Private Confession and Absolution
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
There is a small piece of pastoral history the Lutheran tradition has kept in its memory for nearly five hundred years, and it is the kind of small piece of history that has, over the centuries, shaped more pastoral lives than most of the larger pieces. In the autumn and winter of 1521 and into the early spring of 1522, the Reformer Luther was in hiding at the Wartburg Castle in Saxony, under the protection of his prince, while the rest of the German Reformation sorted itself out in his absence. Several of his colleagues at Wittenberg, while he was away, had begun to teach that the Roman practice of private confession had been abolished by the gospel — that the Christian, having heard the good news of justification by faith alone, no longer needed to come to a pastor and confess his sins aloud. The Reformer was vehemently against the move. After his return to Wittenberg in March of 1522, in the famous Invocavit Sermons he preached on the eight days following his return, and seven years later in the Brief Exhortation to Confession he appended to the Large Catechism, Luther insisted again and again that private confession is one of the great treasures the Church has. I would not give it up, he wrote, for all the wealth of the world. The Lutheran Reformation did not abolish private confession. The Lutheran Reformation set it free.
That, in a single sentence, is the Lutheran doctrine of private confession. It is free. It is not a requirement, as the Roman canon law had made it a requirement; it is not a burden, as the medieval practice of enumeration had made it a burden; it is not, in the Small Catechism’s own answer, a list of sins the penitent has to recite. Before God we should plead guilty of all sins, the catechism says, but before the pastor we should confess only those sins which we know and feel in our hearts. The freedom is total. The Christian who knows his sin and feels its weight may come to his pastor at any time, at his own initiative, to confess that particular sin and to receive, from the pastor, the absolution that Christ has commissioned the pastor to speak in His Name. That is, in its purest form, Lutheran private confession. A penitent. A pastor. A particular sin named aloud. A particular absolution spoken in return. The whole transaction in five minutes. The whole transaction sufficient.
The Small Catechism answers the question what is Confession? in a sentence as compact as any in the Reformer’s writing. Confession embraces two parts: the one is, that we confess our sins; the other, that we receive absolution, or forgiveness, from the confessor, as from God Himself, and in no wise doubt, but firmly believe, that by it our sins are forgiven before God in heaven. Two parts. Confess. Receive. The first is the work of the penitent. The second is the work — and the gift — of the Lord, through the mouth of His servant the pastor. Notice the catechism’s striking phrase. From the confessor, as from God Himself. The pastor at the moment of the absolution is not, in the Lutheran reading, a man speaking his own opinion on the penitent’s spiritual standing. He is the Lord’s commissioned mouthpiece. The Word does the deed. The forgiveness the pastor speaks is the forgiveness God speaks — because the pastor is, at that moment, exercising the Office of the Keys we walked through last month.
A word, here, about what private confession is not. It is not, in the Lutheran reading, Roman penance. The medieval Roman penitential system, against which Luther had fought his entire career, required three things of the penitent: contrition (sorrow for sin), enumeration (an exhaustive listing of every mortal sin since the last confession, with the species and number of each), and satisfaction (a list of works the priest assigned for the penitent to perform to “make up” for the sin — fasting, alms, pilgrimage). The Reformer’s Brief Exhortation takes these three apart with characteristic force. Contrition, yes — the penitent must come knowing his sin and grieving it. But the contrition is the work of the law, and the law has already done its work in bringing the penitent to the confessor’s door; we do not need to manufacture more of it. Enumeration, no — the Small Catechism itself says the penitent should confess only those sins which he knows and feels. The pastor is not a tax collector counting up debts; the pastor is a steward of forgiveness, and one named sin is sufficient for the whole absolution to be given. And satisfaction, emphatically no — Christ has already satisfied for sin on the cross, and no work the penitent can perform can add anything to the satisfaction the Lord has made. The Lutheran absolution is whole and free and given on the spot. There are no works to do afterward. The forgiveness is complete in the speaking.
