Books · On the Dignity of the Human Being
Life Embodied: The Human Body as God's Good Creation
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Scripture: Genesis 2:7; Psalm 8:3–5; John 1:14; Romans 12:1; 1 Corinthians 6:19–20; 2 Corinthians 12:9
1. We are not souls trapped in bodies
There is a way of talking about ourselves that sounds pious (it is not). We speak as though the real person is the soul and the body is a temporary container he is issued at birth and returns at death (useful for a while, of no lasting significance and gladly left behind). Funeral homes, who are generally kind to us and who did not invent the problem, have adopted this language almost universally (“she is not really in there”) and Christians repeat it without noticing that it is not our confession. It is the Greeks’ and Plato could have written it.
Scripture does not allow it. God formed the man from the dust and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, “and the man became a living creature” (Genesis 2:7, ESV). The Hebrew is nephesh chayyah (“a living being, a living soul”) and the syntax matters: the man does not receive a soul as a separate item added to the clay. The man, dust and breath together, becomes a living soul; the whole creature, and not a part of him, is what the word describes. Scripture uses the same phrase of the animals so I will not rest the dignity of man on the words themselves (that rests on the image of God and on the breath God breathed into this creature and no other). What the verse settles is the shape of the creature. Body and soul together are the one human being God made and death, which tears them apart, is an outrage precisely because it severs what God joined.
This is why the Christian faith is so physical. In Holy Baptism water is applied to a body along with the Word. In the Lord’s Supper Christ gives us His true body and blood to eat and to drink for the forgiveness of sins.¹⁶ We are not a religion that regards matter as beneath God’s attention, because God has never regarded matter as beneath His attention. He made it, He called it good, He works through it, and in the fullness of time He took it up into Himself: “And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us” (John 1:14, ESV). Jesus Christ had a real body. He had a body His mother had fed and washed and worried over. He was hungry and thirsty, He grew tired, He bled, and He died, and the Church has always understood that a merely apparent humanity would have redeemed nothing.¹⁷ When He rose, He rose bodily. He ate fish in front of the disciples to prove it. The body is therefore God’s good gift, even now, even as our bodies carry the damage of sin and move toward the grave.
The Fathers fought this out early because among the earliest serious challenges the Church faced were those who denied that Christ had truly come in the flesh. There were men who could accept that God had appeared among us and could not accept that He had been born, fed, and buried, and they solved the problem by making His body a mere appearance. The Church’s answer was not a compromise. Ignatius of Antioch, writing on his way to be killed, insists that Christ was “truly born, and did eat and drink… truly persecuted under Pontius Pilate… truly crucified,” and adds “truly raised from the dead.”¹⁸ Irenaeus took the argument further and drew out what it means for us. If the flesh cannot be saved, he says, then the Lord did not redeem us with His blood, the cup of the Eucharist is not communion in His blood and the bread is not communion in His body. The whole economy collapses at once. Against every spiritualizing of salvation he insisted that what God made, God saves: this flesh, the one that gets hungry and sick and eventually dies.¹⁹
Tertullian gave the argument its best-known sentence: caro salutis est cardo, the flesh is the hinge of salvation.²⁰ A hinge is the thing on which the door swings and without it the door is a mere board leaning against a wall. His point is that everything God does for us He does through the body and he runs the whole sequence: the flesh is washed that the soul may be cleansed, anointed that the soul may be consecrated, signed with the cross that the soul may be fortified, overshadowed by the laying on of hands that the soul may be illuminated by the Spirit, and fed on the body and blood of Christ that the soul may be fattened on God. Our salvation does not bypass our bodies. It comes through them, every time, because that is how God chose to do it.
I do not know a place in the Confessions where this is put more forcefully than the Formula’s first article where it distinguishes between our nature and the sin that corrupts it. Original sin is not the substance of what we are; the human nature, even fallen, remains God’s creature and God’s workmanship, which is why the Son of God could assume it without assuming sin, and why God will raise it rather than replace it.²¹ In other words, sin has corrupted our nature but it has not made it someone else’s.
