Chapter 5—Article V: The Means of Grace and the Office of the Ministry
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
A promise is only comforting if you know where to find it. Article V exists to answer that question. Where has God promised to meet sinners today? The Lutheran Confessions answer without hesitation: in the Gospel preached, in Holy Baptism, in Holy Absolution, and in the Lord’s Supper.
That answer runs against the current of most religion, and even most of our instincts. We assume that finding God is something we do by climbing, reaching upward through effort, feeling, or spiritual intensity until we break through to Him. Article V says the opposite. The Christian faith begins with God coming down to us, through means He has appointed and attached His promise to. He does not leave us to search the sky or, worse, to search our own unreliable hearts. He puts His grace where we can hear it, see it, and touch it.
These appointed channels have a name in the tradition, the means of grace, and the name is worth learning, because it may be one of the most freeing phrases in Christian theology. It relocates the whole question of assurance. The anxious believer stops asking, Have I felt enough? Is my experience real enough? and starts asking the question Article V answers, a question with a certain answer. I want you to see from the start that the answer never changes. It is never “inside yourself,” but always where God has fixed His promise. This book puts the whole of it in one sentence: God gives Christ through means.
1. What the Article Says
Article V is short and it comes where you would expect if you have been following the Confession’s logic. Article IV has just said that we are justified by grace, for Christ’s sake, through faith. Article V immediately asks the obvious next question: and how does anyone come to have that faith? The Article answers:
That we may obtain this faith, the Ministry of Teaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments was instituted. For through the Word and Sacraments, as through instruments, the Holy Ghost is given, who works faith; where and when it pleases God, in them that hear the Gospel, to wit, that God, not for our own merits, but for Christ’s sake, justifies those who believe that they are received into grace for Christ’s sake. They condemn the Anabaptists and others who think that the Holy Ghost comes to men without the external Word, through their own preparations and works. (AC V.1–4)
(The Confession is quoted in an older English translation, in which “Holy Ghost” is the Holy Spirit and “to wit” means “namely.”)
Read in its plain sense, the Article makes three claims, and all three point in the same direction, which is outward.
God instituted the means. Faith does not arise from nowhere and it is not something we manufacture. “That we may obtain this faith, the Ministry of Teaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments was instituted.” In other words, when the Confession speaks of the ministry here, it is not first talking about the man in the pulpit. It means the work of teaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments, through which God hands His gifts to us. The preached Gospel and the Sacraments are God’s own appointment. He gave them for a purpose, so that faith may be created.
The Spirit works through them, as through instruments. “For through the Word and Sacraments, as through instruments, the Holy Ghost is given, who works faith.” The Holy Spirit is not idle where the Gospel is preached and He does not ordinarily work saving faith by bypassing these channels. He works through them, the way a message works through a voice. The Word and Sacraments are the instruments in the Spirit’s hand.
He does it freely, “where and when it pleases God.” The means are not magic. They do not force God’s hand or work automatically, as if grace were a mechanism we operate. The Spirit creates faith through them in His own time and way, in those who hear the Gospel. That phrase sets no hidden limit on God’s good will toward you. The sidebar in section 5 explains why.
Then the Article draws its one boundary: it condemns “the Anabaptists and others who think that the Holy Ghost comes to men without the external Word.” We will come with care to what that means, and to whom it does and does not apply. Even here the concern is pastoral. The Confession is protecting the place where the frightened can reliably find God, against the idea that we must instead find Him within.
A note on the Article’s name. The Augsburg Confession was presented in both German and Latin. The German heads this article Vom Predigtamt, “Of the Preaching Office,” and its text says that God instituted the preaching office and gave the Gospel and the Sacraments. The Latin speaks of the “ministry of teaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments.” Both join the office to the means it serves, and this chapter follows the emphasis they share: the office exists to deliver Christ through Word and Sacrament. (The further questions of who may hold the office and how they are called belong to Article XIV, and we will take them up in chapter 14.)
Therefore the Article does not send a troubled believer inward, to the intensity of his own search, but outward, to the Gospel and the Sacraments God instituted for that purpose.
2. Biblical Theology
The Confession is only gathering up what Scripture everywhere assumes: that God saves through an external, spoken, tangible Word.
