Books · The Augsburg Compass

Chapter 4—Article IV: Justification

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

There is a question that has kept Christians awake in every century. A conscience that has taken God seriously, and itself honestly, finally asks: How can I stand before a holy God? At two in the morning it usually takes another form: How can I know that I am right with God? Martin Luther asked it until it nearly destroyed him. Articles I to III have prepared for the answer.

This is the article Luther called “the first and chief article” and the Apology (Ap), Melanchthon’s defense of the Augsburg Confession, called “the chief topic of Christian doctrine” (Ap IV.2), the one on which, as later Lutherans put it, the Church stands or falls. If we get this wrong, nothing else can quite be right; if we get this right, a trembling sinner can have peace with God that the accusations of conscience, the devil, and death itself cannot take away. Here the Reformers believed they had recovered the Gospel itself, the good news the whole Bible had been telling.

Three small words carry the doctrine: gift, promise, and receive. Justification is a gift God gives in a promise we receive. It is not a wage we earn.


1. What the Article Says

Article IV of the Augsburg Confession (AC) is short. The Reformers did not need many words to say the one thing that mattered:

Also they teach that men cannot be justified before God by their own strength, merits, or works, but are freely justified for Christ’s sake, through faith, when they believe that they are received into favor, and that their sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake, who, by His death, has made satisfaction for our sins. This faith God imputes for righteousness in His sight. Rom. 3 and 4. (AC IV)

I find it helpful to read the Article as saying four things, and every one of them either takes something out of our hands or puts something into them.

It rules us out as the ground. “Men cannot be justified before God by their own strength, merits, or works.” Our effort, our goodness, and our religious achievement are all set aside. This is not pessimism. It follows directly from Article II, which confessed that we are born in sin, without the fear of God and without trust in Him. A person truly dead in sin cannot make himself acceptable to God any more than a corpse can make itself breathe.

It names the ground: Christ, freely. “But are freely justified for Christ’s sake” (gratis, as a gift; propter Christum, for the sake of Another). The ground of my acceptance is entirely outside me: Christ’s death, which “made satisfaction for our sins.” What I could not do, He has done, and done completely.

It names the means: faith that takes God at His word. We are justified “through faith, when they believe that they are received into favor, and that their sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake.” Notice what faith does here. It does not achieve; it believes, and so takes God at His word. Faith is the empty hand that receives the gift, and it is trust in a promise.

It names the mode: God reckons faith as righteousness. “This faith God imputes for righteousness in His sight.” God credits righteousness to the believer. It is a reckoning (Romans 4 uses the word again and again), and the righteousness that lets me stand is counted to me, not produced by me. Faith is not counted because it is a fine virtue. The Formula of Concord says it justifies “because it lays hold of and accepts the merit of Christ in the promise of the holy Gospel” (FC SD III.13).

That is the article. The verdict rests on Christ’s merit and it is received as a gift. Luther’s Smalcald Articles (SA), his own summary of the faith written a few years later, call this “the first and chief article” and say, “Of this article nothing can be yielded or surrendered … Therefore, we must be sure concerning this doctrine, and not doubt” (SA II.i.5). Everything the conscience needs depends on it.

In other words, Article IV moves the ground of your standing with God off of you and onto Christ. If your acceptance depended on your strength or your record, you could never be sure of it. You would always wonder whether you had done enough. Article IV says that it does not depend on you. It is a gift, for Christ’s sake, received by faith.


2. Biblical Theology

The Reformers did not invent this doctrine. They found it in Paul, and above all in Romans 3, 4, and 5, the center of this chapter and of the letter. Everything else in Scripture gathers around these three chapters.

Romans 3: the righteousness of God, given as a gift. Paul spends the first chapters of Romans proving that the whole world, Jew and Gentile, stands guilty before God: “None is righteous, no, not one” (Romans 3:10 ESV); “by works of the law no human being will be justified in his sight, since through the law comes knowledge of sin” (3:20). That is the diagnosis of Article II, restated. Then Paul turns with the words “But now”: “But now the righteousness of God has been manifested apart from the law … the righteousness of God through faith in Jesus Christ for all who believe” (3:21–22). We “are justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus, whom God put forward as a propitiation by his blood, to be received by faith” (3:24–25). A propitiation is a sacrifice that turns away God’s just anger. God can therefore be both “just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus” (3:26). The sin is really paid for at the cross, and so the acquittal is not a fiction. Paul then draws the conclusion the whole Reformation would rally to: “we hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law” (3:28).

