Books · On the Dignity of the Human Being

What Is a Human Being Worth?

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

A Plain-Language Companion to On the Dignity of the Human Being


This is the plain-language companion to the longer book, On the Dignity of the Human Being. It follows the same argument in the same order, without the footnotes and the technical apparatus, and it is written for anyone in the pew who wants to know what the Christian faith says about a human life from the womb to the grave. Scripture quotations are from the English Standard Version.


A word before you begin

You do not need to read this book straight through from first page to last. Each of the parts can be read by itself and you may feel free to skip from one part to another. If something is weighing on you today, I suggest you turn to that part and come back to the others later when you are ready.

Contents

  1. What is a human being worth?
  2. Life at the beginning (saying the hard things by name; when a child dies before he is held; if you are carrying something from years ago)
  3. Your body is not a container
  4. The poor, the sick, and everyone easy to overlook
  5. Growing old, and dying (dementia; the one who is doing the carrying; when treatment can no longer help)
  6. What we do with our dead (cremation; what to do with the ashes; when someone takes his own life)
  7. Together again (the longing to see them again; the judgment)
  8. What this asks of a congregation

Where this leaves us


1. What is a human being worth?

The world already has an answer to this question and I believe it is a careless answer at best. The world sizes a person up by what he is able to do. We think well of the strong and the capable and we are glad when a man “pulls his own weight.” There is nothing wrong with that, but the trouble starts when a description of what someone can do today begins to be treated as a verdict on what he is ultimately worth. Measuring in this way cannot tell us everything a human being is worth. Think about some of the harder cases. For instance, what is a child worth while he is still hidden inside his mother? What is a man worth after an accident has taken the use of his legs, or a woman after dementia has taken her memory, or a father who can no longer tell which of the faces around his bed belong to his own children? And what is left of a person’s dignity once he has died and his body lies in a casket at the front of the church? Questions like these are harder to answer and they come up often. Sooner or later each of us will be asked to answer them.

The Christian starts from a different place when answering these questions. Where the world starts with the person and tries to work out what he is worth, the Christian starts with God.

So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them. (Genesis 1:27)

The human being is more than one more animal among the other animals. You were made in God’s image, a gift that was given to you before you could do anything at all.

Here I have to be careful with the word image, because the Church uses it in two ways. In the strict sense, the image of God was the righteousness Adam had before the Fall (knowing God, trusting God, being right with God) and that image has been lost. That is what our Confessions (the Lutheran statements of faith gathered in the Book of Concord) mean when they say the image is gone and it is why we need Christ to restore it. He begins that work through His Word and Baptism, received in faith, and He finishes it when He raises us. Yet Scripture keeps using the word about people who are plainly sinners. After the flood God forbids the shedding of human blood “for God made man in his own image,” and James warns against using the same tongue to bless God and to curse “people who are made in the likeness of God.” Neither of these passages has saints in mind, but both are talking about us. In other words, the word has a second and wider sense. Every human being still stands before God as the creature He made, the one He speaks to and means to redeem. Sickness, old age, and sin have never taken that away.

Most people who disagree with us hold one of three views and have usually drifted into it without choosing:

Some say worth comes from usefulness, from what a person contributes. That can at least be measured. The difficulty is that it describes tools well and people poorly. It also leads to a logical conclusion: if a person’s worth goes up as he contributes more, then it goes down when he contributes less. Every one of us is headed for the day when he contributes very little.

Some say worth comes from capacity, from being self-aware, able to reason, and able to want things. This view is more careful than the first and it is the one you will meet most often in medical ethics today. Its weakness is that capacities do not stay put. A newborn does not have them yet. A patient under anesthesia has them switched off for a while. An injury can damage them and dementia can take them away forever. If a person’s worth rises and falls with a brain scan then what we are really talking about is how well his body is functioning rather than what he is worth.

And some say worth comes from autonomy, from a life being mine and subject to my own choosing. Of the three this is the easiest to appreciate because it sounds like freedom. However, it places a person’s worth in the very thing that suffering takes from him first. Carry it through to the end and here is where it lands: a man whose illness has left him almost no choices is handed the one choice still open to him and is told that taking it is dignity. Terrible.

Put the Christian answer alongside these three. The difference is where the weight rests. Each of the three places a person’s worth inside him, in something he has and so can lose. Scripture places it outside him altogether: in the God who made him, in the Son who took on his human nature and paid for him, and in God’s promise to raise him from the dead. That is why the Christian answer holds steady however much the man himself changes. Luther once drew a line between our love and God’s love. Human love, he said, is drawn to whatever already pleases it. In other words, we are drawn to people who are already attractive or useful to us. God’s love works the other way around. It does not go looking for something lovely to love. It loves the unlovely and makes them lovely. Our love follows worth. God’s love confers it.

So your worth rests on who made you and on what He paid for you. The Son of God became a man. He was conceived in a womb and born as an infant. He knew hunger, thirst, weariness, and grief, and in the end He was put to death. He did not think human flesh was beneath Him. He put it on. When He rose on the third day He kept that body. He rose in a body with His wounds still there for Thomas to see and He has that body still.


2. Life at the beginning

God gives life. We receive it.

Every Sunday we confess God the Father as maker of heaven and earth. In the Small Catechism Luther explains that line in a way that leaves us no credit for any part of ourselves. God made me. He gave me my body and soul, my eyes and ears and every other part of me, my mind and my senses and He still takes care of every one of them. He does it, as the Catechism says, “out of fatherly, divine goodness and mercy, without any merit or worthiness in me.” That changes the question of worth. Before you could talk or think or decide anything, you had already been given everything. Nothing you have done since has made you any more God’s creature than you were at the moment you were conceived.

The Psalmist thanks God for work done on him before he was born:

For you formed my inward parts; you knitted me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. (Psalm 139:13–14)

We cannot see with bare eyes a child in the womb. God sees him and is at work on him there.

The Lord Himself came that way.

When God became man He came the way every one of us comes. He was conceived, carried by His mother, and born. Luke tells of Mary going to visit her relative Elizabeth while both of them were expecting. As soon as Elizabeth heard Mary’s greeting the child in her own womb leaped and Elizabeth, filled with the Holy Spirit, called Mary “the mother of my Lord.” The first to respond in that scene is a child no one could yet see. I want to be careful here. Luke tells the story to show us who Jesus is and that is how it should first be read. Even so, when this is how our Savior entered human life, a Christian cannot treat the first weeks of anyone’s life as if they did not count.

This is not a new position, and it was never a popular one.

Christians have believed this from the start and they first believed it in a world that disagreed. The Greeks and Romans practiced both abortion and exposure (leaving an unwanted baby outside to die). A father was free to refuse a newborn and the baby was left out in the open to whatever came. Over against this stands the oldest manual of Christian teaching we have from outside the New Testament. Written for new converts, it lists among its commands: you shall not murder a child by abortion, nor kill that which is begotten. Another early Christian, explaining the faith to a curious outsider, said that believers marry and have children like everyone else, “but they do not destroy their offspring.” Other defenders of the faith said the same when Christians were accused of being murderers.

This matters for us in two ways. First, a Christian who calls the unborn child his neighbor today is saying nothing new. The Church said so back when simply being a Christian was against the law. Second, the early Christians did more than forbid the practice. In time the Church took the care of abandoned babies on itself, and by the fifth century a church council could direct, as a matter of routine, that whoever found an abandoned baby report it to the church and that the finding be announced at the altar the next Sunday.

The Fifth Commandment has two halves.

“You shall not murder” is the half everyone remembers. Luther’s explanation in the Small Catechism adds the half we tend to forget: we must not injure our neighbor’s body, “but help and support him in every physical need.” The Large Catechism presses harder still. Luther says that if you see someone going hungry and do not feed him, you have let him starve, and he says God counts as a murderer anyone who withholds help from a person whose life is in danger. No neighbor is more defenseless than an unborn child. He has no voice to speak up for himself, no way to protect himself, and no way to feed himself. Everything depends on what someone else decides.

And the mother is our neighbor too.

In all the arguing she is often the one nobody is helping. A woman who did not expect to be pregnant may also be dealing with poverty, a partner who has left, illness, violence, shame, or a weariness her critics have never known. Repeating the moral principle more loudly does nothing for her. The Christian answer has to include mercy that costs us something: food and clothes, rides, money, medical care, a place to live, and someone who will stay with her when she is most afraid. If a congregation says that unborn life is sacred and will not be inconvenienced by a frightened mother, it has said only half of what it believes. She bears God’s image too and she is owed the same dignity we ask for her child.

Children are a gift, and the gift costs something.

Our society talks about children as something we decide on and plan for, perhaps a stage of life we enter when the timing suits us. Scripture talks about them as an inheritance, something given to us: “Behold, children are a heritage from the LORD, the fruit of the womb a reward” (Psalm 127:3). Nobody earns an inheritance and nobody can arrange to receive one. It comes from someone else’s hand. Luther was blunt on this. The Church of his day ranked marriage and raising children below the life of the monk and the nun and he refused to accept it. For him being a parent is a calling that comes with God’s own command and the tiring, unglamorous work of it is God’s work. He makes the point best when he is at his least dignified. A father washing diapers may look foolish to his neighbors, Luther says, yet God smiles on it because the man is doing it in faith.

Jesus made the same point without an argument. The disciples, meaning well, tried to keep children from bothering Him and He was angry with them: “Let the little children come to me and do not hinder them” (Matthew 19:14). He also gave a warning about harming children that is as severe as anything He said: it would be better for such a person to be thrown into the sea with a millstone tied around his neck.

Saying the hard things by name.

I would rather leave these implied. However, a pastor who stays quiet leaves his people to pick up the meaning of the Fifth Commandment from the loudest voice around them. You deserve better than that from your own church.

