still narrower than the one either tradition has with the memorialist.

Anglican. The Thirty-Nine Articles (the Church of England’s statement of faith) open their article on the sacraments with Article XIII’s own sentence in English: sacraments “be not only badges or tokens of Christian men’s profession, but rather they be certain sure witnesses, and effectual signs of grace, and God’s good will towards us” (Article XXV). The debt is historical, coming through the Lutheran–English conversations of the 1530s. The Article then draws the line Lutherans ordinarily draw on the number. It names two “Sacraments of the Gospel” ordained by Christ (Baptism and the Supper) and five “commonly called Sacraments” (confirmation, penance, orders, matrimony, and extreme unction) that “are not to be counted for Sacraments of the Gospel,” because “they have not any visible sign or ceremony ordained of God.” The living tradition ranges from a high-church (Anglo-Catholic) practice that treats the five as true though lesser sacraments to an evangelical one nearer the Reformed. The American Prayer Book of 1979 calls them “sacramental rites” and “means of grace,” though “not necessary for all persons in the same way that Baptism and the Eucharist are” (BCP 1979, Catechism, p. 860). The Methodist Articles of Religion keep this article (Article XVI) and its line on the five, though they call the sacraments only “certain signs of grace” and leave out “sure witnesses, and effectual.”

Baptist and Evangelical: the “ordinance.” Many of this book’s readers belong to traditions that call Baptism and the Lord’s Supper “ordinances” rather than sacraments. They understand them as acts of obedience and public testimony commanded by Christ, and many hold them to be symbolic memorials rather than means of grace (Baptist Faith and Message 2000, Art. VII). The older Particular (Calvinist) Baptist confession is closer to the Reformed. It too calls them “ordinances,” yet it teaches that worthy receivers “spiritually receive and feed upon Christ crucified” (Second London Baptist Confession 30.7). Begin where charity requires. These Christians want to honor Christ by doing what He commanded and want to guard genuine faith against the superstition of trusting a rite instead of the Savior. Those are good and godly instincts and the Lutheran shares them. The Lutheran concern is not that they obey Christ (of course they should) but that the word “ordinance,” and the memorial theology that often goes with it, unintentionally reduce God’s action to human testimony. When the sacrament becomes chiefly something I do to profess my faith, the direction has been reversed. What AC XIII calls “testimonies of the will of God toward us” has become chiefly our testimony, a sincere one, to what God has done; the sign now speaks from us, where Article XIII hears God speaking to us. The obedience remains and the sign remains. What drops out of sight is God’s gift, the forgiveness He promised to deliver in the water and at the table, and the comfort of knowing He gives it there. Article XIII was written to give that comfort back.

Quakers and the Salvation Army. Two traditions observe no outward sacraments at all. The Religious Society of Friends (Quakers) hold to an inward baptism of the Spirit and an inward communion with Christ (Robert Barclay, Apology for the True Christian Divinity, Propositions XII–XIII). The Salvation Army has since 1883 chosen not to observe the outward sacraments, does not regard them as necessary to salvation, and does not judge churches that keep them (William Booth, address to his officers, January 1883; International Spiritual Life Commission, 1998). Neither is careless about grace. Both mean to honor the inward, Spirit-wrought reality and to resist a formalism that trusts the outward rite instead of Christ, and that concern deserves respect. The Confessions’ reply is the doctrine of the means of grace. God has willed to give His Spirit only through the external Word and the sacraments He appointed, and the Confessions reject “enthusiasm,” the claim to have the Spirit apart from these means. As the Smalcald Articles put it, God “does not wish to deal with us otherwise than through the spoken Word and the Sacraments” (AC V; SA III.viii.3–10). He does so because He made us creatures who need something to receive. We honor the inward reality best by receiving it where God promised to give it.


7. Pastoral and Practical Significance

Picture a parent kneeling beside a frightened child in the dark. The child has heard the words (“I love you; I am here; you are safe”), and the words are true. Yet the child, being a child, needs more than words spoken into the dark; the child needs to be held. The parent does not merely repeat the promise but gathers the child up, and the promise arrives in a form the child can feel. God knows we are like that. He speaks His promise and then gives it a form we can receive (water, bread and wine, a spoken word of pardon), so that faith has something to hold.