Romans 4: Abraham, and the God who justifies the ungodly. How can this be? Paul reaches back to Abraham: “Abraham believed God, and it was counted to him as righteousness” (Romans 4:3, quoting Genesis 15:6). The word “counted” (Greek logizomai, “to reckon, to credit”) is an accounting word, for righteousness credited to the account. Paul says that God “justifies the ungodly” (4:5). What a thing to say about God! He counts righteousness “apart from works” (4:6). He adds David’s blessing on “the man against whom the Lord will not count his sin” (4:8). There are two entries in the one ledger: sin not counted and righteousness counted. Abraham was reckoned righteous before he was circumcised and centuries before the law, so his righteousness could not have been the reward of religious performance. It was received by faith. Paul closes the chapter by tying the whole reckoning to Easter. Jesus our Lord “was delivered up for our trespasses and raised for our justification” (4:25).

Romans 5: and therefore, peace. Then Paul writes the sentence Romans 3 and 4 have been building toward: “Therefore, since we have been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ” (Romans 5:1). Paul is speaking of a conscience at peace. Because the verdict is already rendered, and rendered on the ground of Christ’s finished work, the believer is not waiting anxiously to find out how the story ends.

Paul says the same thing elsewhere in other words. We “know that a person is not justified by works of the law but through faith in Jesus Christ” (Galatians 2:16). Paul’s hope is to be found in Christ, “not having a righteousness of my own that comes from the law, but that which comes through faith in Christ, the righteousness from God that depends on faith” (Philippians 3:9), which is a righteousness from outside, God’s own, given to me. Ephesians puts it most simply: “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast” (Ephesians 2:8–9). Every one of these texts pushes in the same direction, away from what we do and toward what God gives.

Sidebar—Three key words. Justification talk gets technical fast, so here are the significant words, once. What does it mean to justify? The Greek word is dikaioō, and in this context it is a courtroom word. It is defined as “to declare, pronounce, one to be just, righteous, or such as he ought to be” (Thayer’s Greek Lexicon). It means to declare righteous, to acquit, as a judge pronounces a verdict, and not to make inwardly good (Romans 4:5 says that God “justifies the ungodly,” and Romans 8:33, “It is God who justifies”). The Formula of Concord fixes this sense: “the word justify here means to declare righteous and free from sins” (FC SD III.17). The Apology sometimes uses “regeneration” for the same gift, and the Formula explains that in such places the word is used “so as to mean only the remission of sins, and that we are adopted as sons of God,” and that the renewal which follows must “not be confounded” with it (FC SD III.18–19). To impute or reckon (logizomai) is to credit to an account (Romans 4). The righteousness that justifies is an alien righteousness (Luther’s phrase, iustitia aliena): Christ’s own, reckoned to us, “outside” us, and not a quality we generate within. This is the central difference. Is justification God’s verdict (declared), or God’s inward renewal (made)? The Lutheran Confessions say the first, and the Reformed agree; the ancient and Roman West, hearing the Latin iustificare as “to make righteous,” leaned toward the second; the Christian East asks a different question altogether (deification).

What about James? A careful reader stops here, because James seems to say the opposite: “a person is justified by works and not by faith alone” (James 2:24). Does Scripture contradict itself? It does not, because the two apostles are answering different questions with the same words. Paul asks how a guilty sinner comes to be accepted by God, and answers: by faith, apart from works of the law. James attacks a dead faith, a mere agreement that God exists, the kind of believing of which he says, “Even the demons believe—and shudder!” (James 2:19). He insists that living faith shows itself in works. He is not describing how a sinner is accepted by God but, as the Apology puts it, “of what nature the just are, after they have been already justified and regenerated” (Ap IV.251). In other words, James is not telling you how to become right with God. He is describing what people who are already right with God look like. Paul speaks of the root; James speaks of the fruit. They even share an example. Abraham, reckoned righteous by faith in Genesis 15 (Paul’s point), showed that faith to be real when he offered Isaac years later (James’s point). The Formula of Concord, quoting Luther, says the same thing: “it is faith alone, without works, which lays hold of the blessing; and yet it is never and at no time alone” (FC SD III.41).

Luther’s sharp remark about James, the “epistle of straw,” and the Confessions’ own reading of James (Ap IV.244–253) are taken up with Article VI (chapter 6). The Lutheran church receives James as Holy Scripture.

