Books · On the Dignity of the Human Being
On the Dignity of the Human Being — Student Guide
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
A Seven-Session Study for the Congregation
Before we begin
This study runs seven sessions, one for each part of On the Dignity of the Human Being. You can follow it with either the full book or the plain-language companion, What Is a Human Being Worth? The companion is shorter and carries no footnotes. No one will be quizzed on which one you read.
Each session gives you a reading, a handful of passages to look up in your own Bible, a place or two in the Small Catechism to find, some questions for discussion, and a prayer to close.
Two things in the back of the full book are worth knowing about now rather than in week seven. Appendix D answers thirty-eight of the questions people actually ask (the ones that come up in a hallway, in a car, or on the telephone) and each answer points to the chapter that argues it. If a question occurs to you between sessions, look there first. Appendix C is a table of the Greek, Hebrew, and Latin terms, so that no word in the book has to stay a mystery. There is also an Appendix F of Scripture passages arranged by the hour in which they are needed (at a bedside, at a funeral, for a worn-out caregiver). It was assembled for the pastor, the elder, and any member who has been asked to sit with someone and does not know what to read.
Two things about the room before we start.
This study is about real people and some of them will be sitting next to you. We are going to talk about miscarriage, abortion, dementia, nursing homes, the decision to stop treatment, cremation, and what to do with a parent’s ashes. In any group of adults some have lived through at least one of those and have never said much about it. You are never obliged to share anything. What is said in this room stays in this room and if something here opens an old wound, come and find me afterward. That is what I am for.
Scripture quotations throughout are from the English Standard Version. Where the study points you to the Lutheran Confessions, the reference is by article and section so you can find it in whatever edition you own.
And a key to the abbreviations, since they appear without explanation almost everywhere else. Our Confessions are gathered in one volume called the Book of Concord, published in 1580. SC and LC are Luther’s Small and Large Catechisms (the Small is the one you were confirmed on). AC is the Augsburg Confession of 1530, the central statement of what Lutherans believe, and Ap is its Apology, the longer defense written the year after. FC is the Formula of Concord of 1577, which settled arguments that broke out after Luther died; FC SD is its full-length Solid Declaration and FC Ep the short summary. If you do not own a copy, say so and we will get one into your hands.
Session 1 — What Is a Human Being Worth?
Read: Introduction and chapter 1 (Life Received), or Parts 1 and 2 of the companion. This is one of the longer readings of the seven; if you have time for only some of it, read the Introduction and sections 1, 2, 7, and 9.
The world measures a person by what he can do and that is not wicked until we forget we have described his abilities and start treating it as a description of his worth. The Christian begins somewhere else. We do not start with the human being and work outward toward his value; we start with God, who made him.
This session lays the foundation the other six stand on and then applies it to life at its most defenseless.
Look these up before we meet:
- Genesis 1:26–27 and Genesis 2:7 (how the human being got here)
- Genesis 9:6 and James 3:9 (who is called God’s image after the Fall)
- Psalm 139:13–16 (what God knows about a hidden child)
- Exodus 20:13 (the Fifth Commandment)
- Luke 1:39–45 (two pregnant women and the Lord)
- Small Catechism, the Creed, First Article (note how many verbs have God as their subject)
- Small Catechism, Ten Commandments, Fifth Commandment (read the whole explanation, including the second half)
For discussion:
- Luther’s explanation of the First Article puts our entire existence in the passive voice: God made me, gave me, still takes care of them. Where in your week do you find yourself measuring your own worth by what you produced?
- The book distinguishes two senses of “the image of God”: one we lost in the Fall and Christ restores, and one that still holds true of every sinner alive. Why does keeping both senses matter when you are standing in a nursing-home hallway?
- The Fifth Commandment forbids killing and commands helping. Luther says God “rightly calls all those murderers who do not afford counsel and help in distress and danger of body and life.” Which half do we teach more? Which half is harder?
- A congregation that confesses the sanctity of unborn life should be prepared to be inconvenienced by a frightened mother. What would that actually cost this congregation, in money, time, and awkwardness?
- Section 2 sets the Christian answer beside the world’s three: worth from usefulness, from capacity, from autonomy. Which of the three have you caught yourself believing? What happens to each one at a bedside?
