Books · The Divine Liturgy

The Broader Lutheran Liturgical Family

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

LBW, ELW, WELS Christian Worship, and the Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary

The Pan-Lutheran Liturgical Inheritance

The story told in the previous chapter — from the Common Service of 1888 through TLH, LW, and LSB — is the LCMS portion of a larger pan-Lutheran liturgical history. The Common Service was not produced by the LCMS but by a cooperative effort among multiple Lutheran bodies in the late nineteenth century, and its adoption was nearly universal across North American Lutheranism. The Lutheran Hymnal (1941) became the standard worship book not only for the LCMS but also for several smaller bodies of the old Synodical Conference (including WELS and the Norwegian Synod, predecessor to today’s ELS). When the ALC (American Lutheran Church) was constituted in 1960 and the LCA (Lutheran Church in America) in 1962, both bodies inherited the Common Service tradition through their predecessor synods.

By the mid-twentieth century, the Lutheran liturgical family in North America stood in remarkable convergence: substantially the same rite (the Common Service), substantially the same hymnody (the German chorale tradition plus Anglo-American hymns), substantially the same calendar (the historic one-year lectionary), and substantially the same confessional substance. The divergences that followed — the production of distinct hymnals by distinct Lutheran bodies — are best understood not as ruptures in this shared inheritance but as variations within it.

The Inter-Lutheran Commission on Worship and the Lutheran Book of Worship (1978)

In 1966 the LCMS, the ALC, the LCA, and the Slovak Zion Synod established the Inter-Lutheran Commission on Worship (ILCW) with the goal of producing a common worship book for North American Lutherans. The ILCW worked for twelve years and produced the Lutheran Book of Worship (LBW) in 1978.²² LBW was a major liturgical achievement. It contained three settings of Holy Communion (Settings One, Two, and Three), Morning Prayer, Evening Prayer, the Litany, Compline, Responsive Prayer, Service of the Word, and over six hundred hymns. The musical settings included new compositions by significant church musicians as well as adaptations of the historic chant traditions.

LBW reflected the broader liturgical renewal movement of the mid-twentieth century — the same movement that produced the Roman Catholic Novus Ordo Missae of 1969 and the Episcopal Book of Common Prayer of 1979. Several distinctive features marked LBW:

First, the LBW eucharistic prayer surrounded the Verba with a more developed Great Thanksgiving (anaphora), drawing on Eastern and patristic models. This represented a return to the fuller eucharistic prayer form that the Lutheran tradition had largely abandoned since Luther’s Formula Missae. The LBW provided four eucharistic prayer options; in each, the Verba were embedded within a longer prayer of thanksgiving, supplication, anamnesis, and (in some forms) epiclesis.

Second, LBW adopted the three-year lectionary developed in the wake of the Second Vatican Council, with adaptations for Lutheran use. This represented a significant break from the historic one-year lectionary, though LBW retained the historic lectionary as an option.

Third, LBW reformed certain language patterns — moving from “Thee/Thou” to “You” address to God, modernizing certain archaic terms, and (in some places) softening masculine language for humanity (though not for God) — anticipating the more thoroughgoing language reforms of later books.

Fourth, LBW’s ecumenical orientation showed itself in shared texts with the Roman Catholic and Episcopal traditions — most notably the ICET (International Consultation on English Texts) versions of the Lord’s Prayer, Creed, Gloria, Sanctus, and Agnus Dei.

The LCMS, as noted in the previous chapter, declined to adopt LBW as its official worship book. The decision came in 1977, after several years of internal debate. In broad terms, the LCMS concerns clustered around the eucharistic prayer form, the rubrics on intercommunion, the rite of confession, certain creedal and liturgical translations, and several smaller textual matters.²³ Because the question is often summarized in general terms that obscure what was actually at stake, a closer examination of the specific arguments is warranted.

The Specific Arguments Against the LBW — A Closer Examination

The full record of the LCMS deliberation is preserved in the proceedings of the 1977 LCMS Convention (Dallas), in the reports of the LCMS Special Hymnal Review Committee, and in the documentation gathered in Fred Precht’s Lutheran Worship: History and Practice (1993). What follows is a synthesis of those arguments, presented with the specific textual and doctrinal claims that drove the decision.

The Eucharistic Prayer

The principal liturgical concern centered on the form of the eucharistic prayer in LBW Holy Communion Setting Two. LBW provided four Great Thanksgiving (Eucharistic Prayer) options, each constructed as a continuous prayer of thanksgiving in which the Verba were embedded within a longer prayer of offering, anamnesis, and (in some cases) epiclesis. The LCMS objection had three component arguments.

First, the language of oblation. Several of the LBW Eucharistic Prayers used language of offering that the LCMS judged inconsistent with the Lutheran Confessions. The second Eucharistic Prayer included the phrase: “We offer ourselves to you as a living and holy sacrifice. Together with this bread and cup, we offer ourselves to be a living sacrifice.” Another reads: “We offer with thanksgiving this bread and cup, the gifts of your creation.” The third included: “Accept our sacrifice of praise and the offering of ourselves.” The fourth, drawing on patristic models, included an explicit anamnetic offering: “Remembering, therefore, his salutary precepts, his life-giving passion and death, his glorious resurrection and ascension, and the promise of his coming again, we give thanks to you, O Lord God Almighty, not as we ought, but as we are able.”

