Books · On the Dignity of the Human Being
Life Received: The Sanctity of Human Life from Conception
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
Scripture: Genesis 1:26–27; Psalm 139:13–16; Psalm 127:3; Luke 1:39–45; Exodus 20:13
1. Human life is a gift, not a possession
God is the author and giver of life and the Christian confesses this before he confesses anything else about himself. “I believe in God, the Father Almighty, maker of heaven and earth” is not a statement about cosmology. It is a statement about where I came from and Luther’s explanation of it in the Small Catechism refuses to let me take credit for a single part of myself. Body, soul, senses, reason, and the daily preservation of all of them are named as gifts and the confession ends with the reason: “All this He does only out of fatherly, divine goodness and mercy, without any merit or worthiness in me.”⁵
It is interesting what that does to the question of worth. Before I could speak, reason, work, or decide anything, I was already a recipient. My existence was never my accomplishment and nothing I have accomplished since has made me more of a creature than I was in the first moment of conception.
Scripture returns to this more often than we notice and it returns often using the word craft. God does not merely permit a human being to come into existence; He works on him, the way a man works on something he intends to keep.
Job, in the middle of an argument with God, says it as an accusation:
Your hands fashioned and made me… Remember that you have made me like clay; and will you return me to the dust? Did you not pour me out like milk and curdle me like cheese? You clothed me with skin and flesh, and knit me together with bones and sinews. You have granted me life and steadfast love, and your care has preserved my spirit. (Job 10:8–12, ESV)
Jeremiah is told something stranger still: “Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, and before you were born I consecrated you” (Jeremiah 1:5, ESV). Isaiah’s Servant says, “The LORD called me from the womb, from the body of my mother he named my name” (Isaiah 49:1, ESV). Paul says it of himself — that God “had set me apart before I was born” (Galatians 1:15, ESV). None of these attempt to explain biology. Yet, what they have in common is a settled assumption: God’s dealings with a person begin before anyone else’s do.
The Psalmist says the same thing from inside the womb:
For you formed my inward parts; you knitted me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. … My frame was not hidden from you, when I was being made in secret, intricately woven in the depths of the earth. Your eyes saw my unformed substance. (Psalm 139:13–16, ESV)
The child in the womb is unseen by the world but not unseen by God. That is the point of the passage. He is praising and praise is the stronger position; the doctrine is simply assumed underneath it.
The Christian understanding of dignity therefore does not begin at birth when a child first becomes visible to the rest of us. Neither does it begin at the point where the child can think, feel, communicate, or survive on his own. Those are milestones in a human life, not the qualifications for having one. Conception marks the beginning of a new human being and that human being is to be received with love and protected from deliberate destruction, regardless of his health, his development, or what anyone expects him to become. A child who will be born with a disability (e.g. Down syndrome, spina bifida, a heart that will need three surgeries) is no less human than a child who will not. A child whose life will be measured in hours is no less worthy of love than a child who will see a hundred years.
2. Three answers the world gives, and why none of them will hold
Before going further it is worth setting the Christian answer beside the alternatives because the alternatives are not going away. Most people who disagree with what this book argues hold one of three positions, usually without having chosen it.
The first grounds dignity in usefulness. A person’s worth is a function of what he contributes: to his family, his employer, the economy, the common good. This has the advantage of being measurable and the disadvantage of being true about tools rather than people. It also has a terminus that no one says aloud: if worth rises with contribution, it falls with contribution and every one of us is headed for the far end of that curve. The position cannot say why a man with advanced dementia should not be quietly disposed of and the honest exponents of it eventually admit as much.
The second grounds dignity in capacity — in self-awareness, rationality, the ability to form preferences and to have a stake in one’s own future. This is the more sophisticated position and it is the one arising mostly within contemporary bioethics. Its difficulty is that capacities come and go. They are absent in the newborn, suspended in the sleeping and the anesthetized, diminished in the injured, and gone in the demented, and a doctrine of human worth that is dictated by an EEG is not a doctrine of human worth at all. It is a doctrine of human function alone.
The third grounds dignity in autonomy — in the capacity to choose, so that what makes a life valuable is that it is mine and subject to my own decisions. This is the most attractive of the three because it sounds like freedom, because it locates worth in precisely the faculty that suffering takes away first. Follow it far enough and you arrive at its logical conclusion: a man whose choices have been narrowed by illness is offered the one choice still available to him and calls it dignity.
