Books · On the Dignity of the Human Being

Life Committed: The Christian Treatment of the Dead

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Scripture: Genesis 23:1–20; Genesis 50:24–25; Deuteronomy 34:5–6; John 19:38–42; Acts 8:2; Romans 6:3–5; 1 Corinthians 15:35–57

1. Does the body still matter after death?

When a person dies something terrible has happened. We have grown used to softer descriptions (a transition, a passing, a natural part of life) and every one of them is said for the best of reasons. Scripture calls death an enemy and it calls it the last one: “The last enemy to be destroyed is death” (1 Corinthians 15:26, ESV). Death entered by sin and it has never once come as a friend (Romans 5:12). What death does is separate what God joined. The body that worked, held children, knelt at the rail, and received the Sacrament lies still and the person who lived in it is not there. The Church has never pretended this is acceptable.

Yet the body of the deceased has not therefore become debris. It remains the mortal remains of a human being who was created by God, lived among us, and bore His image, and for the Christian it is more than that: it is the body God has promised to raise. This is why our treatment of the dead is marked by reverence. We do not worship the body and we do not imagine that it is conscious of anything done around it or that the deceased is in any way affected by how well the service goes. We handle it with care because of the person whose body it was and because of what we confess will happen to it. Human dignity does not evaporate at the moment of death. If it did, the Church’s practice at a graveside would be nothing more than sentimental and we would have no argument against the disposal of bodies by whatever means is cheapest.

2. Burial in the Holy Scriptures

Scripture treats the burial of the dead as a serious human responsibility.

Genesis 23 gives an entire chapter to Abraham’s purchase of a burial place for Sarah. He is a foreigner without land and the first property he ever owns in the country of promise is a grave: “I am a sojourner and foreigner among you; give me property among you for a burying place, that I may bury my dead out of my sight” (Genesis 23:4, ESV). The narrator gives us the whole transaction (the approach to the Hittites, the offer of the best of the sepulchres, Abraham bowing to the people of the land, the naming of Ephron son of Zohar, the field at Machpelah and the cave at the end of it, four hundred shekels of silver weighed out according to the weights current among the merchants, and the trees that were in the field and in all its borders round about) and settles it with care.

Jacob is carried out of Egypt to be buried with his fathers. Joseph, dying in Egypt, makes his brothers swear to carry his bones up when God brings them out: “God will surely visit you, and you shall carry up my bones from here” (Genesis 50:25, ESV). A coffin in Egypt becomes a four-hundred-year confession that God keeps promises. Moses is buried in a valley in Moab and the text adds that “no one knows the place of his burial to this day” (Deuteronomy 34:6, ESV). Devout men carry Stephen to his grave and make great lamentation over him (Acts 8:2). The first Christian martyr is not left where he fell and his church grieves audibly.

Israel’s sense of this runs deep enough that its opposite becomes a curse. Jeremiah pronounces over Jehoiakim, “With the burial of a donkey he shall be buried, dragged and dumped beyond the gates of Jerusalem” (Jeremiah 22:19, ESV). The horror is not the dying but the discarding. Amos indicts Moab for a war crime committed against a corpse, “because he burned to lime the bones of the king of Edom” (Amos 2:1, ESV). Against that, the men of Jabesh-gilead march all night to take down the bodies of Saul and his sons from the wall of Beth-shan, and bury them, and fast seven days (1 Samuel 31:11–13), an act David later goes out of his way to bless. Rachel is buried on the road to Ephrath, and Jacob “set up a pillar over her tomb. It is the pillar of Rachel’s tomb, which is there to this day” (Genesis 35:20, ESV). It was a marker, so that people would know where she was and the narrator notes centuries later that it is still standing.

The decisive example is our Lord’s own burial. Joseph of Arimathea (a member of the council) asks Pilate for the body. Nicodemus brings seventy-five pounds of myrrh and aloes. Two men of standing handle a corpse with their own hands, wrap it in linen with the spices, and lay it in a new tomb in a garden (John 19:38–42). John reports all of it in detail and the detail is the point again: the body of Jesus is treated with reverence, not disposed of. It is not treated as a thing He has finished with. Then, on the first day of the week, the women come to the tomb and do not find that Jesus has slipped out of His body into a spiritual condition. They find the tomb empty and the linen cloths lying there.