Underneath the question “do my works matter or not?” is the question of where your standing rests. Your works matter, as the fruit and evidence of living faith and as love your neighbor needs. However, they are not the ground you stand on before God. That ground is Christ’s righteousness, received by faith.


3. Historical Context

To understand why this article mattered so much in 1530, we need to understand the burden it lifted.

The world Luther inherited. Late-medieval piety framed salvation as a lifelong cooperation with grace. Grace is given (especially through the sacraments), the believer cooperates and grows in righteousness, sins after baptism are dealt with through penance, and merit accumulates toward final acceptance. A maxim widely taught by the late-medieval theologians who trained Luther (the nominalists), though resisted by others, summed up the pastoral approach: facienti quod in se est Deus non denegat gratiam (“to the one who does what is in him, God will not deny grace”). Do your best, and God will supply the rest. The Apology attacks this very teaching (Ap IV.9–11). It sounds reasonable but to anyone who takes it seriously it is a torment, because the question is never settled: Have I done my best? How could I ever know?

Luther’s discovery. Luther, an Augustinian friar and Bible professor, was undone by the phrase “the righteousness of God” in Romans 1:17. He had understood it as the righteousness by which God judges and punishes sinners, and he confessed that he hated it and hated the God who seemed to demand what no one could give. Then, poring over the text, he saw that “the righteousness of God” here is not the standard God wields against us but the righteousness God gives, a gift received by faith. He later wrote that when he saw it he felt “altogether born again,” as though he had “entered paradise itself through open gates” (Preface to the Latin Writings, 1545, WA 54:186, translated here). Whatever the exact year of the breakthrough (scholars debate the dating), its content is the recovery of the Gospel as gift.

Augsburg, and Rome’s reply. At the imperial assembly (the Diet) of Augsburg in 1530, the Lutherans confessed this as the faith of the whole Church. Their summary, they said, contained “nothing that varies from the Scriptures, or from the Church Catholic” (AC, Conclusion of Part I). Rome’s official response, the Confutation, accepted the Article’s rejection of Pelagian merit (the old error, named for the monk Pelagius, that we can earn salvation by our natural powers) but rejected its exclusion of the merit of grace-assisted works. Melanchthon answered in the Apology, whose defense of justification (Ap IV) is the longest and richest treatment in all the Confessions, returning again and again to the terrified conscience and the peace that only a received righteousness can give.

Trent’s answer, and the chronology. The Roman Catholic Church gave its considered dogmatic reply at the Council of Trent, Session VI (1547). The order matters. Trent’s decree came seventeen years after Article IV. The Lutheran confession did not form in reaction to Trent; Trent formed, in part, in reaction to the Reformation.

One more Lutheran clarification. A generation later, a Lutheran named Andreas Osiander argued that justification means Christ’s divine nature dwelling in us and making us really, inwardly righteous. The Formula of Concord (FC, Article III, 1577) said no. The righteousness that justifies is not Christ’s divine nature alone (Osiander’s view), nor our own renewal, but the obedience of “the entire Christ according to both natures” (FC Ep III.3), reckoned to us and received by faith.1 The Formula gladly confesses that God dwells in believers by faith, but it would not let that indwelling become the righteousness we stand on before God, because the indwelling “follows the preceding righteousness of faith, which is nothing else than the forgiveness of sins” (FC SD III.54). To make it the ground would have shifted assurance back inside the believer, and the Lutherans would not let that happen.2

The “do your best and God will supply the rest” religion did not die in 1517. It is the natural religion of the human heart, and it is still found in every believer who measures God’s acceptance by his own performance.


4. Early Church Witness

Was justification by faith a sixteenth-century invention?

The Reformers claimed the early Church, and on the main thing they were right. The Fathers confess that salvation is grace (God’s unmerited mercy) and not the wage of human works. Clement of Rome, writing around the end of the first century, says that we are “not justified through ourselves … but through faith,” not by our own works or piety (1 Clement 32), an early echo of Paul. John Chrysostom, the great fourth-century preacher on Paul, proclaims grace and faith with force. Augustine, the doctor of grace, spent his life insisting against Pelagius that salvation is God’s gift from first to last, faith itself included.

However, the precise distinctions the Reformation drew are not yet formulated in the Fathers: justification as a forensic verdict, righteousness imputed as a legal reckoning, and justification carefully distinguished from the renewal that follows. Augustine himself, reading the Latin iustificare as “to make righteous,” tends to run justification and sanctification together. The claim to make, then, is not “the Fathers taught imputation.” It is “the Fathers held the Gospel of grace, and the Reformation recovered and sharpened it from Paul’s own words.”