Set the Christian answer beside these and the difference lies in where the weight rests. Usefulness, capacity, and autonomy all locate worth inside the person, in something he has and can therefore lose. Scripture locates it outside him entirely in the God who made him, in the Son who assumed his nature and bought him, and in the promise to raise him. That is why the Christian answer does not move when the man does. Nothing has been said about his abilities at all.
Luther makes the point in an unexpected place. Writing about how God’s love differs from ours he says that human love comes into being through what is pleasing to it. In other words, we love what is already lovely, useful, attractive while the love of God does not find but creates its object, loving what is not lovely in order to make it so. It is one of the most useful sentences he ever wrote for a hospital room.⁶ Our love follows worth. God’s love confers it. Anyone whose worth depends on being found valuable is in trouble; anyone whose worth depends on being loved by God is not.
3. Christ entered human life through the womb
The Incarnation grounds this more deeply than any argument from development can. When the eternal Son of God became man, He was conceived by the Holy Spirit and born of the Virgin Mary and He came into human existence in the ordinary manner, though His conception was not ordinary and He had no human father. The Son of God has truly entered our condition. He did not appear to be human; He became human and He became human the way the rest of us do.
Luke gives us the scene:
And when Elizabeth heard the greeting of Mary, the baby leaped in her womb. And Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit, and she exclaimed with a loud cry, “Blessed are you among women, and blessed is the fruit of your womb! And why is this granted to me that the mother of my Lord should come to me? For behold, when the sound of your greeting came to my ears, the baby in my womb leaped for joy.” (Luke 1:41–44, ESV)
I want to be careful here. Luke is not giving us an essay on prenatal development. Instead, he is bearing witness to the identity of Jesus Christ and the fulfillment of God’s promises. That is what the passage is for. Yet it says something else also. The unborn Christ is already the Lord whom Elizabeth confesses and the unborn John is already the prophet through whom God is at work. Two hidden children are the whole action of the scene and the Holy Spirit is the one narrating it.
Three things in that scene reward a second look. The first is who does the recognizing. Elizabeth is filled with the Holy Spirit and only then speaks, which means the confession “the mother of my Lord” is not her inference from Mary’s appearance. It is revealed. No one looking at two pregnant women in the hill country would have concluded anything. The second is the word Luke chooses for John. The baby leaped (the verb is used in the Greek Old Testament of the leaping of lambs and of David dancing before the ark) and Elizabeth interprets it: “the baby in my womb leaped for joy.” Luke is describing the forerunner doing his office from inside his mother, six months before anyone could see him. That is a strange thing to assert about a creature the world would not yet have called a person. The third is Mary’s answer, which the Church has sung during Vespers for fifteen centuries. The Magnificat is a song about a God who scatters the proud, brings down the mighty from their thrones, exalts the humble, fills the hungry with good things, and sends the rich away empty. All sung by an unmarried teenager in an occupied province who has just been handed a pregnancy that could get her killed. Luther called it a song for the lowly and observed that God looked not at Mary’s merit but at her nothingness. That is the same argument this book has been making about every human being in it.⁷
4. What the Church said when the world disagreed
It is worth knowing that this is not a recent Christian position taken up in reaction to modern medicine. The Church has held it from the beginning. Greco-Roman antiquity practiced both abortion and the exposure of unwanted infants, and neither was regarded as remarkable. A father could decline to acknowledge a newborn; the child was then set outside and what happened next, happened. Against that, the earliest Christian instruction we possess outside the New Testament says, in a list of commands for new converts: “you shall not murder a child by abortion, nor kill that which is begotten.”⁸ The Epistle of Barnabas has the same pairing. The anonymous Epistle to Diognetus describes Christians to an outsider in the same terms, “They marry, as do all others; they beget children; but they do not destroy their offspring” and Athenagoras says it while answering the charge that Christians were murderers, as does Tertullian in his own defense of the faith.⁹ The Church arrived at this by reading the Fifth Commandment and it kept saying so for three centuries while it had no power whatever to make anyone agree.