Faith comes from hearing. Paul lays out the chain link by link: “How then will they call on him in whom they have not believed? And how are they to believe in him of whom they have never heard? And how are they to hear without someone preaching? … So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ” (Romans 10:14–17, ESV). Trace it backward and the point is unmistakable. Faith depends on hearing, hearing depends on preaching, and preaching depends on someone being sent. The word Paul uses for “hearing” is akoē, which can mean the hearing itself or “a thing heard.” Under that second sense Thayer’s lexicon gives “instruction, namely oral; specifically, the preaching of the gospel,” and it cites this very passage. In other words, faith comes to us from outside. Someone must speak the Word to us before we can believe it. This is the foundational text for everything Article V confesses.
God works new birth through means. When Paul describes regeneration, he ties it to something concrete. God “saved us … by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5), so that the Spirit’s renewing work is joined to a washing. Peter says we have been “born again … through the living and abiding word of God” (1 Peter 1:23). The new birth is God’s work and He does it through the Word and the water.
The Word is not empty. God says of His Word that “it shall not return to me empty, but it shall accomplish that which I purpose” (Isaiah 55:11). God’s Word does what He sends it to do, whether or not we think we have made it work. The invitation that frames that promise is pure grace: “Come, everyone who thirsts” (Isaiah 55:1). The Word that accomplishes God’s purpose is a Word of free grace and it comes to us.
Christ Himself institutes the sending and attaches forgiveness to it. On Easter evening the risen Jesus said, “As the Father has sent me, even so I am sending you.” Then “he breathed on them and said … ‘Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them’” (John 20:21–23). Here in one scene is the whole shape of Article V: a sending (the office), the Spirit joined to it, and a concrete authority to forgive sins placed in human mouths. When a Christian hears “your sins are forgiven,” Christ’s own institution is being exercised. This is the root of what Lutherans call Holy Absolution.
The Spirit’s freedom does not mean the Spirit’s independence from the Word. Two passages are often raised here, and both, read whole, confirm the point. Jesus says, “It is the Spirit who gives life; the flesh is no help at all. The words that I have spoken to you are spirit and life” (John 6:63). Notice that in the same breath He calls His words, an external spoken means, “spirit and life.” In Acts the Holy Spirit falls on Cornelius and his household, and Luke tells us exactly when: “While Peter was still saying these things, the Holy Spirit fell on all who heard the word” (Acts 10:44). The Spirit came with wonderful freedom of timing, as Article V says (“where and when it pleases God”), but He came through the preached Word, and baptism followed at once. The sudden, felt nearness of the Spirit that many Christians rightly long for came to Cornelius while Peter was preaching.
Therefore, every one of these texts sends the believer away from the sky and away from the mirror, to the Word God has spoken and the water He has joined to it, because that is where He has promised to give Christ.
3. Historical Context
Article V was written against a specific and painful memory. In the early years of the Reformation, some who had left Rome went much further than Luther. They taught that the truly spiritual Christian receives the Spirit directly (inwardly and immediately), so that the external Word, preaching, and the sacraments are at best a help for beginners and at worst a “dead letter” that quenches the living Spirit.
The name the Reformers gave this needs care, because it does not mean today what it meant then. Luther called this “enthusiasm” (Schwärmerei)—not excitement or emotional worship, but the expectation that God ordinarily works apart from the external Word He has promised. (The English word comes from a Greek one meaning “having God within.”) The figures he had in view included Andreas Karlstadt, his former Wittenberg colleague, who came to set the Spirit’s inward working above the outward means and denied Christ’s bodily presence in the Supper, and Thomas Müntzer, who exalted an inner revelation of the Spirit over the “mere” letter of Scripture.
The Confession itself names “the Anabaptists” (“re-baptizers,” their opponents’ name for them, since they held that infant baptism was no baptism), a broad sixteenth-century label for the radical reformers who rejected infant Baptism. Some of them set the outward Word aside, while others, such as the Swiss Brethren, held fast to Scripture. Article V’s target is the teaching that the Spirit comes without the external Word, not every group that bore the name. Today’s Mennonites are not the people this condemnation describes either. Their Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (1995) accepts “the Scriptures as the Word of God” and holds that other claims, “such as tradition, culture, experience, reason, and political powers,” must “be tested and corrected by the light of Holy Scripture” (Art. 4). The Lutheran–Mennonite study commission of 2010 reached the same judgment, that “the condemnation in Article V” does not “apply to Mennonites today” (Healing Memories, 79).1 Lutherans and Mennonites still differ on Baptism, and chapter 9 tells how Lutherans once treated the Anabaptists.
