Books · On the Dignity of the Human Being

On the Dignity of the Human Being — Teacher's Guide

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

A Seven-Session Study for the Congregation


Read this before you teach any of it

This guide is for you. Hand out the student guide; keep this one.

Every other study you have led is about a subject. This one is about the people in the chairs and someone will be in tears before it is over. Plan for it.

Know who is in the room before session one. Somewhere in any group of adults there will be a woman who had an abortion years ago and has never told anyone. A man whose wife is in memory care and who has been visiting less than he thinks he should. A couple who lost a baby decades ago and were never offered a name, a prayer, or a service. Someone who told a doctor to stop and has been turning it over ever since. There will also be someone whose mother was cremated and whose ashes are still in a sibling’s home. You are not going to figure out which is which and you must not try. Teach as though all of them are present, because they are.

The one rule that governs this study: never leave a session on the Law. Naming these subjects preaches the Law without your help. If a session ends with people feeling caught, you have taught half of the Christian faith and sent them home with it. Close every session with the Gospel spoken in the present tense and in the second person: Christ died for that. It is forgiven. Come and hear it said. The closing prayers in the student guide are written to do this; use them or better ones, but do not skip them for time.

Say this aloud in session one and again in session five. “You are never obliged to share anything in this room. What is said here stays here. If something in this study opens something old, come and find me — I would rather you came than that you sat with it.” Then be available afterward, because more pastoral work will get done in the ten minutes after class than in the hour of it.

Where to be careful with your own certainty. On two matters the book states a strong conviction and then limits it: cremation (chapter 5) and the treatment of remains (chapter 5 §9). Teach both halves with equal energy. A leader who conveys the preference and drops the limitation has misrepresented the book and wounded someone for nothing.

The book is now about 45,000 words. No one in your class will read all of it and you should say so in week one. Assign the compendium as the ordinary reading and treat the full work as the place to go when someone wants the argument, the footnote, or the citation. Three parts of the back matter are worth putting in their hands directly: Appendix D, which answers about thirty of the questions people actually ask and points each one to the chapter that argues it; Appendix C, the table of Greek, Hebrew, and Latin terms; and Appendix F, Scripture arranged by the hour in which it is needed.

Read Appendix E before session one. The book quotes the Heidelberg Catechism, Cranmer, and a good many Fathers and someone in your class will eventually ask why a Lutheran is quoting a Reformed catechism. Appendix E answers it: Scripture is the norm that norms, the Confessions are the norm that has been normed, and everyone else is a witness and never an authority (quoted where he says what Scripture and the Confessions say, corrected openly where he does not). Knowing the answer in advance makes the question a good moment rather than a defensive one.

Practicalities. Sixty to seventy-five minutes per session. Aim for fifteen to twenty minutes of teaching and the rest discussion; this is not a lecture series and the discussion is where the pastoral work happens. Session 5 will run long, so protect it and consider giving it ninety minutes. Have copies of the Small Catechism in the room; most people will not own one and will not say so. Scripture is ESV throughout.


Session 1 — What Is a Human Being Worth?

Preparation. Read the Introduction and chapter 1 of the book. In the Confessions: Small Catechism, First Article of the Creed and the Fifth Commandment; Ap II 15–26 and FC SD I 10 on the image of God; LC I 189–191 on the positive duty in the Fifth Commandment.

The center of gravity: human worth is received, not achieved, and therefore it does not move when a person’s abilities do.

Aim. By the end people should be able to say (1) that dignity rests on what God has done rather than on what a man can do; (2) that the image of God has a narrow sense that was lost and a broad sense that remains; (3) that the Fifth Commandment both forbids and commands; and (4) that everything the commandment forbids is also forgiven in Christ.

Leading the teaching. Open with the question and let it sit: what is a human being worth? Take answers. They will be the world’s answers, offered sincerely. Write them on the board, then ask what happens to each one at a bedside. Then go to the First Article and do this slowly, because the entire study rests on it. Read Luther’s explanation aloud and have someone count the verbs that have God as their subject: made, given, takes care of, defends, guards, protects.

Section 2 is the teaching center of this hour and it will carry the discussion. The book sets the Christian answer beside the world’s three (worth from usefulness, from capacity, from autonomy), all of which locate worth inside the person, where it can be lost. Write the three on a board, then ask what each one says about a man with advanced dementia. Then write the Christian answer beside them and ask what is different: the weight rests outside him entirely. Finish with Luther’s thesis from the Heidelberg Disputation. Our love comes into being through what is already pleasing to it; God’s love does not find its object but creates one. The book calls it one of the most useful sentences Luther ever wrote for a hospital room.

The image of God is where you are likeliest to get into trouble, so prepare it. Someone who knows his catechism will object that the Confessions say we lost the image and he will be right. Have the answer ready. In the strict sense the image is original righteousness (knowing God, fearing God, trusting God) and it was lost in the Fall and is restored only in Christ (Ap II 15–26; FC SD I 10; Colossians 3:10). Yet Scripture keeps using the phrase of sinners: God grounds the prohibition of murder in it after the flood (Genesis 9:6) and James uses it of people we curse (James 3:9). There is therefore a broader sense in which every human being still stands before God as His creature. Both senses are needed. Drop the first and you contradict the Confessions; drop the second and you have no argument left against anything done to a man once he stops being useful.

