Books · On the Dignity of the Human Being
Life Honored: The Elderly and the Dying
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Scripture: Exodus 20:12; Psalm 71:9, 17–18; Isaiah 46:4; John 19:26–27; Romans 14:7–8; 1 Timothy 5:8
1. Growing old does not mean becoming less human
Age takes things from us in an order most of us would not have chosen. Eyesight first, usually, then hearing, then the strength to carry what we used to carry without thinking about it. Tasks that took ten minutes take an hour and then take help. For some, age also takes memory and the ability to follow a conversation to its end. A woman who ran a household, raised several children, held a job, buried a husband, and was the person everyone else called in a crisis may end up dependent on those same children for the ordinary necessities of a day. This reversal is hard on everyone. The elderly parent feels embarrassed, frustrated, and fearful; the adult children feel the pull of work, their own children, and money, and they feel guilty about resenting any of it. Both sides usually assume they are the only one struggling.
Scripture does not romanticize any of this. Moses counts the years and does not flatter them: “The years of our life are seventy, or even by reason of strength eighty; yet their span is but toil and trouble; they are soon gone, and we fly away” (Psalm 90:10, ESV). The Preacher describes the failing body in a series of images that anyone who has sat in a nursing home will recognize at once (the keepers of the house trembling, the strong men bent, the grinders ceasing because they are few, the doors on the street shut, the almond tree blossoming white, the grasshopper dragging itself along) until “the dust returns to the earth as it was, and the spirit returns to God who gave it” (Ecclesiastes 12:3–7, ESV). Nothing there pretends the process looks dignified. Yet the same Scripture insists that age is to be honored and it does so in the imperative: “You shall stand up before the gray head and honor the face of an old man, and you shall fear your God: I am the LORD” (Leviticus 19:32, ESV). The two halves of that verse belong together. Honoring the old is put beside the fear of God, as something owed. Proverbs adds the picture: “Gray hair is a crown of glory; it is gained in a righteous life” (Proverbs 16:31, ESV).
Those difficulties are real. They do not touch the question of dignity. Human life is not valued by output. An elderly person does not become less human as his abilities decline. His life does not become less worthy of protection because he can no longer live alone and he does not owe anyone a justification for still being here.
2. The Fourth Commandment and the care of parents
“Honor your father and your mother, that your days may be long in the land that the LORD your God is giving you” (Exodus 20:12, ESV). Luther’s explanation is a list of verbs: we are not to despise or anger our parents and other authorities, but to “honor them, serve and obey them, love and cherish them.”⁴¹
We generally teach this commandment to children. Luther treats the Fourth Commandment at greater length than any other commandment in the Large Catechism (seventy-six paragraphs against forty-eight for the First) and he insists that the honor owed to parents is owed for life, becoming in some ways more demanding as the parents grow older.⁴²
The Large Catechism does something surprising with this commandment. Luther takes “father and mother” and extends the office outward (to those who stand in a parent’s place, to masters and teachers, to civil authority, and to the ministers of the Word) so that the Fourth Commandment turns out to govern nearly every relationship of authority and dependence a person will ever stand in.⁴³ Honor, in this account, is not warm feeling toward the people who raised you. It is a debt owed to an office God established, payable whether or not the officeholder has been admirable and Luther is candid that many parents have not been. Paul’s version is blunt: “if anyone does not provide for his relatives, and especially for members of his household, he has denied the faith and is worse than an unbeliever” (1 Timothy 5:8, ESV). He is writing, in context, about the care of widows.
In old age that honor takes new forms: groceries, rides to appointments, help with a checkbook, a difficult conversation about the car keys, money, presence, and the patience to hear the same story many times over and to respond as though it were the first. Our Lord Himself, dying, arranged for the care of His mother from the cross: “Woman, behold, your son! … Behold, your mother!” (John 19:26–27, ESV). In the middle of redeeming the world He took care of a specific practical problem and He did it because it was His to do.
Honoring one’s parents does not require that one person personally perform every act of care regardless of the cost. Some conditions require skilled nursing. Some houses cannot be made safe. Some caregivers have illnesses, jobs, or children of their own that put round-the-clock care out of reach, and pretending otherwise ends with two people in crisis instead of one. The use of professional caregivers, assisted living, or a nursing home is not by itself a failure to honor a parent. A family can honor a father beautifully through a combination of its own work and professional help. A father can also be neglected in his own daughter’s spare bedroom. The question is never where the person sleeps but whether he is loved, safe, visited, and attended to.