Against the enthusiasts Luther drew a line that became one of the most characteristic Lutheran convictions: God has bound Himself to come to us through the external Word and the Sacraments, and any “spirit” that claims to arrive apart from and before that Word is not the Holy Spirit. He put it with full force in the Smalcald Articles, where he wrote that “we must firmly hold that God grants His Spirit or grace to no one, except through or with the preceding outward Word” (SA III.viii.3). A few paragraphs later he said it again: “God does not wish to deal with us otherwise than through the spoken Word and the Sacraments. It is the devil himself whatsoever is extolled as Spirit without the Word and Sacraments” (SA III.viii.10–11). The point was not to quench the Spirit but to locate Him, to tell people where to look.
Luther would not let anyone treat this as somebody else’s problem. In the same article he traced it to Eden, where the old serpent “converted Adam and Eve into enthusiasts,” and he concluded that “enthusiasm inheres in Adam and his children from the beginning [from the first fall] to the end of the world” (SA III.viii.5, 9). In other words, the urge to look for God inside ourselves belongs to every fallen heart, our own included. Luther found it in Rome as well, for “the Papacy also is nothing but sheer enthusiasm, by which the Pope boasts that all rights exist in the shrine of his heart, and whatever he decides and commands with [in] his church is spirit and right, even though it is above and contrary to Scripture and the spoken Word” (SA III.viii.4). That is the Confessions’ judgment on the papacy’s claim in the sixteenth century to set its own decrees above Scripture, not a verdict on Roman Catholic Christians today. Because Luther traced enthusiasm to every fallen heart, his sharp words are aimed at a teaching and not at a people, and we will see in section 6 why they cannot simply be laid on the modern Pentecostal Christian who loves the Scriptures, is baptized, and comes to the Lord’s Table.
Article V therefore speaks of the office in the same breath as the means. The office exists to deliver Christ through Word and Sacrament. The enthusiasts had made that delivery secondary to an inner voice. The Reformers would give a frightened conscience today the answer they gave then: look to the external Word God has spoken.
4. Early Church Witness
The idea that God binds His grace to external means was not a Reformation novelty; its roots run deep, especially in the West.
The clearest witness is Augustine, who gave the Church a phrase it never forgot: a sacrament is a “visible word.” “The word is added to the element,” he wrote, “and there results the Sacrament, as if itself also a kind of visible word” (Tractates on John 80.3). In other words, a sacrament is God’s promise joined to something you can see and touch. Luther quotes the first half of that sentence twice in the Large Catechism and says that Augustine “has scarcely said anything better” (LC IV.18; V.10). This is the Lutheran understanding as well. The Word joined to a physical element (water, bread, wine) is God’s chosen way of delivering grace to creatures who live in bodies. Augustine also insisted, against the Donatists (a North African party who held that the sacraments of an unworthy priest were void), that the power of the sacrament comes from Christ’s Word and not from the worthiness of the minister. The Augsburg Confession condemns the Donatists on the same ground (AC VIII.3). That objectivity lets a believer rely on the gift whoever hands it over.
John Chrysostom, the greatest preacher of the early Church, bore witness in another key, to the astonishing dignity and power of the preached Word, through which God works on His people. In On the Priesthood he calls the teaching of the Word “the one instrument, the only diet, the finest atmosphere” for the healing of souls (IV.3).
We should not claim too much here. The fully developed Lutheran doctrine of the “means of grace” is a later systematizing of these instincts, not a phrase the Fathers used in our technical sense, and the patristic witness on this particular point is thinner than it is on the Trinity or the person of Christ. The visible word vocabulary is also distinctly Western. The conviction behind it is wider, since the Eastern Fathers also taught that God gives grace through the Word joined to water, oil, and bread (Cyril of Jerusalem, Mystagogical Catecheses 2–4; Gregory of Nyssa, Catechetical Oration 33–37). The Eastern Orthodox Church still teaches in that spirit. The nineteenth-century Russian Longer Catechism of Metropolitan Philaret defines a sacrament, or Mystery, as “a holy act, through which grace, or, in other words, the saving power of God, works mysteriously upon man” (Q. 284). We therefore claim the Fathers as genuine witnesses, not as proof that they held Article V word for word. The conviction that God comes to us through a Word joined to visible things is at least as old as Augustine’s “visible word.”