- Luther wrote that our love comes into being through what is already pleasing to it, while God’s love does not find its object but creates one. What difference does that make to a person who has stopped being pleasing to anyone?
- The early Church forbade abortion and the exposure of infants and took the exposed in and raised them, eventually building houses for them. Why do those two belong together and what would the equivalent be here?
- Scripture calls children “a heritage from the LORD,” and Luther said a father washing diapers is doing something God thinks more of than the fasting of any monk. How does a congregation that believes that treat an unexpected pregnancy differently?
- The book names abortion, euthanasia, and physician-assisted suicide directly, and then says: “None of these three is unforgivable. All three are forbidden.” What goes wrong in a church that says only one of those two sentences?
Remember:
- Your worth is not a report on your abilities. It is a fact about who made you and what He paid for you.
- Usefulness, capacity, and autonomy all put worth inside a person, where it can be lost. Scripture puts it outside him.
- This is not a new position. The Church held it when being a Christian was still illegal and it paid for it.
- Human life is received, not achieved. That is the whole of the First Article.
- The Fifth Commandment has two halves and we usually forget the second.
- The mother is our neighbor too and she is often the person no one is actually helping.
- There is no sin here for which the blood of Christ is insufficient. None.
Closing prayer: Almighty God, our Maker, You formed us before we could ask to be formed and You have kept us every day since without being asked. Teach us to receive our lives from Your hand and to receive our neighbor the same way, especially the neighbor who can do nothing for us. Where we have valued people by their usefulness, forgive us; where we have been silent when we should have helped, forgive us; and where any of us carries a grief or a guilt from these things, speak Your absolution and let us believe it. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Session 2 — Your Body Is Not a Container
Read: chapter 2 (Life Embodied), or Part 3 of the companion.
We have all heard it said at a viewing: she is not really in there. It is meant kindly and it is not our confession. Scripture does not describe a soul housed temporarily in a body. God formed the man from the dust and breathed into him and the man became a living creature: one creature, dust and breath together.
This is why our faith is so physical and why the resurrection of the body is not a footnote to salvation.
Look these up before we meet:
- Genesis 2:7 (note the verb: he became a living creature)
- John 1:14 (where God put Himself)
- 1 Corinthians 6:19–20 (note the reason given)
- 2 Corinthians 12:9 (the answer Paul got when God said no)
- Psalm 8:3–5
- Small Catechism, the Creed, Second Article (what the purchase price was)
- Small Catechism, Baptism and the Sacrament of the Altar (note how physical both are)
For discussion:
- Where have you heard the body described as a container the soul is glad to be rid of? Why does it sound Christian when it is not?
- If the body is God’s good creation, what does ordinary care for it look like and where is the line between stewardship and the pursuit of physical perfection?
- Consider the man in the book who loses his legs, then his hands, then his speech. What exactly has changed and what has not?
- “You are not your own, for you were bought with a price.” Paul is writing about sexual sin. What else follows from that sentence about what we may do to other people’s bodies?
- Tertullian wrote that “the flesh is the hinge of salvation”: the flesh is washed so the soul may be cleansed, the flesh is fed on Christ so the soul may be filled with God. What does that say about why Baptism uses water and the Supper uses bread?
- God could have dealt with us inwardly, privately, without water or bread or the sound of the pastor’s voice. He chose not to. Why does that matter to someone who cannot trust his own feelings?
- The book lists four things not to say to a suffering person: God sent this to teach you; everything happens for a reason; God will not give you more than you can handle; you would be better with more faith. Which have you heard? Which have you said?
- Luther distinguished the theologian who expects to find God in strength and success from the one who looks for Him in suffering and a cross. What does that change about where you look during a bad year?
- The book says care remains possible long after cure is gone. Who in this congregation is in that situation right now and what would care look like this month?
Remember:
- You are not a soul with a body attached. You are one creature and death is an outrage because it tears apart what God joined.
- The Son of God did not think human flesh was beneath Him. He put it on and He wears it still.
- Health is a blessing. It is not the source of anyone’s worth and illness is not a report card.