2. God’s ordinary way of reaching you is physical
Follow Tertullian’s hinge into our own practice and you find the reason Lutherans are so stubborn about the means of grace. God could have chosen to deal with us inwardly, privately, spirit to spirit, without water or bread or the sound of the pastor’s voice. He did not. He binds Himself to physical things and to the words of ordinary men so that we may have something outside ourselves to hold on to. The catechisms make the reason explicit. Without the Word, Luther says, water is water and no Baptism at all; with the Word it is “a gracious water of life and a washing of regeneration in the Holy Spirit,” and the Large Catechism presses the same point at length: it is “not only natural water, but a divine, heavenly, holy, and blessed water… all on account of the Word.”²² The power is in the Word and the Word has been joined to water you can feel on your forehead.
Luther will not let this be softened into symbolism. In the Supper, the body and blood of Christ are given “under the bread and wine, for us Christians to eat and to drink,” and the benefit is stated in the catechism: “forgiveness of sins, life, and salvation.”²³ A body is being given to a body. Whatever a Christian thinks about his own flesh on a bad morning, on Sunday he opens his mouth and God puts something in it.
This is why the Church has never been able to treat the physical as spiritually indifferent and it is why the arguments of this book about the sick, the old, and the dead are not sentimental additions to the faith, because they follow from where God has chosen to meet us.
3. The body is to be cared for, not worshiped
Because the body is God’s creation, we owe it ordinary care: food, rest, cleanliness, medical treatment, and a reasonable unwillingness to endanger our lives for no good purpose. This is stewardship and Luther (who had no patience for false spirituality about the body) treated neglect of one’s own health as tempting God and warned that it could make a man “a suicide in God’s eyes.”²⁴
Luther’s fullest treatment of this came out of a plague year and it is the most useful thing he wrote on the Christian and the body. In 1527 pastors in Breslau wrote to ask whether a Christian might flee or whether flight betrayed a lack of faith, and the plague reached Wittenberg itself while he was answering. His answer refuses both of the easy positions. A man with no duty binding him to a place may go, and should, because God gave him a body to look after and medicine to use and to neglect either is to tempt God. A man bound by office or by love, though (a pastor, a magistrate, a parent, a neighbor with a sick man next door), stays and takes the risk and does not let anyone call the staying foolish. Then Luther gets very practical — take the medicine and do not sneer at the physician who prescribed it, fumigate the house and the yard and the street if the street will let you, help purify the air, keep away from the places where you are not needed and go at once to the places where you are, and when you do go help your neighbor in the manner you would want helping if it were your own house with the door shut and the mark on it and no one coming up the walk.²⁵
What holds the two halves together is that the body is not the self’s property, to spend or to hoard as it pleases. It is a trust. You care for it because God gave it, you will spend it when your neighbor’s need requires it and neither the caring nor the spending is the measure of your standing before God.
Stewardship is not the same thing as the pursuit of physical perfection and our culture has thoroughly confused the two. Appearance, youth, strength, and longevity have become goods pursued as though they were ultimate and a person may spend years and a fortune trying to hold off the visible evidence of age while his marriage, his children, his vocation, and his faith go untended. The body is a gift. It is not a god and it fails everyone who has ever relied on it. Health is a blessing and it is not the source of anyone’s dignity. A man who runs every morning is not worth more than a man who cannot walk. A woman who lives to be a hundred is not thereby more faithful than a woman who dies at forty. Sickness is not the evidence of failure. Some illness follows from our own choices and much of it follows from genetics, infection, injury, age, and circumstances no one controls.
4. Illness does not diminish human dignity
Consider a man who worked long hours for many years, provided for a family, ushered on Sunday, and could be counted on to shovel the walk of anyone on his street when the snow fell. A neurological disease takes his legs. In time it takes his hands, then his speech, and finally his ability to eat without help. Has he become less human? The answer is no and the answer has to be no. His circumstances have changed. He has not. He is the same creature God made, the same man Christ died for, and the same neighbor he was when he was shoveling the walk.
The Apostle Paul was given an affliction that God declined to remove and the answer he received is the one we hand to every sufferer since: “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness” (2 Corinthians 12:9, ESV). This does not make suffering good and it does not make medical treatment faithless. It means that weakness is not a place outside the reach of God’s grace. The Gospel directs us to a Redeemer who did not save us by a display of strength but by being beaten, condemned, and nailed to a cross while onlookers remarked that He could not even save Himself. Christians have no grounds for despising the weak.