3. The dignity of those living with dementia
A woman who raised several children and kept her own house may reach a year in which she cannot remember her wedding, cannot follow a sentence to its end, cannot name the daughter sitting beside her, and eventually cannot take any conscious part in the life that was hers. Families say that the person they knew is already gone. That sentence is true about everything they can see. What it cannot be allowed to become is a doctrine because as doctrine it locates the person in memory and cognition and if that is where the person lives then every one of us is a person only for as long as his memory holds.
The Christian speaks more carefully. The man living with dementia remains a human being. He has not stopped being the creature God made and his family’s obligations toward him have not lapsed because he can no longer recognize the people discharging them. His inability to state his faith does not invalidate God’s promises to him. A baptized Christian who can no longer recite the Creed has not been stripped of his Baptism because faith is not an intellectual accomplishment by which we hold on to God. It is God’s gift, worked and sustained by His Word,⁴⁴ and the decisive thing about a baptized man is what God has done and does not take back, and forgetting is not the unbelief that rejects it. He is held in the memory of God and God’s memory is the one that was holding him up all along.
This is a reason to keep bringing the Word to people whose minds have failed, whose hidden spiritual condition is God’s business. A pastor can pray with a man who cannot answer. He can read the Twenty-third Psalm, speak the Lord’s Prayer, and sing a stanza of a hymn the man learned as a boy. Anyone who has done this knows how often the mouth remembers what the mind cannot. The Supper needs a clear word here, because families are frightened of getting it wrong. Start with the presumption: a baptized Christian who has received this Sacrament for decades should go on receiving it. Luther’s answer to who is worthy has never had a clause about memory in it — “he is truly worthy and well prepared who has faith in these words”⁴⁵ — and cognitive failure is not the unworthiness the Confessions are guarding against. Real questions follow and they are questions about how rather than whether: can he swallow safely, what has he confessed in the past, what is this congregation’s practice about admission to the Sacrament. A pastor settles those case by case. He does not settle them by staying away. Withdrawal of pastoral care is never the answer and the inability to communicate is not a reason to stop coming. The daughter who has stopped being able to walk through the door is not a wicked woman. She has been grieving her mother for years without being allowed to call it grief and the room now frightens her. To her I would say only this: go anyway and go without a plan, sit down and be her daughter, because there is nothing you are supposed to accomplish in that room.
4. The elderly are not forgotten by God
Psalm 71 is the prayer of a person whose strength is going:
Do not cast me off in the time of old age; forsake me not when my strength is spent. (Psalm 71:9, ESV)
Many elderly Christians recognize that prayer, because it names their fear: not death, but being set aside while still alive. A woman worries (and she will not say this to her children) that they regard her as a problem to be managed. A man notices that the phone rings less. Both have watched friends die and both have lost the ability to get themselves to church, which for a lifelong member is a grief the congregation rarely understands.
God’s answer through Isaiah is worth quoting at length because of who is doing the carrying:
even to your old age I am he, and to gray hairs I will carry you. I have made, and I will bear; I will carry and will save. (Isaiah 46:4, ESV)
The God who made him will carry him. The elderly Christian cannot do what he once did for the Church and the Lord who called him through the Gospel has not made His faithfulness contingent on it. An old man usually knows that Christ has not forgotten him. What he has begun to doubt is whether his church has. The care of elderly and homebound members is therefore a central part of a congregation’s pastoral ministry and not something done only when time allows. The pastor brings the Word to those who can no longer come to the Word. He hears confession and speaks absolution, he prays, he brings the Supper where it is right to do so, and he tells an old man that Christ has not forgotten him and neither has his church.
5. The family doing the carrying
The people caring for the elderly need care as well and they are usually the ones closest to breaking. The arrangement almost always falls unevenly. One child does most of it (ordinarily the daughter, ordinarily the one who lives nearest, ordinarily without much having been decided) and the others contribute opinions from a distance. She is managing her mother’s medications, her own job, and a teenager at home. The resentment that builds in that situation is not a failure of Christian love. It is what happens to a person carrying more than one person can carry. Telling her to be more patient will not change that. Some of what she is owed is obvious and seldom given.
