Books · The Divine Liturgy

From the Reformation to the LCMS

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

The Lutheran Hymnal, Lutheran Worship, and Lutheran Service Book

The Lutheran Orthodox Period and the Pietist Reaction

The century following Luther’s death (1546) saw the consolidation of Lutheran liturgical life in the various territorial churches of the Holy Roman Empire. The major Lutheran Kirchenordnungen (church orders) — those of Saxony, Brandenburg, Pomerania, Württemberg, and others — followed Luther’s pattern: the Mass was retained in vernacular German, with substantial preservation of the historic ordo, weekly Eucharistic celebration in cathedral and city churches, the chanting of the propers, the use of Latin in scholarly and festival contexts, and the development of a rich chorale tradition for congregational singing. This is the era that produced the great Lutheran composers — Heinrich Schütz, Dietrich Buxtehude, Johann Pachelbel, and ultimately Bach — whose music was inseparable from the liturgical context that gave it meaning.

Two movements in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries disrupted this liturgical heritage. The first was Pietism, beginning with Philipp Jakob Spener’s Pia Desideria (1675) and continuing through August Hermann Francke and the Halle school. Pietism, in its concern for personal conversion and the lived experience of faith, tended to view the historic liturgy as a “dead orthodoxy” — externally observed without inner faith. While Pietism made important contributions to mission, education, and personal devotion, its tendency was to relativize the means of grace in favor of subjective religious experience. The result, over time, was a weakening of liturgical practice in many Lutheran territories, a reduction in the frequency of Eucharistic celebration, and a shift in emphasis from the gathered church around Word and Sacrament to the individual believer’s interior life.

The second disruption was Rationalism, the application of Enlightenment principles to theology and liturgy in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. The Rationalist liturgies eliminated or reduced the elements that did not fit a rationalistic framework: the Verba were sometimes weakened, the Creed reduced to moral statements, the doxologies and Sanctus removed as supernaturalist. By the early nineteenth century, the Lutheran liturgical heritage was in genuine danger across much of Germany.

The Confessional Revival and the Saxon Immigration

The early nineteenth century saw a Lutheran confessional revival, sometimes called the Erweckungsbewegung (Awakening Movement) or the Neulutheraner (Neo-Lutheran) movement. Theologians and pastors such as Claus Harms, Wilhelm Löhe, Theodor Kliefoth, and Adolf von Harless rediscovered the Lutheran Confessions, recovered the historic liturgy, and reformed worship practice along confessional and liturgical lines. Löhe in particular was a master liturgist whose Agende für christliche Gemeinden des lutherischen Bekenntnisses (Agenda for Christian Congregations of the Lutheran Confession, 1844) reconstructed a full Lutheran liturgy from the sixteenth-century church orders.¹⁸

It was this confessional and liturgical Lutheranism that the Saxon immigrants brought to Missouri in 1839 under the leadership of Martin Stephan and, after Stephan’s deposition, C. F. W. Walther. The Saxons settled in Perry County, Missouri, and St. Louis, and in 1847 founded the German Evangelical Lutheran Synod of Missouri, Ohio, and Other States — the body that would become the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod. Walther himself was a fierce defender of the historic liturgy. In his Pastoraltheologie (Pastoral Theology, 1872), he wrote that “the highest aim of Lutheran ministers must be the pure preaching of the Word of God and the right administration of the Sacraments according to the institution of Christ. To this end the proper liturgical order of the church serves.”¹⁹

The Kirchenbuch and the Common Service

The early Missouri Synod used the Kirchenbuch für Evangelisch-Lutherische Gemeinden ungeänderter Augsburgischer Confession (Church Book for Evangelical Lutheran Congregations of the Unaltered Augsburg Confession, 1856), based on Löhe’s Agende and on the sixteenth-century Saxon church orders. As German-speaking Lutheranism in America gradually transitioned to English, the need arose for an English-language Lutheran liturgy. Several Lutheran bodies cooperated in producing the Common Service (1888), an English-language Lutheran liturgy drawn from “the common consent of the pure Lutheran liturgies of the sixteenth century.”²⁰ The Common Service became, with minor variations, the standard Lutheran English-language liturgy in North America for the next century. It is the rite contained in The Lutheran Hymnal (1941) as “The Order of Holy Communion” (often called “Page 15” after its location in TLH).

The Common Service is a remarkable achievement of confessional Lutheran liturgical scholarship. It preserves the full historic ordo: Invocation, Confession and Absolution, Introit, Kyrie, Gloria, Salutation and Collect, Epistle, Gradual or Hallelujah, Gospel, Creed, Hymn, Sermon, Offertory, General Prayer, Preface, Sanctus, Lord’s Prayer, Verba, Pax, Agnus Dei, Distribution, Nunc Dimittis, Thanksgiving, Salutation and Benedicamus, Benediction. Every major element of Luther’s Formula Missae and of the historic Western Mass is preserved.

