Books · The Augsburg Compass

Chapter 6—Article VI: The New Obedience

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

A child does not wash the dishes in order to become part of the family. He washes them because he already belongs.

Picture two people at the same sink. One is a hired servant who is not sure of his place: he works hard, watches the door, and knows that if the work stops, so might his welcome. The other is a child who could not be more a child than he already is. He works too (sometimes clumsily, often gladly), yet he does not wash one plate to purchase what he already has for free. From across the room the two look identical. Everything is different at the sink.

The Christian life is the second kind and Article VI is where the Confession says so. Article IV has just told us that we are justified (declared right with God) by grace, for Christ’s sake, through faith alone, entirely apart from our works. However, Paul, who fought harder than anyone to keep that door open, is also the one who cannot stop talking about the life that comes pouring through it: “For freedom Christ has set us free” (Galatians 5:1, ESV); “through love serve one another” (Galatians 5:13); walk by the Spirit and you will bear His fruit (Galatians 5:16, 22–23). The Christian no longer works to be loved by God, but because he is already loved by God in Christ. The movement is from a servant’s fear to a child’s freedom, and that freedom bears much fruit.


1. What the Article Says

Article VI is one of the shortest paragraphs in the whole Confession, and it is placed with care. Article IV said how a sinner is justified: by faith, not works. Article V said how that faith is born: through the Gospel and the Sacraments. Article VI now heads off the objection that has trailed the doctrine of grace from the first day (if works don’t save, then works don’t matter) before it can take root:

Also they teach that this faith is bound to bring forth good fruits, and that it is necessary to do good works commanded by God, because of God’s will, but that we should not rely on those works to merit justification before God. For remission of sins and justification is apprehended by faith, as also the voice of Christ attests: “When ye shall have done all these things, say: We are unprofitable servants.” (Luke 17:10) The same is also taught by the Fathers. For Ambrose says: “It is ordained of God that he who believes in Christ is saved, freely receiving remission of sins, without works, by faith alone.” (AC VI)

The article holds two truths in one hand and will not drop either. First, this faith “is bound to bring forth good fruits.” Notice the word bound. It is a word of obligation, because faith ought to bring forth good fruit and God wills and commands the works. It is also a description, because living faith cannot help doing good. Luther said that works can no more be separated from faith than heat and light can be separated from fire, and the Formula of Concord (1577, the later Lutheran confession written to settle the quarrels that followed his death) adopted his words (FC SD IV.10–12). Good works are not spiritual extra credit for the unusually devout, and a “faith” that produces nothing is not the faith that lays hold of Christ. Therefore the article says that good works are necessary. Then, in the same breath, it shuts a door: “we should not rely on those works to merit justification before God.” The works are necessary as fruit, never as the payment that buys our standing, because that standing was already given freely, “without works, by faith alone.”

Hold those two clauses together and you have the phrase this book will return to again and again: faith alone that is never alone. Faith alone justifies, and nothing we do adds to what Christ has done. However, the faith that justifies never stays alone; it always arrives with a whole family of good works in tow. Drop the first clause and you are back to earning your salvation. Drop the second and you have imagined that grace leaves a person unchanged.

The question an ordinary Christian carries is simply this: Why does the Christian do good works? The article has already answered. He never does them to earn God’s favor, because Christ won that favor for him at the cross. He always does them because that favor is already given, and a loved child is free at last to live like one.


2. Biblical Theology

Article VI teaches what the New Testament teaches everywhere: grace comes first and works second, and the order is never reversed.

We are saved for good works, not by them. The clearest single text settles the sequence for good: “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast.” Then, without a pause, Paul goes on: “For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them” (Ephesians 2:8–10). I want you to see that in two verses both errors are refuted at once. Verse 9 shuts out works-righteousness, because salvation is a gift and not a wage, so boasting is impossible. Verse 10 shuts out the opposite error, for we are “created … for good works.” The works are the road we walk on once we are saved, and even that road God “prepared beforehand.”

Faith is the kind of thing that works. Paul can gather the whole of it into a phrase: what counts is “faith working through love” (pistis di’ agapēs energoumenē, Galatians 5:6). The verb is energeō (“to be operative, be at work, put forth power”), and Thayer’s lexicon files this verse under its middle form, “to display one’s activity, show oneself operative” (Thayer’s, energeō). Much turns on that phrase. Paul is not saying that love is the ingredient that finally makes faith good enough to justify. He is describing what justifying faith does. It goes to work and the work it does is love. Faith receives Christ and a faith that has received Christ cannot sit still.