3. Burial as a confession of faith

Christian burial is more than a hygienic necessity. It is a confession, made with our hands, about what we believe concerning death and resurrection. Laying a body in the earth admits that death is real. The words over Adam are read over us: “you are dust, and to dust you shall return” (Genesis 3:19, ESV). The body formed from the ground goes back to the ground and a graveside is the one place where a congregation is not able to pretend otherwise. Christians should not want to pretend otherwise. Our hope is not a denial that this has happened.

The grave is not the end of the story, though, and the language the Church uses over it indicates such. Paul reaches for a seed:

What is sown is perishable; what is raised is imperishable. It is sown in dishonor; it is raised in glory. It is sown in weakness; it is raised in power. It is sown a natural body; it is raised a spiritual body. (1 Corinthians 15:42–44, ESV)

Paul is not teaching that the buried body contains within itself some natural power to germinate. Resurrection is God’s act, worked through Jesus Christ, and a corpse has no more capacity to raise itself than Adam’s dust had to shape itself. What the image gives us is the relationship between what goes into the ground and what comes out of it: continuity with transformation, the same body and not the same condition. In other words, the man who is buried is the man who will be raised and he will not be raised in the state in which we left him.

This is also why the Creed bothers to say that Christ was “crucified, dead, and buried.” The phrase is the Church’s insistence that He went all the way in (not merely as far as dying, but into the condition of the dead, into the grave that receives every one of us) so that there is now no part of the road ahead of us that He has not already been down. Luther’s Easter hymn puts it like this: Christ “was by God the Father given” into death, and in the grave He lay, and death is now “a form and nothing more.”⁴⁷

Baptism has already said this about him once. “We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life” (Romans 6:4, ESV). The grave is the second burial of a man who was buried with Christ at the font years earlier and the first burial is the one that determines how the second ends. The grave is therefore a place of waiting. The Christian dead are asleep in the New Testament’s favorite word for it, koimaō (“to sleep, to fall asleep”), from which we get cemetery (koimētērion, a sleeping place, a dormitory). The early Christians made that word their own for the ground they buried in and it tells you what they expected to happen there. They buried in ground of their own as soon as they could. By about the year 200 the church at Rome was keeping a cemetery of its own on the Appian Way (Hippolytus names the deacon Callistus as the man put in charge of it) and over the next two centuries the catacombs outside Rome grew into miles of galleries cut into soft rock, the dead laid in shelves along the walls with names painted or cut on the slabs that closed them and here and there an anchor, a fish, or a palm. Many began on the land of wealthier Christians who made room for poorer ones, which is why some of those cemeteries still carry the names of the families who gave them. They were not hiding places; they were graveyards, used openly and visited on anniversaries. When the Church could build above ground it kept burying its dead close (beside the church, often around it) so that a congregation walked past its grandparents on the way to hear the Word. Our own churchyards are the direct descendant of that habit and that habit was a confession: these people are not gone, they are asleep, and we intend to keep them near the place where the trumpet will be heard. The word describes the body lying in the earth and the certainty that it will be woken, not the condition of the soul, which is with Christ. (Chapter VI takes that up.)

4. The Christian funeral

A Christian funeral is first of all a service of the Word. The congregation gathers in the presence of death and it gathers around a Gospel that has something specific to say to that. Scripture is read, Christ is preached, the Church prays and sings and gives thanks and the family is given something to hold that will still hold long after the flowers have wilted and are gone.

The deceased may be remembered with gratitude. A life shared is worth naming. The danger (and it is a real danger at the funeral of a beloved member) is that the service quietly changes its subject. The eulogy grows and the Gospel shrinks. No one intends it and a congregation goes home having heard that a good woman has gone to her reward. That sounds like comfort and is in fact the Law (God’s demand rather than God’s gift), since everyone present knows privately that they would not survive the same scrutiny. No one enters eternal life for having been a devoted husband, a generous neighbor, a faithful trustee, or a beloved grandmother. We enter through Jesus Christ and the funeral sermon that says so is the only one that can comfort the man in the pew.