Then the Fifth Commandment, both halves, and do not rush the second. Read LC I 190–191 aloud: if you see one suffer hunger and do not give him food, you have caused him to starve, and God “rightly calls all those murderers who do not afford counsel and help in distress and danger of body and life.” Then move deliberately to the mother. She is the neighbor the argument usually forgets and the book says plainly that a congregation not prepared to be inconvenienced by a frightened mother has confessed only half of what it thinks it has confessed.

Naming the three. Abortion, euthanasia, and assisted suicide are named directly in the book and should be named directly here. Do it once, clearly, without heat or flourish. Then, in the same breath, say the two sentences the book puts together: None of these three is unforgivable. All three are forbidden. If you can deliver only one of those with conviction, work on the other before you teach this session.

Walking through the discussion questions.

  1. Measuring your own worth by what you produced. Expect professional and domestic examples. Land: the First Article was true of you before you produced anything.
  2. Two senses of the image. The doctrinal question. Land: the narrow sense is why we need Christ; the broad sense is why we visit the nursing home.
  3. Which half of the commandment we teach. Expect honest admission that we teach the prohibition. Land: the omission is not neutral; Luther calls it murder.
  4. What the mother would cost this congregation. Push for specifics: money, rides, a room, a name. Vagueness here is the whole problem.
  5. Forbidden and forgiven. The pastoral question and the one to end on. Land: a church that manages only “forbidden” has not been faithful, only correct.

Do not skip the early Church material. The Didache forbids killing a child by abortion, in a list of commands given to new converts, at a time when the surrounding society practiced both abortion and the exposure of infants and regarded neither as remarkable. The point is that a Christian saying this today is not defending a novelty. Do not stop at the prohibition either: the early congregations also took in the exposed children and raised them at their own cost. The confession and the inconvenience arrived together, which is the same challenge section 5 puts to us about the mother.

Misunderstandings to watch for. (a) That dignity is something we confer by being welcoming. Chapter 7 answers this, but it shows up early, so correct it gently now. (b) That naming abortion as sin means condemning the person; the whole structure of the session is built to prevent this, so make the structure visible. (c) That “the image of God” means intelligence or moral capacity; it does not, and if it did, dignity would decline with dementia.

Closing. Use the prayer. Then, before anyone stands up, say the sentence: if something tonight opened something old, come and find me. Say it every week. Someone may come weeks later because you said it the first time.


Session 2 — Your Body Is Not a Container

Preparation. Read chapter 2. In the Confessions: Small Catechism, Second Article; FC SD I 29, 33, 44, 46 on the distinction between our nature and the sin corrupting it.

The center of gravity: God made an embodied creature, took that flesh Himself, and intends to raise it, so the body is neither a prison nor a possession.

Aim. People should be able to say (1) that a human being is one creature and not a soul in a container; (2) that Christian stewardship of the body is not the pursuit of health; (3) that illness changes a person’s circumstances and not his standing; and (4) that what is true of my body limits what I may do to yours.

Leading the teaching. Start with the funeral-home sentence (she is not really in there) and ask who has heard it. Then read Genesis 2:7 and put the weight on the verb. He did not receive a soul. He became one. Be honest that nephesh chayyah is used of animals too. The distinctiveness of man rests on the image of God and on the breath God breathed into this creature and no other, not on a Hebrew phrase. The book concedes this and so should you.

FC SD I is the confessional ground here and worth five minutes. The Formula insists that original sin is not the substance of fallen man; the nature remains God’s creature and workmanship. Its argument is the one this session needs: if our nature and our sin were the same thing, the Son of God could not have assumed the one without the other (SD I 44). He did. Therefore they are not the same. Therefore God will raise this flesh, “but without sin” (SD I 46).

The illustration of the man losing his legs, then his hands, then his speech, is the session’s turning point. Ask the question the book asks and let the silence run: has he become less human? Someone will say the obvious thing and someone else will hesitate. Name the hesitation kindly. It is the world’s way of measuring a man and all of us carry it.

Walking through the discussion questions.

  1. The container language. Expect immediate recognition. Land: it is Plato’s and it is why the resurrection of the body sounds strange to people who say the Creed weekly.
  2. Stewardship versus perfection. Expect good-natured argument about diet and exercise; keep it light. Land: the body is a gift, not a god, and it fails everyone who relies on it.
  3. The man who loses everything. The doctrinal question. Land: circumstances changed, he did not.
  4. What follows for other people’s bodies. Push this outward: exploitation, violence, how we speak of the sick, what we permit to be done to the powerless. Land: no one becomes our property by needing us.
  5. Who is in that situation now. Get names if the group will give them, and a plan if they will make one.

The Fathers give you the best five minutes in this session. Ignatius insisting, on his way to be killed, that Christ was truly born and truly raised. Irenaeus: if the flesh cannot be saved, the Lord did not redeem us with His blood and the cup is not communion in His blood, and the whole economy collapses at once. Then Tertullian’s caro salutis est cardo, the flesh is the hinge of salvation. Take the hinge slowly, as the book does. A hinge is not the door, but without it the door is a mere board leaning against a wall. Everything God does for us He does through the body. Then bring it to the font and the rail (section 2). God could have dealt with us inwardly and privately. He chose water, bread, wine, and the sound of the pastor’s voice, so that we would have something outside ourselves to hold. That is why Lutherans are stubborn about the means of grace, and it has nothing to do with an attachment to ceremony.