The LCMS concern was not the eucharistic sacrifice of thanksgiving as such — the Lutheran Confessions explicitly permit and commend this kind of sacrifice (Apology XXIV.19, 25). The concern was that the LBW language did not clearly distinguish the sacrifice of thanksgiving (which the church properly offers in the Supper) from the propitiatory sacrifice (which only Christ has offered, once for all, on the cross). When the prayer says “we offer this bread and cup” in immediate proximity to the Verba — “This is my body… This is my blood” — the implication can be, and historically in Roman Catholic theology has been, that the church offers the consecrated body and blood of Christ to God as a propitiatory action. This is precisely what the Augsburg Confession Article XXIV rejected: the medieval scholastic doctrine that the Mass is a propitiatory sacrifice for sin distinct from but applying Calvary’s merit, by which (the medieval doctrine held) forgiveness was conferred ex opere operato on the living and the dead. The Apology Article XXIV is even more pointed: “The propitiatory sacrifice is Christ alone. All other sacrifices are sacrifices of thanksgiving… It is sheer hypocrisy to call the Mass a propitiatory sacrifice.” The Smalcald Articles (II.II.1) call the Mass-as-propitiatory-sacrifice “the greatest and most horrible abomination.”

The LCMS argument was that the LBW language, while not explicitly contradicting these confessional definitions, blurred them in a way that allowed — even invited — misunderstanding. Where Luther had labored to isolate the Verba as Christ’s gift to the church, the LBW reincorporated them into a prayer of offering. The Reformation’s careful surgical removal of the medieval Canon had been undone in liturgical practice, the LCMS argued, even if the prayer’s authors did not intend any return to medieval sacrificial theology.

Second, the embedded Verba. In the historic Lutheran tradition following Luther’s Formula Missae (1523), the Words of Institution stand alone or with minimal framing, as the consecratory action proclaimed by the minister to the people. In Luther’s original reform, the entire body of the Roman Canon was eliminated, leaving the Verba as the consecratory speech-act sung aloud in the same manner as the Gospel. The LBW form embedded the Verba within a continuous prayer addressed to the Father, transforming them from proclamation into part of the church’s prayer of offering. The LCMS argued this changed the function of the Verba: they ceased to be Christ’s gift announced to the people and became part of the church’s offering to God.

The Commission on Worship summarized the concern as follows: the placement of the Verba within an extended Eucharistic Prayer, however carefully composed, has the inevitable effect of subordinating them to the surrounding action of offering. The Lutheran tradition has held that the Verba are not the church’s prayer but Christ’s gift; they are spoken not by us to God but by Christ, through His called minister, to us. The LBW Eucharistic Prayer form, while compatible with this understanding when read in isolation, did not enforce it and permitted alternative readings that the Lutheran tradition had consistently rejected.

Third, the epiclesis. Several of the LBW Eucharistic Prayers included an epiclesis — an invocation of the Holy Spirit upon the elements or upon the assembly. For example: “Send your Spirit upon us and upon these your gifts; bless this offering of bread and cup, that being one body in Christ we may know the resurrection of the dead.” The LCMS objection was that the epiclesis, while ancient and present in Eastern eucharistic prayers, can shift the perceived moment of consecration from the Verba to the invocation of the Spirit. Eastern Orthodox theology, which has the most developed epicletic tradition, locates the consecration in the epiclesis rather than in the Verba. The Lutheran tradition, by contrast, has consistently located the consecration in the Verba — Christ’s own words effecting what they declare. The LBW epiclesis, the LCMS argued, opened the door to an alternative location of the consecration that was theologically problematic and contrary to the Reformation settlement.

The LCMS resolution of these eucharistic-prayer concerns appeared in Lutheran Worship (1982). Divine Service I retained the Common Service form (Verba largely standing alone, with the Lord’s Prayer either before or after). Divine Service II provided an optional Eucharistic Prayer — but with the language of offering carefully revised, the Verba clearly framed (and capable of standing alone per rubric), and the epiclesis omitted or rendered as a general petition for proper reception rather than as a consecratory invocation.

The Rubrics on Communion Practice

The second principal concern was the LBW’s rubrics on Communion practice. The LBW Holy Communion service included an invitation to communicants that read substantially: “All baptized Christians who believe in the real presence of our Lord Jesus Christ in this holy meal are welcome to receive the Sacrament.” This formula — “all baptized Christians who believe in the real presence” — was the working invitation of the ALC and LCA, both of which practiced what they called “responsible” or “eucharistic hospitality” forms of open communion.

The LCMS practice, by contrast, has been close (closed) communion: the Sacrament is administered to members of the LCMS and of churches in altar-and-pulpit fellowship with the LCMS, after individual examination by the pastor regarding faith, life, and understanding of the Sacrament. This practice rests on three pillars.

First, the Sacrament as a confession of faith. The Lutheran tradition has historically held that to commune at an altar is to confess the faith of the celebrating church. Paul’s words in 1 Corinthians 10:16–17 — “The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body” — are read by Lutherans as making the Supper an expression of unity in confession, not merely an expression of unity in baptism. Where doctrinal unity does not exist, communion at the altar would be a false confession of unity that does not exist.

Second, the warning of 1 Corinthians 11:27–29 against unworthy reception: “Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord. Let a person examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment on himself.” The LCMS reads this as requiring pastoral discernment before admission to the Sacrament — including discernment of whether the prospective communicant rightly understands the Sacrament he is about to receive.

Third, the pastoral office of the keys. The pastor stands at the altar as the called and ordained servant of Christ, responsible to Christ for what he administers and to whom. The LCMS has held that the pastor’s responsibility includes the determination of who may and may not commune. This responsibility cannot be discharged by a generic invitation that admits any baptized person who self-identifies as believing in the real presence; the pastor must know, in some pastorally appropriate way, that the communicant in fact confesses what the celebrating congregation confesses.

The LBW formula — “all baptized Christians who believe in the real presence” — was, on the LCMS reading, incompatible with all three of these commitments. It made baptism plus self-attestation of real-presence belief the criterion for admission, removing the pastor’s discernment and confessing, through the act of communing, a unity of faith that did not in fact exist between Missouri Synod Lutherans and members of the many denominations whose people might present themselves at the altar. The Commission on Worship objected that the proposed invitation extended fellowship beyond the boundaries the Confessions and historic Lutheran practice had observed; to print this invitation as the official rubric of the rite would commit every congregation using LBW to a practice contrary to the LCMS understanding of the Sacrament.