Two things follow that matter for us. The first is that when a Christian today says the unborn child is a neighbor, he is not defending a novelty. He is saying what the Church said before it was legal to be a Christian at all. The second is more sobering. The early Church did not only forbid exposure. In time it took the care of foundlings on itself, until a council at Vaison in 442 could simply direct that whoever found an abandoned child report it to the church and that the finding be announced at the altar the next Sunday.
5. The unborn child is our neighbor
The Fifth Commandment is short. “You shall not murder” (Exodus 20:13, ESV). Luther’s explanation of it is longer and the second half is the half we forget: “We should fear and love God so that we do not hurt or harm our neighbor in his body, but help and support him in every physical need.”¹⁰ The commandment therefore has two edges. It forbids us to harm our neighbor and it commands us to keep him alive. The Large Catechism presses this until it is uncomfortable. We sin against the commandment not only by the hand that strikes but by the hand that does not help, and Luther emphasizes the point: “if you see one suffer hunger and do not give him food, you have caused him to starve.” He then uses the word the rest of us would have avoided and says that God “rightly calls all those murderers who do not afford counsel and help in distress and danger of body and life.”¹¹
One more thing belongs here. The Decalogue has two tables and the Fourth Commandment opens the second (the table governing how we treat the people God has put around us). The Fifth stands next in that list and immediately after the honoring of parents and before marriage, property, and reputation. The ordering is not accidental. Before God says anything about what is yours He says something about whether your neighbor is still breathing. Life comes first among the earthly goods because it is the one carrying all the others.
Proverbs puts the omission in these terms:
Rescue those who are being taken away to death; hold back those who are stumbling to the slaughter. If you say, “Behold, we did not know this,” does not he who weighs the heart perceive it? (Proverbs 24:11–12, ESV)
We did not know is anticipated and rejected in the same breath. The unborn child is the most defenseless neighbor there is. He cannot speak for himself, defend himself, or feed himself, and he depends entirely on someone else’s decision. Dependence of that kind does not reduce his claim on us. It is the claim and it puts the burden on whoever has the power to protect him.
Which brings us to the mother, who is also our neighbor and who is very often the person no one in this conversation is actually helping. A woman facing an unexpected pregnancy may be carrying poverty, abandonment, illness, violence, shame, or an exhaustion that the people lecturing her have never had to feel. The Christian answer to that cannot be a restatement of the moral principle at a higher volume. It has to include mercy and mercy that costs something: food, clothing, transportation, money, medical care, a place to live, and someone willing to sit with her when the fear is worst. A congregation that confesses the sanctity of unborn life and is not prepared to be inconvenienced by a frightened mother has confessed only half of what it thinks it has confessed. She is a human being made in God’s image and she is owed the same dignity we are demanding on behalf of her child.
6. Children are a gift and the gift has a cost
Our culture speaks of children as a choice, a plan, a stage of life entered when conditions permit. Scripture speaks of them as an inheritance handed over: “Behold, children are a heritage from the LORD, the fruit of the womb a reward” (Psalm 127:3, ESV). A heritage is something received from someone else’s hand. You do not earn one, you cannot arrange for one, and whatever you go on to do with it, you did not make it.
Luther wrote about this with bluntness. He had watched the medieval Church treat marriage and childbearing as the second-best Christian life, a concession for people unequal to celibacy and he would not have it. Parenthood is a divine station — a vocation, a calling with God’s own command attached. He is at his best where he is least dignified, insisting that a father washing diapers, ridiculous though he looks to the neighbors, has God and all His angels smiling on him, “not because that father is washing diapers, but because he is doing so in Christian faith.”¹² The joke is deliberate; the doctrine under it is not. God hides Himself in ordinary offices and the care of a small dependent creature is one of them.
This bears on the argument of the chapter more than it may seem to. A congregation that receives children as a gift will find it hard to treat an unexpected one as an accident. Treat the arrival of a child as an inconvenience to be managed and you have already conceded the premise you meant to dispute and a frightened young woman can tell within a month which kind of church she has walked into.
Our Lord’s own handling of children makes the point without the argument. When the disciples sensibly tried to keep them away from a busy man, He was indignant and told them to stop: “Let the little children come to me and do not hinder them, for to such belongs the kingdom of heaven” (Matthew 19:14, ESV). He also attached to their mistreatment a warning He attached to almost nothing else, that it would be better for such a man “to have a great millstone fastened around his neck and to be drowned in the depth of the sea” (Matthew 18:6, ESV).