Your assurance does not hang on winning a historical argument and you do not need to claim more than the evidence shows in order to be comforted. The Gospel of grace is ancient and the Reformation stated it again with new clarity.


5. Lutheran Confessional Theology

Here the Confession speaks with its clearest voice and it speaks with gladness. For Lutherans this is not one doctrine among many. The Formula of Concord calls it “the chief article in the entire Christian doctrine, without which no poor conscience can have any firm consolation” (FC SD III.6). It is the article by which the Church lives and the Confessions rejoice in it.

Justification is a verdict, not a process. God declares the sinner righteous for Christ’s sake. He does not first make us inwardly good and then accept us for the goodness He finds. The righteousness that justifies is Christ’s own, reckoned to faith: an alien righteousness, from outside, “for you.” This is why the doctrine is called forensic (from the law court). In other words, the verdict falls like a judge’s gavel. God does not take our temperature and pronounce us well enough. He pronounces the verdict “righteous” on the ground of Christ, and the verdict is true because Christ’s righteousness is really credited to us. Paul puts both sides of the exchange in a single verse: “For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God” (2 Corinthians 5:21). Our sin was counted to Him, and His righteousness is counted to us.

Faith is the empty hand. The Apology puts it this way: “faith justifies and saves, not on the ground that it is a work in itself worthy, but only because it receives the promised mercy” (Ap IV.56). It is trust (fiducia), the open, empty hand that receives the promise of mercy for Christ’s sake. A beggar’s outstretched hand adds nothing to the gift it takes, and that is exactly why faith can be the means of a free gift. If faith were a work, justification would not be free, and the terrified conscience would be thrown back on itself.

Where the promise is given. Even the hand is God’s gift. The very next article of the Confession says where faith comes from: “That we may obtain this faith, the Ministry of Teaching the Gospel and administering the Sacraments was instituted. For through the Word and Sacraments, as through instruments, the Holy Ghost is given, who works faith” (AC V.1–2). Paul says the same: “So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ” (Romans 10:17). God does not leave the promise floating in the air for us to reach up and find. He speaks it to us in the preached Gospel and the absolution, He joins it to water in Baptism, and He gives it into our mouths in the Lord’s Supper. That is why the conscience is sent outward to the Word and the Sacraments, where the promise is spoken to it “for you,” and not inward to its own believing. A weak faith holds the same Christ as a strong one. The father in the Gospel cried out, “I believe; help my unbelief!” (Mark 9:24), and Jesus did not send him away. Article V (chapter 5) and the sacramental articles take this up in full.

Justification and renewal: distinguished, never divorced. The Formula of Concord draws a careful line. God’s declaring us righteous (justification) and God’s making us holy (sanctification, renewal) are both real and both His work. However, they are not the same thing, and the second is never the ground of the first. The Formula says that renewal and good works are not to be “set up as a part or cause of our righteousness” (FC SD III.39). Renewal follows justification as the fruit follows the root; it is never mixed into the verdict. Still, the two are never apart. When the person is justified, the Formula says, “he is also renewed and sanctified by the Holy Ghost” (FC SD III.41). Article VI (chapter 6) takes up the new life that follows. Why fight so hard to keep them distinct? The moment renewal becomes part of the ground of acceptance, assurance dies, for now I must ask whether I have been renewed enough, and I am back to earning God’s favor.

This is the place to introduce a distinction the book will develop later: Law and Gospel. The Law commands and accuses and drives us to Christ; the Gospel promises and gives Christ freely. Justification cannot be understood without this distinction, for it is the Law that says “you cannot,” and the Gospel that says “but Christ has.” Its fuller treatment belongs to Article XX (chapter 20).

The Lutherans could therefore say, with Luther, that the believer is at once righteous and a sinner (simul iustus et peccator). He is wholly righteous in God’s verdict because of Christ, while still a sinner in himself who daily returns, in repentance, to that same verdict and hears it again. The Formula says why he can never stand on his own renewal. It “is incomplete and impure in this life because of the flesh,” so that he “cannot stand with and by it … before God’s tribunal” (FC SD III.32). This is not a contradiction but an accurate description of the Christian life, and it frees us. My standing with God does not wait on my improvement.

All of this gives you a place to stand that your own heart cannot undermine. The verdict is in. It rests on Christ, and you receive it by faith. Your worst days do not cancel it, and on those days above all the promise is spoken to you again in the Word and the Sacraments.


