Books · The Augsburg Compass

Chapter 15—Article XV: Church Usages (Rites and Ceremonies / Adiaphora)

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Picture two faithful Christians in the same congregation, at odds over worship. One loves the old hymns, the church’s seasons, and the reverence of a set liturgy; the other longs for something simpler and freer (a guitar instead of an organ, fewer forms, and more spontaneity). Both are sincere and both have reasons, yet each suspects the other of getting something wrong, of being either stuffy and dead or shallow and irreverent. It is one of the most common quarrels in the life of the church, and it can divide a congregation more bitterly than a dispute over doctrine ever would.

Now ask the two of them one question and see what happens: Has Christ actually commanded either position? Has He anywhere required the organ, or the guitar, or the church year? Has He forbidden any of them? The question has one answer and that answer is no. It opens one of the most freeing (and most distinctly Lutheran) teachings in the whole Augsburg Confession, the subject of Article XV.

This chapter belongs beside the one before it. Article XIV said that Christ orders His Church so His gifts may be delivered with certainty, and that the man in the pulpit was sent (chapter 14). Article XV says the complement: Christ leaves many of the outward forms of church life free, so His people may serve one another in love rather than live under burdens He never laid on them. Together the two articles sketch a whole way of being the church, good order without authoritarianism, and genuine freedom without chaos. At the heart of Article XV is this: Christ has freed your conscience, and Christian freedom always serves love rather than self. Perhaps your own conscience has asked am I getting the forms right? Article XV answers that question, and then turns the freed conscience outward, toward the neighbor. Free because of Christ. Guided by love.


1. What the Article Says

Article XV is brief and makes its point in two motions:

Of Usages in the Church they teach that those ought to be observed which may be observed without sin, and which are profitable unto tranquillity and good order in the Church, as particular holy days, festivals, and the like. Nevertheless, concerning such things men are admonished that consciences are not to be burdened, as though such observance was necessary to salvation. They are admonished also that human traditions instituted to propitiate God, to merit grace, and to make satisfaction for sins, are opposed to the Gospel and the doctrine of faith. Wherefore vows and traditions concerning meats and days, etc., instituted to merit grace and to make satisfaction for sins, are useless and contrary to the Gospel. (AC XV.1–4)

The first motion is positive. The church’s usages, “particular holy days, festivals, and the like,” which “may be observed without sin” and are “profitable unto tranquillity and good order,” ought to be kept. The reformers had not thrown out the church’s ceremonies. They kept the calendar, the festivals, the readings, and much of the historic liturgy, because such things serve peace, order, and teaching.

The second motion is the guardrail: “consciences are not to be burdened, as though such observance was necessary to salvation.” A ceremony may be good, useful, even beautiful, and still it is not a condition of God’s favor. The moment a free usage is taught as necessary, it has turned from a servant into a master, obscuring the Gospel. There is a sharper edge too. Human traditions “instituted to propitiate God” (that is, to appease Him and win Him over), “to merit grace, and to make satisfaction for sins” are “opposed to the Gospel and the doctrine of faith.” That is the one thing Article XV will not tolerate. Its quarrel is with ceremony turned into a way of earning what Christ has already given, and not with ceremony as such. The last sentence applies the same judgment to vows and to rules about foods and days, which the Confession takes up in its own articles later (chapters 26–27).

What, then, are adiaphora? The word is Greek, adiaphora [ad-ee-AH-for-ah] (“indifferent things”), formed from a- (“not”) and diaphoros (“differing”), and it is the name the church came to use for the things Article XV is about (one such thing is an adiaphoron). In other words, adiaphora are matters neither commanded nor forbidden by God, and therefore free. Everything in Article XV turns on that word. I want you to see that it cuts in two directions at once. To the person who says you must keep this ceremony to please God, adiaphora answers that he is free. To the person who says you must abolish all ceremony to prove you are free, it answers just as firmly that these things are free and that freedom does not require bareness. The refrain is therefore two-sided. Free to keep. Free to change. Never free to stop loving.


2. Biblical Theology

The freedom Article XV describes is no Reformation novelty. It is the clear teaching of the New Testament, which guards it on every side, against those who would bind it and against those who would abuse it.