The Lutheran Hymnal (1941)

The Lutheran Hymnal (TLH) was the official hymnal of the LCMS from 1941 until the publication of Lutheran Worship in 1982 — and, by enduring congregational use, well beyond. TLH contained the Common Service (Page 15), Matins and Vespers, the Litany, and a rich selection of 660 hymns drawn from the German chorale tradition (Luther, Gerhardt, Heermann, Nicolai, Rinkart), the English hymn tradition (Watts, Wesley, Newton, Cowper, Heber), and Scandinavian and other European Lutheran sources. The musical settings were stately, doctrinal, and substantial; the texts were theologically rich.

For two generations of American Lutherans, TLH defined Lutheran worship. Its prose was Elizabethan in cadence (“Thee” and “Thou” addressing God, with the corresponding verb forms — “Thou hast,” “Thou art”). Its theology was thoroughly confessional. Its Service of Holy Communion was the Common Service nearly unchanged. Many LCMS congregations continue to use TLH to this day, either as their primary hymnal or alongside more recent resources.

Lutheran Worship (1982)

By the 1960s and 1970s, pressure was mounting for a new hymnal that would address modern English usage, ecumenical liturgical convergence (especially the Roman Catholic Novus Ordo Missae of 1969 and Episcopal Book of Common Prayer of 1979), and the needs of a postwar American Lutheranism that had largely shed its German linguistic identity. The Inter-Lutheran Commission on Worship (ILCW), with participation from the LCMS, the American Lutheran Church (ALC), and the Lutheran Church in America (LCA), produced the Lutheran Book of Worship (LBW) in 1978.

The LCMS, however, declined to adopt the LBW, citing theological concerns about specific elements (notably the wording of the Eucharistic Prayer, certain rubrics on intercommunion, and aspects of the rite of confession). The Synod instead produced Lutheran Worship (LW) in 1982 — a hymnal based on the LBW but with modifications reflecting LCMS doctrinal and pastoral commitments.²¹ LW included three Divine Service settings: Divine Service I (the page 15 service updated to contemporary English), Divine Service II (a newer setting in two musical forms, IIa and IIb), and the traditional services from TLH retained in slightly modified form.

LW represents a moderate liturgical renewal: contemporary English replaces Elizabethan English; new musical settings are added alongside traditional ones; the three-year lectionary is offered alongside the historic one-year lectionary; the eucharistic prayer is enriched with optional thanksgiving texts surrounding the Verba (though the Verba remain capable of standing alone as in Luther’s Formula Missae). LW did not achieve universal acceptance in the LCMS — many congregations continued with TLH — but it served as the official hymnal of the Synod from 1982 until the publication of LSB in 2006.

Lutheran Service Book (2006)

Lutheran Service Book (LSB), published by Concordia Publishing House in 2006, is the current official hymnal of the LCMS. It is the product of a decade of work by the LCMS Commission on Worship and represents a significant maturation of LCMS liturgical practice. LSB contains five settings of the Divine Service:

  • Divine Service, Setting One — a contemporary-language adaptation of the Common Service with new musical settings.
  • Divine Service, Setting Two — another contemporary-language setting with different music.
  • Divine Service, Setting Three — the page 15 service from TLH in its original Elizabethan English and traditional Common Service music.
  • Divine Service, Setting Four — a simpler contemporary-language setting, designed for occasions when full musical resources are unavailable.
  • Divine Service, Setting Five — a setting based on Luther’s Deutsche Messe (1526), with hymnody substituting for many of the chanted propers, drawing extensively on Luther’s own chorales.

In addition to these five Divine Service settings, LSB contains Matins, Vespers, Morning and Evening Prayer, Compline, the Service of Prayer and Preaching, the Daily Lectionary, the historic one-year and three-year lectionaries, and 636 hymns drawn from the historic Lutheran chorale tradition, the broader Western hymnodic tradition, and the best of contemporary Lutheran hymn-writing.

The achievement of LSB is its careful balance of continuity and renewal. It preserves the full historic Common Service (in Setting Three), restores the full Deutsche Messe pattern (in Setting Five), offers contemporary-language settings for those who prefer modern English (Settings One, Two, and Four), retains the historic one-year lectionary alongside the three-year, and provides a hymnody that is theologically rich, musically diverse, and confessionally Lutheran. To worship in the LCMS Divine Service in 2026 is to worship in unbroken continuity with Luther, with the medieval Western church, with the apostolic age, and ultimately with the heavenly liturgy of Revelation 4–5.


¹⁸ Wilhelm Löhe, Agende für christliche Gemeinden des lutherischen Bekenntnisses (Nördlingen: Beck, 1844). For Löhe’s liturgical theology, see James L. Schaaf, Wilhelm Loehe’s Relation to the American Church: A Study in the History of Lutheran Mission (Heidelberg: Ruprecht-Karls-Universität, 1961). ¹⁹ C. F. W. Walther, Pastoraltheologie, 3rd ed. (St. Louis: Concordia, 1897), 110, translation mine. ²⁰ The Common Service Book of the Lutheran Church (Philadelphia: General Council Publication House, 1917), preface. ²¹ For the history and rationale of Lutheran Worship, see Fred L. Precht, ed., Lutheran Worship: History and Practice (St. Louis: Concordia, 1993).

Topics
Worship and LiturgyThe Lord's Supper
Church Year
End of the Church Year
Scripture
Revelation 4

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.