The Law has its place here too because death preaches it whether we do or not. Every person in that room has just been shown what he is and where he is going. What the Church adds is the announcement they cannot make for themselves: that Jesus Christ has borne their sin, gone into death ahead of them, come back, and promised the same to all who believe in Him. A Christian funeral is neither a denial of grief nor a surrender to it. It is the Church doing in the presence of the enemy what the Church does every Sunday, which is to preach Christ crucified and risen to people who need Him.

5. Preaching at a funeral

The sermon itself can sometimes cause more harm than good. The commonest failure at a funeral is a sermon with no Scripture in it or simply a set of warm observations about the deceased with a verse attached at the front of the bulletin cover. The pastor must choose a passage, preach it, and let it govern the hour. The family may have a favorite verse or pericope and it is usually worth honoring; where it will not carry a sermon, preach something that will and read theirs anyway.

Then say the person’s name and say that she died. The room already knows. The refusal to say it in plain words tells them that the Church is as frightened of this as everyone else. Say something true about her, too, and keep it to two or three sentences that are accurate and not inflated. A eulogy describing someone the family does not recognize is worse than none and the children can always tell the difference. If she was difficult, do not make her sweet. Find the true thing and say that. The discipline is this: whatever is said about her life must not be offered as the reason she is with Christ because the moment a virtue becomes a ground the sermon has changed religions. Preach to the living, since the deceased is beyond our help and was never the intended audience. In that room are people who have not been inside a church in years, people who are furious, people quietly making calculations about their own age and at least one who is dreadfully frightened. What they need is the death and resurrection of Jesus offered to the people still breathing.

Do not explain the death. You do not know why and the attempts are both untrue and cruel (she is in a better place, God needed another angel, everything happens for a reason). They are what people remember years later; chapter 2 §6 applies here. Do not press the Law, either. Death preaches it without any help from us, since every person in the room has just been shown what he is and where he is going and the preacher’s job is to answer it.

Keep it short. Twelve minutes is generous, grief shortens attention to almost nothing, and a family in the front pew is enduring rather than listening. Then end on Christ and not on the deceased: the last thing the room hears should be a promise, in the future tense, about a resurrection that has not happened yet, because that is the only sentence in the whole service that no one there can supply for himself. One more thing, for the pastor rather than for the sermon. Go to the luncheon. More real ministry happens over lunch in a church fellowship hall than in the twelve minutes you spent preparing and a family will remember for a long time whether their pastor stayed.

6. The blessing of the body and the committal

The rites around Christian burial deserve theological care because they are easily misunderstood by grieving people who are not in a condition to parse fine distinctions.

A pastor prays at the casket and commends the deceased to God’s keeping. The commendation is the prayer that gives the person back to God by name, “into your hands, O merciful Savior.” That much the Lutheran Book of Worship order for the Burial of the Dead prints and directs, and its words are worth using because of where they came from.⁴⁸ What the pastor is not doing is making the deceased holy or conducting anything that alters his relationship to God. Forgiveness and eternal life are received through faith in Jesus Christ and they are not conferred or ratified by a ceremony performed afterward.⁴⁹ A blessing over a body is not a work done for the dead. It is a confession made by the living.

That needs one qualification. We commend the dead to God (“receive him into the arms of your mercy”) and that is a prayer offered for a man who has died. The Confessions do not forbid it. The Apology says of the ancients that they spoke of prayer for the dead, “which we do not prohibit,” and refuses to side with those who called such prayers useless.⁵⁰ What it disapproves is something else entirely: the Supper applied ex opere operato on the dead man’s behalf, as though the Church held a work in its hands that could be spent on him. We may pray for our dead. We may not treat any rite as a transaction conducted over them.