6. Comparative Theology

This is the article where the Reformation and Rome divided, and where much of Protestantism still differs within itself. Each tradition is described first from its own sources, before the Lutheran confession speaks.

Roman Catholic. Begin with what Rome actually teaches, from Rome. The Council of Trent (Session VI) confesses that justification is by grace, that it begins with prevenient grace (grace that comes first, before we can do anything), which no one merits, and that no one is justified by his own unaided works. Trent says that “none of those things which precede justification—whether faith or works—merit the grace itself of justification” (Session VI, ch. 8). Rome is not Pelagian and does not teach “salvation by works,” and it is unjust to say so.

Where, then, is the divide? Trent teaches that justification is not only the forgiveness of sins but also an inward renewal by grace infused (poured into) the soul, that the justified truly cooperate with that grace, and that their grace-enabled good works merit an increase of grace and eternal life. The Catechism of the Catholic Church puts the first point in Rome’s own words: “Justification is conferred in Baptism, the sacrament of faith. It conforms us to the righteousness of God, who makes us inwardly just by the power of his mercy” (CCC 1992). Trent is careful to say that these merits are God’s own gifts: God “will have the things which are His own gifts be their merits” (ch. 16). Trent’s canons (the short, numbered condemnations attached to its decree) nevertheless condemn the teaching that a sinner is justified “by faith alone,” understood as meaning that nothing else is required to cooperate (canon 9), and justification “by the sole imputation” of Christ’s righteousness to the exclusion of the grace and love poured into the heart by the Holy Spirit (canon 11). The differences are specific: infused righteousness versus imputed; justification as including an inward renewal, “not remission of sins merely, but also the sanctification and renewal of the inward man” (ch. 7), in which the will cooperates, versus a verdict received by faith alone; the merit of works after justification; and assurance, which matters most for pastoral care.

On assurance, Trent teaches that no pious person should doubt God’s mercy, Christ’s merit, or the power of the sacraments, but that no one can know “with a certainty of faith, which cannot be subject to error,” that he himself has obtained God’s grace (ch. 9). The Lutheran confession answers that the Gospel is preached so that “the pious may receive the sure hope of salvation.” It goes on to say that “the adversaries give men bad advice … when they bid them doubt whether they obtain remission of sins,” and it asks how such persons will “sustain themselves in death” (Ap IV.119). I want to be careful with those words. They are the Confession’s judgment on what was being taught to consciences in the sixteenth century, and not a verdict on the Roman Catholics you know. Paul gives the reason: the promise “depends on faith, in order that the promise may rest on grace and be guaranteed to all his offspring” (Romans 4:16). Rome asks you to trust God’s mercy but holds that you cannot know, with the certainty of faith, that you yourself are in His grace. The Lutheran confession says you can, because God has said it to you.

In 1999 the Lutheran World Federation (a worldwide fellowship of Lutheran church bodies) and the Roman Catholic Church signed the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. Together they confess that “by grace alone, in faith in Christ’s saving work and not because of any merit on our part, we are accepted by God and receive the Holy Spirit, who renews our hearts while equipping and calling us to good works” (§15). The Declaration also judges that the teaching of each church, as the Declaration presents it, does not fall under the other’s sixteenth-century condemnations (§41). It is a real achievement, though the common ground is thinner than it looks. Later the Methodists (2006) and the Reformed (2017) formally associated themselves with it, and the Anglican Consultative Council welcomed and affirmed its substance (2016).

It should be understood for what it is. Commentators call it a “differentiated consensus”: the two sides agree on the basic truths (the Declaration’s own phrase is “a consensus in basic truths,” §40), while differences of language and emphasis remain. Imputation and infusion were not merged. On merit, on assurance, and on the simul, the Declaration and the Annex added to it set the two accounts side by side and judge them compatible, and the Declaration insists that “nothing is thereby taken away from the seriousness of the condemnations” (§42). Trent’s canons still formally stand.

Two cautions are in order. First, the Declaration does not claim the differences vanished. It judges that each church’s teaching, as presented there, no longer falls under the other’s condemnations, a claim many welcome and some contest. Second, the Lutheran World Federation is not all of Lutheranism. Significant confessional bodies, including the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, did not receive the Declaration, judging that it left the forensic, by-faith-alone core insufficiently secured.3 The Declaration neither ended the Reformation nor left everything where it was.