The LCMS resolution in LW (1982) and continued in LSB (2006) was to provide rubrics consistent with close communion practice — typically with language directing prospective communicants to speak with the pastor before communing for the first time, and clearly stating the congregation’s confession.

Confession and Absolution

The third concern was the LBW’s “Brief Order for Confession and Forgiveness.” Several aspects of this order troubled LCMS reviewers.

First, optionality. The LBW placed the Brief Order as an optional preparatory rite before the entrance hymn of Holy Communion. The rubric stated: “When desired, the Brief Order for Confession and Forgiveness may be used.” The LCMS objection was that confession of sin is not optional for sinners approaching the holy Sacrament. The historic Lutheran tradition — from Luther’s Deutsche Messe through the Common Service — had treated Confession and Absolution as integral to the rite, not as a discretionary add-on that the presiding minister could include or omit at his preference. To make confession optional was, in the LCMS view, to weaken the catechetical formation of the rite: the people approaching the altar must know themselves to be sinners receiving from a gracious God, and a rite that systematically omits this admission obscures the gospel.

Second, the form of the absolution. The LBW absolution read: “Almighty God, in his mercy, has given his Son to die for us and, for his sake, forgives us all our sins. As a called and ordained minister of the Church of Christ, and by his authority, I therefore declare to you the entire forgiveness of all your sins…” The LCMS objection was less to the LBW form itself (which is theologically defensible) and more to the way the rite framed it. In some LBW use, the absolution was printed as a “Declaration of Grace” and sometimes spoken in indicative third-person form (“God forgives us”) rather than the more explicit declarative form (“I forgive you all your sins in the name of the Father…”). The Lutheran tradition has held that the absolution is most fully exercised when spoken in first-person to second-person: “I forgive you all your sins.” This form most clearly conveys the given-to-you character of the absolution and most clearly exercises the Office of the Keys. A third-person statement that “God forgives us” is a true statement but less directly addressed to the specific hearer.

Third, the relative downplaying of individual confession. LBW included a brief rite for “Individual Confession and Forgiveness” (LBW pp. 196–197) but treated it as a secondary option without prominent commendation. The LCMS tradition has historically valued individual confession as a pastoral practice — Luther’s Small Catechism explicitly commends it — and had argued for its more prominent inclusion.

The LCMS resolution in LW (1982) was to restore Confession and Absolution as an integral part of the rite (not optional), to provide a more explicitly declarative absolution form, and to give greater prominence to individual confession as an available pastoral resource.

Creedal and Liturgical Language

The fourth concern was a cluster of language issues in the Creeds and other liturgical texts. LBW adopted the translations of the International Consultation on English Texts (ICET), which had been developed ecumenically — with Roman Catholic, Episcopal, Methodist, Presbyterian, and Lutheran participation — and adopted by multiple denominations in their post-1970 worship books. Several specific points drew LCMS attention.

The Nicene Creed. The ICET (and so LBW) text rendered the Greek di’ hēmas tous anthrōpous kai dia tēn hēmeteran sōtērian as “for us and for our salvation,” omitting the explicit “men” (tous anthrōpous, “human beings, persons, men”). The traditional translation, “for us men and for our salvation,” made the inclusivity of the redemption explicit; the new translation softened the gender reference for inclusive-language reasons. LCMS reviewers preferred the traditional rendering because (a) it more directly translated the Greek (anthrōpous is a personal-individual term, not the abstract noun “humanity”), and (b) the gender reference, while inclusive of all human beings, was theologically significant in connection with the Incarnation — Christ took on humanity as a man, Mary’s son, not as a generic genderless human.

More significant doctrinally was the rendering of kai enanthrōpēsanta — “and became truly human” in ICET, “and was made man” in the traditional rendering. The Greek can be translated either way; “human” is the abstract noun, “man” the personal form. The LCMS concern was that “became truly human” can be heard as a statement about Christ’s nature without explicit reference to his individuated personhood, while “was made man” preserves the personal, gendered, individual character of the Incarnation. The Council of Chalcedon’s affirmation that Christ is “complete in manhood, of one substance with us in his manhood” used the personal-individual term; the LBW translation moved away from this in a direction the LCMS judged less precise.

The descent into hell. The phrase “He descended into hell” (in the Apostles’ Creed, Latin descendit ad inferos) was rendered “He descended to the dead” in ICET (and so in LBW). The LCMS objected that the traditional “into hell” preserved a stronger doctrinal claim — that Christ entered the realm of the damned in his victorious descent — while “to the dead” weakened this to a mere statement about the location of the deceased. The Latin inferos can be translated either way etymologically, but the Lutheran tradition (following 1 Peter 3:18–20 and the Formula of Concord IX) had read the descent as a victorious entry into hell, proclaiming victory to the imprisoned spirits and (in the Formula of Concord’s formulation) “destroying for us hell’s power, and taking away from the devil all his power.”

The Apostles’ Creed in corporate “We believe” form. LBW provided the Apostles’ Creed in both “I believe” (traditional) and “We believe” (corporate) forms. The LCMS preferred “I believe” even in corporate use, because the Apostles’ Creed historically functions as a baptismal symbol — the individual’s confession of faith made at the font — even when prayed by a congregation. The traditional Latin is credo (“I believe”), and the personal pronoun has been seen as theologically significant. The objection was not to the corporate setting but to the move from personal to corporate pronoun: when the whole congregation says “I believe” together, each person individually confesses the faith as his own; when they say “We believe,” the confession is collectivized and can become less personally appropriated.