Abortion. Deliberately killing an unborn child is taking an innocent human life and the commandment forbids it. Giving it the name of a medical procedure does not make it anything else. When a doctor operates on an ectopic pregnancy (where the child has lodged outside the womb) or treats a mother whose pregnancy is killing her, the Church has long judged that he is not breaking the commandment. In that case the child’s death follows from the treatment. It was never what the doctor set out to do. Real cases are seldom this tidy and a family facing one needs its doctor and its pastor together. No woman who has lived through that should read this and decide she is a murderer. She is a mother whose child has died. Some of you reading this have had an abortion, or pressed someone into one, or paid for one. I will say the rest of it quickly. That sin is forgiven in Christ, entirely, and there is nothing left of it for anyone to pay. The last part of this section says the same thing at more length.

Euthanasia. Killing a patient to put an end to his suffering takes a human life, no matter how gently it is done, how kindly it is meant, or what the law allows. The intention is merciful and the act is not. It sits very close to something entirely right, which is stopping a treatment that has become all burden and no benefit. When we stop such a treatment we let the disease finish what it was going to do while we go on caring for the patient to the end. When we kill him we make ourselves the cause of his death. Part 5 takes this up.

Physician-assisted suicide. The same judgment holds, with one more sorrow added. Offered as freedom, assisted suicide usually reaches the bedside of someone who already suspects he has become a burden. Once the option is there it rarely stays just an option. The patient begins to ask himself whether he ought to take it and then to wonder whether his family is asking the same thing. The Church meets that fear with presence, with relief of pain, and with the promise of Christ. Abortion, euthanasia, and physician-assisted suicide are all forbidden by the Fifth Commandment. None of them is unforgivable.

When a child dies before he is held.

Miscarriage, stillbirth, the death of a newborn, a diagnosis during pregnancy that turns a happy visit to the doctor into a quiet drive home: the Church must not meet these losses with explanations. A child you never got to hold is still your child. You grieve for him and for the whole life you had already begun to picture for him. That grief is not too much and the Church should treat it that way. We can offer prayer, Scripture, a name for the child, a service, and, where it can be done, a reverent burial of the child’s remains. It is never too late to do this. Perhaps you lost a baby twenty years ago and nobody offered you any of this (for most of that generation nobody did). We can still do all of it. Come and ask.

Parents often ask what becomes of a child who dies before he could be baptized. God is merciful. Our failures do not limit His power to save and neither does our being unable to reach the font in time. Our Confession calls Baptism necessary and it is; it is not ours to despise or neglect. He has bound us to Baptism; He has not tied His own hands with it. Luther wrote to women who had lost babies to miscarriage. He would not let them think God had rejected a child because the mother’s body failed and he told them to give the child into God’s keeping and stop tormenting themselves. Where Scripture has given us no specific promise I will not create one, but silence is not a verdict and it is not permission to fear the worst.

If you are carrying something from years ago.

God has spoken more than the Fifth Commandment. If this part stopped at the commandment it would leave out half of the Christian faith. The Law (what God demands of us) shows us our sin. The Gospel (what God gives us in Christ) shows us the Savior who carried it and there is no sin His blood cannot cover. If you are carrying the weight of an abortion or a decision made in a hospital room that you have never repeated to anyone, hear this and do not read past it. Christ died for that sin. It is not the one exception, it is not too old to be reached, and the many years you have spent paying for it were never the price. He paid the price and the account has been closed since Good Friday. Whether you can believe that this afternoon is not what settles the matter, which is exactly why God did not leave the saying of it to you.

Come and tell me or tell whoever your own pastor is. It stays between you, him, and God; that is what private confession is for, it is still ours and it takes no appointment and no explanation beyond “I need to talk to you.” Then you will hear the absolution, the word of forgiveness spoken to you in God’s name. A man will say to your face, in the stead and by the command of the Lord Jesus Christ (in His place and at His command), that you are forgiven all your sins, in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. That is not his opinion of your case. It is the verdict.


3. Your body is not a container

There is a way of talking that sounds pious. It treats the soul as the real person and the body as a container he is handed at birth and hands back at death (useful for a while and no great loss when it goes). Funeral homes use this language nearly everywhere (she is not really in there) and a good many Christians have picked it up without realizing that it contradicts what we confess. It comes from Plato, who taught that the body is a prison and the soul is better off out of it. Genesis tells it differently. God shaped the man from the dust and breathed into him, “and the man became a living creature.” The man did not receive a soul as something extra added to the clay. He became one. In other words, you are one creature, dust and breath together, and that is why death is such an outrage: it pulls apart what God put together. At the font water is poured over a head. At the Communion rail bread and wine are put into a mouth. God made the material world and called it good. In the fullness of time He took it up into Himself: “And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us.”

One of the first great errors the early Church had to fight concerned Christ’s flesh more than His divinity. Some people could accept that God had appeared among us yet could not accept that He had been born, had eaten, and had been buried. So they said His body only seemed to be real. Ignatius, a bishop who wrote his letters while he was being taken to his death, insists that Christ was “truly born, and did eat and drink… truly persecuted under Pontius Pilate… truly crucified” and adds “truly raised from the dead.” Irenaeus, a bishop in Gaul later in the same century, showed what was at stake for us. If our flesh cannot be saved (so his argument runs), then Christ’s blood did not redeem us, the cup at the altar does not give us His blood and the bread does not give us His body. Take away the body and everything else goes with it.

Tertullian, a teacher in North Africa about the year 200, put it in a sentence people still quote: the flesh is the hinge of salvation. He meant that God does everything He does for us through the body. The body is washed so that the soul is cleansed and the body is fed on Christ so that the soul is filled with God.

Which is why God reaches you through ordinary, physical things.

God could have dealt with each of us privately and inwardly, spirit to spirit, with no water, no bread, and no pastor’s voice. He chose otherwise. He binds Himself to things we can touch and to words spoken by ordinary men so that we have something outside ourselves to hold on to. Luther’s catechisms explain why. Without the Word, the Small Catechism says, the water is plain water and no Baptism. Joined to the Word it is, in the Large Catechism (the longer companion to the little one we were confirmed on), “divine, heavenly, holy, and blessed water.” In the Supper a body is given to a body. A Christian may think very little of his own flesh on a bad morning. Yet, on Sunday he opens his mouth and God feeds him. So the Church has never been able to call the physical side of life spiritually unimportant.

So take care of your body, and do not worship it.

Eat, sleep, keep clean, see the doctor, and do not put your life at risk for no good reason. Luther said that a man who will not use medicine and common sense to look after his body is tempting God and must beware lest he become a suicide in God’s eyes. Caring for the body is simply good stewardship of what God has given. Our culture has mixed up this ordinary care with the pursuit of a perfect body and the two are very different things. Health is a blessing from God and still no one’s worth comes from it. A woman who lives to a hundred is no more faithful than one who dies at forty. In addition, sickness is not a sign that someone has failed. Some of it comes from our own choices and a great deal of it comes from genes, germs, accidents, and age. Whatever the cause, the sick person is our neighbor and he is owed our care before anyone asks how he came to be sick.

Illness does not make you less of a person.

Picture a man who worked hard for many years, raised a family, ushered on Sunday, and shoveled the walk for everyone on his street. A disease takes his legs. Then it takes his hands, then his speech, and at last his ability to feed himself. Is he less human now? The answer has to be no. His circumstances are different. He is the same man God made and Christ died for and the same neighbor who used to clear the snow.

Paul begged God three times to take away an affliction and was told, “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.” That answer does not make suffering good or going to the doctor a failure of faith but it tells us that weakness lies within the reach of God’s grace. Our Lord saved the world by being beaten and nailed to a cross while the people watching said He could not even save Himself.

What you do with your body is not private.

“You are not your own, for you were bought with a price. So glorify God in your body.” Paul wrote this about sexual sin and his whole argument rests on one fact: your body has been bought. The Small Catechism names the price, which was the holy, precious blood of Christ and His innocent suffering and death. If my body is not mine to use as I please, my neighbor’s certainly is not. That rules out exploitation, violence, and every arrangement where a human being becomes a thing for someone else’s use or profit. Those limits do not relax because the other person is weaker, poorer, younger, or dependent on me.

About suffering, and what not to say.

Some things should never be said to a person who is suffering. Do not tell him God sent this to teach him a lesson. You cannot know that and when people put that idea to our Lord about a man born blind, He rejected it. Do not tell him everything happens for a reason, which is a statement about fate and says nothing about God. Do not promise him that God will not give him more than he can handle. That verse is about temptation. Applied to suffering it is untrue, because God often lets His people carry more than they can handle so that they will stop trying to carry it themselves. Above all, never tell him that more faith would make him well. That is false and it is cruel. Here is what can be said:

His suffering is not a verdict. Job’s friends believed that anyone who suffers must have done something to deserve it and the book of Job was written in large part to overturn that belief. His suffering does not prove that God is punishing him for some particular sin and we have no authority to draw that conclusion.

God is not indifferent to it. The Son of God knows weakness, hunger, exhaustion, pain, and death in His own body. He went through suffering Himself instead of watching it from far off. He went through it knowing He could have stopped it at any moment and choosing not to.

God is at work in it, though we cannot say why He has allowed it. We do not say that God gives people cancer to make better people of them. We do say that He is present in it and that He has promised to work all things together for good for those who love Him. Most of the time that work cannot be seen while it is happening. We understand it later, if we ever do.

God is found where you would least think to look. Luther described two kinds of theologian. The first looks for God in strength, success, and visible blessing and ends up calling evil good and good evil. The second calls a thing what it really is and looks for God in suffering and in the cross, because that is where God has chosen to hide Himself. Luther’s point concerns where to look for God while the suffering lasts and it is the reason a Lutheran pastor at a bedside points to a crucifix.