Section 6 on suffering is the most immediately useful thing in the hour. Do not rush it and do not soften the four things not to say: God sent this to teach you, everything happens for a reason, God will not give you more than you can handle, you would be better with more faith. Read them out. Someone in the room has had all four said to them. Then give the things that can be said (the book gives six, ending with Romans 8 and the promise that suffering ends) and land on Luther’s distinction between the theologian of glory and the theologian of the cross. In practice it is the reason a Lutheran pastor at a bedside points to a crucifix.

Misunderstandings to watch for. (a) That caring for the body is worldly. Some genuinely pious people believe this and it is a Gnostic instinct, not a Christian one. (b) That illness indicates a spiritual failure; watch for it especially in prayer-chain language. (c) That 1 Corinthians 6 is only about sexual sin. It is about that and the reason Paul gives has a much wider reach.

Closing. Do not end on the list of what not to say. Before the prayer, read Romans 8:31–39 aloud, all of it, and say: this is what we have instead of an explanation, and it is better than one. Then the prayer. Then point ahead: next week the same argument turns outward toward the neighbor.


Session 3 — The Poor, the Sick, and Everyone Easy to Overlook

Preparation. Read chapter 3. In the Confessions: AC IV and AC VI, read in that order; Ap IV 122–182 if you want the long form.

The center of gravity: mercy is the fruit of justification and never its price, and the congregation that gets the order wrong ends up guilty or proud.

Aim. People should be able to state AC IV in their own words, explain why AC VI follows and does not compete with it, and name what the weaker members are called in 1 Corinthians 12.

Leading the teaching. Do AC IV first, not the parable; the whole session depends on the order. Ask: does anything in this session get anyone saved? No. Christ has done that and the work is finished. Then ask why we do any of it. AC VI: faith should bring forth good fruit. Luther’s double thesis from The Freedom of a Christian is the line to write on the board: a perfectly free lord of all, subject to none; a perfectly dutiful servant of all, subject to all. Both at once, and for the same reason.

Then the Samaritan, and spend your time on the end of the parable. The lawyer asks a boundary question: whose need obligates me? Jesus answers a vocation question: which of these proved to be a neighbor? He has changed the question and He sends the man off with an imperative rather than a definition. 1 Corinthians 12:22 is the session’s best moment. Have someone read it, then read the word alone: indispensable. Neither tolerated nor accommodated nor included as an act of congregational generosity. Paul says it about the ones who only seem weaker.

The paragraph on paternalism will be uncomfortable, because it describes good people. The failure of Christian charity here is not cruelty but the quiet assumption that the person being helped has nothing to contribute and need not be consulted. Ask where they have seen it. If someone admits to doing it, do not rescue them too quickly, but do not leave them there either.

Walking through the discussion questions.

  1. Why AC IV first. Land: reversed, you get a guilty church or a proud one, and both are unbelief.
  2. Indispensable. Land: our homebound list is not a charity list; it is a roster of members the body cannot do without.
  3. The world’s arithmetic. Expect defensiveness and let it pass; the question is about the congregation, not the people in the room.
  4. Paternalism. The hard one. Land: dignity requires being treated as a person and not as a case.
  5. One thing that would never make the newsletter. End concrete. Write down what people say.

Section 3 is the tool that makes the rest of the hour work. Two kinds of righteousness: one before God, entirely passive, received, complete; one before other people, entirely active, the real work of love, adding nothing whatever to our standing before God. Put both on the board and then name the two failures the book names. Collapse the second into the first and you get the anxious Christian who cannot give without wondering whether it counted: generous, miserable, and not humble but unbelieving about what Christ finished. Collapse the first into the second and you get the comfortable Christian who can explain justification and has not visited anyone in years.

Section 4 on vocation is where the relief comes. God does not need your good works; your neighbor does. Have the class name their own stations aloud (child, parent, spouse, employee, neighbor, member, citizen) and then note that the stations come with particular people attached, most of whom they did not choose. That is the liberating half and the inconvenient half at once. Teach both.

The Fathers here are vivid and you should let them be. Tertullian’s common fund and “see how they love one another.” Julian the Apostate complaining that the Galileans support our poor as well as their own. Basil telling his congregation that the coat in the closet belongs to the naked and that they are not declining to be generous but wronging people with a claim. Expect pushback on Basil and use it. Take the urgency and leave the notion of merit, because where he talks as though alms purchase something from God we do not follow him (Ap IV 275–284).

Section 8 on money will be the most uncomfortable ten minutes and it is worth having. Free giving, real amounts, decided by people who know the names. The awkward part is that a congregation unwilling to talk about the fund leaves the widow with the shut-off notice unable to ask for something she does not know exists.

Misunderstandings to watch for. (a) Works-righteousness by the back door: “so we have to do this to be real Christians.” Answer it every time it appears, using AC IV. (b) The opposite: “we’re saved by faith, so mercy is optional.” AC VI. (c) Treating accessibility as a budget question rather than a question of whether the Gospel reaches the person.

Closing. This session generates guilt faster than any of the others, because everyone in the room can name someone they have not visited. Do not let them leave with it. Say: nothing you have failed to do this year is being held against you; Christ finished that account, and the reason we are free to look at the list at all is that our standing does not depend on it. Then the prayer.