- We follow a Lord who saved the world by being beaten and killed. Christians have no grounds for despising the weak.
- The inability to cure does not cancel the obligation to care.
- “The flesh is the hinge of salvation.” God does not work around your body. He works through it.
- Suffering is not a verdict on your life and the four sentences in question 7 are not comfort.
Closing prayer: Lord Jesus Christ, You took our flesh and did not despise it; You were hungry and tired and in pain and You rose from the dead still bearing the body You were born in. Teach us to honor these bodies of ours as Your good gift and not as our god, to care for them without worshiping them, and to see in every weak and failing body a neighbor whom You have bought at a great price. Amen.
Session 3 — The Poor, the Sick, and Everyone Easy to Overlook
Read: chapter 3 (Life Shared), or Part 4 of the companion.
A lawyer once asked Jesus who his neighbor was and Luke tells us he asked it “desiring to justify himself.” He wanted a boundary because a man who knows where his obligation stops can finally relax. Jesus gave him a road, a robbery, and three men, two who walked past and one who did not.
Before we talk about mercy, though, we have to get justification and sanctification in the right order, because a congregation that gets them backwards ends up either guilty or proud.
Look these up before we meet:
- Luke 10:25–37 (note the question Jesus asks at the end, which is not the question He was asked)
- Matthew 25:31–46
- 1 Corinthians 12:22–26 (note one word in verse 22)
- James 2:14–17 and 1 John 3:16–18
- Augsburg Confession (AC), Article IV (justification) and Article VI (new obedience); read them together, in that order
For discussion:
- Why does the book insist on putting AC IV before any discussion of mercy? What happens in a church that reverses them?
- Paul calls the weaker members “indispensable.” Not tolerated, not accommodated, but indispensable. What would it change here if we believed that about our homebound members?
- The book says, “Measure your members by what they can do for you and you have adopted the world’s standard inside the Church.” Where does that standard show up in our life together?
- Christian mercy can go wrong in a way that looks like kindness: deciding for people instead of with them. Where have you seen it? Where have you done it?
- The book distinguishes righteousness before God, which is entirely passive and complete, from righteousness before other people, which is the actual work of love. What goes wrong when those two get mixed? Which error is more common here, the anxious Christian or the comfortable one?
- God does not need your good works; your neighbor does. God has also arranged the world in stations (you are someone’s child, parent, employee, neighbor). Name your own stations aloud. Who is standing in them with you?
- Tertullian described a congregation’s common fund that buried the poor and kept the old, and said outsiders remarked, “See how they love one another.” The emperor Julian complained that the Christians “support not only their own poor but ours as well.” Would either man have said that about us?
- Basil told his congregation that the coat in the closet belongs to the naked, and that in refusing to give they were not declining to be generous but wronging people who needed it. Is he right? Where does a Lutheran want to correct him?
- Paul says each should give “as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion.” What replaces compulsion and what does 2 Corinthians 8:9 have to do with it?
- Most of this work is unremarkable and no one will ever hear about it. Name one thing you could do this week that would never make the newsletter.
Remember:
- We are justified by grace through faith for Christ’s sake and never by our charity. The work is finished.
- Faith that receives Christ is never indifferent to a neighbor in trouble. Both things are true at once.
- The poor are not a category. They are people and what they need is not interchangeable.
- The weaker members are the indispensable ones and Paul says it about the ones who only seem weaker.
- Needing help in one area says nothing about capacity in every other.
- Two righteousnesses: one before God, entirely received; one before men, entirely active. Keep them apart and both survive.
- Your station is where your neighbor finds you and stations hand you particular people with names.
Closing prayer: Merciful Father, You did not wait until we deserved anything before You loved us and You have never once measured us by what we could return. Free us from the world’s habit of counting people by what they produce. Make this congregation a place where the weak are indispensable and the forgotten are noticed and keep us from the pride that turns mercy into power. For the sake of Jesus Christ, who became poor for us. Amen.
Session 4 — Growing Old, and Dying
Read: chapter 4 (Life Honored), or Part 5 of the companion.
Age takes things from us in an order none of us would have picked. A woman who ran a household and buried a husband and was the one everyone called in a crisis may end up depending on her own children to get through a day. That reversal is hard on everyone. It does not touch the question of dignity at all.