Understood that way, everything done at a Christian funeral is teaching and it is worth knowing which of it the book directs and which of it the Church has simply come to do. Our rite prints the meeting of the body at the door, the remembrance of Baptism in the words of Romans 6, the commendation at the coffin, the committal at the grave, and the sign of the cross made in the blessing at the end. What it does not direct, and what we do anyway, is most of the rest of what a visitor sees: the pall, the white cloth spread over the casket, which is the Church putting the baptismal garment back on him; and the tall candle standing at the head of the coffin, the paschal candle lit at the Easter Vigil, because Easter is the whole argument. Neither is ancient. The medieval pall was a herse-cloth, often dark and often armorial and no one read it baptismally; the Easter candle was put away after Ascensiontide and did not attend funerals through the year. The white pall understood as the baptismal garment and the paschal candle standing at the coffin are recoveries of the last century and they arrived at nearly the same moment among Lutherans, Anglicans, and Rome, working from the same conviction about Baptism and Easter.

When the body is committed to the earth in the “sure and certain hope of the resurrection,” the Church is not claiming that the rite produces the resurrection. Christ raises the dead. The rite announces what He has promised over a body that cannot hear it in front of people who need to. Thanksgiving for the deceased person’s Baptism belongs here for the same reason. It moves the family’s attention off what the deceased accomplished and onto what God did, unasked, when they were an infant.

7. The Christian preference for burial

I believe traditional burial should remain the preferred Christian practice and I want to give my reasons. It is not because God requires an intact body in order to raise the dead. He does not, and section 8 says so. My reasons are that burial says with the body what we say with our mouths and that it goes on saying it after everyone has gone home.

The body is received as a gift from God. It is fed, washed, healed, and honored throughout a life. When death comes, it is handled with reverence, carried by people who loved the man, and laid in the earth to wait. There is a visible continuity between the body that sat in that pew and the body given into God’s keeping and the congregation sees that continuity. Burial also leaves something behind: a place. A cemetery is not a storage facility for the dead. It is a piece of ground where a family can stand, where children can be told who these people were, and where the two hardest facts of the Christian faith stand side by side (a grave, which says this is true of all of us, and a cross on the stone above it or marker on the ground which says this is not the end of us).

There are limits to my own argument. Scripture nowhere commands earth burial as the only permissible treatment of a Christian’s body. The Lutheran Confessions establish no such requirement and no pastor has the authority to bind a conscience where God has not bound it. Confusing a fitting practice with a divine command is exactly the error our Confessions spend so much energy resisting.⁵¹ Traditional burial may be commended warmly, taught faithfully, and chosen gladly, without any suggestion that the family who chose otherwise has sinned.

8. Cremation and the resurrection of the body

Cremation is now the majority practice in this country (it was almost unknown here a century ago) and the reasons are usually practical. It costs a fraction of what burial costs. Families are scattered and the children who would tend a grave live far away. A death comes at a bad time financially. Occasionally the reason is a conviction about the body.

The theological question is this: does cremation prevent or compromise God’s ability to raise the dead? It does not. Not in the least, not in any degree, and no Christian should carry that fear. The God who formed Adam out of the dust of the ground is not inconvenienced by ashes. Every buried body returns to dust as well; burial is slower. That is the whole of the difference and it is not a theological difference. Christians have died in fires, at sea, in mines, in wars, and in circumstances where nothing was recovered and the Church has never once suggested that the resurrection of such people is in doubt. “What is sown is perishable; what is raised is imperishable” (1 Corinthians 15:42, ESV). The power is God’s, not the corpse’s, and it does not depend on the condition of the material. Anyone who has stood at the grave of a man long dead knows that if God needed intact remains, none of us would rise. Cremation therefore cannot put a human being beyond the reach of Christ.