Session 4 — Growing Old, and Dying

Preparation. Read chapter 4. In the Confessions: Small Catechism, Fourth Commandment; LC I 103–178, and LC I 111 in particular, where children are to “serve them, help them, and provide for them when they are old, sick, infirm, or poor”; SC, Sacrament of the Altar, Fourth Part, on who is worthy.

The center of gravity: dignity does not decline with strength and stopping a burdensome treatment is not killing.

Aim. People should leave able to say (1) that the Fourth Commandment runs the whole length of a life; (2) that personhood is not located in memory; (3) that the Sacrament belongs to the member who can no longer ask for it; and (4) the difference between allowing a death and causing one, in words they could use on a family member at two in the morning.

Leading the teaching. This session has two halves and you should say so at the start, because people will come wanting one or the other.

The first half, old age and dementia. Open on the reversal: the woman who was the one everybody called, now depending on her children. Ask what that is like from both sides and expect more candor than usual; adult children carrying elderly parents are rarely asked. Establish the Fourth Commandment’s reach with LC I 111 and 1 Timothy 5:8 and then relieve the pressure you just created at once. A nursing home is not by itself a failure. The question is never where she sleeps. Some people in that room have put a parent in a facility and have been quietly ashamed of it for years; say the sentence for them.

On dementia, do what the book does: grant what the family sees before correcting what they conclude. “The person we knew is already gone” is true about everything visible and you must not scold anyone for saying it. What it cannot become is a doctrine, because as doctrine it locates the person in memory and then every one of us is a person only for as long as his memory holds.

On the Supper, state the presumption first. Do not lead with the cautions, which leaves a family thinking the Sacrament has been withdrawn from the member least able to ask for it. A baptized Christian who has received this Sacrament for decades should go on receiving it; Luther’s answer to who is worthy has no clause about memory in it. Then the practical questions (swallowing, prior confession, this congregation’s practice) as questions about how, not whether.

The second half, the end of treatment. This is the most practically useful twenty minutes in the entire study and many in the room will face it. Draw the line carefully and slowly. The Fifth Commandment forbids taking innocent life and commands sustaining it. It does not command treating every available procedure as obligatory. Withdrawing a burdensome treatment while keeping the patient warm, clean, medicated, and accompanied is letting a disease finish its course; the cause of death is the illness. Administering a lethal dose is euthanasia; prescribing one for the patient to take is assisted suicide; in both, we have made ourselves the cause. Use the words rather than the euphemisms, exactly as the book does.

Then deliver the comfort aloud, in the second person. Do not leave this as a principle. Someone in that room told a doctor to stop, in a hallway and on no sleep, and has been turning it over ever since. Say it: when you told them to stop, you did not kill your mother. The cancer killed your mother. Then offer the absolution and mean the offer.

Walking through the discussion questions.

  1. Honoring a parent at eighty-five. Land: the honor gets more demanding as they become less able to demand it.
  2. Not where she sleeps. Land: loved, safe, visited, attended to; a father can be neglected in his own daughter’s spare bedroom.
  3. “Already gone.” Land: true of what we see, ruinous as doctrine.
  4. Baptism and the Creed she can no longer recite. Land: she is held in the memory of God.
  5. Stating the difference. Make them actually say it in their own words. Correct gently until it is right, because they will need it.
  6. The conversation you are putting off. Concrete. Some will go home and have it.

Two sections change the shape of this hour and both are about people who are in the room.

Section 5, the family doing the carrying. The caring almost always falls unevenly (one child, usually the daughter, usually the nearest, usually without anything having been decided) and she carries it while the others contribute opinions from a distance. Say clearly that the resentment building in that situation is not a failure of Christian love. Then name the four things she is owed and rarely gets: relief that is actual relief, permission to feel what she feels, someone to tell her she is grieving, and honesty about the limits. The third of those is the one that undoes people. In a long decline the losses come one at a time over years and she has never been allowed to call it grief. When you name it, expect tears and let there be a silence afterward. The book then speaks to the sibling who lives far away and to the daughter herself; give her its word in the second person, that she is tired and not failing and that what she has got wrong is forgiven. Read Galatians 6:2 before 6:9, in that order, and say why: the endurance is commanded to someone who is supposed to be carrying part of a shared load.

Section 6, the loneliness of outliving people. Shorter, and worth the time. The woman who reaches for the phone before remembering there is no one on the other end who would find it funny for the same reasons. Then Psalm 71:18 (he does not only ask to be kept, he asks to be kept for something) and the practical consequence, which is that we sort our people by age and then wonder why the old feel useless.

Section 7, learning to die before you have to, carries the session from age to death. The ars moriendi existed; we stopped teaching it; death moved out of the house. Luther’s 1519 sermon gives you three usable moves: settle your affairs early so that at the hour you have one thing to attend to; do not stare down death, sin, and hell but look at Christ, because “examine yourself harder” is precisely the direction with no comfort in it; and stop auditing your own sincerity about the sacraments, since the promise is God’s word and not your feeling about it. Finish on Simeon and point out where the Church sings his song: at the end of the Supper, by a congregation that has just received Christ.