The Lord’s Prayer. LBW provided the Lord’s Prayer in two forms: the traditional “Our Father, who art in heaven… forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us…” and the modernized ICET version “Our Father in heaven… forgive us our sins, as we forgive those who sin against us…” LCMS preference was for the traditional form, both for its established liturgical use (still the form most American Lutherans had memorized) and for its translation of opheilemata as “trespasses” — the technical term implying violation of obligation, with stronger Matthean connection than the looser “sins.”

Other texts. Various smaller textual revisions in LBW — Collect translations, the Magnificat, the Nunc Dimittis, the Gloria Patri — were judged by LCMS reviewers to be either less precise renderings of the Latin or Greek originals or to import theological assumptions different from confessional Lutheran exegesis. Most of these were minor; cumulatively they added to the case for an LCMS revision.

The LCMS resolution in LW (1982) was to provide both traditional and modernized renderings where possible, retaining the traditional forms as the principal options and the modernized versions as alternatives. LSB (2006) continues this dual provision, with Setting Three in traditional language and Settings One/Two in contemporary translations.

The Baptismal Rite

A fifth concern, less prominent but real, was the LBW’s rite of Holy Baptism. The traditional Lutheran baptismal rite included an explicit threefold renunciation: “Do you renounce the devil? Do you renounce all his works? Do you renounce all his ways?” The LBW rite softened this to: “Do you renounce all the forces of evil, the devil, and all his empty promises?” The substance was not contradicted, but the LCMS argued that the traditional threefold form was both more dramatic and more theologically explicit — naming the devil three times in his three modes of opposition (his person, his works, his ways), in continuity with the patristic and Reformation-era baptismal rite.

LBW also incorporated certain trinitarian renunciations and affirmations drawn from broader ecumenical practice. LCMS reviewers judged these acceptable but noted that the traditional Lutheran rite was preferable in its directness and its preservation of the historic baptismal pattern. The LCMS resolution in LW (1982) restored the traditional threefold renunciation: “Do you renounce the devil? Yes, I renounce him. Do you renounce all his works? Yes, I renounce them. Do you renounce all his ways? Yes, I renounce them.” This form has been carried forward into LSB (2006).

Hymnody and Editorial Choices

A sixth concern was the editorial treatment of certain hymns in LBW. Several traditional hymns had been edited for various reasons — modernization of archaic language, alteration of masculine generic terms, removal of stanzas judged offensive by ecumenical sensibilities. For example, “Onward, Christian Soldiers” was omitted from LBW entirely (judged militaristic); various hymns by Charles Wesley and Isaac Watts received contemporary-language updates that the LCMS judged sometimes felicitous and sometimes not. The principal LCMS objection was not to editorial alteration as such but to the practice of altering hymn texts without clear theological warrant — particularly where alterations reflected current cultural sensibilities rather than doctrinal precision. The LCMS resolution in LW (1982) restored certain traditional hymn texts that LBW had altered or omitted, while retaining most LBW textual decisions where they were judged improvements.

The Lectionary

A seventh concern was LBW’s adoption of the three-year lectionary as primary, with the historic one-year lectionary relegated to an option. The three-year lectionary, developed in the wake of the Second Vatican Council’s Ordo Lectionum Missae (1969), was a substantial liturgical innovation. While its broader Scripture exposure was widely welcomed, the LCMS had concerns about specific text selections (which sometimes truncated readings at theologically problematic points), about the loss of the historic Sunday character (the One-Year Lectionary’s centuries-long association of specific Gospel texts with specific Sundays — the “Stir up” Collect of Advent I, the appointed Holy Week readings, and so forth), and about the ecumenical assumptions underlying the three-year lectionary’s design. The LCMS resolution in LW (1982) was to provide both lectionaries with relatively equal prominence; LSB (2006) continues this dual provision.

The Convention Decision and Its Aftermath

The cumulative effect of these concerns was decisive at the 1977 LCMS Convention (Dallas). The Convention adopted Resolution 3-04, which expressed appreciation for the work of the ILCW but declined to adopt LBW as the official LCMS worship book in its 1978 form. The Resolution directed the LCMS Commission on Worship to prepare a hymnal “consonant with the doctrine, life and worship of the Synod” — a hymnal that would “draw upon” but not simply adopt the LBW.

The result, after five years of further work, was Lutheran Worship (1982). LW retained substantial portions of LBW — much of the hymnody, many of the musical settings, the general shape of the rites, the use of the three-year lectionary as one option — while modifying the specific elements that had been the subject of LCMS objection. Divine Service I of LW preserved the historic Common Service in updated language. Divine Service II provided the LBW-style setting with the modifications described above. The historic one-year lectionary and a modified three-year lectionary were both provided. The baptismal rite restored the traditional threefold renunciation. The Eucharistic Prayer was carefully reworded with the language of oblation excised. The communion rubrics were aligned with close communion practice. Confession and Absolution were restored as an integral part of the rite.

LW was the official LCMS hymnal from 1982 until the publication of LSB in 2006. LSB has continued and refined the same approach — engaging the ecumenical liturgical renewal where compatible with Lutheran confession, while preserving the substantive distinctives that the LCMS had identified as worth preserving.

The story of the LCMS engagement with LBW is therefore not a story of stubborn separation but of careful theological discernment. The LCMS Commission on Worship, the Commission on Theology and Church Relations, and the Convention spent the better part of a decade examining LBW in detail. The decision not to adopt the book was not based on a general unwillingness to revise worship — the LCMS subsequently produced LW and LSB, both of which represent substantial liturgical updating from TLH — but on specific textual and doctrinal concerns that the LCMS could not, in conscience, allow to stand in its official worship book. The popular narrative that the LCMS rejected LBW out of mere conservatism does not survive contact with the actual record of the deliberations. The LCMS rejected the specific points listed above, retained the substantial work of the ILCW where compatible with its confession, and produced its own worship book that incorporated what it could and modified what it could not.