5. Lutheran Confessional Theology
What is a means of grace? Put simply, it is a way God has appointed to give us Christ and the forgiveness He won: the Gospel spoken, or joined by Christ’s command to water, bread, and wine. On the means of grace the Confession speaks warmly and often, and the rest of the Book of Concord fills out how God gives through them. It is important to look at the means one by one, because the Lutheran church treasures each of them and the wider Protestant world has sometimes forgotten one or two. Luther names all four in the Smalcald Articles, where the Gospel “not merely in one way gives us counsel and aid against sin”: through the spoken Word, through Baptism, through the Sacrament of the Altar, and through the power of the keys, that is, Absolution, “and also through the mutual conversation and consolation of brethren” (SA III.iv).
The preached Gospel. First and foundational is the living voice of the Gospel: Christ proclaimed and applied to the hearer. Through this living voice the Spirit creates and sustains faith (Romans 10:17). The same Word also convicts. Through the Law the Spirit shows us our sin and through the Gospel He gives us Christ (AC XII; Ap XII). Both come from outside us. For the penitent the Gospel is always God’s final word. Where Christ is preached, God is at work.
Holy Baptism. God joins His Word to water and makes it, in Luther’s phrase, a “gracious water of life,” its power resting not in the water but in “the word of God which is in and with the water, and faith, which trusts such word of God in the water” (SC IV). Here God’s promise is attached to something done to you, something you can point back to on your worst days. Luther teaches the troubled conscience to say, “Nevertheless I am baptized; but if I am baptized, it is promised me that I shall be saved and have eternal life, both in soul and body” (LC IV.44). If you have wandered from it, its promise has not been withdrawn. Luther says that “a truly Christian life is nothing else than a daily baptism, once begun and ever to be continued,” and that repentance “is nothing else than a return and approach to Baptism” (LC IV.65, 79). (Baptism has its own chapter, chapter 9 on Article IX, but it belongs on this list because it is a means of grace.)
Holy Absolution. Absolution needs special attention, because much of Protestantism has let it fall away while the Lutheran Confessions keep it. (Anglicans, Roman Catholics, and the Eastern Orthodox have kept it too.) The Augsburg Confession insists that private absolution be retained in the churches (AC XI). When a pastor, by Christ’s institution (John 20:23), speaks the words “your sins are forgiven,” that word delivers forgiveness to this sinner, by name. Luther prized private absolution as one of the great comforts of the Christian life, a place to bring a specific, tormenting sin and hear a specific, personal word of pardon. In the Smalcald Articles he calls Absolution “an aid and consolation against sin and a bad conscience, ordained by Christ [Himself] in the Gospel,” which must not be abolished, “especially on account of [tender and] timid consciences” (SA III.viii.1). What a comfort for a troubled conscience! A Christian crushed by guilt does not have to wonder whether God, in general, forgives; he can hear the forgiveness spoken to him. This is what the means of grace do for the conscience: they give the promise a voice and a name to speak to. (Confession and Absolution return in chapter 11, on Article XI.)
The Lord’s Supper. God attaches His Word to bread and wine, and Christ gives His very body and blood with them. He said, “This is my body, which is given for you” (Luke 22:19), and of the cup, “this is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins” (Matthew 26:28). The Small Catechism fastens on the words “for you” and teaches that the one who believes them has what they say (SC VI). Here Christ Himself, with the forgiveness He won, is placed on your tongue. If you fear that your faith is too weak to receive Him, the Formula of Concord answers that the Supper “was instituted especially for Christians weak in faith, yet penitent, for the consolation and strengthening of their weak faith” (FC Ep VII.19). (Its own great chapter is chapter 10, on Article X.)
Notice that in all four God comes down to us and gives us Christ. Assurance does not rest on the strength of your feelings or the success of your inward search; it rests on God’s promise fixed to means outside you. You can doubt your experience, but your Baptism and the absolution spoken over you still stand.
