Books · On the Dignity of the Human Being

Life Shared: The Poor, the Sick, and the Vulnerable

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Scripture: Luke 10:25–37; Matthew 25:31–46; James 2:14–17; Galatians 6:2; 1 John 3:16–18; 1 Corinthians 12:22–26

1. Who is my neighbor?

A lawyer asked Jesus that question and he asked it (Luke tells us) desiring to justify himself. It is a good question asked for a bad reason. He wanted a boundary because a boundary would tell him where his obligation stopped and a man who knows where his obligation stops can finally relax. Jesus gave him a road, a robbery, and three men, two who walked past and one who did not.

But a Samaritan, as he journeyed, came to where he was, and when he saw him, he had compassion. He went to him and bound up his wounds, pouring on oil and wine. Then he set him on his own animal and brought him to an inn and took care of him. (Luke 10:33–34, ESV)

The Samaritan did not first establish that the injured man deserved help or investigate whether his own decisions had put him on that road at that hour or determine whether he was the sort of person who would have helped in return. He saw a human being who was bleeding and he stopped. Then he paid for the room and promised to cover whatever else the man needed when he came back through.

It is interesting what Jesus does with the lawyer’s question at the end. The lawyer asked who his neighbor was, meaning: whose need obligates me? Jesus asks which of the three “proved to be a neighbor to the man who fell among the robbers,” which is a different question altogether. He has turned a boundary question into a vocation question and He sends the man away with an imperative rather than a definition: “You go, and do likewise” (Luke 10:37, ESV). Our neighbor is not simply the person we already love. Our neighbor is the person God has put in front of us.

None of this was new with the parable. Israel had been given the shape of it in the Law and the shape is specific:

If among you, one of your brothers should become poor… you shall not harden your heart or shut your hand against your poor brother, but you shall open your hand to him and lend him sufficient for his need, whatever it may be… You shall give to him freely, and your heart shall not be grudging when you give to him. (Deuteronomy 15:7–10, ESV)

There are three things the text will not allow. It will not allow a limit set by the giver: sufficient for his need, whatever it may be. It will not allow grudging compliance, since the heart is legislated along with the hand. It will not allow the decision we would be tempted to make, warning against the “unworthy thought” that the year of release is near and the loan may not be worth extending.

The proverbs state the theology the Law assumes: “Whoever oppresses a poor man insults his Maker, but he who is generous to the needy honors him” (Proverbs 14:31, ESV), and “Whoever is generous to the poor lends to the LORD” (Proverbs 19:17, ESV).

2. Good works are the fruit of faith, not the price of it

Before this book says anything more about mercy it has to say something about justification because a congregation that gets these two in the wrong order will end up with either a guilty church or a proud one. We are not justified before God by our charity. The Augsburg Confession says: we cannot be justified before God by our own strength, merits, or works, but are justified freely for Christ’s sake through faith, when we believe that we are received into favor and that our sins are forgiven for Christ’s sake.³⁰ No one is saved by the number of the poor he has fed, the sick he has visited, or the money he has donated. Christ has accomplished our salvation and the work is finished.

The faith that receives Christ is never indifferent to a suffering neighbor. The same Confession says so and it does not say may: this faith “is bound to bring forth good fruits,” and Christians ought to do the good works commanded by God — “but that we should not rely on those works to merit justification before God.”³¹ Luther’s formulation in The Freedom of a Christian is worth memorizing (the Christian is free lord of all and dutiful servant of all) and he means that both are true at the same moment and for the same reason.³² In other words, we do not serve the neighbor in order to persuade God to love us. We serve the neighbor because God has already loved us and the neighbor is standing right there.

3. Two kinds of righteousness, and why the distinction rescues both

The trouble with the last section is usually a confusion of categories and Luther supplied the tool for sorting it out. He distinguishes two kinds of righteousness and a Christian who holds them apart can be generous without anxiety and confident without pride.