7. What the commandment forbids, by name
I would rather not write this section. It would be easier to teach the commandment, leave the applications implicit, and let each reader work out his own conclusions. A pastor who does that, however, leaves his people to learn what the Fifth Commandment means from whoever speaks the loudest and they deserve better from their own church.
Let me say directly what the Fifth Commandment says about three things our generation has learned to discuss in softer words.
Abortion. The deliberate destruction of an unborn child is the taking of an innocent human life and the commandment forbids it. It is not a medical procedure like any other and calling it one does not change what it is. One thing has to be said in the same breath. A physician who operates on an ectopic pregnancy or who treats a mother whose life the pregnancy is taking is not doing the act the commandment forbids (the child’s death there is a consequence of the treatment and not its object, and the distinction between those two is the same one I draw at the deathbed in chapter 4). No woman who has been through that should read this page and conclude she is a murderer. She is a mother who lost a child and she should be grieved with and not interrogated. I say that as a matter of doctrine and I would say it in any pulpit. I also say it knowing exactly who is reading. Because in any congregation of any size some of the people reading this sentence have had an abortion, or driven someone to one, or paid for one, and have been carrying it for thirty years. The commandment is not a club for the use of the rest of us. I will say this quickly and pray it is heard: that sin is forgiven in Christ, entirely, and there is nothing left of it for her to pay. Section 9 below says the same at length.
Euthanasia. To kill a patient in order to end his suffering, however gently it is done and however kindly it is meant, whatever the law permits, is to take a human life and the commandment forbids it. The intention is merciful and the act is not. What makes this difficult is that it stands very close to something entirely legitimate, which I take up in chapter 4: the decision to stop a treatment that has become a burden without a benefit. Those two are not the same act. In the one case we are letting a disease complete what it was always going to do while we care for the patient to the end. In the other we are making ourselves the cause of his death.
Physician-assisted suicide. The same judgment applies, with one added sorrow. What is offered as autonomy (the dignity of choosing one’s own hour) usually arrives at the bedside of someone who has begun to believe he is a burden. Once the option exists, it seldom stays only an option; it can quietly become a question the patient starts asking himself and then a question he suspects his family is asking. A society that hands a suffering man the means to die has not given him a choice so much as a suggestion. The Church answers that suggestion with presence, pain relief, and the promise of Christ, which is the only thing anyone has ever had to say into that particular fear.
None of these three is unforgivable. All three are forbidden.
8. When a life ends before it is held
Not every pregnancy ends with a living child.
Miscarriage, stillbirth, the death of a newborn, a prenatal diagnosis that turns a joyful appointment into a silent car ride home — these losses are real losses, and the Church must not respond to them with explanations. A child who was never held is still a child who died and his parents grieve him and the whole unlived life they had already begun imagining: the birthdays, the first day of school, the ordinary racket of a house with another person in it. That grief is proportionate and it should be received as such.
Pastoral care here is necessary. Prayer, Scripture, the naming of the child, a memorial service, and, where it is possible, the reverent burial or interment of the child’s remains. No parent should be told that another pregnancy will settle the matter. The child who died is not replaceable by the child who might come later and a family knows that even when no one will say it to them. It is also never too late to do any of it. If you lost a child twenty years ago and no one offered you a name, a prayer, or a service (and for most of that generation no one did) the Church can still do all three. The child is still your child. Come and ask and we will name that son or daughter before God and commend him to the Lord who has had him all along.
The hardest question these parents ask is about a child who died before Baptism. Begin where the answer is clear. God is merciful, His saving power is not limited by our failure or our inability to get to the font in time and He has bound us to the means of grace without binding His own hands with them.¹³ Luther, writing in 1542 to women who had miscarried, refused to let them believe that God had turned away a child because a mother’s body failed before the Church could act; he told them to commend the child to God and to stop turning the knife.¹⁴ That counsel is four hundred and eighty years old and I have nothing better to offer, because there is nothing better. Where Scripture has given us no specific promise I will not create one and I will not pretend to a certainty I do not have, but silence is not a verdict and it is not permission to fear the worst. What I can do is commend these children to the mercy of God, who knew them more fully than their parents ever did, and point grieving parents to the one place where the character of God is on display without ambiguity: the cross of Jesus Christ. David’s word over his own dead infant is the shape of it — “I shall go to him, but he will not return to me” (2 Samuel 12:23, ESV). That is a father entrusting a child to God, which is exactly what we are asking these parents to do.