Christ has set the conscience free. The chief text is Paul’s: “For freedom Christ has set us free; stand firm therefore, and do not submit again to a yoke of slavery” (Galatians 5:1, ESV). Paul’s word for freedom is eleutheria (“liberty”). Thayer’s lexicon gives its first New Testament sense as “liberty to do or to omit things having no relation to salvation” (citing 1 Corinthians 10:29), and then as liberty “from the yoke of the Mosaic law” (citing Galatians 5:1 and 13). Both senses belong to this chapter. In context (the climax of Paul’s fight against requiring circumcision of Gentile believers), the “yoke” is the law pressed on them as the way to be right with God: “You are severed from Christ, you who would be justified by the law” (Galatians 5:4). If even a rite God Himself once gave Israel may not be bound on the conscience as necessary, then a rite the church devised certainly may not, and what Christ has freed no one may enslave again. A few verses later Paul keeps freedom from turning into selfishness: “do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another” (Galatians 5:13).

Human traditions must not be bound on the conscience. Paul is blunt with the Colossians, who were being pressed to keep food laws and festivals as though salvation hung on them: “Therefore let no one pass judgment on you in questions of food and drink, or with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath. These are a shadow of the things to come, but the substance belongs to Christ” (Colossians 2:16–17). Once Christ has come, to bind the shadow on the conscience again is to go backward. Paul goes on to say that rules such as “Do not handle, Do not taste, Do not touch,” however wise they look, are “according to human precepts and teachings” and “of no value in stopping the indulgence of the flesh” (Colossians 2:20–23). Jesus Himself draws the line, quoting Isaiah against the Pharisees who had raised their tradition (the Corban rule, by which a man could declare that what his parents would have gained from him was “given to God,” Mark 7:11) above God’s command: “in vain do they worship me, teaching as doctrines the commandments of men” (Matthew 15:9). Notice what He condemns. It is not every human custom but human tradition made equal to God’s Word and bound on the conscience.

Freedom is exercised in love. If Scripture guards freedom against the legalist, it guards it just as carefully against the one who would wield it selfishly. Paul’s great treatment is Romans 14, where a congregation is divided over food and over “days”: “One person esteems one day as better than another, while another esteems all days alike. Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind” (Romans 14:5). Paul forbids either side to look down on the other because God has received them both: “Let not the one who eats despise the one who abstains, and let not the one who abstains pass judgment on the one who eats, for God has welcomed him” (Romans 14:3). No one may put “a stumbling block… in the way of a brother” (Romans 14:13). He says the same to Corinth: “‘All things are lawful,’ but not all things are helpful.… Let no one seek his own good, but the good of his neighbor.… whether you eat or drink, or whatever you do, do all to the glory of God” (1 Corinthians 10:23–24, 31).

The apostolic instinct: do not over-burden. When the first great dispute over ceremonies arose, the Jerusalem council refused to lay the whole Mosaic law on Gentile believers: “it has seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us to lay on you no greater burden than these requirements” (Acts 15:28). Even those few requirements were asked for the sake of peace, not as a way to earn standing with God. Freedom is never formlessness, however. Paul insists that “all things should be done decently and in order” (1 Corinthians 14:40), the text that grounded the orderly call of chapter 14 and now grounds the church’s freedom to keep good order in worship.

Timothy and Titus. Paul circumcised Timothy freely, “because of the Jews who were in those places” (Acts 16:3). When false brothers, who had “slipped in to spy out our freedom that we have in Christ Jesus, so that they might bring us into slavery,” demanded the same rite of Titus, Paul refused: “to them we did not yield in submission even for a moment, so that the truth of the gospel might be preserved for you” (Galatians 2:4–5). The rite was the same both times. What differed was whether yielding would deny the Gospel. The Formula of Concord cites this very verse, with Galatians 5:1, when it sets the limit (FC Ep X.6).

The biblical shape, in sum: Christ has freed the conscience (Galatians 5:1), so no tradition may be bound as necessary (Colossians 2; Matthew 15:9); yet freedom is for love (Galatians 5:13; Romans 14; 1 Corinthians 10) and does not abolish good order (1 Corinthians 14:40; Acts 15). Where yielding would deny the Gospel, even a free thing must be refused (Galatians 2:3–5; Acts 16:3). Has God commanded this—or has He set me free?


3. Historical Context

Article XV was written into a two-sided fight and its most important refinement came out of a crisis after 1530.