Sidebar—“Where and when it pleases God”: the Spirit’s freedom, and why faith is God’s work. Article V says the Spirit works faith through the means “where and when it pleases God” (ubi et quando visum est Deo). That small phrase guards against two errors at once. On one side, it denies that the means work mechanically, as if grace were dispensed automatically by the ritual, regardless of whether the promise is believed. The Confessions hold both sides together here. The sacraments “are effectual by reason of the institution and commandment of Christ, notwithstanding they be administered by evil men” (AC VIII.2), yet the Confession condemns “those who teach that the Sacraments justify by the outward act, and who do not teach that, in the use of the Sacraments, faith which believes that sins are forgiven, is required” (AC XIII.3; cf. Ap XIII.18). In other words, a sacrament stands on Christ’s word even when the pastor is unworthy, and its blessing is received by faith in the promise.
On the other side, the phrase denies that faith is the hearer’s own achievement. Conversion itself is the Spirit’s work and not our cooperation, what theologians call monergism (“one working”). The Formula of Concord confesses this against both the enthusiasts, who expect the Spirit apart from the means, and the synergists (from the Greek for “working together”), who make the will a partner in its own conversion (FC Ep II). After conversion, the Formula adds, the new heart does work with the Spirit: “through the power of the Holy Ghost we can and should cooperate” (FC SD II.65). Monergism is therefore no excuse for idleness.
The Wesleyan and Arminian traditions (Methodists and many other evangelical churches) answer differently, with a doctrine of prevenient grace (“grace that goes before”), a grace given to all that restores the will’s ability to respond; that debate belongs to Article XVIII (Free Will), in chapter 18. On the means themselves, however, John Wesley stood close to the Reformation. Against those who urged believers to wait in “stillness” apart from the means, he called them “the ordinary channels” by which God conveys grace (Sermon 16, “The Means of Grace,” 1746).
One caution belongs with the phrase. “Where and when it pleases God” is no secret clause hidden behind the promise, as if God might be unwilling toward you while His Word says otherwise. Scripture tells us what pleases Him: He “desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth” (1 Timothy 2:4). The Formula of Concord warns against searching for God’s will in His hidden counsel and directs us to learn it from the Word that is preached to us (FC Ep XI.6; FC SD XI.26, 70). Therefore the phrase keeps the means from becoming our tool without making them any less certain for the one who hears.
In other words, because faith is God’s gift given through His means, your salvation does not finally depend on the quality of your response, but on the faithfulness of the God who comes to you.
6. Comparative Theology
Almost every Christian tradition agrees that God uses the Word; the differences come over the sacraments and, more deeply, over whether the Spirit’s ordinary saving work is bound to external means at all. I want to present each tradition in its strongest and fairest form, moving from the traditions nearest the Lutheran conviction about the sacraments toward the one that stands farthest from it.
Roman Catholic. The Roman Catholic Church teaches a robust doctrine that God truly gives grace through external, physical means (indeed through seven sacraments), and here there is real, deep common ground. The Catholic and the Lutheran both refuse to make grace a purely inward, invisible affair. The classic Catholic principle is that the sacraments work ex opere operato, “from the work worked,” meaning that their efficacy rests on Christ’s institution and the rite performed, not on the worthiness of the minister or of the recipient. Lutherans share the conviction that the sacrament does not depend on the minister’s holiness (AC VIII.2). The Confessions nevertheless reject ex opere operato as the scholastic theologians taught it. The Apology’s words are sharp: “Here we condemn the whole crowd of scholastic doctors, who teach that the Sacraments confer grace ex opere operato, without a good disposition on the part of the one using them, provided he do not place a hindrance in the way” (Ap XIII.18). That is the Confessions’ judgment on the teaching of the medieval schools as it stood in the sixteenth century, not a verdict on Roman Catholic Christians today. Roman Catholic teaching has held from Trent onward that the sacraments confer grace on those “who do not place an obstacle” (Session VII, canon 6), and it teaches that “the fruits of the sacraments also depend on the disposition of the one who receives them” (CCC 1128). The difference that remains is over what in us receives the gift. The Lutheran Confessions say it is faith trusting Christ’s promise. The Council of Trent rejected the teaching that faith in the divine promise alone suffices to obtain grace (Session VII, canon 8). Both churches, then, say the receiver matters. They part over whether faith alone takes hold of the gift. The traditions also differ on the number of the sacraments and on the ordained priesthood.