Read him Romans 8. Read the text itself, aloud, from verse 31 to the end. It was written to be read to frightened people and it still works on them.

And it ends. It may not end in this life (Paul asked three times and was told no), but it does end. Parts 6 and 7 are about that and everything said here about the failing body should be read in their light.

When there is nothing left to cure.

Medicine is one of God’s great mercies and Christians accept it gratefully. Still, it cannot do away with death. Sooner or later every body comes to the end of what treatment can do and at that point we are tempted to think that a body which cannot be fixed no longer matters. It still matters. Caring goes on long after curing has stopped. The doctor who cannot take away the disease can still take away the pain. The daughter who cannot give her father his strength back can still bring him food, clean sheets, a shave, and her company. The pastor who can no longer hold a conversation with a dying member can still pray with him, read him the Psalms, and speak Christ’s promises over him.


4. The poor, the sick, and everyone easy to overlook

A lawyer once asked Jesus who his neighbor was and Luke says he asked it “desiring to justify himself.” He was looking for a limit, since a man who knows where his duty ends can stop worrying about it. Jesus answered him with a story. A man was robbed on the road and three travelers came by. Two of them walked past and one stopped. The Samaritan saw someone bleeding and went to him without asking whether the man deserved help or whether his own choices had landed him on that road. Then he paid for the room at the inn and promised to cover whatever more was needed when he came back that way. The end of the story is interesting. The lawyer had asked who is my neighbor, meaning whose need he was obliged to meet. Jesus asked him instead which of the three “proved to be a neighbor.” The lawyer wanted to know where his duty stopped and Jesus showed him what his calling was. Then He sent him away with a command and no definition at all: “You go, and do likewise.”

First, though: this is not how you get saved.

A congregation that gets the order wrong will end up either guilty or proud. Our charity does not justify us before God. The Augsburg Confession (the 1530 statement that is the heart of what Lutherans believe) states: we are justified freely, for Christ’s sake, through faith, and not by our own strength, merits, or works. Nobody is saved by how many hungry people he has fed, how many sick he has visited, or how much money he has given. Christ has done the saving and it is finished.

Yet, faith that holds on to Christ never shrugs at a neighbor in trouble. The Augsburg Confession says so a little further on. Faith is bound to bear good fruit and Christians are to do the good works God commands because God wills it, without counting on those works to earn anything. In other words, we do not serve our neighbor to talk God into loving us. We serve him because God already loves us and the neighbor is standing right there. Luther’s summary is worth learning by heart (the Christian is a perfectly free lord of all, subject to none, and a perfectly dutiful servant of all, subject to all) and both halves of it are true at the same moment.

Two kinds of righteousness.

Much of the confusion here comes from mixing up two different things and Luther gave us a way to keep them apart. The first is your standing before God. You did not build it and you cannot add to it, nor can a bad week damage it. It is Christ’s own righteousness credited to you, received by trusting His promise, and complete from the moment it is given. The second is what you do for other people: cooking the meal, paying the bill, making the visit, running your business honestly. That is righteousness too and Scripture speaks warmly of it. Luther says the first kind is what produces the second. It belongs out in the world where your neighbor can see it and benefit from it. It adds nothing at all to where you stand with God.

Mix them up and you become one of two people. Pour the second into the first and you get the Christian who quietly keeps track of his merits. He cannot put a dollar in the plate without wondering whether it counted. He is generous and he is unhappy and the unhappiness can pass for humility although underneath it he does not believe that Christ finished the work. Pour the first into the second and you get the Christian who has understood grace correctly and drawn the wrong conclusion from it. He can explain justification to you. He has not visited anyone in years. Keeping the two apart protects both. Your standing with God is settled and nothing can improve it so you are free to spend yourself on your neighbor without a thought for what it earns you. That freedom does not leave you sitting still either. In his preface to Romans Luther calls faith a living, busy thing and a faith like that goes looking for its neighbor.

Where your neighbor actually finds you.

If our good works do not go up to God, where do they go? God has no need of them. Your neighbor does. God has ordered the world in stations (the places where each of us already stands). You are someone’s child and perhaps someone’s parent, husband or wife, employee or employer. You are someone’s neighbor and a member of this congregation. Each of these places carries its own work and that work is how you serve God. Luther taught that God Himself is at work in it. He gives daily bread through the farmer and the baker and hides Himself so well in these ordinary jobs that we do not notice His hand. The first result is a relief, since nobody has to invent a special ministry in order to serve God. The mother up in the night with a sick child, the man who runs his business honestly when cheating would pay better, and the daughter who drives hours to sit with her father do not need to turn what they are doing into something more spiritual before it counts. The second result is less comfortable. Your station places your duties right where you are so you cannot simply watch the world go by. It is possible to hold strong opinions about the poor in general and do nothing for the family down the street. Your station gives you particular people with names and faces and most of them you did not choose.

The poor are not a category.

Poverty divides people. Those of us who are comfortable start to talk about “the poor” as a problem, a line in a budget, or a number we hope is moving in the right direction. Talking in general terms is convenient because it is not associated with a real person. The poor are in fact men, women, and children, each with a name, a history, and fears of their own, and they do not all need the same thing. One family needs a month’s rent. Another needs a job, a place to live, or treatment. Helping them also takes humility. Whatever I have, God gave me, and I live on His generosity exactly as much as anyone I help lives on mine. The one who writes the check is no better a person than the one who cashes it. Having money does not show that someone is righteous and being poor does not show that someone has sinned. The book of Job was written partly to refute that idea and what Jesus says about the rich should settle the matter.

The weakest members are the ones Paul calls indispensable.

Paul’s word is indispensable and he used it of the ones who seem weaker. If we measure members by what they can do for us, we have brought the world’s standard into the Church. The homebound widow who has not been in the sanctuary for years is as much a member of Christ’s body as anyone in the pew. The man with an intellectual disability is a Christian in full. The woman whose illness keeps her home most Sundays is owed as much of her pastor’s time as the man who serves on every committee. This has practical consequences for the building. A ramp, an accessible restroom, a hearing loop, a large-print bulletin, a pew cut short so a wheelchair can sit with the family and not out in the aisle, and someone willing to carry the Lord’s Supper to a bedside decide whether a member hears the Gospel or does not.

And mercy must not turn into condescension.

There is a danger hidden inside Christian charity. The person giving help begins to behave as the senior partner. He assumes the other person has nothing to contribute, makes decisions for him without asking, and talks about him in the third person while he sits right there. Mercy has then become a way of holding power over someone and it is hard to object to because it looks like kindness. The person receiving help still has a will, a conscience, relationships, and duties of his own. Wherever possible he should have a say in the decisions about his own life, even when that takes longer and he chooses what we would not have chosen. Needing help in one part of life says nothing about a person’s ability in all the others.

The early Church practiced this mercy before it owned buildings, kept budgets, or had any protection in law. Tertullian, answering the charge that Christians were a dangerous secret society, describes their common fund. Each member gave what he could, once a month and of his own free will. The money went to bury the poor, to support orphaned children, and to care for old people who could no longer leave the house. That, he says, is what outsiders comment on: see how they love one another. About two centuries later the emperor Julian tried to bring back the old pagan religion and got nowhere. He wrote in frustration that the Christians were gaining ground because “the impious Galileans” (his name for Christians) “support not only their own poor but ours as well.”

The Fathers preached this forcefully and did not go easy on property. Basil, who built a hospital outside his city for the poor and for lepers, told his people that the bread in their hands belonged to the hungry, the coat hanging in the closet to the naked, and the money hidden in the ground to the destitute. When they refused to give, they were wronging people in need, which is worse than falling short of generosity. John Chrysostom, the great preacher of Constantinople, preached the same message until it cost him. He said that the poor are an altar more to be revered than the one in the sanctuary and one we pass in every street.

We read these men gratefully. Their urgency was right and we have much less of it than they had. We do need one correction ready. Now and then they speak as if giving alms could atone for sin and there we do not follow them. Our Confessions teach that such gifts please God when they come from people already reconciled to Him by faith and that they earn nothing for those who are not. So we take the urgency and leave behind the idea that giving buys forgiveness. God does promise to reward the good works of His children, but as a Father’s gift and never as the price of salvation.

And a word about money, since mercy that never reaches a budget is a sentiment.

Giving is free. “Each one must give as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver” (2 Corinthians 9:7). No one may lay a set percentage or a dues assessment on a Christian’s conscience. Paul gives a better reason than compulsion: “you know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though he was rich, yet for your sake he became poor, so that you by his poverty might become rich” (2 Corinthians 8:9). His argument runs from the manger and the cross straight to the offering plate. Freedom from compulsion does not mean our giving can be allowed to accomplish nothing and a congregation that gives cheerfully and gives almost nothing has understood only half of what Paul said.

The help should be handed out by people who know the names: a small group the congregation trusts, who work discreetly, keep confidential records that only a few people ever see, and leave the pastor free to act at once when there is no time to call anyone together. The widow with the shut-off notice does not ask because she has no idea there is anything to ask for. So tell the congregation that the fund exists and tell them how to ask. Then make asking easy, private, and quick.

Most of this work is ordinary and no one writes it down. A member visits a widow. A family brings meals to someone home from surgery. A young man mows a yard that an elderly neighbor could no longer keep up. A congregation pays the utility bill for a family whose income stopped when the diagnosis came. Hardly any of it needs a committee, a name, or a mention in the newsletter.


5. Growing old, and dying

Growing old takes things away from us and seldom in the order we would pick. For most people the eyes go first, then the ears, then the strength to carry what used to be easy to carry. A job that took ten minutes starts to take an hour and then help is needed. For some, memory goes as well. A woman who kept a house, brought up her children, worked, buried her husband, and was the one the whole family phoned in trouble may now need those same children to get through a day. She is embarrassed by it, frustrated, and frightened. Her children are pulled between their jobs, their own families, money, and the miles between them and then they feel guilty for resenting any of it. None of it touches what she is worth.