The setting of 1530. Rome charged the reformers with tearing up the church’s worship and abolishing her sacred ceremonies, and Article XV answers that they had done nothing of the kind. They kept the church year, the festivals, the readings, and much of the liturgy and its vestments, because such usages serve good order. The Confutation, the Roman reply, accepted the article’s first part. What it rejected was the second part, that traditions instituted to appease God and merit grace are contrary to the Gospel (Ap XV.1). The Apology (Melanchthon’s defense of the Confession) makes the same point: “we cheerfully maintain the old traditions… made in the Church for the sake of usefulness and tranquillity” (Ap XV.38), and it names Sunday and the three high festivals among them. Against the radicals who abolished ceremonies wholesale, the article’s first sentence stands just as firmly: such usages, freely kept, are good.

The Interim. The doctrine’s hardest lesson came two decades later. In 1547 the Lutherans lost the Smalcald War, and the next year Emperor Charles V imposed a settlement (the Interim) that restored Roman teaching and Roman ceremonies in their churches. Philip Melanchthon, Luther’s closest colleague, judged that many of the ceremonies could be tolerated because they were free things, and he helped draw up a milder compromise. Others, led by Matthias Flacius, refused. They did not think the ceremonies evil in themselves. Giving way then, under threat and as a sign of submission, would have told everyone that the Reformation had surrendered the Gospel, and it would have misled the weak. A generation later the Formula of Concord settled the question. Ceremonies neither commanded nor forbidden are in themselves free. In time of persecution, however, when a plain confession is required, one must not yield to the enemies of the Gospel, “for in such a case it is no longer a question concerning adiaphora, but concerning the truth of the Gospel, concerning [preserving] Christian liberty, and concerning sanctioning open idolatry, as also concerning the prevention of offense to the weak in the faith” (FC Ep X.6). That episode taught the church where freedom ends, and it is the source of what the church came to call the casus confessionis (“a case of confession”).

Sidebar — The two Interims. The Emperor’s settlement of 1548, which imposed Roman doctrine as well as Roman ceremonies, is called the Augsburg Interim. The Leipzig proposals, drawn up with Melanchthon’s help as a milder alternative for Saxony, conceded many of its ceremonies as adiaphora. It was against these that Flacius and others took their stand, on the ground that yielding at that moment and as demanded would signal surrender of the Gospel and deceive the weak.


4. Early Church Witness

The early Church did not possess the developed Lutheran category of adiaphora. That is a Reformation systematization, built from Scripture and worked out in the controversy of the 1540s–1570s. Its roots are nonetheless there, in the Fathers’ handling of custom, and I find it helpful to hear two of them directly.

Augustine on custom and charity. Augustine gave the West its wisdom on things indifferent. Writing to a correspondent named Januarius, he distinguishes what carries divine authority and binds everywhere from the varying customs of local churches, and he counsels Christians not to make a burden of what God has left free, choosing charity over contention. In one of these letters he passes on the advice of Ambrose, bishop of Milan (that in Milan he did not fast on Saturday, but in Rome he did), the counsel that hardened into the proverb “when in Rome, do as Rome does.” Ambrose’s point was that customs may differ without dividing the faith.

Irenaeus on diversity within unity. The second-century Church nearly split over the date and the fast before Easter. When Bishop Victor of Rome moved to break communion with the churches of Asia over the difference, Irenaeus of Lyons urged restraint, observing (as Eusebius preserves it) that “the disagreement in regard to the fast confirms the agreement in the faith” (Church History 5.24.13). The Formula of Concord repeats a form of the same saying: “Disagreement in fasting does not destroy agreement in faith” (FC Ep X.7). This is the instinct Articles VII and XV would later confess: a difference in ceremony need not break the unity of the faith.

The Fathers support the principle of freedom in custom, and Augustine and Irenaeus are real, citable witnesses that ceremonies vary and need not divide. However, they do not supply the finished doctrine of adiaphora with its casus confessionis, which came later. They are the roots of the teaching, not the whole of it. Even so, Augustine and Irenaeus were already asking, in effect, whether God had commanded a custom or left it free, and they were already answering with charity.


5. Lutheran Confessional Theology

The Confession’s teaching gathers into a single freedom, guarded on two sides and bounded by one limit, and all of it is for a conscience freed by Christ and turned toward the neighbor in love.