Fruit grows; it is not manufactured. On the last night before His death, Jesus said, “I am the vine; you are the branches. Whoever abides in me and I in him, he it is that bears much fruit, for apart from me you can do nothing” (John 15:5). Notice what a branch does not do. It does not strain to produce grapes in order to earn its place on the vine. It bears fruit because it is joined to the vine and the vine’s own life flows through it. Cut it off, and it does not merely do less; it can do “nothing.” Good works are the overflow of a life joined to Christ, not a crop we grow by willpower to trade for His approval. The Sermon on the Mount says it from the other direction, “every healthy tree bears good fruit” (Matthew 7:17). The tree is made good first and the fruit simply shows what it already is.

Even our fullest obedience buys nothing, and that is the relief. When His disciples have done everything commanded, Jesus tells them to say, “We are unworthy servants; we have only done what was our duty” (Luke 17:10). Article VI quotes this on purpose (its older translation reads “unprofitable servants”). Now, a word is needed here, because “servant” can mislead. The servant Jesus describes in Luke 17 is not the anxious hireling trying to earn a place in the household. He is already the master’s servant, and his confession of being “unworthy” is one of humility, not fear. The Christian serves not to become part of God’s family, but because he already belongs to it. What good news that is! If your best works never earned your standing before God, then your failures do not undo it. Christ forgives them, even the ones you cannot see (Psalm 19:12). Christ’s favor never rested on your performance. You are free to serve without keeping score.

Even the working is God’s gift. Paul says in one breath, “work out your own salvation with fear and trembling,” and in the next, “for it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure” (Philippians 2:12–13). The believer genuinely works and God is at work in the working, down to the willing. That is why the new obedience need never harden into pride, and why grace does not leave us idle but is “training us to renounce ungodliness … zealous for good works” (Titus 2:11–14).

Paul and James: an apparent contradiction, resolved

No treatment of faith and works can avoid the one place where the Bible looks, at first, as though it argues with itself. Paul writes that “one is justified by faith apart from works of the law” (Romans 3:28). James writes that “a person is justified by works and not by faith alone” (James 2:24). Side by side they seem to collide.

The way through it is to hear the two different questions. Paul is answering, “How is a sinner justified before God?” How does a guilty person come to be declared righteous by a holy Judge? He is justified by faith, which receives Christ, apart from anything he brings. James is answering, “What does living faith look like?” How do you tell true, saving faith from a dead counterfeit? Real faith shows itself in works. A “faith” that produces nothing is the kind James has in mind when he writes, “Even the demons believe—and shudder!” (James 2:19), and it saves no one. There is, then, no contradiction. Paul excludes works from the ground of justification; James excludes dead faith from the definition of saving faith. In other words, Paul is saying that works cannot get you into God’s favor, and James is saying that a faith which never does anything was never the real thing to begin with. When James calls a workless faith “dead” (James 2:17), he is saying exactly what Article VI says: the faith that justifies is a living faith, and living things bear fruit. The Apology of the Augsburg Confession (the Confession’s official defense) gives this same answer to James 2:24 (Ap IV.244–253).

Sidebar—Luther and the “epistle of straw.” Readers sometimes hear that Luther “rejected” the letter of James. In a 1522 preface to the New Testament, Luther called James “an epistle of straw” (ein rechte stroern Epistel; LW 35:362) compared with the books that most clearly preach Christ, and he questioned its apostolic authorship. It was Luther’s own private literary judgment, an opinion about how clearly a book proclaims the Gospel, expressed early and never made a rule of faith. It was not the confession of the Lutheran Church. The Book of Concord treats James as Holy Scripture and answers the objection from James 2:24 by saying that “the reply is easy and plain” (Ap IV.244ff). Lutheran Bibles have always included James and Luther himself preached from it and quoted it approvingly elsewhere. The fair summary is that Luther’s remark is a window into how fiercely he guarded the article of justification, while the Lutheran confession receives James as God’s Word and reads it, as above, in full harmony with Paul.


3. Historical Context

The teaching of Article VI was worked out under attack, and it helps to know what the attack was.