The first is righteousness before God (coram Deo, in God’s sight). It is entirely passive. It is not achieved, improved, or maintained by anything I do; it is Christ’s own righteousness, credited to me, received by faith, and complete from the moment it is given. Luther calls it an alien righteousness, meaning it comes from outside me. It is not earned by my performance or increased by my good works.³³

The second is righteousness before men (coram hominibus, in the world’s sight and in the neighbor’s). This one is active. It consists of the actual work of actual love: the meal cooked, the bill paid, the visit made, the honest business conducted. It is real righteousness and Scripture praises it. In Luther’s own account it is what the first righteousness produces. What it does not do is add anything whatever to my standing before God.

Collapse the two and you get one of two disasters. Collapse the second into the first and you get the anxious Christian, who cannot give a dollar without wondering whether it counted. He is never sure he has done enough. He is generous and miserable and the misery is not humility. It is unbelief about what Christ finished. Collapse the first into the second and you get the comfortable Christian who has correctly grasped that he is saved by grace and has concluded that the neighbor is therefore optional. He has not visited anyone in years. He mistakes the emptiness of his hands before God for emptiness of obligation before his neighbor, which is precisely the inference Luther spent his life denying.

The distinction rescues both. Since my standing before God is settled and cannot be improved, I am free to attend entirely to my neighbor rather than to the state of my own soul, which is the only condition under which love is actually love. Since that same freedom was purchased and given, it never becomes a reason to do nothing.

4. Vocation: where the neighbor actually finds you

If good works do not go up to God, where do they go? God does not need your good works. Your neighbor does. That is the center of the whole ethic: since Christ has done everything necessary for your salvation, your works are released from the job of earning anything and are free to be aimed at the person in front of you, who has a real need that a real act will meet.

God has arranged the world in stations (the estates and offices in which we already stand). You are someone’s child, someone’s parent, someone’s husband or wife, someone’s employee or employer, someone’s neighbor, a member of this congregation, a citizen. Every one of those relationships has work attached to it and that work is the form serving God takes for you. Luther’s claim is that God Himself is at work inside it. He gives daily bread through the farmer and the baker and governs through the magistrate, hiding Himself in ordinary offices so completely that we do not recognize His providence.³⁴

Two consequences follow from that. The first is liberating. You do not have to invent a ministry in order to serve God. The mother up in the night with a sick child or the man running a business honestly when dishonesty would pay better or the daughter driving hours to sit with her father is ministry. None of that needs upgrading into something more spiritual. The second is inconvenient. Vocation puts your obligations where you actually are, which means you cannot sit back while the world goes by. A man can hold strong convictions about the poor in general while doing nothing for the family down the street. Stations do not permit that. They hand you particular people, with names and faces, most of whom you did not choose.

5. The poor are not a separate class of humanity

Poverty separates people. Those of us on the comfortable side begin, without intending anything unkind, to speak of the poor as a category (a problem to be addressed, a budget line item, a population, a statistic that we hope is trending in the right direction). The abstraction is convenient because abstractions make no claims on anyone.

The poor are men, women, and children with names, families, histories, fears, and responsibilities and they are our neighbors. Attending to them requires attending to their actual circumstances, since the causes are not identical and the remedies are not interchangeable. One family needs a month’s rent. Another needs work or housing or medical care or a course of treatment for an addiction. Christian mercy is active and not passive. It also requires humility. Whatever I have, I have because God gave it to me, and I live on His generosity exactly as much as the family I am helping lives on mine. The man who writes the check is not morally superior to the man who cashes it. Prosperity is not proof of righteousness and poverty is not proof of sin. The book of Job exists partly to refute that equation and Jesus’s remarks about the rich ought to settle it.

6. The sick and disabled belong to the whole congregation

Paul’s image of the Church as a body is so familiar that we have stopped hearing what he actually says with it:

On the contrary, the parts of the body that seem to be weaker are indispensable … But God has so composed the body, giving greater honor to the part that lacked it, that there may be no division in the body, but that the members may have the same care for one another. If one member suffers, all suffer together. (1 Corinthians 12:22–26, ESV)

Indispensable. Neither tolerated nor accommodated nor included as an act of congregational generosity, but indispensable and it is the ones who seem weaker that he says it about. Measure your members by what they can do for you and you have adopted the world’s standard inside the Church. The homebound widow who has not been in the sanctuary for years is not a lesser member of Christ’s body. The man with an intellectual disability is not a partial Christian. The member whose illness keeps her home most Sundays is not owed less pastoral attention than the member on three committees. The Church is not a society of the capable that has generously made room for a few others. It is the assembly of sinners whom Christ has called by the Gospel and every one of us arrived by the same door.