The category: adiaphora. An adiaphoron is a matter God has neither commanded nor forbidden. The Formula of Concord adds the decisive qualification: such rites, “instituted alone for the sake of propriety and good order, are in and of themselves no divine worship, nor even a part of it” (FC Ep X.3). They are the frame around the worship God commands, not offerings we bring to Him. Because such things are free, the church may keep them (holy days, the order and ceremonies of the liturgy, vestments, the church year) for the sake of good order and teaching, and it may also change or drop them. Even so, the Formula insists that in such changes “all frivolity and offense should be avoided, and special care should be taken to exercise forbearance towards the weak in faith” (FC Ep X.5). Not everything called free is free, however. When “such things are proposed as are in principle contrary to God’s Word (although painted another color), these are not to be regarded as adiaphora,” and “useless, foolish displays, that are profitable neither for good order nor Christian discipline” are not genuine adiaphora either (FC SD X.5, 7).

No congregation should bind these things on another as though God had spoken where He has not. This is what is often called the normative principle (more on it below): what God has not forbidden, He has left free. Article VII has already drawn the line: “to the true unity of the Church it is enough to agree concerning the doctrine of the Gospel and the administration of the Sacraments. Nor is it necessary that human traditions, that is, rites or ceremonies, instituted by men, should be everywhere alike” (AC VII.2–3; chapter 7). The church’s unity rests on what Christ gives, the Gospel and the Sacraments, and so the forms around them cannot be its bond.

The two errors it rebukes. Article XV stands, as Lutheran theology so often does, against two opposite mistakes at once. The first is legalism (“you must do this”), which binds a free ceremony on the conscience as necessary for salvation or as a way to merit grace. The article admonishes that consciences “are not to be burdened” with such things and calls traditions instituted “to merit grace” “opposed to the Gospel” (AC XV.2–3). Article IV has already said why. We are justified freely for Christ’s sake, through faith, and not by our own works or merits (AC IV; chapter 4). A ceremony that claims to win God’s favor is competing with Christ for a place that is already His. The second error is lawless individualism (“I refuse all tradition because I am free”), which treats freedom itself as a new law that forbids form and despises order. The Formula of Concord condemns this error as firmly as the first: it rejects the abolishing of ceremonies “in such a manner as though it were not free to the congregation of God to employ one or more [this or that] in Christian liberty” (FC Ep X.12), just as it rejects ceremonies “forced upon the congregation of God as necessary” (Ep X.10). This too misunderstands liberty, for it cannot rest until everyone else is as free of forms as it demands to be. Both errors make a law where Christ left freedom. The Lutheran answer is that the conscience Christ has freed may keep these things or change them, but always in love.

Freedom is for love. Christian liberty (Galatians 5:1) is never freedom from the neighbor; it is freedom for him (Galatians 5:13; Romans 14). The strong do not flaunt their liberty to wound the weak, the weak do not use their scruples to judge the strong, and the congregation handles its indifferent things by love rather than by combat. By “the weak” Paul means the believer whose conscience is troubled by something others feel free to do, and his first word about him is “As for the one who is weak in faith, welcome him” (Romans 14:1). That is why Article XV can never be reduced to “do whatever you like.”

The limit: a free thing can stop being free. There is one boundary: a free thing ceases to be free when it is used to deny the Gospel. Sometimes a free ceremony is demanded as a confession, as submission to those who would suppress the Gospel, or in a way that would teach a lie and mislead the weak. It is then no longer indifferent. Faithfulness requires not yielding, in order to confess the truth and guard Christian liberty. The technical name for such a moment is the casus confessionis, a “case of confession,” from the Formula’s phrase “in time of persecution and in case of confession” (FC Ep X.2).

Why God left these things free. Why did God not simply legislate every detail of worship, as He once did for Israel’s tabernacle? God cares how His people worship. However, He is raising mature children, and not merely obedient servants. Paul uses this very picture for the difference between Israel under the law and the church in Christ. The heir, “as long as he is a child, is no different from a slave… but he is under guardians and managers until the date set by his father.” Then God sent His Son “to redeem those who were under the law, so that we might receive adoption as sons. And because you are sons, God has sent the Spirit of his Son into our hearts, crying, ‘Abba! Father!’ So you are no longer a slave, but a son” (Galatians 4:1–2, 5–7). The freedom is given before the wisdom is learned. We are sons first and then grow up into that freedom. Christian maturity requires wisdom, not merely rule-following. A faith that could only ever do what it was explicitly told, paralyzed wherever no rule had been given, would still be in its infancy. By leaving much free, God gives His people room to grow in love, discernment, and consideration for one another, and to ask not only whether a thing is permitted but whether it serves and builds up the neighbor in love. Freedom, rightly seen, is therefore neither a burden nor a loophole but a gift, the room in which Christian wisdom and love are learned.