WELS and ELS Responses to LBW

While the LCMS was the only confessional Lutheran body formally participating in the Inter-Lutheran Commission on Worship that produced LBW, the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (WELS) and the Evangelical Lutheran Synod (ELS) — both outside the ILCW — also evaluated LBW closely and reached conclusions that paralleled and in some respects exceeded the LCMS critique. The WELS and ELS responses bear examination because they illustrate how a stricter confessional position than the LCMS itself responded to the same liturgical materials.

The Historical Context

WELS had been part of the Synodical Conference (with LCMS, ELS, and the Slovak Synod) from 1872 until 1961, when WELS suspended fellowship with the LCMS over concerns about the LCMS’s increasing involvement with the American Lutheran Church (ALC) — concerns that focused on what WELS judged to be unionistic cooperation across confessional lines. By the time LBW was being developed in the 1970s, WELS and the LCMS were no longer in altar-and-pulpit fellowship, and WELS had no formal voice in the ILCW process. The same was true of the ELS, which had withdrawn from the Norwegian Lutheran Church of America in 1918 over its merger with bodies the ELS founders judged confessionally compromised, and which stood in fellowship with WELS rather than with the LCMS.

WELS and ELS were therefore observers rather than participants in the LBW development. Their evaluations appeared in WELS theological journals (Wisconsin Lutheran Quarterly, Northwestern Lutheran) and ELS publications (Lutheran Sentinel, Lutheran Synod Quarterly), as well as in the deliberations of the WELS Commission on Worship that would eventually produce Christian Worship (1993). The ELS, with smaller resources, would publish the Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary (ELH) in 1996, drawing on the work of WELS and on its own Norwegian Lutheran heritage.

Shared Confessional Objections

WELS and ELS shared all of the principal LCMS objections to LBW. The Eucharistic Prayer with its language of oblation, the embedded Verba, the epiclesis, the open-communion rubric, the optional and softened Confession-and-Absolution rite, the ICET creedal translations, the softened baptismal renunciation, the relegated one-year lectionary — every one of these LCMS concerns was also a WELS and ELS concern, and on the same confessional grounds: AC XXIV on the Mass, Apology XXIV on propitiatory versus eucharistic sacrifice, the Pauline warnings on the Sacrament, the historic Lutheran practice of close communion, and the catholic substance of the rite preserved by the Common Service tradition. A representative WELS critique judged the LBW eucharistic prayer to be a return, in liturgical form, to a sacrificial conception of the Mass that the Reformation had rejected on doctrinal grounds. An ELS evaluation in Lutheran Synod Quarterly reached substantially the same conclusion, with particular concern for the embedded Verba and the loss of the declarative character of the consecration.

Additional WELS and ELS Concerns Beyond the LCMS Critique

Beyond the shared objections, WELS and ELS raised several concerns that went further than the LCMS critique, or that took the LCMS critique to a more thoroughgoing conclusion.

First, fellowship and unionism. The LBW was a product of inter-Lutheran cooperation between the LCMS, the ALC, and the LCA. From the WELS perspective, the LCMS’s participation in the ILCW was itself problematic — the same kind of fellowship-blurring cooperation that had led WELS to break fellowship with the LCMS in 1961. The LBW was therefore objectionable not merely because of its specific textual contents but because of the process by which it had been produced. WELS theologians argued that producing a common worship book with bodies whose doctrine and practice diverged from confessional Lutheran standards was itself a form of public confession of unity that did not exist — and that the resulting book carried, in its very existence, an implicit ecumenical claim that WELS could not endorse.

The WELS position on church fellowship — articulated in WELS’s This We Believe statement and in numerous WELS doctrinal documents — holds that fellowship at every level (altar, pulpit, prayer, joint mission, joint worship-book production) requires full doctrinal agreement. The LCMS’s longstanding position has been more nuanced: certain forms of cooperation can occur without full doctrinal agreement, provided that confessional integrity is maintained. WELS judged the ILCW process to cross the line; the LCMS did not. From the WELS perspective, even the LCMS’s eventual decision not to adopt LBW did not retroactively justify LCMS participation in producing it. The ELS shared this fellowship judgment.

This argument is the principal WELS/ELS extension beyond the LCMS critique. Where the LCMS evaluated LBW textually and reached a negative conclusion on the specific points discussed above, WELS and ELS evaluated LBW both textually and procedurally — and the procedural judgment was, for them, prior to the textual judgment. A common worship book produced through unionistic cooperation could not, in WELS/ELS judgment, be adopted regardless of how its specific texts read, because adoption would ratify the cooperative process by which it had been produced.

Second, the ICET texts and ecumenical translations. The ICET (International Consultation on English Texts) translations adopted in LBW had been developed in committee with Roman Catholic, Episcopal, Methodist, and Presbyterian participation. The LCMS objected to specific renderings (as detailed above) but accepted the basic legitimacy of the cooperative translation enterprise — and indeed adopted many ICET texts in Lutheran Worship (1982). WELS objected more fundamentally to the production of shared liturgical texts with bodies in serious doctrinal disagreement. The argument was theological: shared liturgical texts express, by their very sharing, a unity of faith. The ICET translations, used in common across Roman Catholic, Episcopal, Methodist, Presbyterian, and Lutheran services, presupposed a unity of faith among these bodies that did not in fact exist. WELS therefore declined to use the ICET texts in its Christian Worship (1993) at points where the LCMS Lutheran Worship (1982) had retained them, preferring instead its own translations developed within WELS. The ELS Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary (1996) likewise generally prefers traditional renderings over ICET texts.