5. The body and the Christian life
“You are not your own, for you were bought with a price. So glorify God in your body” (1 Corinthians 6:19–20, ESV). In its setting Paul is addressing sexual immorality and the Christian’s bodily union with Christ and the argument turns on this: your body is not a neutral instrument because it has been purchased and by the reckoning of the Creed’s Second Article, as Luther explains it, the purchase price was “not with gold or silver, but with His holy, precious blood and with His innocent suffering and death.”²⁶ What you do with your body is therefore never a private matter between you and your preferences. Our obedience, our service, our marriages, our friendships, and our worship are all bodily and the Christian is called to honor God in the body rather than in some interior region where nothing can be seen.
The Confessions handle this same ground under the Sixth Commandment. Luther’s explanation is a positive charge: that we “lead a sexually pure and decent life in what we say and do, and husband and wife love and honor each other.”²⁷ The Large Catechism then treats marriage as an estate God instituted and defends and treats the chastity commanded here as the ordinary condition of a body that already belongs to someone besides itself. What is forbidden is forbidden because a person is not a thing.
That obligation also turns outward. If my body is not mine to use as I please, then my neighbor’s body is certainly not mine to use as I please. This forbids sexual exploitation, violence, and every arrangement in which a human being becomes a thing for another’s gratification or profit. Dignity sets limits on what we may do to people even when we have the power, the money, or the authority to do it, and those limits do not relax because the other person is weaker, poorer, younger, or dependent on us, since Christian freedom is the freedom to serve the neighbor.²⁸
6. What to say about suffering and what not to say
No chapter on the body can avoid this. Do not tell a suffering person that God sent this to teach him something. You do not know that, Scripture does not license the guess, and our Lord refused the inference when it was put to Him directly about a man born blind. Do not tell him that everything happens for a reason; that is a sentence about fate. Do not tell him that God will not give him more than he can handle, a misapplication of a verse about temptation that is untrue as a statement about suffering, since God regularly permits His people more than they can handle in order that they may stop handling it. Above all, do not tell him he would be better if he had more faith. That is the cruelest sentence a person can speak and it is always false. What can be said is this:
First, that his suffering is not a verdict. Job’s friends held the position that suffering implies guilt and the book exists in large part to demolish it. Whatever a man is going through, his suffering does not authorize us to pronounce God’s judgment upon him or to name some particular sin for which he is being punished.
Second, that God is not indifferent to it. The Incarnation is decisive here. The Son of God knows bodily weakness, hunger, exhaustion, pain, and death because He experienced them in His own flesh, and He did not observe suffering from a distance. He went through it with the added horror of knowing He could have stopped it at any moment and choosing not to.
Third, that God is at work in it without our being able to say that He sent it. The tradition has a distinction here that I would not want to be without: God’s alien work (the strange, contrary, wounding work He takes no delight in) serves His proper work, which is to save. He does not stand outside our affliction and Scripture says that He chastises those He loves. What we may not do is reverse that and tell a particular man that his particular cancer was sent to him for a particular lesson. We do not know that. We do know that He has promised to work all things together for good to those who love Him, and that the working is usually invisible at the time and understood only afterward, if at all.
Fourth (and this is Luther’s characteristic move), that God is most reliably found where we would least think to look. A theologian of glory expects to find Him in strength, success, and visible blessing and ends by calling evil good and good evil. A theologian of the cross says to look for God in suffering and the cross, where He has chosen to hide Himself.²⁹ That is a claim about where to look while suffering lasts and it is the reason a Lutheran pastor at a bedside points to a crucifix.
Fifth, and this is the one to have by heart. Read Romans 8. Not a summary of it. Read the text, aloud, from verse 31 to the end. It is a list of what cannot separate him from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord: not death, not life, not angels, not rulers, not things present, not things to come, not powers, not height, not depth, nor anything else in all creation. It was written to be read to frightened people and it still works on them.
Last, that it ends. Not necessarily here (Paul asked three times and was refused), but it ends. Chapters V and VI are about that and everything in this chapter about the failing body is written in their light.