What remains is a different question and a real one: what does the practice say? How we treat our dead teaches, whether or not we intend it to. The early Church did prefer burial to the Roman pyre and the neighbors noticed. The pagan speaker in Minucius Felix’s dialogue complains that Christians “execrate our funeral piles, and condemn our burials by fire.” What is striking is the answer he gets. Octavius does not say that fire endangers the dead. He says, “Nor, as you believe, do we fear any loss from sepulture, but we adopt the ancient and better custom of burying in the earth.” The oldest Christian word on this subject is the one I am arguing here: the manner of burial touches nothing in God’s power and the Church buries because it is the old and better custom.⁵² If cremation were chosen as a deliberate repudiation of the resurrection or out of contempt for the body as so much used material, that intention would be contrary to the Christian confession — and I would say so to the person who said it to me. That is almost never what is happening. When cremation is chosen because a widow cannot pay what a funeral costs, the pastor who responds to her as though she had denied the Creed has misread the situation entirely and has wounded her.

Here is how I intend to go about it. I will teach the congregation why the Church has historically buried its dead and I will teach it on an ordinary Sunday rather than in the first hour after a death when nothing can be heard. When a family chooses cremation I will not treat the choice as a confession about anything. I will ask what they are planning for the remains, which is the question that actually matters, and help them plan something worthy of the person. Then I will preach the resurrection at the service exactly as I would at any other. In short: I would rather we buried our dead, but I will not stand at the door of the church and criticize anyone’s arrangements. Cremation does not prevent the resurrection and it is not, in itself, a rejection of the Christian faith.

9. The reverent treatment of cremated remains

If cremation is chosen, a question follows that our culture has almost entirely stopped asking: what is to be done with what is left? The answer is governed by the same understanding of dignity that governs everything else in this chapter. Cremated remains are not an object. They are the mortal remains of a human being who bore the image of God and for whom Christ died and they are owed reverence for the same reason a body is owed reverence.

Let me begin with what a permanent place of interment gives a family because that is the actual argument. It gives them somewhere to go. A grave, a niche in a columbarium (a wall built with small chambers for exactly this purpose), a corner of ground with a stone on it — a family can stand there, and so can grandchildren who were not born when she died and will be told her name for the first time at that spot. It lets a family say that she has died, which grief needs and does not always get. It also gives the Church one more chance to do what the Church is for: the remains may be committed with Scripture, prayer, the commendation, and the preaching of the resurrection, so that the last thing said over her is the Gospel. This is what I would counsel whether the body was buried or burned. Where the cost of a plot is out of reach, the congregation should quietly find a way and a congregation with ground of its own already has most of the answer.

I would therefore gently discourage the arrangements that leave no such place (the urn kept indefinitely on a shelf, the ashes divided among the children, the scattering over water, the formation of an article of jewelry). These choices are not made out of irreverence. They are made out of love and out of an inability to let go, which are the most understandable motives there are. The remains of a loved one are not the loved one and our bond with the dead is not preserved by keeping physical custody of them.

Some of you scattered your father’s ashes years ago because it was what he asked for or divided them because there were several of you and one urn or have had him on a shelf for years because no one could bear to be the one who decided. If you have been reading this section with a knot in your stomach, let it go. Scripture gives no command here, the Confessions give none, and a preference of mine is not a law over anyone’s conscience. You did not put your father beyond the reach of Christ and you did not lose him. God has never needed our help keeping track of His people and on the last day He will not be searching. Your father will be raised from wherever he is. We do not need to hold on to the ashes in order to hold on to the promise. The counsel above is for the family standing in a funeral home this week with the decision still in front of them. It is not a verdict on the family that already made it. If yours is one of the ones still sitting on a shelf, then the decision is still in front of you too and unfinished things can be finished. Come and ask. It takes very little to arrange, it can be done quietly with a few people, and it finishes something that has been open for a long time.

10. The body given away: autopsy, donation, and medical science

Families are asked these questions at the worst possible moment, usually with no preparation, and usually by a stranger.

An autopsy does not injure a person and does not touch his resurrection. It is sometimes required by law and it is sometimes the only way a family learns what actually happened, which can matter enormously to the living and occasionally to the children who inherit the same condition. A Christian family may consent without misgiving. What they may reasonably ask is that the body be treated with care and returned to them for burial and any competent examiner will regard that as ordinary.