Article XIII gathers up the sacramental chapters before it into one vision. Why Baptism? On your worst days you will need more than an abstract belief that you belong to God. You will need to say, “I am baptized,” because it happened to you, water and word, and God’s promise to wash away your sins holds. The Supper answers the same weakness. Faith fed on ideas alone would starve, so God gives His own body and blood into your hand and mouth, for the forgiveness of your sins. Why Absolution? Believing in general that God forgives is one thing and hearing “your sins are forgiven” spoken to you by name is another. In every case the logic is the same, and it is the logic of the Incarnation: the God who came down in Christ to reach us keeps coming down, in signs we can receive, to strengthen us. Of course He gives visible promises. He knows exactly the kind of creature He made.

This changes how you receive the sacraments. They are not, first, duties you perform to show God your seriousness, things you do for God. They are gifts, things God does for you. The Apology defines a sacrament this way: “a ceremony or work in which God presents to us that which the promise annexed to the ceremony offers; as, Baptism is a work, not which we offer to God, but in which God baptizes us” (Ap XXIV.18). The movement of the Christian life runs downward, God stooping to you in water and bread and word, and your devotion follows from it. God did not give the sacraments because His promise was weak, but because our faith is. His word needs no help. What He props up with visible signs is us, and He meets our weakness with the kind of help weak, embodied creatures can receive. When your conscience is troubled, do not look inside yourself for proof that God is gracious; go where Christ has promised to give Himself, to His Word, to your Baptism, to the absolution, and to His Supper.

Who is acting here? At the font, at the rail, and in the spoken pardon, God is acting.


8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading

8.1 Summary

Article XIII teaches that the sacraments were ordained “not only to be marks of profession among men, but rather to be signs and testimonies of the will of God toward us, instituted to awaken and confirm faith,” so that “faith be added” to receive the promises they carry. They are God’s promise joined to a visible sign, Augustine’s “visible word.” From this follow the two guardrails of this chapter: a sacrament is neither magic nor a mere symbol.

Against the merely symbolic (memorial) view, the sacraments are God’s efficacious testimonies, signs through which He actually gives the reality they signify and not signs that merely point to it. Against a mechanical ex opere operato, the promise is received by faith; yet Lutherans equally deny that the gift depends on the worthiness of the minister or on how strongly the recipient feels it. A sacrament, defined by Christ’s institution, Christ’s promise, and a visible sign, is properly Baptism and the Lord’s Supper, or three counting Absolution, as the Apology sometimes does with its test of command and promise (Ap XIII.3–4). The medieval seven do not survive the stricter definition.

On the nature of the sacraments the Lutheran stands closer to Rome (and to the Orthodox, the Anglicans’ Article XXV, and the Reformed “sign and seal”) than to memorialism. On this article the real divergences with Rome are the number and whether faith in the promise is what receives the gift. The Lutheran shares the Baptist and Evangelical desire to obey Christ and to guard faith against trusting a rite, but he fears that the memorial view which often goes with the “ordinance” can unintentionally reduce God’s action to human testimony. To the Quakers and the Salvation Army, who honor the inward reality without the outward rite, the Confessions answer with the means of grace: God gives His Spirit through the Word and the sacraments He appointed.

Underneath all of this is the reason God gives signs. He made us bodily creatures and saves human beings, not disembodied minds, as the Incarnation shows. Through water, bread, and a spoken pardon He forgives our sins and so awakens and confirms our faith.

8.2 Tables

Table 13.1—How Many Sacraments, and Why?

