Books · On the Dignity of the Human Being

Appendix D: Questions People Actually Ask

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

These are the questions that arrive in a hallway, in a car, or on the telephone. They are answered here at the length a pastor would answer them, with a pointer to the chapter that argues the case.

About the beginning of life

When does a human life begin? At conception, a new human being exists. Scripture does not give us an embryology and it does not need to: it treats God’s dealings with a person as beginning before anyone else’s do (Psalm 139:13–16; Jeremiah 1:5). Since we know a human life is there, and since the Fifth Commandment forbids destroying one, the burden falls on anyone who would claim it is not yet a life. Chapter I §1.

Is abortion an unforgivable sin? No. There is no unforgivable sin except the final refusal of the Spirit’s work and a person worried about having committed it has by that very worry shown that he has not. Abortion is forbidden by the Fifth Commandment and it is forgiven in Christ, entirely, and both of those are true at once. Chapter I §7 and §9.

What if the mother’s life is in danger? An intervention undertaken to save the mother’s life (an ectopic pregnancy, for example) is not the act the commandment forbids. The child’s death there is a consequence of the treatment and not its object. That distinction is the same one drawn at the deathbed in chapter 4. A woman who has been through this is a mother who lost a child and she should be grieved with. Chapter I §7.

We lost a baby before birth. Was our child saved? We confess that salvation is through Christ alone and that Baptism is His gift and His command to us. We also confess that God has bound us to the means of grace without binding His own hands. Where Scripture has given no specific promise I will not invent one and I will not pretend to a certainty I do not have. But silence is not a verdict and it is not permission to fear the worst. Luther wrote to women in exactly this position and told them to commend the child to God and to stop tormenting themselves. Chapter I §8.

Our child died years ago and no one offered us anything. Is it too late? No. The child can still be named before God, prayed for, and remembered in a service, and the fact that decades have passed changes nothing about that. Come and ask. Chapter I §8.

Does the Church have anything to say to a woman in a crisis pregnancy besides “don’t”? It had better. A congregation that confesses the sanctity of unborn life and is unwilling to be inconvenienced by a frightened mother has confessed half of what it thinks it has. Groceries, rent, a ride, a crib, a doctor, and someone to sit with her. Chapter I §5.

About the body and illness

Is my body really me, or just something I have? It is you. God formed the man from dust and breathed into him and the man became a living creature: one creature, not a soul in a container. This is why death is an outrage and not a graduation. Chapter II §1.

Am I sick because of some sin? Almost certainly not in any way you could trace and our Lord refused that inference directly when it was put to Him about a blind man. Some illness follows our own choices and much of it follows genes, germs, injury, and age. In every case the sick person is a neighbor first and a case second. Chapter II §4.

Is it a failure of faith to take medicine, or to see a doctor? No. Luther called neglect of one’s own body a tempting of God and gave detailed practical instructions during a plague year: take the medicine, air the house, help your neighbor. Medicine is God’s gift, handled by people He is working through whether they know it or not. Chapter II §3.

What about tattoos, cosmetic surgery, bodybuilding, extreme dieting? The book does not legislate any of these and neither will I. The question worth asking is the one underneath them: is this body being cared for as a gift, or worshiped as a god, or despised as an enemy? Those three produce very different lives and a person usually knows which one he is living in. Chapter II §3.

About the poor and the vulnerable

Does helping the poor earn anything with God? Nothing whatever. We are justified freely for Christ’s sake through faith and the work is finished. Then, being free, we are aimed at a neighbor who has a need an actual act will meet. Get those in the wrong order and you end with a guilty church or a proud one. Chapter III §2.

How do I know who my neighbor is? Stop asking. That was the lawyer’s question and Jesus refused it, asking instead which man proved to be a neighbor. The people God has actually put in front of you (in your household, your work, your street, your congregation) are the answer. Chapters III §1 and §4.

What if the person asking for help will misuse it? Some will. The Samaritan did not audit the man in the ditch first. Prudence is allowed (money is not always the right help and sometimes it is the wrong help). But suspicion must not become the default posture of a Christian toward a person in need, and it very easily does. Chapter III §5.

