Books · On the Dignity of the Human Being

Appendix E: What Other Catechisms Say, and Where We Stand With Them

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

This book has quoted several documents that are not ours. It owes the reader an account of why, and of where the agreement stops. The rule stated in the Note on Citations governs throughout: outside our confession a writer is a witness and never an authority, he is quoted where he says what Scripture and the Confessions already say, and where he says something else I say so rather than passing over it quietly.

The Heidelberg Catechism (1563)

Where it is quoted here: the Introduction and chapter 6 §5.

The Heidelberg Catechism is a Reformed document, written at the direction of Elector Frederick III of the Palatinate, in a territory that had been Lutheran and was being turned. Lutherans of the period regarded it (correctly) as an instrument of that turning and the eucharistic material in it is not something a Lutheran can sign.

Its first question is nonetheless one of the great confessions of the Christian faith. What is your only comfort in life and in death? — “That I, with body and soul, both in life and in death, am not my own, but belong unto my faithful Saviour Jesus Christ.” Body and soul. In life and in death. Not my own. That is the argument of this entire paper in thirty words.

Question 57 is quoted for the same reason. Asked what comfort the resurrection of the body gives, it answers that “this my body, raised by the power of Christ, shall be reunited with my soul, and made like unto the glorious body of Christ.” This my body: not a body, not a better one, not a replacement.

Where we part company. Chiefly on the Lord’s Supper. Question 76 explains eating the body of Christ as embracing His suffering with a believing heart and being united to Him by the Holy Spirit; Question 47 insists that Christ’s human nature is no longer on earth, which is the Reformed premise that makes a real bodily presence in the Supper unavailable. We confess that the true body and blood of Christ are given and received under the bread and wine. Question 80’s characterization of the Roman Mass, added in the later 1563 editions, is sometimes said to be harsher than anything we would say. It is not. The Smalcald Articles call the Mass “the greatest and most horrible abomination” and name it idolatry. The real difference is the premise rather than the severity of the language: Q80 condemns from the eucharistic position of Q47 and Q76, which we reject, while our own objection is to the Mass as a sacrifice and never to the presence of Christ’s body and blood. The catechism’s treatment of predestination and of the images in worship follows the Reformed line at points where we go a different way. I have written elsewhere at length about what we owe this catechism and where we must depart from it; quoting its first question here is not a step toward any of that.

The Book of Common Prayer and the Thirty-Nine Articles

Where they bear on this book: chapter 5 §6, on the committal.

Our own burial rite’s committal comes to the Lutheran Book of Worship, as it comes to most of the English-speaking Church, from Thomas Cranmer’s Burial of the Dead in the Book of Common Prayer of 1549, revised in 1552 and settled in 1662. Cranmer took the office’s shape from the medieval Sarum use; the English triad and the phrase “sure and certain hope” have no Latin antecedent there and are, so far as the liturgical scholars trace them, his own English composition. Our book reorders him: the LBW front-loads the phrase, “In sure and certain hope of the resurrection to eternal life through our Lord Jesus Christ, we commend to almighty God our brother N., and we commit his body to the ground; earth to earth, ashes to ashes, dust to dust,” where the 1662 Prayer Book puts “in sure and certain hope” at the end.

This is worth knowing rather than concealing and it is a gift to the argument of chapter 5 rather than an embarrassment to it. Cranmer wrote those words for precisely the reason §6 gives: to confess something over a body without doing anything for the dead. His 1552 revision removed the Communion from the funeral and recast the 1549 commendation, which had been addressed to the deceased, into the third person.

