The Office of the Keys
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
There is a scene halfway through Matthew’s gospel that the Christian Church has been arguing over for two thousand years. The Lord and His disciples have come north from Galilee to the headwaters of the Jordan River — a small town called Caesarea Philippi, at the foot of Mount Hermon, in the shadow of a Greek shrine carved into a cliff face. The Lord turns to His disciples and asks them what the crowds in Galilee have been saying about Him. He hears the answers. John the Baptist. Elijah. Jeremiah. One of the prophets. Then He asks the question He has come north to ask. But who do you say that I am? (Matthew 16:15, ESV). Peter, in one of the moments in the gospels at which the slow, plain fisherman becomes briefly the spokesman for the entire Christian Church, answers. You are the Christ, the Son of the living God (Matthew 16:16). And the Lord, by way of response, makes Peter a promise that has divided Christian readers ever since. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven (Matthew 16:19).
We come, in this new month of January, to the second of the three sacramental chief parts of Luther’s catechism — the Office of the Keys and Confession. The Reformer did not, in fact, include a separate section on the Office of the Keys in the first 1529 edition of his Small Catechism; the section we know as the Office of the Keys in the standard Lutheran editions was added not long afterward by Luther’s own followers and has been printed alongside the Reformer’s six original chief parts ever since. It is, in every meaningful sense, Lutheran teaching, and Luther himself wrote at length about the Keys in his own works — most notably in his 1530 treatise On the Keys and in the Brief Exhortation to Confession appended in 1529 to the Large Catechism. Take up the Small Catechism’s section on the Keys and you have the heart of the Lutheran doctrine: The Office of the Keys is that peculiar power which Christ has given to His Church on earth: to forgive the sins of penitent sinners, but to retain the sins of the impenitent as long as they do not repent. One sentence. The whole doctrine.
A word, first, about the image. Keys. The Lord did not, at Caesarea Philippi, hand Peter a literal set of keys. The image is older than the apostle, and it is borrowed from the Hebrew Scriptures. In the twenty-second chapter of Isaiah, the Lord transfers the key of the house of David from one steward, Shebna, to another, Eliakim. I will place on his shoulder the key of the house of David. He shall open, and none shall shut; and he shall shut, and none shall open (Isaiah 22:22). The key is the symbol of the authorized steward — the man in the household whose office it is to let in and keep out. The Lord, in giving Peter the keys of the kingdom of heaven, is placing on the apostle’s shoulder the office Eliakim had carried in his day — the office of the authorized steward of the household of God. Peter is not the master of the house. Christ is. Peter is the steward who has been given the keys to open and to shut on the Master’s authority.
The authority is twofold. Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. Two verbs. The Greek is δέω (deō), “to bind, to tie up,” and λύω (luō), “to loose, to set free.” Bind — to hold in, to retain the sin against the impenitent sinner who has refused to repent. Loose — to let go, to forgive the sin against the penitent sinner who has come in repentance. The Christian Church, on the authority given by her Lord at Caesarea Philippi, exercises both halves of that authority. The forgiveness is real. The retention is also real. And if I tell you in advance that the Christian Church has, for two thousand years, been more comfortable speaking the first half of that authority than the second, you will hear in my tone something of the pastoral burden of the office. The Christian conscience prefers to be loosed. The Christian conscience does not always want to be told what cannot be loosed while it still refuses to repent.
The Lord, on the evening of the day of His resurrection, gave the same authority a second time — and in a second place, in the upper room in Jerusalem, in the hearing not of Peter alone but of the assembled disciples. Peace be with you, the Lord said. As the Father has sent me, even so I am sending you. And then, the gospel of John records, he breathed on them and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld” (John 20:21–23). Notice that the verb is forgive. Not announce the forgiveness, in the third person, as if the apostles were postal carriers delivering a letter someone else had written. Forgive. In the first person, in the active voice, on the Lord’s own authority. The apostles, by the breath of the risen Christ Himself, were given the power to forgive sins in His Name. Forgive — and the forgiveness is real in heaven. Withhold — and the withholding is real in heaven. The Office of the Keys is the apostolic exercise of the Lord’s own forgiving Word.
The Lutheran Confessions take this doctrine and frame it carefully against two opposing errors. The first error, against which the Reformers had fought for decades, was the Roman papal claim that the Keys had been given to Peter alone and had been passed down to a single line of bishops in the see of Rome. The Lutheran Confessions reject that reading without hesitation. The keys belong, the Augsburg Confession says in its long Article XXVIII, to the whole Church, not to certain persons only. The Keys are exercised by every Lutheran pastor in every Lutheran chancel, every Sunday morning, on the Lord’s own command and not on the bishop of Rome’s. The second error, against which the same Confessions had to fight on the other side, was the radical Reformation claim that the Keys had not really been given to any ordained office and that every Christian could speak the forgiveness of God to himself. The Confessions reject that too. The Keys are given to the Church, but the Church exercises them through the called and ordained ministry — the public preaching office the Augsburg Confession defends in its Articles V and XIV. No one, the Confessions say, should publicly teach in the Church or administer the Sacraments unless he be regularly called. The Christian father at his supper table may certainly speak the comfort of the gospel to his troubled child; but the public absolution, said in the assembly, on the Lord’s own authority, is the Lord’s gift to the ordained ministry of the Word.
In other words, the Office of the Keys is the Christian Church’s confession that the Lord’s forgiveness has been given a place to live in the world. Christ’s death paid for sin once for all on Calvary, two thousand years ago. The forgiveness He bought is delivered in the assembly of His people, through the mouth of a pastor He has called, on the authority He gave to His apostles after His resurrection. The pastor at the altar on a Sunday morning, when he raises his hands and pronounces over the kneeling congregation the words I forgive you all your sins, in the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit, is not speaking on his own authority. He is speaking on the Lord’s. The forgiveness is real. The forgiveness is attached to the Word being spoken. The forgiveness, in the Augsburg Confession’s own phrase in Article V, is the means through which God gives the Holy Spirit. The Word does the deed.
We will take up next month the form of the Office of the Keys that has been, for many Lutheran Christians, the most pastorally tender — private confession and absolution. Lent begins this year on the fourteenth of February, and there is no better season for the Christian conscience to consider what the Reformer Luther himself called one of the great treasures the Church has: the absolution spoken aloud, in private, to a Christian who has named his particular sin to a pastor commissioned to speak the Lord’s forgiveness back to him in the Lord’s Name. For now, on the next Sunday in which our liturgy comes to the absolution at the head of the service, listen for the verbs. I forgive you all your sins. The man saying them is not speaking on his own authority. The Keys are in his hand. The door is being opened.
In Christ, Dylan MacDonald
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.