This has architectural consequences. A ramp, an accessible restroom, a hearing loop for those with hearing aids, a large-print bulletin, a pew cut short so a wheelchair can sit with the family instead of in the aisle, a willingness to bring the Lord’s Supper to a bedside: these are the difference between a member hearing the Gospel and not hearing it and they say to the congregation what the congregation says it believes. Such things do not replace the preaching of the Word; they are how it gets to the person who needs it.

7. Mercy must not become paternalism

There is a danger inside Christian charity. The person who gives help begins to regard himself as the senior partner. He assumes the one receiving help has little to offer. Mercy has then become a way of exercising power over someone and it is all the more difficult to challenge because it looks like kindness. The person receiving assistance is still a human being with a will, a conscience, relationships, and responsibilities of his own. Wherever it is possible he should be part of the decisions that govern his life, even when including him is slower and the outcome is one we would not have chosen. His dignity requires more than the delivery of goods. It requires being treated as a person rather than as a case. This matters most in the care of the disabled, since needing help in one area of life says nothing about capacity in every other.

8. What this costs and who decides

Three principles follow:

First, the giving is free. Paul is explicit: “Each one must give as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver” (2 Corinthians 9:7, ESV). There is no assessment, no schedule of required percentages laid on a Christian conscience. What replaces compulsion is not a lower standard but a better motive and the motive Paul actually appeals to is the only one available: “you know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though he was rich, yet for your sake he became poor, so that you by his poverty might become rich” (2 Corinthians 8:9, ESV). The argument runs from the manger and the cross to the offering plate.

Second, the money is real. Freedom from compulsion is not freedom from effect and a congregation that gives cheerfully and negligibly has understood only the first half. Paul tells Timothy to charge the rich in this present age “to be generous and ready to share” (1 Timothy 6:18, ESV), and the Jerusalem congregation distributed proceeds “to all, as any had need,” which is an amount determined by the need rather than by what was convenient.

Third, it is decided by people who know the names. This is where congregations go wrong in both directions. Some hand everything to a committee. That is efficient and it slowly turns neighbors into cases. Others leave it entirely to the pastor’s discretion, flexible and impossible at once (able to be manipulated, unable to explain himself without betraying confidences, and eventually suspected). The old arrangement is better than either: a small, trusted group who knows the congregation, works quietly, and keeps confidential records that only a few people ever see. This gives the pastor room to act immediately when there is no time to convene anyone.

The difficult part is that this requires a congregation to talk about money in church, which most would rather not do. The reluctance is understandable. The widow with the shut-off notice does not ask because she has no idea whether there is anything to ask for. Tell people the fund exists. Tell them how to ask. Then make it easy, private, and quick, because a family in that position has usually already been humiliated by someone else.

9. The Church’s ministry of mercy

The Church’s first and irreplaceable work is to preach the Gospel and administer the Sacraments. That is what the Church is for and no amount of good done in the community substitutes for it.³⁵ The Gospel it preaches, however, bears fruit in the people who hear it and a congregation where that fruit never appears should examine what it has been preaching.

The early Church did this before it had buildings, budgets, or legal standing and the pagans noticed. Tertullian, defending Christians against the charge of being a dangerous secret society, describes the common fund: each member contributes what he can, monthly and voluntarily, and the money goes “to support and bury poor people, to supply the wants of boys and girls destitute of means and parents, and of old persons confined now to the house” and he adds that this is the thing outsiders remark on: “See, they say, how they love one another.”³⁶ Two centuries later the emperor Julian, attempting to revive paganism and frustrated at his lack of progress, wrote that the Christians were succeeding because “the impious Galileans support not only their own poor but ours as well.” He meant it as a complaint and it survives as a compliment.³⁷