Misunderstandings to watch for. (a) That refusing treatment is suicide. It is very common, very frightening, and flatly wrong; address it directly. (b) That “do everything” is the faithful position. It is not and it often produces a worse death. (c) That a person with dementia cannot be ministered to; the whole session argues otherwise. (d) That hospice means giving up on God.

A caution. Someone may disclose a euthanasia or assisted-suicide decision in a family, possibly in a state where it is legal. Do not litigate it in the room. Acknowledge it, say clearly and once what the commandment says, and then say just as clearly that there is no sin here outside the reach of Christ’s blood. Follow up privately that week.


Session 5 — What We Do with Our Dead

Preparation. Read chapter 5 in full; it is the longest chapter and this is the longest session. In the Confessions: AC IV; AC XXIV 21–30 and Ap XXIV 89, 92, 94, 96 on what a rite can and cannot do; AC XV 1–2, AC XXVIII 30–52, and FC SD X 9 on ceremonies and consciences. Have the Lutheran Book of Worship burial rite in front of you.

Give this session ninety minutes if you can. If you cannot, protect the cremation and remains material at the expense of the historical survey, not the other way around.

The center of gravity: the body of a dead Christian is the body God has promised to raise and everything the Church does with it confesses that, while binding no one’s conscience to a method.

Aim. People should leave able to say (1) why the Church has historically buried its dead; (2) what the funeral rites do and do not accomplish; (3) that cremation cannot put anyone beyond Christ’s reach; and (4) that their pastor’s preference for burial is a preference and not a law.

Who is in the room. Assume all three are present: someone whose mother was cremated, someone with an urn on a shelf at home, and someone who scattered a parent’s ashes years ago and cannot undo it. Teach so that all three can hear the counsel without being put on trial. This is the hardest thing in the study.

Leading the teaching.

Open with the body, not with the method. Death separates what God joined; the body left behind has not become debris. Establish that first and the rest follows. If you begin with burial-versus-cremation you will spend an hour on logistics and never get to the doctrine.

The Scriptural survey, briskly. A whole chapter for Abraham buying a grave. Joseph’s bones, a four-hundred-year confession that God keeps promises. Stephen carried to his grave by devout men who made great lamentation. Then John 19: two men of standing handling a corpse with their own hands, seventy-five pounds of spices, linen, a new tomb. Then the empty tomb, where the women do not find that Jesus has slipped out of His body. The same body that was laid down is the body that stood up.

The rites. Walk through what the LBW burial rite prints (the meeting of the body at the door, the remembrance of Baptism, the commendation, the committal, and the sign of the cross in the closing blessing) and say what each one teaches. Then name what the book does not direct and we do anyway: the white pall, which puts the baptismal garment back on him, and the paschal candle at the head of the coffin. Both are recoveries of the last century, shared with Anglicans and Rome. Then draw the confessional line: the pastor is not making the deceased holy and nothing done at the casket alters her standing before God.

And qualify it at once, or you will contradict our own rite. We do pray for our dead (“receive him into the arms of your mercy”) and the Confessions do not forbid that. Ap XXIV 94 says of the ancients that they spoke of prayer for the dead, “which we do not prohibit,” and Ap XXIV 96 declines to side with those who called such prayers useless. What is rejected is the Supper applied ex opere operato on the dead man’s behalf. If you skip this, someone who reads the rite carefully will conclude the pastor contradicted himself.

Mention in passing that the committal’s words (“earth to earth, ashes to ashes, dust to dust, in sure and certain hope”) are Cranmer’s own English composition in the Prayer Book of 1549, written for the reason the book gives: to confess something over a body without doing anything for the dead. They reached the LBW as they reached most of the English-speaking Church.

Burial, and why. Give the reasons rather than the preference: continuity the congregation can watch with its own eyes and a place that outlives everyone present. Then give the limitation with the same energy; this is not optional. Scripture commands no method. The Confessions establish none. No pastor may bind a conscience where God has not. Say it twice, the second time in your own words.

Cremation. The theological question is whether cremation compromises God’s ability to raise the dead and the answer is no. Say it the way the book says it: not in the least, not in any degree, and no Christian should carry that fear. Give the reasons: the God who made Adam from dust is not inconvenienced by ashes; every buried body returns to dust anyway; Christians have died in fires, at sea, and in wars where nothing was recovered, and the Church has never once doubted their resurrection. Then the honest second half: how we treat our dead teaches, whether we mean it to or not. The early Church preferred burial and its neighbors noticed, but look at the earliest Christian answer. Octavius does not claim fire endangers the dead; he says, “Nor are we, as you imagine, afraid of any injury from the manner of burial, but we practise the old and better custom of interment.” The oldest Christian word on the subject is the one this session is arguing. Say also what the book says about the widow who chooses cremation because she cannot pay what a funeral costs: she has not denied the Creed and must not be answered as though she had.

The remains. Lead with what a permanent resting place gives a family, not with what you would discourage. Somewhere to go. Grandchildren not yet born who will hear her name at that spot. A family able to say in the open that she has died. One more service, too, so that the last thing said over her is the Gospel. Then, briefly and gently, what you would discourage (the urn kept indefinitely, the ashes divided, the scattering over water) and say why those choices are made: out of love and an inability to let go, which are the most understandable motives there are.