Organ and tissue donation is a genuine good and I would encourage it. A cornea, a kidney, a liver: these are the Fifth Commandment’s positive half (helping and supporting a neighbor in every bodily need) performed on a scale our great-grandparents could not have imagined, by a man who will not be inconvenienced by the giving, for a neighbor he will never meet. The objection sometimes raised, that God requires the body intact, has already been answered in section 8 and is answered again here: He does not. Greater love hath no man than this, and the donor is usually a young person whose family is having the worst day of its life and consents anyway. The family that said no did nothing wrong, either. There is no command here either, the decision is made in a hallway with little time and no sleep and anyone still churning through the decision should let it go.

Donation of the whole body to a medical school is harder. It is a real gift: physicians have to learn anatomy on someone and every surgeon who has ever helped a member of this congregation learned on a body that a family gave. What gives me pause is what happens afterward. The body may be held for a year or more, and what comes back, if anything comes back, is usually cremated remains, sometimes commingled, sometimes with no service at all. That is not a sin. It is a loss, and it is a loss of exactly the thing sections 7 and 9 argue for: a place, a service, a Gospel spoken over what is left. My counsel is therefore practical rather than prohibitive. If you intend to do this, arrange the ending in advance. Ask the school what its practice is, whether the remains are returned and when, and whether the family may take them. Tell your pastor and plan the committal now, so that when the year is up someone knows to gather the family at a graveside and read the promises.

11. Suicide, and what the Church says over that grave

The question is asked at almost every funeral of this kind, usually by someone who cannot get the words out. Let me begin with what the Church has sometimes done and should not do again. There were centuries in which a suicide was denied Christian burial, buried outside the churchyard wall or at a crossroads and his family left to carry the verdict along with the grief. That practice was meant to deter and whatever it deterred it certainly punished. It punished the wrong people, since the dead man was past deterrence.

Two things have to be held together. The first is that we do not pretend. Suicide is contrary to the Fifth Commandment, which forbids the taking of innocent life and does not make an exception for one’s own. A man’s life is not his property to end any more than his neighbor’s is. To say otherwise, however kindly meant, would be to abandon the commandment precisely where a suffering person most needs to hear it and there are people in every congregation who are closer to that edge than anyone knows. The second is that we do not presume. We do not know what was in that mind. Severe depression, psychosis, the derangement of pain or of a drug: these are illnesses of the mind itself and a man in their grip is not making a free judgment in any sense we would recognize. The Church has never had the authority to declare who is lost and it does not acquire that authority by standing at a hard graveside. Our Confessions teach us to judge doctrine, not hearts. We may say what the commandment says; we may not say where this man is because we were not told and we do not know.

What we can say is what we always say. This man was baptized. God put His name on him and made promises to him that were never conditioned on how he died. Christ died for the sin of the whole world, including this one, and the mercy of God is not a narrower thing than we had thought. Therefore we bury him with the full rites of the Church, we preach Christ over him as we would over anyone, and we commend him to the God who knows what we do not.

If you are the one who found him or the one who did not answer the phone that evening or the one who has spent years going back over the last conversation hunting for the sentence that would have changed it, hear this: You did not do this. Whatever you did actually get wrong in those years (and there will be something, because between any two people there always is), Christ died for it and there is nothing left of it for you to pay. If you cannot believe this, bring it to me and I will say it to you openly.

If you are the other one — if you are reading this at an hour when nothing looks survivable and you have got as far as working out who would find you — then hear the rest of it before you put this book down. Your life is not a burden God is enduring. He made it, He bought it with His Son’s blood, and He is not finished with you. Tell someone tonight, tonight and not tomorrow. Tell me. I will not be shocked. I will keep what you tell me as carefully as I can, but if your life is in danger I will get you help. If you cannot reach me, call or text 988, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, at any hour of the day or night. If you are in immediate danger, call 911.