The Fourth Commandment does not expire.

“Honor your father and your mother.” Luther explains it with a list of verbs (honor them, serve and obey them, love and cherish them). The Large Catechism spends longer on it than on any other commandment and Luther presses the point that the honor is owed for as long as our parents live. Paul is blunt: a person who will not provide for his own household “has denied the faith and is worse than an unbeliever.”

In old age that honor turns practical: groceries, rides to the doctor, the checkbook, the hard talk about the car keys, money, time, and the patience to hear one story again and again and to answer each time as if it were new. Our Lord did this from the cross. While He was dying for the sins of the world He saw to it that His mother would be looked after, because that duty was His.

However, the commandment does not require one person to do all of it at any price. There are illnesses that need trained nurses and there are houses that no amount of work will make safe. Some caregivers have sicknesses, jobs, and children of their own that put care around the clock out of reach. Pretending otherwise leaves two people in crisis instead of one. Moving a mother into a nursing home does not, by itself, mean the family has failed to honor her. A family can honor a father well by doing part of the work itself and paying for help with the rest. It is also possible to neglect a father who lives in his own daughter’s spare room. The question to ask, wherever she sleeps, is whether she is loved, kept safe, visited, and looked after.

Dementia.

Dementia can bring a woman who raised a family to the point where she no longer remembers her wedding day, loses the thread of a sentence halfway through, and cannot say the name of the daughter sitting next to her. Her family will often say that their mother is already gone. That is accurate about what they can see and dangerous as a belief about who she is. It would mean that a person exists in her memory and her thinking and then each of us would be a person only until our memory failed. She is still a human being and still the creature God made. Her family owes her everything it owed her before, even if she cannot tell who is doing the caring. She may be unable to say what she believes and God’s promises to her stand anyway. Losing the words of the Creed does not undo a Baptism. Forgetting is not unbelief. Faith was never a mental achievement by which we keep hold of God. It is His gift, worked and kept alive by His Word, and what settles the matter for a baptized woman is what God has done for her. She is held in His memory and His memory was what held her all along.

So keep bringing her the Word. A pastor can pray with someone who cannot answer him. He can read the Twenty-third Psalm, pray the Lord’s Prayer, and sing a verse of a hymn she learned as a child. The lips often remember what the mind has lost.

Families are afraid of doing the wrong thing with the Lord’s Supper, so it needs a plain answer. Begin by assuming she should keep receiving it. When Luther describes who is worthy to receive, memory is nowhere on his list. There are questions to work out (whether she can swallow safely, what she has confessed over the years, what this congregation practices) and they are questions about how she receives. The pastor works them out with the family one case at a time. He does not work them out by staying away.

Withdrawal is never the answer. The daughter who has stopped being able to walk through the door has been grieving her mother for years without being allowed to call it grief and the room now frightens her. To her I would say only this: go anyway and go without a plan, sit down and be her daughter, because there is nothing you are supposed to accomplish in that room.

The one who is doing the carrying.

The people who give the care need care themselves and they are usually nearer the breaking point than anyone else in the family. The work is almost never shared evenly. One child ends up with most of it (most often a daughter, most often the one who lives closest, and most often without anyone having decided it) while her brothers and sisters send advice from farther off. She is managing her mother’s pills, her own job, and her own children. Some days what she feels is resentment and after that she feels guilty for feeling it. Her resentment is what happens to anyone asked to carry more than one person can carry and telling her to be more patient will not help her. What she needs is plain and seldom given:

First, she needs relief: somebody else in the house for a weekend, taking the nights, the medicine, and the bathroom so that she can sleep. If a congregation cannot find people to give an afternoon each, the trouble is that nobody has asked them by name.

Second, she needs permission to feel what she feels. If she trusts you, sooner or later she will confess that on some days she wishes it were over and she will be appalled at herself for saying so. Tell her that a wish is not an intention. Nearly every caregiver has had that wish. Wanting someone’s suffering to stop is a different thing from wanting that person dead. Where there is something to absolve, absolve it, and where there is no guilt, do not invent any.

Third, someone has to tell her she is grieving, because in all likelihood no one has. A long decline takes a person away a piece at a time over years (first the conversations, later the recognition, until her own mother looks at her as if she were a stranger). She is grieving without any of the allowances grief is normally given and that is why so many caregivers are caught off guard by what they feel at the funeral. Saying the word grief to her may be the most useful thing a pastor does for her.

Fourth, she needs the truth about what a house can and cannot hold. Some care cannot be given safely at home. A family that once promised never to “put her in a home” may find that keeping the promise is hurting the very woman they made it to. Exhausted families often hear the Fourth Commandment as an order to wear themselves out and they need to hear otherwise.

Then there is the child who lives far away and visits at Christmas. You probably feel ashamed already and shame is usually what keeps people away. When you do come, stay a weekend instead of an afternoon and while you are there take all of it off her hands: the nights, the medicine, the bathroom, and the unpleasant parts along with the easy ones. In the weeks between, phone her and ask how she is holding up and let that conversation be about her. Thank her for all she is doing that you cannot do.

A word to the daughter as well. You are tired, not failing, and tiredness is not a sin to be repented of. Where you have been short with your mother, or have wished it over, or have gone two weeks without going, Christ forgives it. If it sits on you, come and hear it said to your face. Then go back and let someone else take a turn. Paul’s word to you is worth reading in the right order: “Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ” (Galatians 6:2) comes before “Let us not grow weary of doing good” (Galatians 6:9). The endurance is asked of someone who is supposed to be carrying part of a shared load, not the whole of it alone.

And the particular loneliness of being the one who is left.

It grows out of grief and yet it is something different. Picture an elderly widow. She has buried her husband, her brothers and sisters, most of her friends, and more acquaintances than she could list. Nobody still living knew her when she was a girl. Something funny happens and her hand goes to the phone before she remembers that the person who would have laughed at it for the same reasons is no longer there to answer.

Being there counts for more than feeling for her and being there means going. A short visit does more than any amount of concern felt from far off, because it breaks the silence and because what she has lost is being remembered by someone. Old people also have something to give and hardly anyone asks them for it. The Psalmist does not only ask to be kept; he asks to be kept for something: “do not forsake me, until I proclaim your might to another generation” (Psalm 71:18). Paul tells Titus that the older women are to teach the younger ones and that the older men are to set an example of sober and self-controlled living.

No one has forgotten you.

Psalm 71 was prayed by someone whose strength was leaving him: “Do not cast me off in the time of old age; forsake me not when my strength is spent.” Plenty of older Christians know that prayer. What they fear is less dying than being ignored while they are still alive. Many can no longer get themselves to church, which for a lifelong member is a grief the congregation rarely understands.

God answers through Isaiah and the answer is worth hearing whole because of who says He will do the carrying:

even to your old age I am he, and to gray hairs I will carry you. I have made, and I will bear; I will carry and will save. (Isaiah 46:4)

That is said to you. The Lord who made you has promised to carry you to the end and He has not set you down. An elderly Christian can no longer do for the Church what he once did and God’s faithfulness to him never depended on it. That is why visiting the homebound is central to a congregation’s ministry and should never be left for whenever there is time. The pastor takes the Word to people who can no longer get to it. He hears their confession and absolves them, prays with them, brings them the Supper where that is right, and tells an old man that Christ has not forgotten him and neither has his church.

Learning to die before you have to.

For a long stretch of its history the Church set out on purpose to teach people how to die. Handbooks on dying well were printed, with woodcuts, so that a Christian would come to his deathbed having already thought about it. Almost all of that is gone. Death has moved into hospitals, few of us have been in the room when it came and hardly anyone talks about it.

Luther wrote a book of this kind himself in 1519 and three pieces of its advice are worth keeping. The first is to put your affairs in order early (your will, and your forgiveness of anyone you are angry with, and theirs of you) so that when the time comes you have only one thing left to attend to. The second concerns the three pictures that crowd in on a dying man: death, sin, and hell. Luther says no one can face them down and anyone who tries will be crushed by it. He tells him to look away from them to Christ, in whom death has been defeated, sin has been carried, and hell has been closed. He is sharp about looking for comfort inside yourself (in your conscience, your feelings, or your own election), because no comfort lies there: “Seek yourself only in Christ and not in yourself.” The third is the most Lutheran of the three. People worry whether they have received the sacraments worthily. Luther turns them to the promise God attached to the sacraments. God does not lie. The absolution is His word, not the pastor’s opinion, and the body and blood given at the bedside are given for you. Receive them, he says, and then trust what they say instead of checking up on your own sincerity.

Simeon shows what it looks like when this has been learned. He holds the child and he is ready to go: “Lord, now you are letting your servant depart in peace… for my eyes have seen your salvation” (Luke 2:29–30). His peace comes from having seen what God promised him. Lutherans have long sung his song after the Lord’s Supper and it is placed there on purpose: people who have just received Christ stand up and sing the words of a man ready to die.

So do not wait for a diagnosis before you think about your own death and do not let your family’s first talk about it take place in a hospital hallway in the middle of the night. Put your wishes in writing. Tell someone where the papers are kept. Make the arrangements and pay for them if you are able. Then stop worrying about it and get on with living.

When treatment can no longer help.

When nothing will bring back health our task is to stay with the patient, neither abandoning him nor insisting that every remaining treatment be tried. The line here has to be drawn with care. The Fifth Commandment forbids the deliberate taking of an innocent life and it commands us to help and protect our neighbor’s life. It does not turn every available procedure into a duty. Some treatments hold out a hope of recovery or of relief. Others bring pain, confusion, separation from family, and weeks in intensive care while giving little or nothing back. To decline or stop a treatment of that second kind is a different act from killing the patient. A pastor who lets a family believe otherwise has failed them. The difference lies in what we are doing and what we intend by it. When a treatment that has become a burden is stopped and the patient is kept warm, clean, eased with medicine, and never left alone, we are allowing the disease to run its course while we go on caring for him until the end. The illness is what causes the death. Giving a lethal dose is euthanasia. Prescribing that dose for the patient to take himself is assisted suicide. In either case we have made ourselves the cause of the death and a merciful motive does not change what the act is.