Then speak to the family who already did it, and do not soften this. Some of them scattered a father’s ashes because he asked, or divided them because there were several children and one urn, and they have been sitting there with a knot in their stomach. Say it: let it go. Scripture gives no command here, the Confessions give none, and a preference of mine is not a law over anyone’s conscience. You did not put your father beyond the reach of Christ and you did not lose him. God has never needed our help keeping track of His people and on the last day He will not be searching. To the family whose ashes are still on a shelf, give the book’s invitation and not a deadline: the decision is unfinished, unfinished things can be finished, it can be done quietly with a few people, and they need only come and ask. If you get through this session without saying all of this, you have taught it badly no matter how well the rest went.

Three more sections, and the one on suicide matters most.

Section 10, autopsy and donation. Brisk and practical. An autopsy injures no one and is sometimes the only way a family learns what happened. Organ donation is the Fifth Commandment’s positive half on a scale our great-grandparents could not have imagined and the book encourages it; the family that said no did nothing wrong either. Whole-body donation to a medical school is a real gift with one real difficulty. The difficulty is not the dissection but the disposition: the body may be held a year or more and what comes back is usually cremated remains, sometimes with no service at all. Teach the fix rather than a prohibition: arrange the ending in advance, ask the school its practice, and plan the committal now.

Section 11, suicide. Prepare this one in writing before you teach it. Someone in the room has buried a son, a brother, or a father this way and the question is asked at almost every such funeral by someone who cannot get the words out.

Teach it in the book’s order, doctrine before application. Begin with what the Church has done and should not do again (burial outside the wall, the family left carrying a verdict along with the grief) and say that whatever it deterred, it punished the wrong people. Then hold the two halves together, slowly. We do not pretend: the Fifth Commandment forbids taking an innocent life and makes no exception for one’s own, and to say otherwise abandons the commandment exactly where a suffering person most needs to hear that his life is not his to discard. There are people in every congregation closer to that edge than anyone knows and this sentence is for them. And we do not presume: we do not know what was in that mind, a man in the grip of an illness of the mind itself is not making a free judgment in any sense we would recognize, and the Church has never had authority to declare who is lost.

Then say what we can say, as a promise: this man was baptized, God put His name on him and made him promises never conditioned on how he died, Christ died for the sin of the whole world including this one, and so we bury him with the full rites and commend him to the God who knows what we do not. Only then turn to the living: the one who found him is told you did not do this and the congregation is told to say his name to the widow rather than go quiet around this death. Add the last part aloud: we stay with that family long after the funeral, because this grief comes mixed with guilt, anger, and an unanswerable question, and the people carrying it are at real risk themselves.

Section 13, what to arrange in advance. Practical, and it sends people home with something to do: what you want written down and two people told which drawer it is in, burial or cremation and where, the plot, the hymns, the viewing, whether the pastor is called before or after. Say, as the book does, that none of it is commanded and no one has sinned by dying with nothing written down.

Decide the order now, because there will not be time for all of it. There is roughly double the teaching material of any other hour here. Say the release (let it go; you did not put your father beyond the reach of Christ) inside the first twenty minutes and say it again at the close. If you are running long, cut in this order: the Scriptural survey in §2, then the catacombs and churchyards in §3, then the preaching material in §5. Do not cut §8’s release, §9’s release, or §11.

Closing. Do not end on the checklist. Put it down and before the prayer say something like this: everything we have talked about tonight is something Christ has already been through. He was laid in a borrowed tomb by men who loved Him and He came out of it. Whatever any of you decided, or failed to decide, or are still carrying about a grave, that is forgiven, and on the last day He will not be searching. Then the prayer. Then stay in the room.

Walking through the discussion questions.

  1. A whole chapter on a grave. Land: Scripture takes the burial of the dead seriously enough to spend narrative on it.
  2. Easter and burial. Land: the same body laid down is the body that stood up.
  3. What a visitor would learn. Good, concrete, and it makes the rites teach.
  4. Why “gone to her reward” is the Law. The sharpest doctrinal question in the study. Land: everyone in the room knows privately that they would not survive the same scrutiny.
  5. Does cremation prevent the resurrection? Land: no, and give them the reasons so they can repeat them to someone else.
  6. Why the pastor says both things. Land: a fitting practice is not a divine command and confusing the two is the error our Confessions exist to resist.
  7. What a resting place gives. End here, on the gift rather than the prohibition.

Misunderstandings to watch for. (a) That cremation is a sin. It is the most common, so correct it early and unmistakably. (b) That the funeral does something for the deceased. (c) That the Confessions forbid prayer for the dead; they do not (Ap XXIV 94). (d) That “sure and certain hope” is a claim about the deceased’s faith rather than a confession of Christ’s promise. (e) That scattering ashes puts someone beyond the resurrection.

A caution, and it is the one this session needs most. Someone may disclose a suicide in the family, possibly for the first time in that room. Do not let the group process it. Thank them for saying it, say the one sentence that belongs to them (he was baptized, and Christ died for the sin of the whole world, and that includes this one) and move the hour on. Then find them within twenty-four hours, privately, and hear the rest.