Tradition How many? The defining test Means of grace or symbol? Primary source
Roman Catholic Seven Instituted by Christ; confer grace ex opere operato Efficacious means Trent Sess. VII; CCC §§1113–1134
Eastern Orthodox Seven (Dositheus 1672; held less rigidly by many modern theologians) Instituted in the Gospel; “something natural, and … something supernatural”; “not bare signs” but “efficient means of grace” Efficacious mysteries Confession of Dositheus XV; Philaret, Longer Catechism; Jeremias II, First Answer (1576)
Lutheran Two (or three with Absolution) Christ’s institution + promise + visible sign (Ap XIII: command + promise) Efficacious sign received in faith AC XIII; Ap XIII
Anglican Two + five “commonly called” Two “of the Gospel”; five not counted as such Efficacious (two); the five “sacramental rites,” means of grace (BCP 1979), with a range of teaching Thirty-Nine Articles XXV
Reformed / Presbyterian Two Signs and seals of the covenant of grace Efficacious by the Spirit, received by faith Calvin, Inst. IV.14; Westminster 27
Baptist / Evangelical Two “ordinances” Commanded acts of obedience and testimony Symbolic memorial (BFM); spiritual feeding by faith (2LBCF) Baptist Faith and Message (2000) Art. VII; Second London Baptist Confession 28–30 (Reformed Baptist)
Quaker / Salvation Army None (outward) Inward reality without outward rite n/a (inward only) Barclay’s Apology; Salvation Army position

*Confidence: high on the Roman Catholic, Lutheran, Anglican, and Reformed rows; moderate on the Orthodox and Baptist rows (convention and internal range); limited on the non-sacramental row (small traditions, no denomination canon entry yet). *

Table 13.2—Sacrament vs. Ordinance vs. Mystery: The Word Is the Theology

Term Tradition(s) What it signals
Sacrament Lutheran, Roman Catholic, Reformed, Anglican A God-given means of grace: God’s promise joined to a sign, received in faith; God is the primary actor
Ordinance Baptist, most Evangelical A commanded act of obedience and testimony: chiefly what the believer does to profess faith; the believer is the primary actor (in the memorial view; Reformed Baptists, 2LBCF 30.7, also confess spiritual feeding by faith)
Mystery (mystērion) Eastern Orthodox A divine mystery: efficacious and real, but approached with reverent reserve (apophatically); the mechanism left undefined, and the number held with less rigidity than in the West

The choice of word is not incidental; it usually signals who is understood to be acting in the rite.

8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)

  • Sacrament—God’s promise joined to a visible sign, instituted by Christ and received in faith.
  • Means of grace—the external Word and Sacraments through which God gives His Spirit and forgiveness.
  • Word and Sacrament.
  • Ex opere operato—“by the work worked”; used with care in this chapter.
  • Enthusiasm / Schwärmerei—the claim to have the Spirit apart from the external means.
  • Sign and seal—Romans 4:11; glossed in the text.
  • Ordinance and mystery—glossed in the text.

8.4 Further reading

  • The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XIII; Apology XIII (the definition and the number); the Large and Small Catechisms on Baptism and the Supper.
  • Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3; Edmund Schlink, Theology of the Lutheran Confessions.
  • On the medieval settling of “seven”: Peter Lombard, Sentences IV.
  • For the comparisons, from their own sources: Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1113–1134 and Trent, Session VII; the Confession of Dositheus (1672) and Philaret’s Longer Catechism, with George Mastrantonis, Augsburg and Constantinople (1982), for Patriarch Jeremias II’s reply to the Augsburg Confession; Calvin, Institutes IV.14, the Westminster Confession (ch. 27), and the Heidelberg Catechism (Q65–68); the Thirty-Nine Articles (XXV) and the 1979 Book of Common Prayer, Catechism; the Baptist Faith and Message and the Second London Baptist Confession (ch. 28–30); Robert Barclay’s Apology and an official Salvation Army statement for the non-sacramental traditions.

Footnotes

  1. The German text of AC XIII has no closing condemnation. It ends with the positive teaching, that the Sacraments are “recht gebraucht, so man’s im Glauben empfängt und den Glauben dadurch stärkt,” rightly used when they are received in faith and faith is strengthened by them (Triglotta, 48). The rejection of those who teach that the Sacraments justify “by the outward act” belongs to the Latin text. The Apology states it in its own words: “Here we condemn the whole crowd of scholastic doctors, who teach that the Sacraments confer grace ex opere operato” (Ap XIII.18). ↩

Topics
Other Churches and TraditionsBaptism
Scripture
Romans 4:11Romans 4:9–11Titus 3:5Acts 22:161 Corinthians 10:161 Corinthians 10:1–51 Corinthians 11:29Genesis 17:11Matthew 28:19Acts 2:38Matthew 26:26–28John 20:23Mark 9:24
Confessions
AC XIIIAp XIIILC IVSA IIILC VAC VIIISD VIIAC VAp XXIVLC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.