7. When the body cannot be healed
Medicine is one of God’s great mercies. Diseases that emptied villages are now prevented by vaccination. Injuries that once meant a lifetime of disability can now be repaired. Pain that once had to be endured can usually be relieved. Christians receive all of it with thanks and the physician does God’s work whether or not he knows it.
Medicine cannot abolish death. Every human body eventually reaches the end of what treatment can do and at that point the temptation is to conclude that a body which cannot be restored has become worthless. It has not. Care remains possible long after cure is gone. A physician who can no longer remove a disease can still remove pain. A daughter who cannot give her father back his strength can still give him food, clean sheets, a shave, and good company. A pastor who can no longer converse with a parishioner who has stopped responding can still pray, read the Psalms aloud at the bedside, and speak the promises of Christ.
¹⁶ SC, Baptism; SC, Sacrament of the Altar; LC IV and V. ¹⁷ AC III; Gregory of Nazianzus, Epistle 101 (To Cledonius), written against Apollinarius: “that which He has not assumed He has not healed.” The principle stands behind the confessional insistence on a true and complete humanity in Christ. ¹⁸ Ignatius of Antioch, To the Trallians 9–10 and To the Smyrnaeans 1–3, written on the road to Rome and to his execution. Chapter 9 gives the fivefold “truly”; chapter 10 names the party — “if, as some that are without God… say, that He only seemed to suffer, then why am I in bonds?” ¹⁹ Irenaeus, Against Heresies V.2.2 — if the flesh is incapable of salvation, then neither did the Lord redeem us with His blood, nor is the cup of the Eucharist the communion of His blood. ANF vol. 1. ²⁰ Tertullian, On the Resurrection of the Flesh 8.2. The Latin is caro salutis est cardo; ANF renders it “the flesh is the very condition on which salvation hinges,” and “the flesh is the hinge of salvation” is the common English rendering used here. The sequence has five members in Tertullian, not four — washing, anointing, signing, the laying on of hands, and feeding — and all five are given above. ANF vol. 3. ²¹ FC SD I 29, 33, 44, 46 (Original Sin), which distinguishes the nature God created and will raise from the corruption that clings to it — SD I 44 argues that the Son of God could not have assumed our nature were the two identical, and SD I 46 that God will raise “the substance of this our flesh, but without sin.” See also FC Ep I. ²² SC, Holy Baptism, Third Part, for the first quotation; LC IV 17 for the second, with LC IV 14 to the same effect (“not mere ordinary water, but water comprehended in God’s Word and command… God’s Word and command are added”). ²³ SC, Sacrament of the Altar, First and Second Parts. ²⁴ The inference is from LC I 186–192, which is neighbor-directed throughout; the claim itself rests on Luther, Whether One May Flee from a Deadly Plague (1527), LW 43:119–138, where the duty to preserve one’s own life and the duty to risk it for the neighbor are held together. ²⁵ Luther, Whether One May Flee from a Deadly Plague (1527), LW 43:119–138. The treatise is cited again here because it is the fullest thing Luther wrote on the care of one’s own body and the neighbor’s together. ²⁶ SC, Creed, Second Article. ²⁷ SC, Ten Commandments, Sixth Commandment; LC I 199–221 on marriage as an estate God instituted and defends. ²⁸ Luther, The Freedom of a Christian (1520), LW 31:343–377 (the Open Letter to Leo X runs 334–343; 327–333 is the editor’s introduction): the Christian is “a perfectly free lord of all, subject to none,” and “a perfectly dutiful servant of all, subject to all.” ²⁹ Luther, Heidelberg Disputation (1518), theses 19–21: “That person does not deserve to be called a theologian who looks upon the invisible things of God as though they were clearly perceptible… He deserves to be called a theologian, however, who comprehends the visible and manifest things of God seen through suffering and the cross… A theologian of glory calls evil good and good evil. A theologian of the cross calls the thing what it actually is.” LW 31:40–41, 52–53. Luther writes theologus, not theologia — the person, not the discipline. On thesis 20, LW renders posteriora Dei as “the visible and manifest things of God”; the sense is God’s rearward parts (Exodus 33:23), and the rendering is disputed.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.