Anglican. The Thirty-Nine Articles of the Church of England (1571) speak to this Article directly: “Sacraments ordained of Christ be not only badges or tokens of Christian men’s profession, but rather they be certain sure witnesses, and effectual signs of grace, and God’s good will towards us, by the which he doth work invisibly in us, and doth not only quicken, but also strengthen and confirm our Faith in him” (Art. XXV). A Lutheran can read that sentence with gladness. It refuses to make the sacraments mere badges of our profession and it says that God works through them. The Article does not settle how God works through them and Anglicans have read it in both a Reformed and a more catholic sense. The Methodist Articles of Religion are Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine, and their sixteenth article keeps the sentence but calls the sacraments “certain signs of grace” without the words “sure witnesses, and effectual.”
Reformed. Close to Lutheranism in a different way is the Reformed tradition, which explicitly speaks of the “means of grace” and treasures the preached Word; its confessions call the sacraments “signs and seals” of the covenant of grace, God’s promise of salvation in Christ. The difference is one of mode. The Reformed confessions speak of the sacraments chiefly as signs and seals that confirm and strengthen faith (Heidelberg Q65–66), while also calling them “effectual means of salvation” by the working of the Spirit (Westminster Shorter Catechism Q91). Lutherans speak more directly of the sacraments as instruments through which the Spirit gives and creates faith. The Westminster Confession can say that by the right use of Baptism “the grace promised is not only offered, but really exhibited, and conferred, by the Holy Ghost, to such (whether of age or infants) as that grace belongeth unto, according to the counsel of God’s own will” (28.6). (“Exhibited” has its older sense here of held out and handed over.) Both traditions hold that the Word and the Sacraments are God’s ordinary means. They part where Westminster adds that “grace and salvation are not so inseparably annexed unto it, as that no person can be regenerated, or saved, without it; or, that all that are baptized are undoubtedly regenerated” (28.5), and that Baptism’s efficacy “is not tied to that moment of time wherein it is administered” (28.6). The Lutheran Confession says that God has promised to give the Spirit through the means and that the promise in the sacrament is meant for everyone who receives it. It is a real difference, because it touches the very question this Article asks: has God promised to give His Spirit through the means themselves?
Baptist. With the Baptist tradition the agreement narrows to the Word. Most Baptists honor the preached Word as central and powerful. In this they share the Reformation’s confidence. The divergence is over the sacraments, which much of the Baptist tradition calls ordinances. In the words of the Southern Baptist Convention’s Baptist Faith and Message (2000), baptism is “an act of obedience symbolizing the believer’s faith,” and in the Supper members of the church “memorialize the death of the Redeemer and anticipate His second coming.” They are signs and testimonies, not means that convey grace. (Baptists are not all alike. The older Reformed Baptist confession of 1689, the Second London Confession, holds a higher view of the ordinances than much of later Baptist practice.)
Pentecostal and Charismatic. Great care must be taken here, because this is the tradition most likely to be misread against Article V and because so many readers love and belong to it. The “enthusiasts” condemned in the sixteenth century cannot simply be equated with modern Pentecostal Christians. Most Pentecostals love the Scriptures, preach Christ with fervor, baptize, and celebrate Communion. The disagreement Article V raises is not whether God speaks (every Christian confesses that He does) but how God has promised to speak. The Assemblies of God confess that salvation is received through repentance and faith, “by the washing of regeneration and renewing of the Holy Ghost,” citing the same Titus 3:5 that section 2 quoted. The traditions part over assurance and over the Spirit’s further work. The same statement, citing Romans 8:16 (“The Spirit himself bears witness with our spirit that we are children of God”), names “the direct witness of the Spirit” as the inward evidence of salvation. It also teaches a baptism in the Spirit that follows conversion, a distinct experience of the Spirit’s empowering that is not the same as water Baptism. Lutherans confess that witness too (Romans 8:16), and the Lutheran Confession teaches the believer to hear it where the Spirit bears it, in the external Word and Sacraments, rather than in an inward experience beside them. This bears directly on where a Christian should look for assurance. Even so, it is a difference of emphasis among fellow Christians and not the ancient error transplanted whole. The genuine gift the Pentecostal and charismatic movements guard, that God is living, present, and active and that dead formalism is a real danger, is one the Lutheran gladly affirms.