One mistake holds that a life may be thrown away once the suffering is great enough or the dependence becomes a nuisance. The opposite mistake holds that life must be stretched out by every means for as long as the machines can manage it, as if death were a defeat we owe the patient to delay at any cost. Christians reject both for one reason. Our lives do not belong to us and they do not belong to medicine either: “whether we live or whether we die, we are the Lord’s.”

Some of you have already answered this (in a hallway, on no sleep, with a doctor waiting) and you have been turning it over ever since. When you told them to stop, you did not kill your mother. The cancer killed your mother. You declined more weeks of pain added to a death that was already coming. That is not the Fifth Commandment broken; it is the Fifth Commandment kept, because you went on caring for her when no one could cure her. If your conscience will not rest, bring it to me. I will tell you again that you did no wrong in this. Whatever else from those days weighs on you, I will absolve and it will be finished.

Hospice, and the conversations to have early.

At their best, hospice and palliative care (care aimed at comfort rather than at cure) are a work of mercy. They ease pain, bring under control the symptoms that frighten patient and family alike, support the whole household, and make it possible for someone to die at home with the people who love him instead of among strangers. A Christian may accept this care with a clear conscience. Accepting that you are dying is not wanting to die, still less causing death. Near the very end the body often cannot use food and fluids given by tube and a family should not be told they are starving their mother.

Have these conversations long before any crisis. None of it is morbid and none of it means giving up hope. It is one of the last acts of love a person can do for his family. The questions are simple. Who makes decisions for me if I cannot? What do I want done and what do I not want? Do I want my pastor called? Where will I be buried and has it been paid for?

What the pastor is there to do.

He comes to the deathbed as a minister of the Word and that is the reason he is in the room. The dying man may be afraid. He may be going over something he did years ago that he has never told a soul. Whatever it is, the pastor has come to proclaim Christ to him. He hears his confession and absolves him. He reads the Twenty-third Psalm, or John 14, or Romans 8, or whichever passage this man has leaned on through his life. He gives him the Supper while he is still able to receive it and he prays with the family. At the end he commends him to God in the Church’s old words: Into your hands, O merciful Savior, we commend your servant. They say out loud what the dying man can no longer say for himself and they echo the psalm our Lord prayed from the cross (Psalm 31:5; Luke 23:46).

A Christian does not enter death showing God how strong his faith has been. He goes with nothing in his hands because Christ has already done everything that needed to be done. If you are the one dying, or sitting beside him, hear it now: neither death nor life, nor anything else in all creation, can separate you from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord (Romans 8:38–39).


6. What we do with our dead

A death is a terrible thing. People reach for gentler language (a transition, a passing, a natural part of life) and they mean well by it. Scripture speaks more plainly. Death is an enemy, the last enemy Christ will destroy. It tears apart what God put together. The body that went to work, carried children, and knelt at the communion rail is still and the person who lived in it has gone. Even so, the body left behind belongs to a human being whom God created and for whom Christ died and for a Christian there is more to say than that: this is the body God has promised to raise. So we treat our dead with reverence. We take care with it for two reasons, the person it belonged to and what we confess God will one day do with it.

Scripture takes burial seriously.

The first land Abraham ever owned in the country God promised him was a grave. He was a foreigner there who owned nothing at all and Genesis gives a whole chapter to how he bought a burial place for Sarah. Jacob asked to be taken back out of Egypt and laid with his fathers. Joseph, when he was dying, made his brothers promise that they would take his bones with them when God led them out and for four hundred years his coffin waited in Egypt as a sign that God keeps His word. When Stephen was killed, devout men carried him away to be buried and mourned him loudly. The Church’s first martyr was not left lying where the stones had dropped him.

Our Lord’s own burial is the clearest case of all. Joseph of Arimathea went to Pilate and asked for the body and Nicodemus came with seventy-five pounds of spices. These were respected men and they did the work themselves. They wound the body in linen with the spices and laid it in a new tomb in a garden. John tells all of this carefully because the care is the point: the body of Jesus was honored, not simply got rid of. Then early on the first day of the week the women went to the tomb. They found the tomb empty and the linen wrappings lying where He had been.

Burial is something we say with our hands.

To lay a body in the ground is to admit that death is real. The words spoken to Adam, “You are dust, and to dust you shall return,” are spoken over every one of us and at a graveside nobody can pretend they are untrue. Christians have no reason to want to pretend. Our hope does not deny that a death has happened. Yet the grave is not where it ends and the things the Church says at a grave make that plain. Paul’s picture is a seed: what is sown perishable is raised imperishable, sown in weakness and raised in power. He does not mean that a buried body can sprout by some power of its own. Only God raises the dead and a corpse can no more bring itself back to life than the dust could have formed itself into Adam. The seed shows how the two ends are joined: the one who goes into the ground and the one who comes up out of it are the same person, changed. In other words, the man we bury is the man God will raise, though not in the condition we left him.

Your Baptism already said this about you once. “We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death.” At the font you were buried with Christ. The grave will be your second burial and it is the first one that decides how the second will turn out. That makes the grave a place to wait. The New Testament’s favorite word for the Christian dead is asleep and our word cemetery comes from the Greek for a sleeping place. The word speaks about the body lying in the ground and the sure hope that it will be woken. It does not describe the soul, which is with Christ.

The funeral.

A Christian funeral is first a service of the Word. The Scriptures are read and Christ is preached. The congregation prays, sings, and gives thanks, and the family goes home with something to hold on to that will last well after the flowers have been thrown away. It is right to remember the one who died and to thank God for her life. The risk (and it is a real one when everybody loved her) is that the service drifts away from its subject. The tributes get longer and the Gospel gets shorter. Nobody plans it that way and yet people leave having been told that a good woman has gone to her reward. That sounds comforting. In fact it is the Law (what God demands, as opposed to what He gives), because every person in the room knows privately that they could not pass the same test. No one enters eternal life for being a loving husband, a kind neighbor, a faithful member of the church council, or a devoted grandmother. We enter through Jesus Christ and that is what the funeral sermon is there to say.

The prayers at the casket, and what they do.

The pastor prays at the casket and commends the one who has died to God by name. He is not making her holy and nothing he does there changes where she stands with God. Forgiveness and eternal life come through faith in Jesus Christ; a ceremony held afterward neither grants them nor confirms them. We do pray for our dead (“receive him into the arms of your mercy”) and the Confessions do not forbid that. They reject using the Lord’s Supper as a good work to be spent on a dead man’s behalf. In other words, praying for our dead is permitted to us; treating any rite as a transaction carried out over them is not. We ask God to do for her what He has promised: keep her and raise her on the Last Day. Those prayers give no one a second chance after death. Nor do we pronounce on anyone’s last hour. We do not know what passed between God and the one who was dying and we commend her to the God who does.

Seen in that light, every part of a funeral is teaching something. The funeral service in our worship book provides for meeting the body at the church door, for recalling Baptism with the words of Romans 6, for the commendation at the coffin (commending her to God), for the committal at the grave (laying her to rest), and for the sign of the cross in the closing blessing. Other things are custom. The white cloth over the casket is called the pall and it is the Church dressing the one who has died in the white garment of her Baptism. The tall candle at the head of the coffin is the paschal candle, first lit at Easter, and it stands there because everything we believe about death rests on Easter. Neither is ancient in this use. The pall used to be black and the Easter candle stayed in its own season; Lutherans, Anglicans, and Roman Catholics all gave them these meanings within the last century, at about the same time and from the same convictions about Baptism and Easter.

When the body is committed “in sure and certain hope of the resurrection to eternal life” (words that go back to Thomas Cranmer’s English Prayer Book of 1549), the Church is not saying that the rite causes the resurrection. Christ is the one who raises the dead. The rite declares His promise over a body that cannot hear it, for the sake of the people standing around it who need to. Giving thanks for her Baptism fits at this point for the same reason. It turns the family’s eyes away from what their mother did and toward what God did for her.

Why I would rather we buried our dead.

God does not need an intact body in order to raise anyone and the section on cremation below says so. My reason is that burial says with the body what we confess with our mouths in the Creed and it goes on saying so long after the mourners have left the cemetery. All through a life the body is received from God as a gift. It is fed and washed, nursed through illness, and treated with honor. At death the people who loved him handle it gently, carry it out, and lay it in the ground to wait. The congregation can see for itself that the body given into God’s keeping is the same one that sat beside them in the pew. Burial also leaves a place behind, where a family can stand and children can be told who these people were. Two of the hardest truths of our faith sit side by side in that ground (the grave, telling us that every one of us will die, and the cross on the stone or the marker in the grass, telling us that death is not the end of the story).

There are limits to my own argument. Nowhere does Scripture require that a Christian be buried in the earth and in no other way. The Confessions set no such rule either and no pastor may bind your conscience where God has left it free. Treating a good custom as though it were God’s command is an error our Confessions take up again and again. So burial can be warmly commended, faithfully taught, and gladly chosen, and none of that means that a family who chose differently has sinned.

Cremation.

Most people in this country are now cremated, though a hundred years ago it was almost unheard of here. The reasons are usually practical. Cremation is far cheaper than burial. Families live far apart and the children who might have looked after a grave have moved away. Sometimes a death simply comes at a bad time for the family’s finances. The theological question is whether cremation stops God from raising the dead, or makes it any harder for Him. It does not. It does not in the least and no Christian needs to carry that fear. The God who shaped Adam from the dust is not troubled by ashes. A buried body turns to dust too; it only takes longer and the time it takes is the only difference between them. Christians have died in fires, at sea, in mine collapses, and in wars that left nothing to bring home, and the Church has never once doubted that God will raise them. Stand at the grave of someone who died a very long time ago and you will see that if God needed remains in good condition, none of us would rise. Cremation cannot put anyone out of Christ’s reach.