One more thing, and this part is for the congregation rather than the family. We go quiet around this death. We do it out of tact and it does not land as tact. It lands on a widow as though her husband had been struck out of the parochial records and it means the one person everybody in the building is thinking about is the one person no one will name. Say his name. Say it to her at the mailbox or in the parking lot, years later if that is where you are. Not knowing what to say is no reason to say nothing and she is not waiting for the right thing. She is waiting to hear that someone besides her still remembers he existed. Then we stay with the family long after the funeral because this grief is unlike the others. It comes mixed with guilt, with anger that has nowhere to go, and with the unanswerable question, and the people carrying it are at elevated risk themselves.

12. When the body cannot be recovered

Sometimes there is nothing to bury. A man is lost at sea, or in a fire, or in a building that came down, or in a war on the other side of the world. Families bear a particular anguish in these cases: the absence of a body denies them the evidence their grief needs and some of them wait years without ever quite being able to begin.

The Church’s word to them is that the dignity of their dead is not diminished and his resurrection is not in question. Christian hope has never rested on our ability to locate, preserve, or bury a body. The Lord who calls every star by name and numbers the hairs of our heads is not at a loss. Isaiah’s God says to His people, “Behold, I have engraved you on the palms of my hands” (Isaiah 49:16, ESV), a more durable record than any cemetery keeps. A memorial service should be held regardless. The Gospel is proclaimed, the bereaved are prayed for, the person is commended to God’s mercy, and the congregation does with words what it could not do with a casket. The absence of a body is not the absence of hope and families in this situation often need to be told that in so many words.

13. What to arrange before you need it

The material in this chapter is nearly useless to a family learning it for the first time on the worst morning of their lives. Here is what to settle while nothing is wrong. None of it is commanded by God. No one has ever sinned by dying with nothing written down and a family left to guess is not being punished for an omission. This is love and forethought, not law, and I would far rather you did it badly this month than perfectly never.

Write down what you want and tell two people which drawer it is in (not a safe deposit box, which cannot always be opened until after the funeral). That happens more often than anyone would believe. Say whether you wish to be buried or cremated and where. This is the single most common thing families fight about and the fight is never really about the method; it is about a son far away who was not consulted, and it turns bitter because everyone involved has not slept. One sentence in your own handwriting ends an argument that has not started yet. If you are to be buried, settle the plot while you can (where it is, whether it is paid for, and who else is already in it), because families discover at the worst possible time that a plot purchased decades ago has no record, or has two spaces and three people who expected to use them. If you are to be cremated, say what is to become of the remains and when. That is the step our generation routinely omits and it is exactly how an urn ends on a shelf for a decade with no one willing to be the one who decides.

Choose the hymns and the texts. Three hymns and a psalm is plenty, and pick things a congregation can actually sing. Say what you want done with the body in the meantime, too (whether you wish to be embalmed, whether there is to be a viewing, whether the casket is open or closed). There is no right answer, families disagree sharply about viewings, and your preference settles it. And tell your family whether you want your pastor called before you die rather than after. Most people assume the call is a courtesy paid afterward. It is not a courtesy and chapter 4 §10 describes what he comes to do, which he cannot do once you have gone.

Then put it away and stop thinking about it. The point of settling this is to be finished with the logistics so that when the hour comes the people who love you can attend to you instead of to a funeral director’s checklist.

14. The dignity of the dead and the comfort of the living

What the Church does with the dead serves two purposes and they are meant to be held together. The first is reverence for the deceased as a human being God created and Christ redeemed. The second is the proclamation of Christ’s promises to the living, who need them more than the dead do. Separate the two and each one fails. A funeral that handles the body beautifully and never preaches the Gospel has given a family a fine ceremony and withheld the one thing the Church had. A funeral that preaches the resurrection of the body while treating the body itself as an inconvenience to be processed has contradicted its own sermon in front of everybody.

Our words and our hands should be saying the same thing at the same time and when a congregation gets that right the family notices without being able to say what they noticed. What they have noticed is that someone believes this and that is worth more to them in that week than anything we could explain.