Relief. That means someone else does it for a weekend. If we cannot find four people willing to take an afternoon each, what we lack is someone willing to ask them.
Permission to feel what she feels. She will admit, if she trusts you, that some days she wishes it were over and then be horrified at herself. She should be told that the wish is not the same as the intention, that it is nearly universal among caregivers, and that wanting a person’s suffering to end is not wanting the person dead. Absolve what needs absolving and do not manufacture guilt where there is none.
Someone to tell her that she is grieving. In a long decline the losses arrive one at a time over years (the conversations, the recognition, the woman’s own mother looking at her as a stranger). This is grief without any of the permissions grief usually carries and it is the reason so many caregivers are stunned by how they feel at the funeral. Naming it helps more than almost anything a pastor can do.
Honesty about the limits. Some things cannot be done at home safely and a family that has promised never to “put her in a home” may be keeping a promise at the cost of the person it was made to. Chapter IV §2 has already said this; it needs saying again to the exhausted, who often hear the Fourth Commandment as a demand that they destroy themselves.
Now a word to the other child, the one who lives far away and comes at Christmas. You are probably ashamed already which is usually why people stay away. Come for a weekend rather than an afternoon and take the whole thing off her while you are there: the nights, the medications, the bathroom, not only the easy parts. Call her in the weeks you are not there and ask about her and not about your mother. Thank her for everything she is doing that you are not able to. She has been waiting for someone to say that sentence.
A word to her as well. You are not failing. You are tired, which is a different thing and tiredness is not a sin to be repented of. Needing a break is not a sin and neither is longing for her suffering to end. Where you have sinned against her (the sharp word, the impatience you regret), bring it to Christ and hear it plainly: that is forgiven. Then go back and let someone else take a turn. Paul’s word to these people is worth reading in the right order: “Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ” (Galatians 6:2, ESV) comes before “let us not grow weary of doing good” (Galatians 6:9, ESV). The endurance is commanded to a person who is supposed to be carrying part of a shared load, not the whole of it alone. If we quote the second verse at a worn-out daughter and do nothing whatever about the first, we have used Scripture to excuse ourselves.
6. The particular loneliness of outliving people
A subject that gets almost no attention in the literature and comes up constantly in a parish: the loneliness of being the one who is left. It is not the same as grief, though it grows out of it. A woman of eighty-six has buried a husband, two of her three closest friends, a brother, and more acquaintances than she can count. Her doctor is younger than her children. No one living remembers her as a girl. When something funny happens she reaches for the phone before remembering there is no longer anyone on the other end who would find it funny for the same reasons. That is a kind of poverty. A congregation can address it or ignore it, but it cannot make it go away by feeling sorry about it.
Scripture takes the widow more seriously than we do. She stands in the Law beside the orphan and the sojourner as one of the three whom God specifically watches over and whose mistreatment He specifically avenges. Paul gives Timothy an entire passage on the congregation’s duty to widows, including the flat sentence quoted earlier about the man who will not provide for his own. James defines pure religion as visiting orphans and widows in their affliction. There is no equivalent volume of material about congregational programs and the disproportion is instructive.
Two practical things follow. The first is that presence is worth far more than sympathy and presence means going. A short visit is worth more than any amount of concern expressed at a distance and it is worth more than most people believe, because they cannot imagine that so little would matter so much. It matters because it interrupts the silence and because being remembered by someone is the thing that has gone. The second is that the old have something to give and almost no one asks them for it. The Psalmist’s prayer is not merely to be kept: “So even to old age and gray hairs, O God, do not forsake me, until I proclaim your might to another generation, your power to all those to come” (Psalm 71:18, ESV). He wants to be kept for something. Paul tells Titus that the older women are to teach the younger and the older men to model what he calls sober, dignified, self-controlled living, which assumes a congregation in which the generations are in the same room often enough for that to happen.
7. Learning to die before you have to
The Church used to teach people deliberately how to die. The late medieval ars moriendi (the art of dying) circulated as a printed handbook with woodcuts, on the assumption that a Christian should arrive at his deathbed having already thought about it. We have lost that almost entirely. Death has moved out of the house and into institutions. Most people have never seen one, and the subject is now rarely spoken of.
