Studies · Catechism Corner

You Shall Not Steal

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

We come, in December, to the part of the year in which the Christian household is most exercised about property. The credit cards come out. The shopping lists come together. The packages arrive on the porch. The household budget, for many of the families in our parish, takes its largest single-month strain of the calendar year in the weeks between Thanksgiving and Christmas. It is not the worst place to take up the Seventh Commandment. You shall not steal, the LORD said on Sinai. The Hebrew is לֹא תִּגְנֹב (lo tignov), and the verb ganav means precisely what the English says — to take by stealth, to seize what does not belong to one, to filch, to plunder. The commandment in its narrowest sense is the commandment against the burglar, the pickpocket, and the embezzler. But the commandment, on Luther’s reading, is much wider. It is, in the Large Catechism, one of the longest single sections in the entire Decalogue — because the Reformer saw the Seventh Commandment touching almost every transaction of the daily Christian economy. The commandment is, in Luther’s hands, the LORD’s fence around the property He has given to the neighbor. And the Reformer was, characteristically, less interested in catching the burglar than in catching the small daily thefts that the average Christian, in any age, finds it easier to commit than to confess.

The Reformer in the Small Catechism gives the answer in two halves, as always. We should fear and love God so that we do not take our neighbor’s money or property, nor get them by false ware or dealing, but help him to improve and protect his property and business. The negative: not take, not get by false ware or dealing. The positive: help him to improve and protect his property and business. Notice the breadth. The negative is not only the burglar’s taking. It is also the merchant’s false ware — the selling of inferior goods at the price of better ones, the manipulation of weights and measures, the misrepresentation of what one is selling. It is the laborer’s false dealing — the giving of less work than the wage has paid for, the cheating of the employer who has trusted him. It is the lender’s unjust interest — what the older Lutherans called usury, the exacting of a return from the neighbor that exceeds what fairness and friendship would allow. It is the family member’s small unauthorized takings — the unreturned book borrowed from a friend, the petty diversion of household funds, the use of the employer’s time or supplies for one’s own ends. The Seventh Commandment, in Luther’s catechism, reaches into all of these.

The Reformer in the Large Catechism is at his most vivid on the commercial application of the commandment. He was writing in the early sixteenth century, in a German economy that was undergoing rapid change — the growth of long-distance trade, the rise of large merchant houses, the new commercial possibilities and the new commercial sins. Luther saw, with a pastor’s eye, that the largest thefts of his day were not being committed by the burglars and the highway robbers. They were being committed in the counting houses of the merchants who were charging the small farmer ruinous interest, by the officials who were taxing the peasants beyond what the laws warranted, by the guildmasters who were colluding to fix prices, by the landlords who were squeezing the rents until the tenants could not eat. Yes, Luther writes with characteristic bluntness, we should hang the small thieves, the burglars and the cutpurses; but the great thieves — the bankers, the lords, the merchant princes — these are the ones who sit in the seats of honor and call themselves gentlemen. The Reformer was, on this commandment, a sharp-eyed social critic. He saw, in his own day as in every age, that the worst violations of the Seventh Commandment are often the ones that the law itself cannot reach, because the lawmakers themselves are sometimes the ones doing the taking.

This is a humbling commandment for the modern Christian to read. The Large Catechism’s catalogue of small daily commercial sins reads, on first hearing, like the front page of any honest American economic life. The contractor who pads the invoice. The salesman who exaggerates the product. The employee who clocks in early and clocks out late. The taxpayer who shades the numbers on the return. The neighbor who borrows the lawn mower and never returns it. The car dealer who hides the defect. The advertiser who promises what the product cannot deliver. The renter who damages the apartment and walks away. The corporation that knowingly sells a harmful product because the profit outweighs the lawsuits. Every one of these, the Reformer says, is theft — and every one of them, in some measure, is committed by Christians who have somehow persuaded themselves that the Seventh Commandment was about burglary and therefore did not apply to them. The Reformer will not let us off the hook. The commandment binds the whole of the Christian’s economic life. Lo tignov. Do not take.