⁴⁷ Luther, “Christ Jesus Lay in Death’s Strong Bands” (Christ lag in Todesbanden, 1524), LW 53:255–257. The third stanza is the one quoted: Christ has taken from death its own right and power — all sein Recht und sein Gewalt — so that “an empty form alone remains; his sting is lost forever.” The second stanza says the opposite, that no one could overcome death, which “ever grew more strong and bold.” Stanza numbering follows Luther’s full text; the cento at TLH 195 numbers differently and omits his third stanza. The English phrases are the Massie translation as the hymnals carry it. ⁴⁸ Lutheran Book of Worship (Minneapolis and Philadelphia: Augsburg Publishing House and Board of Publication, Lutheran Church in America, 1978), “Burial of the Dead,” a rite still used in many Lutheran congregations. Its committal — “In sure and certain hope of the resurrection to eternal life through our Lord Jesus Christ… earth to earth, ashes to ashes, dust to dust” — descends from Thomas Cranmer’s Burial of the Dead in the Book of Common Prayer of 1549, revised 1552 and settled 1662, and its commendation is the American Prayer Book’s restored form; see Appendix E. The pall and the paschal candle are customary alongside the printed rite rather than directed by its rubrics. ⁴⁹ AC IV; AC XXIV 21–30 and Ap XXIV 89, 92, on the rejection of rites understood as works performed on behalf of the dead. The Lutheran Reformation’s objection to Masses for the dead is doctrinal, not aesthetic, and it governs how we explain what a blessing at the casket is and is not. ⁵⁰ Ap XXIV 89, 92, 94, 96. Paragraph 94: “we know that the ancients speak of prayer for the dead, which we do not prohibit; but we disapprove of the application ex opere operato of the Lord’s Supper on behalf of the dead.” Paragraph 96 declines to follow Aerius, who held prayers for the dead useless. ⁵¹ AC XV 1–2 and AC XXVIII 30–52; FC SD X 1–2 for the definition of ceremonies neither commanded nor forbidden by God, and FC SD X 9 for the congregation’s liberty to change them and the refusal to burden consciences with them as though they were. FC SD X is an article about church ceremonies under the pressure of the Interim, so it governs a question like this one by extension rather than directly; AC XV and AC XXVIII carry the weight. ⁵² Minucius Felix, Octavius 11, is a hostile witness — the pagan Caecilius complaining that Christians “execrate our funeral piles, and condemn our burials by fire” — and Octavius 34 is the Christian answer quoted above. Tertullian, On the Resurrection of the Flesh 1, mocks the pagan inconsistency of burning the dead and then feasting them. The list of devouring fires, waters of the sea, maws of beasts, crops of birds and stomachs of fishes at De res. 4 is the sceptic’s cavil, which Tertullian is reciting in order to answer; his own answer comes at De res. 32 — “Even Unburied Bodies Will Be Raised Again. Whatever Befalls Them God Will Restore Them” — and again at 63, where the flesh is not dissolved into fire and water and beasts but only “poured into them, as into vessels.” Augustine’s City of God I.12–13 and his On the Care of the Dead (c. 421) argue the balance this section tries to keep: burial rites are a comfort and a witness to the living, and God’s power to raise the dead is in no way dependent upon them. Augustine is cited here for what he says about burial and the living, not for the whole of De cura, in which he also holds that the departed are aided by the prayers and alms of the Church (De cura 1–2, 6, 22). Note that De cura 3–5 is Augustine quoting his own City of God I.12–13, so the two citations here are one argument rather than two independent witnesses. Our Confessions make the distinction he is reaching for — prayer for the dead is not forbidden, but the Supper is not a work applied on their behalf (Ap XXIV 94).

Topics
Death and Grief
Scripture
Genesis 23:1–20Genesis 50:24–25Deuteronomy 34:5–6John 19:38–42Acts 8:2Romans 6:3–51 Corinthians 15:35–571 Corinthians 15:26Romans 5:12Genesis 23:4Genesis 50:25Deuteronomy 34:6Jeremiah 22:19Amos 2:11 Samuel 31:11–13Genesis 35:20Genesis 3:191 Corinthians 15:42–44Romans 6:41 Corinthians 15:42Isaiah 49:16
Confessions
AC IVAC XXIVAp XXIVAC XVAC XXVIIISD X

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.