Luther wrote his own version in 1519, before the Reformation was fully underway and for this purpose it remains among the most useful things he wrote.⁴⁶ Three things in it are worth having. The first is that a man should set his affairs in order early (his will, and his forgiveness of the people he is angry with, and theirs of him) so that when the hour comes he is free to attend to one thing only. A dying man has enough to do without also settling a lawsuit. The second is his handling of what he calls the three images that assault a dying man: death, sin, and hell. His counsel is not to stare them down, which he says cannot be done and will destroy anyone who tries, but to look somewhere else: at Christ, in whom death is overcome, sin is borne, and hell is shut. He is sharp about looking for comfort inside oneself (in one’s conscience, feelings, or election): “Seek yourself only in Christ and not in yourself.” That is precisely the direction in which there is no comfort to be found. The third is the most Lutheran thing in the treatise. Against the anxiety about whether one has received the sacraments worthily, Luther points the dying man to the promise attached to them: God does not lie, the absolution is His word and not the priest’s opinion and the body and blood given at that bedside are given for you. Seek out the sacraments, he says, and then believe what they say instead of auditing your own sincerity.
Simeon in the temple shows what this looks like once it has been learned. He has the child in his arms and he is finished: “Lord, now you are letting your servant depart in peace, according to your word; for my eyes have seen your salvation” (Luke 2:29–30, ESV). He is not at peace because his life has gone well, or because he is tired, or because he has made his peace with the inevitable. He is at peace because he has seen what he was promised. Lutherans have sung his words after the Supper since the Reformation and the placement is deliberate: a congregation that has just received Christ turns around and sings the song of a man ready to die.
Paul reaches the same place by a different road: “For I am already being poured out as a drink offering, and the time of my departure has come. I have fought the good fight, I have finished the race, I have kept the faith” (2 Timothy 4:6–7, ESV). Yet what he expects at the end of it is not a verdict on the race but a gift — “the crown of righteousness, which the Lord, the righteous judge, will award to me on that day.” Even there the accounting is Christ’s.
Do not wait for a diagnosis to begin thinking about it and do not let your family’s first conversation about your death happen in a hospital hallway in the middle of the night. Write down what you want. Tell someone where the papers are. Make the arrangements and pay for them if you can. Then put it out of your mind and go and live.
8. Caring for the dying
There comes a point in an illness when treatment can no longer restore health and the Christian’s task at that point is neither to abandon the patient nor to demand that every remaining intervention be attempted.
A distinction has to be drawn here carefully. The Fifth Commandment forbids the deliberate taking of innocent human life and commands us to help and sustain our neighbor’s life. It does not command us to treat every available procedure as morally obligatory. Some treatments offer a real prospect of recovery or meaningful relief; others impose serious burdens (pain, disorientation, separation from family, weeks in an intensive care unit) while offering little or nothing in return. Declining or discontinuing a treatment of the second kind is not the same act as killing the patient and it is a pastoral failure to let a family believe that it is.
The difference lies in what we are doing and what we intend by it. When a burdensome treatment is withdrawn and the patient is kept warm, clean, medicated, and accompanied, we are allowing a disease to finish its course while caring for the person to the end. The cause of death is the illness. When a lethal dose is administered, we have committed euthanasia; when it is prescribed for the patient to take himself, we have assisted a suicide. In both cases we have made ourselves the cause of death and no amount of compassion in the motive changes the object of the act. I named both in chapter 1 and I restate them here because this is the chapter families are living in when the question arrives. It usually arrives in the middle of a long vigil from a tired person who loves the patient and wants the suffering to stop.
Two errors stand on either side of that line. The first says a human life becomes disposable once suffering is severe enough or dependence has become inconvenient. The second says biological life must be prolonged by every means for as long as technology permits, as though death were a defeat we owe it to the patient to postpone at any cost. The Christian rejects both and for the same reason: our lives are not our own property and they are not medicine’s property either. “For none of us lives to himself, and none of us dies to himself. … So then, whether we live or whether we die, we are the Lord’s” (Romans 14:7–8, ESV).