There is a separate question here and a fair one: what does the practice say? The way we treat our dead teaches something whether we mean it to or not. The early Christians preferred burial to the Roman funeral pyre and their pagan neighbors took note of it. In a Christian dialogue from those years the pagan speaker grumbles that Christians “execrate our funeral piles, and condemn our burials by fire,” which is to say they curse the pyres. The Christian’s reply is worth hearing. He says (using an old word for burial, sepulture), “Nor, as you believe, do we fear any loss from sepulture, but we adopt the ancient and better custom of burying in the earth.” One of the oldest Christian words on this subject is the one I am arguing: the way a body is laid to rest takes nothing away from God’s power and the Church buries its dead because burial is the older and better way. If someone chose cremation on purpose to reject the resurrection, or because they held the body in contempt, that would go against our confession and I would say so. That is almost never what is going on. A widow who chooses cremation because she cannot afford a funeral has not denied the Creed and a pastor who treats her as if she had has read her wrongly and hurt her. In short: I would rather we buried our dead, but I will not stand at the door of the church and criticize anyone’s arrangements. Cremation does not prevent the resurrection and it is not a rejection of the Christian faith.

What to do with the ashes.

Ashes are what remains of a human being who bore God’s image and for whom Christ died so they are owed the same reverence as a body. The best thing to do with them is to give them a lasting place. That gives the family somewhere to go, whether it is a grave, a niche in a columbarium (a wall of small compartments made to hold urns), or a corner of ground with a stone on it. The family can stand there and one day so can grandchildren who were born after she died and who learn her name for the first time in that spot. A place like that helps a family admit that she has died, which grief needs and does not always get. It also gives the Church one more opportunity to do its own work: her remains can be committed with Scripture, prayer, and the preaching of the resurrection, so that the last words said over her are the Gospel. This is what I would counsel whether the body was buried or burned. If a family cannot afford a plot, the congregation should quietly find a way to help.

I would therefore gently discourage the arrangements that leave no such place (the urn kept indefinitely on a shelf, the ashes divided among the children, the scattering over water, ashes made into jewelry). People choose these things out of love and because letting go is hard and nothing could be more understandable than that.

Some of you scattered your father’s ashes years ago because it was what he asked for, or divided them because there were several of you and one urn, or have had him on a shelf for years because no one could bear to be the one who decided. If you have been reading this with a knot in your stomach, you may set it down. Scripture gives no command here, the Confessions give none, and a preference of mine is not a law over anyone’s conscience. You did not put your father beyond the reach of Christ and you did not lose him. God has never needed our help keeping track of His people and on the Last Day He will not be searching. Your father will be raised from wherever he is. We do not need to hold on to the ashes in order to hold on to the promise. The counsel above is for the family standing in a funeral home this week with the decision still in front of them. It is not a verdict on the family that already made it. If your father’s ashes are still on a shelf, then the decision is still in front of you too and unfinished things can be finished. Come and ask. It takes very little to arrange, it can be done quietly with a few people, and it finishes something that has been open for a long time.

Giving the body away: autopsy, donation, medical science.

These questions usually come at the worst possible moment, with no warning, and from someone the family has never met.

An autopsy does no harm to the person and has nothing to do with his resurrection. The law sometimes requires one and sometimes it is the only way a family finds out what really happened, which can matter a great deal to those left behind and to children who may have inherited the same condition. You may agree to it with a clear conscience. It is reasonable to ask that the body be handled with care and given back to you for burial.

Organ and tissue donation is a real good and I would encourage it, provided the donor is truly dead and nothing is done to hasten his death. Giving a cornea, a kidney, or a liver is the Fifth Commandment’s positive side (helping our neighbor in every bodily need), carried out for a stranger who will never learn the donor’s name, and it costs the one who has died nothing at all. We have already seen that God does not need the body whole in order to raise it. A family that decided against donation did nothing wrong either, since God has given no command here.

Donating your whole body to a medical school is harder. It is a genuine gift. Doctors have to learn anatomy somehow and every surgeon who has ever operated on someone in this congregation learned on a body that a family gave. I hesitate over what happens afterward. The school may keep the body for a year or longer. Usually only ashes come back, if anything comes back at all, and often no service of any kind has been held. That is no sin. Yet, it gives up exactly what this part of the book has been arguing for: a place, a service, and the Gospel spoken over what is left. My counsel is therefore practical rather than prohibitive. If you plan to do this, plan the ending as well. Find out what the school does with remains, whether they are returned and when, and whether your family can receive them. Then tell your pastor and arrange the committal ahead of time, so that when the school is finished someone will know to bring the family to a graveside and read God’s promises there.

When someone takes his own life.

The question comes up at nearly every funeral after a suicide, often from someone who can hardly bring himself to ask it. For centuries a person who took his own life could be refused Christian burial and put in the ground outside the churchyard wall and his family then had to carry that verdict on top of their grief. The practice was supposed to discourage suicide. Whatever it discouraged, it certainly punished, and it punished the wrong people, because the man who had died was beyond the reach of any warning.

First, we do not pretend. Suicide breaks the Fifth Commandment, which forbids taking an innocent life and does not exempt one’s own. A person’s life is no more his to end than his neighbor’s life is. To say anything else, however kindly it was meant, would drop the commandment at the very point where a suffering person most needs to hear that his life is not his to throw away, and in every congregation there are people nearer that edge than anyone realizes. Second, we do not presume. We do not know what was going on in that mind. Deep depression, psychosis, the confusion brought on by pain or by a drug: these are illnesses of the mind itself and a person in their grip is not choosing freely in any sense we would recognize. God has never given the Church the authority to say who is lost and it does not gain that authority by standing at a graveside. We may say what the commandment says. Where this man is now we may not say, because we were not told and we do not know.

We can say what we would say at any Christian funeral. This man was baptized. God put His name on him and made him promises that never depended on the way he died. Christ died for the sins of the whole world and this one is among them. So we bury him with the full rites of the Church, we preach Christ over him as we would over anyone, and we commend him to the God who knows what we do not.

If you are the one who found him, or the one who did not answer the phone that evening, or the one who has spent years going back over the last conversation hunting for the sentence that would have changed it, hear this: you did not do this. Whatever you did actually get wrong in those years (and there will be something, because between any two people there always is), Christ died for it and there is nothing left of it for you to pay. If you cannot believe this, bring it to me and I will say it to you openly.

If you are the other one — if you are reading this at an hour when nothing looks survivable — hear the rest of it before you put the book down. Your life is not a burden God is enduring. He made it, He bought it with His Son’s blood, and He is not finished with you. Tell someone tonight, tonight and not tomorrow. Tell me. I will not be shocked. I will keep what you tell me as carefully as I can, but if your life is in danger I will get you help. If you cannot reach me, call or text 988, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, at any hour of the day or night. If you are in immediate danger, call 911.

The rest of us tend to go silent about a death like this. We intend it as tact but to the widow it feels as if her husband had been erased from the church’s memory and the one person everyone is thinking about becomes the one person nobody mentions. Say his name. Say it to her, even years later. Nobody expects you to have the right words. She is waiting to hear that someone other than her still remembers that he lived. Then stay with that family long after the funeral, because this grief is different from the others. Guilt is mixed into it, and anger with nowhere to go, and a question no one can answer, and the people who carry it are at risk themselves.

What to settle before you need it.

None of this helps much if a family reads it for the first time on the morning someone has died. So settle these things now, while everyone is well. God does not command any of it. Dying without a written plan is no sin and a family left to guess is not being punished for anything. It is a matter of love and of thinking ahead rather than of law. I would far rather you did it badly this month than perfectly never.

Write down what you want and tell your family where to find it. Do not put it in a safe deposit box, since those sometimes cannot be opened until after the funeral. Say whether you want to be buried or cremated, and where. Nothing causes more family arguments at a death than this. The argument is rarely about the method itself. Usually it is about a son who lives far away and was never asked and it turns bitter because everyone is worn out. A sentence in your own handwriting settles it before it starts. If you will be buried, sort out the plot now: where it is, whether it has been paid for, and who is already buried in it. Families too often find out at the worst moment that a plot bought long ago has no record, or that it has room for two while three people expect to use it. If you will be cremated, say what should happen to the ashes and when. Our generation tends to skip this step and that is exactly how an urn sits on a shelf for a decade because no one wants to be the one who decides.

Choose the hymns and the readings. Pick ones a congregation can really sing. Say what should be done with your body before the funeral too: embalming or not, a viewing or not, an open casket or a closed one. Families often disagree strongly about viewings and your wishes will settle it. Finally, tell your family whether you want your pastor called before you die and not only after. Many people think of that call as a courtesy paid once someone has died but the pastor comes to do things he cannot do once you have gone.

Then put the papers away and stop thinking about them. The purpose is to have the practical arrangements finished, so that when the time comes the people who love you can pay attention to you instead of to a funeral director’s checklist.

When there is no body at all.

Sometimes there is nothing to bury. Someone is lost at sea, or dies in a fire or a collapsed building, or is killed in a war far from home. Families in that position carry a particular kind of pain, because without a body their grief lacks the evidence it needs and some of them wait for years without really being able to begin. Their loved one has lost none of his dignity and his resurrection is not in doubt. Christian hope has never depended on our being able to find a body, keep it, or bury it. God says to His people, “Behold, I have engraved you on the palms of my hands” and that record will outlast every cemetery’s. Hold the memorial service anyway. Read the Gospel, pray for the family, commend the one who died to God’s mercy, and let the congregation do with words what it could not do with a casket. If that is your family, God knows where your son is and He will raise him.