The Quakers. The clearest case of “the immediate Spirit, apart from outward means” is older than Pentecostalism and unrelated to it. It is the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers). Following Robert Barclay’s classic Apology, Friends have historically taught that the Inward Light of Christ (often called the inner light) teaches the soul immediately. They have not practiced the outward rites, holding that the one baptism is the inward baptism of the Spirit and that true communion is a daily spiritual feeding on Christ. (Some evangelical Friends churches now allow water baptism and the Supper on request, as a matter of conscience.) This is where the line Article V draws becomes visible in its purest form: a devout, Christ-loving tradition that has historically kept no outward sacraments and holds even the Scriptures as “a secondary rule, subordinate to the Spirit” (Barclay, Prop. III). Friends today range from programmed churches with pastors and sermons to unprogrammed meetings gathered in silence. The Quaker position springs from a real concern to guard the Spirit’s freedom and inwardness. However, it is the point at which the Lutheran Confession says that God has promised to meet us at the means, and that it is there we should seek Him.
Each tradition, then, answers the chapter’s question in its own way, and the differences matter. The Lutheran answer, however, is plain. God is found in the Word preached and in Baptism, Absolution, and the Supper, outside us, where He can be found for certain.
7. Pastoral and Practical Significance
Everything in this chapter finally serves one weary, familiar question: How do I know God is for me, not humanity in general but me?
There are two places you can look for the answer, and only one of them is safe. You can look inward (at your feelings and the sincerity of your faith) and try to find enough evidence there to be sure. Many sincere Christians live this way, and it wears them out, because the evidence is never quite enough and the heart is a shifting witness. The Law rightly sends us inward to see our sins (1 Corinthians 11:28), but it never sends us there to find our assurance. I want to send you to the other place. It is outward, to what God has actually done and said and attached His promise to. Article V is the great turn from the anxiety of self-inspection to the comfort of the external Word.
This is why the means of grace matter so much to the pastor and to the person in the pew. When you cannot feel God’s love, you can hear it in the Gospel preached to you this Sunday. When you doubt whether you belong to Christ, you can return to a fact outside your feelings: I have been baptized, and God put His name on me. When a particular sin will not stop accusing you, you do not have to manufacture a sense of forgiveness. You can go and hear it spoken in Absolution, by Christ’s own institution. When you long for Christ Himself, you are given Him on the tongue in the Supper, “for you.” In every case God gives Christ through means, and assurance rests on His promise. When your conscience is troubled, then, go where Christ is given: to the preached Word, back to your Baptism, to the absolution, and to the Lord’s Table.
If you have never been baptized, the promise is spoken to you as well: “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is for you and for your children and for all who are far off, everyone whom the Lord our God calls to himself” (Acts 2:38–39). Speak to a pastor.
Article V closes with a condemnation but only to guard the place where God has promised to be found. Christianity is not, at its heart, our climb up toward a hidden God; it is God’s descent to us through the humble means He chose: a voice, water, a word of pardon, and bread and wine. We should close this chapter thinking not mainly about anyone the Article critiques, but with relief. Where does God promise to meet me? Each of us can answer it now: I know where Christ has promised to meet me.
8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading
8.1 Summary
Article V confesses that, to bring us to the faith that justifies (Article IV), God instituted the ministry of teaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments, and that through these means, as through instruments, the Holy Spirit works faith “where and when it pleases God” in those who hear. Faith comes by hearing an external Word (Romans 10:17); God works new birth through Word and washing (Titus 3:5); His Word does not return empty (Isaiah 55:11).
Against the “enthusiasts” who expected the Spirit apart from the external Word, the Confession locates grace where God has promised it, in the Gospel preached, in Holy Baptism, in Holy Absolution, and in the Lord’s Supper. In this way it moves the anxious conscience from self-inspection to the comfort of the external Word. Christianity is not our climb up to God but God’s coming down to us through the means He has appointed.
The traditions differ over the sacraments (means, signs, or ordinances) and over whether the Spirit’s ordinary saving work is bound to external means at all, with the Quaker Inward Light as the clearest contrast. The modern Pentecostal, however, is a fellow Christian differing in emphasis, not the enthusiast of the sixteenth century. The chapter’s abiding gift is a sure place to find God: the Word and Sacraments, where He has promised to meet us.