Eastern Orthodox. The Christian East asks a different question. Its leading images are less the courtroom than the hospital and the family. Salvation is theosis, or deification: real, transforming union with God, becoming “partakers of the divine nature” (2 Peter 1:4) by grace, through a synergy in which God’s grace and the healed human will cooperate. There is deep common ground (grace is primary, Christ is the Savior, salvation is God’s gift), but the forensic and imputational categories are not the organizing ones. The East is frankly synergistic (grace and the will work together), where the Lutheran confession is monergistic in conversion (God alone does the work). However, the Orthodox insist with equal force that grace always comes first and that no one is saved by unaided nature. When the West put the question directly, the East answered it. In the 1570s Lutheran theologians at Tübingen sent the Augsburg Confession to Constantinople, and Patriarch Jeremias II answered it article by article, with respect and with clear disagreement. A century later, answering a Calvinist confession circulated under the name of Patriarch Cyril Lucaris, the Synod of Jerusalem (1672) taught that a person is not simply justified by faith alone but by faith working through love. Its Confession of Dositheus rejected outright the picture of faith as a hand that lays hold of Christ’s righteousness and applies it to us (Decree 13).

Reformed and Presbyterian. Here the Lutheran finds his closest kin. The Reformed confess justification as forensic, by faith alone, on the ground of Christ’s imputed righteousness, which is the same confession of justification. The differences lie less in the article itself than around it. The Reformed often set justification within the larger theme of union with Christ, in which justification and sanctification are distinct gifts of the one union. Classic Reformed confessions also distinguish full assurance from faith itself (Westminster 18.3) and give a larger place to the marks of grace in the believer. The Reformed, too, send the conscience to the preached Gospel and the sacraments (Heidelberg Q65). The Lutheran sends it there almost wholly, and to sacraments in which God gives what He promises to every one who receives them, here and now (see chapters 5 and 9).

Anglican. The Thirty-Nine Articles of the Church of England stand very close to Article IV. Article XI reads: “We are accounted righteous before God, only for the merit of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ by Faith, and not for our own works or deservings: Wherefore, that we are justified by Faith only is a most wholesome Doctrine, and very full of comfort, as more largely is expressed in the Homily of Justification.” Article XII adds that good works “are the fruits of Faith, and follow after Justification” and “cannot put away our sins.” Anglicans today hold a wide range of opinion (Anglo-Catholic, broad, and evangelical) on how firmly the Articles bind.

Methodist and Wesleyan. Wesley affirmed justification by faith in the Reformation sense. He defined it as pardon, the forgiveness of sins, received by faith and not earned, and he distinguished it from sanctification. The Methodist Articles of Religion are Wesley’s abridgment of the Thirty-Nine Articles, and their Article IX keeps Anglican Article XI almost word for word, confessing “that we are justified by faith, only.” The Wesleyan accents lie downstream: a strong doctrine of prevenient grace, which restores to every person the freedom to respond; a tight link between justification and the pursuit of holiness (what Wesley called “Christian perfection,” by which he meant perfect love rather than sinlessness); and an evangelical Arminian account of the will, in which grace frees each person to accept or refuse God’s offer.

Baptist and evangelical. Most Baptists affirm justification by grace through faith on the ground of Christ’s righteousness, and the Calvinist, or Particular, Baptist confessions, such as the Second London Confession, stand very close to Westminster. There is wide internal diversity (Calvinist and Arminian streams; debates over the place of repentance and obedience) and one structural difference from the Augsburg tradition. Baptists hold baptism and the Lord’s Supper as ordinances of obedience and witness, not as means through which God gives forgiveness, so justification is not tied to them. The Baptist Faith and Message (2000) speaks of justification as God’s full acquittal and of repentance and faith as experiences of grace. The language of “deciding for Christ” belongs to popular evangelical preaching more than to the confessions. There is no single “Baptist position,” so it is best to name the confession being described.

Sidebar—The New Perspective on Paul. Some readers will have met a scholarly debate about Paul. Since the late twentieth century, several New Testament scholars (E. P. Sanders, James Dunn, N. T. Wright) have argued that Second Temple Judaism was not a religion of earning salvation by works. On their reading, when Paul opposes “works of the law,” he targets the boundary markers (circumcision, food laws, Sabbath) that fenced Jewish identity, so that “justification” is as much about who belongs to God’s covenant people as about how an individual is acquitted. This is a debate among biblical scholars about Paul’s meaning, not a denomination, and its proponents span the churches. It has drawn substantial response (from D. A. Carson, John Piper, Stephen Westerholm, and others) arguing that it under-reads Paul’s concern with human works-righteousness and the plight of the guilty conscience. The confession followed in this chapter is the traditional reading; the debate is noted so that a reader who encounters it knows the ground.