From the moment Luther preached justification by faith alone, the same charge came back: you have abolished good works and handed people an excuse to sin. Article VI (and, at length, Article XX) is the Reformation’s steady answer. The Gospel does not abolish good works; it establishes them, giving them their true motive, God’s will and our gratitude, and their true place, as fruit and not payment.

The sharper test, though, came from within the Lutheran movement after Luther’s death, when earnest teachers seized one clause of Article VI at the expense of the other and forced the church to say precisely what “necessary” does and does not mean (see the sidebar in section 5). The Confession’s balance was tested hard and held.

One boundary belongs here too. Article VI is a seed, not the whole tree. The full defense of faith and good works, the long reply to “Doesn’t grace make people lazy?”, is Article XX (chapter 20). The “works” Article VI has in view are the good works God commands, not the man-made religious observances Article XV will take up (chapter 15).


4. Early Church Witness

Article VI does not only assert its case. It closes by appealing to the ancient Church (“the same is also taught by the Fathers”), and the appeal is fair.

The article’s own quotation comes under the name of Ambrose, though scholars have long recognized the words as those of Ambrosiaster, the anonymous fourth-century commentator on Paul whose work circulated for centuries under Ambrose’s name: “It is ordained of God that he who believes in Christ is saved, freely receiving remission of sins, without works, by faith alone” (Ambrosiaster, on 1 Corinthians 1:4). That an ancient commentator on Paul could write “by faith alone” (the very phrase the Reformation was later accused of inventing) mattered enormously to the men who signed the Confession.

Behind that line stands the deeper witness of Augustine. Against Pelagius, who taught that human nature as God made it is able to keep God’s commands without the inward help of grace, Augustine insisted that every genuinely good work is itself the fruit of grace already given, never a payment that earns it. He pressed the whole of Article VI into a single unforgettable sentence: “when God crowns our merits, He crowns nothing other than His own gifts” (Letter 194.5.19, translated here from cum deus coronat merita nostra, nihil aliud coronet quam munera sua). If even our crowns are His gifts, boasting is impossible and gratitude is the only fitting response. A century and a half later Gregory the Great still taught that good works flow from grace at work in the believer: “heavenly pity first works something in ourselves without the help of ourselves,” and only then does our will follow (Moralia in Job 16.25.30). By his day, though, the Western church was moving toward the later medieval system in which good works and penances earned merit, so we cite Gregory for this one point only.

However, the claim must be measured. Augustine is contested ground: Rome reads him as teaching both grace and a righteousness God works within us, so that God rewards our works as merit, while Lutherans hear in him that every merit God crowns is His own gift and never the ground of our standing before Him. We need not pretend the Fathers held the finished Reformation formula word for word. Even so, the root is real and old. Grace comes first, and good works grow from it as fruit, a conviction as ancient as Augustine’s war with Pelagius and older than the name of any Reformer.


5. Lutheran Confessional Theology

What is the new obedience? It is simply the life of the forgiven, and that changes how it feels to obey.

Faith is a living, working thing. The Confessions never picture justifying faith as bare agreement in the head. Faith lays hold of Christ, and in laying hold of Christ it lays hold of life, and life moves. That life is the Holy Spirit’s own. He comes with faith, renews the heart, and bears in us what Paul calls “the fruit of the Spirit”: “love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control; against such things there is no law” (Galatians 5:22–23). The new obedience is His work in us before it is ever ours. The Apology therefore puts love and good works exactly where the New Testament puts them: after faith, as its fruit, never as the thing that makes faith count (Ap IV.125). The Lutheran hears Paul’s “faith working through love” (Galatians 5:6) as a portrait of what justifying faith does, not a condition faith must satisfy before it may justify. The Formula of Concord reads the verse the same way. Once a person has been justified, “a true living faith worketh by love,” and “it never is alone, but always has with it love and hope” (FC Ep III.11).

Where we part from Rome: faith that receives, or faith formed by love. Medieval theology had a formula for that verse: fides caritate formata, “faith formed by love.” On that account bare faith does not justify; faith becomes justifying only once it is shaped and completed by love poured into the heart. The Lutheran answer is a courteous but firm no. The Apology objects that the adversaries “do not ascribe justification to faith except on account of love” (Ap IV.109). Love is the fruit of a faith that already justifies, not the form that makes it justify. Faith justifies “not on the ground that it is a work in itself worthy, but only because it receives the promised mercy” (Ap IV.56), and not because our charity has first perfected it. That distinction between faith that receives Christ and faith made acceptable by love lies at the heart of the disagreement on this article, and it is deep enough that we never need to exaggerate it.