The positive half of the catechism is, again, where the gospel lives. Help him to improve and protect his property and business. The Seventh Commandment, in its positive form, is not principally a prohibition. It is principally a calling. The Christian is not called only to refrain from stealing from the neighbor. The Christian is called, in the active form of the commandment, to help the neighbor’s property prosper. The merchant is called to deal fairly and to help his customers thrive. The employer is called to pay fairly and to help his workers prosper. The worker is called to labor diligently and to help his employer’s business succeed. The neighbor is called to protect the neighbor’s property as if it were his own — to return the borrowed tool in better condition than he took it, to keep watch on the neighbor’s house when the neighbor is away, to give honest counsel when the neighbor’s business is in trouble. The Seventh Commandment in its positive form is the doctrine of the Christian commercial life — the doctrine that the Christian’s whole economy is a sphere in which the LORD has set the Christian to love the neighbor as himself.

The December timing is, as I said, fitting. The Christmas season in our country has become, in many of its outward expressions, a season about property — the buying, the giving, the wrapping, the receiving. The Lutheran Christian, on the Reformer’s reading of this commandment, has every reason to enter the Christmas economy with gladness. The giving of gifts is the Christian’s active fulfillment of the Seventh Commandment’s positive half. The Christmas hospitality is the Christian’s help to the neighbor’s joy. The Christmas alms — what the older Christian tradition called the Christmas dole, the gifts of food and money to the poor at the year’s end — are the Christian’s help to the neighbor in real need. The Christmas season is, in this respect, the most Seventh-Commandment-shaped season in the Christian calendar, when it is kept faithfully. The estate of property the LORD has given each Christian is, in the season of the Incarnation, the estate the LORD calls the Christian to give back into the neighbor’s hand. Whoever has two tunics, John the Baptist had said in the wilderness, is to share with him who has none, and whoever has food is to do likewise (Luke 3:11, ESV). The Christmas season is the small annual Christian rehearsal of that sermon.

A word about the deeper Lutheran point under all of this. The Christian, on the Lutheran doctrine of the First Article we walked through two Octobers ago, holds no property in his own right. All that the Christian has — his body, his soul, his eyes, his ears, his clothing, his food, his house, his family, his fields, his cattle, his every good gift — has come from the Father, out of pure, fatherly, divine goodness and mercy, without any merit or worthiness in me. The Christian is, on the catechism’s own reading of the First Article, not the owner of his property. The Christian is the steward of it. The property belongs to the LORD. The Christian manages it on the LORD’s behalf, for the sake of his neighbor and his own household. This is the Lutheran key to the Seventh Commandment. The Christian who has understood that the property is not his own is the Christian who can, in good conscience, give freely, deal fairly, protect faithfully, and use gladly. The Seventh Commandment does not principally bind the Christian’s fingers. The Seventh Commandment principally binds the Christian’s understanding of what his property is.

In other words, the Seventh Commandment is the LORD’s protection of the neighbor’s property and the LORD’s calling of the Christian into the work of the neighbor’s prosperity. It begins with the narrow prohibition of theft. It widens, through the Large Catechism’s long catalogue, into the prohibition of every form of dishonest dealing in the daily commerce of the world. It widens further, in the positive direction, into the active help the Christian is called to give to the neighbor’s property, work, and economic life. And it rests, in the deepest Lutheran reading, on the doctrine of the First Article — that the Christian is not the owner of what he holds, but only the steward of what the LORD has given for his neighbor’s sake and his own. Lo tignov. And, on the next page of the catechism, help him to improve and protect his property and business. The Christian’s hands are not just kept off the neighbor’s goods. The Christian’s hands are put to work in the neighbor’s life.

We will take up next month, in the new year of 2030, the Eighth Commandment of the Decalogue — You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor — and the Lutheran tradition on speech, reputation, and the wounds the tongue can inflict that the body cannot. For now, on the next Sunday in our liturgy, when we come to the confession of sins, hold the Seventh Commandment in your hearing. Ask not only whether you have taken, but whether you have helped. The commandment is owed in both directions. And a blessed Advent, and a most blessed Christmas, to every household reading this.

In Christ, Dylan MacDonald

Topics
The Ten CommandmentsVocation and Daily Life
Scripture
Luke 3:11
Confessions
SCLC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.