The Reformer Luther, in the Brief Exhortation, takes pains to recover the pastoral joy of private confession that the Roman system had buried beneath its weight. The Christian who has been gnawed by a particular sin — the unkind word, the secret habit, the act he cannot forgive himself for — has been given, by his Lord, a particular mouth and a particular hand through which to hear, audibly, that the particular sin has been forgiven. The general absolution at the head of the Sunday service is real. The general absolution forgives the same sin. But the Christian conscience is, in some moods, hard of hearing, and the general absolution can sometimes feel, to the troubled conscience, like a letter addressed to whom it may concern. The private absolution is the letter addressed to him, in his own name, on the day he came to ask for it. Your sins are forgiven, the pastor says, in the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. And the your in that sentence is the second person singular. The pastor is not, at that moment, speaking to the world. He is speaking to one Christian, on the Lord’s authority, about the Christian’s own sin. There is nothing else like it in the Christian’s life.
The modern Lutheran congregation has, in many places, lost the practice. There is no denying it. The Roman Catholic in our country still goes to confession, more often than the Lutheran does. The reasons for the Lutheran loss are several — partly a healthy Reformation reaction against the abuses of the medieval system that, over time, became an unhealthy reaction against the practice itself; partly a modern American religious culture that has come to prefer privacy over witness in spiritual matters; partly, I will confess, the failure of pastors of my own generation to offer private confession with the warmth and the seriousness the Reformer himself recommended. The Reformer’s word against us is plain. Despise it not. The treasure is still in the Church’s chest. The Lutheran pastor in this parish is, and has always been, available to any member of the congregation who comes to him with a sin he needs to name aloud and hear forgiven aloud. The door is not locked. The Office of the Keys has not been put away.
In other words, the Lutheran doctrine of private confession is the doctrine that the absolution Christ won on Calvary may be delivered, on request, in particular. The Christian conscience that is laboring under a particular weight need not labor alone. The Christian who has, in some season of his life, found that the general absolution at the head of the Sunday service is not landing on his particular sin may come to his pastor, name the sin, and hear from the pastor’s own mouth, in the Lord’s own Name, the particular word he needs. I forgive you all your sins, in the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. The Reformer’s promise that he would not give it up for all the wealth of the world is a promise the modern Lutheran congregation would do well to reclaim. There is not a man or woman in this parish, including the pastor, who could not, in some season, benefit from going.
A small word about timing. Lent begins this year on the fourteenth of February — Ash Wednesday — and the forty days of fasting and self-examination that lead the Church to Holy Week begin then. I do not think the Christian should feel obligated to come to private confession during Lent. The Lutheran practice has never been obligatory, and I will not be the pastor who makes it so. But Lent is, in the Christian calendar, the season most naturally suited to the practice. The congregation will hear, on the first Sunday of Lent, the words of Psalm 51 — Have mercy on me, O God, according to your steadfast love; according to your abundant mercy blot out my transgressions (Psalm 51:1, ESV) — and the David who first prayed them did so under the weight of a particular, named, terrible sin. The Lutheran congregation that has heard those words on its lips this Lent has every freedom, and every encouragement, to come to its pastor and name a particular sin of its own. The pastor will be there. The Lord’s authority will be in his hand. The five-minute transaction we have walked through in this month’s article will be done — and the penitent will leave the office with a sin named, an absolution spoken, and the weight of the Christian conscience lightened by exactly the weight the Christian conscience was carrying when he came in.
We will take up next month daily contrition — the working out of confession in the unspoken life of the Christian, when the moment is not yet right or the pastor is not yet at hand. Luther’s Brief Exhortation has more to say to us about the conscience than I have been able to gather in this single article, and we will gather more of it in March. For now, blessed Ash Wednesday and a blessed Lent. I would not give private confession up, Luther wrote, for all the wealth of the world. The Lutheran pastor in this parish would not either.
In Christ, Dylan MacDonald
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.