About aging and the end of life

Am I dishonoring my mother by putting her in a nursing home? No, not by itself. The Fourth Commandment asks whether she is loved, safe, visited, and attended to. It does not require that one person perform every act of care regardless of cost and pretending otherwise ends with two people in crisis instead of one. A parent can also be neglected in a spare bedroom. Chapter IV §2.

My father has dementia and does not know me. Is he still himself? Yes. He has not stopped being the creature God made and his Baptism has not lapsed because he cannot recite the Creed. Faith was never an intellectual achievement by which we hold onto God. He is held in the memory of God. Chapter IV §3.

Should someone with advanced dementia still receive the Lord’s Supper? Begin with the presumption that a baptized Christian who has communed all his life should go on communing. Luther’s answer to who is worthy has no clause about memory in it. The real questions (can he swallow safely, what has he confessed, what is this congregation’s practice) are questions about how, not whether. Chapter IV §3.

Is it a sin to stop treatment? No. The Fifth Commandment forbids taking innocent life and commands sustaining it; it does not command treating every available procedure as obligatory. Withdrawing a burdensome treatment while keeping the patient warm, clean, medicated, and accompanied is allowing a disease to finish what it was going to do. The cause of death is the illness. Chapter IV §8.

Then what is the difference between that and euthanasia? What we are doing, and what we intend by it. In the first case the disease kills and we care for the person to the end. In the second a lethal dose is given or prescribed and we have made ourselves the cause of the death. Compassion in the motive does not change the object of the act. Chapter IV §8.

Is hospice giving up on God? No. Accepting that you are dying is not the same as wanting to die and hospice at its best is a form of mercy. Chapter IV §9.

I told them to stop last year and I have wondered ever since. You did not kill your mother. The cancer killed your mother. What you declined was more pain added to a death already coming and that is the Fifth Commandment kept and not broken. If your conscience will not take that from a page, bring it to your pastor and hear the absolution spoken over it. Chapter IV §8.

My husband stopped going to church forty years before he died. What am I to think? This is the most common question I have ever been asked in a hallway and it is nearly always a widow asking it about a husband. We do not know. The Church judges doctrine and not hearts and I was not told what passed between your husband and God in the last hour, or in any of the hours before it. Anyone who tells you confidently that he is lost has claimed an authority God never gave him, and anyone who tells you confidently that all is well because he was a decent man has changed the subject to his character, which was never the ground of anyone’s salvation.

Here is what we do know and it is more than it sounds. He was baptized. God put His name on that child and made him promises that were never conditioned on his attendance and God does not take His name back when a man stops showing up. Whatever your husband did with those promises in forty years, the promises were made and they were not withdrawn. That is not the same as saying unbelief cannot refuse them. A man can turn his back on what God has promised, and that is exactly why I pronounce neither way. Christ died for the whole world: for the faithful, and for the lapsed, and for the ones who meant to come back and kept not doing it.

I commend him to God’s mercy, therefore, which is exactly what I would do for anyone, and I do not pretend to know what I do not know. One more thing belongs to you. Forty years of praying for a man who would not come is not a failure. It is one of the most faithful things a person can do. God heard every one of them and you may leave the rest with Him now. Chapter V §11 for the same reserve applied to a harder case; chapter 6 §2.

Is it all right that I feel relieved? Yes. After a long decline relief is what nearly everyone feels and almost no one admits it; it is the thing people are most ashamed of at a funeral. Relief is not the absence of love. It is the body’s answer to the end of a long strain and it often sits right beside grief in the same hour. Wanting a person’s suffering to end was never the same as wanting the person gone. If it still troubles you, bring it and I will absolve it. Then it is finished. Chapter IV §5.

Who pays for a funeral when there is no money? Ask. That is the whole answer and the asking is the only hard part. A congregation with any kind of benevolence fund can usually cover more of this than people imagine, funeral homes will very often work with a family that talks to them early, and the county has provisions no one advertises. What you should not do is make the decision about your mother’s body on the basis of a number you were handed in the first hours of grief. Call your pastor before you sign anything. Chapter III §8; chapter 5 §9.