Good works are necessary by God’s will and as fruit, never as merit. This is the balance Article VI struck and the later Confessions defended. Living faith will bear good works and God does command them, yet they add nothing to our justification. Good works become fruit rather than payment. The tree is planted by grace and its fruit is real, but the fruit buys nothing toward our standing. The works also do not have to be flawless to be welcome. Even the best fruit of a Christian still carries the stain of the old Adam (the sinful nature that still clings to us until death), and God receives it for Christ’s sake, as Peter says when he speaks of “spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ” (1 Peter 2:5), a verse the Formula of Concord cites for this very point (FC SD VI.22). This frees the Christian to do much, gladly and without fear.

The law becomes a friend again. Freed from the law as a way of earning God’s favor, is the believer simply turned loose without direction? No. The commandments still show a forgiven child what a life of love actually looks like. So far as we are new creatures, they are a lamp to walk by: “Your word is a lamp to my feet and a light to my path” (Psalm 119:105). The old Adam in us still needs the law’s sting and still feels it (FC Ep VI.4), but the law can no longer condemn us, for in Christ we are freed “from the curse and coercion of the Law” (FC Ep VI.2). Each time it stings, the Gospel answers it and sends us back to Christ.

Sidebar—“Necessary,” but necessary how? The Third Use of the Law and two old quarrels.

Quarrel one: what does “necessary” mean? After Luther’s death, two teachers pulled Article VI’s word necessary in opposite directions. Georg Major argued that “good works are necessary for salvation.” Nikolaus von Amsdorf recoiled so hard that he claimed “good works are injurious to salvation.” Others, wanting to protect the freedom of the Christian, said good works are not necessary at all but free, since the regenerate (those born anew by the Spirit) do them willingly and not under compulsion. The Formula of Concord (Article IV, 1577) rejected all three. Good works are indeed necessary. The Formula explains the word carefully: it means the necessity of God’s ordinance, command, and will, and of our obligation as His creatures, and not the necessity of coercion (FC SD IV.14–17; FC Ep IV.8–10). God wants these works and commands them, but He does not wring them out of us by threats, because His children do them willingly. The Formula draws this chapter’s own picture, since the freed spirit, it says, “does not do this from fear of punishment, like a servant, but from love of righteousness, like children” (FC Ep IV.12; Romans 8:15). Living faith also brings them forth as surely as a good tree bears fruit (FC Ep IV.6). They are not “necessary for salvation,” which smuggles works back into the ground of our standing. As a flat statement they are not “injurious” to salvation either. Works become harmful only when someone trusts in them for his standing, and the fault then lies in the false trust and not in the works (FC SD IV.37–39).

Quarrel two: does the law still speak to Christians? Luther had already contended with Johann Agricola, who taught that repentance should be preached from the Gospel and not from the law, so that the law had no place in the church’s preaching of repentance. After Luther’s death some theologians went further and denied that the law should be urged on believers at all. Against this “antinomianism” (“against-law-ism”), the Formula of Concord (Article VI) affirmed what theologians call the third use of the law.

The three uses, briefly. Beyond restraining outward wickedness (the first, civil use) and exposing sin to drive us to Christ (the second, theological use), the law also guides believers, showing them the shape of good works (the third use). Lutherans affirm this use while adding a characteristic caution: even for the Christian the law never stops also accusing (lex semper accusat, “the law always accuses,” Ap IV.38). Of the believer’s own obedience the Apology says, “Otherwise the Law always accuses us. For who loves or fears God sufficiently?” (Ap IV.167). The Formula puts the same point its own way, since the believer keeps the law willingly “so far as he is regenerate,” while the old Adam must still be driven (FC Ep VI.3–7). The guiding use is therefore always held together with the knowledge that we never keep the law perfectly, and that knowledge keeps sending us back to grace. The Reformed tradition leans harder on this guiding use. On this point that is a difference of emphasis and not a division (see section 6).

The Christian does good works, then, because a living faith cannot help it, because God wills the good of His children and their neighbors, and because the forgiven serve from God’s favor, never for it.


6. Comparative Theology

Nearly every Christian tradition agrees that saving faith is living and that good works matter. The real questions are two: why do good works follow, and what do they accomplish? I want to take each tradition in its strongest and fairest form.