Traditions that serve, and traditions that burden. From this follows a distinction that runs through the whole of Article XV. There are traditions that serve the Gospel (the calendar, the liturgy, the reverent forms that carry the Word to the people and order their common life), and these the church keeps gladly and freely. There are also traditions that seek to replace or burden the Gospel (human requirements imposed as necessary, as meritorious, as the price of God’s favor), and these the church must refuse, however ancient or beautiful. The same outward ceremony can be either, depending on how it is used.

Where God has commanded and promised, we receive His gifts and obey; where He has freed, we serve one another in love.


6. Comparative Theology

Christians divide over worship more visibly than over almost anything else and the divisions here are real and old.

The headline: two principles of worship. The sharpest difference concerns the rule that governs worship. The Reformed and Presbyterian churches hold the regulative principle of worship. The elements of worship (prayer, the reading and preaching of the Word, song, and the sacraments) must be positively commanded in Scripture, and what God has not appointed may not be added (Westminster Confession 21.1, with Deuteronomy 12:32; the elements are listed in 21.3–5). The circumstances of worship (time, place, order, and the like) are left to “the light of nature, and Christian prudence, according to the general rules of the Word” (WCF 1.6). Reformed writers often add the story of Nadab and Abihu, who “offered unauthorized fire before the LORD, which he had not commanded them” (Leviticus 10:1). The principle springs from a sincere, God-fearing desire to worship God only as He has appointed, and from a holy dread of “will-worship” (worship we invent for ourselves and offer God as if He had asked for it). It shaped the simple, Word-saturated worship of the Puritan tradition, and even the Puritan refusal of Christmas. Westminster grounds the principle on Matthew 15:9 and Colossians 2, the very texts Lutherans read as charters of freedom, so the two traditions are reading the same Bible by different rules. This is not the “lawless individualism” of the previous section. The Reformed refuse forms out of reverence for God’s command and not out of indifference to order.

The Lutheran holds instead the normative principle: whatever Scripture does not forbid may be ordered by the church for good order. The Anglican Articles (XX and XXXIV) hold it too, and the Methodist Articles of Religion carry Article XXXIV forward as their Article XXII. The Lutheran fully shares the Reformed horror of earning God’s favor by worship and agrees that worship is God’s to define where He has spoken. The concern is simply that Scripture has also granted genuine freedom, and that to forbid what God has not forbidden is to bind the very conscience He set free. The two are best understood as two God-fearing convictions rather than as a right church and a wrong one. I would put the difference this way. One asks “Where has God commanded this?” and the other asks “Where has God forbidden this?”, and the difference is real enough to produce visibly different sanctuaries.

The Anglican Articles speak to this very article and deserve to be heard in their own words. Article XXXIV, “Of the Traditions of the Church,” begins, “It is not necessary that Traditions and Ceremonies be in all places one, and utterly like,” and it ends, “Every particular or national Church hath authority to ordain, change, and abolish, ceremonies or rites of the Church ordained only by man’s authority, so that all things be done to edifying.” Article XX gives the Church “power to decree Rites or Ceremonies,” and in the same article forbids it to “enforce any thing to be believed for necessity of Salvation.” That stands very near to AC XV and AC VII. The difference is one of weight. Article XXXIV also says that whoever “willingly and purposely” breaks the common ceremonies “ought to be rebuked openly,” so the Anglican lays the stress on the church’s authority and on common, ordered prayer, while the Lutheran lays it on the freedom of the conscience. The principle is the same.

Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox, and a surprise. Lutherans love tradition. The Lutheran keeps the creeds, the church year, the historic liturgy, and the reverent ceremonies of the Western church gladly, and in actual worship stands far closer to Rome and the Orthodox than to the plainer Protestant traditions. The Roman Catholic Church holds that Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture together make up one deposit of the Word of God, and it binds certain observances on the conscience in the precepts of the Church, such as the holy days of obligation and the days of fasting and abstinence (Catechism §§2041–2043; on Tradition, §§74–83, 97). The Eastern Orthodox live within an organic Holy Tradition, with a rich calendar of fasts and feasts woven through the whole of life. Their own teaching also draws a line within the church’s life: “Not everything in the Church belongs to its Holy Tradition,” and the merely human customs “may be very positive and very helpful to the life of the Church as long as they are not taken to be what they are not” (Thomas Hopko, The Orthodox Faith, vol. 1, “Tradition”; Orthodox Church in America). With both, the Lutheran shares much: a reverence for received worship, and the conviction that the church may order its common life.