This session also takes up the hardest practical question most families ever face: when treatment can no longer help, what are we permitted to do?
Look these up before we meet:
- Exodus 20:12, and the Small Catechism, Fourth Commandment, with its list of verbs
- Psalm 71:9 and 71:17–18
- Isaiah 46:4 (note who does the carrying, and how long)
- John 19:26–27 (what our Lord arranged from the cross)
- 1 Timothy 5:8
- Romans 14:7–8
For discussion:
- The Fourth Commandment is usually taught to children. What does honoring a parent look like when the parent is old and where is it hardest?
- A nursing home is not by itself a failure to honor your mother; the question is never where she sleeps. What is the question, then, and how would a family know the answer honestly?
- Families say of a parent with dementia that the person they knew is already gone. The book says that is true about everything we can see and that it must not become a doctrine. Why not?
- A baptized Christian who can no longer recite the Creed has not been stripped of her Baptism. What does that mean for how we visit and for whether she receives the Sacrament?
- Stopping a burdensome treatment is not the same act as killing the patient. Can you state the difference in your own words, the way you would say it to a frightened family in the middle of the night?
- One child usually does most of the caring while the others contribute opinions from a distance. What does that person actually need and what does she never get? What would relief look like here, with names attached?
- In a long decline the losses come one at a time over years and it is grief without any of the permissions grief usually carries. Why is that grief so hard to name and what would it do for a caregiver to have someone name it?
- There was a time when the Church taught people how to die, deliberately, as a subject. Why did we stop and what did we lose?
- Luther told a dying man not to stare down death, sin, and hell but to look somewhere else. Where, and why is “examine yourself harder” the wrong advice at that hour?
- Simeon says he can depart in peace because his eyes have seen God’s salvation, not because his life went well and not because he is tired. The Church sings his song at the end of the Lord’s Supper. Why there?
- What conversation should you be having with your own family that you have been putting off?
Remember:
- An old man does not become less human as his abilities go and he owes no one a justification for still being here.
- The honor owed to parents is owed for life and it gets more demanding as they become less able to demand it.
- Faith is not an intellectual accomplishment by which we hold on to God. A baptized Christian is held in the memory of God.
- The Fifth Commandment does not require every available procedure. Declining a burdensome treatment is not killing.
- The cause of death is the illness.
- The caregiver is grieving and no one has told her so.
- Settle it early, then put it away and go and live. That is what people who have settled it are freed to do.
Closing prayer: O God, who has carried Your people from the womb and promises to carry them to gray hairs, do not cast off the old among us and do not let us cast them off either. Give patience to those who care for failing parents, comfort to those whose minds are going, and courage to families who must make decisions they never wanted. When we have done all we can and cannot cure, teach us to stay. When the hour comes, receive Your servants into the arms of Your mercy, through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Session 5 — What We Do with Our Dead
Read: chapter 5 (Life Committed), or Part 6 of the companion. This is the longest session. Try not to miss it.
When a person dies something terrible has happened. We have grown used to softer words and every one of them is said for the best of reasons. Scripture calls death an enemy. Yet the body left behind is not debris; it is the body God has promised to raise.
This session covers the Christian funeral, what the rites at the casket do and do not accomplish, why the Church has historically buried its dead, cremation, and what to do with cremated remains. Your pastor will tell you what he prefers and why. He will also tell you that his preference is not a law over anyone’s conscience.
Look these up before we meet:
- Genesis 23:1–20 (count how many verses Scripture spends on buying a grave)
- Genesis 50:24–25 (ask what a coffin in Egypt was confessing for four hundred years)
- John 19:38–42 (who handled the body of Jesus, and how)
- Romans 6:3–5 (the burial that happened to you first)
- 1 Corinthians 15:42–44
- Augsburg Confession, Article XV, on ceremonies and consciences
For discussion:
- Scripture gives a whole chapter to Abraham buying a burial place. What is the narrator telling us by taking his time?
- “The same body that was laid down is the body that stood up.” How does Easter change what a Christian burial is?
- What is the pall, the paschal candle, and the sign of the cross over the casket each saying? What would a visitor learn from watching our funeral without hearing a word?