Third, the doctrine of the public ministry. WELS holds a distinctive position on the office of the public ministry that differs in some respects from the LCMS position. WELS teaches that the public ministry of the gospel is one divinely instituted office, of which the pastoral office is one form — alongside other forms such as Christian day school teacher, professor of theology, and parish administrator. The LCMS holds that the pastoral office is the specific divinely instituted form of the public ministry, with other offices being auxiliary to it and deriving their authority from it. The LBW ordination and installation rites were written within the LCA/ALC theological framework, which differed from both WELS and LCMS on the office of the ministry, but in different directions on different points. WELS noted that the LBW ordination rite would need substantial revision to fit WELS doctrine. The WELS Christian Worship (1993) provides ordination, installation, and commissioning rites that reflect WELS’s distinctive theology of the public ministry — including rites for the commissioning of teachers and staff ministers that have no exact parallel in LBW or LW.

Fourth, the music and hymn selections. While WELS shared the LCMS concern about specific hymn alterations in LBW, WELS additionally noted that the broader hymn selection in LBW reflected the more pietistic and (at points) more revivalist hymnodic tradition of American Lutheran piety in the LCA/ALC orbit, with less proportional emphasis on the strict chorale tradition that WELS (like the LCMS) had historically prized. The WELS Christian Worship (1993) gives greater proportional space to the German chorale tradition than LBW does, and the ELS Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary (1996) gives still greater space to it — alongside the Scandinavian-heritage hymnody that the ELS preserves from its Norwegian Synod roots.

Fifth, the cultural assumptions of liturgical renewal. WELS theologians noted that LBW reflected the broader assumptions of the mid-twentieth-century liturgical renewal movement — assumptions shared by Roman Catholic Vatican II reformers, Episcopalian Book of Common Prayer (1979) reformers, and Methodist United Methodist Hymnal reformers. These assumptions included a preference for the three-year lectionary, the recovery of the patristic eucharistic prayer form, an inclusive-language sensibility, ecumenical convergence in shared texts, and a more “horizontal” emphasis on the congregation as the gathered assembly (sometimes at the expense of the “vertical” emphasis on God’s action in the means of grace). WELS judged these broader assumptions to be themselves problematic — not because every individual element was necessarily wrong, but because the cumulative effect was to move Lutheran worship in directions the Confessions did not warrant. ELS theologians, in their own evaluations, reached substantially the same conclusion.

The ELS Particularities

The ELS, while sharing all the WELS objections, had certain additional concerns rooted in its Norwegian Lutheran heritage. The Norwegian Synod and its successor bodies had preserved distinctive Scandinavian Lutheran liturgical elements — including elements drawn from the Bugenhagen Order developed by Johannes Bugenhagen for the Scandinavian Lutheran churches in the sixteenth century, and the Landstad hymnal tradition that gave Norwegian Lutheran worship its characteristic shape. The LBW, drawn primarily from the German Lutheran heritage and from broader ecumenical sources, did not preserve the specific Norwegian Lutheran elements that the ELS valued. The ELS therefore had additional reasons, beyond the confessional objections shared with WELS and LCMS, to produce its own worship resource. The Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary (1996) gives substantial space to Norwegian hymnody (Landstad, Brorson, Kingo, Sandell), retains certain Norwegian-heritage liturgical elements, and preserves the Common Service in a form parallel to the WELS and LCMS treatments.

The ELS evaluation of LBW also noted what ELS theologians called the “doctrinal trajectory” concern: the ALC and LCA bodies producing LBW had, in ELS judgment, been moving in a confessionally weaker direction for some decades, and LBW reflected this trajectory in its liturgical choices. Adopting LBW, even with modifications, would be to align with that trajectory rather than to stand against it. The ELS’s small size and resources meant the practical decision was easy — there was never a serious possibility of ELS adopting LBW — but the theological evaluation was nevertheless articulated for the record.

Practical Outcomes

The practical outcome of the WELS and ELS responses was that neither body adopted LBW. WELS continued to use The Lutheran Hymnal (1941) until 1993, when it published Christian Worship. ELS likewise used TLH until 1996, when it published the Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary. Both bodies produced their own resources that:

  • Preserved the historic Common Service substantively unchanged.
  • Retained the Verba largely standing alone in the consecratory action, with no LBW-style Great Thanksgiving anaphora.
  • Maintained explicit close communion rubrics, in some respects stricter than the LCMS formulation.
  • Preserved the traditional declarative Absolution as the principal form.
  • Retained the traditional creedal language (with modernized renderings limited to specific alternatives).
  • Restored the traditional threefold baptismal renunciation.
  • Made the historic one-year lectionary the primary lectionary with the three-year as alternative.
  • Preserved the German chorale tradition (and, in ELH, the Norwegian Lutheran tradition) as the musical core.
  • Reflected WELS/ELS distinctive doctrine on the office of the public ministry in their ordination and installation rites.

The WELS Christian Worship (1993) and the ELS Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary (1996) stand alongside LCMS Lutheran Worship (1982) and Lutheran Service Book (2006) as the principal contemporary confessional Lutheran worship resources. Their existence — three distinct contemporary worship books from three closely related but separately governed confessional Lutheran bodies — reflects both the unity of confessional Lutheran liturgical commitment and the practical reality of separate ecclesial governance.

Convergence and Divergence

Looking at the broader picture, the WELS and ELS responses to LBW illustrate three points worth noting.

First, the confessional consensus. On every substantive theological point — eucharistic prayer, communion practice, confession and absolution, creedal language, baptismal rite — the LCMS, WELS, and ELS responses to LBW converged. The objections were not parochial or denominational quirks; they were confessional objections rooted in the Augsburg Confession, the Apology, the Smalcald Articles, and the Formula of Concord. Any body that takes these Confessions as binding will, when presented with LBW, reach substantially the same conclusions. The convergence of LCMS, WELS, and ELS evaluations is therefore not surprising but expected.