Roman Catholic: first, what Rome affirms. Rome must be stated carefully, because it is so often caricatured. The Catholic Church emphatically rejects Pelagianism, the notion that we can earn our way to God by unaided effort. Trent teaches that justification begins entirely with God’s unearned grace and that we can do nothing to merit that first grace. It even calls faith “the beginning of human salvation, the foundation, and the root of all Justification,” and says that nothing before justification, “whether faith or works,” merits it (Session VI, ch. 8). The Lutheran–Catholic difference is therefore not “grace versus works.” Both confess grace and both confess that saving faith is living and fruitful.

Roman Catholic: then, the real divergence. It lies elsewhere and it is genuine. The Council of Trent (Session VI, 1547) teaches that justification “is not remission of sins merely, but also the sanctification and renewal of the inward man” (ch. 7). God’s grace and charity are “poured forth” in the heart and “inherent” in the justified (canon 11), and faith, hope, and charity are “infused at once,” that is, poured in together (ch. 7). Faith without hope and charity “neither unites man perfectly with Christ, nor makes him a living member of His body” (ch. 7). Trent reads Paul’s “faith working through love” (Galatians 5:6) in just this way, as “faith which worketh by charity.” Trent also teaches that the good works of a person in grace truly merit an increase of grace and, finally, eternal life (Trent, Session VI, chs. 7, 16; canons 9, 11, 24, 32). Set the two accounts side by side and the contrast is clean: the Lutheran says faith receives Christ; Rome says faith formed by love justifies. For the Lutheran, works are the fruit of a righteousness credited to us. For Rome, works flow from and increase a righteousness infused in us, and they merit reward.

Rome would add at once that this merit is itself grace. Its Catechism opens its teaching on merit with a prayer from its Missal that echoes Augustine, “in crowning their merits you are crowning your own gifts,” and says that “with regard to God, there is no strict right to any merit on the part of man” (CCC 2006–2007; cf. Trent, Session VI, ch. 16). The disagreement is over whether God’s gifts in us become the ground on which eternal life is given. By the judgment of the Lutheran Confessions, the divergence, over the ground of justification and over merit, is serious enough to divide the churches. It should be drawn in measured words and never as the slander “Rome teaches works-salvation,” which Rome itself rejects.

(Readers who want the twentieth-century conversation on justification, the 1999 Joint Declaration with its real convergences and its stated limits, will find it in chapter 4, with its Table 4.2. Confessional Lutheran church bodies, among them the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, did not receive it.)

Eastern Orthodox: a different question. Orthodoxy does not frame salvation in the West’s courtroom terms. It speaks of the believer’s synergeia (“working together”) with God’s grace on the way to union with Him. When the Synod of Jerusalem answered the Reformation in the Confession of Dositheus (1672), it wrote, “We believe a man to be not simply justified through faith alone, but through faith which worketh through love, that is to say, through faith and works” (Decree 13). Orthodox theologians today weigh that confession’s authority differently.

Reformed and Presbyterian: the closest kin. The Reformed confess justification by faith alone, with good works as the necessary fruit and evidence of faith and the grateful response of the redeemed. The Heidelberg Catechism even files good works under the heading “Gratitude.” It asks, tenderly, “Since we have been delivered from our misery by grace through Christ without any merit of our own, why then should we do good works?” The answer begins where Article VI does: “Because Christ, having redeemed us by his blood, is also restoring us by his Spirit into his image.” The good works follow from that, as thankfulness, as praise to God, as assurance of faith “by its fruits,” and as a witness that wins the neighbor (Heidelberg Q86, 2011 translation). The Reformed foreground the law’s guiding third use as the rule of the Christian life, while Lutherans, affirming that same use, keep one ear always on the law’s continuing accusation and on the sharp distinction of law and gospel. Calvin even calls the guiding use “the principal use” (Institutes II.7.12). At the same time, the Heidelberg Catechism still has the law preached to Christians “so that the longer we live the more we may come to know our sinfulness and the more eagerly look to Christ for forgiveness of sins and righteousness” (Q115). It is a real difference of emphasis inside a very large agreement.