7. Together again

Death is an enemy, not a friend.

After a death people say what they can to make the loss easier to bear. Death is a natural part of life. He is at peace. She is in a better place. They mean it kindly. Each of them takes for granted that nothing terrible has happened. Yet, death was never part of what God intended for the world He made. Scripture calls it the wage of sin and the last enemy and the Son of God came to destroy it and to rescue us from it, never to make us comfortable with it. So a Christian may grieve without apology. Tears are no sign that faith is weak. When Jesus stood at the tomb of Lazarus He already knew that in a few minutes He would call His friend out alive and still He was deeply moved and wept with Mary and Martha. Anyone who tells a mourner at a funeral to stop crying did not learn that from Christ.

We need not pretend that death does not hurt us and cause grief. It takes the people we love. The conversation stops, the chair at the table stays empty, and a voice we could have picked out of any crowd is gone from the world. Death wounds us! However, there is one plain fact about this enemy: he has been beaten, because Christ is risen from the dead.

What happens when a Christian dies?

At the moment of death the body is laid in the earth and the soul goes to be with Christ. Paul said his desire was “to depart and be with Christ, for that is far better,” and he wrote of being “away from the body and at home with the Lord.” To the thief on the cross our Lord promised, “today you will be with me in paradise.” That is comfort and it belongs to the hour of dying. If you have been holding on to the promise that the one you love is with Christ, keep holding on to it. It is true.

The Creed ends on something larger. It does not stop at the soul’s going to God. It goes on to confess the resurrection of the body. On the Last Day Christ will raise the dead and join each soul to its body again and those who belong to Him will live forever as whole people in a creation made new. Much of what Christians say to one another has let this slip. The heaven on most sympathy cards is a place where souls live on without their bodies, which is a smaller hope than the one God has given us. He raises the dead and He makes all things new.

It all rests on one event.

Paul hangs the entire faith on Christ’s rising: “if Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is in vain and your faith is in vain.” Take Easter away and nothing is left of the Gospel. Lazarus was given back his old life and later died again. Jesus came out of the tomb in a glorified body over which death has no power at all. Paul calls Him “the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep,” which is a farmer’s word. The firstfruits were the first sheaves of the harvest, gathered ahead of the rest and offered to God as a pledge that the whole field would follow.

How Paul actually argues it.

In First Corinthians 15 Paul takes up the resurrection in an order we would not have expected and the order itself teaches something.

He begins with the witnesses, the people who saw the risen Lord, before he says anything about doctrine. Christ died, was buried, was raised on the third day, and was seen by Peter and by the Twelve. Then He was seen by more than five hundred at one time, “most of whom are still alive, though some have fallen asleep,” and after that by James, by all the apostles, and finally by Paul. The note about the five hundred was an invitation to go and find them and ask. Next Paul reasons backward from denial. He supposes the resurrection is false and follows that to the end without softening it. Our preaching would be empty and so would your faith. The apostles would be telling lies about God. You would still be in your sins. Those who died trusting in Christ would simply be gone. “If in Christ we have hope in this life only, we are of all people most to be pitied.” Paul leaves himself no retreat. He does not hold back some other Christianity that could carry on as a set of good morals if Christ’s body were still in the grave. Everything is placed on the one claim that He rose.

Only after that does he take up the question everybody asks: “with what kind of body do they come?” Paul states that what is sown perishable is raised imperishable. What is sown in dishonor is raised in glory and what is sown in weakness is raised in power. What is sown a natural body is raised a spiritual body. The phrase “spiritual body” is where most people go wrong. Paul does not mean that we will rise as spirits. If he did, the word body would mean nothing and the chapter would have no point. He is comparing two ways a body can be alive. The body we have now is kept going by ordinary natural life. The body we will have is kept going by the Spirit of God. In other words, it is the same body, now entirely in the Spirit’s power, and for that reason it can no longer wear out or decay. The risen Christ shows us what this looks like. He ate fish with His disciples and He invited Thomas to touch His wounds.

The chapter closes with a taunt thrown at death and then with the sentence that tells us why all of this had to happen: “The sting of death is sin, and the power of sin is the law. But thanks be to God, who gives us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ.” Sin is what gives death its sting and the Law is what gives sin its strength. When the sin is taken away the sting goes too. We cannot take it away ourselves. God gives the victory as a gift. Then Paul turns from the Last Day back to the present and draws a therefore for ordinary life: “be steadfast, immovable, always abounding in the work of the Lord, knowing that in the Lord your labor is not in vain.” Because the body will be raised, the faithful work we do in the body now is never wasted.

What will the raised body be like?

Here Scripture makes promises and does not hand us a description. The raised body will be imperishable, glorious, and strong. The weakness, corruption, and death we carry now will not be carried into it. People ask questions that no verse answers (will my mother be young again, will my son have back the arm he lost, will the scars still show). Job is the best guide for questions like these. He trusted far more than he knew and he said so: “And after my skin has been thus destroyed, yet in my flesh I shall see God, whom I shall see for myself, and my eyes shall behold, and not another.” In my flesh. My eyes. Not another. Job had no idea how God would do it. He knew that God would be the one doing it and that the man raised up would be Job himself.

Scripture does give us one clear comparison. Christ “will transform our lowly body to be like his glorious body.” So whatever the raised body is, it will not be more of what we suffer now. It will also be the same body that was baptized.

The longing to see them again.

Of everything death does to us, the separation hurts the most. A widower has lost the one person he confides all things to. He keeps finding this out at odd moments when something happens and there is nobody to tell. Parents who have lost a child grieve him again and again: on his birthday, in the year he would have started school, at the graduation of another family’s son. Grown children who have buried both parents speak of a kind of dizziness when it dawns on them that no one alive remembers them as small.

The church at Thessalonica was grieving in just this way. Paul did not order them to stop. He told them not to grieve “as others do who have no hope,” which is another matter altogether, and he told them why:

For the Lord himself will descend from heaven with a cry of command, with the voice of an archangel, and with the sound of the trumpet of God. And the dead in Christ will rise first. Then we who are alive, who are left, will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air, and so we will always be with the Lord. Therefore encourage one another with these words. (1 Thessalonians 4:16–18)

So you may look forward to seeing your people again. The promise itself holds out that hope and there is nothing sentimental about it. Yet, being reunited is not the heart of heaven. The Lord Himself is our hope and our joy in one another will come from being with Him. We will be together because we will be with Him. There is more here than a date in the future. If you are dreading the first Sunday after the funeral, let me tell you what you are walking into. We do not commune alone. We commune “with angels and archangels and with all the company of heaven,” and that company includes the man whose hymnal is still in the rack where he left it. The separation is real, but it is not total. At that rail the Church on earth and the Church with Christ are at one Supper. You will kneel where he knelt and you will receive the same body that was given for both of you from the same Lord who has him now and will not lose you. Come forward.

Together with them. Paul comforts the grieving with a promise: Christ will raise their dead and gather His whole people, the living and the dead, to Himself at one time. Then he tells the congregation to comfort one another with these words.

Will we know each other?

Pastors are often asked this on the drive home from the cemetery. The answer is yes. Scripture does not explain how we will recognize one another but it gives good reason to expect that we will. After Easter Jesus is still Jesus. His disciples know Him (even if not always at first) and He shows them His hands and His side. He is the same Man they had followed and His history is still His own. God promises to raise the very people who died and Paul’s words together with them take it for granted that those people will know one another. No one enters everlasting life as less than he was and God loses nothing of what made you yourself. We should not claim to know more than Scripture tells us and we have no need to.

And the world itself.

Our hope reaches past each one of us to the whole creation. Paul says creation is “groaning together in the pains of childbirth,” while we who believe “wait eagerly for adoption as sons, the redemption of our bodies.” A sick world groans and a sick man groans. God will answer both of them together. John was shown what that answer looks like:

Behold, the dwelling place of God is with man. He will dwell with them, and they will be his people, and God himself will be with them as their God. He will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain anymore, for the former things have passed away. (Revelation 21:3–4)

Every part of life this companion has walked through carries the marks of sin: the unborn child cannot protect himself; the body falls ill and gives out; the poor do without; the old grow weaker and busy people forget them; the dying are torn from their bodies and from the people they love. Mourners stand beside an open grave. None of it will come with us into everlasting life.

The judgment, which cannot be left out.

We cannot speak honestly about the Last Day and keep quiet about half of what the Church confesses concerning it. Each of the creeds we say names the judgment. In the words of the Nicene Creed, “He will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead.” Daniel foresaw that some would wake to everlasting life and some to shame. Our Lord said that everyone in the tombs will hear His voice and come out, “those who have done good to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil to the resurrection of judgment” (John 5:29).

Our Confessions are just as clear. The Augsburg Confession teaches that Christ will raise all the dead, will give eternal life to the godly, and will condemn ungodly men and the devils “to be tormented without end,” and it rejects the gentler teaching that such punishment will one day run its course. I would rather not have written that sentence. However, it is our Lord’s own word before it is our confession’s: “And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life” (Matthew 25:46).

Two things belong with that statement. The first is that you do not go to that day unknowingly. At the font God gave you His saving promise in Christ, a promise to be received and held by faith, when He put His name on you before you had done anything to deserve it. It is announced again every time a man stands in front of you and says the absolution, that in the stead and by the command of the Lord Jesus Christ you are forgiven all your sins. It is put into your hands at the Communion rail. That is what the Gospel is for: to deliver the sentence of the Last Day in advance, so it can be believed now instead of dreaded then. If this part has frightened you, you have not misread it. That fear is old and common and many faithful Christians have carried it their whole lives. I would rather absolve it than argue with it, so let me: Christ has already taken your judgment. The Judge on that bench is your brother and nothing in your life is going to surprise Him. Come Sunday and receive His forgiveness.