And the harder one. The book says there are people in every congregation closer to that edge than anyone knows, and if that is true then one of them may be sitting in your class while you teach this. Say the paragraph addressed to that reader aloud rather than summarizing it (Your life is not a burden God is enduring. He made it, He bought it with His Son’s blood, and He is not finished with you. Tell someone tonight, tonight and not tomorrow.) because he will not read it later. Be available afterward as well, and unhurried. If anyone does approach you, do not counsel and do not probe; stay with him, get him to his physician or to a crisis line that night, and tell him you will be there tomorrow. You are not the clinician. Your part is to stay with him.

Expect tears and expect someone to stay afterward. Do not schedule anything immediately after this session.


Session 6 — Together Again

Preparation. Read chapter 6. In the Confessions: Small Catechism, Third Article, noting the tense of the last clause; AC XVII, which reads that Christ “will appear for judgment, and will raise up all the dead; He will give to the godly and elect eternal life and everlasting joys”; Ap XXI 9–10 for what the Confessions assume about the departed.

The center of gravity: the soul is with Christ now, the body will be raised at the Last Day, and the Creed ends on the second.

Aim. People should be able to distinguish the intermediate state from the resurrection without downgrading either, to say why grief is not weak faith, and to know where the Church locates the communion of saints on an ordinary Sunday.

Leading the teaching. Begin with the sympathy-card sentences (she is in a better place, death is a natural part of life) and ask what is wrong with them. They are said out of kindness; grant that, then show what each of them concedes: that nothing catastrophic has happened. Scripture calls death an enemy, and the last one. Lazarus is the text that settles Christian grief, so spend time there. Jesus knew He was about to raise the man and He wept anyway. Anyone who has been told at a funeral that he should not be crying has been given something other than the mind of Christ.

Then the two-stage structure, and be precise, because most of the confusion comes from collapsing the two. The believer’s soul is with Christ now: Philippians 1:23, 2 Corinthians 5:8, Luke 23:43. Protect that comfort before you go on. Someone in the room has been holding onto “she is with Christ” since the funeral and if your next sentence sounds like a correction you will take it from her. Say clearly that it is true and that you are not taking it back. Then say that it is not the whole hope and not what the Creed ends on: the Creed says the resurrection of the body and AC XVII says Christ will raise up all the dead. Give them the book’s plain statement of it. God is not conducting a rescue of souls from a creation He has written off. An evacuation and a restoration are not the same thing and we have been promised the second.

Job 19:25–27 should be read aloud by someone other than you. In my flesh. My eyes. Not another. He does not know the mechanism; he knows who is doing it and that it will be him. That is the right model for every speculative question this session will generate.

The communion of saints is the part leaders forget and it is the most pastorally useful thing in the session. The widow who does not know how she will get through the Sunday after the funeral should be told what she is walking into. We do not commune alone. We commune “with angels and archangels and with all the company of heaven,” and that company includes the man whose hymnal is still in the rack. At the rail the Church on earth and the Church with Christ are at one Supper. Say it to her directly and tell her to come forward, because she will not work it out on her own.

Walking through the discussion questions.

  1. What is wrong with the sympathy-card sentences. Land: they concede that nothing terrible happened.
  2. Jesus wept. Land: grief is not a failure of faith.
  3. Why collapsing the two stages shrinks the hope. Land: the Creed ends on the resurrection of the body.
  4. What Job knows. Land: certainty about the Person, not the mechanism.
  5. Recognition: what can we say and where do we stop. Land: yes, and then stop; the risen Jesus was recognized as Himself.
  6. The widow at the rail. Land: the separation is real and it is not total.
  7. Being there in April. Practical. Get commitments.

Section 4 gives you a way to teach 1 Corinthians 15 that people have not heard. Walk Paul’s own order. He starts with the witnesses and the remark that most of the five hundred are still alive is a challenge: he is telling a congregation they can go and ask. Then he argues backward from denial, refusing every softening: empty preaching, empty faith, still in your sins, and the dead simply perished. There is no fallback in Paul, no version of the faith that survives as a moral philosophy once the tomb is conceded. Then the question about the body, and here clear up “spiritual body,” which misleads nearly everyone. It does not mean made of spirit; it means governed by the Spirit rather than by our natural life. The risen Christ eating fish in front of the disciples shows what Paul means. Finish on the therefore about ordinary work.

Section 9, the judgment, is the part you may be tempted to skip. Do not. Every creed puts judgment in the same breath as the resurrection and AC XVII says Christ will condemn the ungodly “to be tormented without end” and rejects the idea that the punishment runs out. The book says it would rather not have written that sentence and that it is in our confession. Teach it with the same honesty.

Teach it in the book’s order, because the order is the pastoral care. State it, then the two things that belong with it. First, a Christian does not come to that day as an open question, since the verdict was announced over him at the font and in the absolution and at the rail. That is what the Gospel is for, to deliver the last day’s sentence in advance so that it can be believed instead of dreaded. The second is that judgment “according to works” is not a second road to salvation. Works are never the ground of the verdict: eternal life is given on account of the promise and the works of the reconciled please God on account of faith. The Formula refuses in so many words the claim that good works are necessary to salvation. Then say why it belongs at all: take the judgment out and you have taken out the reason anyone needed saving and then the empty tomb becomes a pleasantry.

Make sure nobody leaves this section frightened, and check by asking, not by assuming. If someone is afraid, do not tell him he has misheard and do not reason with the fear. The book tells the frightened reader that he has not misread it and is not the first to tremble and then absolves the fear rather than arguing with it. Do the same.