The clarifying line is this: we simply refuse to confuse good traditions with God’s commands. A tradition that serves the Gospel is a gift to keep. A tradition bound on the conscience as necessary, or offered to merit grace, has overstepped. Rome itself distinguishes the apostolic Tradition from “the various theological, disciplinary, liturgical or devotional traditions, born in the local churches over time,” which “can be retained, modified or even abandoned” (Catechism §83), and it calls the precepts “positive laws decreed by the pastoral authorities” (that is, laws the church has made, as distinct from God’s own law). Rome makes them binding “to guarantee to the faithful the indispensable minimum in the spirit of prayer and moral effort” (§2041). A Catholic, then, does not take a fast day for a divine command either. The question between us is narrower: whether the church’s pastors may bind such a law on the conscience under pain of sin, as Rome does with the Sunday and holy-day obligation (Catechism §2181). The Smalcald Articles answered that question sharply for their own day: “The declaration of the Papists that human traditions serve for the remission of sins, or merit salvation, is [altogether] unchristian and condemned,” and “when they declare that it is a mortal sin if one breaks these ordinances [does not keep these statutes], this, too, is not right” (SA III.xv.1–2). That was the Confessions’ judgment on the teaching and practice of the sixteenth century, and it is no verdict on the Catholic neighbor who keeps a fast day today. Whether bishops may bind such ordinances on consciences at all is the question of Article XXVIII (chapter 28), and the foods and fasts of Article XXVI belong to chapter 26.

Baptist, Evangelical, and Pentecostal. Practice ranges widely. The Second London Baptist Confession (1689) adopts Westminster’s regulative principle nearly word for word (22.1), while much of contemporary Evangelicalism exercises very broad freedom in worship forms. Pentecostal worship prizes openness to the Spirit’s leading in the gathered congregation (1 Corinthians 14:26), which usually means freedom from fixed forms. The Lutheran shares the conviction that no form saves and that worship is free before God, while noting what every tradition, the Lutheran included, must hear: “freedom” can itself harden into an unwritten law. The congregation where one may not kneel, or keep silence, or use an old form is no freer than the one where one must.

The seventh-day Sabbath. One modern question belongs to this chapter only as an example. The seventh-day Sabbath, kept as a continuing obligation by the Seventh-day Adventist tradition, turns on Colossians 2:16 (“let no one pass judgment on you… with regard to… a Sabbath”). The Lutheran reads the verse as making the day an adiaphoron, a shadow whose substance is Christ. The Adventist holds the seventh day to be a standing command of the Decalogue, kept not to earn salvation but as “a symbol of our redemption in Christ” (Fundamental Belief 20), and reads the “Sabbath” of Colossians 2:16 as the ceremonial sabbaths of Israel’s festival calendar. The question of seventh-day Sabbath observance is an important modern instance of Christian liberty, and it is treated more fully in chapter 26.

The Lutheran answer, then, is that God has given His Gospel and Sacraments and left the forms free, to be kept in love.


7. Pastoral and Practical Significance

This short article becomes very practical in the life of a congregation.

Consider what divides churches. People rarely split over the doctrine of justification. They split over music (organ or guitar, hymns or choruses), robes and vestments, candles, projection screens, liturgy and informality, Advent wreaths, and how often and in what manner the congregation comes to Communion. These fights can be ferocious and can drive faithful people out of a church they love, all over things Christ never commanded! Most worship wars are not fought over doctrine. They are fought because people forget the doctrine of Christian freedom. Often both sides have forgotten it: one side insists that everyone must keep the old form, the other insists that everyone must abandon it, and each is certain that faithfulness requires the whole congregation to worship the way it does.

Article XV hands the church a better way through, and it begins with one question, whether God has commanded the thing or set us free. Where Christ has instituted something and attached His promise to it (the preaching of the Gospel, Baptism, Absolution, the Lord’s Supper), there is nothing to negotiate. These are His gifts, the means by which He gives forgiveness, and the church receives them. Where the answer is that these things are adiaphora (the style of the music, the color of the altar and pulpit cloths, the presence or absence of a screen), the question changes entirely. It is no longer “Who is right and who is wrong?” but “How shall we, who are free, use our freedom to serve one another?” (Romans 14). Neither side may despise or judge the other and either may turn out to be the “weak” brother of Romans 14 on a given Sunday. Freedom is exercised for the neighbor and not against him. A congregation may, rarely, have a form pressed on it in order to teach something false or to make it disown the Gospel, and then the form must be refused, as section 5 explained. A quarrel over organ or guitar is almost never such a moment and neither side should claim that it is.