8.2 Tables in this chapter
Table 5.1—How Is Faith Created and Sustained?
| Tradition | How grace ordinarily comes | The sacraments are… |
|---|---|---|
| Lutheran | Through Word and Sacrament as instruments the Spirit uses (monergism; “where and when it pleases God”) | Means of grace: God gives Christ through them, received by faith |
| Roman Catholic | Through the Word and seven sacraments, working ex opere operato | Means that confer grace ex opere operato; their fruit depends on the recipient’s disposition (CCC 1128) |
| Reformed | Through the Word, by which God effectually calls; the sacraments seal and strengthen faith and are “effectual means” by the Spirit (WSC Q91) | Signs and seals of the covenant of grace; by the Spirit grace is “exhibited, and conferred” on those to whom it belongs (WCF 28.6), though not tied to the moment of the rite |
| Baptist | Through the preached Word; conversion by faith | Ordinances: obedience, testimony, and memorial (BF&M 2000, Art. VII), not means that convey grace |
| Pentecostal (e.g., Assemblies of God) | Through the Word, with strong emphasis on the Spirit’s direct witness and a subsequent baptism in the Spirit | Ordinances: baptism a declaration of faith; the Supper a symbol, memorial, and prophecy (AG). Charismatics within sacramental churches keep their own church’s teaching |
| Quaker (Religious Society of Friends) | Through the Inward Light of Christ, immediately | Historically none observed; baptism and communion held to be inward and spiritual (some evangelical Friends permit the outward rites) |
Table 5.2—Word and Spirit: Bound to the Means, or Free of Them?
| Position | Where the Spirit ordinarily works |
|---|---|
| The Spirit works through the external means | Lutheran, Roman Catholic; Reformed (the Word, and the sacraments as signs and seals to which grace is not bound); Baptist (the Word); Pentecostal (the Word, with emphasis on the Spirit’s direct witness and gifts) |
| The Spirit works chiefly immediately, apart from outward means | Friends (Quakers), historically; the outward Word held as a secondary rule (Barclay, Prop. III) |
Source: AC V, VIII, XIII; Ap XIII; CCC 1127–1131 and Trent, Session VII; Heidelberg Q65–67, Westminster Confession 27–28 and Shorter Catechism Q88, Q91; Baptist Faith and Message (2000), Art. VII, and Second London Confession 28–30; Assemblies of God Statement of Fundamental Truths §§5–7; Barclay, Apology, Props. II, III, XII, XIII.
Confidence: high for the Lutheran and Roman Catholic rows (binding documents); moderate for the Reformed row (Westminster and Heidelberg remain normative across a diverse family) and for the Baptist and Pentecostal rows (one body’s statement stands for a varied movement); limited for the Friends, whose meetings range from programmed evangelical churches to unprogrammed meetings with no shared creed. Some individual charismatic spirituality leans toward the second row of Table 5.2 by emphasis; that is not the teaching of the Pentecostal bodies cited.
8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)
Means of grace; Word and Sacrament; enthusiasm / Schwärmerei; ex opere operato; monergism; synergism; prevenient grace.
8.4 Further reading
- The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC V, VIII, XI, XII, and XIII; Apology IV and XIII; Smalcald Articles III.iv and III.viii (on enthusiasm); Small Catechism IV and VI; Large Catechism (Baptism; the Sacrament of the Altar; the Creed’s Third Article); Formula of Concord II and XI.
- Edmund Schlink, Theology of the Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3 (the means of grace).
- Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Holsten Fagerberg, A New Look at the Lutheran Confessions.
- Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (the “visible word”); on preaching, Chrysostom, On the Priesthood.
- For the comparisons, from their own sources: Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1113–1134; Calvin, Institutes IV.14 and the Heidelberg and Westminster loci; the Baptist Faith & Message (2000); the Assemblies of God Statement of Fundamental Truths; John Wesley, Sermon 16, “The Means of Grace”; and Robert Barclay, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity (for the Quaker Inward Light).
Footnotes
-
Lutheran–Mennonite International Study Commission, Healing Memories: Reconciling in Christ (2010), in Healing Memories: Implications of the Reconciliation between Lutherans and Mennonites, LWF Studies 2016/2 (Leipzig: Evangelische Verlagsanstalt, 2016), 79. ↩
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.