The second thing is that Scripture’s language of judgment “according to works” does not describe a second road to salvation. The Bible speaks of the judgment in this way and still never makes our works the reason for the verdict. Eternal life is given because God has promised it. The good works of those He has reconciled to Himself please Him because they come from faith, and on that day they will be named as its evidence, never as its price.

Why bring the judgment up at all? Because a church that preaches the resurrection as only a happy ending has turned the Gospel into something everyone could expect anyway. Leave the judgment out and nobody seems to need saving and then the empty tomb means very little. The dead do not rise because rising simply happens to all of us in the end. They rise because Christ calls every one of them out of the grave (John 5:28–29), and those who are His rise to life because He was raised and has claimed them as His own.

Grief, in the meantime.

None of this takes away the pain of being parted now. You can trust with all your heart that your wife is with Christ and still weep at the table each morning. You can confess the resurrection of the body every Sunday and still come apart when you find a note in her handwriting. Faith holds on to Christ’s promises while the grief goes on.

For this reason a congregation’s care for the bereaved cannot stop on the day of the funeral. The casseroles and the sympathy cards are over in a few weeks and the grief lasts for years. The hard days are the birthdays, the anniversaries, the first Christmas, and the ordinary day that catches someone off guard. On those days a congregation can do what the funeral could not. Visit them. Call them. Say the name of the one who died, since most people avoid it and the family is longing to hear it. Do not rush anyone into looking as though they are over it and do not take a person’s ability to get through the day as proof that the sorrow has gone.


8. What this asks of a congregation

A congregation cannot confess the dignity of the human being and then put the doctrine on a shelf. Either the confession shapes how the congregation lives or it shows how far the congregation has fallen short of it. A church can teach the sanctity of life and forget its widows. It can preach about the family and never help the family sitting behind them whose father is out of work. It can confess the resurrection of the body every Sunday and hand the care of the dying over to professionals. The first people to notice are always the ones being passed over.

Children belong in the congregation with no conditions attached: children from comfortable homes and from struggling ones, healthy children and children with disabilities, children whose parents are married, unmarried, widowed, or going through something the rest of us know nothing about. Our Lord answered the question when He took a child in His arms in front of the disciples and said, “Whoever receives one such child in my name receives me.” Young families need adult company and practical help more than a curriculum and they need to hear that a crying child is welcome in church. We sometimes call children the future of the Church and the phrase comes too easily, since they are members of the Church today and they need Christ today. The Church serves them by baptizing them, teaching them the faith, and standing behind the parents God has given them.

The sick should never be left to conclude that they have failed. A long illness is no evidence that a person’s faith is lacking and nobody should hear from a neighbor in the pew or from the prayer chain that stronger faith would have brought a better scan. Christ came for the weak and for sinners and for people who cannot fix themselves.

The ones who cannot easily get here should be on someone’s mind. Can someone using a walker make it from the parking lot to a pew? Can a person whose eyesight is failing read the bulletin? Are the homebound visited regularly, or only when somebody happens to think of them? Who has been missing for a while and has anyone picked up the phone? Is the family caring for a disabled child being helped, or only admired? Every congregation will answer these differently and none of them can meet every need with a program. Any congregation can make a habit of noticing who is missing and calling them.

Teach the young this before they need it. Almost everything in this companion comes into a person’s life without warning and at a time when learning anything new is out of the question. The answer is to teach it early, to children and young people, while they are not yet in the middle of it.

Our great-grandparents had an easier time of this than we do. People used to die at home. Children saw the body, helped take food to the neighbors, stood at the grave, and by the time they were grown had been to enough funerals to know what one was. Today people die in hospitals and care homes, professionals handle the body, and children are often kept away so that they will not be upset. So adults reach middle age, see a dead body for the first time, and have no idea what to say or what to do with their hands.

Bring the children to funerals. Answer the question they asked, which is usually simpler than the grown-ups fear. Use the word died instead of passed or lost or gone to sleep (the last of these has scared more children than the plain truth ever did). Take them to the cemetery and show them the family stone. A child who has stood in a churchyard and heard his father read the Twenty-third Psalm aloud will carry that with him into old age.

Teach the Catechism and include the hard parts: the Fifth Commandment in both its halves, the First Article with its word about where each of us came from, and the Third Article, which ends with the resurrection of the body and gives a child his first plain word that he will die and that dying will not be the end. Teach the hymns as well. The Church has always kept its teaching within reach through what it sings and a man whose memory is failing will often still know the hymns his mother sang.

Remember the congregation’s own dead. The members of a congregation who have died in Christ are still its members, though it will not see them again in this life. The Church sets aside All Saints’ Day for them. In many places it has also become the day to remember those who died in the past year (other churches keep the next day, All Souls’, for that), and that is fine so long as it stays the Church confessing that the company of the redeemed is much larger than the people who fit in the building. Reading aloud the names of those buried from this congregation during the year is a custom worth keeping and families come for it. A churchyard, where a congregation has one, is neither a nicety nor a chore for the mower. The congregation’s own dead are waiting there for the resurrection and everyone who walks past it on the way into church is reminded of that each Sunday. Keep it up and keep its records.

The dying and the bereaved need the congregation for the longest time and that is exactly when visits fall off, because people do not know what to say. Go anyway. You do not need the right words. Sitting quietly beside someone is the whole of the work. After the funeral the family still belongs to this congregation and they still belong to it in April when everyone else has gone back to normal life and they have not. Where we have failed at this (and no congregation has done it well, mine included), the answer is the same absolution we hand everybody else.

We do not make people worthy of love by choosing to love them. The unborn child is not made worth protecting by our saying so. The disabled man does not gain value on the day the ramp is finished. The widow in the nursing home does not receive her dignity on the afternoon her pastor at last comes to see her. Every one of them was worthy of love already. Our work is to see what God has made and to treat it that way.


Where this leaves us

Every life starts out wholly dependent on others. A baby cannot speak or walk or feed himself. Someone else does all of it and nobody expects anything different. Then we grow up. We get stronger, learn a trade, build something, marry, raise children, carry others for a time, and are counted on. Somewhere along the way, without ever choosing to, most of us come to think of our lives as our own property. It is a comfortable thought and it does not survive the second half of life. The body weakens. Our abilities leave us, and not in the order we would have picked. We learn that we cannot keep hold of our lives and in time we give up trying and then we die. The body a parent once carried in his arms is carried out of the church by six people who loved him.

If our dignity rested on strength or intelligence or independence or usefulness, it would go up and down over the course of a life. A newborn would have hardly any. A man with a disability would have less than the man next door. An old woman would see hers slip away year by year. The dead would have none left.

The Church confesses something altogether different. Our dignity rests on what God has done for us. God made human life. He made us in His image and gave us body and soul, senses and reason, and He keeps all of it going every day without being asked. When sin and death had spoiled everything after the Fall, He did not abandon what He had made. The Son of God became man. He was conceived in a mother’s womb and born a baby and He knew hunger and thirst, weariness and grief. He laid His hands on the sick whom others were afraid to touch. He gathered up the children His disciples were trying to send away. He preached to the poor and ate with people the respectable kept their distance from and He never counted weakness as a reason to pass anyone by. Then He gave His life on a cross and He bought us back not with gold or silver but with His holy, precious blood.

The cross did not finish Him. On the third day He rose from the grave in His body. He kept His human nature and rose as the Lord who had been crucified, the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep, and He has promised to raise all who belong to Him.

Everything in this companion comes down to a few ordinary things we do. We welcome a child with thanks because life is a gift from God and not something we own. We take care of the body because God made it good. We serve the poor, the sick, and the disabled because they are our neighbors. We honor the old because dignity does not fade as strength does. We stay with the dying because Christ went through death and came back. We treat the bodies of our dead with reverence, and we bury them, because death does not undo what God has made and because we believe the grave will not keep them.

None of this takes the loss away. We know what it is to sit at a bedside and hold a hand that no longer holds ours back. We know how quiet a house is a week after the funeral, when the food is gone and the cards have stopped and the one we loved is still missing. Christians grieve (and we grieve hard) and our faith has never told us not to.

Yet, we have been given a promise from the only Man who has gone through death and come back. He is the resurrection and the life. A day is coming when the graves will open at His voice and the dead in Christ will be raised imperishable. Body and soul will be joined again and the whole people of God will be gathered into the presence of their Lord (every one of them, the ones we buried and the ones we never had the chance to bury). Death will be no more. Neither will mourning, nor crying, nor pain, and He will wipe away every tear from their eyes. Until that day we receive life with thanks, guard it with love, uphold it with mercy, and when death comes we commend it to the God who raises the dead.

If you have read this far, it is likely that something in your own home sent you to it. Perhaps you are deciding what to do about a parent who can no longer be left alone. Perhaps you are carrying something from years ago that you have never told another soul. Perhaps you have an urn on a shelf and a knot in your stomach, or you buried someone in the spring and every Sunday since has hurt. I wrote this for you and not for a library. You do not have to settle all of it at once and you must not try to settle any of it alone. Take the part you are living in and then come and find me.

For the human being belongs to God, in life and in death. Because Christ lives, we shall live also.

Soli Deo Gloria.

In Christ,

Topics
Death and Grief
Scripture
Genesis 1:27Psalm 139:13–14Psalm 127:3Matthew 19:142 Corinthians 9:72 Corinthians 8:9Galatians 6:2Galatians 6:9Psalm 71:18Isaiah 46:4Luke 2:29–30John 14Psalm 31:5Luke 23:46Romans 8:38–39Romans 61 Thessalonians 4:16–18Revelation 21:3–4John 5:29Matthew 25:46John 5:28–29
Confessions
SCLC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.