Take one example the whole church knows: the church year. Some Christians assume that every believer must keep Lent, or Advent, or the whole calendar of the church’s seasons, as though it were commanded. Others assume the church year is somehow unbiblical, a human invention the truly free avoid. Article XV says neither. The church year is a gift, a way of walking through the life of Christ year after year, and it has shaped and fed God’s people for centuries. The church year is a wonderful servant. It becomes a terrible master. Kept freely, as a help to faith, it is pure gift; imposed as a law, as though God’s favor depended on observing it, it becomes exactly the kind of burden Article XV forbids. The same is true of nearly everything the worship wars are fought over.

Article XV concerns the freedom of a conscience justified by Christ. If the Gospel has freed your conscience, you are no longer asking whether the forms are right enough to please God, because that question was answered once for all at the cross. That answer is still given to you where Christ has promised to give it: in His Word preached, in your Baptism, in the Absolution, and in His body and blood at the altar. When your conscience asks whether you have kept the forms well enough, go there and hear it again. You are free to keep the old and good, free to receive the new and helpful, and free above all to stop policing your neighbor and start loving him. Paul’s reason is simple: “welcome one another as Christ has welcomed you, for the glory of God” (Romans 15:7). The neighbor across the aisle who loves the other hymnal has been welcomed by the same Christ, at the same font and the same table. The church’s ceremonies are gifts to serve faith, never chains to bind the conscience.

Article XV thus completes what Article XIV began. There Christ orders His Church so that His gifts are delivered with certainty; here He leaves many outward forms free so that His people may serve one another in love. Together they give good order without authoritarianism, and genuine freedom without chaos.

Has God commanded this—or has He set me free? Free because of Christ. Guided by love.


8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading

8.1 Summary

  • Christ has freed the conscience. We are justified freely for His sake, through faith (AC IV), so no ceremony can add to His work and no tradition may be bound on the conscience as necessary (Galatians 5:1; Colossians 2:16–17).
  • Article XV says the church’s usages “profitable unto tranquillity and good order” ought to be kept, but never as necessary to salvation; traditions instituted “to merit grace” are “opposed to the Gospel.”
  • Adiaphora are things God has neither commanded nor forbidden. They are free, and they are in themselves no worship of God, nor even a part of it (FC Ep X.3).
  • Freedom rebukes two errors: legalism (“you must do this”) and lawless individualism (“I refuse all tradition because I am free”). Free to keep. Free to change. Never free to stop loving.
  • Freedom serves love (Galatians 5:13; Romans 14) and keeps good order (1 Corinthians 14:40).
  • The limit is the casus confessionis (FC X): a free thing ceases to be free when it is used to deny the Gospel.
  • The Reformed regulative principle admits as elements of worship only what Scripture commands, and leaves the circumstances to Christian prudence; the Lutheran and Anglican normative principle leaves free what Scripture does not forbid.
  • Lutherans love tradition; we simply refuse to confuse good traditions with God’s commands.
  • The church’s ceremonies are gifts to serve faith, never chains to bind the conscience.

8.2 Tables

Table 15.1—Worship: Regulative, Normative, and Prescribed

Regulative principle Normative principle Received liturgy and tradition
Governing rule The elements of worship must be commanded in Scripture; circumstances are ordered by prudence Whatever Scripture does not forbid is free The received liturgy and tradition order worship
Church year / holy days Strict practice rejected holy days besides the Lord’s Day (Scottish and Puritan: no Christmas); the Continental Reformed kept the chief feasts of Christ freely Free; kept for good order and teaching Central; the calendar structures the year
Images / instruments Images rejected under the second commandment; instruments historically excluded, now widely used Free (not forbidden) Icons and images central; Rome keeps the organ and other instruments, while the Orthodox sing unaccompanied
Underlying concern Worship God only as He commands; avoid will-worship Do not bind what God left free (Lutheran); edifying, common order under Scripture (Anglican) Worship received from the apostles as the Church’s share in Christ’s own (and the heavenly) worship; continuity and reverence across time
Representative traditions Reformed / Presbyterian; historic Puritan / Baptist Lutheran; Anglican; Methodist Roman Catholic; Eastern Orthodox

Confidence: high on the Reformed and Lutheran/Anglican principles (confessional texts); the Roman Catholic and Orthodox column describes a received practice rather than a single “principle.”