Second, the additional WELS and ELS concern about fellowship. WELS and ELS went further than the LCMS in objecting not merely to the LBW’s content but to the cooperative process that produced it. This reflects WELS’s and ELS’s stricter position on church fellowship — a position the LCMS does not entirely share. The disagreement between LCMS on the one hand and WELS/ELS on the other regarding the application of fellowship principles is real and longstanding; the LBW question highlighted it. From the LCMS perspective, evaluating a proposed worship book on its merits and then producing a corrected version was the appropriate confessional response. From the WELS/ELS perspective, the cooperative production of the book with non-confessional Lutheran bodies was itself the problem, and participation in such a process was a confessional error regardless of whether the resulting book was ultimately adopted.

Third, the practical result. Three separate worship books emerged from confessional American Lutheranism in the post-LBW period: LCMS Lutheran Worship (1982) and Lutheran Service Book (2006); WELS Christian Worship (1993) and Christian Worship: Hymnal (2021); ELS Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary (1996). All three traditions share substantial confessional and liturgical agreement; they differ in matters of detail, in fellowship practice, and in the specific institutional and cultural backgrounds of their producing bodies. Lutheran worship in the United States today is therefore not monolithic — but among confessional Lutherans, it is recognizably and substantially unified in its rejection of the directions LBW took and in its preservation of the historic Common Service tradition.

The ALC and the LCA adopted LBW and used it as their principal worship resource. When these two bodies (with the smaller Association of Evangelical Lutheran Churches) merged in 1988 to form the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA), LBW became the new church’s official worship book. It continued in ELCA use until the publication of Evangelical Lutheran Worship in 2006.

Evangelical Lutheran Worship (2006)

In 2006 — the same year LSB was published by the LCMS — the ELCA published Evangelical Lutheran Worship (ELW) as its current worship and song resource.²⁴ ELW is a substantial revision and expansion of LBW. Its Holy Communion liturgy is organized around ten “Settings” (numbered One through Ten), each with its own musical character — from traditional Common Service music (Settings One through Four), to global music influences (Setting Six, with African-American gospel influences; Setting Seven, with Caribbean and Latin American influences), to contemporary musical idioms. This breadth of settings reflects the ELCA’s commitment to musical and cultural diversity in worship.

Several features distinguish ELW from LSB and from the LCMS tradition more broadly. First, ELW employs expansive and inclusive language for humanity throughout, and offers a wider range of options for divine language (though it retains the traditional “Father, Son, and Holy Spirit” in the Trinitarian formula). Second, ELW’s eucharistic prayer options are extensive and include thirteen prayer options, several drawing extensively on patristic and Eastern anaphoras. Third, ELW reflects ELCA’s full-communion agreements with the Episcopal Church (USA), the Reformed Church in America, the Presbyterian Church (USA), the United Church of Christ, the United Methodist Church, and the Moravian Church — including provisions for shared ministry and intercommunion. Fourth, ELW continues the three-year lectionary as its principal lectionary, with the Revised Common Lectionary as the standard form.

It must be said honestly that ELW represents a stream of Lutheran worship that has moved significantly farther from the historic Common Service substance than has LSB. The expansion of eucharistic prayer options, the inclusive language reforms, the full-communion agreements with non-Lutheran bodies (some of which deny Lutheran sacramental teaching), and the broader ecumenical orientation mark ELW as the book of a Lutheranism in significant theological transition. Confessional Lutheran observers — both within and outside the ELCA — have expressed concern that ELW reflects, in liturgical form, the doctrinal departures that have accompanied the ELCA’s broader trajectory. Nevertheless, the historic shape of the Western Mass is recognizable in ELW, and the substantial elements (Kyrie, Gloria, readings, Creed, Verba, Sanctus, Lord’s Prayer, Agnus Dei, Distribution, Benediction) remain in place. ELW is a Lutheran worship book, even as it represents a different trajectory within the Lutheran family than LSB.

Christian Worship — The Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (WELS)

The Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (WELS) is the second-largest of the historically confessional Lutheran bodies in North America (after the LCMS), with approximately 360,000 members at the time of this writing. WELS was a member of the Synodical Conference along with the LCMS, the Norwegian Synod (now ELS), and the Slovak Synod from 1872 until WELS broke fellowship with the LCMS in 1961 over the LCMS’s involvement with the ALC and its (in WELS judgment) compromised practice of fellowship.

WELS used The Lutheran Hymnal (1941) — the same book used by the LCMS — as its principal worship resource for most of the twentieth century. In 1993 WELS published Christian Worship: A Lutheran Hymnal (CW93), its own hymnal containing two settings of Holy Communion: “The Common Service” (preserving the historic page-15 service from TLH with modernized language) and “Service of Word and Sacrament” (a newer setting with different music and minor structural variations). CW93 contained 623 hymns, drawing heavily from the German chorale tradition and the broader Lutheran hymnodic heritage.

In 2008 WELS published Christian Worship: Supplement, adding additional hymns and a third Holy Communion setting (“Service of the Word and Sacrament II”). In 2021 WELS published Christian Worship: Hymnal (CW21), a major revision and expansion of the 1993 book. CW21 contains five Communion services, expanded hymnody, and updated translations. The musical settings include both traditional Common Service music and newer compositions.

WELS liturgical practice is closely parallel to LCMS practice. WELS maintains closed communion (closer-fellowship at the altar than even the LCMS in some respects), confesses the same Lutheran Confessions, retains the historic ordo of the Divine Service, and shares the LCMS’s confessional commitments on the means of grace, the real presence, and the office of the holy ministry. The principal differences between WELS and LCMS lie not in liturgical text but in matters of church fellowship, the doctrine of the ministry (where WELS has historically taken a stricter “lay” view of the pastoral office), and certain matters of practice. In liturgical substance — the rite, the readings, the creeds, the sacramental theology — WELS and LCMS stand in nearly complete agreement.

Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary — The Evangelical Lutheran Synod (ELS)

The Evangelical Lutheran Synod (ELS) is the smaller of the two principal confessional Lutheran bodies in fellowship with WELS, with roots in the Norwegian Synod that came to America with the great wave of Norwegian Lutheran immigration in the nineteenth century. The ELS was reorganized in 1918 after the merger that produced the Norwegian Lutheran Church of America (later part of the ALC), which the ELS founders judged compromised in its confessional commitments. The ELS today numbers approximately 17,000 members and stands in altar-and-pulpit fellowship with WELS.

The ELS published the Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary (ELH) in 1996.²⁵ ELH contains the historic Common Service in its traditional form (closely parallel to LSB Setting Three), Matins, Vespers, the Litany, and over six hundred hymns drawn from the German, Norwegian, and broader Lutheran chorale tradition. ELH is distinguished by its preservation of distinctive Norwegian Lutheran liturgical elements: the use of the Bugenhagen Order (a sixteenth-century rite that influenced Scandinavian Lutheran practice), certain Norwegian collects and prayers, and a hymnody that includes significant Norwegian Lutheran composers (Landstad, Brorson, Kingo, and others) alongside the German chorale tradition.

The ELH liturgy is, in shape and substance, the same Common Service celebrated in WELS and LCMS congregations. The Order of the Holy Communion in ELH follows the classical structure: Invocation, Confession of Sins, Absolution, Introit, Kyrie, Gloria, Salutation and Collect, Old Testament Reading, Gradual, Epistle, Alleluia, Holy Gospel, Nicene Creed, Hymn of the Day, Sermon, Offertory, Prayer of the Church, Preface, Sanctus, Lord’s Prayer, Verba, Pax Domini, Agnus Dei, Distribution, Nunc Dimittis, Thanksgiving, Salutation and Benedicamus, Benediction. The ELH preserves the use of the historic one-year lectionary as its principal lectionary, providing the three-year lectionary as an alternative.

The ELS and WELS are partners in the Confessional Evangelical Lutheran Conference (CELC), an international fellowship of confessional Lutheran bodies that maintains the practice of close (closed) communion and the historic substance of Lutheran confession and worship. Together with the LCMS, these three North American bodies represent the principal confessional Lutheran liturgical heritage in the United States.

A Shared Liturgical Substance and Its Variations

Standing back from the survey of LSB, LBW, ELW, CW, and ELH, one observes a striking pattern: the substantial ordo of the Divine Service is identical across all five worship books. Each begins with the gathering of the people; each moves through Confession, Word, and Sacrament; each concludes with Benediction and Sending. Each retains the Kyrie, Gloria (or its alternatives), Creed, Sanctus, Lord’s Prayer, Verba, Agnus Dei, and Aaronic (or trinitarian) blessing. Each preserves the dialogical character of the rite — the Salutations, the Amens, the responses of the people. Each retains the historic calendar (Advent through Trinity) and provides for both one-year and three-year lectionaries (or at least the three-year lectionary, in the case of LBW and ELW).

The variations among these books cluster around four loci. First, the form of the eucharistic prayer — ranging from the minimalist Verba-and-frame approach of LSB Setting Three (continuous with Luther’s Formula Missae) to the developed Great Thanksgiving of LBW Setting Two and ELW Settings One through Ten (drawing on patristic and Eastern models). Second, the language register — from the traditional Elizabethan English of LSB Setting Three and ELH to the contemporary ICET English of LBW, LSB Setting One, CW, and ELW, with ELW going further in inclusive language than the others. Third, the lectionary tradition — with the historic one-year lectionary preserved as an option in LSB, CW, and ELH, while LBW and ELW use the three-year lectionary as the standard. Fourth, the breadth of musical and cultural settings — with ELW offering the widest variety (ten settings) and ELH the most consistently traditional palette.

These variations matter, but they should not obscure the underlying unity. A Lutheran from an LCMS congregation can worship intelligibly at a WELS or ELS Divine Service; a Lutheran from an ELCA congregation can recognize the shape of the rite at an LCMS celebration; a confessional Lutheran from any of these bodies can identify the moment of consecration, the moment of distribution, the moment of benediction. The Lutheran liturgical family is real, even where serious confessional differences exist among its members. To understand the LCMS Divine Service is therefore, by implication, to understand the broader pattern of Lutheran worship — and to appreciate both the unities that bind the family together and the variations that distinguish its branches.


²² Lutheran Book of Worship (Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House / Philadelphia: Board of Publication of the Lutheran Church in America, 1978). For the history and theology of LBW, see Philip H. Pfatteicher, Commentary on the Lutheran Book of Worship: Lutheran Liturgy in Its Ecumenical Context (Minneapolis: Augsburg Fortress, 1990). ²³ The full record of the LCMS Commission on Worship’s evaluation of LBW is preserved in Lutheran Worship: History and Practice, ed. Fred L. Precht (St. Louis: Concordia, 1993), especially chapters 2–4. ²⁴ Evangelical Lutheran Worship (Minneapolis: Augsburg Fortress, 2006). For a critical Lutheran assessment, see John T. Pless, “Evangelical Lutheran Worship: A Confessional Lutheran Assessment,” Logia: A Journal of Lutheran Theology 16, no. 4 (Reformation 2007): 5–14. ²⁵ Evangelical Lutheran Hymnary (Mankato, MN: Evangelical Lutheran Synod, 1996).

Topics
Worship and LiturgyMarriage and FamilyThe Lord's Supper
Scripture
1 Corinthians 10:16–171 Corinthians 11:27–291 Peter 3:18–20
Confessions
AC XXIVSC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.