You will meet these traditions in your family, your town, and your reading, and charity requires knowing what they actually teach. However, charity is not the same as indifference. Once each has been heard, the Lutheran confession still says something specific and precious: your acceptance with God is a finished gift, credited to you and received by faith, and therefore something you can be sure of. With Rome and the East the difference turns on whether that certainty may be had at all; with the other churches of the Reformation it turns on where the conscience is sent to find it.


7. Pastoral and Practical Significance

If justification were even partly grounded in your transformation, your cooperation, or your record, then the honest answer to the conscience’s question would be: you can’t know, not yet, and maybe not ever. You would always be waiting to see whether the process finished well. That is precisely the anxiety the medieval conscience knew, and that many sincere believers still carry: a low, chronic uncertainty about whether they have done enough.

The Gospel of justification cuts the anxiety at its root by moving the ground of acceptance entirely outside you. The verdict is already rendered. It rests on Christ’s finished work, not your unfinished progress. It is a gift, held out in a promise, and received by the empty hand of faith. A gift God has promised you and given you in His Word and Sacraments is something you can be sure of, because the Giver is faithful.

This is why the doctrine is, finally, the comfort of the terrified conscience. When the Law accuses you and death draws near and your whole life’s record looks like far too little (and it will), the answer is not to search yourself for enough evidence of change. The answer is to look away from yourself to Christ and to go where He is given for you, to the preached Word, the absolution, your Baptism, and the Lord’s Table. There you hear again the promise that His righteousness, not yours, is what God counts. You are simul iustus et peccator, still a sinner and wholly righteous in Christ, and so you may have peace.

I would be leaving something out if I spoke only to the troubled. If you are not troubled at all, and you have quietly decided that because God justifies the ungodly it does not much matter how you live, Paul has a word for you first: “Are we to continue in sin that grace may abound? By no means!” (Romans 6:1–2). Then he tells you why, and it is the Gospel again: “all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death,” so that “we too might walk in newness of life” (Romans 6:3–4).

It is no accident that the Reformers, having recovered this, could not stop giving thanks. To know that God justifies the ungodly, and that the whole weight of your standing rests on Christ received by faith, is to be handed back a conscience at peace. The first response to justification is praise, and good works follow freely from a heart that no longer has to earn God’s love. We come back, then, to the question we started with (How can I know that I am right with God?), and this is the answer: by Christ’s righteousness, given in His promise and received by faith, and not by your record.


8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading

8.1 Summary

Article IV confesses that we cannot be justified before God by our own strength, merits, or works, but are justified freely, for Christ’s sake, through faith, and that God imputes this faith to us for righteousness. Justification is God’s verdict, not God’s process: the righteousness that saves is Christ’s own, reckoned to the believer and received, not achieved. Faith is the empty hand that takes the gift God holds out in His promise, and God gives that faith through the Word and the Sacraments. Luther called this “the first and chief article.” To the terrified conscience it answers that we stand before God on nothing in ourselves but on Christ, for us.

Rome (at Trent) confesses that justification is unmerited and begins in prevenient grace. It teaches that justification includes an inward renewal by infused grace, that the justified cooperate with that grace, and that their good works, which are themselves God’s gifts, truly merit an increase of grace and eternal life; its canons condemn justification by faith alone as Trent understood that phrase, that is, a faith with which nothing else cooperates. The 1999 Joint Declaration brought Rome and the Lutheran World Federation to agreement on the basic truths while naming the differences that remain (what commentators call a “differentiated consensus”), and not all Lutherans endorsed it. The East speaks of salvation as being drawn into God’s own life (theosis) rather than as a courtroom verdict. The Reformed and much of evangelicalism share the forensic Gospel with their own accents. Through all of it the Lutheran confession says one thing with joy: justification is a gift, received by faith, and therefore sure.