Table 15.2—Adiaphora and Its Limits

Question Answer
What is an adiaphoron? A matter God has neither commanded nor forbidden, and therefore free (e.g., the style of music, vestments, the church year, times of worship). Such rites “are in and of themselves no divine worship, nor even a part of it” (FC Ep X.3).
Who may order it? The church in each place, freely, “as may be most useful and edifying” (FC Ep X.4). It may keep, change, or drop it, but “all frivolity and offense should be avoided” (FC Ep X.5). No church should condemn another for having fewer or more ceremonies, where there is agreement in doctrine and in the right use of the Sacraments (FC Ep X.7).
How is it handled in the congregation? By love (Romans 14; 1 Corinthians 10): the strong do not despise the weak, the weak do not judge the strong, and freedom serves the neighbor, for God has welcomed both (Romans 14:3; 15:7).
When does it stop being free? In a casus confessionis, when, under demand from opponents of the Gospel, yielding it would deny the Gospel, confirm error, or mislead the weak. Then it must be confessed, not surrendered (FC X).
The one thing to remember A free thing ceases to be free when it is used to deny the Gospel.

The adiaphora decision tree. Start with the first question: Has God commanded or forbidden this in His Word? If He has commanded it, keep it as His (it is not free); if He has forbidden it, do not (it is not free); if neither, it is an adiaphoron and free. Then, for a free thing, ask whether it is profitable for good order and edification. If it is, keep it freely; if it is burdensome, divisive, or misunderstood, the church may change or drop it. Finally comes the exceptional branch, marked as the exception: Is it being demanded as a confession, so that yielding would deny the Gospel or confirm error (a casus confessionis*)?* Then do not yield.

8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)

  • Adiaphora [ad-ee-AH-for-ah]: things neither commanded nor forbidden by God.
  • Casus confessionis (“case of confession,” from FC X’s “in time of persecution and in case of confession,” Ep X.2): the point at which a free thing must be confessed and not yielded. (The modern term status confessionis is related but broader.)
  • The regulative principle and the normative principle of worship.
  • Christian liberty.
  • Human traditions.

8.4 Further reading

  • The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC XV; AC VII (unity and differing rites); Apology XV (the old traditions cheerfully maintained); Formula of Concord X (adiaphora and the casus confessionis); Smalcald Articles III.xv (human traditions).
  • Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3.
  • Richard Hooker, Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity, Books III–IV, the classic Anglican defense of the Church’s freedom to order its ceremonies.
  • The Fathers, from their own texts: Augustine, Letters 54–55 (to Januarius); Eusebius, Church History 5.24 (Irenaeus to Victor, the Paschal fast).
  • For the comparisons, from their own sources: the Catechism of the Catholic Church §§2041–2043 (the precepts of the Church) and §§74–83, 97 (Tradition); the Thirty-Nine Articles XX and XXXIV; the Westminster Confession 1.6 and 21.1 (the regulative principle, with its proof text Deuteronomy 12:32; Reformed writers also cite Leviticus 10:1–2); the Second London Baptist Confession (ch. 22); Timothy (Kallistos) Ware, The Orthodox Church, 3rd ed. (London: Penguin, 2015), the chapter “Holy Tradition: The Source of the Orthodox Faith”; an official Seventh-day Adventist statement on the Sabbath (see chapter 26).
Topics
Christian FreedomWorship and LiturgyOther Churches and Traditions
Scripture
Galatians 5:11 Corinthians 10:29Galatians 5:4Galatians 5:13Colossians 2:16–17Colossians 2:20–23Mark 7:11Matthew 15:9Romans 14:5Romans 14:3Romans 14:131 Corinthians 10:23–24Acts 15:281 Corinthians 14:40Acts 16:3Galatians 2:4–5Galatians 2:3–5Romans 14:1Galatians 4:1–2Deuteronomy 12:32Leviticus 10:11 Corinthians 14:26Colossians 2:16Romans 15:7Leviticus 10:1–2
Confessions
AC XVEp XAp XVSD XAC VIIAC IVSA III

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.