The Fathers preached this hard and they were not gentle about property. Basil the Great, who built a hospital and hostel outside Caesarea for the poor and the leprous, told his congregation that the bread they were holding belonged to the hungry, the coat in the closet belonged to the naked, and the money buried in the ground belonged to the destitute. Refusing to give, they were not declining to be generous but wronging people who needed it.³⁸ Chrysostom preached the same in Antioch and Constantinople until it cost him, insisting that the altar of the poor stands beside the altar of the sanctuary and that a man who honors the one while ignoring the other has understood neither.³⁹

A Lutheran reads these men with real gratitude and with one correction ready to hand. Where they occasionally speak as though almsgiving purchased something before God, we do not follow them; the Apology is clear that alms please God in those who are already reconciled by faith, and merit nothing in those who are not.⁴⁰ Take the urgency and leave behind the idea that almsgiving buys forgiveness. God does promise to reward the good works of His children, but as a Father’s gift and never as the price of salvation. The urgency is right and we have far less of it than they did.

Most of this work is unremarkable and unrecorded. A member visits a widow, a family cooks for someone home from surgery, a young man mows a yard that has gotten away from an elderly neighbor, or a congregation quietly covers a utility bill for a family whose income stopped when the diagnosis came. Very little of this requires a committee, a name, or a line in the newsletter.


³⁰ AC IV. ³¹ AC VI; Ap IV 122–182 on the relation of faith and works. ³² Luther, The Freedom of a Christian, LW 31:344. ³³ Luther, Two Kinds of Righteousness (1519), LW 31:297–306, for the alien and the proper righteousness, where the second is what the first produces; and the preface to the 1535 Galatians commentary, LW 26:4–12, for the passive righteousness coram Deo and the active righteousness coram hominibus. Both schemes are Luther’s and they are not the same distinction: this section takes its pair of portraits from the first and its vocabulary of before God and before men from the second. See also Ap IV and FC SD III. ³⁴ Luther, The Freedom of a Christian, LW 31:365–366, on works aimed at the neighbor rather than at God; and The Estate of Marriage, LW 45:39–41, on the ordinary station as the place God’s command finds a man. The related theme — God working through the creature as through a mask — runs through the Lectures on Genesis (LW 1–8) and the Large Catechism’s treatment of daily bread (LC III 72–75). ³⁵ AC V and VII, on the ministry of Word and Sacrament and the marks by which the Church is known. ³⁶ Tertullian, Apology 39.5–7, ANF vol. 3. ³⁷ Julian the Apostate, Letter 22 (to Arsacius, c. 362), trans. W. C. Wright, The Works of the Emperor Julian, vol. 3, Loeb Classical Library 157; the letter is also preserved in Sozomen, Ecclesiastical History V.16. ³⁸ Basil of Caesarea, Homily on “I Will Pull Down My Barns” (Homily 6) §7, and Homily to the Rich (Homily 7). The paraphrase above is a summary of his argument rather than a quotation; Schroeder’s translation reads that the bread is for the hungry and the garments are for the naked, and Basil’s list also includes the shoes and the buried silver. Basil’s foundation outside Caesarea, the Basileias, is described by Gregory of Nazianzus in Oration 43.63. ³⁹ John Chrysostom, Homilies on Second Corinthians 20.3, on the altar of the poor — “This altar is composed of the very members of Christ, and the body of the Lord is made your altar”; and Homilies on Matthew 50 (the almsgiving passage is at §§3–4 in the Migne divisions, printed at §4 running into §5 in NPNF). ⁴⁰ Ap IV 275–284, on alms, the works of the reconciled, and what they do and do not merit.

Topics
Vocation and Daily Life
Scripture
Luke 10:25–37Matthew 25:31–46James 2:14–17Galatians 6:21 John 3:16–181 Corinthians 12:22–26Luke 10:33–34Luke 10:37Deuteronomy 15:7–10Proverbs 14:31Proverbs 19:172 Corinthians 9:72 Corinthians 8:91 Timothy 6:18
Confessions
AC IVAC VIAp IVSD IIILC IIIAC VLC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.