Closing. End on the absolution rather than on the doctrine. Say it in the second person and do not hedge it: Christ has already taken your judgment; the verdict was announced over you at the font and it is announced again every time you hear the absolution. The Judge on that bench is your brother. Then the prayer.

Misunderstandings to watch for. (a) Heaven as permanent disembodiment. It is extremely common and it is the sympathy-card theology. (b) Soul sleep, stated as though it were our position; it is not and Philippians 1:23 is the answer. (c) Making reunion with loved ones the point of heaven. Correct it once, gently, and do not hammer it; the longing is written into the promise. (d) Treating ongoing grief as spiritual failure.


Session 7 — What This Asks of Us

Preparation. Read chapter 7 and the Conclusion. Bring the list of names the group generated in session 3 and the accessibility questions from chapter 7. Bring a pen.

The center of gravity: the confession either shapes this congregation or exposes it and the Church does not create the dignity it recognizes.

Aim. People should leave with one specific thing that will be different here, attached to a specific person who will do it.

Leading the teaching. Keep the teaching to ten minutes at most; this session is for the room. Open with the indictment as the book states it: a church can teach the sanctity of life and forget its widows, preach the importance of the family and do nothing for the family a few pews back, confess the resurrection every Sunday and treat the care of the dying as an arrangement best left to professionals. In each case the doctrine is intact and the congregation is not living in it.

Then work the questions in chapter 7 through aloud and honestly. Can a person using a walker get from our parking lot to a pew without help? Can someone with poor vision read our bulletin? Are the homebound visited on a schedule or when someone remembers? Who has not been seen in some time and has anyone called? Write the answers down where people can see them. This study should end in a short list with names on it, not in general good feeling.

Then guard against the two failures this session invites.

The first is despair. The list will be longer than the congregation can carry and people will leave feeling condemned. Head it off with the Gospel in the second person, as chapter 7 does: no congregation has done this well, mine included, and the answer is not a resolution to try harder next year. It is the same absolution we hand everybody else.

The second is self-congratulation and it is harder to see. Chapter 7 §9 exists to answer it: we do not make people worthy of love by deciding to love them. The unborn child does not become worth protecting because we said so. The disabled man does not become valuable because we built a ramp. The widow does not acquire dignity on the afternoon her pastor finally visits. They were all worthy of love already. Our job is to recognize what God has made and act accordingly, and where we failed, the failure was ours and the dignity was never in question.

Three sections to work in, all of them concrete.

Section 5, teaching the young. Make the historical point first: death used to happen in the house, children saw a body and stood at a graveside, and they learned what a Christian funeral was by attending several while they were still young. Now they are kept away on the theory that it would upset them and we produce adults meeting their first corpse in middle age. The counsel is practical: let the children come to the funerals, answer their questions at the level they asked them, say died rather than passed or lost or gone to sleep, take them to the cemetery and show them the stone. Teach the Catechism too, without skipping the hard parts, and teach them the hymns, because hymns and catechism are what remain when the mind goes, as session four showed.

Section 6, the congregation’s own dead. All Saints’ Day, read slowly, with the names of those buried this year and a bell. Families come for it. If your congregation has a churchyard, say that it is neither an amenity nor a burden to be mowed. It is where the congregation’s own dead wait for the resurrection.

Section 8, what the pastor owes. Read it aloud, all of it, and do not soften it. A congregation is entitled to know what it may expect and the clause about the seal of confession in particular needs saying in public: a member should be able to say the worst thing he has ever done in that study and know it goes no further under any pressure whatever. Then say the last line as your own. The man teaching this needs the same absolution he has been handing out for seven weeks and a congregation expecting its pastor to be the one person in the building who does not require it has misunderstood everything he has been telling them.

Walking through the discussion questions.

  1. Where practice does not match confession. Expect honesty; write it down.
  2. The accessibility audit. Do it as a group, aloud. Assign someone to walk the building this week.
  3. What young families need that is not a program. Land: adult company, practical help, and the assurance that a crying child is not a problem.
  4. People stop visiting because they do not know what to say. Land: there is nothing to say and sitting next to someone without saying it is the entire job.
  5. Why we do not hand out dignity. The doctrinal close. Land: this is a confession about God, not a compliment we pay ourselves.
  6. One thing, and who will do it. Do not let the session end without both halves.

Closing the whole study. Read the last paragraphs of the Conclusion aloud. The class will be holding the compendium, so read from its wording rather than the book’s (“I will not end by telling you any of this makes the loss easier”) and go to the end. Then pray, and then say the sentence one last time, because someone may need to hear it again: if anything in these weeks opened something you have been carrying, my door is open, and the conversation stays between you, me, and God. Then stay in the room for whoever lingers.

In Christ, Dylan MacDonald

Topics
Death and Grief
Scripture
Colossians 3:10Genesis 9:6James 3:9Genesis 2:71 Corinthians 6Romans 8:31–391 Corinthians 12:221 Timothy 5:8Galatians 6:2Psalm 71:18John 19Philippians 1:232 Corinthians 5:8Luke 23:43Job 19:25–271 Corinthians 15
Confessions
Ap IISD ILC IAC IVAC VIAp IVAC XXIVAp XXIVAC XVAC XXVIIISD XAC XVIIAp XXISC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.