Anglican: the English echo. The Church of England’s Thirty-Nine Articles stand very near Article VI. They confess “that we are justified by Faith only” and call it “a most wholesome Doctrine, and very full of comfort” (Art. XI). Of good works they say that they “cannot put away our sins, and endure the severity of God’s Judgement; yet are they pleasing and acceptable to God in Christ, and do spring out necessarily of a true and lively Faith” (Art. XII). The same article ends on this chapter’s own picture of a living faith known by its works “as a tree discerned by the fruit.” Anglicans today give the Articles differing weight but on this point their historic confession and ours speak with nearly one voice.

Methodist and Wesleyan: holiness in a warmer key. The Methodist Articles of Religion are Wesley’s abridgment (1784) of the Thirty-Nine, and their Article X repeats Anglican Article XII almost word for word, though without “necessarily.” The Wesleyan tradition shares the Reformation’s sola fide (“we are justified by faith, only, is a most wholesome doctrine,” Methodist Art. IX) and confesses that good works “are the fruits of faith, and follow after justification” (Art. X). To this it adds a warm, serious emphasis on sanctification, the Spirit’s work growing toward what Wesley called “Christian perfection,” by which he meant not an absolute perfection free of ignorance, mistake, and infirmity but “perfect love,” a heart filled with love for God and neighbor. The Lutheran gladly affirms the hunger for holiness. The divergences belong more fully to a later chapter (free will, chapter 18): Wesley’s account of a prevenient grace (grace that goes before and enables the will to respond) and the hope of entire sanctification (the full love for God and neighbor described above) in this life.

Baptist and broader Evangelical: a debate within the family. Most Baptists and evangelicals stand squarely with the Reformation on justification by faith alone, with good works as fruit and evidence. Within evangelicalism runs the so-called “Lordship salvation” debate, and its question is simple: must genuine faith bear visible fruit? One side, associated with John MacArthur, says that saving faith always submits to Christ as Lord and always goes on to bear fruit. The other, the “Free Grace” position (associated with Zane Hodges and the Grace Evangelical Society), holds that eternal life is given to faith alone, that assurance rests on Christ’s promise rather than on our fruit, and that good works, though commanded and rewarded at Christ’s judgment seat, are not a condition of salvation. Both sides affirm justification by faith alone and deny that works merit it. Article VI speaks to both. Its “faith … bound to bring forth good fruits” resists any account that fully severs faith from its fruit, and its “not to merit justification” resists any account that makes works the ground of our standing. The Lutheran Confession rests assurance where the Free Grace side rests it, on Christ’s promise, and it holds with the Lordship side that living faith bears fruit, but it never sends the conscience to its fruit to find its certainty (see chapter 4).

“Antinomianism” names a tendency that can appear in any church, our own included: the drift toward treating grace as a reason obedience no longer matters. It would be both unjust and untrue to pin the label on any living denomination, since no serious church teaches it. It is a danger that haunts the edges of grace-preaching everywhere, and Article VI, with Formula of Concord IV and VI, is its direct answer.


7. Pastoral and Practical Significance

Most of the readers this book will reach are not looking for permission to do less. They are tired. Perhaps you are one of them, a lifelong churchgoer, a serious Christian, even a pastor, who has spent years quietly trying to prove to God, to others, and to yourself that you are worth loving. You pray a little harder when God feels far away, and you measure your standing with God by how well you obeyed this week. You have turned the Christian life into a performance review that never closes, and you are exhausted, because the verdict never feels secure and the bar keeps moving. To you Article VI is not a scolding. It is the review being cancelled. That word is not only printed in a book. Christ speaks it to you in His Word, gave it to you in your Baptism, declares it in the absolution, and gives Himself to you in His Supper, and that is where I would send you when the old fear comes back.

The Christian’s good works no longer ask, “Will God love me if I do this?” They ask, “Since God already loves me in Christ, how may I love my neighbor today?” That is the difference between working for God’s favor and working from it. Nothing changes in the list of things a Christian does (the same prayers, the same kindness, the same faithfulness at home and at work), but the reason for doing them is entirely different. Duty done to secure love is heavy, while the same duty done out of love already secured is light. It is the freedom Paul keeps shouting about, faith working through love (Galatians 5:6, 13). This is why obedience, rightly understood, is not grim. Many Christians have never been told that obedience freed from fear becomes a joy.