9. A word to those burdened by the past
The Fifth Commandment is not the only word God has spoken, and a paper on human dignity that ends these subjects at the commandment has stopped halfway through the Christian faith.
The Law shows us our sin. That is its work and it does it better than anything. The Gospel shows us the Savior who has borne that sin and there is no sin for which His blood is insufficient. None! including this one. The person God has brought to repentance is not handed a sentence of lifelong self-punishment to be served out before forgiveness begins. He is directed to Christ crucified and in the Absolution the pastor does not express a hope that God might someday overlook the matter. He announces, on Christ’s authority and in His stead, that the sin is forgiven.¹⁵
What I say of the woman in section 7 I say of every other reader that section touched: the son who agreed to something in a hospital room and has never repeated it to anyone, the daughter who signed a form, the family who helped a father do what he had already decided to do. The commandment stands. The blood of Christ stands, too!
If you are carrying one of these burdens hear this and do not read past it. Christ died for that sin. It is not the one exception, it is not too old to be reached, and the many years you have spent paying for it were never the price. He paid the price and the account has been closed since Good Friday. Whether you can believe that this afternoon is not what settles the matter, which is exactly why God did not leave the saying of it to you. Come and tell me or tell whoever your own pastor is. It stays between you, him, and God; that is what private confession is for, it is still ours, and it takes no appointment and no explanation beyond “I need to talk to you.” (Chapter VII §8 explains how the seal of confession differs from the ordinary confidence of other pastoral conversations.) Then you will hear a man say to your face, in the stead and by the command of the Lord Jesus Christ, that you are forgiven all your sins, in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. That is not his opinion of your case. It is the verdict, settled and pronounced.
The same Gospel that comforts the dying and the bereaved comforts the woman who is certain she is the one exception. She is not the exception. The Church must therefore speak clearly about the sanctity of life and just as clearly about the forgiveness of sins and it must never let a congregation hear the first without the second. The confession of human dignity includes the protection of the vulnerable and the restoration of the fallen.
⁵ SC, Creed, First Article. ⁶ Luther, Heidelberg Disputation (1518), thesis 28: “The love of God does not find, but creates, that which is pleasing to it. The love of man comes into being through that which is pleasing to it.” LW 31:41, 57. ⁷ Luther, The Magnificat (1521), LW 21:297–358, on God’s regard for the lowly and on Mary’s own nothingness as the ground of His choice rather than any merit in her. ⁸ Didache 2:2. The Didache (The Teaching of the Twelve Apostles) is a first- or early second-century manual of Christian instruction, not Scripture and never claimed as such, and it is our earliest window onto what converts were taught immediately after the apostolic age. ⁹ Epistle of Barnabas 19:5; Epistle to Diognetus 5:6; Athenagoras, A Plea for the Christians 35; Tertullian, Apology 9 — “we may not destroy even the fetus in the womb… That is a man which is going to be one.” All are in the Ante-Nicene Fathers. (An earlier draft cited Aristides, Apology 15, for the refusal to expose infants. It does not say so; what that chapter supports is the care of widows, orphans, strangers, and prisoners, and fasting in order to feed the hungry.) ¹⁰ SC, Ten Commandments, Fifth Commandment. ¹¹ LC I 189–191. Luther moves from the prohibition to the positive duty and concludes that to withhold help from a neighbor in bodily need is to be guilty of his death before God. ¹² Luther, The Estate of Marriage (1522), LW 45:17–49, on marriage and parenthood as divine stations and on the dignity of the ordinary work they require. ¹³ SC, Baptism, Second Part. AC IX teaches that Baptism is necessary to salvation and condemns those who say children are saved without it; the reserve above rests on the distinction the article assumes — God has bound us to the means of grace, and He has not bound His own hands with them. ¹⁴ Luther, Comfort for Women Who Have Had a Miscarriage (1542), LW 43:247–250. ¹⁵ SC, Confession; SC, the Office of the Keys; AC XI and XXV. See also Luther, A Sermon on Preparing to Die (1519), LW 42:99–115, on the pastoral use of absolution with the frightened conscience.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.