- The book warns that at the funeral of a beloved member the eulogy grows and the Gospel shrinks, and that “a good woman has gone to her reward” sounds like comfort but is actually the Law. Why is that the Law?
- Does cremation prevent God from raising the dead? Where in Scripture is your answer?
- Your pastor would rather we buried our dead and he says he will not stand at the door of the church and criticize anyone’s arrangements. Why does he go to such lengths to say both?
- What does a permanent place of interment give a family that keeping the ashes at home does not?
- Should a Christian be an organ donor? What about donating a body to a medical school and what does the book say to arrange in advance if you do?
- There were centuries when the Church denied Christian burial to a suicide. The book says that practice punished the wrong people. It also says we must not pretend the Fifth Commandment has an exception. How do you hold both?
- Over a suicide the book holds two things together: we do not pretend and we do not presume. Say in your own words what each half protects.
- Go through the list in section 13 (your wishes written down and which drawer they are in, the plot, the hymns, the viewing, whether your pastor is called before or after). Which of these have you actually done?
Remember:
- Death is an enemy. The body of the dead is not debris; it is the body God has promised to raise.
- Christian burial is a confession made with our hands: it admits death is real and calls the grave a waiting place.
- The rites at the casket do nothing for the dead. They confess what the living believe and they teach.
- We may pray for our dead. We may not treat any rite as a work spent on their behalf.
- Cremation cannot put anyone beyond the reach of Christ. Not in the least and not in any degree.
- A permanent resting place gives a family somewhere to go and gives grandchildren not yet born a name to be told.
- Scripture commands no method of burial and a pastor’s preference is not a law over your conscience.
- An autopsy injures no one; organ donation is the Fifth Commandment’s second half at a scale our great-grandparents could not have imagined.
- Over a suicide the Church does not pretend and does not presume and it buries him with full rites.
- Settling the arrangements in advance is one of the last acts of love you can perform for the people you leave behind.
Closing prayer: Lord Jesus Christ, You were laid in a borrowed tomb by men who loved You, and on the third day You left it empty. Teach us to handle our dead with reverence and to bury them in hope, remembering that the grave is a place of waiting and not an ending. Comfort those among us who still cannot pass a certain cemetery, or a certain shelf in a certain room, and assure every one of us that on the last day You will not be searching. You know where Your people are. Raise us with them and let us see You in our flesh. Amen.
Session 6 — Together Again
Read: chapter 6 (Life Restored), or Part 7 of the companion.
Our comfort at a funeral is not that the dead survive in some form. It is that Christ will raise them and that He will gather all of His people, the dead and the living, to Himself at once.
This session is about what we actually confess in the last line of the Creed and about what to say to a widow who wants to know whether she will see her husband again.
Look these up before we meet:
- Job 19:25–27 (read it aloud, slowly)
- John 11:17–27 and 11:33–35 (what Jesus knew, and what He did anyway)
- 1 Corinthians 15:14, 19–20, 42–44
- 1 Thessalonians 4:13–18 (note the last verse, which is an instruction)
- Philippians 1:23 and 2 Corinthians 5:8 (the state of the believer after death)
- Revelation 21:3–5
- Small Catechism, the Creed, Third Article (note the tense of the last clause)
- Augsburg Confession, Article XVII
For discussion:
- “She is in a better place.” “Death is a natural part of life.” What is wrong with these and why do we keep saying them?
- Jesus wept at the tomb of Lazarus knowing He was about to raise him. What does that settle about Christian grief?
- The book distinguishes the believer’s soul with Christ now from the resurrection of the body at the Last Day. Why does collapsing those two leave us with a smaller hope than we were given?
- Job says, “in my flesh I shall see God… my eyes… and not another.” He does not know the mechanism. What does he know?
- Will we recognize one another? What can we say and where should we stop?
- The book says that at the Communion rail the Church on earth and the Church with Christ are at one Supper. What does that mean for a widow kneeling there and why is it not sentimental?
- Walk through Paul’s order in 1 Corinthians 15: the witnesses first, then the argument from denial, then the question about the body, then the taunt, then a therefore about ordinary work. Why does he begin where he begins?