Perhaps you are the other reader this book will reach. You have heard “grace” so often that you have quietly concluded it asks nothing of how you live. Since works don’t save, you reason, they don’t much matter, and faith gets along fine with no fruit at all. To you the article says just as clearly that the faith that saves is alive, and living things grow. A “faith” that produces nothing across a lifetime is not the humble, fruit-bearing faith of Article VI. It is the dead faith James describes: “For as the body apart from the spirit is dead, so also faith apart from works is dead” (James 2:26). Paul asks your question for you and answers it: “Are we to continue in sin that grace may abound? By no means! How can we who died to sin still live in it?” (Romans 6:1–2). Four centuries after Augsburg a Lutheran pastor, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, gave this abuse of grace its lasting name, “cheap grace,” grace pocketed as a permission slip rather than received as a gift. However, the cure is never a march back to the servant’s fear. It is to point again to the vine. Real union with Christ bears fruit, and if there is no fruit at all, the question is whether you are joined to the vine. The answer is found outside you, in the Word that promises Christ to you and the Baptism that joined you to Him. A Christian goes back to that Baptism every day in repentance, drowning the old Adam and rising to “walk in newness of life” (Romans 6:4). To the one who comes back, the promise stands: “Already you are clean because of the word that I have spoken to you” (John 15:3).

Both dangers have the same cure. To the one crushed by earning, Article VI says: you may stop earning, for the favor is given; now bear fruit in freedom. To the one coasting on grace, it says: come back to the vine, because a branch truly joined to Christ bears fruit. Both are sent to Christ. For both, the answer is to abide in Him, where He gives Himself in His Word and Sacraments, and let the fruit come, for “he who began a good work in you will bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ” (Philippians 1:6). If you fear that your faith is too weak to lay hold of Christ, remember that of Christ the prophet wrote, “a bruised reed he will not break, and a faintly burning wick he will not quench” (Isaiah 42:3; see Matthew 12:20).

Why, then, does the Christian do good works? You do not do them to be loved or to be safe, because in Christ you are both. You do them because you are a child in your Father’s house and a branch on a living vine, and it is the most natural thing in the world for a loved child, unafraid at last, to pick up a towel and begin.


8. Summary, Tables, and Further Reading

8.1 Summary

Article VI answers the objection that justification by faith alone (Article IV) makes good works pointless. It confesses that justifying faith “is bound to bring forth good fruits,” that good works commanded by God are “necessary … because of God’s will,” and yet that “we should not rely on those works to merit justification before God” (AC VI, quoting Luke 17:10 and Ambrose/Ambrosiaster). Together the two clauses give the chapter’s motto: faith alone justifies, but the faith that justifies is never alone.

Scripture fixes the order. We are saved for good works, not by them (Ephesians 2:8–10); faith works through love (Galatians 5:6); the branch bears fruit because it is joined to the vine (John 15:5); our works earn nothing toward our standing (Luke 17:10); and God Himself, by His Holy Spirit, is at work in our working (Philippians 2:13). Paul and James answer different questions and do not contradict each other. The Fathers, Augustine above all, taught that grace goes before. The Formula of Concord pinned down what “necessary” means (by God’s will and as fruit, not “for salvation”) and kept the law as the believer’s guide, even as it always also accuses (Apology IV).

Rome, affirming grace and rejecting Pelagianism, still differs sharply (faith formed by love, and works that merit, a merit Rome itself calls God’s gift), where the Lutheran says faith receives Christ and works are its fruit. The Orthodox join faith and works; the Reformed and the Anglican Articles stand close to Article VI; Wesleyans stress sanctification; evangelicals argue over whether genuine faith must bear visible fruit. Through it all the movement is from fear to freedom. The Christian works not for God’s favor but from it, good works become fruit rather than payment, and so he learns that obedience, unchained from fear, is finally light.

8.2 Key terms (see Glossary, Appendix D)

  • The new obedience—the changed life that follows justifying faith; the title of Article VI.
  • Good works (bona opera)—the works God commands, done by the justified as the fruit of faith; not human religious observances (Article XV).
  • Justification—God’s declaring the sinner righteous for Christ’s sake, received through faith.
  • Sanctification—the Spirit’s renewing work in the justified; kept distinct from justification.
  • Faith—trust that receives Christ; “faith alone that is never alone.”
  • Sola fide—“by faith alone”: faith receives Christ and His righteousness, with no work of ours added.
  • Fides caritate formata—“faith formed by love,” the scholastic formula; Trent teaches the substance in its own words (Session VI, ch. 7).
  • Merit—in Roman teaching, the claim that the good works of the justified truly earn an increase of grace and eternal life. The Lutheran Confessions reject merit for forgiveness, grace, and justification, while confessing that God graciously promises rewards to the works of believers (Ap IV.194).
  • Antinomianism—the tendency to treat grace as a reason obedience no longer matters.
  • Law and Gospel—God’s word as command and accusation, and as promise and gift.
  • Third Use of the Law—the law as guide for believers (FC VI).