Most people will have to meet this question at some point in their lives. Some of you have already answered it (in a hallway, on no sleep, with a doctor standing there waiting) and you have been quietly turning it over ever since. When you told them to stop, you did not kill your mother. The cancer killed your mother. What you declined was more weeks of pain added to a death that was already coming and that is not the Fifth Commandment broken; it is the Fifth Commandment kept, because you went on caring for her when no one could cure her. If your conscience needs it, bring this to me in person and I will speak the absolution over it and it will be finished. Christ does not leave His people to retry a death for the rest of their lives.
9. Hospice and palliative care
Hospice and palliative care are, at their best, a work of mercy. Their work is to relieve pain, manage symptoms that frighten patients and families, support the household, and make it possible for a person to die at home among people who love him rather than among strangers.
A Christian may accept such care without any failure of faith. To accept that one is dying is not to want to die and it is certainly not to cause death. The dying person continues to receive nourishment, fluids, hygiene, pain relief, and company appropriate to his condition. Appropriateness is a real qualifier here. In the last days of an active dying process, artificial nutrition and hydration can add burden without adding benefit and a family should not be told that they are starving their mother when the body has simply stopped being able to use what is given. These are decisions requiring honest medical counsel, a clear head, and pastoral care.
Families should also be urged to have these conversations long before the crisis. Who decides if I cannot? What do I want and not want? Whom do I want called and do I want my pastor there? Where am I to be buried and is it paid for? None of that is morbid and none of it is a failure of hope. It is one of the last acts of love a person can perform. I have seen the difference it makes between a family that had the conversation and a family that did not.
10. The pastor at the bedside
The pastor’s presence at a deathbed is not ceremonial and it is not moral support. He comes as a minister of the Word. The dying person may be afraid. He may be thinking over things he did long ago that he has never told anyone. He may be worrying about the wife who will have to manage the house alone. Whatever he is carrying, the pastor is there to proclaim Christ to him. He hears the man’s confession and pronounces the absolution. He reads the Twenty-third Psalm, or John 14, or Romans 8, or whatever text this particular Christian has leaned on for decades. He administers the Supper while it can still be received. He prays with the family and he commends the dying man to God with the old words of the commendation.
At the end he commends him. That is the Church’s oldest and plainest act at a deathbed. The words are old: Into your hands, O merciful Savior, we commend your servant. They are not an incantation. These words are saying aloud what he can no longer say himself. He is in good company in the saying of it. “Into your hand I commit my spirit” is Psalm 31:5 and it was a child’s bedtime prayer in Israel long before our Lord made it His last word from the cross (Luke 23:46, ESV). Stephen, dying while being stoned, says it to Jesus directly — “Lord Jesus, receive my spirit” — then asks forgiveness for the men killing him and “fell asleep” (Acts 7:59–60, ESV). The verb is the one the New Testament keeps choosing.
The Christian does not walk into death holding up the quality of his faith. He goes in holding nothing because Christ has already done everything that needed doing. This statement needs to be heard by the dying, that neither death nor life nor anything else in all creation will be able to separate him from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord.
⁴¹ SC, Ten Commandments, Fourth Commandment. ⁴² LC I 103–178, the longest treatment of any commandment in the Large Catechism. LC I 111 extends the duty explicitly: children are to “serve them, help them, and provide for them when they are old, sick, infirm, or poor.” ⁴³ LC I 141–178, extending the Fourth Commandment to those standing in a parent’s place — masters, teachers, civil authority, and the ministers of the Word — and treating the honor owed as a debt to the office rather than a sentiment toward the person. ⁴⁴ AC V; SC, Creed, Third Article: “I cannot by my own reason or strength believe in Jesus Christ, my Lord, or come to Him; but the Holy Spirit has called me by the Gospel.” The conviction that the person is held in God’s memory rather than in his own I owe to John Swinton, Dementia: Living in the Memories of God (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2012). ⁴⁵ SC, Sacrament of the Altar, Fourth Part; LC V 33ff. ⁴⁶ Luther, A Sermon on Preparing to Die (1519), LW 42:99–115. The three images and the counsel to look away from them to Christ are at LW 42:101–107; the sacraments and the promise attached to them from 42:100 and especially at 110–115.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.