- “Spiritual body” does not mean a body made of spirit. What does it mean and why does the risen Christ eating fish settle it?
- Every creed puts the judgment in the same breath as the resurrection and AC XVII does not soften it. Why can a paper on the Last Day not leave it out and why is a Christian not meant to face that day as an open question?
- The casseroles and the cards stop within weeks and the grief goes on for years. What would it take for this congregation to still be there months later, when everyone else’s life has resumed?
Remember:
- Death is a defeated enemy: still able to hurt us, no longer able to keep us.
- Grief is not weak faith. Our Lord wept at a grave He was about to open.
- The soul is with Christ now; the body will be raised at the Last Day. Both, in that order, and the second is the end of the Creed.
- The body that will be raised is the body that was washed.
- Reunion is real and it is second. We will be together because we will be with Him.
- Say the person’s name. Most people avoid it and the bereaved are longing to hear it.
- Remove the resurrection and there is no Gospel left to add anything to. Paul stakes everything on one claim.
- The verdict of the last day has already been announced over a Christian: at the font, in the absolution, at the rail.
Closing prayer: Almighty God, whose Son is the resurrection and the life, we confess with the whole Church the resurrection of the body and the life everlasting. Give us the comfort of that promise in the middle of our grief and not instead of it. Keep us close to those who mourn, long after the funeral is over, and teach us to say the names of our dead without fear. On the last day, raise us with all Your people into the presence of our Lord, where death shall be no more. Amen.
Session 7 — What This Asks of Us
Read: chapter 7 (The Church’s Calling) and the Conclusion, or Part 8 and the closing of the companion.
The dignity of the human being is not a doctrine to be filed away. It is a confession that either shapes the life of a congregation or exposes it.
This last session turns the whole study on ourselves.
Look these up before we meet:
- Romans 12:9–16 (read it as a description of a congregation)
- Galatians 6:2 and 6:9–10
- Mark 9:36–37
- 1 John 3:16–18
- Ephesians 4:1–6
For discussion:
- A church can confess the resurrection every Sunday and treat the care of the dying as someone else’s department. Where does our practice not yet match our confession?
- Go through the questions in chapter 7 honestly. Can a person with a walker get from our parking lot to a pew? Can someone with poor eyesight read our bulletin? Who has not been seen in some time and has anyone called?
- Young families are usually more tired than they let on. What do they need from us that is not a program?
- People stop visiting the dying because they do not know what to say. What is the answer to that?
- The Church does not make people worthy of love by deciding to love them. Why does that distinction keep this whole study from becoming a compliment we pay ourselves?
- Children used to learn what a funeral was by attending several while they were still young. Now they are kept away. What has that cost and what would we have to change to undo it?
- All Saints’ Day, the reading of the names, the churchyard: what does a congregation say about the resurrection by how it treats its own dead?
- Section 8 states what a pastor owes: that he will come, bring the Word rather than himself, tell the truth, keep what is said to him, prepare, and never use a deathbed. Is anything missing from that list?
- Name one thing that should be different here because of these seven weeks. Then name who will do it.
Remember:
- Every stage of life in this study is one the congregation either notices or does not.
- Christian love usually begins with the willingness to notice someone who has been forgotten.
- “If one member suffers, all suffer together” is a description, not a sentiment.
- Where we have failed at this, the answer is not a resolution to try harder. It is the same absolution we give everybody else.
- We do not hand out dignity. We recognize what God has already made and act accordingly.
- Teach the young this before they need it and let them come to the funerals.
- The congregation’s dead are not former members.
Closing prayer: Lord God, You have made every person we will meet this week, and You have bought every one of them with the blood of Your Son. Open our eyes to the ones we have stopped seeing: the homebound, the grieving, the exhausted, the ones whose names have dropped off our lists. Forgive us the neighbors we have overlooked. Make this congregation a place where life is received with gratitude, protected with love, sustained with mercy, and given back in death to the God who raises the dead. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, who is the resurrection and the life. Amen.
Thank you for these seven weeks. If anything in this study opened something you have been carrying, my door is open and the conversation stays between you, me, and God.
In Christ, Dylan MacDonald
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.