8.3 Tables in this chapter

Table 6.1—Why Do Good Works? Cause, Fruit, or Merit?

Tradition Why good works follow What the works do
Lutheran The necessary fruit of a living faith that receives Christ; God wills them; gratitude Testify to faith and the Spirit’s presence; serve the neighbor; never merit justification, and never the ground of the conscience’s certainty
Roman Catholic Flow from infused (poured-in) righteousness; faith justifies only with hope and charity joined to it (Trent, Session VI, ch. 7) Truly merit an increase of grace and eternal life (merit itself God’s gift; Pelagianism rejected)
Reformed The necessary fruit and evidence of faith; Christ’s renewal by His Spirit; grateful response; the law as guide Confirm faith and glorify God; do not merit (very close to Lutheran)
Wesleyan / Methodist Fruit of faith and of the Spirit’s sanctifying work, growing toward holiness Express faith working through love, by grace “working with us” (Art. VIII); they “cannot put away our sins” (Art. X), so they do not merit
Baptist / Evangelical Fruit and evidence of faith, with an internal debate over whether genuine faith must bear visible fruit Evidence that faith is genuine (Lordship) / commanded and rewarded, but not a condition of salvation or of assurance (Free Grace)

Table 6.2—The Three Uses of the Law

Use What it does Emphasis
First (civil) Restrains outward wickedness in society Held by all
Second (theological) Exposes sin, accuses, drives the sinner to Christ Held by all; Lutherans stress it, with law/gospel
Third (guiding) Guides the believer in the shape of good works Reformed foreground this; Lutherans affirm it but add lex semper accusat (the law still also accuses the Christian)

Numbering follows the Formula of Concord. Calvin lists the accusing use first and the civil use second.

8.4 Further reading

  • The Book of Concord, in the Concordia Triglotta (1921), the edition quoted here (online at bookofconcord.org), or in Kolb & Wengert (2000), the standard modern translation: AC VI; Apology IV (faith, love, and the fulfilling of the law); Formula of Concord IV (Good Works) and VI (the Third Use of the Law), with the editors’ historical introductions to both articles.
  • Charles Arand, Robert Kolb & James Nestingen, The Lutheran Confessions; Edmund Schlink, Theology of the Lutheran Confessions; Francis Pieper, Christian Dogmatics, vol. 3 (sanctification and good works).
  • Timothy Wengert, Law and Gospel (Melanchthon and Agricola on repentance, background to FC V); C. F. W. Walther, The Proper Distinction Between Law and Gospel.
  • Augustine, the anti-Pelagian writings (“God crowns his own gifts”); Article VI’s own citation of “Ambrose” (Ambrosiaster) on 1 Corinthians.
  • For the comparisons, from their own sources: the Council of Trent, Session VI, and Catechism of the Catholic Church §§1987–2029; the Heidelberg Catechism (Q86, Q115) and Westminster Confession ch. 16; the Thirty-Nine Articles (XI–XII); the Confession of Dositheus (Decree 13); the Methodist Articles of Religion and Wesley’s Plain Account of Christian Perfection; and, on the intra-evangelical debate, MacArthur’s The Gospel According to Jesus with Hodges’s Absolutely Free!
  • Dietrich Bonhoeffer, The Cost of Discipleship (on “cheap grace”; a modern Lutheran voice, used illustratively).
Topics
Justification and GraceOther Churches and Traditions
Scripture
Galatians 5:1Galatians 5:13Galatians 5:16Luke 17:10Ephesians 2:8–10Galatians 5:6John 15:5Matthew 7:17Psalm 19:12Philippians 2:12–13Titus 2:11–14Romans 3:28James 2:24James 2:19James 2:171 Corinthians 1:4Galatians 5:22–231 Peter 2:5Psalm 119:105Romans 8:15James 2:26Romans 6:1–2Romans 6:4John 15:3Philippians 1:6Isaiah 42:3Matthew 12:20Philippians 2:13
Confessions
AC VISD IVAp IVEp IIISD VIEp VIEp IV

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.