8.2 Tables

Table 4.1—Justification: Declared, Infused, or Deified

Tradition What justification/salvation is Righteousness is… The human role
Lutheran God’s verdict (forensic): sins forgiven, righteousness reckoned, for Christ’s sake Imputed: Christ’s whole obedience, doing and suffering (FC SD III.15); alien, received Faith, God’s gift through Word and Sacrament (AC V), receives; works are the fruit, never the ground
Reformed / Presbyterian Forensic verdict within union with Christ Imputed (Christ’s obedience, within a covenant framework) Faith receives; full assurance may follow faith (Westminster 18.3)
Methodist / Wesleyan Pardon received by faith; distinct from the new birth Pardon / imputation (imputation affirmed with caution), with strong emphasis on following holiness Faith enabled by prevenient grace; cooperation in sanctification
Roman Catholic (Trent) Forgiveness and inward renewal by infused grace Infused (inherent), cooperated with Grace-enabled cooperation; the works of the justified, as God’s gifts, merit increase of grace and life
Eastern Orthodox Theosis: transforming union with God (Not a forensic category)—participation in God’s life by grace Synergy: grace and the healed will cooperate; grace always first

Confidence: high on the Lutheran, Reformed, and Roman (Trent) rows; moderate on the Eastern Orthodox row.

Table 4.2—The Joint Declaration (1999): Convergence and Remaining Differences

Confessed together in the Joint Declaration Still differing, or explained differently
By grace alone, in faith, not because of merit, we are accepted by God Righteousness imputed (Lutheran) vs. infused (Roman)
The person justified is also renewed by the Spirit The merit and reward of grace-wrought good works
Each church’s teaching, as presented, is not touched by the other’s 16th-c. condemnations (§41) Assurance and the simul: addressed together (§§29–30, 34–36; Annex 2A), but explained differently
Later associated: Methodists (2006), Reformed (2017); substance affirmed by the Anglican Consultative Council (2016) Trent’s canons remain formally in force; the Lutheran World Federation does not speak for all Lutherans (e.g., the Missouri Synod did not receive it)

Confidence: high on the text of the Joint Declaration; moderate on its interpretation and reception.

8.3 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)

  • Justification: God’s verdict declaring the sinner righteous for Christ’s sake.
  • Imputation: the crediting of Christ’s righteousness to the believer’s account.
  • Grace: God’s undeserved favor in Christ.
  • Sola fide: “by faith alone.”
  • Theosis: the Eastern Orthodox account of salvation as transforming union with God.
  • Sanctification: the Spirit’s renewal of the justified, distinguished from justification and never divorced from it.
  • Related: monergism and synergism (God alone works conversion, or God and the human will cooperate); prevenient grace (in Wesleyan teaching, grace given to all that enables the will to respond).

8.4 Further reading

  • The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC IV; Apology IV (the fullest treatment); Smalcald Articles II.i; Formula of Concord III.
  • Alister E. McGrath, Iustitia Dei: A History of the Christian Doctrine of Justification (the standard history).
  • Robert Kolb & Charles Arand, The Genius of Luther’s Theology; Oswald Bayer, Martin Luther’s Theology.
  • Council of Trent, Session VI (in Denzinger or Tanner, Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils); Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1987–2029.
  • The Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (1999), with the Official Common Statement and Annex (official texts, vatican.va / lutheranworld.org).
  • On the Reformed view: John Calvin, Institutes III.11–18; Westminster Confession ch. 11. On the New Perspective (both sides): N. T. Wright, Justification; and Stephen Westerholm, Perspectives Old and New on Paul.
  • On the Orthodox response to the Augsburg Confession: George Mastrantonis, Augsburg and Constantinople (1982).

Footnotes

  1. The Formula rejects the opposite error as well, Francesco Stancaro’s teaching that Christ is our righteousness according to His human nature alone. ↩

  2. A contested strand of twentieth-century scholarship (associated with the Finnish theologian Tuomo Mannermaa) argues that Luther held a more participatory view of justification (Christ really present in faith), closer to the Eastern idea of deification and relevant to Lutheran–Orthodox dialogue. Many confessional Lutherans judge it to underplay the forensic, imputational core that the Formula of Concord (Article III) locks in. It is noted here for completeness; the confessional position followed in this chapter is the forensic one. ↩

  3. Rome, too, had raised questions in its 1998 Response, which the Official Common Statement and Annex of 1999 were written to answer. ↩

Topics
Justification and GraceOther Churches and Traditions
Scripture
Romans 3:10Romans 4:3Genesis 15:6Romans 5:1Galatians 2:16Philippians 3:9Ephesians 2:8–9Romans 4:5Romans 8:33James 2:24James 2:19Romans 1:172 Corinthians 5:21Romans 10:17Mark 9:24Romans 4:162 Peter 1:4Romans 6:1–2Romans 6:3–4
Confessions
Ap IVAC IVSD IIISA IIEp IIIAC V

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.