There our paths diverge slightly. Cranmer in 1552 removed prayer for the dead altogether. The Apology declined to go that far: it refuses to prohibit such prayer and objects only to the Supper applied ex opere operato on a dead man’s behalf. The later Prayer Book tradition came back toward us and that is where our own rite gets its words. The commendation many of us pray at Lutheran funerals — “Into your hands, O merciful Savior, we commend your servant… Acknowledge, we humbly beseech you, a sheep of your own fold, a lamb of your own flock, a sinner of your own redeeming. Receive him into the arms of your mercy” — is the American Prayer Book’s restored Commendation and behind it stands the medieval commendatio animae that Cranmer had cut. We say it for the Apology’s reason and not for a medieval one. Article XXXI of the Thirty-Nine Articles rejects “the sacrifices of Masses, in the which it was commonly said, that the Priest did offer Christ for the quick and the dead.”

Where we would not simply sign. The Articles were framed to hold one national church together and they draw on Reformed and Lutheran material alike: the Thirteen Articles of 1538, produced during the Anglo-Lutheran negotiations, and the Württemberg Confession of 1552 are both in their ancestry. Article XXVIII is signable in more of its parts than a Lutheran expects: the Articles of 1553 had contained a flat denial of the bodily presence and that clause was struck out in the revision of 1563. Where we cannot follow it is the word only (“given, taken, and eaten, in the Supper, only after an heavenly and spiritual manner”) and still more the sentence after it, which makes faith the means by which the body of Christ is received. Article XXIX draws the consequence and says the wicked “in no wise are partakers of Christ,” where we confess that they receive the body and blood to their judgment. That is a real division and not a verbal one. On burial and on the resurrection of the body, however, an Anglican and a Lutheran are saying the same thing and have been for five hundred years.

The Westminster Standards (1646–1647)

Where they bear on this book: nowhere directly, and the reason is worth stating.

The Westminster Shorter Catechism opens with a question as famous as Heidelberg’s (What is the chief end of man?) and answers, “Man’s chief end is to glorify God, and to enjoy him forever.” A Lutheran can say that sentence without reservation. The Larger Catechism’s treatment of the sixth commandment (their sixth is our fifth, since the Reformed tradition divides the Decalogue differently) is a genuinely useful piece of moral theology on the preservation of life.

On the subject of this book, though, the Westminster Confession has a sentence I passed over and ought not to have: the dead are raised “with the selfsame bodies, and none other, although with different qualities” (WCF XXXII.2). That is chapter 6’s argument stated more precisely than the Heidelberg states it, and in a form a Lutheran needs to qualify nowhere.

I have held the outside voices to two and the Heidelberg is the one with the longer history among us. That is a judgment about how much explaining a quotation is worth, not a judgment about the men. Their framework (the covenant of works and the covenant of grace and a doctrine of election worked out in a direction we do not follow) would have needed a good deal of it.

The Fathers

Where they are quoted here: chapters I §4, II §1, III §9, and V §8.

The Fathers are not a fourth source of doctrine. They are witnesses to what the Church was already teaching and their value in a paper like this one is precisely that they were not trying to settle the questions we are asking. When the Didache forbids killing a child by abortion, when Ignatius insists that Christ was truly born and truly raised, when Irenaeus says that if the flesh cannot be saved then the Lord did not redeem us with His blood, when Tertullian calls the flesh the hinge of salvation, and when Basil tells his congregation that the coat in the closet belongs to the naked — they are saying, in the second and third and fourth centuries, what this book argues from Scripture in the twenty-first.

One correction I make as I go. Where the Fathers speak of almsgiving as though it purchased standing before God, we do not follow them, and Ap IV 275–284 states why. We take their urgency and not the idea that alms buy forgiveness, for the urgency is right and we have far less of it than they had. God does reward the good works of His children, but as a Father’s gift and never as the price of salvation.

The rule, restated

None of these documents is cited to settle anything. Scripture settles it and the Confessions state what Scripture settles. What these other voices provide is corroboration across time and across division. When a Reformed catechism, an Anglican prayer book, a second-century church manual, and a Lutheran pastor in Ohio all insist that the body of a dead Christian matters and will be raised, that convergence is worth a reader’s attention, though it is an old agreement and not an argument.

Topics
Death and GriefOther Churches and TraditionsThe Lord's Supper
Confessions
Ap IV

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.