About death and burial

Does the Church prefer burial to cremation? I do and I have given my reasons: burial says with the body what we say with our mouths and it leaves a place behind. Scripture commands no method, though, the Confessions establish none, and no pastor may bind a conscience where God has not. Chapter V §7.

Does cremation prevent the resurrection? No. Not in the least, not in any degree, and no Christian should carry that fear for one more day. The God who made Adam of dust is not inconvenienced by ashes and every buried body returns to dust in any case. Christians have died in fires, at sea, and in wars where nothing was recovered. Chapter V §8.

We scattered my father’s ashes. Did we do something wrong? You did not put him beyond the reach of Christ and you did not lose him. God has never needed our help keeping track of His people and on the last day He will not be searching. The counsel in this book is for families with the decision still ahead of them; it is not a verdict on the family that already made it. Chapter V §9.

What should we do with ashes we still have at home? The thing I would commend is a permanent place of interment (a grave, a columbarium niche, or ground set aside) committed with Scripture, prayer, and the preaching of the resurrection. It gives the family somewhere to go and gives grandchildren not yet born a name to be told at a particular spot. Ask your pastor; it takes very little to arrange and it finishes something. Chapter V §9.

Is an autopsy permitted? Yes, and it is sometimes the only way a family learns what happened, which can matter to the living and occasionally to the children. Chapter V §10.

Should I be an organ donor? I would encourage it. It is the Fifth Commandment’s positive half (helping a neighbor in bodily need) performed at a scale our great-grandparents could not have imagined, by someone who will not be inconvenienced, for a neighbor he will never meet. Chapter V §10.

May I donate my body to a medical school? Yes, and it is a real gift. Arrange the ending in advance: ask what the school’s practice is, whether the remains come back and when, and plan the committal now, so that when the time comes someone knows to gather the family at a graveside and read the promises. Chapter V §10.

Will the Church bury someone who took his own life? Yes, with the full rites, and it should. We do not pretend: the Fifth Commandment makes no exception for one’s own life. We also do not presume, because we do not know what was in that mind, and severe mental illness is not a free judgment in any sense we would recognize. What we can say is what we always say: this man was baptized, Christ died for the sin of the whole world, and we commend him to the God who knows what we do not. Chapter V §11.

There is no body to bury. Is a memorial service a lesser thing? No. Christian hope has never rested on our ability to find or preserve a body. Hold the service, preach the Gospel, and say as much to the family in so many words, because they have begun to suspect they are being offered second best. Chapter V §12.

About the resurrection

Is my mother in heaven now, or is she waiting? Both things are true and keeping them straight prevents most of the confusion in this area. The soul of a believer is with Christ now — “today you will be with me in paradise.” The resurrection of the body is at the Last Day and that is what the Creed ends on. Holding the first does not diminish the second and the second is the larger of the two. Chapter VI §2.

Is it wrong to want to see my husband again more than I want to see Christ? It is honest and it is where most of us start. The longing is written into the promise: Paul’s comfort to a grieving church is that we will be caught up together with them. The correction is gentle and it is only this: we will be together because we will be with Him. Chapter VI §6.

Will we recognize each other? Yes. The risen Jesus was recognized as Himself, with a history still His, and what we are promised is that the people who died will be raised, not replaced. Beyond that we should not claim more detail than we were given. Chapter VI §7.

What will the resurrection body be like? Will my son have his arm back? Scripture gives promises rather than specifications: imperishable, glorious, powerful, and like Christ’s own glorious body. It does not answer the particular questions and I will not pretend to. What it does say is that the corruption we are enduring now will not be carried over. Chapter VI §5.

Is it wrong to still be grieving after two years? No. Faith does not suppress grief; it receives Christ’s promises in the middle of it. Our Lord wept at a grave He was about to open. Anyone who tells a widow she should be further along by now is offering something other than the mind of Christ. Chapter VI §10.

What do I say to someone whose husband just died? Very little. Go, sit down, and say his name, which most people avoid and the bereaved are longing to hear. There is nothing you are required to explain and the explanations are usually what wound. Come back in a few months. Chapter VI §10.

Topics
Death and Grief
Scripture
Psalm 139:13–16Jeremiah 1:5

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.